As a general reply cos multiple people mentioned "piu" - like i said its not technically wrong but most hk people will say "fei" instead. I've seen Lucas do this on multiple occasions, where he speaks in a more "formal/written" way or use word choice you'd commonly only use when speaking mandarin. Its difficult constantly switching between two languages so it's understandable why he gets confused!
Yangyang said, Lucas, Xiaojun, and Hendery use Cantonese when they are together. Yangyang and Ten use English when they are together. Kun and Ten use Korean to speak to each other. When they are together (seven members), they use Mandarin. When they are with their manager, they use Korean.... Yeahhh just in WayV.... also, they often use more than one language in one sentence😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@hayatunnufus2855 I guess he uses mandarin with everyone, maybe Korean with Ten and Kun but I don't think his Korean is very good so probably Mandarin
Lucas said in Happy Together his mother tongue is Cantonese and in the vlive with Yuta,Winwin and Ten he said he come to korea just for study mandarin lol
Lol I have to count too because the numbers in Chinese is different than in English and it really confuses me. Like 100,000 is 100 thousand but in Chinese is 10万
Simply going off of their track record with schooling and where they lived, Lucas technically should be the best at Canto since he lived in HK for his whole life before joining SM, but his brain gets easily jumbled by too many languages lmao
@@encityShake If he's able to do activities in HK in the future, I think his Cantonese will return back to normal! But I'm not sure if WayV will ever be able to promote in HK at this point because of everything that's going on there :s
i’m a new fan so i don’t really know much about their lives, but what makes hendery and xiao jun not as great as lucas in cantonese since hendery is from macau and xiao jun is from guangdong. People in macau and guangdong speak cantonese.
@@tracy_5577 yes xiaojun is from mainland so he had to learn mandarin as well. school is in mandarin even though cantonese is spoken where he is from. And Henry went to school in mainland too. He went to school in Beijing
@@tracy_5577 It actually depends on where one's family is from. Due to historical reasons, the majority of Hong Kong people are immigrants from Mainland China. These people are from different backgrounds. There are Shanghainese, Hokkien, Teochew, Hakka, and Cantonese. Likewise, the people of Guangdong are made up of three major groups, the Cantonese, the Teochew, and the Hakka, so even though these people have Cantonese as their mother tongue, they are still more or less influenced by the accent of the older generation in their family. Lucas's paternal grandmother is Teochew. Xiaojun's paternal grandmother is Hakka. Also, Xiaojun is from Dongguan and sometimes he pronounces certain words with a Dongguan accent. Hendery is from a Wing Chun Kung Fu family and he grew up in Foshan, so I guess he is from a family of Cantonese origin. This explains why all three members are fluent in Cantonese, but there are very subtle differences in their accents. Out of all three members, Hendery's accent is the closest to the Canton (aka Guangzhou) accent and he's also the most articulate.
Lucas, Hendery, and XiaoJun definitely speak Cantonese when they're together. You can always here them speaking in the background in Cantonese. Its actually cute that YangYang seems to be picking it up just by hanging around them. And I think Lucas just gets all jumbled up because he's all over the place with the languages; Mandarin when promoting with WayV and then Korean and English with Super M, he always seems to need a moment the "settled" with whichever language he's suppose to be speaking in. Its times like this where I wished my Dad would've taught me Cantonese so I can understand them better xD
I replied a comment similar to yours about Lucas stumbling/his words getting jumbled, and said that i think it's about the speed of processing ideas/words and articulating them match or not match. I mean i am either fluent or semi fluent in 5 different languages including my mother tongue, but still i stumble, butcher my sentences or forget words even when i am speaking my mother language. Though i think it's not because Lucas and I are not fluent, but is because our brains (at least myself) work very quick on the go but the process of speaking out loud/articulating gets jumbled because of not being able to switch as quickly as needed between languages. Just today i had to stop and try to remember the equivalent of the word Genius in my mother language Turkish, to be able to translate something to my mom.
it's really hard to pick one language when he knows so many. lucas speaks 3-4 languages(3-4 because i'm not sure if cantonese and mandarin are considered languages, they're topolects and have different rules). he's at least decently fluent in all of them, and since cantonese is his mother tongue, i'd guess lucas thinks mainly in cantonese but switches to mandarin, korean and english sometimes. that's why sometimes when he's speaking he slips up a little cantonese. my dad is similar to lucas, and thinks in mandarin, english and cantonese, and sometimes he struggles a little when he's talking lol
it's fascinating bc you can tell where each 99 line is from based on how they speak canto. Xiaojun has a more guangdong accent and speaks with formal vocabulary. Lucas speaks with very casual/informal vocabulary commonly used in Hong Kong canto and Hendery is like the mix of both since he's from Macau.
