I think Rouge would show up in the Knuckles first so that it won't feel like fan service to her in the movie when there's no build up to her. That's just my thought
I believe this too. I also believe the Knuckles show will actually be quite serious as a way to prepare the audience for the shift in tone from the first two live-action Sonic movies to the third live-action Sonic movie, as the first two live-action Sonic movies were relatively light-hearted while the third live-action Sonic movie will be an extremely dark movie (with only a few light-hearted moments here and there).
Maria Robotnik *has* to die in Sonic Movie 3 indeed. (And Gerald too) Her death plays a big part of Shadow's character hence why he's the way he is in SA2. And Paramount has gotta listen to the fans again on this one and treat her devastating demise AND Shadow's PTSD with respect. There are many kids movies out there (take Spider-Verse, Puss in Boots 2 for example) that were comedic and light-hearted but knew when to take themselves seriously.
I completely agree with you, except I think that Angourie Rice should be cast as Maria. Actually, to be honest, I don't really care who is cast as Maria as long as she is a cute white girl (like in SA2). And yes, like you I also want Maria's death and Shadow's PTSD to be treated with respect.
I think this is something that I could see happening here. Shadow having bits of his story being revealed little by little before unveiling the whole story gives us context to what happened to him during those times before being sealed off. I believe that Tom and Maddie will still being integral part of his story and I think they’re both still going to be around even if they’re not going to be there once he’s confident in who is he is and his friends.
In my headcanon for the movie, Black Doom offers Gerald a way to cure Maria through a sample of his blood or DNA or whatever which will make Maria immortal (unless she gets killed), but in return, Gerald has to help Black Doom and the rest of his species eat half of the human population. Gerald reluctantly agrees and Maria is made immortal (like Black Doom promised), but then Black Doom uses a GUN soldier as a pawn to kill Maria. This GUN soldier is Tom's father, because if I remember correctly, someone said in Sonic 1 (or maybe Sonic 2, I can't remember) that there has been a Wachowski protecting the town of Green Hills for 50 years and for that to have been said was NOT a coincidence. There are NO coincidences in movies, EVERYTHING you see in any movie is ONLY THERE because it is MEANT to be there. So anyway, Shadow kills Tom's father as revenge for Maria's death and now he's hunting the rest of the Wachowski family and this eventually brings Shadow to Sonic, as Sonic became a member of the Wachowski family at the end of the first live-action Sonic movie.
Actually speaking on that, if you go back to the 1st movie oddly specific that this line was in it ""I mean, there's been a Wachowski protecting this town for more than 50 years."" the same amount as Project Shadow... Sonic X revealed the soldier who ended up killing Maria and the effect it had on them so what if it's supposed to be a red herring of perhaps Tom's father being the very guy that shot Maria in the the Sonic cinematic universe?
If they killed Longclaw, they'll kill Maria. Also, I'd actually want the Live and Learn scene to go for hyper. I have a feeling that super would kinda lose it's affect after a possible battle between Shadow and Sonic. Not to mention, I think it'd be cool if it wasn't just Sonic and Shadow.
"If they killed Longclaw, they'll kill Maria." You're right. And in the concept art for Sonic 3, Gerald is shown as a skeleton. Maria will definitely be killed in the movie.
it would be interesting if the Soap Shoe were created by G.U.N a prototype meant for Shadow but they didn't get approved and Sonic randomly steals them, because they look cool. 😎
@@twoczents thx, also not saying this could or needs to happen, but as a Idea, this could be a interesting way to introduce the Thorndyke family as they could've been the creators of the Sneakers as a proxy for the government. so if sonic ever breaks his shoes he can always find upgrades hehe. 😁
Amy and Shadow are the most essential; the important to appear. The movie's story will be influenced by both elements of Sonic Adventure 1 + 2. While characters like Rouge, Big the Cat, Cream, etc. could be saved for later for other sequels or spin-offs if Paramount and Sega is willing to do so? Or those characters could appear suddenly in the movie but in a post-credits scene? Who knows? But what if Rouge appears to be part of the movie's storyline along with Amy and Shadow? It does makes sense as she may be the one who will break Shadow free from his 50-year slumber in suspended animation in the underground lab while stealing some top-secret tech from there for you-know-who (Eggman, hopefully be played by Jim Carrey again) whom happens to be alive from the rumble of his Death Egg Robot....but injured.
I do like the idea of sonic & Amy having a confidential romantic relationship, but I would like to see sonic liking Amy, not being a simp, but just a man in love who is kind and compassion, integrity with sonics heart to follow his love ones he stands and acceptably believes in, Amy would accept sonic’s honesty, caring and passion, I would also like Amy to be independent, mature & a compact of being energetic & a weaponise character with a hammer which, sonic gives it to her or something like that, as for an actress for Amy rose, Margot Robbie, she is playing a pink character in a live action Barbie as Barbie, in my opinion, if rouge comes in I’ll go for Michelle peyther, her definition fits for rouges, Make rouge for what she was from SA2 of her’s obsession of the master emerald and jewels 💎, think like she’s catwoman, she is a rival to knuckles, as an treasure hunter, but has a crush on knuckles, The final one is shadow being redeemed, where he is gonna win back to save the destruction of the earth from the biolizard as a prototype to him, he can slightly bad, but still care for others, but being compensate by someone that annihilation is not the right way, making people to be saved with a smile This is long so, those were how I would love to see in the 3rd instalment piece 👌. Edit: the story will be set a few months after sonic 2 during the Christmas season, sonic and knuckles do Spar at the mountains, they fight for 5 minutes, sonic and knuckles enter at the garage which is tails lab, he gives sonic an emerald radar to search for the missing chaos emeralds, they found a purple emerald in a cave, they take it back home, tails said that it will take him a while to process and analysis the emerald, but meanwhile, robotnik and stone go to an private facility under water, project shadow by the time they wake the creature up from his unconsciousness, shadow was away in rage and filled with vengeance, robotnik makes a deal with him to get revenge on sonic and his family and friends, when G.U.N created a female bat from sonics DNA, her goal is searching for the master emerald ETC.
@@BurningFlamesofDivineDragon I know, But Sonic X Japan is not PG by USA's Standards, it has cursing in it and questionable dialogue that isn't suitable for other Audiences
I don't see everything in this video happening in the movie, but some of it sounds like it definitely could happen. Rouge and Amy are likely candidates, but I'm not really sure about Omega. It'd make sense for him to be there, but I don't know if he will be there. I don't know how to incorporate Rouge into the movie without going overboard with her... you know what. If Sonic X can find a way around it, then I think the movies could as well. All I'm hoping for is a good movie, to be honest. I'm not one to make all these crazy expectations that I know won't be fulfilled. I have confidence in Paramount because they've been doing well with Sonic, Tails, Knuckles, and Robotnik, and they have been able to make two very enjoyable Sonic movies. I still have no idea who's voicing Shadow...
2011's King Fu Panda 2 opens up with a genocide of Pandas, and has a psychopath villain obsessed with murdering the main character....Why do people suddenly think that showing a character die in a flashback is too much for PG?
@@2ndspringtube708 Didn't SA2 show only a G.U.N soldier holding a... gun and that's how they showed she died? Like, it's not hard to show murder without showing murder.
I swear people act like kids are oblivious to the concept of death as if they never experienced the loss of a pet or a grandparent or something. I think most kids know the pain of death of a loved one so this shouldn’t be much of a problem.
@@jaydenlenzy3487 first of all a pet is different from an actual human being well known ,second of all they die naturally and they don’t really see them when they die and finally we are talking about a little girl getting shot onscreen do you think the kids of the families would like to see that onscreen ?being shot isn’t like dying naturally you know ?
I have a bit of theory of how amy could be introduce into the movie. Amy is a big fan of tarot cards , cards that can predict a person future ,and one of amy's cards tells her that she will go on a huge grand adventure on the planet earth and while there she will have a destined encounter with someone who is blue and by using a portal ring amy embarked on that journey and through crazy shenanigans amy winds up being apart of the main plot . when it comes to her relationship with sonic i think it would be like it's obvious that they both like each other and they just act really around each other, which in return can lead to a few cute moments between them , and depending how long the movie franchise continues i can see their relationship grow and develop throughout other movies . But hey .that's just a theory, a sonic theory
that's actually how her first appearance in sonic CD was, she drew tarot cards and ended up on little planet with sonic. I could see her have a mostly faithful appearance like tails
Sonic having a crush on Amy would be a VERY welcome and refreshing twist to their well-known dynamic! And if they aren't gonna make Amy insane, I'd be down for Movie Sonamy!
"Sonic having a crush on Amy would be a VERY welcome and refreshing twist to their well-known dynamic!" I disagree, I'd prefer Amy to not have a crush on Sonic at the start of the movie but to develop a crush on him by the end of the movie (but even then, only a mild crush). I'd prefer that twist. Something about Sonic being romantic just doesn't sit right with me. lol
@@Rishi123456789 But this is a completely different version of Sonic... He's a bit younger in the movies than in the games. I'll be very shocked if he isn't the one who falls for Amy. And how is that a twist? That's been done to death in other movies. Granted, it is different for these two characters specifically, but it doesn't feel refreshing in my opinion. It's still the same dynamic as before. That said, no one knows what Paramount will do.
@@RosheenQuynh: "I'll be very shocked if he isn't the one who falls for Amy." I won't. And we don't even know yet whether Amy will appear in the movie or not (she probably will though). Also, not everything about the movie versions of the characters is different from the game versions of the characters. For example, Movie Tails is still a genius and Movie Knuckles is still gullible.
@@Rishi123456789 I wasn't speaking about the third movie specifically, I just meant whenever she shows up. And I didn't say everything was different about their movie versions, but if they want to make Amy likable, she can't be a persistent and annoying fangirl...
Maria's death would not be a problem. PG movies can show characters die. Plus SA2 and Shadow showed Maria die, even if it wasn't shown explicitly we still were able to tell she died. And those games were rated E and E10+
You know Maria doesn't Need To Die She Could Just Get Critically injured or and shot And she would be forced to Inject herself With Black Dooms Blood she would then become the ultimate lifeform like shadow
Sonic X isn't even canon I do wish folks would stop using non-canon content as examples. I can't see Paramount using Sonic X references for the majorated of the third film. The writers have already said that Sonic 3 will be using the games Sonic Adventure 2 as well as the video game Shadow the Hedgehog. I hope this helps.
Half the stuff you talked about I could see happening like Shadow's backstory him, seeing Maria die right before he gets sent to Earth and wanting revenge I also feel like Amy will appear and maybe she'll need Sonic's help or she heard stories about him and wanted to meet him.I'm just not sure she'll fall for him first or if he'll fall for her first or maybe they'll fall for each other over the course of the movie but now I'm thinking because THIS Sonic is open about having relationships with the people he meets and cares about maybe he'll fall for he first and wouldn't mind dating her who knows maybe he'll start to get interested in girls and he might look at Amy that way when he meets her.I honestly don't think we'll see Rouge,Omega,or Big and I don't think Sonic will leave Tom and Maddie they're his family and they care about each other also A LOT of fans will be VERY sad if that happened
Ok but imagine they bring rouge and Amy into the plot by rouge stealing something valuable of Amy’s and runs to earth for her next hit (whispers of chaos emeralds on earth) and then Amy chasing her the whole way over HAH. Could set up a plot instigation of things going missing, Amy only having half the answers when she runs into sonic, and rouge running into shadow on a gem nab. It would have comedic potential and add plausibility to rouge and Amy’s arrival before getting into the more serious stuff
As a Sonally fan, it stung right in the heart to hear that Sonic will have a crush on Amy. As a Sonally fan, it stung even more because you're RIGHT!!!! THIS VERSION WOULD FALL IN LOVE WITH AMY!!!!!! OH NO!!!!! NOOOOOO!!!!!!!!! lol
I'm a HUGE Sonally fan and honestly, I wouldn't mind the idea of it! It'd be refreshing. It's never been done before! Of course, I'd rather have Sonic and Sal's dynamic...
