Got injured in an accident? You could be one click away from a claim worth millions. You can start your claim now with Morgan & Morgan at ForThePeople.com/medicine without leaving your couch. Remember, it's free unless you win. This is a first time watch for Answer, Oak, and Diamond Dave. Badd Medicine Arcade (Gaming channel) ruclips.net/channel/UCHIstVk00GtduPIXlJLdC3A Early Drops & Full Reactions on YT Memberships & Patreon: www.patreon.com/baddmedicine Backup channel Subscribe here ruclips.net/channel/UC1CLUwA27dz-94o3FR0o3xg
My uncle was essentially doc roe. He was awarded a sliver star signed by regab. Yes recognition I n many years later. Saved 53 mens lives the only thing he said was it was cold. He doesn't like to talk about it. Je wasn't with the 101. He was in the 158th anit tank corps. The other 3 medics in his division were killed. He was the only one left to serve 200 men
Boy, I hope you've got your reactions in the can, so you won't get spoiled by commenters. This series is based on the book by historian Stephen Ambrose, based on interviews with then-surviving members of E Company. The characters are real, though their portrayals are not 100% accurate. Please consider another Tom Hanks miniseries, "From the Earth to the Moon" -- a history of the Apollo program, mission by mission.
My Dad was an Engineer with the Airborne and flew in that previous night on one of the gliders towed in. We only got select stories, but what he told us was incredible. He once punched an Officer in the face and went to the brig. And shot down a scout plane that kept flying over them trying find their position. A colorful soldier.
Glad you are seeing this....as you watch the remaining episodes, you will be amazed that about half of the Easy Company actors are British/Scottish!!! Their different USA accents - Brooklyn, San Fran, etc. - are nail on!!!!
I'm a simple woman...I see Badd Medicine, I click. I see Band of Brothers, I click. You gentlemen are FANTASTIC and I'm so glad you're doing this! My family had personal connections to Moose Heiliger from Concord MA❤❤❤
@@MoMoMyPup10 Yup, and the fact they're old enough to have family members they grew up with who were in the war makes their perspective more interesting than the avg youtuber too!
Something that I read recently that was interesting was that Winters only went on the set once. All the actors were in the back of a truck, and he opened the tarp and others said they could just see the blood drain from his face. Winters later said he felt he saw ghosts on that day, because the casting was so good at getting actors who look so close to the actual people.
Calling it one of the best TV series ever made is no hyperbole. IMO, it's the best 10 hours of television ever made. The show is not only perfect storytelling and a fantastic story, but it's a technical masterpiece of filmmaking. Excited to see you guys react to it!
I LOVE when Oak was talking how he was into more documentaries than shows and Quinn was looking straight into the camera like “This dude is going to love this so much more he has no idea” lol
Honestly, this series is probably the best television ever made. It's absolutely wonderful. And I have no qualms shamelessly promoting it and spitting out fun facts such as the fact that throughout filming, all the actors were only known by their character name, so much so that when the army guy who consulted on the film talks about them, years, decades later, he still refers to them as their characters. The next is that the real people i.e. Wild Bill, Dick Winter, etc were even more amazing. And they were tough as nails. Couldn't keep those guys down.
There's so much they had to tone down for the show because they thought the audience would never believe it. The actual men were such superheroes they did things deemed too "unrealistic" for TV.
@@pabloc8808 I know right? It's so fascinating listening to the podcasts (done for the 20th anniversary) and learning about the OG guys. Really just Legends.
If they haven't seen it yet, every war show they watch after this will be 2nd rate.. And EVERY reaction I've watched has the same laugh and chuckle the first time they see "Ross" as Capt Sobel.
The Band of Brothers experience is either 1) you watched it when it was new and you've spent the last 20 years realizing that you recognize every other up-and-coming actor from a bit part in the show, or 2) you watched the show later on and are mystified about why X actor only got a bit part.
Only one that comes close is Chernobyl or pacific. And true detective before they decided to continue it with more seasons. Band of brothers is the personification of perfection
@@trev9168 chernobyl is still on my to watch list, but i love the pacific mention bc, while i do have a preference over band of brothers *overall*, i also did love the pacific for what it was and i don't think it gets the praise it deserves tbh. 😭
This is a 10/10 perfect show. One of the vets came to the filming and walked away from the set because he said "he was looking at ghosts" that speaks volumes on how much they put into being true to those who didn't make it.
Buckle up guys. You're in for a ride... Edit: As a vet (though not in wartime), soldiers always rely on humor. Dark humor, gallows humor, light hearted humor, anything and everything to get the mind off of the task at time.
Dark humor, e.g.: "There was blood upon the risers, there were brains upon his 'chute Intestines were a-dangling from his paratrooper suit They poured it from his helmet and they poured it from his boots And he ain't gonna jump no more" to the tune of "The Battle Hymn of the Republic".
Do me a favor guys, encourage them to watch Schwimmer's BEST role in a serious war movie called "Uprising" which was done around the same time as Band of Brothers. He was EXCELLENT in it. These guys would have an amazing reaction to a VERY important story as far as I'm concerned. Schwimmer was excellent in that role.
I honestly dont understand how you guys have never seen Band of Brothers after over twenty years but Im glad we get to experience it with you now. Enjoy the greatest television show ever made. One that actually nails the landing.
Sobel was absolutely real and portrayed in the series as described by the men of Easy when Stephen Ambrose interviewed them for his book of the same name. That being said, he did not want to comment / be interviewed himself and so he kinda missed an opportunity to refute any of the claims against his character. For those who haven't read the book, there's also a funny anecdote about Sobel's lack of coordination even when he shouldn't have needed a map. It's been a while since I read the book but I'll try and recount it from memory: I can't recall if it was the incident where someone impersonated Major Horton or whether it was a seperate incident where the guys had messed with him, but in an attempt to get his own back Sobel took a chance when the men were sleeping in foxholes as part of their training. Essentially he went around and stole their guns while they slept, with the aim of chastising them the next morning for not having looked after their weapon. Supposedly Sobel ended up getting lost during the night and instead went around taking the guns from Fox company instead. Easy company started getting yelled at the next morning for not having looked after their weapons but they were all dumbfounded since...well...they were holding their weapons. Later, a pissed off Fox company showed up demanding their weapons back. It should be said, that even though Sobel gets a bad rap both in the book and on the show, whether they liked him or not, I think every man agreed that Sobel "made" Easy what it was.