@@woongbinsupreme Quick question what does "오花鹿" mean? like I know, in the case of the video, its Korean and Mandarin(?) mixed... I only understood the literal broken down meaning of "oh, flower, and deer (??)", but I'm guessing that is not what it means...
@@idkJustCallMeJae it doesn't mean anything skdksk 😂 samgyupsal in Chinese is 五花肉，pronounced wuhuarou in mandarin and mmfahyuk in canto, 五/five in Korean is 오 as you know and hendery clowning the poor boy's accent just made it sound like 오花鹿😂😂😂 i hate him istg... but to answer your question, yes you absolutely interpreted it properly!
As soon as they start speaking canto they start sounding like dumb teenagers or my trash ass cousins or my older relatives roasting me.... it’s such a different brain mode to when they’re speaking Korean..
I actually agree that hendery sounds most fluent. Xiaojun has a slight south western Chinese accent and lucas’s cantonese is slightly broken. Xiaojun also says things kinda weirdly, like half mandarin half cantonese. Hendery’s cantonese is close to perfect. But I still love them all so much and they deserve the world. 💗
@@hibadw3259 yes his mother tongue is Cantonese but I think it’s because that he didn’t use his Cantonese a whole ton before xiaojun and hendery came, his Cantonese naturally got worse. It’s kinda like Yuta’s japanese where he said that he definitely forgot some.
@@megancheng3553 poor baby Lucas I can't imagine what is he going through every time he wants to talk, my mother tongue is Arabic and sometimes when I speak Hebrew I completely forget all about English, I need a whole minute to switch into English ... so I kinda understand him now 💔💔😭😭
@@veek.6310 ofc, i know he grew up speaking cantonese as a hong konger myself, i speak canto too. he does speak pretty slow but i think its just that he hasnt been using his cantonese a lot until 2019 causing him to naturally get worse at cantonese.
hendery is a cantonese native speaker (he said it during his vlive) cause he was born in macau and lived there. xiaojun was from guangdong, a place where mostly people use canton as their original language. lucas was lived in hongkong. so when i heard they spoke with cantonese, i just pretended to be shocked like : "WOW SO COOL." eventho i knew those 3 dorks are cantonese native speakers lol. and now their cantonese are lacking a bit cause their brain already learn another languages.
I love listening to wayv speak cantonese. I lived in guangzhou for a couple years and a lot of my coworkers spoke cantonese in the office and if became sort of a comforting language? Even though I can't speak it and only understand maybe 15 words, it's such a nice language to listen to.
yessss! I worked in hong kong and whenever I hear them speak it reminds me of my coworkers and students and brings me a lot of comfort. hard to reconcile that with the stance they took on HK back in 2019 though, that still hurts my heart
same! my family speaks (very) standard mandarin with a little taiwanese mixed in, but maybe because i grew up with cantonese babysitters, so even though i don't completely understand cantonese, it's somehow comforting to hear cantonese being spoken.
For real Yangyang is living the life of my dreams, he speaks German and Mandarin (my fave-sounding languages) plus English and picks up Canto. What an icon
i love wayv so much and it surprised me that three of them could speak canto because i am cantonese and hearing them speak my language just makes me so happy :')
even the way they use vocab is different! poor baby just strugglin out here 😂 i really wonder why they don't let hen or dejun speak canto more esp during their ments
I'm Cantonese and I know some Mandarin, and what the heck, my mind is about to explode, I've been mixing up languages now and I'm officially dead, this video got me even more confused with the 2 languages.
Tbh you can’t actually compare Lucas’ and Hendery’s Cantonese. Lucas is a hongkonger and Hendery is from Macau. The Cantonese in these two places vary. There’s some differences in the phrases and tones. HongKongers often add English phrases in their sentences, making them sound not so native.
yeah like theres some terms that are in other places that dont exist in hong kong (i think one of them is pie; like hk doesnt really have "pie" so they just make the cantonese word for pie sound like the english word for pie lol)
Im pretty sure it's safe to compare because as a Cantonese speaker whose family comes from HK, I think still Hendery's Cantonese is the most fluent and clearest. Hendery also sounds the really confident and comfortable when he speaks Cantonese, whereas Lucas stumbles and sometimes has weird diction choices. Also, at least, on camera, Lucas doesn't really speak long sentences and when he tries it's a bit incoherent. Edit: Lucas sounds more fluent in Cantonese when he's having a conversation, which makes sense because he's then solely thinking in that language.
