Ghamidi sahb na IJMAH ko Nazar Andaz Kion Kia? - Muhammad Hassan Ilyas

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 дек 2024

Комментарии • 75

  • @irfanabbasi9892
    @irfanabbasi9892 5 лет назад +8

    MashaAllah . Another scholar in the footsteps of Ghamidi Saheb. Hope his legacy shall continue even after him. As far as the caller is concerned I sympathise with him as it happens in the words of Late Maulana Ishaque that " all we are stuck" and can't even think beyond what has been poured into our minds by mullas.

  • @MohammedXain
    @MohammedXain 5 лет назад +11

    Same cliched arguments from the caller that i despite being only 27 and not being an aalim have heard over and over again. The only remedy is that had this person read the Quran even once in the language he understands, he wouldn't be asking this question.

  • @Umair_Linguistics
    @Umair_Linguistics 4 года назад +2

    Thank you Hassan Bhai, may Allah bless you in both worlds 😊❣️

  • @Ayan-Edit628
    @Ayan-Edit628 Месяц назад

    zbardst jwab Weldon husansb

  • @hassanjahangiri
    @hassanjahangiri 5 лет назад +5

    Scholarly reply, as expected from Muhtaram Hassan Iliyas sahb 🙏

  • @irshadansari4515
    @irshadansari4515 4 года назад +2

    Sahi samjaya zajakalla

  • @reyazhajam3437
    @reyazhajam3437 2 года назад

    Mere monh se baatein cheenlee.aisa lagraha tha Jaise bol mere the aur monh illyas sahab ka tha .jazakallalh hayakallah hafizullahutallah.

  • @papskhan5541
    @papskhan5541 4 года назад

    Masha Allah .. i wish i could find many answers from him ... i wish i really wish... i badly need some real answers.. i think this is the only school of thought to give me answers in a right and honest way

  • @anistanveer1298
    @anistanveer1298 4 года назад

    Best answer

  • @AnwarKhan-rh7pb
    @AnwarKhan-rh7pb 4 года назад +1

    Good job sir

  • @pupilofghamidi5842
    @pupilofghamidi5842 5 лет назад +5

    Well defined , as expected as a scholar.

  • @afzaalmultipletv7988
    @afzaalmultipletv7988 4 года назад +1

    Beautiful jawab weldon hassa ilyas sb shkria

  • @sohailghouri4246
    @sohailghouri4246 5 лет назад +2

    تبارک الرحمن

  • @qurantafseerbymrsadnan2837
    @qurantafseerbymrsadnan2837 3 года назад

    ویری گڈ ایکسیلنٹ کیا خوب جواب دیا آپ نے سوال کرنے والے کا کیا سوال تھا

  • @sohailghouri4246
    @sohailghouri4246 5 лет назад +1

    ماشااللہ

  • @naumanrana2181
    @naumanrana2181 3 года назад

    Ajj app Ko phali bar suna aur app Ko apna ustad man laya sir

  • @thekiranshow209
    @thekiranshow209 4 года назад +4

    Nice interpretation bro

  • @ahsanalii8768
    @ahsanalii8768 2 года назад

    Nice bhai jan

  • @sohailghouri4246
    @sohailghouri4246 5 лет назад +1

    سوال کے لئیے رابطہ عنایت فرمائیے

  • @syedhassan233
    @syedhassan233 4 года назад +2

    الیاس صاحب اللہ آپکو سلامت رکھے

  • @iZeeshan
    @iZeeshan 5 лет назад +6

    well done...Molviyo ne patti padhai hai aam logo ko...k quran me yeh nahi hai quran me wo nahi hai....
    Allah hidayat den molviyo ko...

  • @irfanabbasi9892
    @irfanabbasi9892 4 года назад +1

    " Danishwers" are requested to be brief. Today people aren't stupid. Before giving certificates of " gumrahi" to others they should first produce their own certificate of " rahi" signed by the competent authority.

  • @Ijazulhassan1
    @Ijazulhassan1 3 года назад

    YES,AAP(S.A)NAY PAABAND KIA

  • @SulmanMalik
    @SulmanMalik 4 года назад +1

    & Hum yahoodi ur esao ki trha to namaz nahii prhty brother. Unka tariqa alag hai namaz parhny ka. To hume b phir wesi hi prhni cahhiye. Kue kay quran me ye wala tariqa ni aya jis trha hum prhty teh hainn. To sari hadees galat ummat sari gumrah ijma galat quran ky kihlaf .ur hume quran ky mutabiq wese hi namaz prhni cahhiye jese yahoodi esai parhty hain.

