Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Rotten-Rooming
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 апр 2022
- The plaintiff says she and the defendant lived together, but her ex-roomie still owes her for old utility bills she never paid, so she’s suing her. The defendant says the plaintiff told her she didn’t have to pay for oil in the house, and she insists she owes nothing.
Case #24-086
Ahh the good old "I will give you the money when my tax comes in" line.
Right? If you ever hear someone tell you they'll pay for something when taxes come in... walk the other way.
@@projectionv.accountability1010 If I've learned anything from People's Court and Judge Judy, that would be it!!!!
Yeah but she did
😁💯
Isn't there a saying Judge Mathis has about people promising to pay you from their taxes?
The plaintiff was mad she didn't get the defendants dog.. that's why she sued.
Plaintiff.....I thought it was Sarah Palin for a minute! Lol 🤭
Lol.
Not the good old “I’ll pay you when my taxes come in” if you hear that run.
That plaintiff lied about the verbal agreement to not pay for the oil. U can tell but the judge had no choice bc of the writing.
Idk because she paid exactly half two months in a row. That’s not exactly convincing either
I def think she Sued out of spite of not getting the Dog. I think the plaintiff did tell her not to worry, because why would she alter the 2nd month to month lease with that SAME change? It’s just weird.
Exactly. I think so too especially considering the 2nd lease took the oil completely out.
I feel that you guys are wrong. This is why, we must get things in writing. He say, she say! I bet, if that was you. You wouldn’t be complaining. In reality, it’s not about a dog. It’s the principle, you owe you owe simple. Have a great day!
The plantiff got a whole damn library with her.
The meme made me click💥💨FAST
😭😭
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I think she sued over the dog!
I think so too. Def wouldn't give Plaintiff HER Dog, and Plan got mad and wanted to teach her a lesson and how Dare she not give up her pet
You can't live in anywhere for free. I never understood how people think people have to pay for lifestyle. You have to work and pay your own bills it's nobody's responsibility but yours. The defendant has too many excuses
All you need is a lovable pet to hypnotize your landlord into forgiving your bills.
Yeah, she paraded out the bad health, dead employer, no money excuses. As JM says, those are YOU problems, not anyone else's.
one word🙄KAREN
I want to know what kind of luxurious home she’s living in. I rent a 2 bedroom apartment in San Diego just 1.5 miles from the beach for the same amount this woman is paying to rent a room. Yeah you have to pay your fair share but I’m thinking this woman was taken advantage of.
She always paid the rent, the plaintive said it. She never lived for free.
Being a CA resident all my life, never heard of oil as a utility. Wow, that stuff is expensive!!
If you live in the mountains...i think
Yeah on the East coast where I reside we have pretty cold winters and some houses have heating boilers that run off of a special oil that ranges between $400-$600.
@@Marcedes-oq8kw WOWEE, that's ALOT..guess we make up for it in CA for the cost of living, home or rent prices, gas prices..
In Oklahoma we heat with gas or wood. Never had an "oil" bill
I lived in Germany for 10 years, and we also had oil as a utility, with a gigantic tank in our basement. Kinda caught me off guard-too.
Idc how much I like the dog, if I allow someone to stay with a written lease, and they don't pay up, I'll give them 15 days to pay, then they're out.
Pretty sure it’s legally 30 days notice, however I completely agree.
@@jamilahzahirahhadidI agree
Know one is talking about how that dog was secretly paying for that oil on the side with its cuteness lol
So tired of people calling other people abusive when they don't treat their pet like a newborn baby
That's a bad dog mom.
You sound like the kind of person that doesn't pay any attention to their pet and then gets upset when you get called out for it. Animals aren't "things." They have emotional and psychological needs beyond their physical needs.
@@stonew1927 While I agree, what she described wasn’t abuse. Putting a dog in ‘time out’ by crating them isn’t abuse, it’s a way for them to be disciplined. Now if she were screaming/hitting/kicking a dog, then I’d classify that as abuse. You’re not training a dog at that point, you’re scarring them
@@stonew1927 Ibet your kids walk all over you. Letting them do whever they want can also be seen as "abuse" sine we're being petty.