Lucas is me when I'm switching from Mandarin to Cantonese 😂 Eventhough my Cantonese used to be more fluent than my Chinese but as I kept speaking Chinese more because of my friends and suddenly transitioning to Cantonese seems very confusing because sometimes they sound the same and I'd forget how to say most words in cantonese 😂
To those who thinks that Lucas is not fluent in any language...i just wanna to say he is already good enough..its really normal to get struggles with some language. Im a multilingual speaker too.i speak 9 languages. Sometimes i got confused and mixed up too. I can related to Lucas.
walalah really got me even tho i’m a cantonese speaker at first i was like what tf did he say banana? but after he was like vanilla. i was like ohhhhhhh lol
I'm actually low-key proud of myself because I can understand what they are talking about (normally I need subtitles when watching other groups) . Especially when u r living in a multilingual environment. 😌
Man cantonese is such a nice language and when people say it it makes them sound nicer than mandarin (im not being rude or anything but I speak chinese and mandarin just has a harsher tone to it :/)
omg though i speak both and I've always thought canto was such a crass language 😂 just because it's so slang-y in every day use and in mando we speak it how we write it, so it's just more polite in general... it's funny how different people hear differently though!
at this point idk what language lucas speaks fluently in anymore 😂 those times when you can't even speak properly edit : wayv : at a cantonese interview lucas who is a native cantonese speaker : YO WHAT'S UP LADIES
this is so funny to watch. i grew up speaking both mandarin and cantonese so I understand everything, it's so funny when they just randomly incorporate both into one sentence cause I do the same when talking to my family and don't even realize LMAO
I grew up watching HK drama and at one point i can understand without even reading much of the subtitles. Then transition to anime, then to kdrama. Now i barely remember any Cantonese. Lol
a lot of the time i don’t even realize they are switching because i speak (native) english and chinese and also understand canto since i grew up the same province hendery and xj did lmao it feels like the same language though it’s literally three
the thing about cantonese used nowadays is that it's informal and quite casual. mandarin is spoken with the same structure and vocabulary as formal cantonese, and informal cantonese uses words with slightly different contexts than mandarin, so sometimes cantonese speakers who speak a lot of both cantonese and mandarin may be a little unsure of when to use formal cantonese or not
lucas' accent somehow doesn't sound very local to me but hendery def sounds like he walked outta macau/hk. and xiaojun u can tell he's not from hk or macau or southeast asia, and sounds like he's from mainland/guangdong
4:09 i think the chinese subs were right though? lucas only says "no, fold a plane" in canto, and the sentence after that is in mandarin and correctly subtitled
I have a friend who live in Taiwan but speak Canto like he is born in Hong Kong. And he is a born Malaysian Chinese so he speak Mandarin and Malay fluently. I don't even know what is his main language anymore.😂 I asked him before, what language was he thinking with and he said he was confused most of the time.😂 Another question that I asked him made me feel like an idiot was if he dream in Chinese and he said 'I dream about your language.'😆 well, my language is very different from Malay so I was weirded out by that.😂
The problem for Lucas Hendery and Xiaojun is the written text Xiaojun Simplified Chinese Cantonese PRC while Lucas and Hendery use Traditional Chinese text for Cantonese HKG and Macau. In the case of Lucas and Hendery Yangyang can simply reply to them in Tradtional Chinese Taiwan-spoken mandarin while the latter two use Traditional Chinese Cantonese. To make it easy on NCT Mainland China Taiwan and Hong Kong Line they should be using Traditional Chinese Taiwan text just like how Lucas's local airline Cathay Pacific simply uses Traditional Chinese Taiwan on their website and Aeroplanes.
i’m not a fan of wayv, but when i heard them speak cantonese, i felt comfortable. it’s not often when you hear kpop idols speak cantonese. the second clip when hendery? i think ask what yang yang? wanted to learn really hits me because that how i am too when teaching others cantonese 😂
![[ENG] A chillingly accurate(?) lie detector... Hoping for WayV to be honest 🙏 | Idol Human Theater](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/tM7xXvMbaWU/mqdefault.jpg)
As a general reply cos multiple people mentioned "piu" - like i said its not technically wrong but most hk people will say "fei" instead. I've seen Lucas do this on multiple occasions, where he speaks in a more "formal/written" way or use word choice you'd commonly only use when speaking mandarin. Its difficult constantly switching between two languages so it's understandable why he gets confused!
like i normally just say ticket instead of piu or fei
Yangyang said, Lucas, Xiaojun, and Hendery use Cantonese when they are together.