Do me a favor, encourage them to watch Schwimmer's BEST role in a serious war movie called "Uprising" which was done around the same time as Band of Brothers. He was EXCELLENT in it. These guys would have an amazing reaction to a VERY important story as far as I'm concerned. Schwimmer was excellent in that role.
I did watch this a few years back, and seeing this now I'm just realising that Schwimmer shot this DURING Friends. That's insane. That guy did not get enough credit as an actor.
Sobel was real. He was a real A-Hole. And what is funny, the only difference between him cutting the fence that let the cows out. In real life, it was done in the middle of the night.
There's some controversy about that, Sobel's family claims the Easy men portrayed him in a negative light due to antisemitism; not saying he wasn't a dick, just that maybe he wasn't as much of a dick as shown here. Plus, the vets themselves acknowledged that Sobel's training kept them alive and was the reason they were able to do some of the things they did. Also Sobel fought in Normandy and, despite his well-earned reputation as a bad field commander, he was outstanding, immediately after landing he led his men to destroy an MG nest and then went on to fight at Carentan.
@@pabloc8808 There's a few cases of this (the worst being with Dike in a later episode). It's a problem of this series adapting Ambrose's book to the memories of the Brothers instead of getting a full picture of every side character. It makes for a fantastic story but completely susceptible to bias.
@@kueller917 Yup, Ambrose's book is a textbook example of what NOT to do as a historian. He got so much wrong because he was lazy and generally incompetent, it's not that hard to double check information you get from primary sources by simply... finding other primary sources. Or records. Or anything, really, but he just didn't bother.
Great that you watch with subtitles. Makes it easy to follow who is who - for when vets names are ultimately revealed in the finale and in the documentary. Speaking of which, please be sure to watch the accompanying HBO documentary once you finish the miniseries. It serves as a perfect capstone/ episode 11 with lots of context from all the vets. It is called “We Stand Alone Together.” The men disliked Sobel and definitely knew he wasn’t cut out to be a combat leader but they did give him credit for his tough training getting them ready. In the meantime - enjoy the amazing ride about these amazing men.
Great reaction! I love this series! As a veteran myself, there is a lot more levity than what people think. It really helps you to mentally get through training and anything else that comes your way.
Lol Mason Quinn said he's watched this show multiple times and owns the DVDs and then 5 seconds later the graphic says "first time watching" for all 4 guys lol
Simon Pegg - Cornetto Trilogy, Mission Impossible, The Boys - delivered the court martial notice in the jeep. This series has at least one young star I know will blow your minds. This series will leave you shell shocked, proud and in tears.
Good review guys. I agree that Band of Brothers is the one of the best if not the best show ever made! Interesting fact that Sobel was an excellent training officer but was not good in the field. Yes Sobel was real and was the first commanding officer of easy company and yes his Sargents did rebel against him. Many of the men of Easy Company who trained under Sobel who survived, including some of the men who "rebelled" against him later in life admitted that the hard training they received under Sobel as one of the reasons they were able to survive the war. So what Col Sink did giving him the command of a training school was the best allocation of his resources.
I remember most of this filming down the road from me in the UK (as well as Saving Private Ryan). I distinctly remember being in a history lesson & we'd hear WW2 planes & explosions going off. A couple of years later, i believe in 2003, our great history teacher showed us an episode. I've rewatched the show almost every Christmas since then.
My father was in the Army Air Corps, and my mother joined the Marines in World War 2 when she was just 19. I'm looking forward to all your reactions to this fantastic series.
I have been feeling quite stressed and odd lately; I moved to another country a couple of days ago and it has taken a lot of work to make that actually happen. I'm very excited about this new chapter in life, however, I'm still quite exhausted from the past months. A couple of years ago I woudn't have imagined how much happiness I could get from seeing that some youtube reactor starts to react to a show I love, and now I gotta say that you guys put a huge smile on my face yesterday and I felt my worries melting away as I was watching your reaction. I'm sure you're gonna enjoy the show - it is amazing! Thank you for your existence and cheers&love from this Finnish person now living in Greenland!
Regarding the training…… Camp Toccoa Georgia was the FIFTH consecutive boot camp for Winters. He went to boot camp (#1) at Camp Croft SC in Sept 1941 when he joined the Army in August 1941. Instead of staying with his unit he was assigned to be one of the drill instructors for the next boot camp. (#2) When that boot camp was over Winters, a college graduate, was assigned to OCS (#3) at Ft. Benning Ga in April 1942 as a trainee. (He met Nixon there as a fellow trainee) When OCS was over and he was commissioned as a 2nd Lt. he was once again assigned to Camp Croft as a DI (boot camp #4) because there were no openings at Parachute Training. Several weeks he was transferred to Camp Toccoa (#5). Camp Toccoa was a combination boot camp/parachute training. Winters, Nixon & Sobel trained the men for their boot camp but joined them as fellow trainers in parachute training.
I am so shocked but SO HYPED! I've watched this so much too, own several of the books about and from these men, and back in the day (2003) I used to talk with some of the actors on the BoB forums, posting fan art etc. (Michael Cudlitz was super nice.) My pride and joy is a signed copy of the BoB hardcover from one of the real Easy Co men before he passed away. I won't say which one, as to not spoil that he survives in the show :)
It's amazing how often reacters completely miss Michael Fassbender's appearance. It's not even a small one; he's the guy who has to redo the no-water run.
The first time I saw BoB was in the fall, and so, just like you, fall comes around, and I HAVE to watch it again. Last year, one of my DVD's was scratched, so I went and upgraded to Blu-ray. 😊
Absolute masterpiece. My grandfather also fought in the war for the allies ( Royal Australian Army ) so I feel a connection to the story being told. I watch this series at least once per year. Mason knows what the guys are in for.... one hell of an experience.