@@raymontyoungblood4453 If they do that, I'm so curious how they'll play it out! Like, will Amy flirt back? Will she be playing hard to get but still tease him? Will she be disgusted of him? We have no idea!
I’d love to see Silver appear for a post credit scene. I know not a lot of people like Silver due to his reputation/representation in 06, but I still think he is a good and memorable character. IDW did a great job portraying him and I think with good writing and voice acting he can be a good character to introduce to the movies
I really agree that this movie shouldn't be a complete copy of SA2, it takes away it's uniqueness if it's just a retelling of something we've seen a thousand times. And with Sega being on a roll with Amy content lately, I think she is an obligatory introduction at this point, you can even have her already on Earth but in another country, say Japan, to justify her mannerisms.
now THAT would be interesting. all the sonic characters so far keep landing in America so for Amy to land in Japan would be a really good twist. but then would she speak with an accent? It would work. Or would she just be passing by as she looks for sonic and doesnt really get to learn the language, but stays there long enough that she picks up some of the culture? either way I hope something like that happens cuz there's sooo much potential
"you can even have her already on Earth but in another country, say Japan, to justify her mannerisms." But Amy's mannerisms are very Western, it's Cream who has Japanese mannerisms.
@@Rishi123456789 If you take her tomboy tendencies yes but Amy is a girly girl first and foremost, contrary to the west's more "girlboss" approach. Her idle animations are always delicate, her run especially, she is very friendly to open conversation with anyone, she particularely has a fascination with cooking, baking, shopping, she has an affinity for fate and fortune, that's what I'm getting at. Like, Sonic had his superhero idea from the comics he read, Amy might have the same approach but with manga instead, romance manga could be her thing (you know why). Amy already has eastern motifs from her creation, I say go all the way instead of straight up going Boom Amy just because the fake fans don't like her character.
I’m tired of people keep saying Boom Amy is best Amy, when she wasn’t. That would be Adventure-Unleashed Amy instead. And making her grow up in Japan honestly could help explain her mannerisms too. Or at least with a Japanese family. Maybe Rouge can pop up in England or London for the Knuckles series. And if Amy gets her ideas of love from Japanese romance manga and models herself off Japanese magical girls when using her own powers like Sonic did with superhero comics, that would be very fitting indeed. Amy’s love of the occult and her hammer (she can make so many of them) help callback to various magical girl tropes in Japan too.
I think one major change I want is when Eggman blows up the moon. How about instead, Eggman blows up the town of Green Hills. (Nobody has to die, maybe Sonic and the team get everybody evacuated just in time.) It would not only be emotional and heartbreaking, but also maybe give a chance to see Sonic get majorly pissed. Make the stakes higher and also make the adventure much more personal. But it doesn't have to be permanent. Maybe they can use the chaos emeralds to repair the town at the end of the movie.
@@dragondelsur5156 @andrewgreeb916 Actually, I just thought of it. Maybe not just destroying Green Hills, maybe all of the other places that Sonic went to on their trip. So Siberia, Hawaii, San Fransisco, Egypt, etc. All the places that Sonic went to in the first and second movie where Eggman knows. So the cannon doesn't need to fire one single shot, it could fire several shots that level all of those places and more around it to show the power. And that it wasn't even at full power.
I don’t know. It’s still possible that they could use Tom more prominently and push the father-son aspect even further. And even though we might see Amy and Rouge it’s still possible that the people behind the film could go another route and Tom might be the feasible key. I believe that Sonic 3 will be hitting much harder on the relationship between Tom and Sonic and that one of it’s strongest themes will be loss. In my mind there’s a fifty-fifty shot of the studio deciding to make the alternative choice and have Tom be put in Amy and Rouge’s shoes. I’m not saying that it’s the sure route that they will take, but it’s possible and the reason that I think this is because of Sonic X. To me Tom is somewhat like Chris, but is far more mature and more realistic. Partly what makes the character of Tom more easily relatable is that he has a more common career and position in life and that he’s shown to have more other flawed relationships with the ones that he loves. Whereas Chris was in a position where most people would dream of it, but rarely ever experience it. And as far as his relationships went with family and friends who he held close, they were shown to be more upbeat with few negatives. Also what helps Tom more is his maturity and knowledge and experience of how to handle others better. Whereas with Chris even though he was good hearted, was still a preteen and knew far less about such topics. Lastly it’s also important to note that Chris was the one who got the heavily important scenes in place of Amy and Rouge in Sonic X whereas Tom often fills that role in the films. However, I could still be wrong too. The studio could still decide to bring in Amy and Rouge as I’m not one hundred percent sure that they will take the route between Sonic and Tom. But even if they don’t include Tom as much, I do still think that Long Claw will be brought-up as like how Shadow lost his creator and Maria, Sonic lost Long Claw and that could be a possible talking point between the two.
Well I agree on you with most things but for certain things like Maddie and Tom leaving it kind of breaks my heart because I really like those characters and I would hate to see them go in fact we didn’t really even see them in the sonic two movie we normally just saw them in the beginning in fragments of the middle and then at the end so it wouldn’t make any sense to sit down with them but I get what you’re saying and honestly that would look like a great with you just keep Maddie and Tom in the mix and it would be great to see all of the sonic characters in the movie but I just think that if they have Maddie and Tom to come home to them parents would be great and we can see how they all react to having human parents!
The idea of Sonic and Amy's twist of Sonic possibly liking Amy instead makes me so happy and excited. I just think it would be so cute. As far as who I think would be in it, I kinda agree on the fact that Amy would be more likely to appear than Rouge. I can see Rouge appearing in the Knuckles TV show instead. I'm not worried about how Shadow's character will be written. Because I know he will be written well. The idea of ending the trilogy with Sonic going off on his own would be perfect. I'm just wondering, after that, would it be better to start a TV show or continue doing movies after that happens? I guess it would depend on how creative they can be with coming up with new stories. I'd find that pretty exciting! Honestly, I'm glad the way they've been writing Sonic differently. And Ben really suits this Sonic. Ben always does an amazing job of voicing characters joyful, energetic characters who have had a rough past. I'm so used to the Sonic who likes to be by himself. I still have a little hard time accepting this Sonic. But Ben is one of my favorite actors (thanks to when I first heard that he was casted to voice Sonic. When I heard how fitting he was for Sonic, I watched a couple of shows that he was in.) I know I've seen other people say that they want Black Doom in the movie. I could care less. In fact, I'd rather not see him. Perfect Chaos would be an awesome villain for the movie though. It's gonna be another year until a trailer comes out. But it's gonna come really fast.
Sonic X is to these movies like how the 90s Marvel cartoons are to the Marvel movies. Adaptations, retellings, referencing. I'm not a huge gamer or comic book reader but I already know this from what people review on this stuff
Lean into the dark aspects of the lore and give an emotional core to it like Kung Fu Panda 2 and Puss in Boots 2 did, both had dark and mature elements to it (bordering on the lines of PG to the point where you question if it's really a family friendly film) as well as really emotional moments that almost make you cry. I don't want them to make me cry (they should atleast try), just as long as the emotions hit pretty hard and make you feel things. The last 2 movies were pretty lighthearted but since this is the third movie, they should go all out for it to be the biggest in the trilogy. I also think adding Amy and Rouge is the most ideal because it doesn't overwhelm the audience with too many characters and adds the most important and relevant ones to the story, I could see Omega working but doubt they'll add him, which I'm okay with. Last time we had too many characters was Spiderman 3, and people didn't really like how that turned out. Regardless I'm super excited for the third installment and really can't wait for it to turn out, it may not be all I expect it to be (which is probably way too high for my own good tbh) but it'll still be super great and I don't doubt that.
Don't you think It's a bit early for speculation given how mutch we're still in the dark about every aspect of the movie(what characters will appear,who plays them,wich game stuff comes)!
I agree with this, would be fantastic to see the Maria scene in the movie, also would love to see Gerald Robotnik, and Super Shadow of course! Music from the games would be one of the best decisions they could make. Everything you said I would want to see 100%. Day 1 of asking for the Discord link to work
I want to see all best lines and quates and Easter eggs, soundtrack from sonic adventure 2 games and shadow and maria backstory and sonic v shadow. and if possible Amy or rouge the bat being teased later on. this is Shadows movie.
I think we only need Shadow, Rouge, Maria, and Gerald as new characters. Shadow because why not? Rouge to develop Shadow's character, Maria to establish Shadows motivation, and Gerald to provide overarching conflict.
Omega should not be in Sonic 3, Amy and Rouge should be because they’re important to the story of SA2, and Sonic having a crush on Amy in Sonic 3 I like
I personally think Sonic won't have a big crush on Amy, but she will. I think Sonic will really love a friendly relationship with her: just like with Tom, Maddie, Knuckles and (as I heard) Shadow.
Alright so, honestly I can’t see characters like Amy and Omega showing up in the movie. I don’t see how they could enter the story without a complicated explanation, and feel like they’d just take away screen time from other characters. Omega couldn’t be introduced the way you suggested unfortunately because if the government had the technology to make super powerful robots like Omega 50 years ago, why would they have even bothered hiring Robotnik to capture Sonic? He did have some impressive machines but nothing more impressive than an Omega. And if Robotnikis coming back and he makes a new robot, there’s no way they’d make him create Omega over Metal Sonic. The only other characters from the games I can see showing up are maybe Rouge, emphasis on the ‘maybe’ because I still don’t see how she could be introduced, and (maybe a bit of Hopium on my end but) Chaos since we still need a big bad for the movie and it absolutely must NOT be Shadow. Maybe the Bio Lizard would make more sense it’s linked with project shadow, but Chaos is more popular.
I also think that would be interesting and I'd like to see somewhere in the movie shadow tells sonic about how he lost his best friend and sonic actually empathize with him like he did with knuckles in the second movie like you can have sonic be like "you don't have to do this I know your going through a lot right now" and then shadow is just like "how?! I lost everything I cared about that day! How could you possibly know how that feels like?!" And then sonic can be like "because I lost someone special too!" And then there'd be a pause and then sonic can be like "your not alone shadow" and then there'd be another pause and then tails can come in and use one of his gadgets to trap shadow and then shadow would realize he got trapped and be like "YOU LIER!" like how knuckles was in the second movie I think that'd be really awesome to see
Amy is generally more iconic and a more used character overall but I think rouge would be the better character to include overall just because she would make it easier to give shadow screen time and give him someone to bond with a little. Amy was important to remind shadow of what Maria really wanted but like In sonic x I feel like another character could fill that roll. I personally think Tom would be a great person to tell shadow the good of humanity since he also gave sonic an inspiration speech in the second movie Although if they do have omega I believe that would give shadow someone to share screen time with so amy could be picked over rouge then. That’s of course assuming that they can’t all be in the movie at once. Last thing I think the idea you had of sonic having a crush on amy would be an interesting idea and definitely within his movie character.