    • @Razaalifcma
      @Razaalifcma 4 года назад +2

      You didn't pick the whole point brother. No one in this world understand a simple multiplication unless he switches on his learning mind set. I believe in Sahih ahadis of prophet so does Ghamidi Sahab. It's all propoganda against him. If you too believe in Hadis and these mullahs, why don't they follow Namaz as is written in Hadis. 90% Pakistani and Indian do not practice Rafa ul yadain while going to in returnin rakuh. While there are more than 100 Sahih ahadis confirming it. You might say "we are Hanfi and these ahadis are abandoned or منسوخ". But other might say that you are "Munkir e Hadis (just like you label Ghamidi Sahab as munkar e Hadis). This also means k inkaar e Hadis to Sab Kar rahay hain. Farq sirf itna hai. Ap ko wo inkar to qabool Nahi jis say ap k firqay par zarb ati ho. Aur wo qabool hai Jo ap k firqay ki tasdeeq karay. Pura India Pakistan bhara para hai darbaroon aur Mazaron say. Bilkul waziah hadisain Hain qabar per koi building Na banany ki. To Sab Brailvi Deobandi Munkar e Hadis Nahi Hain. Food for thought

    • @Razaalifcma
      @Razaalifcma 4 года назад

      Plus Ghamidi Sahab Hadis Ka inkar Nahi kartay yah propoganda hai molvioun Ka. Unnki kitaab "meezan" main 1200 say ziada ahadis Hain. Sara Deen unhon ny hadeeson say hi bataya hai. Lakin unhon ny Hadis to samjny aur istadlaal Karny Ka Sahi tariqa bataya hai. His per molvi chirr gay hain. Asal main wo Ghamidi Sahab k ilm aur akhlaq Ka muqabla to Kar Nahi saktay. Jahil logon ko mutnaffar Kar sakty Hain Jo wo khoob Kar rahy hain.

    • @tehreemxiaomi1095
      @tehreemxiaomi1095 4 года назад

      @@Razaalifcma very nice reply brother

    • @smshafique9873
      @smshafique9873 3 года назад

      @@Razaalifcma Aap ne durust farmaya mgr Afsos----------?

  • @zeeshanfarhan5794
    @zeeshanfarhan5794 4 года назад +1

    I am shia and like Scholars

  • @Factszz
    @Factszz 4 года назад +1

    The Best appropriate name for so Called Ijmah-Ummah of Sunni Mullahs and Imams; and Shia Imams is Iqbal's *"Shaitan ki Majlis Shoora".* For example: This is Ijmah of Sunni Infidel Imams that verses of Stoning were eaten by Goat

  • @m.hassanakram6527
    @m.hassanakram6527 4 года назад

    Apki Rai ka bhi ehtaram krty hue arz ha ke ijma ko dalel ham ehle eman keliye mante Hain yane jis bat pr ahle eman mutafik hon or dosri baat ya ke Jo batein Nabi s.a.w ny sahabi ki kasir tadad ki mjudgi ma khahein unky bare ma apka kia khiyal ha imam Muslim tu ek majlis ki alg alg rawiyon sy tariq apne kitab ma likhty hain

  • @shabih2008
    @shabih2008 4 года назад +1

    Sabse pehli baat yeh kehna ki Quran ek khamosh kitaab hai ek mere hisaab se Quran ki gustakhi hai

  • @hamidkhurshid8161
    @hamidkhurshid8161 4 года назад

    I have a question for Ghamdi Sahab.... can you please explain rights of Transgenders according to Islam?

  • @yousafkhan7622
    @yousafkhan7622 4 года назад

    quran quran quran serf quran aour sunnat jo baba adam se shuro hoa hazrat nabi pak thak. baki hadees insaano ka lekha hoa historical record hy aour kese kahaniya hy jes ki ko khas ahmyat nahi. serf quran aour sunna bass baht khattam

  • @shohrathussain2673
    @shohrathussain2673 2 года назад

    Waqt zaey kiya. Mosalmanon kay liye quran aur sahi hadees kaafi hein. Aap zehmat na fer maaein. Hamaarey ul maey deen mojood hein. 72 firqay hongay, ek jamaat hogi jo rahey raast par hogi.