@@Daydream355 You can bet all you want and you'd be wrong on so many counts. Best to keep quiet if you don't know what you're talking about.
It amazes me how a living situation can start out so well but end up unattainable in the end. This is why it's best to live alone.
So true!!
Most people have no ethics, and to be TOTALLY TRUTHFUL, ESPECIALLY WOMEN AND MEN RAISED BY SINGLE MOM'S...
This is "THE FALLOUT" we're seeing NOW in the MILLENNIALS and Baby Boomer, Gen X women!!!
**EXTREME SELFISHNESS (Narcissism), SEXISM against males, men & boys, all sorts of extreme drugs, alcohol, etc abuses, lots of mom's and even the father's and mom's killing & extreme abuses to their own newborns, toddler to college level children, to their parents, grandparents and bunches of ignorant/ numbskull, hooligans and hateful, unethical thoughts followed through with worse behaviors!!!
If I could I would reorganize most of the governments, especially in the West, Canada, USA, Europe and a bunch more and put honest, straight forward, ethical people like myself and whomever else is ready to go by the Constitution and treat people correctly and punish these devilish people and especially get all of these clowns out of offices!!!
No, it can work. You must vet your prospective roommate to ensure they're compatible with you and have steady employment in order to pay the rent. Some people just throw up an ad on Craigslist and accept any nutjob off the street because they're too lazy to do the research. Personally, I wouldn't let that defendant in my yard, much less share my apartment with her.
People get comfortable and think well I guess I do not have to pay no more.
I live alone and I love it.. been burned in the past🙄
I love the Plaintiff! - a dog (or any other being) - IS A MEMBER OF THE FAMILY!
Unconditionally!
Love it..so many episodes THANKYOU
Oil bills are variable and can devastate a renter.
Facts!
Oil???? Bill what the heck are they talking about
@@michellehard83 I was just as confused as you were. I had to do some research. But, apparently some people heat their homes with oil instead of gas. I never knew. I personally don't know anyone who does this but I guess it's becoming a more popular option.
@@phantasmalady9265 thank you because I've never heard anything about that before and was like what the heck they need oil for lol
@@staceymccarty672 me too 🤣
It's that typical entitled attitude, " I agreed to pay, but I don't have the money, so I won't pay". So many people don't take any personal responsibility.
Exactly. Well written.
BEST COMMENT 👏like we all have problems lady 🤦♂️STFU
I believe the plaintiff was overbearing and sending mixed signals. That said, the defendant is better off where she is now. She doesn't need the drama of that control freak.
Happy Thursday..watching from Australia.
The plaintiff obviously wanted the dog, and therefore the defendant, to stay. And I'm pretty sure she said, pay what you can
The defendant is full of it. It is quite normal to pay half of ALL the utilities when you are a roommate with one other person. I don't get the excuse that she did not have any money as if that clears you from paying with you owe.
She had a cute pet.
She was delightful, but couldn't afford the place.
Is it normal? People normally rent a room out of someone's place and their is a monthly lump sum, not half of all the bills, especially for a house.
In NH and many other states, no one can demand parts of bills that are based on usage such as heating bills without separate meters for each person. Internet and cable is something else, that's a flat fee monthly.
@@ellarose1974 it depends. My coworker/bff moved in with me and the deal was 350 a month and half of bills (water and electricity) and it worked out perfectly
I like your dog so you don't have to pay your way.....lol
Can afford to travel but not her bills smh
I LOVE when Judge Malian says “watch this”, and it goes exactly how she predicts it. It’s just so satisfying haha!
I hate when she does that. It’s like she is giving the person a heads up to lie.