I hate to say it but Rouge has 2 things going against her, first is her design and second is that she isn't the female lead. Not introducing Amy in this movie would be criminal considering we might not get any more movies after this one, and not everything has to be about Shadow in this movie, it's an adaptation, not a copy and paste of SA2's plot.
@@dragondelsur5156 yeah design is a problem but I feel like that is an easy fix especially since these characters are getting a little design change for the movies anyways. Amy is more of an important character to the sonic series but the specific story thats being adapted is sa2 which rouge was a more important character in. And the story doesn't have to be all about shadow im just saying it would be easy to give him more screen time and better character development if he had another character talking to him instead of him just monologuing in is head. Although now that u bring up this could be the last movie, that does make me think amy would be chosen over rouge. That is if they have to choose. Its possible they both get added but I think its also risky......unless...... Maybe rouge and Amy can have a dynamic of being rivals/ enemies to each other. This could knock out 2 back stories in a shorter time span and would make it feel like they dont need too much individual screen time. This would also give them a little extra motivation to help the opposing team. Its not too far fetched of an idea since they already have a mild rivalry in some sonic media
@@dragondelsur5156 there is her being strongly associated with GUN. some speculate having her appearing in the knuckles show would make her presence feel natural
These are some really cool ideas, however there are two things I would like to mention. I like the idea of having a full team dark, but I don't think Omega would make the cut. He's just not that interesting character, and wouldn't do much to accent the team. However, there is another character who you could introduce in the Knuckles show, and carry over into Sonic 3 who would have a lot more story potential. This being E-102 Gamma. As for the parting ways, I highly doubt they would do this but I want to bring it up. What if they recreated the ark raid near the end of the movie, but with Sonic and his human family, running from a gun toting Shadow. You could even use this as the spark that makes Shadow remember his promise. As for whether or not Sonic's family would die in this scene, that would be a cojn flip, but I think this would be a better explanation for Sonic leaving them, whether for their own safety or because their gone. That's all I have to say, and I look forward to the next video.
True But Omega Needs to be in The Post credits cause Sonic Movie 3 Would not be the last one even though Eggman or Stone would create Omega while he was abandoned in the room along with Shadow,Rouge was send by GUN to look for Eggman’s Treasure in the dark room but instead she found Shadow & Omega then she release them I’m sore that’s gonna happen in Sonic Movie 4 When Team Dark is formed.
I do hope they realize that if the mario movie has mario music so sonic as well and also go all out in movie 3 and have zero percent side plot like the mario movie did and also go more out with the Easter eggs and also go alot more harder on the marketing if they really want this film to succeed
I definitely see them making sonic the one having a little crush on Amy because in the movies he's much more child like, playful and just like you said he longs for relationships. Honestly I do hope they do this tho bc it would be kinda adorable to see what sonic does around Amy LOL!!
Not a lot of talks of whether or not Dr. Eggman will return for Sonic 3 in this video huh? Because I'm still concerned about that since Jim Carrey's retirement plan. Whether or not he might do it or find another actor to replace him. I still do not want Agent Stone to take Eggman's place. I still do not want Sonic 3 to still be a Jim Carrey-less sequel or anything like that.
gonna be honest with ya buddy...I don't think Amy will fit in Movie 3 because shadow will take all the attention, it's like in sonic movie 2 where we had tails and knuckles at the same time, I didn't feel for tails like I should have because knuckles took that feeling, when you look at it, sonic bond with tails should have been powerful and left an impact for tails but no, it went all to knuckles, not that I hated it, but thinking that the same thing can be pulled again is just stupid. also let us think about it amy +love sup plot in a movie about government cover-ups, darker tone, and a 12 years old girl with aids- im sorry ''NIDS'' gets shot, in the freaking space! it doesn't seems right. and rouge...oh god...she is a secret agent for humans, there is just no way the commander of G.U.N will be like ''Since you refused to join us we thought of recruiting one of your kind as ours'', I'm not buying any of that...look im not trying to be negative, or to low down any one's hype, I think that omega being in the room with shadow has potential, shadow using him to show off his power like in sa2 first boss is gonna be neat. I really don't think Amy, rouge, or any character should be in the story of movie 3, but at the end of the day I'm just a guy with a personal opinion, I'm sure that whatever they are gonna do they're gonna do it right and we will enjoy it just right (mostly to the point where we rewatch it 10 times in a month) that is all
Wow, I didn't even think about the possibility of Movie Sonic having a crush on Amy. This actually makes sense given the way you explained it. Even though I'm an anti-Sonamy girl, I think if this were to happen, I'd be okay with that. I always told myself that I would never like Sonamy unless Sonic loved Amy like she loves him. As long as Sonic's happy, I'm happy.
I think Rouge might be introduced in the mushroom planet since it kinda foreshadowed a character entering and the only other character who would look for the master Emerald would be Rouge
Sonic parting ways with Tom and Maddy is a good idea, considering that Sonic is constantly putting them in danger. And perhaps Tom and Maddy maybe having a baby themselves as well as Sonic becomes more mature to the point that he decides to go his own way..
Honestly, I don't want to see the characters parting ways. Because that would mean that Sonic won't be staying in green hills anymore. I don't think I can get used to not having Sonic around on earth anymore. 😟🥺 Besides, wouldn't it be more interesting to have all the sonic characters move to green hills on earth instead?
I actually wrote a bit about what I also want in this movie Opening open 50 yrs ago shadow and Maria moment before a black transition to shadow being released, multiple time throughout the movie shadow spaces out and he has flashbacks/memories. A bonding scene between Tom and shadow. Shadow vs skt. Shadow on the ark scene/ where he remembers maria’s True wish (hopefully by Amy) brother bonding (or respect) between sonic and shadow. Maybe black doom appearance??/ shadow lives with humans or smt else. Possibly shadow hurting Tom but it reminds him so much of Maria he stops and helps him, even questioning what he’s doing. Really really hope amy appears! Even rouge and omega (This writing was a while ago so it may not be perfect English)
First off number one, take notes from "The Super Mario Bros Movie" in exploring more of Sonic's world while carefully balancing the pacing of the story out between the human world and his along with others. We've waited long enough for that. Two, if anyone is to be cast as Shadow it should be Robert Pattinson due his outstanding performance as the batman. Remember, Sonic's favorite superhero is batman in this trilogy so him meeting a hedgehog who looks like him with that borderline homicidal PTSD personality from the latest iteration of Pattinson's role as that vigilante...OH MY LAWD! 😂 People would be loosing it in the theaters let alone the trailers! And third, for the last trailer it should reminiscent SA2 LAST EPISODE, WISHES...ARE ETERNAL. And in a split second give everyone the jump scare with the Biolizard with the same pose when he first roared on screen before showing the release date etc. Now that would be a hook, line, and sinker for all of us if I do say so myself by letting the audience know that this film will have dire consequence situations, man! 😢
If I was the writer, this is what I would do. ACT 1. The opening scene would include Agent Stone listening to GUN talk about Shadow and overhear the location. He would travel and release him. Right after Shadow’s eyes turn to electricity, we would cut to a 15 minute flashback of Shadow’s backstory except Gerald’s death. We cut back to present day and He can’t remember anything except Maria’s death. The 2 would make a deal to get revenge. They would then find a Chaos Emeralds. We cut to Sonic in the woods pretending Longclaw was there. Tails and Knuckles will come and tell Sonic there is a bank heist going on in Manhattan. They would stop them and have them arrested then go home for dinner. After dinner, they would watch Speed and hear screaming in the streets. The trio would go outside to stop what’s happening. Tails and Knuckles would have an electric wire wrap round them and knock them unconscious and Stone would have done it. Shadow and Sonic would battle. Shadow and Stone would escape and GUN would arrest Sonic, accusing him of terrorism. The film would cut to Stone And Shadow making a plan to find Chaos Emeralds until Someone breaks in to steal items. Stone tases the thief and Shadow unmasks her and turns out it is Rouge the Bat whom would have been in the Knuckles show and in that show she would have been secretly working for GUN. Rouge would want revenge for GUN killing her friend Topaz. They would team up. Meanwhile, they would recreate the SA2 opening but Sonic would get caught. Just for fan service. Comment for ACT 2👍👍
You know, I've been thinking about the begining of Sonic 3 And I think it should start with Shadow's fake memory that Gerald implanted into him and right when Maria gets shot, we return to the post credits of Sonic 2 where he opens his eyes but this time he mutters, "Maria". After that, his eyes glow and we zoom into his eyes with the intro of Sonic the Hedgehog 3
I know I’m asking for too much, but the characters I want to see in the next Sonic movie are, Amy, Rouge, Vector, Esbio, Charmy, Mighty, Ray, Big, Rough, Tumble, Orbot, Cubot, Knack and the Es.
Man I so excited to see what direction they will take to introduce Shadow's and Maria's past including Gerald, they were the highlights that differentiate SA2 from other Sonic games. Im afraid they might not include any of it tho as GUN is like, a generic stereotype of US military, and painting that image of them shooting a sick and defenseless child might get Paramount in some trouble lol (idk how it works as Im not from the US but if it were with my country I would be sure they would get a lot of backlash from people that are connected to military to some degree) Also, if you don't mind, how did you get the art in the thumbnail? It looks cool!
Im scared for Movie 3. Way too much expectations and pressure. The more the number of installments go up the more that's expected of it and less forgiving people will be on what hasn't come yet. For example- Two movies in and third movie is confirmed to be based on SA2, yet Amy, Metal, Chaos, Big, Death Egg, etc hasn't come yet. We can't have all of this in Movie 3 alongside Shadow and Biolizard. The thing is even if you could, you'll end up having to split the focus on plots and characters. Movie 2 introduced only TWO friends of Sonic and Tails clearly got the short end of the stick (wasn't that bad but enough to notice the difference between him and Knuckles. Though tbf Sonic has more of an arc in the movies in comparison, so three significant developers would have been a lot). Then you got human characters to focus on too who aren't even G.U.N. It's insane. And yall wanna have Gerald, Maria, etc in here too. Like.... As you said, we seriously gotta sacrifice things here for the greater good. Amy and Shadow will be like the Knuckles and Tails of Sonic 3, but with a more strenuous villain on a completely different level than Death Egg Robot. And on the subject of that villain, it obviously should be Biolizard. I find it just as weird as anyone else to have it before Chaos (a much bigger deal than Sonic meeting Knuckles first than Tails), but it just doesn't make sense for Chaos to serve as their central enemy, including not taking two supers to defeat it. It'd be equally weird to introduce it in like Movie 4 obviously too. I don't know man; that's a hard call. Metal Sonic I feel could share a movie with one of the top villains, but I feel it should be Movie 4, unless they give Shadow the spotlight for Biolizard finale to balance out say Sonic dealing with Metal Sonic earlier in the movie-Sonic takes care of Metal; Shadow takes leadership on Biolizard. Anyways. I don't know what the appeal with Big is, but he can be left out, really. This meme culture and stuff... just leave him. Get Amy, Shadow, and Rouge (because Rouge always gotta be with Shadow, just like the other continuities). That's a handful already, and that's without the main villain. But at least you have all the core SA2 animal characters there. Chaotix were seen in the S2 prequil novel, but perhaps you can introduce them and keep them on another planet, like say Knuckles uses his rings to go to another planet for business and talks with them *there* only. With them due to reappear but on Earth in later movies. I don't care what Big did in SA and Heroes, he isn't needed here. Save the resources. Luckily for them, Maria can be an actual human actress. Gonna make a separate comment for a whole other side of thoughts.