Yangyang and Ten use English when they are together.
Kun and Ten use Korean to speak to each other.
When they are together (seven members), they use Mandarin.
When they are with their manager, they use Korean....
Yeahhh just in WayV.... also, they often use more than one language in one sentence😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣
How about winwin😂, what the language he uses to speak each other?
@@hayatunnufus2855 I guess he uses mandarin with everyone, maybe Korean with Ten and Kun but I don't think his Korean is very good so probably Mandarin
@@hayatunnufus2855 winwin uses korean with ten but mandarin with all the other members
Nana Yuuki the members also said that hendery and ten use english when they are together
Hayatun Nufus, he also uses his specific dialect and tongue with his family btw
You know Lucas is a native cantonese speaker when he starts counting the number digits . My parents do it all the time lmao
LMFAOOOOOO
im not Chinese can you please explain it to me yfjudfj
minx.toesies 4:16 he is counting in cantonese😁
Lucas said in Happy Together his mother tongue is Cantonese and in the vlive with Yuta,Winwin and Ten he said he come to korea just for study mandarin lol
Lol I have to count too because the numbers in Chinese is different than in English and it really confuses me. Like 100,000 is 100 thousand but in Chinese is 10万
Never in my life have I seen a man as close to saying "aYo whAT's UP bITCHES-" as Lucas was in that interview.
same energy as JOHNNY in the one United States one saying “WHATS UP M- JOHFAM”
TIMESTAMP PLEASE
Jaidaa 4:55
Simply going off of their track record with schooling and where they lived, Lucas technically should be the best at Canto since he lived in HK for his whole life before joining SM, but his brain gets easily jumbled by too many languages lmao
@@encityShake If he's able to do activities in HK in the future, I think his Cantonese will return back to normal! But I'm not sure if WayV will ever be able to promote in HK at this point because of everything that's going on there :s
i’m a new fan so i don’t really know much about their lives, but what makes hendery and xiao jun not as great as lucas in cantonese since hendery is from macau and xiao jun is from guangdong. People in macau and guangdong speak cantonese.
Tracy _ yes, I want to know too
@@tracy_5577 yes xiaojun is from mainland so he had to learn mandarin as well. school is in mandarin even though cantonese is spoken where he is from. And Henry went to school in mainland too. He went to school in Beijing
@@tracy_5577 It actually depends on where one's family is from. Due to historical reasons, the majority of Hong Kong people are immigrants from Mainland China. These people are from different backgrounds. There are Shanghainese, Hokkien, Teochew, Hakka, and Cantonese. Likewise, the people of Guangdong are made up of three major groups, the Cantonese, the Teochew, and the Hakka, so even though these people have Cantonese as their mother tongue, they are still more or less influenced by the accent of the older generation in their family.
Lucas's paternal grandmother is Teochew. Xiaojun's paternal grandmother is Hakka. Also, Xiaojun is from Dongguan and sometimes he pronounces certain words with a Dongguan accent. Hendery is from a Wing Chun Kung Fu family and he grew up in Foshan, so I guess he is from a family of Cantonese origin. This explains why all three members are fluent in Cantonese, but there are very subtle differences in their accents. Out of all three members, Hendery's accent is the closest to the Canton (aka Guangzhou) accent and he's also the most articulate.
Lucas, Hendery, and XiaoJun definitely speak Cantonese when they're together. You can always here them speaking in the background in Cantonese. Its actually cute that YangYang seems to be picking it up just by hanging around them. And I think Lucas just gets all jumbled up because he's all over the place with the languages; Mandarin when promoting with WayV and then Korean and English with Super M, he always seems to need a moment the "settled" with whichever language he's suppose to be speaking in. Its times like this where I wished my Dad would've taught me Cantonese so I can understand them better xD
I replied a comment similar to yours about Lucas stumbling/his words getting jumbled, and said that i think it's about the speed of processing ideas/words and articulating them match or not match. I mean i am either fluent or semi fluent in 5 different languages including my mother tongue, but still i stumble, butcher my sentences or forget words even when i am speaking my mother language. Though i think it's not because Lucas and I are not fluent, but is because our brains (at least myself) work very quick on the go but the process of speaking out loud/articulating gets jumbled because of not being able to switch as quickly as needed between languages. Just today i had to stop and try to remember the equivalent of the word Genius in my mother language Turkish, to be able to translate something to my mom.