Let’s gooooooo! I love y’all’s reactions and I love Band of Brothers (I grew up with it and the 101st- I’m an army brat) and to see yall reacting to it I’m excited! Can’t wait to follow y’all’s journey with this series. Definitely look at The Pacific and Master of the Air after as well if you haven’t yet!
Haven't watched Masters of te Air yet but The Pacific is so much bleaker than Band of Brothers (for a reason, of course). It's a fantastic show but I was shook watching it, we know a lot about the Pacific Theater but don't really understand how much worse it was than Europe for those men.
I saw this serie a few times now. I remember when it was on Dutch tv I hated that I had to wait a week for the next episode and on a Sunday while I had to go back to base the next morning to NCO school. The story and buildup is so good and as a vet and growing up with stories from my grandparents who lived through WW2 it hits so close to home. I even had the honour to talk to some of pur Canadian liberators on our national libaration day in the 90s. Brilliant series. And all those Brits playing Americans is amazing.
Happy to see you are reacting to it! I think i have watch every reactor in youtube reacting to this awesome show. Enjoy! PS! Try not to Google stuff ahead of time. It takes the edge off if you know who is who in the beginning (who survived)
I was in Saudi on 9/11 and came back stateside at the end of September for some additional training in D.C. before being redeployed. I watched most of this series from a hotel room in Maryland during that few weeks of training. I re-watch it once a year and it's every bit as good over 20 years later, but it still puts me in mind of those crazy days right after 9/11. A lot of people will tell you that The Pacific isn't as good a series, but I think it's every bit as good and absolutely worth the watch in the future.
“When I went in, I was eighteen. I thought it was all glory and you win lots of medals. You think you’re going to be the guy. Then you find out the cost is very great. Especially when you don’t see the kids you were with when you went in. Living with it can be hell. It’s like the devil presides in you. I knew what I sighed up for, yes, and I would do it again. But the reality of war-words can’t begin to describe it.” William “Wild Bill” Guarnere Easy Company, 101st airborne
Man, it's been more than a decade since I watched this. My sister and I watched this together with our mother and it's something I've never forgotten. It's a documentary series with filmed scenes, very beautiful and respectfully made. This had such a big impact on me and gave me so much insight in the times of war and the people from the time. Very good series to see for everyone who has an interest in WOII.
Oh this is going to be good. Just wait until Why We Fight. Hey you should watch the documentary We Stand Alone Together after this series. Should be on the discs if you're watching from DVD or Bluray.
Why We Fight and the documentary can make any grown man with a soul cry. The documentary is both heartbreaking and heartwarming, those men were truly a different breed. "A different time".
@pabloc8808 Oh hell yeah. I'm nearly 40, have served myself, and have watched this over a dozen times. "Why We Fight" makes me cry every single time.
So incredibly excited to have you guys finally reacting to Band of Brothers on the channel. Cannot WAIT to see Oak loose it over this incredible series!
Oh my word! Mr. Oak, as you said you're really into WW2 history, but you've never seen BoB, that to me is exceptionally rare. All I can say is, prepare for your most profound viewing experience of a lifetime, hands down. I'm addicted to watching BoB reactions on YT. My tally must be close or more than 20x reactions seen. I'm unquestionably excited to see this once more, with you guys. Thumbs up!
Peaky Blinders and Band of Brothers, you guys are too good to me. ❤ Yeah guys this one is legendary. I usally watch it once a year for over a decade now. Much love!
31:08 you can RUclips the Ron Livingston special feature from the DVD set to see the training regimen the actors went through. They got it pretty damn close to the real deal.
One of the cable channels (History, i think) plays the series twice a year - Memorial Day weekend and around Dec 7. I watch it every time. This is such a well made series.
I am a huge fan of this channel, I wanted you guys to know this series really inspired me on my weight loss journey. I will be running two foot races on Currahee mountain on Oct, 5th in honor of the hero's that trained on that mountain and then fought for our freedom. Thank you so much for all that you guys do.
Flashing back to training was a real nice device to get aquainted with the characters. Knew it was a winner when the Vets were speaking of their experiences during the intro. I own the set.
You guys are doing some amazing series right now, so excited for the next few weeks. My grandpa married his sweetheart and joined up. He was 22. He served in the pacific where he earned two Purple Hearts and the Bronze Star for heroic actions. He never spoke about it much, but he said that mail call was the worst time, hearing the name called out of someone who was killed just the day before. Even in his old age whenever he walked in the mountains behind his home he couldn’t stop himself listening for snapping twigs or the shuffle of gear. My husband’s grandfather lied about his age and joined the navy at 16. The men of that age were built different, I can’t fathom it.
A quick search of the main channel page suggests that the Baddies may not yet have experienced another of HBO's finer miniseries, "John Adams." If y'all are going on an American history binge, I'd heartily recommend having a go at that one.
The amount of work they put into molding the actors into the men of Easy is so cool. The fact the actors all took time to talk to the real men easy and their loved ones to learn how to best portray them. The made the actors go through bootcamp together to bond.
I think this is the one of the best tv shows ever made. They just make it so real somehow. I'm really looking forward to your reactions to these episodes. There's so many scenes that I can't wait to see what you think and feel about.
This is my favorite series ever. I usually watch it once every couple of years. It is fantastic. I hope you all enjoy it as much as I have, seems like from this first episode that is going to be the case.
I went over to Europe with my dad this spring on a BoB tour through Stephen Ambrose Tours and followed their footsteps. Went to Toccoa, visited England, crossed the channel to Normandy went over the bridges of market garden, ran the field in crossroads, walked through the forests of Bastogne, saw Dachau, and captured the Eagles nest. It was a once in a lifetime opportunity. Recommendation: The National WWII Museum did a weekend symposium for the 20th anniversary. Many of the actors, writers, and children of the actual soldiers attended and had sessions. Those can all be found on RUclips. It is very interesting and also entertaining.
Shifty Powers niece was on our tour. She brought his actual jump wings and clicker along! Absolutely highly recommend this tour. We got to see way more from WWII than just BoB. We had a full time historian and he personally knew many of the actual men, and boy did he have some Stories.