I kinda want this whole film to take place through Amy’s perspective. Everyone who’s a Sonic fan likely knows the story of Shadow so he’s not exactly hard to screw up, but there’s a message I want to be delivered through Amy that I want to send. This version of Amy would be portrayed by Linda Cardellini, and look comparatively “ugly” and “unattractive” compared to her game counterpart: weird smell, dirty quills, these huge buck teeth, everything, along with a poor self image. Constantly being judged the humans, and having to live in fear. That coupled with an internal conflict between her ID and superego(Lisa Ortiz and Cindy Robinson respectively), it’s an arc of self control. Yeah, the stupid line about marriage gets out and Sonic is brutally injured by Amy at first, which sends everyone into a panic, labeling her a stalker and fangirl, even Sonic is scared, but Maddie says something that I want to be the recurring message: “When something or someone hurts you, you have two options, you can either choose to fear it, and make fun of it, or you can choose to help it, understand it, get to know it better”. And urges Sonic to find Amy, thinking that the incident may have been more accidental than the media and general public are led to believe. So he meets her and everything that Maddie said about Amy was apparently true, and that she is this poor, dirty ragged misunderstood talking hedgehog much like how he was years ago. And the two relate to each other about having these types of outbursts and that Amy’s not in trouble. The two hit it off surprisingly well. Sonic even discovers that Amy has an amazing singing voice, too. And as the movie goes on, we get more of Amy’s more redeeming qualities: her inspiring and encouraging others, her showing compassion for the most ugliest of creatures, her sacrificial qualities, and her singing too. Amy actually composed “Escape from the City” out of her love for Sonic, which Sonic thoroughly enjoys. The story happens similarly to the game. I made Amy ugly to provide a visual contrast for her more redeeming qualities, and give Sonic reasons to fancy her beyond just being “pretty girl”. Plus I like the ugly duckling trope; the handsome hero actually falling for this Lena hyena looking girl would be touching.
WTF did I just read??. Hell no, I would hate that Amy, and even more if she beat up Sonic. And why the heck Amy should be ugly in the movie like the original design of Sonic Movie??.
The writers have already stated that this 3rd Movie will be adapted using Sonic Adventure 2 as well as the video game Shadow The Hedgehog. Can't see anything you said here happing sorry.
A couple of things I think should happen 1 I think this movie should be spilt into 2 parts part 1 can end with a epic super sonic vs super shadow where shadow wins and the villans win summoning some sort of monster and part 2 where we get shadows redemption and everything and I definitely agree on the humans bit feel like the 3rd movie would be perfect for a good sendoff and I also really like the idea of sonic crushin on amy lol
I think Tom will be a great person to change Shadow about humanity I don't mind if it's Amy too but Tom was a police officer & he also wants to protect people like how Maria wants for Shadow to do
I honestly kind of hope that instead of Omega being in the 3rd Sonic Movie, it's Metal Sonic. If we have Metal and Amy, we're not only finishing the classic cast, but we could also have him be part of the SA2 version Team Dark with Shadow and Rouge, just instead of Eggman, it's his creation. Also, it'd be pretty cool to see just an all out brawl between Team Hero and Team Dark with Sonic fighting Shadow, Tails fighting Metal, and Knuckles... I guess talking to Rouge. I don't think Knuckles would be really comfortable beating up Rouge, and he might push her a round a little, it's just they won't have an epic fight like him and Sonic did in the second movie. With Metal being introduced here, it would also lead up nicely into a Sonic Movie 4 with the events of Sonic Heroes. And then Omega could be introduced there. I'm a big fan of Metal, and I'm really hoping that we get to see him in the third Sonic Movie. Heck, he could maybe even be the big bad as he turns into his Metal Overlord form and tries to crash the Ark into the Earth, causing Shadow and Sonic to have to team up and beat Metal while also trying to stop the Ark from crashing. And then Sonic Movie 4 can go right on ahead to Sonic '06. But that's just a thought I had.
Looking at the comments, I secretly hope for a combo of SA1 and SA2's plot in the third movie (but not verbatim). I think it'd be neat but unlikely to happen.
I wouldn't mind if Sonic stayed on earth, after all how many Sonic games take place on earth, and I really like Tom and Sonic's dad-and-son relationship and also the other human characters. Besides what's wrong with Sonic staying on earth for most of the future movies and possibly more shows? I see nothing wrong with it.
Its gotten to the point to where it's almost weird if movie sonic isn't with humans. Idk that could be just me. It would be weird if movie sonic had a movie with no humans and just all the game characters. It would feel like a different story to me
I hope that Escape from the city with Live & learn are in the third Sonic movie. As for characters however, I feel like they should only do Shadow and Rouge, I say that because, I don't want too many characters introduced in one movie, all at once, I think for the next movie (after 3) should be based on Sonic cd and maybe Sonic hero's or the first Sonic adventure.
I hope Amy Rose, Big The Cat and Rouge are willing to be voiced by Anna Kendrick, James Corden and Scarlett Johansson in Sonic Movie 3. I also hope that Maria Robotnik is willing to be played by AnnaSophia Robb in Sonic Movie 3. My 2 predictions about Amy Rose's personality and the secretly romantic relationship between her and Sonic: 1. I want Amy Rose to be an energetic and optimistic tomboy: Despite this, I want her personality to be level-headed and mature similar to the Sonic Boom version of her. 2. I want Amy Rose and Sonic's secretly romantic relationship between each other to be similar to 2 heroic anime characters from My Hero Academia: Izuku Midoriya and Ochaco Uraraka. (While Amy Rose and Sonic are in their secretly romantic relationship, They have to keep their secretly romantic relationship a secret as I think Amy Rose and Sonic have to act like friends and epic battle-ready hand-to-hand combat partners to each other whenever Tails, Knuckles, Tom, Dr. Maddie, Ozzie, Wade, possibly Crazy Carl, Rachel, Jojo, Randall, Commander Walters, G.U.N., Dr. Eggman, Agent Stone and some other people are around.
That’d be a great idea but I have to disagree with the tomboy thing since That contradicts Amy’s character shes very much a tough girly girl and i always liked that about her just making her a tom boy kinda gives the message that feminine girls cant be strong they have to be boyish which isn’t her character at all.
Isn't that literally making Amy generic? Especially when you include Boom Amy into the mix? She is a girly girl but half tomboy too, she has no extremes on what she is. And fucking hell will it frustrate me if she acts like a fun killer. I can see your point but... thing is, unless Amy and Sonic act differently in public (with Amy showing her love for Sonic and him pretending not to care, only showing their true feelings in private), why keep their relationship a secret? I think Sonicsta said it best when he said Movie Sonic and mainline Sonic are completely different, Mo!Sonic already craved for family, friends and such after he lost the only parental figure he had, Ma!Sonic won his friends because of who he is, Tails and Amy's persistance on keeping up with the blue blur made them win him over. Point is, Mo!Sonic might be more open with Amy but I think everything will rely on how Amy is adapted (initial crush or not, better not be similar to the disgusting false role model from Boom).
Okay, that part when you said Sonic needs to leave Green Hills to be in his own world sorta confused me.. Didn't you said you wanted him to be different from the games? How's making him back to his own world any different from his games counterpart?
I agree with you on both Sonics being different which is true completely and Sonic is going to a crush 😻 on Amy Rose 🌹 in the movies 🎥 but I disagree with the parting ways I don’t think will happen cause Green hills is his home 🏠
My vision for this film is that Team Sonic goes against Shadow and Agent Stone, and Stone is out of the picture somehow while Shadow works together with them in the end to fulfill Maria's true wish, remembering a false one this whole time. They'd have to stop Metal Sonic, one of Gerald Robotnik's creations, to make his grandson's life-long dream of world domination come true, stealing chaos energy from other animals (including Amy, who they save). Shadow would walk off to do his own thing, later coming across Team Dark (Rouge and Omega), sent by GUN, as Team Sonic forms an alliance with an extraterrestrial group fighting for peace across the galaxy (the Freedom Fighters.
As long as sonic doesn't do the griddy on Maria's grave, the movie will be great
Wha-
I think this would make it better tbh
bro but imagine
@@SONICSTA Shadow would literally kill him
Dude, what?! XD
I think Rouge would show up in the Knuckles first so that it won't feel like fan service to her in the movie when there's no build up to her. That's just my thought
I believe this too. I also believe the Knuckles show will actually be quite serious as a way to prepare the audience for the shift in tone from the first two live-action Sonic movies to the third live-action Sonic movie, as the first two live-action Sonic movies were relatively light-hearted while the third live-action Sonic movie will be an extremely dark movie (with only a few light-hearted moments here and there).
@@Rishi123456789 and hopefully they go too far in mature tones like...Shadow's Solo Game!
Yeah ummmmmm..
Maria Robotnik *has* to die in Sonic Movie 3 indeed. (And Gerald too) Her death plays a big part of Shadow's character hence why he's the way he is in SA2. And Paramount has gotta listen to the fans again on this one and treat her devastating demise AND Shadow's PTSD with respect. There are many kids movies out there (take Spider-Verse, Puss in Boots 2 for example) that were comedic and light-hearted but knew when to take themselves seriously.
I completely agree with you, except I think that Angourie Rice should be cast as Maria. Actually, to be honest, I don't really care who is cast as Maria as long as she is a cute white girl (like in SA2). And yes, like you I also want Maria's death and Shadow's PTSD to be treated with respect.
I think this is something that I could see happening here. Shadow having bits of his story being revealed little by little before unveiling the whole story gives us context to what happened to him during those times before being sealed off.
I believe that Tom and Maddie will still being integral part of his story and I think they’re both still going to be around even if they’re not going to be there once he’s confident in who is he is and his friends.
In my headcanon for the movie, Black Doom offers Gerald a way to cure Maria through a sample of his blood or DNA or whatever which will make Maria immortal (unless she gets killed), but in return, Gerald has to help Black Doom and the rest of his species eat half of the human population. Gerald reluctantly agrees and Maria is made immortal (like Black Doom promised), but then Black Doom uses a GUN soldier as a pawn to kill Maria. This GUN soldier is Tom's father, because if I remember correctly, someone said in Sonic 1 (or maybe Sonic 2, I can't remember) that there has been a Wachowski protecting the town of Green Hills for 50 years and for that to have been said was NOT a coincidence. There are NO coincidences in movies, EVERYTHING you see in any movie is ONLY THERE because it is MEANT to be there. So anyway, Shadow kills Tom's father as revenge for Maria's death and now he's hunting the rest of the Wachowski family and this eventually brings Shadow to Sonic, as Sonic became a member of the Wachowski family at the end of the first live-action Sonic movie.