@@a7xmaNga wah y'all so cool... my Eng is only decent nowhere near fluent and I'm not really good with my native languages either skskskkd
I wonder what language Lucas thinks in because he seems to struggle in every language he speaks lmao
An interviewer asked them that question once and his response was "I don't know!" followed by "I think in Cantonese when I'm angry" lmaoooo
THE WAY I WHEEZED AT THIS COMMENT HAHAHAHAHAHA
it's really hard to pick one language when he knows so many. lucas speaks 3-4 languages(3-4 because i'm not sure if cantonese and mandarin are considered languages, they're topolects and have different rules). he's at least decently fluent in all of them, and since cantonese is his mother tongue, i'd guess lucas thinks mainly in cantonese but switches to mandarin, korean and english sometimes. that's why sometimes when he's speaking he slips up a little cantonese. my dad is similar to lucas, and thinks in mandarin, english and cantonese, and sometimes he struggles a little when he's talking lol
Probably Canto first, his Mandarin and Korean seems to be about the same, then English.
This is common for people who speak multiple languages. Whenever I speak Spanish or French, I think in Mandarin.
it's fascinating bc you can tell where each 99 line is from based on how they speak canto. Xiaojun has a more guangdong accent and speaks with formal vocabulary. Lucas speaks with very casual/informal vocabulary commonly used in Hong Kong canto and Hendery is like the mix of both since he's from Macau.
Hendery: 希望 dajia keyi 多多 support our
Multilinguals: 👁👄👁
HE'S SUCH A FUCKIN CLOWN IM SO AJXJEJWJD
Him not letting yangyang live with the "我要食 ... 오花鹿" lmaoooooo im deceased
@@woongbinsupreme Quick question what does "오花鹿" mean? like I know, in the case of the video, its Korean and Mandarin(?) mixed...
I only understood the literal broken down meaning of "oh, flower, and deer (??)", but I'm guessing that is not what it means...
@@idkJustCallMeJae it doesn't mean anything skdksk 😂 samgyupsal in Chinese is 五花肉，pronounced wuhuarou in mandarin and mmfahyuk in canto, 五/five in Korean is 오 as you know and hendery clowning the poor boy's accent just made it sound like 오花鹿😂😂😂 i hate him istg... but to answer your question, yes you absolutely interpreted it properly!
@@woongbinsupreme ohh that makes sense thank you!
LMAO THAT WAS ME
I DIED AT XIAOJUN's "WALALA" 😂
I am a native cantonese speaker and i also was confused on what he was talking about
Hearing them speak broken ass canto makes me so happy 😭😭😭 this is how I speak with my family as well so it makes me laugh so hard
Omg same here 😂😭
Where are you from?
Fiona XD I’m from Toronto Canada ! What about you?
Me too girl😭😭 I wish my canto was better😰
Rachel Lee TORONTO NCTZEN/WAYZENNI SQUAD 😯🙋🏻♀️🙋🏻♀️
As soon as they start speaking canto they start sounding like dumb teenagers or my trash ass cousins or my older relatives roasting me.... it’s such a different brain mode to when they’re speaking Korean..
Rather than the actual contents of what they’re saying it’s the endings of the sentences... hai mm hai ah?
I'm dying, cos I grew up in a Cantonese-speaking household and I had the exact same reaction LMAO
in conclusion, i still can't understand them.
International fans problems
Right I want to distinguish Mandarin and Cantonese but even that I can't
Same😭😂
I can, kinda
@@sanjikamgr7468 I only speak Mandarin but for me Cantonese sounds more... flowy? Like rounder maybe, whereas Mandarin is more sharp and short
The fact that when they speak Cantonese Yangyang is like "yeahyeah okay its okay but i dont understand anything"
I actually agree that hendery sounds most fluent. Xiaojun has a slight south western Chinese accent and lucas’s cantonese is slightly broken. Xiaojun also says things kinda weirdly, like half mandarin half cantonese. Hendery’s cantonese is close to perfect. But I still love them all so much and they deserve the world. 💗
I don't understand why Lucas's Cantonese is broken? Isn't he from hongkong and his mother tongue is supposed to be Cantonese??