Band of Brothers is a timeless series. It's not a "war" tv show, it's not a "history" tv show. This portrays the triumphs, heartbreak, struggle, and persistence of the American, and human, spirit. You can watch this series from a psychology lens and learn about mindset and growth. You can learn how to be a strong leader. You can explore the depths of human bonding and go through the various stages of team development: forming, storming, norming, and performing. Band of Brothers shows us how men grow and connect, how we can rise to occasions, how we can uplift each other, and how we can work together for a common cause. I love this show, and I'm so glad you guys are (finally) watching it. These men were the greatest generation, and people we, in modern times, can look to for inspiration - not to "feel better" but to work towards.
Rarely have I ever seen a more well matched show and reactors. Cannot wait for you to experience this. Hands down the greatest miniseries ever made. I would HIGHLY recommend watching not only key the documentary episode included on the DVD’s, but also Ron Livingstone’s vlog series from the incomparable training by the legendary Captain Dye (who plays Col. Sink in BoB)
So jealous you guys are getting to watch this for the first time. Truly a masterpiece that still holds up today. This is series I rewatch every year and I’ve watched multiple channels react. Just an amazing piece of cinematic art. Enjoy, boys.
28:25 "Just send it in the mail?!" - Until the late 1960s, any legal firearm could be mailed through the Postal Service, including new purchases. You could order guns from anyone (including Sears and Roebuck) and have them shipped to your door.
The most realistic part of this episode: "Nobody told me." "I telephoned." "I'm quartered with a family that has no telephone." The second most realistic part: One last thing before getting on the airplane to go do this invasion you've been practicing for two and a half years - take this pill, we think it might help but we don't know if there will be any side effects.
Oh my gosh, yes! For some reason, I kept thinking you guys had already reacted to this series, so the few times I would search Band of Brothers & Badd Medicine reaction, nothing ever came up and I'd get bummed. I must have manifested it! Haha! ;) You guys are in for a great ride, this is one of the best TV shows ever made. I rewatch it almost every year.
Welcome to the miniseries! One of the quirks of being in the service is that you can formally affiliate with a unit you serve with. When I was serving in the Army in 2003, I was assigned to the 1/506th in South Korea, and this miniseries was required watching for us. They left such an impression on me that I affiliated with them, and I carried their insignia with me to each successive unit. These guys are like extended family to me.
Band of the brothers : Brotherhood of war The Pacific : Brutality of war Generation Kill : Futility of war The holy trinity, i haven't watched airmen one
It’s been glossed over quite a bit, but one of the characters that gets precious little focus did a lot to secure Easy Company’s survival. Once it became clear that Sobel was incompetent in the field in spite of his excellence in training, Ed Tipper got to work. Tipper purposely mislaid maps and documents, and subtly misdirected Sobel in such a way that Sobel’s incompetence was glaringly obvious to the brass. He did a lot behind the scenes that resulted in Sobel being replaced with Meehan.
You are about to embark on a unique television series. The story of exceptional people and their incredible emotional sacrifice. You will know and remember them them by name by the end of the show 😁
Bro, i started this series a month ago and I still haven't been able to get through the episodes, but what I've seen so far is really good. It's cool that they reacted to it on the channel.
Got injured in an accident? You could be one click away from a claim worth millions. You can start your claim now with Morgan & Morgan at ForThePeople.com/medicine without leaving your couch. Remember, it's free unless you win.
This is a first time watch for Answer, Oak, and Diamond Dave.
Badd Medicine Arcade (Gaming channel) ruclips.net/channel/UCHIstVk00GtduPIXlJLdC3A
Early Drops & Full Reactions on YT Memberships & Patreon: www.patreon.com/baddmedicine
Backup channel Subscribe here ruclips.net/channel/UC1CLUwA27dz-94o3FR0o3xg
My uncle was essentially doc roe. He was awarded a sliver star signed by regab. Yes recognition I n many years later. Saved 53 mens lives the only thing he said was it was cold. He doesn't like to talk about it. Je wasn't with the 101. He was in the 158th anit tank corps. The other 3 medics in his division were killed. He was the only one left to serve 200 men
react wołyn 2016(polish movie and subtilles engslich) ,trust me very god movie war!
watch the pacific too please
Boy, I hope you've got your reactions in the can, so you won't get spoiled by commenters. This series is based on the book by historian Stephen Ambrose, based on interviews with then-surviving members of E Company. The characters are real, though their portrayals are not 100% accurate.
Please consider another Tom Hanks miniseries, "From the Earth to the Moon" -- a history of the Apollo program, mission by mission.
My Dad was an Engineer with the Airborne and flew in that previous night on one of the gliders towed in. We only got select stories, but what he told us was incredible. He once punched an Officer in the face and went to the brig. And shot down a scout plane that kept flying over them trying find their position. A colorful soldier.
So it begins.
Théoden King
where is the horse and the rider..../ side note, middle earth built map on my page :D
*cue lord of the rings ost on helms deep*
Yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Glad you are seeing this....as you watch the remaining episodes, you will be amazed that about half of the Easy Company actors are British/Scottish!!! Their different USA accents - Brooklyn, San Fran, etc. - are nail on!!!!
I'm a simple woman...I see Badd Medicine, I click. I see Band of Brothers, I click. You gentlemen are FANTASTIC and I'm so glad you're doing this! My family had personal connections to Moose Heiliger from Concord MA❤❤❤
I'm a simple man, I read the words "band of brothers reaction" and my eyes pop out of my socket like a cartoon character.
@@Quzga Yeah but every now and then the movie perfectly lines up with the channel, and it's epic -- this is one of those times
@@MoMoMyPup10 Yup, and the fact they're old enough to have family members they grew up with who were in the war makes their perspective more interesting than the avg youtuber too!
You aren’t a simple woman. You are THE BEST type of woman.
Lol so you one of the 700 that plays this trash.
Something that I read recently that was interesting was that Winters only went on the set once. All the actors were in the back of a truck, and he opened the tarp and others said they could just see the blood drain from his face. Winters later said he felt he saw ghosts on that day, because the casting was so good at getting actors who look so close to the actual people.