Actually speaking on that, if you go back to the 1st movie oddly specific that this line was in it ""I mean, there's been a Wachowski protecting this town for more than 50 years."" the same amount as Project Shadow... Sonic X revealed the soldier who ended up killing Maria and the effect it had on them so what if it's supposed to be a red herring of perhaps Tom's father being the very guy that shot Maria in the the Sonic cinematic universe?
Interesting
If they killed Longclaw, they'll kill Maria. Also, I'd actually want the Live and Learn scene to go for hyper. I have a feeling that super would kinda lose it's affect after a possible battle between Shadow and Sonic. Not to mention, I think it'd be cool if it wasn't just Sonic and Shadow.
"If they killed Longclaw, they'll kill Maria."
You're right. And in the concept art for Sonic 3, Gerald is shown as a skeleton. Maria will definitely be killed in the movie.
it would be interesting if the Soap Shoe were created by G.U.N a prototype meant for Shadow but they didn't get approved and Sonic randomly steals them, because they look cool. 😎
@@God-T yes
@@twoczents thx, also not saying this could or needs to happen, but as a Idea, this could be a interesting way to introduce the Thorndyke family as they could've been the creators of the Sneakers as a proxy for the government. so if sonic ever breaks his shoes he can always find upgrades hehe. 😁
Amy and Shadow are the most essential; the important to appear. The movie's story will be influenced by both elements of Sonic Adventure 1 + 2. While characters like Rouge, Big the Cat, Cream, etc. could be saved for later for other sequels or spin-offs if Paramount and Sega is willing to do so? Or those characters could appear suddenly in the movie but in a post-credits scene?
Who knows? But what if Rouge appears to be part of the movie's storyline along with Amy and Shadow? It does makes sense as she may be the one who will break Shadow free from his 50-year slumber in suspended animation in the underground lab while stealing some top-secret tech from there for you-know-who (Eggman, hopefully be played by Jim Carrey again) whom happens to be alive from the rumble of his Death Egg Robot....but injured.
We need rouge cause of boobies
Eggman being injured for an extended period would give them the perfect excuse to have him gain a bunch of weight for the 3rd movie.
I completely agree with these and are valid points except I think big the cat should make like a random cameo like as a joke or gag
Makes sense
I do like the idea of sonic & Amy having a confidential romantic relationship, but I would like to see sonic liking Amy, not being a simp, but just a man in love who is kind and compassion, integrity with sonics heart to follow his love ones he stands and acceptably believes in, Amy would accept sonic’s honesty, caring and passion, I would also like Amy to be independent, mature & a compact of being energetic & a weaponise character with a hammer which, sonic gives it to her or something like that, as for an actress for Amy rose, Margot Robbie, she is playing a pink character in a live action Barbie as Barbie, in my opinion, if rouge comes in I’ll go for Michelle peyther, her definition fits for rouges, Make rouge for what she was from SA2 of her’s obsession of the master emerald and jewels 💎, think like she’s catwoman, she is a rival to knuckles, as an treasure hunter, but has a crush on knuckles, The final one is shadow being redeemed, where he is gonna win back to save the destruction of the earth from the biolizard as a prototype to him, he can slightly bad, but still care for others, but being compensate by someone that annihilation is not the right way, making people to be saved with a smile
This is long so, those were how I would love to see in the 3rd instalment piece 👌.
Edit: the story will be set a few months after sonic 2 during the Christmas season, sonic and knuckles do Spar at the mountains, they fight for 5 minutes, sonic and knuckles enter at the garage which is tails lab, he gives sonic an emerald radar to search for the missing chaos emeralds, they found a purple emerald in a cave, they take it back home, tails said that it will take him a while to process and analysis the emerald, but meanwhile, robotnik and stone go to an private facility under water, project shadow by the time they wake the creature up from his unconsciousness, shadow was away in rage and filled with vengeance, robotnik makes a deal with him to get revenge on sonic and his family and friends, when G.U.N created a female bat from sonics DNA, her goal is searching for the master emerald ETC.
Him: Sonic X Is one of the most PG Sonic content
Sonic X Japanese: AM I A JOKE TO YOU!?!?!?!?!?
Just FYI Sonic X isn't even canon.
@@BurningFlamesofDivineDragon I know, But Sonic X Japan is not PG by USA's Standards, it has cursing in it and questionable dialogue that isn't suitable for other Audiences
I don't see everything in this video happening in the movie, but some of it sounds like it definitely could happen. Rouge and Amy are likely candidates, but I'm not really sure about Omega. It'd make sense for him to be there, but I don't know if he will be there. I don't know how to incorporate Rouge into the movie without going overboard with her... you know what. If Sonic X can find a way around it, then I think the movies could as well. All I'm hoping for is a good movie, to be honest. I'm not one to make all these crazy expectations that I know won't be fulfilled. I have confidence in Paramount because they've been doing well with Sonic, Tails, Knuckles, and Robotnik, and they have been able to make two very enjoyable Sonic movies. I still have no idea who's voicing Shadow...
There’s an easy solution to the Rouge problem, just change the design like in Prime.
Agreed.
Or they can just straight-up Rip her design from prime and just slightly edit it to fit in with the movie
2011's King Fu Panda 2 opens up with a genocide of Pandas, and has a psychopath villain obsessed with murdering the main character....Why do people suddenly think that showing a character die in a flashback is too much for PG?
It’s a little girl and she dies being shot by a gun ,that’s just too much to be onscreen
@@2ndspringtube708 Not if you film it the right way
@@2ndspringtube708 Didn't SA2 show only a G.U.N soldier holding a... gun and that's how they showed she died? Like, it's not hard to show murder without showing murder.
I swear people act like kids are oblivious to the concept of death as if they never experienced the loss of a pet or a grandparent or something. I think most kids know the pain of death of a loved one so this shouldn’t be much of a problem.
@@jaydenlenzy3487 first of all a pet is different from an actual human being well known ,second of all they die naturally and they don’t really see them when they die and finally we are talking about a little girl getting shot onscreen do you think the kids of the families would like to see that onscreen ?being shot isn’t like dying naturally you know ?
I have a bit of theory of how amy could be introduce into the movie.
Amy is a big fan of tarot cards , cards that can predict a person future ,and one of amy's cards tells her that she will go on a huge grand adventure on the planet earth and while there she will have a destined encounter with someone who is blue and by using a portal ring amy embarked on that journey and through crazy shenanigans amy winds up being apart of the main plot . when it comes to her relationship with sonic i think it would be like it's obvious that they both like each other and they just act really around each other, which in return can lead to a few cute moments between them , and depending how long the movie franchise continues i can see their relationship grow and develop throughout other movies .
But hey .that's just a theory, a sonic theory
that's actually how her first appearance in sonic CD was, she drew tarot cards and ended up on little planet with sonic. I could see her have a mostly faithful appearance like tails
Sonic having a crush on Amy would be a VERY welcome and refreshing twist to their well-known dynamic! And if they aren't gonna make Amy insane, I'd be down for Movie Sonamy!
Same
"Sonic having a crush on Amy would be a VERY welcome and refreshing twist to their well-known dynamic!"
I disagree, I'd prefer Amy to not have a crush on Sonic at the start of the movie but to develop a crush on him by the end of the movie (but even then, only a mild crush). I'd prefer that twist. Something about Sonic being romantic just doesn't sit right with me. lol
@@Rishi123456789 But this is a completely different version of Sonic... He's a bit younger in the movies than in the games. I'll be very shocked if he isn't the one who falls for Amy.
And how is that a twist? That's been done to death in other movies. Granted, it is different for these two characters specifically, but it doesn't feel refreshing in my opinion. It's still the same dynamic as before. That said, no one knows what Paramount will do.
@@RosheenQuynh: "I'll be very shocked if he isn't the one who falls for Amy."
I won't. And we don't even know yet whether Amy will appear in the movie or not (she probably will though). Also, not everything about the movie versions of the characters is different from the game versions of the characters. For example, Movie Tails is still a genius and Movie Knuckles is still gullible.
@@Rishi123456789 I wasn't speaking about the third movie specifically, I just meant whenever she shows up. And I didn't say everything was different about their movie versions, but if they want to make Amy likable, she can't be a persistent and annoying fangirl...
Maria's death would not be a problem.
PG movies can show characters die.
Plus SA2 and Shadow showed Maria die, even if it wasn't shown explicitly we still were able to tell she died. And those games were rated E and E10+
You know Maria doesn't Need To Die She Could Just Get Critically injured or and shot And she would be forced to Inject herself With Black Dooms Blood she would then become the ultimate lifeform like shadow
@@pickedtundra0480 What.
@@ChaoticCooper and or shot was what I meant to say
Did you forget that Sonic X is an anime and anime has different standards in Japan for America at that time
Sonic X isn't even canon I do wish folks would stop using non-canon content as examples. I can't see Paramount using Sonic X references for the majorated of the third film. The writers have already said that Sonic 3 will be using the games Sonic Adventure 2 as well as the video game Shadow the Hedgehog. I hope this helps.
Half the stuff you talked about I could see happening like Shadow's backstory him, seeing Maria die right before he gets sent to Earth and wanting revenge I also feel like Amy will appear and maybe she'll need Sonic's help or she heard stories about him and wanted to meet him.I'm just not sure she'll fall for him first or if he'll fall for her first or maybe they'll fall for each other over the course of the movie but now I'm thinking because THIS Sonic is open about having relationships with the people he meets and cares about maybe he'll fall for he first and wouldn't mind dating her who knows maybe he'll start to get interested in girls and he might look at Amy that way when he meets her.I honestly don't think we'll see Rouge,Omega,or Big and I don't think Sonic will leave Tom and Maddie they're his family and they care about each other also A LOT of fans will be VERY sad if that happened
Ok but imagine they bring rouge and Amy into the plot by rouge stealing something valuable of Amy’s and runs to earth for her next hit (whispers of chaos emeralds on earth) and then Amy chasing her the whole way over HAH. Could set up a plot instigation of things going missing, Amy only having half the answers when she runs into sonic, and rouge running into shadow on a gem nab. It would have comedic potential and add plausibility to rouge and Amy’s arrival before getting into the more serious stuff
Oh another thing if we get Amy she stays with sonic tails and knuckles
Absolutely loved this video, felt like the points were well made and awkwardly agree on the sonic and Amy subplot! Hope a lot of these happen then not
As a Sonally fan, it stung right in the heart to hear that Sonic will have a crush on Amy.
As a Sonally fan, it stung even more because you're RIGHT!!!! THIS VERSION WOULD FALL IN LOVE WITH AMY!!!!!! OH NO!!!!! NOOOOOO!!!!!!!!! lol
Thanos - "I'm sorry little one"
I'm a HUGE Sonally fan and honestly, I wouldn't mind the idea of it! It'd be refreshing. It's never been done before! Of course, I'd rather have Sonic and Sal's dynamic...
@@RosheenQuynh yeah lol. I've never thought about that kind of dynamic, but Sonista def got this characterization right for sure
@@raymontyoungblood4453 If they do that, I'm so curious how they'll play it out! Like, will Amy flirt back? Will she be playing hard to get but still tease him? Will she be disgusted of him? We have no idea!