  • @muzaffarhussain1073
    @muzaffarhussain1073 4 года назад +1

    بات کی طرف کبھی کسی کا دھیان نہیں گیا کیا حضرت ابوبکر صدیق نے سب سے کم روایتی کیوں کیوں پیش کیا یہ بھی تو ایک سوال ہے نا اور کیا یہ سب سے بڑی ذمہ داری نہیں تھی کی احادیث کو باقاعدہ لکھوانا میری زبان زیب نہیں دیتی میرا میرا میں اتنی جسارت نہیں کر سکتا احادیث کو اسی وقت لکھوانا چاہیے تھا اگر قرآن پاک لکھا جا سکتا ہے تو احادیث کیوں نہیں لکھی جاسکتی ہر مسئلک کا بندہ اپنی مرضی کی حدیث کو مانتا ہے کہتے ہیں فلاں ضعیف ہیں میرے حساب سے اس بات پر کام ہی نہیں ہوا آج تک

    • @shohrathussain2673
      @shohrathussain2673 2 года назад

      Quran aur sahi hadees.......iskay baad allah nay fermaya, akmalto lakum deeno kum. Mosalman, ghamdi aur iss jeysey Ahmaqon sey motassir na hon.

  • @हौसला-ह9ग
    @हौसला-ह9ग 4 года назад

    Assalalslamualaikum, ijma o qyas imaginary Shariyet ki imaginary istelahein gain,

    • @Abc123-b3n
      @Abc123-b3n 4 года назад

      IJMA AUR SUNNAT MEIN KIYA FARAQ HAI?

  • @muhammadfaisal8700
    @muhammadfaisal8700 4 года назад

    ابوبکر رضی اللہ عنہ وغیرہ نے بیان کرنا ضروری نہیں سمجھا اس لیئے ان سے بہت کم روایتیں منقول ہے حتی کہ یہ حضرات قرآن جمع کرنابھی ضروری نہیں سمجھا تو اس بارے میں کیا کہینگے؟اکثر روایتیں کم عمر صحابہ سے منقول ھے جب بعد انہوں نے ضروری سمجھا بیان کردی

    • @azaankhan2022
      @azaankhan2022 3 года назад

      Hadis or sunaat ma faraq Hai ,sunaat Jo yeh din ka hesa hi

    • @shohrathussain2673
      @shohrathussain2673 2 года назад

      Quran aur sahi hadees donon mojood hein. Jin kay dilon par allah nay mohur lagadi hey un ko parhney ki zaroorat nahein.

  • @iqbalahmedkhan3338
    @iqbalahmedkhan3338 3 года назад

    Aims kiya hai. Siyasi garho bandi. Ajmana mein kaun kaun hain yeh jannat zaruri hai. Jams kah kar musalamaanon ka imanadara khara karna gunah hai

  • @sarangvision5533
    @sarangvision5533 4 года назад +1

    Ab Purany baaby aor kahania khatm ,

  • @sohailghouri4246
    @sohailghouri4246 5 лет назад +1

    ربی یزید

  • @muhammadfaisal8700
    @muhammadfaisal8700 4 года назад

    اس صاحب کا علم کمزور ھے

  • @sarfarazrizvi5637
    @sarfarazrizvi5637 4 года назад

    غامدی صاحب قرآن و حدیث کے مفہوم کو اپنے مطلب کا ترجمہ و تفسیر کرتے ہیں

    • @sarangvision5533
      @sarangvision5533 4 года назад +1

      Tmy apni mother language ka pta nah ,tu tmy Arabic language ka kaisy pta he k waho apni mrzy ka turjuma krta ha ,

    • @yousafkhan7622
      @yousafkhan7622 4 года назад

      Sarfaraz Rizvi .kaha ghamdi sahb kaha pakistan.india.bangladesh ke jahil molve jo ajj tak apni omat ko na teetar bana sake na bater serf firqe bana sake

    • @yousafkhan7622
      @yousafkhan7622 4 года назад

      asad khan ,india,pakistan,bangladesh,afganistan ke molla mufti group ko ghamdi sahb ke qurani fahm tak ponchne ke liye mazeed 2000 saal b kaam hy

    • @afzaalmultipletv7988
      @afzaalmultipletv7988 4 года назад

      Ghamdi sb waqat ke imam hain