@@traceyaz125 oh I never thought of it that way :o I figure if they’re lying at that moment then they’ve probably lied about other things too though
@@traceyaz125 yes and no because she does that about the point the plaintiff is suing for. If she is suing over non-payment of oil and the defendant says, she told me I didn't have to pay, it stands to reason she's going to disagree
@@SabrinaLWilliams I understand. But I have watched years of JM and unless the litigant is scrupulously honest it almost always triggers the other litigant to lie. You can see it in their faces. I just think it’s a hinky move on JM’s part.
@@traceyaz125 I see both sides but I think she does it when she already has the measure of the case and the other party has not provided a scrap of evidence to support their story so she does it to teach them a lesson but by that point she already knows how she's going to rule
Why is Sarah Palin suing people now...
COME ON THE DEFENDANT KNOWS THAT SHE OWED THAT DAMN $$$ SHE'S TOO OLD NOT TO KNOW BETTER SHE'S NOT A DAMN CHILD PAY ALL OF YOUR OWN BILLS LIAR .....GLAD THAT THE PLAINTIFF WON
I will pay you for the cheeseburger I ate today tomorrow.
The plaintiff let the defendant slide on paying rent an her part of the bills just bc the plaintiff really liked the defendants dog and cared about it so much that she just didn't care about the money lmfaooo
Oil is SO hard to tell people how much it will be. I had an oil stove for a couple of years. One year it would be $400 to fill up my tank then the next year it would be $600 then back down to $400 then on year it was $900. That’s when I switched to a wood stove. Oil prices are usually around the cost of Diesel Prices. So if Diesel is up so will oil.
I had oil heat before it's hard because the price goes up sometimes
I have gas but I never use it as all my cooking I do is all electric. 😁
wow interesting...
I rented a home where the cost to fill the oil tank was often higher than the cost of the monthly rent. That was during the Gulf War so, some parallels as to what we are seeing today.
@@mamacindyrogofsky495 it's cheaper to heat and cook with gas than electric.
Less than 5 minutes into the episode, the defendant pulls out the old "health problems" excuse.
Defendant has too many excuses, just pay your bills and if you can’t afford it then you can’t afford a dog
Haha this is how the plaintiff is going to get that dog! When they get home or even outside of the courtroom she’s gonna say give me the dog and you don’t have to pay me! 😂😂 I would bet a lot that’s how it’s going to go down!!! The oil is already bought and paid for so it’s kinda money in the bank for the plaintiff, or should I say doggy in the dog house!!! 😂😂😂
Anyone else confused about what an oil bill is lol um what
No. Some people have oil based heating systems.. look it up.
I googled and from what I got from it, it's like a gas bill!! instead of gas she uses oil to heat the unit so she has an oil bill...
Yup. I was until I read this comment and the answers. Lol
@@supaflychik78 Some of us ain't ever had an oil bill. I have electric and gas.
Home heating oil is basically dyed diesel fuel, meaning untaxed for road use. Home heating oil is generally whatever the local diesel fuel cost is minus the road tax that's included at the pump, usually .80 to $1.00 less than the price at the pump. Heating oil is still very common in Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, Tennessee..etc. The current price per gallon in central Indiana is $4.17 per gallon and most standard tanks are 275 gallons...a complete fill up at that price would be almost $1200.
wtf dude.. the response to "she abused her dog" is not "well, it's her dog"! I'm not necessarily agreeing that she was abusing it, but the fact that she owns it should never be a justification.
I was looking for comments like this! Abuse is never okay!
@@mtb3803 I'm actually totally shocked by that because Judge Milian is a huge animal lover.
I think judge knew she wasn't abusing the dog, the judge wanted to end what saying.
The plaintiff using the word use "abuse" doesn't make it so.
@@hottuna2006 and? Still doesn't make "well it's her dog" an ok response to the accusation.
Heating oil bill in Winter = high.
Rest of the year = $0
Yearly bill divided by 12 is probably $40 (her share) per month.
Bobbi looks like the poster woman for "Karens".