@@hibadw3259 yes his mother tongue is Cantonese but I think it’s because that he didn’t use his Cantonese a whole ton before xiaojun and hendery came, his Cantonese naturally got worse. It’s kinda like Yuta’s japanese where he said that he definitely forgot some.
@@megancheng3553 poor baby Lucas I can't imagine what is he going through every time he wants to talk, my mother tongue is Arabic and sometimes when I speak Hebrew I completely forget all about English, I need a whole minute to switch into English ... so I kinda understand him now 💔💔😭😭
I thought lucas is just naturally a slow speaker and short sentenced, like he grew up in hong kong, they speak canto there
@@veek.6310 ofc, i know he grew up speaking cantonese as a hong konger myself, i speak canto too. he does speak pretty slow but i think its just that he hasnt been using his cantonese a lot until 2019 causing him to naturally get worse at cantonese.
hendery is a cantonese native speaker (he said it during his vlive) cause he was born in macau and lived there. xiaojun was from guangdong, a place where mostly people use canton as their original language. lucas was lived in hongkong. so when i heard they spoke with cantonese, i just pretended to be shocked like : "WOW SO COOL." eventho i knew those 3 dorks are cantonese native speakers lol. and now their cantonese are lacking a bit cause their brain already learn another languages.
Actually most Guangdong people speak Mandarin nowadays and less people speak Cantonese(most of them are elderly people)
I love listening to wayv speak cantonese. I lived in guangzhou for a couple years and a lot of my coworkers spoke cantonese in the office and if became sort of a comforting language? Even though I can't speak it and only understand maybe 15 words, it's such a nice language to listen to.
yessss! I worked in hong kong and whenever I hear them speak it reminds me of my coworkers and students and brings me a lot of comfort. hard to reconcile that with the stance they took on HK back in 2019 though, that still hurts my heart
same! my family speaks (very) standard mandarin with a little taiwanese mixed in, but maybe because i grew up with cantonese babysitters, so even though i don't completely understand cantonese, it's somehow comforting to hear cantonese being spoken.
For real Yangyang is living the life of my dreams, he speaks German and Mandarin (my fave-sounding languages) plus English and picks up Canto. What an icon
And Korean
i love wayv so much and it surprised me that three of them could speak canto because i am cantonese and hearing them speak my language just makes me so happy :')
When they speak in Cantonese or English, I don't need subtitles finally. 😂😂
First time in life
Speaking of Hendery, His Sisters Are So Beautiful TaT Also i believe he speaks cantonese with his family
HENDERY IMINTING YANGYANG ACCENT IS SENDING ME INTO ORBIT
i really enjoy hearing canto line’s different accents though. it’s really a giveaway of where they’re from... then you have lucas lol
even the way they use vocab is different! poor baby just strugglin out here 😂 i really wonder why they don't let hen or dejun speak canto more esp during their ments
I'm Cantonese and I know some Mandarin, and what the heck, my mind is about to explode, I've been mixing up languages now and I'm officially dead, this video got me even more confused with the 2 languages.
i get the two confused a lot too ahah
Cantonese isnt a race lol its a language
I'm Canto and Mando and I'm learning both and struggling! I mix them up all the time!
@@danwolf4510 actually it is alright to call people who live in Canton areas Cantonese, like the areas covering Macau, Hong Kong, Guangzhou etc.
I'm Mandarin and I know like no Cantonese but I lowkey wanna learn cuz of these three goofs🥺
Tbh, I love to hear Hendery speaking Cantonese.. It sounds super natural
Tbh you can’t actually compare Lucas’ and Hendery’s Cantonese. Lucas is a hongkonger and Hendery is from Macau. The Cantonese in these two places vary. There’s some differences in the phrases and tones. HongKongers often add English phrases in their sentences, making them sound not so native.
yeah like theres some terms that are in other places that dont exist in hong kong (i think one of them is pie; like hk doesnt really have "pie" so they just make the cantonese word for pie sound like the english word for pie lol)
Im pretty sure it's safe to compare because as a Cantonese speaker whose family comes from HK, I think still Hendery's Cantonese is the most fluent and clearest. Hendery also sounds the really confident and comfortable when he speaks Cantonese, whereas Lucas stumbles and sometimes has weird diction choices. Also, at least, on camera, Lucas doesn't really speak long sentences and when he tries it's a bit incoherent.
Edit: Lucas sounds more fluent in Cantonese when he's having a conversation, which makes sense because he's then solely thinking in that language.
