@@rheynotryan lol you obviously don't know what falsetto is since you've answered that, and yeah C#6 is in the range of whistle notes, ariana Grande do them all the time
I think they sang the post-chorus in separate groups except the last one. You can tell the difference between their voices. 1:142:08 Red Velvet 2:061:16 Aespa
Why SM Entertainment made them sing some misogynistic bullshit (no disrespect to Wendy and Seulgi from RV, Winter and Karina from AE, Taeyeon and Hyoyeon from GG or BoA) only to have RV and AE sing an absolutely beautiful Christmas song is beyond me
The chorus with all their voices blending together is just so beautiful on my ears WOW! But I felt like I went to heaven when I first heard Seulgi and Ningning haromonzing. SO BEAUTIFUL! I hope we get more Red Velvet x Aespa collabs in the future!!
Yeri: 'I love Winter' Winter: 'i love you too yeri' Yeri: 'oh,i was say for the season Winter' Winter: :| 😂😂😂 Anyways,i love them voice is so so beautiful 😍❤️ love you girls!
9 CHICAS HERMOSAS! 9 VOCALISTAS 9 RAPERAS Y 9 BAILARINAS! RED VELVET Y AESPA NUNCA NOS TRAICIONA! ELLAS SIEMPRE VAN A SER LAS REINAS DEL K-POP! RED VELVET Y AESPA FOREVER! REVELUV Y MY FOREVER! 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Irene - Leader, Lead Dancer, Lead Rapper, Sub Vocal, Center, Visual Seulgi- Main Dancer, Lead Vocal Wendy - Main Vocal Joy - Lead Vocal, Sub Rapper Yeri - Lead Rapper, Sub Vocal Karina - Lead Dancer, Lead Rapper, Sub Vocal, Visual Giselle - Main Rapper, Sub Vocal Winter - Lead Vocal, Lead Dancer, Visual NingNing - Main Vocal, Maknae
@@artesdeprincesas aww a joy fangirl ❤, idk red velvet that well but I agree! the very few times I watch joy perform, she radiates elegance and is very striking
Ningning actually has decent amount of lines on here considering there’s 9 people singing in a 3min32sec song. She sung in the 1st verse, 2nd verse, prechorus, bridge, has a couple of shared lines and adlibs.
Intro: Winter, Wendy, Giselle, Joy] Hold on! Yeah, ah, can you see what I see? Uh-huh Hoo [Verse 1: Irene, Karina, (Yeri), Joy, Seulgi & Ningning, *Giselle*] Han jang nameun dallyeoge Gwaenhi mami dugeundae Gidaryeoon gyejeol Naega saranghaneun winter (I love winter) Gipeun naui otjang sok Ppalgan yangmal kkeonaebwa Neomu gidaryeoon sunganiya *neomu meotjingeol, ooh-ooh* [Verse 2: Winter, Seulgi, All, Ningning, *Wendy*] Jingle bell, jingle bell Jingle bell all the way (Uh-huh) Caroli ullineun geori Iksukan radio melody Ah, that's right, that's right, yeah Eorin aicheoreom nan Ttwinora everywhere (Oh, yeah) Here and there, out there *aswiwotdeon sungando* *da useumyeonseo bonaellae* [Pre-Chorus: Winter, Joy] Hayan nuncheoreom gadeuk ssain chueok sok, oh Hamkkehae jwoseo cham gomawo, oh [Chorus: All] Everybody come have yourself a (-self a) Beautiful Christmas Uri himkkeot dallyeoon one year Majimageul jeulgyeo Everybody come have yourself a (-self a) Beautiful Christmas Uri hamkke haneun oneuri The best time of the year [Post-Chorus: All, Giselle, Yeri] Huin nuncheoreom (Ooh-ooh-ooh) Gidaryeotdeon (Ooh-ooh-ooh) I sungandeul (Ooh-ooh) Best time of the year Best time! [Verse 3: Winter, Irene & Yeri, Seulgi, Giselle, *Karina & Giselle*] Ding-ding-dong, eoseo nolleo wa Ije uril wihan party time Check it wishlist, jeogeoboja miri Myeot gae jeogeosseo? du soni mojara Gajang majimagui aswiumgwa Dagaoneun seollem 12wori naege deouk uimi inneun geon *kkeuteun tto dareun sijakseon* [Pre-Chorus: Wendy, Ningning] Dasi doraon yeogi olhae gyeouldo, oh Neowa hamkkera deo ttatteuthae, oh [Chorus: All] Everybody come have yourself a (-self a) Beautiful Christmas Uri himkkeot dallyeoon one year Majimageul jeulgyeo Everybody come have yourself a (-self a) Beautiful Christmas Uri hamkke haneun oneuri The best time of the year [Post-Chorus: All, Karina] Huin nuncheoreom (Ooh-ooh-ooh) Gidaryeotdeon (Ooh-ooh-ooh) I sungandeul (Ooh-ooh) Best time of the year [Bridge: Joy, Karina, Irene, Winter, Giselle, Wendy] Tto neowa ireoke Teuri apeseo, oh, holy night Jeonhago sipeun mal To the ladies I'm wishing you a happy Christmas More than anyone To the fellas Oh, yeah, urideurui 1nyeon More than happiness To my friends and to my family You mean to me the Christmas time [Post-Bridge: Yeri, Seulgi] Oh, yeah, everybody clap your hands, come on! Uh-uh, it's the best time of the- It's the best time of the year [Chorus: All] Everybody come have yourself a (-self a) Beautiful Christmas Uri himkkeot dallyeoon one year Majimageul jeulgyeo Everybody come have yourself a (-self a) Beautiful Christmas Uri hamkke haneun oneuri The best time of the year [Post-Chorus: All, Yeri, Winter, Irene] Huin nuncheoreom (Ooh-ooh-ooh) Gidaryeotdeon (Ooh-ooh-ooh) I sungandeul (Ooh-ooh) Best time of the year (The best time of the year) Saranghaneun (Ooh-ooh-ooh) Neoui gyeote (Ooh-ooh-ooh) Neul hamkkehae (Ooh-ooh) It's the best time Baby, it's the best of the year
Winter Wendy Giselle Irene Karina Yeri Joy Seulgi ning 2 Giselle Winter Seulgi Giselle Ning 2 Wendy Winter Joy ALL Giselle winter Yeri irene Seulgi Giselle winter Wendy Ning 2 ALL Karina Joy Karina Winter Irene Giselle Wendy Yeri Seulgi Ning 2 ALL Yeri Wendy Karina Irene
@@savage_0217the favoritism started since debut tho remember she got a mama solo days after debuting yet mys didnt say a thing karina got hers 2 years after debuting and mys are still calling her the sm princess when its crealy winter because she is yyjs daughter or whatever
The " i love Winter" IS SOOO CUTE !!!