Seeing them must have triggered some of his memories
Calling it one of the best TV series ever made is no hyperbole. IMO, it's the best 10 hours of television ever made. The show is not only perfect storytelling and a fantastic story, but it's a technical masterpiece of filmmaking. Excited to see you guys react to it!
I LOVE when Oak was talking how he was into more documentaries than shows and Quinn was looking straight into the camera like “This dude is going to love this so much more he has no idea” lol
Honestly, this series is probably the best television ever made. It's absolutely wonderful. And I have no qualms shamelessly promoting it and spitting out fun facts such as the fact that throughout filming, all the actors were only known by their character name, so much so that when the army guy who consulted on the film talks about them, years, decades later, he still refers to them as their characters.
The next is that the real people i.e. Wild Bill, Dick Winter, etc were even more amazing. And they were tough as nails. Couldn't keep those guys down.
you're absolutely right, Batman!
There's so much they had to tone down for the show because they thought the audience would never believe it. The actual men were such superheroes they did things deemed too "unrealistic" for TV.
@@pabloc8808 I know right? It's so fascinating listening to the podcasts (done for the 20th anniversary) and learning about the OG guys. Really just Legends.
If they haven't seen it yet, every war show they watch after this will be 2nd rate..
And EVERY reaction I've watched has the same laugh and chuckle the first time they see "Ross" as Capt Sobel.
I liked when Wizard of Oz used to come on NBC once a year
I still get goosebumps when this series intro starts
The Band of Brothers experience is either 1) you watched it when it was new and you've spent the last 20 years realizing that you recognize every other up-and-coming actor from a bit part in the show, or 2) you watched the show later on and are mystified about why X actor only got a bit part.
And find out half the cast are british.
Welcome to what's arguably the finest miniseries ever made....the gold standard.
Welcome to the best mini series ever made
A person of culture, I see. The BEST.
Only one that comes close is Chernobyl or pacific. And true detective before they decided to continue it with more seasons. Band of brothers is the personification of perfection
No lie
I used to hold this series up as the greatest but Chernobyl now shares that spot with BoB. You can't go wrong with either one.
@@trev9168 chernobyl is still on my to watch list, but i love the pacific mention bc, while i do have a preference over band of brothers *overall*, i also did love the pacific for what it was and i don't think it gets the praise it deserves tbh. 😭
When you rewatch the show numerous times, it gets you emotional seeing these guys back in boot camp. They're so happy and carefree.
Exactly. I can’t imagine going through and then jump in the dark to not see some of them again while being 20 years old.
This is a 10/10 perfect show. One of the vets came to the filming and walked away from the set because he said "he was looking at ghosts" that speaks volumes on how much they put into being true to those who didn't make it.
Buckle up guys. You're in for a ride...
Edit: As a vet (though not in wartime), soldiers always rely on humor. Dark humor, gallows humor, light hearted humor, anything and everything to get the mind off of the task at time.
Dark humor, e.g.:
"There was blood upon the risers,
there were brains upon his 'chute
Intestines were a-dangling
from his paratrooper suit
They poured it from his helmet
and they poured it from his boots
And he ain't gonna jump no more"
to the tune of "The Battle Hymn of the Republic".
Sobel is real. His son was still going to Easy Company reunions. There are interviews about the portrayal of him.
They make him come off as a real asshole but in honestly his harsh training regimen ensured they'd survive what was to come.
@@Shadowpack95 These were almost all young "boys". He helped make them men.
Do me a favor guys, encourage them to watch Schwimmer's BEST role in a serious war movie called "Uprising" which was done around the same time as Band of Brothers. He was EXCELLENT in it. These guys would have an amazing reaction to a VERY important story as far as I'm concerned. Schwimmer was excellent in that role.
@@Shadowpack95 if he was competent, regardless of his training method and leadership, they might have still succeeded albeit some setbacks
What's great is that you guys just started watching Peaky Blinders, and Aunt Pol (RIP) was married IRL to Damian Lewis who leads this series.
I honestly dont understand how you guys have never seen Band of Brothers after over twenty years but Im glad we get to experience it with you now. Enjoy the greatest television show ever made. One that actually nails the landing.
Sobel was absolutely real and portrayed in the series as described by the men of Easy when Stephen Ambrose interviewed them for his book of the same name. That being said, he did not want to comment / be interviewed himself and so he kinda missed an opportunity to refute any of the claims against his character. For those who haven't read the book, there's also a funny anecdote about Sobel's lack of coordination even when he shouldn't have needed a map. It's been a while since I read the book but I'll try and recount it from memory:
I can't recall if it was the incident where someone impersonated Major Horton or whether it was a seperate incident where the guys had messed with him, but in an attempt to get his own back Sobel took a chance when the men were sleeping in foxholes as part of their training. Essentially he went around and stole their guns while they slept, with the aim of chastising them the next morning for not having looked after their weapon.
Supposedly Sobel ended up getting lost during the night and instead went around taking the guns from Fox company instead. Easy company started getting yelled at the next morning for not having looked after their weapons but they were all dumbfounded since...well...they were holding their weapons. Later, a pissed off Fox company showed up demanding their weapons back.
It should be said, that even though Sobel gets a bad rap both in the book and on the show, whether they liked him or not, I think every man agreed that Sobel "made" Easy what it was.
Do me a favor, encourage them to watch Schwimmer's BEST role in a serious war movie called "Uprising" which was done around the same time as Band of Brothers. He was EXCELLENT in it. These guys would have an amazing reaction to a VERY important story as far as I'm concerned. Schwimmer was excellent in that role.
I am shocked you guys have not seen this series, you are in for a treat fellas enjoy.
I did watch this a few years back, and seeing this now I'm just realising that Schwimmer shot this DURING Friends. That's insane. That guy did not get enough credit as an actor.
So glad you guys are doing this series! I watched this series 8+ times in the past 2 years
Somehow I got it into my head that you had seen this already. You guys are in for a treat.
Only MQ has seen it. 🤜🤛
Oh good, a new cry session once a week with the boys
You , my dudes , are in for a ride .
BoB needs to be shown in every High School history class .
Sobel was real. He was a real A-Hole. And what is funny, the only difference between him cutting the fence that let the cows out. In real life, it was done in the middle of the night.