@@justinseagull7124 yea exactly. That’s why Cantonese from HK is mixed with English too
Tbh WayV speaking Cantonese just hit different- I feel so much at home when they're speaking🥺
does winwin speaks fluent cantonese?
@@sammi3517 I don't think so but I know he knows a few words
@@chijuaq he speaks in wenzhounese which sounds so crazy (the words and stuff)
We call it the devil dialect
LOLOLOL when you speak Cantonese and you got the "walala" before they explained it
Being someone who understands canto is aMaZiNg
meeee
The walala got me in tears LOL!!
i dont even understand or speak Cantonese but i just like listening to it
Xiaojun's Walala and the way Hendery corrected it and all of them laughing LMAOOOOOO
*patiently waiting for a song in canto* :3
Actually Hendery sounds more like a Hongkonger to me even though he's from Macau😂
Yea cuz Macau is right next to Hong Kong so the way of speaking is very similar :)
Yeah. Lucas’ Cantonese accent actually sounds more like how a mainlander would pronounce
I have never felt so proud of my nationality before 😩
Damn it hits different when you actually understand what they're saying 🥺🙏🏻 representation really matters
Lucas is me when I'm switching from Mandarin to Cantonese 😂 Eventhough my Cantonese used to be more fluent than my Chinese but as I kept speaking Chinese more because of my friends and suddenly transitioning to Cantonese seems very confusing because sometimes they sound the same and I'd forget how to say most words in cantonese 😂
To those who thinks that Lucas is not fluent in any language...i just wanna to say he is already good enough..its really normal to get struggles with some language.
Im a multilingual speaker too.i speak 9 languages. Sometimes i got confused and mixed up too. I can related to Lucas.
This is whar I needed
I love Artists who speaks their native language in an Interview or any other variety show and its sounds so amazing....
Hendrey speaks authentic Cantonese because in Macau they also speak canto there! Its probably more used than mandarin 💚 (I'm from hong kong)
Yang Yang trying to speak cantonese sounds so much like me trying to speak korean XD
yangyang is so freaking good at learning languages its shooking
It actually feels really good and heartwarming to be able to understand their language that majority don’t ykyk
LMAO when hendery chose ten i knew he was gonna nail it WAHAHAH thai sounds similar to canto sometimes
3:05 idk why but i LOST IT when hendery mimicked yangyang's "o dangzan yiu sik o hua lok a"
3:54 tou dai is more accurately “disciple” lol
i never hear someone speak cantonese this much before I stan wayv 😂 I want to learn more about it 😂
walalah really got me even tho i’m a cantonese speaker at first i was like what tf did he say banana? but after he was like vanilla. i was like ohhhhhhh lol
This is the only thing I don't need subtitles for omg
I love wayv 😍😍
I want to see Lucas and Jackson talk in Cantonese idk why Cantonese sounds like so good
This make me feel more closer to them 💚
I don't understand a single word that they're saying (expect the random English) for once and it's so confusing.
Now i know how much i miss hearing them talking in Cantonese n Mandarin again. WayV palli² comeback juseyo 😅💕
Xiaojun sounds so fluenttt omggg
When you're Italian but you study many languages and you're thinking if you should study ALSO Cantonese and you watch this video: 👁️👄👁️
This is so funny when you understand all the languages they spoke especially the wanala to walnut to wakanda to finally vanilla part HAHAHAHAHA
3:20 WinWin's polopau and ha-gaw is so cute
i love hearing their cantonese i can watch their videos without subtitles😭😭
I'm actually low-key proud of myself because I can understand what they are talking about (normally I need subtitles when watching other groups) . Especially when u r living in a multilingual environment. 😌
i'd like to say, Coz Im also from Hong Kong, "piu" is basically correct
omg lmao when i hear them speak chinese i hear my chinese bros, WayV.
When i hear them speak canto i hear my uncles fighting XD just me?
omg can you please make another one?!
My Cantonese kings.💕
I like how the title says 'Lucas Hendery XJ' when they're the ones who ... already speak Canto ... 😂
love hearing them speak canto and mandarin. no longer need those subtitles
aghhhhhh 😭 I'm so happy I don't need subs for once! 😂 but I'm CBC so even some stuff goes over my head LOLOL
Can anyone of them even speak completely in one language anymore?