The saying 'The more I meet humans, the more I love my dog'. If humans were like dogs there would be love, care and true forgiveness around the world.
She could have asked to see prior oil bills and/or checked with the oil company to get an idea.
1:08 if the lady in that dress ever sees this, you are absolutely beautiful!❤️
I love this! Very rarely do you see people going out of their way to be kind these days. I really hope she saw your comment. ❤️❤️❤️
@@bridgoteaww, and yes that's so true, ❤️❤️
I’ve lived LOTS of places. Never once have I heard that Oil is a utility. Like…wtf??
Plaintiff looks like Sarah Palin to me
Why haven't they yet trained the litigants on where to stand in the hallway? Some yellow feet shaped stickers would do.
Lmfaooo I like seeing them squirm
Something tells me Judge Milian has plenty of 'extra' money she isn't exactly working for minimum wage
Something is not right about the plaintiff 🤔
God bless everyone. Pay the bill
Heating oil is absolutely NUTS. We rented a 1950's house with crummy insulation and we paid over $2,500 in the winter for heating oil ALONE.
You can tell the defendant isn't a good person by the way she let the swinging door close on her witness.
She pushed her side open far enough so it wouldn’t hit the other lady. Besides that they went in different sides, even if it closed it wouldn’t and didn’t hit the other lady.
Does the plaintiff look like Sarah Palin?
The plaintiff looks like a cross between Sarah Palin and Jennifer Coolidge (Stiffler's Mom).
Honestly I feel like we needed to meet the dog 😂
Telling your dog to not lick itself stops medical problems like sore spots. But it can also be a sign of medical problems as well
She forgave her for the oil bill until she didn’t get to keep the dog. 🐕
Trying to evict someone in New York is an non-landlord friendly process. A judge will allow a tenant to live rent free in you space for an additional 6months to a year b4 they finally remove them from your place. And good luck trying to collect the back rent and/or lawyer fees. Ha!! This is why so many landlords are so particular with who they rent to.
It's the same sh!t in California😒. Tenants have more rights than landlords.
@@FartintheWind it’s crazy bc it seems judged can understand the concept of stealing food and clothing, but somehow can’t understand the concept of stealing shelter.
I used to work in foreclosures in NY, and you'd be surprised at how many chances people get to pay when they're clearly not going to. Settlement conferences have to be held before you can get a judgement to foreclose on the house, and we had files where they would have 15/20+ conferences. You get to the point where you wonder when a judge is going to realize these people aren't making an effort.
@@Pepper9873 It’s crazy. Theft of housing should be a thing. If I can’t walk into a boutique and walk out with clothing or a grocery store with food with just a promise to pay back when or if I get around to it, I shouldn’t be able to live on someone else’s property and do the same. Some ppl sell items, some ppl sell ideas, others sell housing and should be compensated for it like every other market.
@@ayanamuhammad6870 housing advocates are the curse that make these tenant friendly laws to enable bad tenant behavior that otherwise would be criminal. Get rid of housng advocates or at least fight them, otherwise, they continue to get away with their bullshit.
Private Caregivers make good money ! She needs to raise her rates, she seems like a nice lady.
she has money for a pet but can"t afford her rent.
and purebred pedigree of course top of the blood line and then never home and cant afford half of anything
Yet she talking crap! 💩
The woman in the pink jacket say behind the plaintiff I've seen twice before on 2 different cases,I notice because she blinks ALOT.
The plaintiff thought the dog was her husband.
Come on Barbie let's go party.... 😁😁😁😁🤣🤣
Emotionally abused the dog. LOL.
how is the bill for oil over $400 in June? who heats the house that much in the summer?
when a plantiff walks in holding that many papers, i can already tell what type of person she is… more papers used here than found at a local public library
She came to win.
@@Etj17 yeah with an encyclopedia britanica
I think when a plaintiff comes to court with little to no paperwork says more about them than someone who shows up with the library of alexandria 😭
You gotta be joking about how great the dog was , to make up for not paying for oil.