He wasn’t some failure though. He went on to win awards for valor and did well in the Army for over 20 years.
There's a documentary about Sobel on RUclips. He might have won some awards, but he had a tough time postwar
There's some controversy about that, Sobel's family claims the Easy men portrayed him in a negative light due to antisemitism; not saying he wasn't a dick, just that maybe he wasn't as much of a dick as shown here. Plus, the vets themselves acknowledged that Sobel's training kept them alive and was the reason they were able to do some of the things they did. Also Sobel fought in Normandy and, despite his well-earned reputation as a bad field commander, he was outstanding, immediately after landing he led his men to destroy an MG nest and then went on to fight at Carentan.
@@pabloc8808 There's a few cases of this (the worst being with Dike in a later episode). It's a problem of this series adapting Ambrose's book to the memories of the Brothers instead of getting a full picture of every side character. It makes for a fantastic story but completely susceptible to bias.
@@kueller917 Yup, Ambrose's book is a textbook example of what NOT to do as a historian. He got so much wrong because he was lazy and generally incompetent, it's not that hard to double check information you get from primary sources by simply... finding other primary sources. Or records. Or anything, really, but he just didn't bother.
Great that you watch with subtitles. Makes it easy to follow who is who - for when vets names are ultimately revealed in the finale and in the documentary.
Speaking of which, please be sure to watch the accompanying HBO documentary once you finish the miniseries. It serves as a perfect capstone/ episode 11 with lots of context from all the vets. It is called “We Stand Alone Together.”
The men disliked Sobel and definitely knew he wasn’t cut out to be a combat leader but they did give him credit for his tough training getting them ready.
In the meantime - enjoy the amazing ride about these amazing men.
Great reaction! I love this series! As a veteran myself, there is a lot more levity than what people think. It really helps you to mentally get through training and anything else that comes your way.
Been watching you guys for a while and enjoying each visit. This series and your review is worth the extra thanks!
Thank you very much for the super 🤜🤛
I loooooove Band of Brothers. Watch it at least once a year. Looking forward to Oaks reactions especially
FINALLY! Band of Brothers is one of the greatest pieces of entertainment ever made. So glad you guys are finally getting to see it.
Lol Mason Quinn said he's watched this show multiple times and owns the DVDs and then 5 seconds later the graphic says "first time watching" for all 4 guys lol
Yeah I did a double take but couldn't be bothered to rewind . . . Thx for saving me the trouble
Simon Pegg - Cornetto Trilogy, Mission Impossible, The Boys - delivered the court martial notice in the jeep.
This series has at least one young star I know will blow your minds.
This series will leave you shell shocked, proud and in tears.
Good review guys. I agree that Band of Brothers is the one of the best if not the best show ever made! Interesting fact that Sobel was an excellent training officer but was not good in the field. Yes Sobel was real and was the first commanding officer of easy company and yes his Sargents did rebel against him. Many of the men of Easy Company who trained under Sobel who survived, including some of the men who "rebelled" against him later in life admitted that the hard training they received under Sobel as one of the reasons they were able to survive the war. So what Col Sink did giving him the command of a training school was the best allocation of his resources.
I remember most of this filming down the road from me in the UK (as well as Saving Private Ryan). I distinctly remember being in a history lesson & we'd hear WW2 planes & explosions going off. A couple of years later, i believe in 2003, our great history teacher showed us an episode. I've rewatched the show almost every Christmas since then.
And so, the Band of Brothers journey begins anew.
The actors did a military style bootcamp before filming...you can find it on RUclips 😊
My father was in the Army Air Corps, and my mother joined the Marines in World War 2 when she was just 19. I'm looking forward to all your reactions to this fantastic series.
I have been feeling quite stressed and odd lately; I moved to another country a couple of days ago and it has taken a lot of work to make that actually happen. I'm very excited about this new chapter in life, however, I'm still quite exhausted from the past months. A couple of years ago I woudn't have imagined how much happiness I could get from seeing that some youtube reactor starts to react to a show I love, and now I gotta say that you guys put a huge smile on my face yesterday and I felt my worries melting away as I was watching your reaction. I'm sure you're gonna enjoy the show - it is amazing! Thank you for your existence and cheers&love from this Finnish person now living in Greenland!
I cant wait for you guys to see the documentary after finishing the series. It is an emotional journey
Regarding the training……
Camp Toccoa Georgia was the FIFTH consecutive boot camp for Winters.
He went to boot camp (#1) at Camp Croft SC in Sept 1941 when he joined the Army in August 1941. Instead of staying with his unit he was assigned to be one of the drill instructors for the next boot camp. (#2)
When that boot camp was over Winters, a college graduate, was assigned to OCS (#3) at Ft. Benning Ga in April 1942 as a trainee. (He met Nixon there as a fellow trainee) When OCS was over and he was commissioned as a 2nd Lt. he was once again assigned to Camp Croft as a DI (boot camp #4) because there were no openings at Parachute Training. Several weeks he was transferred to Camp Toccoa (#5).
Camp Toccoa was a combination boot camp/parachute training. Winters, Nixon & Sobel trained the men for their boot camp but joined them as fellow trainers in parachute training.
I am so shocked but SO HYPED! I've watched this so much too, own several of the books about and from these men, and back in the day (2003) I used to talk with some of the actors on the BoB forums, posting fan art etc. (Michael Cudlitz was super nice.)
My pride and joy is a signed copy of the BoB hardcover from one of the real Easy Co men before he passed away. I won't say which one, as to not spoil that he survives in the show :)
It's amazing how often reacters completely miss Michael Fassbender's appearance. It's not even a small one; he's the guy who has to redo the no-water run.
He was such a baby, and with the American accent, it's easy to miss.
OMG YES!! I always assumed you'd all watched this already and that's why there were no reactions, I'm so excited!
I go back and watch this series every year in the fall. Glad y’all are starting this series.
The first time I saw BoB was in the fall, and so, just like you, fall comes around, and I HAVE to watch it again. Last year, one of my DVD's was scratched, so I went and upgraded to Blu-ray. 😊
Finally! Been looking forward to this. I am sure you'll do this amazing series justice.