I doubt it. Truly
Man cantonese is such a nice language and when people say it
it makes them sound nicer than mandarin
(im not being rude or anything but I speak chinese and mandarin just has a harsher tone to it :/)
I’ve heard people compare it to a song because of how many tones and intonations there are and it makes me really proud to be a canto speaker haha
omg though i speak both and I've always thought canto was such a crass language 😂 just because it's so slang-y in every day use and in mando we speak it how we write it, so it's just more polite in general... it's funny how different people hear differently though!
i finally don’t need subtitles to understand 😭
multilingual kings
I will never get over that ig filter on lucas and how he didn't even flinch 😂
at this point idk what language lucas speaks fluently in anymore 😂
those times when you can't even speak properly
edit :
wayv : at a cantonese interview
lucas who is a native cantonese speaker : YO WHAT'S UP LADIES
this is so funny to watch. i grew up speaking both mandarin and cantonese so I understand everything, it's so funny when they just randomly incorporate both into one sentence cause I do the same when talking to my family and don't even realize LMAO
I fell in love with Kpop idols who can speak Cantonese now.
it kinda feels nice them talking in conto cuz like i learnt conto when I was born cuz im hk ppl so ya it feels nice
Winwin's tones are good!!
Hey btw in there video with hello82 for the language thing
they said that lucas Hendery Xiaojun speak canto when they are by themselves so you right
Oh gosh i’m hollering at that vanilla thing with dejun😭🤣🤣
xiaojun speaks Cantonese like a native omg *ps im a native Cantonese speaker myself
Winwin and Kun have good canto! I don't know why but Lucas's canto makes me lol! Struggles of having to switch between so many languages
not me here in the middle of my online lesson 😭
Bro ten and yang yangs pronunciation is pretty good 👏👏
Multilingual kings🙂
I’m from hk and this is so relatable lmao. we always mix english and cantonese when we speak
Yes true thats what i heard from hongkong dramas/movies 🤣
I have never been so grateful that i live in hong kong 😋
I wanna see wayv on tvb smh like in an interview or smth
I grew up watching HK drama and at one point i can understand without even reading much of the subtitles. Then transition to anime, then to kdrama. Now i barely remember any Cantonese. Lol
a lot of the time i don’t even realize they are switching because i speak (native) english and chinese and also understand canto since i grew up the same province hendery and xj did lmao it feels like the same language though it’s literally three
the thing about cantonese used nowadays is that it's informal and quite casual. mandarin is spoken with the same structure and vocabulary as formal cantonese, and informal cantonese uses words with slightly different contexts than mandarin, so sometimes cantonese speakers who speak a lot of both cantonese and mandarin may be a little unsure of when to use formal cantonese or not
lucas' accent somehow doesn't sound very local to me but hendery def sounds like he walked outta macau/hk. and xiaojun u can tell he's not from hk or macau or southeast asia, and sounds like he's from mainland/guangdong
1:06 what a duality of huang guanheng.
i really wonder what language lucas thinks in
4:09 i think the chinese subs were right though? lucas only says "no, fold a plane" in canto, and the sentence after that is in mandarin and correctly subtitled
(nvm i saw u responded to someone else down there LOL)
I have a friend who live in Taiwan but speak Canto like he is born in Hong Kong. And he is a born Malaysian Chinese so he speak Mandarin and Malay fluently. I don't even know what is his main language anymore.😂 I asked him before, what language was he thinking with and he said he was confused most of the time.😂 Another question that I asked him made me feel like an idiot was if he dream in Chinese and he said 'I dream about your language.'😆 well, my language is very different from Malay so I was weirded out by that.😂
the forst thing i noticed was newyear in the live. Im shocked
The problem for Lucas Hendery and Xiaojun is the written text Xiaojun Simplified Chinese Cantonese PRC while Lucas and Hendery use Traditional Chinese text for Cantonese HKG and Macau. In the case of Lucas and Hendery Yangyang can simply reply to them in Tradtional Chinese Taiwan-spoken mandarin while the latter two use Traditional Chinese Cantonese. To make it easy on NCT Mainland China Taiwan and Hong Kong Line they should be using Traditional Chinese Taiwan text just like how Lucas's local airline Cathay Pacific simply uses Traditional Chinese Taiwan on their website and Aeroplanes.
i’m not a fan of wayv, but when i heard them speak cantonese, i felt comfortable. it’s not often when you hear kpop idols speak cantonese. the second clip when hendery? i think ask what yang yang? wanted to learn really hits me because that how i am too when teaching others cantonese 😂
yangyang just sitting there like 👁👄👁
Not me nodding my head like I understand what they’re saying 💀🤚🏾