I’d love to see Silver appear for a post credit scene. I know not a lot of people like Silver due to his reputation/representation in 06, but I still think he is a good and memorable character. IDW did a great job portraying him and I think with good writing and voice acting he can be a good character to introduce to the movies
That would be very interesting. I wonder how they would handle it
I really agree that this movie shouldn't be a complete copy of SA2, it takes away it's uniqueness if it's just a retelling of something we've seen a thousand times. And with Sega being on a roll with Amy content lately, I think she is an obligatory introduction at this point, you can even have her already on Earth but in another country, say Japan, to justify her mannerisms.
now THAT would be interesting. all the sonic characters so far keep landing in America so for Amy to land in Japan would be a really good twist. but then would she speak with an accent? It would work. Or would she just be passing by as she looks for sonic and doesnt really get to learn the language, but stays there long enough that she picks up some of the culture? either way I hope something like that happens cuz there's sooo much potential
"you can even have her already on Earth but in another country, say Japan, to justify her mannerisms."
But Amy's mannerisms are very Western, it's Cream who has Japanese mannerisms.
@@Rishi123456789 If you take her tomboy tendencies yes but Amy is a girly girl first and foremost, contrary to the west's more "girlboss" approach. Her idle animations are always delicate, her run especially, she is very friendly to open conversation with anyone, she particularely has a fascination with cooking, baking, shopping, she has an affinity for fate and fortune, that's what I'm getting at. Like, Sonic had his superhero idea from the comics he read, Amy might have the same approach but with manga instead, romance manga could be her thing (you know why).
Amy already has eastern motifs from her creation, I say go all the way instead of straight up going Boom Amy just because the fake fans don't like her character.
I’m tired of people keep saying Boom Amy is best Amy, when she wasn’t. That would be Adventure-Unleashed Amy instead. And making her grow up in Japan honestly could help explain her mannerisms too. Or at least with a Japanese family. Maybe Rouge can pop up in England or London for the Knuckles series. And if Amy gets her ideas of love from Japanese romance manga and models herself off Japanese magical girls when using her own powers like Sonic did with superhero comics, that would be very fitting indeed. Amy’s love of the occult and her hammer (she can make so many of them) help callback to various magical girl tropes in Japan too.
I think one major change I want is when Eggman blows up the moon.
How about instead, Eggman blows up the town of Green Hills. (Nobody has to die, maybe Sonic and the team get everybody evacuated just in time.) It would not only be emotional and heartbreaking, but also maybe give a chance to see Sonic get majorly pissed. Make the stakes higher and also make the adventure much more personal.
But it doesn't have to be permanent. Maybe they can use the chaos emeralds to repair the town at the end of the movie.
Wouldn't that require to nerf the cannon? You've seen how that thing blew up half of the moon, a shot to Earth could literally erase half the planet.
Firing the cannon at the moon was the ultimate power move, blowing up nowhereville isn't a power move.
@@dragondelsur5156 @andrewgreeb916 Actually, I just thought of it. Maybe not just destroying Green Hills, maybe all of the other places that Sonic went to on their trip.
So Siberia, Hawaii, San Fransisco, Egypt, etc. All the places that Sonic went to in the first and second movie where Eggman knows.
So the cannon doesn't need to fire one single shot, it could fire several shots that level all of those places and more around it to show the power. And that it wasn't even at full power.
I don’t know. It’s still possible that they could use Tom more prominently and push the father-son aspect even further. And even though we might see Amy and Rouge it’s still possible that the people behind the film could go another route and Tom might be the feasible key. I believe that Sonic 3 will be hitting much harder on the relationship between Tom and Sonic and that one of it’s strongest themes will be loss. In my mind there’s a fifty-fifty shot of the studio deciding to make the alternative choice and have Tom be put in Amy and Rouge’s shoes. I’m not saying that it’s the sure route that they will take, but it’s possible and the reason that I think this is because of Sonic X. To me Tom is somewhat like Chris, but is far more mature and more realistic. Partly what makes the character of Tom more easily relatable is that he has a more common career and position in life and that he’s shown to have more other flawed relationships with the ones that he loves. Whereas Chris was in a position where most people would dream of it, but rarely ever experience it. And as far as his relationships went with family and friends who he held close, they were shown to be more upbeat with few negatives. Also what helps Tom more is his maturity and knowledge and experience of how to handle others better. Whereas with Chris even though he was good hearted, was still a preteen and knew far less about such topics. Lastly it’s also important to note that Chris was the one who got the heavily important scenes in place of Amy and Rouge in Sonic X whereas Tom often fills that role in the films.
However, I could still be wrong too. The studio could still decide to bring in Amy and Rouge as I’m not one hundred percent sure that they will take the route between Sonic and Tom. But even if they don’t include Tom as much, I do still think that Long Claw will be brought-up as like how Shadow lost his creator and Maria, Sonic lost Long Claw and that could be a possible talking point between the two.
Well I agree on you with most things but for certain things like Maddie and Tom leaving it kind of breaks my heart because I really like those characters and I would hate to see them go in fact we didn’t really even see them in the sonic two movie we normally just saw them in the beginning in fragments of the middle and then at the end so it wouldn’t make any sense to sit down with them but I get what you’re saying and honestly that would look like a great with you just keep Maddie and Tom in the mix and it would be great to see all of the sonic characters in the movie but I just think that if they have Maddie and Tom to come home to them parents would be great and we can see how they all react to having human parents!
Eggman making an entrance with E.G.G.M.A.N. I wanna see that.
The idea of Sonic and Amy's twist of Sonic possibly liking Amy instead makes me so happy and excited. I just think it would be so cute.
As far as who I think would be in it, I kinda agree on the fact that Amy would be more likely to appear than Rouge. I can see Rouge appearing in the Knuckles TV show instead. I'm not worried about how Shadow's character will be written. Because I know he will be written well.
The idea of ending the trilogy with Sonic going off on his own would be perfect. I'm just wondering, after that, would it be better to start a TV show or continue doing movies after that happens? I guess it would depend on how creative they can be with coming up with new stories. I'd find that pretty exciting!
Honestly, I'm glad the way they've been writing Sonic differently. And Ben really suits this Sonic. Ben always does an amazing job of voicing characters joyful, energetic characters who have had a rough past. I'm so used to the Sonic who likes to be by himself. I still have a little hard time accepting this Sonic. But Ben is one of my favorite actors (thanks to when I first heard that he was casted to voice Sonic. When I heard how fitting he was for Sonic, I watched a couple of shows that he was in.)
I know I've seen other people say that they want Black Doom in the movie. I could care less. In fact, I'd rather not see him. Perfect Chaos would be an awesome villain for the movie though.
It's gonna be another year until a trailer comes out. But it's gonna come really fast.
I just thought of something that probably won't happen.
If they somehow make a family friendly reference to Snapcube, I'm gonna die laughing.
I just hope the first scene is Sonic jumping from a chopper and sliding across the city on a sheet of metal he took
Along as shadow didn’t do the griddy when sonic fell the movie will be great
Sonic X is to these movies like how the 90s Marvel cartoons are to the Marvel movies. Adaptations, retellings, referencing. I'm not a huge gamer or comic book reader but I already know this from what people review on this stuff
Lean into the dark aspects of the lore and give an emotional core to it like Kung Fu Panda 2 and Puss in Boots 2 did, both had dark and mature elements to it (bordering on the lines of PG to the point where you question if it's really a family friendly film) as well as really emotional moments that almost make you cry. I don't want them to make me cry (they should atleast try), just as long as the emotions hit pretty hard and make you feel things. The last 2 movies were pretty lighthearted but since this is the third movie, they should go all out for it to be the biggest in the trilogy.
I also think adding Amy and Rouge is the most ideal because it doesn't overwhelm the audience with too many characters and adds the most important and relevant ones to the story, I could see Omega working but doubt they'll add him, which I'm okay with. Last time we had too many characters was Spiderman 3, and people didn't really like how that turned out.
Regardless I'm super excited for the third installment and really can't wait for it to turn out, it may not be all I expect it to be (which is probably way too high for my own good tbh) but it'll still be super great and I don't doubt that.
Honestly I wouldn’t be surprised if they added some snap cube references in the movie 😭
Don't you think It's a bit early for speculation given how mutch we're still in the dark about every aspect of the movie(what characters will appear,who plays them,wich game stuff comes)!
I agree with this, would be fantastic to see the Maria scene in the movie, also would love to see Gerald Robotnik, and Super Shadow of course! Music from the games would be one of the best decisions they could make. Everything you said I would want to see 100%.
Day 1 of asking for the Discord link to work
Mario?
@@lylelylecrocodile2538 I think he meant Maria. lol
@@Rishi123456789 yeah I know
@@lylelylecrocodile2538 LOL. Thank you for pointing this out, I somehow did not notice i mispelt "Maria" haha! I'll edit this but thank you!
I want to see all best lines and quates and Easter eggs, soundtrack from sonic adventure 2 games and shadow and maria backstory and sonic v shadow. and if possible Amy or rouge the bat being teased later on. this is Shadows movie.
This is the best Sonic movie 3 prediction video I have seen in a while. I agree with almost every point made.
I hope they have more Sonic music in the movie cuz if they don't that's going to be a letdown
7:48
I see what you did there.
I think we only need Shadow, Rouge, Maria, and Gerald as new characters. Shadow because why not? Rouge to develop Shadow's character, Maria to establish Shadows motivation, and Gerald to provide overarching conflict.
You forgot Rouge have appropriate clothing as well that is in the games like heros and riders
And Sonic Forces Speed Battle and I think Dash.
7:46 sonic wants to show knuckles da way!
Btw They better keep The Scene where Amy brings Shadow to His Right state of Mind in The Movie!
Omega should not be in Sonic 3, Amy and Rouge should be because they’re important to the story of SA2, and Sonic having a crush on Amy in Sonic 3 I like
I personally think Sonic won't have a big crush on Amy, but she will. I think Sonic will really love a friendly relationship with her: just like with Tom, Maddie, Knuckles and (as I heard) Shadow.
Alright so, honestly I can’t see characters like Amy and Omega showing up in the movie. I don’t see how they could enter the story without a complicated explanation, and feel like they’d just take away screen time from other characters. Omega couldn’t be introduced the way you suggested unfortunately because if the government had the technology to make super powerful robots like Omega 50 years ago, why would they have even bothered hiring Robotnik to capture Sonic? He did have some impressive machines but nothing more impressive than an Omega. And if Robotnikis coming back and he makes a new robot, there’s no way they’d make him create Omega over Metal Sonic. The only other characters from the games I can see showing up are maybe Rouge, emphasis on the ‘maybe’ because I still don’t see how she could be introduced, and (maybe a bit of Hopium on my end but) Chaos since we still need a big bad for the movie and it absolutely must NOT be Shadow. Maybe the Bio Lizard would make more sense it’s linked with project shadow, but Chaos is more popular.
I also think that would be interesting and I'd like to see somewhere in the movie shadow tells sonic about how he lost his best friend and sonic actually empathize with him like he did with knuckles in the second movie like you can have sonic be like "you don't have to do this I know your going through a lot right now" and then shadow is just like "how?! I lost everything I cared about that day! How could you possibly know how that feels like?!" And then sonic can be like "because I lost someone special too!" And then there'd be a pause and then sonic can be like "your not alone shadow" and then there'd be another pause and then tails can come in and use one of his gadgets to trap shadow and then shadow would realize he got trapped and be like "YOU LIER!" like how knuckles was in the second movie I think that'd be really awesome to see
Sonic X is actually how I found out about Adventure 1 and 2, To be fair I was little and I found out about Sonic between Heroes and the Rush series.