Absolute masterpiece. My grandfather also fought in the war for the allies ( Royal Australian Army ) so I feel a connection to the story being told. I watch this series at least once per year.
Mason knows what the guys are in for.... one hell of an experience.
Let’s gooooooo! I love y’all’s reactions and I love Band of Brothers (I grew up with it and the 101st- I’m an army brat) and to see yall reacting to it I’m excited! Can’t wait to follow y’all’s journey with this series. Definitely look at The Pacific and Master of the Air after as well if you haven’t yet!
Haven't watched Masters of te Air yet but The Pacific is so much bleaker than Band of Brothers (for a reason, of course). It's a fantastic show but I was shook watching it, we know a lot about the Pacific Theater but don't really understand how much worse it was than Europe for those men.
I saw this serie a few times now. I remember when it was on Dutch tv I hated that I had to wait a week for the next episode and on a Sunday while I had to go back to base the next morning to NCO school. The story and buildup is so good and as a vet and growing up with stories from my grandparents who lived through WW2 it hits so close to home. I even had the honour to talk to some of pur Canadian liberators on our national libaration day in the 90s. Brilliant series. And all those Brits playing Americans is amazing.
Happy to see you are reacting to it! I think i have watch every reactor in youtube reacting to this awesome show. Enjoy!
PS! Try not to Google stuff ahead of time. It takes the edge off if you know who is who in the beginning (who survived)
This is by far my favorite show of all time...you guys are in for one hell of a ride...
BAND OF BROTHERS!! YES!! FINALLY!! I'M SO HAPPY TO WATCH YOU GUYS REACT TO THIS!! 😁😁
YES! Clicking like immediately.... best bunch of guys reacting to the best series ever set to film. Looking forward to hearing your comments
I was in Saudi on 9/11 and came back stateside at the end of September for some additional training in D.C. before being redeployed. I watched most of this series from a hotel room in Maryland during that few weeks of training. I re-watch it once a year and it's every bit as good over 20 years later, but it still puts me in mind of those crazy days right after 9/11.
A lot of people will tell you that The Pacific isn't as good a series, but I think it's every bit as good and absolutely worth the watch in the future.
“When I went in, I was eighteen. I thought it was all glory and you win lots of medals. You think you’re going to be the guy. Then you find out the cost is very great. Especially when you don’t see the kids you were with when you went in. Living with it can be hell. It’s like the devil presides in you. I knew what I sighed up for, yes, and I would do it again. But the reality of war-words can’t begin to describe it.”
William “Wild Bill” Guarnere
Easy Company, 101st airborne
Hell yeah!
This is a masterpiece of a show!
I am happy you guys are starting this :D
Man, it's been more than a decade since I watched this. My sister and I watched this together with our mother and it's something I've never forgotten. It's a documentary series with filmed scenes, very beautiful and respectfully made. This had such a big impact on me and gave me so much insight in the times of war and the people from the time.
Very good series to see for everyone who has an interest in WOII.
My favorite series of all time, idk how many times I've personally watched it or how many reactions.
Oak is going to love this because it's based on historical events and they interview actual veterans.
Oh this is going to be good. Just wait until Why We Fight. Hey you should watch the documentary We Stand Alone Together after this series. Should be on the discs if you're watching from DVD or Bluray.
Why We Fight and the documentary can make any grown man with a soul cry. The documentary is both heartbreaking and heartwarming, those men were truly a different breed. "A different time".
@pabloc8808 Oh hell yeah. I'm nearly 40, have served myself, and have watched this over a dozen times. "Why We Fight" makes me cry every single time.
It is amazing how fast he goes from Ross to Capt, Sobel. Credit to the writers, directing and the acting to make that transition so quick.
So incredibly excited to have you guys finally reacting to Band of Brothers on the channel. Cannot WAIT to see Oak loose it over this incredible series!
Oh my word! Mr. Oak, as you said you're really into WW2 history, but you've never seen BoB, that to me is exceptionally rare.
All I can say is, prepare for your most profound viewing experience of a lifetime, hands down.
I'm addicted to watching BoB reactions on YT. My tally must be close or more than 20x reactions seen. I'm unquestionably excited to see this once more, with you guys. Thumbs up!
Peaky Blinders and Band of Brothers, you guys are too good to me. ❤ Yeah guys this one is legendary. I usally watch it once a year for over a decade now. Much love!
Your ads are always 10/10 😂 Give Answer his Oscar.
If you didn't know: Damian Lewis, who plays Winters, was married to the late Helen McCrory, who plays Aunt Polly in Peaky Blinders.
And I could be wrong, but I think she played Narcissa Malfoy in the Harry Potter series as well.
@@JohnLoutsenhizer Yep, she did.
31:08 you can RUclips the Ron Livingston special feature from the DVD set to see the training regimen the actors went through. They got it pretty damn close to the real deal.
One of the cable channels (History, i think) plays the series twice a year - Memorial Day weekend and around Dec 7. I watch it every time. This is such a well made series.
This is always a must watch when a reaction channel starts covering Band of Brothers. It’s a truly excellent series.
I honestly don't think anything can prepare Oak for whats to come. This show set the bar for WW2 presentation in media
I am a huge fan of this channel, I wanted you guys to know this series really inspired me on my weight loss journey. I will be running two foot races on Currahee mountain on Oct, 5th in honor of the hero's that trained on that mountain and then fought for our freedom. Thank you so much for all that you guys do.
the gasp i gasped
Flashing back to training was a real nice device to get aquainted with the characters. Knew it was a winner when the Vets were speaking of their experiences during the intro. I own the set.
You guys are doing some amazing series right now, so excited for the next few weeks.
My grandpa married his sweetheart and joined up. He was 22. He served in the pacific where he earned two Purple Hearts and the Bronze Star for heroic actions. He never spoke about it much, but he said that mail call was the worst time, hearing the name called out of someone who was killed just the day before. Even in his old age whenever he walked in the mountains behind his home he couldn’t stop himself listening for snapping twigs or the shuffle of gear. My husband’s grandfather lied about his age and joined the navy at 16. The men of that age were built different, I can’t fathom it.