When KARENS colide
how can this be possible,
The plaintiff looks like the psychologist from the Sopranos lol
I think the plaintiff should've been allowed to adopt that dog. Clearly it would've been loved beyong comprehention... how can someone scold a dog for licking itself?! Unbelievable.
She should have got the change in writing. The fact that the new lease had no oil being charged implies that’s what they were doing. Just doesn’t prove it. Lesson learned
I’m confused. What’s an oil bill?
I’ve rented for my whole life and never heard of this lol
Be careful Hugging 😂You Just May Get a Slap - ask Chris Rock 🤣
Me from California wondering why are they paying for oil and what is the oil for. 😂😂😂
The plaintiffs witness could not raise her right hand to be sworn in
Funny how when the defendant says medical problems she points to her head.
I'm happy plaintiff adopted a rescue dog
That oil is expensive 😳 How big is the tank? How often does she get oil? 🤔 Something ain't right here.
Oil prices are not standard, they can vary from fill to fill, depending on world markets.
Yes, oil is very expensive. I used to work with Energy Assistance and next to propane, oil is the most expensive type of heating.
I believe the defendant is mean to her dog! This lady absolutely is mean to her dog! I hate people being mean to animals!
That is the plaintiff's point of view; we have no idea if she is really "mean" or not. I got the impression she treated the dog more like a pet than a person and the plaintiff did not agree with that.
1st time I heard rent a room you pay oil. Plaintiff sound a little bit controlling, passive agresive and taking advantage of people in needs.
Oil costs what it costs. Why shouldn’t you have to pay for half? Delusional
why doesn't she go to the dog shelter snd get a dog? so many animals looking for a forever home.
Sorry but I treat my dog like my baby because he is lol I will NEVER be strict with him that’s just me 💁🏾♀️😏
The defendant leaves the court room agreeable happy and cheerful, even though she ''lost'', the plaintive got her money but comes out STILL BAD MOUTHING THE DEFENDANT, NOT CONTENT that she won the case because she just had to get those miserable insults in.
Wow. Good thing peoples court pays for it.
She mentioned waiting for the money *yet* JM breezes over that comment 🙄
Am I the only one that wanted to see a picture of this dog?
The plaintiff seems so annoying I believed the defendant 100% especially at the end with the sly comments about the dog like lady get a man, get a life 🙄
What kind of oil? What does it power! I’m a confused
the defendant said she’s an ex-veteran… what does that mean? lol i thought that either you are a veteran or you aren’t?
😂🤣😂🤣 right!
Yup,totally agree..
People are very strange! 😂
I'm hereeee!!! 👋🏾
Me tooooooooo
The defendant sounded credible 🤷🏾♂️
Not her last comments were “she abuses her dog!” 🤦🏾♀️
the defendant doesnt seem stupid
so she claims the plaintiff 'let her out of the oil charge' verbally
i rekon she would have asked for that in writing
So you can afford an extra 100 a month for oil.
Do you understand that they don't feel oil once a month? That bill is probably 3 to 4 months worth, which is a lot less. Go to a hundred a month a bum is a bum
I think the plaintiff was just being spiteful, the woman paid the rest of her bills on time... Glad she didnt give her dog up!
should
have paid a;l;l her bills not some
It's hardly "spiteful" to expect someone to live up to a lease they signed.
@@barbarak2836 I bet if she gave up that dog there never would have been a court case! The plaintiff is definitely being spiteful. I believe the defendant or that woman wouldn't have made another lease without the oil bill.
She wanted that dog bad.
Plaintiff looks like a bargain basement Sarah Palin.
These oral agreements are just excuses not to pay. Even though there is a written agreement.
all this over a dog
You can’t fix stoopid - Somebody
shame cos they both seem so nice and compatable as forever friends :(
Poor lady. She’s poor and very likely broke. Got sweet F/all sadly she’s a blatant liar. She’s got all the answers