Amy is generally more iconic and a more used character overall but I think rouge would be the better character to include overall just because she would make it easier to give shadow screen time and give him someone to bond with a little.
Amy was important to remind shadow of what Maria really wanted but like In sonic x I feel like another character could fill that roll. I personally think Tom would be a great person to tell shadow the good of humanity since he also gave sonic an inspiration speech in the second movie
Although if they do have omega I believe that would give shadow someone to share screen time with so amy could be picked over rouge then.
That’s of course assuming that they can’t all be in the movie at once.
Last thing I think the idea you had of sonic having a crush on amy would be an interesting idea and definitely within his movie character.
I hate to say it but Rouge has 2 things going against her, first is her design and second is that she isn't the female lead. Not introducing Amy in this movie would be criminal considering we might not get any more movies after this one, and not everything has to be about Shadow in this movie, it's an adaptation, not a copy and paste of SA2's plot.
@@dragondelsur5156 yeah design is a problem but I feel like that is an easy fix especially since these characters are getting a little design change for the movies anyways.
Amy is more of an important character to the sonic series but the specific story thats being adapted is sa2 which rouge was a more important character in. And the story doesn't have to be all about shadow im just saying it would be easy to give him more screen time and better character development if he had another character talking to him instead of him just monologuing in is head.
Although now that u bring up this could be the last movie, that does make me think amy would be chosen over rouge. That is if they have to choose. Its possible they both get added but I think its also risky......unless......
Maybe rouge and Amy can have a dynamic of being rivals/ enemies to each other. This could knock out 2 back stories in a shorter time span and would make it feel like they dont need too much individual screen time. This would also give them a little extra motivation to help the opposing team. Its not too far fetched of an idea since they already have a mild rivalry in some sonic media
@@dragondelsur5156 there is her being strongly associated with GUN. some speculate having her appearing in the knuckles show would make her presence feel natural
These are some really cool ideas, however there are two things I would like to mention. I like the idea of having a full team dark, but I don't think Omega would make the cut. He's just not that interesting character, and wouldn't do much to accent the team. However, there is another character who you could introduce in the Knuckles show, and carry over into Sonic 3 who would have a lot more story potential. This being E-102 Gamma.
As for the parting ways, I highly doubt they would do this but I want to bring it up. What if they recreated the ark raid near the end of the movie, but with Sonic and his human family, running from a gun toting Shadow. You could even use this as the spark that makes Shadow remember his promise. As for whether or not Sonic's family would die in this scene, that would be a cojn flip, but I think this would be a better explanation for Sonic leaving them, whether for their own safety or because their gone.
That's all I have to say, and I look forward to the next video.
True But Omega Needs to be in The Post credits cause Sonic Movie 3 Would not be the last one even though Eggman or Stone would create Omega while he was abandoned in the room along with Shadow,Rouge was send by GUN to look for Eggman’s Treasure in the dark room but instead she found Shadow & Omega then she release them I’m sore that’s gonna happen in Sonic Movie 4 When Team Dark is formed.
I get the idea of gamma, showing that the E series has sentience and the ability to change, before you show omega who is rather robotic.
I do hope they realize that if the mario movie has mario music so sonic as well and also go all out in movie 3 and have zero percent side plot like the mario movie did and also go more out with the Easter eggs and also go alot more harder on the marketing if they really want this film to succeed
I definitely see them making sonic the one having a little crush on Amy because in the movies he's much more child like, playful and just like you said he longs for relationships. Honestly I do hope they do this tho bc it would be kinda adorable to see what sonic does around Amy LOL!!
Not a lot of talks of whether or not Dr. Eggman will return for Sonic 3 in this video huh? Because I'm still concerned about that since Jim Carrey's retirement plan. Whether or not he might do it or find another actor to replace him. I still do not want Agent Stone to take Eggman's place. I still do not want Sonic 3 to still be a Jim Carrey-less sequel or anything like that.
gonna be honest with ya buddy...I don't think Amy will fit in Movie 3 because shadow will take all the attention, it's like in sonic movie 2 where we had tails and knuckles at the same time, I didn't feel for tails like I should have because knuckles took that feeling, when you look at it, sonic bond with tails should have been powerful and left an impact for tails but no, it went all to knuckles, not that I hated it, but thinking that the same thing can be pulled again is just stupid. also let us think about it amy +love sup plot in a movie about government cover-ups, darker tone, and a 12 years old girl with aids- im sorry ''NIDS'' gets shot, in the freaking space! it doesn't seems right. and rouge...oh god...she is a secret agent for humans, there is just no way the commander of G.U.N will be like ''Since you refused to join us we thought of recruiting one of your kind as ours'', I'm not buying any of that...look im not trying to be negative, or to low down any one's hype, I think that omega being in the room with shadow has potential, shadow using him to show off his power like in sa2 first boss is gonna be neat. I really don't think Amy, rouge, or any character should be in the story of movie 3, but at the end of the day I'm just a guy with a personal opinion, I'm sure that whatever they are gonna do they're gonna do it right and we will enjoy it just right (mostly to the point where we rewatch it 10 times in a month) that is all
Wow, I didn't even think about the possibility of Movie Sonic having a crush on Amy. This actually makes sense given the way you explained it. Even though I'm an anti-Sonamy girl, I think if this were to happen, I'd be okay with that. I always told myself that I would never like Sonamy unless Sonic loved Amy like she loves him. As long as Sonic's happy, I'm happy.
i like that mindset
The thumbnail 💀
Hi XPool! I love your vids
*"I'D LOVE TO SEE MARIA DIE"*
Jesus dude💀
Yeah I'm going to agree with you on this one mate this guy is just f****** psycho
And you put Maria and Jesus in the same comment.
I really like that MCU-inspired intro!
I am mostly dying to see Amy Rose and Maria in 19 months!!!
I can’t believe I live in a world were Sonic Adventure 2 is remade as movie before being remade as a game for ps5
I’m genuinely gonna be surprised if Rogue makes it into Sonic Movie 3.
I think Rouge might be introduced in the mushroom planet since it kinda foreshadowed a character entering and the only other character who would look for the master Emerald would be Rouge
the sub of sonic x showed who did shoot maria but not the bullet damaging maria theres a major difference between what sonic x did
Sonic parting ways with Tom and Maddy is a good idea, considering that Sonic is constantly putting them in danger.
And perhaps Tom and Maddy maybe having a baby themselves as well as Sonic becomes more mature to the point that he decides to go his own way..
Honestly, I don't want to see the characters parting ways. Because that would mean that Sonic won't be staying in green hills anymore. I don't think I can get used to not having Sonic around on earth anymore. 😟🥺
Besides, wouldn't it be more interesting to have all the sonic characters move to green hills on earth instead?
I actually wrote a bit about what I also want in this movie
Opening open 50 yrs ago shadow and Maria moment before a black transition to shadow being released, multiple time throughout the movie shadow spaces out and he has flashbacks/memories.
A bonding scene between Tom and shadow.
Shadow vs skt. Shadow on the ark scene/ where he remembers maria’s True wish (hopefully by Amy) brother bonding (or respect) between sonic and shadow.
Maybe black doom appearance??/ shadow lives with humans or smt else.
Possibly shadow hurting Tom but it reminds him so much of Maria he stops and helps him, even questioning what he’s doing.
Really really hope amy appears!
Even rouge and omega
(This writing was a while ago so it may not be perfect English)
First off number one, take notes from "The Super Mario Bros Movie" in exploring more of Sonic's world while carefully balancing the pacing of the story out between the human world and his along with others. We've waited long enough for that. Two, if anyone is to be cast as Shadow it should be Robert Pattinson due his outstanding performance as the batman. Remember, Sonic's favorite superhero is batman in this trilogy so him meeting a hedgehog who looks like him with that borderline homicidal PTSD personality from the latest iteration of Pattinson's role as that vigilante...OH MY LAWD! 😂 People would be loosing it in the theaters let alone the trailers! And third, for the last trailer it should reminiscent SA2 LAST EPISODE, WISHES...ARE ETERNAL. And in a split second give everyone the jump scare with the Biolizard with the same pose when he first roared on screen before showing the release date etc. Now that would be a hook, line, and sinker for all of us if I do say so myself by letting the audience know that this film will have dire consequence situations, man! 😢
If I was the writer, this is what I would do. ACT 1. The opening scene would include Agent Stone listening to GUN talk about Shadow and overhear the location. He would travel and release him. Right after Shadow’s eyes turn to electricity, we would cut to a 15 minute flashback of Shadow’s backstory except Gerald’s death. We cut back to present day and He can’t remember anything except Maria’s death. The 2 would make a deal to get revenge. They would then find a Chaos Emeralds. We cut to Sonic in the woods pretending Longclaw was there. Tails and Knuckles will come and tell Sonic there is a bank heist going on in Manhattan. They would stop them and have them arrested then go home for dinner. After dinner, they would watch Speed and hear screaming in the streets. The trio would go outside to stop what’s happening. Tails and Knuckles would have an electric wire wrap round them and knock them unconscious and Stone would have done it. Shadow and Sonic would battle. Shadow and Stone would escape and GUN would arrest Sonic, accusing him of terrorism. The film would cut to Stone And Shadow making a plan to find Chaos Emeralds until Someone breaks in to steal items. Stone tases the thief and Shadow unmasks her and turns out it is Rouge the Bat whom would have been in the Knuckles show and in that show she would have been secretly working for GUN. Rouge would want revenge for GUN killing her friend Topaz. They would team up. Meanwhile, they would recreate the SA2 opening but Sonic would get caught. Just for fan service. Comment for ACT 2👍👍
If Sonic says goodbye to Tom, I will cry
I think rouge should be In the knuckles spinoff series, and in sonic movie 3's post credit scene, they should show omega!
They way he enthusiastically said I’d love to see Maria die 🤣
7:01 I was thinking about that too!
You know, I've been thinking about the begining of Sonic 3 And I think it should start with Shadow's fake memory that Gerald implanted into him and right when Maria gets shot, we return to the post credits of Sonic 2 where he opens his eyes but this time he mutters, "Maria". After that, his eyes glow and we zoom into his eyes with the intro of Sonic the Hedgehog 3
I know I’m asking for too much, but the characters I want to see in the next Sonic movie are, Amy, Rouge, Vector, Esbio, Charmy, Mighty, Ray, Big, Rough, Tumble, Orbot, Cubot, Knack and the Es.
Well I would like to see Silver the Hedgehog in the post credits scene in Sonic movie 3.
Man I so excited to see what direction they will take to introduce Shadow's and Maria's past including Gerald, they were the highlights that differentiate SA2 from other Sonic games. Im afraid they might not include any of it tho as GUN is like, a generic stereotype of US military, and painting that image of them shooting a sick and defenseless child might get Paramount in some trouble lol (idk how it works as Im not from the US but if it were with my country I would be sure they would get a lot of backlash from people that are connected to military to some degree)
Also, if you don't mind, how did you get the art in the thumbnail? It looks cool!