This is the mini series I watch twice a year. It’s so good.
Twice? better pump them numbers up lol
@@morbidangel2424 I thought that was already quite a bit 😂
A quick search of the main channel page suggests that the Baddies may not yet have experienced another of HBO's finer miniseries, "John Adams." If y'all are going on an American history binge, I'd heartily recommend having a go at that one.
Oh I loved John Adams. I watched like 3 times..
I'll second this, as well as toss along my infinite regard for how John Adams conducted himself in regards to the Boston Massacre.
@TheMadSentinel that would be a good one too
Oh my gosh it’s finally happening! I can’t wait to go on this amazing journey with you guys!!❤
The amount of work they put into molding the actors into the men of Easy is so cool. The fact the actors all took time to talk to the real men easy and their loved ones to learn how to best portray them. The made the actors go through bootcamp together to bond.
I think this is the one of the best tv shows ever made. They just make it so real somehow. I'm really looking forward to your reactions to these episodes. There's so many scenes that I can't wait to see what you think and feel about.
This is my favorite series ever. I usually watch it once every couple of years. It is fantastic. I hope you all enjoy it as much as I have, seems like from this first episode that is going to be the case.
I went over to Europe with my dad this spring on a BoB tour through Stephen Ambrose Tours and followed their footsteps. Went to Toccoa, visited England, crossed the channel to Normandy went over the bridges of market garden, ran the field in crossroads, walked through the forests of Bastogne, saw Dachau, and captured the Eagles nest. It was a once in a lifetime opportunity. Recommendation: The National WWII Museum did a weekend symposium for the 20th anniversary. Many of the actors, writers, and children of the actual soldiers attended and had sessions. Those can all be found on RUclips. It is very interesting and also entertaining.
I need to take this tour! That sounds absolutely incredible! -Oak
Shifty Powers niece was on our tour. She brought his actual jump wings and clicker along! Absolutely highly recommend this tour. We got to see way more from WWII than just BoB. We had a full time historian and he personally knew many of the actual men, and boy did he have some Stories.
So glad you guys are doing this series. Y’all will love it!
Band of Brothers is a timeless series. It's not a "war" tv show, it's not a "history" tv show. This portrays the triumphs, heartbreak, struggle, and persistence of the American, and human, spirit. You can watch this series from a psychology lens and learn about mindset and growth. You can learn how to be a strong leader. You can explore the depths of human bonding and go through the various stages of team development: forming, storming, norming, and performing. Band of Brothers shows us how men grow and connect, how we can rise to occasions, how we can uplift each other, and how we can work together for a common cause. I love this show, and I'm so glad you guys are (finally) watching it. These men were the greatest generation, and people we, in modern times, can look to for inspiration - not to "feel better" but to work towards.
Rarely have I ever seen a more well matched show and reactors. Cannot wait for you to experience this.
Hands down the greatest miniseries ever made. I would HIGHLY recommend watching not only key the documentary episode included on the DVD’s, but also Ron Livingstone’s vlog series from the incomparable training by the legendary Captain Dye (who plays Col. Sink in BoB)
So jealous you guys are getting to watch this for the first time. Truly a masterpiece that still holds up today. This is series I rewatch every year and I’ve watched multiple channels react. Just an amazing piece of cinematic art.
Enjoy, boys.
You guys are one of my favorite reaction channels & this is one of my favorite shows of all time. I’m so excited for you to delve into this story.
Saw this notification at lunchtime and got ridiculously psyched. You certainly didn’t disappoint! This is going to be an amazing journey.
One of the best series ever made, for sure!
28:25 "Just send it in the mail?!" - Until the late 1960s, any legal firearm could be mailed through the Postal Service, including new purchases. You could order guns from anyone (including Sears and Roebuck) and have them shipped to your door.
Correct. Lee Harvey Oswald ordered the rifle he shot Kennedy with through the mail.
Omg I'm so happy to see you guys starting this one! Definitely my fave show of all time ❤️
The most realistic part of this episode:
"Nobody told me."
"I telephoned."
"I'm quartered with a family that has no telephone."
The second most realistic part:
One last thing before getting on the airplane to go do this invasion you've been practicing for two and a half years - take this pill, we think it might help but we don't know if there will be any side effects.
Oh my gosh, yes! For some reason, I kept thinking you guys had already reacted to this series, so the few times I would search Band of Brothers & Badd Medicine reaction, nothing ever came up and I'd get bummed. I must have manifested it! Haha! ;)
You guys are in for a great ride, this is one of the best TV shows ever made. I rewatch it almost every year.
Absolutely living for your sponser adds…amazing guys 😂
Ecstatic that you are taking on this series! I watch it yearly. It’s simply an amazing series. After this, I hope you tackle The Pacific as well.
Welcome to the miniseries! One of the quirks of being in the service is that you can formally affiliate with a unit you serve with. When I was serving in the Army in 2003, I was assigned to the 1/506th in South Korea, and this miniseries was required watching for us. They left such an impression on me that I affiliated with them, and I carried their insignia with me to each successive unit. These guys are like extended family to me.
So happy to see you guys review this masterpiece. My all time favorite mini series.
Band of the brothers : Brotherhood of war
The Pacific : Brutality of war
Generation Kill : Futility of war
The holy trinity, i haven't watched airmen one
It’s been glossed over quite a bit, but one of the characters that gets precious little focus did a lot to secure Easy Company’s survival.
Once it became clear that Sobel was incompetent in the field in spite of his excellence in training, Ed Tipper got to work.
Tipper purposely mislaid maps and documents, and subtly misdirected Sobel in such a way that Sobel’s incompetence was glaringly obvious to the brass. He did a lot behind the scenes that resulted in Sobel being replaced with Meehan.
As a veteran I’ve watch this series like 8 times and it makes my cry every time every episode.
You are about to embark on a unique television series. The story of exceptional people and their incredible emotional sacrifice. You will know and remember them them by name by the end of the show 😁
Bro, i started this series a month ago and I still haven't been able to get through the episodes, but what I've seen so far is really good. It's cool that they reacted to it on the channel.