Im scared for Movie 3. Way too much expectations and pressure. The more the number of installments go up the more that's expected of it and less forgiving people will be on what hasn't come yet. For example- Two movies in and third movie is confirmed to be based on SA2, yet Amy, Metal, Chaos, Big, Death Egg, etc hasn't come yet. We can't have all of this in Movie 3 alongside Shadow and Biolizard. The thing is even if you could, you'll end up having to split the focus on plots and characters. Movie 2 introduced only TWO friends of Sonic and Tails clearly got the short end of the stick (wasn't that bad but enough to notice the difference between him and Knuckles. Though tbf Sonic has more of an arc in the movies in comparison, so three significant developers would have been a lot). Then you got human characters to focus on too who aren't even G.U.N. It's insane. And yall wanna have Gerald, Maria, etc in here too. Like....
As you said, we seriously gotta sacrifice things here for the greater good. Amy and Shadow will be like the Knuckles and Tails of Sonic 3, but with a more strenuous villain on a completely different level than Death Egg Robot. And on the subject of that villain, it obviously should be Biolizard. I find it just as weird as anyone else to have it before Chaos (a much bigger deal than Sonic meeting Knuckles first than Tails), but it just doesn't make sense for Chaos to serve as their central enemy, including not taking two supers to defeat it. It'd be equally weird to introduce it in like Movie 4 obviously too. I don't know man; that's a hard call. Metal Sonic I feel could share a movie with one of the top villains, but I feel it should be Movie 4, unless they give Shadow the spotlight for Biolizard finale to balance out say Sonic dealing with Metal Sonic earlier in the movie-Sonic takes care of Metal; Shadow takes leadership on Biolizard.
Anyways. I don't know what the appeal with Big is, but he can be left out, really. This meme culture and stuff... just leave him. Get Amy, Shadow, and Rouge (because Rouge always gotta be with Shadow, just like the other continuities). That's a handful already, and that's without the main villain. But at least you have all the core SA2 animal characters there. Chaotix were seen in the S2 prequil novel, but perhaps you can introduce them and keep them on another planet, like say Knuckles uses his rings to go to another planet for business and talks with them *there* only. With them due to reappear but on Earth in later movies. I don't care what Big did in SA and Heroes, he isn't needed here. Save the resources. Luckily for them, Maria can be an actual human actress.
Gonna make a separate comment for a whole other side of thoughts.
I kinda want this whole film to take place through Amy’s perspective. Everyone who’s a Sonic fan likely knows the story of Shadow so he’s not exactly hard to screw up, but there’s a message I want to be delivered through Amy that I want to send.
This version of Amy would be portrayed by Linda Cardellini, and look comparatively “ugly” and “unattractive” compared to her game counterpart: weird smell, dirty quills, these huge buck teeth, everything, along with a poor self image. Constantly being judged the humans, and having to live in fear. That coupled with an internal conflict between her ID and superego(Lisa Ortiz and Cindy Robinson respectively), it’s an arc of self control.
Yeah, the stupid line about marriage gets out and Sonic is brutally injured by Amy at first, which sends everyone into a panic, labeling her a stalker and fangirl, even Sonic is scared, but Maddie says something that I want to be the recurring message: “When something or someone hurts you, you have two options, you can either choose to fear it, and make fun of it, or you can choose to help it, understand it, get to know it better”. And urges Sonic to find Amy, thinking that the incident may have been more accidental than the media and general public are led to believe.
So he meets her and everything that Maddie said about Amy was apparently true, and that she is this poor, dirty ragged misunderstood talking hedgehog much like how he was years ago. And the two relate to each other about having these types of outbursts and that Amy’s not in trouble. The two hit it off surprisingly well. Sonic even discovers that Amy has an amazing singing voice, too.
And as the movie goes on, we get more of Amy’s more redeeming qualities: her inspiring and encouraging others, her showing compassion for the most ugliest of creatures, her sacrificial qualities, and her singing too. Amy actually composed “Escape from the City” out of her love for Sonic, which Sonic thoroughly enjoys.
The story happens similarly to the game. I made Amy ugly to provide a visual contrast for her more redeeming qualities, and give Sonic reasons to fancy her beyond just being “pretty girl”. Plus I like the ugly duckling trope; the handsome hero actually falling for this Lena hyena looking girl would be touching.
WTF did I just read??. Hell no, I would hate that Amy, and even more if she beat up Sonic.
And why the heck Amy should be ugly in the movie like the original design of Sonic Movie??.
That sucks.
The writers have already stated that this 3rd Movie will be adapted using Sonic Adventure 2 as well as the video game Shadow The Hedgehog. Can't see anything you said here happing sorry.
Totally agree with omega. I just want the world to see team dark.
A couple of things I think should happen 1 I think this movie should be spilt into 2 parts part 1 can end with a epic super sonic vs super shadow where shadow wins and the villans win summoning some sort of monster and part 2 where we get shadows redemption and everything and I definitely agree on the humans bit feel like the 3rd movie would be perfect for a good sendoff and I also really like the idea of sonic crushin on amy lol
Do you think that one of the human characters will be the one to change Shadows mind?
Also I will cry if Sonic and Tom say goodbye to each other
I felt betrayed enough when it wasn't Amy in sonic X, not sure how I'd take it in the movies
I think Tom will be a great person to change Shadow about humanity I don't mind if it's Amy too but Tom was a police officer & he also wants to protect people like how Maria wants for Shadow to do
I honestly kind of hope that instead of Omega being in the 3rd Sonic Movie, it's Metal Sonic. If we have Metal and Amy, we're not only finishing the classic cast, but we could also have him be part of the SA2 version Team Dark with Shadow and Rouge, just instead of Eggman, it's his creation. Also, it'd be pretty cool to see just an all out brawl between Team Hero and Team Dark with Sonic fighting Shadow, Tails fighting Metal, and Knuckles... I guess talking to Rouge. I don't think Knuckles would be really comfortable beating up Rouge, and he might push her a round a little, it's just they won't have an epic fight like him and Sonic did in the second movie. With Metal being introduced here, it would also lead up nicely into a Sonic Movie 4 with the events of Sonic Heroes. And then Omega could be introduced there. I'm a big fan of Metal, and I'm really hoping that we get to see him in the third Sonic Movie. Heck, he could maybe even be the big bad as he turns into his Metal Overlord form and tries to crash the Ark into the Earth, causing Shadow and Sonic to have to team up and beat Metal while also trying to stop the Ark from crashing. And then Sonic Movie 4 can go right on ahead to Sonic '06. But that's just a thought I had.
Looking at the comments, I secretly hope for a combo of SA1 and SA2's plot in the third movie (but not verbatim). I think it'd be neat but unlikely to happen.
I really want a scene where Sonic & Shadow are fighting each other while in super form.
I wouldn't mind if Sonic stayed on earth, after all how many Sonic games take place on earth, and I really like Tom and Sonic's dad-and-son relationship and also the other human characters. Besides what's wrong with Sonic staying on earth for most of the future movies and possibly more shows? I see nothing wrong with it.
I feel like shadow needs his own movie to properly flesh him out
If they made a shadow movie, it would most likely be based around shadow 05, and nobody wants that
Silver the hedghog post credit scene, Also I Would Love To See Sonic Simping For Amy Im This Film, A Very Fun Dynamic Switch.
Its gotten to the point to where it's almost weird if movie sonic isn't with humans. Idk that could be just me. It would be weird if movie sonic had a movie with no humans and just all the game characters. It would feel like a different story to me
I wanted the 3nd movie is full longer hours 😫
I hope that Escape from the city with Live & learn are in the third Sonic movie. As for characters however, I feel like they should only do Shadow and Rouge, I say that because, I don't want too many characters introduced in one movie, all at once, I think for the next movie (after 3) should be based on Sonic cd and maybe Sonic hero's or the first Sonic adventure.
They do Reference on Sonic Movie 3 with Sonic Adventures 2
I hate that people have forgoten that Shadow the hedgehog is also being adapted for this film.
Bro is speedrunning the Script
I want Amy to be in this movie so badly!! 😭
I’m telling ya, 1. PG-13, 2. Either 2 parts or a 3 hour epic
I hope Amy Rose, Big The Cat and Rouge are willing to be voiced by Anna Kendrick, James Corden and Scarlett Johansson in Sonic Movie 3. I also hope that Maria Robotnik is willing to be played by AnnaSophia Robb in Sonic Movie 3.
My 2 predictions about Amy Rose's personality and the secretly romantic relationship between her and Sonic:
1. I want Amy Rose to be an energetic and optimistic tomboy: Despite this, I want her personality to be level-headed and mature similar to the Sonic Boom version of her.
2. I want Amy Rose and Sonic's secretly romantic relationship between each other to be similar to 2 heroic anime characters from My Hero Academia: Izuku Midoriya and Ochaco Uraraka. (While Amy Rose and Sonic are in their secretly romantic relationship, They have to keep their secretly romantic relationship a secret as I think Amy Rose and Sonic have to act like friends and epic battle-ready hand-to-hand combat partners to each other whenever Tails, Knuckles, Tom, Dr. Maddie, Ozzie, Wade, possibly Crazy Carl, Rachel, Jojo, Randall, Commander Walters, G.U.N., Dr. Eggman, Agent Stone and some other people are around.
God no anyone but James Corden
That’d be a great idea but I have to disagree with the tomboy thing since That contradicts Amy’s character shes very much a tough girly girl and i always liked that about her just making her a tom boy kinda gives the message that feminine girls cant be strong they have to be boyish which isn’t her character at all.
I want Amy to be an extreme coward and a damsel in distress, far different from her usual portrayal.
Isn't that literally making Amy generic? Especially when you include Boom Amy into the mix? She is a girly girl but half tomboy too, she has no extremes on what she is. And fucking hell will it frustrate me if she acts like a fun killer.
I can see your point but... thing is, unless Amy and Sonic act differently in public (with Amy showing her love for Sonic and him pretending not to care, only showing their true feelings in private), why keep their relationship a secret? I think Sonicsta said it best when he said Movie Sonic and mainline Sonic are completely different, Mo!Sonic already craved for family, friends and such after he lost the only parental figure he had, Ma!Sonic won his friends because of who he is, Tails and Amy's persistance on keeping up with the blue blur made them win him over. Point is, Mo!Sonic might be more open with Amy but I think everything will rely on how Amy is adapted (initial crush or not, better not be similar to the disgusting false role model from Boom).
Okay, that part when you said Sonic needs to leave Green Hills to be in his own world sorta confused me..
Didn't you said you wanted him to be different from the games? How's making him back to his own world any different from his games counterpart?
I agree with you on both Sonics being different which is true completely and Sonic is going to a crush 😻 on Amy Rose 🌹 in the movies 🎥 but I disagree with the parting ways I don’t think will happen cause Green hills is his home 🏠
thanks for sharing your take!😄
Maria and Gerald are a part of Shadow’s Canon Event and it must happen no matter what. Without it he has no motivation for anything.
My vision for this film is that Team Sonic goes against Shadow and Agent Stone, and Stone is out of the picture somehow while Shadow works together with them in the end to fulfill Maria's true wish, remembering a false one this whole time.
They'd have to stop Metal Sonic, one of Gerald Robotnik's creations, to make his grandson's life-long dream of world domination come true, stealing chaos energy from other animals (including Amy, who they save).
Shadow would walk off to do his own thing, later coming across Team Dark (Rouge and Omega), sent by GUN, as Team Sonic forms an alliance with an extraterrestrial group fighting for peace across the galaxy (the Freedom Fighters.
we really need the piss on the moon again