Fr
Their voices are so angelic
Except Wendy’s she ruined this song just like every other song
@@caseydominick7806 Troll shes literally the main vocalist for a reason
@@caseydominick7806maybe bc her voice is kinda more westernized
@@minievemidzyno shit I mean she lived in Canada for a while
@@farahahmedkarim377 are you stupid I’m literally just saying why are you so pissed lol like chill?
Wendy is truly the best vocalist I've ever Seen , ningning's whistle note was mind-blowing my girlie finally getting the high notes she deserves.
it's not a whistle
It’s a falsetto
have you never heard beyoncé
@@eirinha2287no hate
Aespa and red velvet. A collab we never new we needed. They're perfect together help😭 also first!
Oo
Yeri is still a dozen
Knew*
We actually knew we need it but thought sm would never approve of it 😭😭🧎🏻♀️🧎🏻♀️
@@yeseoisthequeen shut up
Ningning hitting C#6 effortlessly that whistle note was amazing
it's not a whistle
@@rheynotryan it is used in falsetto voice too
@@eulalia3468 head voice actually, and the entire run was in head voice, not whistle and head voice
@@rheynotryan lol you obviously don't know what falsetto is since you've answered that, and yeah C#6 is in the range of whistle notes, ariana Grande do them all the time
I know this is random, but ur username sounds pretty 🧡
Ningning a voice from heaven
great groups making great music
I think they sang the post-chorus in separate groups except the last one. You can tell the difference between their voices.
1:14 2:08 Red Velvet
2:06 1:16 Aespa
yess
No in first part I can clearly hear Giselle and winter
@@owgxowgzow5498 try compare the times I have mentioned, you can hear the difference.
How can my Christmas not be beautiful, if I will listen to this song starting from now until Christmas?? 😍
I'm always sceptical of new Christmas songs, especially kpop ones, but this one is actually such a bop! A new permenanr addition to my xmas playlist!
they had to make up for ‘step back’ by making the girls sing “to the ladies, i’m wishing you a happy christmas more than anyone” LMFAOO 😭
LMAO SICK
PLEASE 💀😭😭😭
LMFAOOOO
Why SM Entertainment made them sing some misogynistic bullshit (no disrespect to Wendy and Seulgi from RV, Winter and Karina from AE, Taeyeon and Hyoyeon from GG or BoA) only to have RV and AE sing an absolutely beautiful Christmas song is beyond me
@@farahahmedkarim377 exactly 😭😭
THIS IS THE BEST COLLABORATION EVER!!!
Wow it sounds so good 😮😮
I agree 💯
@@elieyahuneptune5404 Always
Wendy ruined the song
@@caseydominick7806 I never asked did i
Talented, brilliant, incredible, amazing, show stopping, spectacular, never the same, totally unique, completely not ever been done before
this song is so beautiful and nice, everyone shined so well. im so happy that red velvet and aespa got to do a collab together! loving this song sm!
이노래 들을수록 진국인 듯 해요... 진짜 너무 좋아요 이런 콜라보는 대찬성이야 진짜... 이런 곡 더 내줘라 스엠아
I was waiting for Ningning’s high note she ate 😭💕💕
Ningning high note!!😲😲😲 2:50
It’s a C#6!!
They made this for me I swear! The two groups that makes me not leave from being a kpop fan
"i love winter" so cute!!
2:15 this part😩
'I LOVE WINTER' OMG WINTER EVERYONE LOVE U😱
Love this song ❤️
Okay this reminds me of SNSD Diamond era what 😭
I hear Seulgi and Ningning leading the chorus
my beautiful talented queens 🥺❤️
The chorus with all their voices blending together is just so beautiful on my ears WOW! But I felt like I went to heaven when I first heard Seulgi and Ningning haromonzing. SO BEAUTIFUL! I hope we get more Red Velvet x Aespa collabs in the future!!
Oh l fall in love with this song 💕😍
Red velvet and Aespa...😲😲
i love the collab and I'm so proud of them and this the best song ever i'm in love with this masterpice 😭😭😭😭😭😭🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹💞💞💞💞💞💞
BEST COLLAB OF THE YEAR! 🤍🤍🤍
Wuhuuu yeaaah OUR WENRIAH CAREY HEREEE🤩🤩💙
I love red velvet n aespa
Winter shone in this song so much!
You can feel the spirit of xmas 🎄 (its april) 💝🎄🎄😻😻
How fast you wanna upload the lyrics version?
Jaeguchi: YES!
Yeri: 'I love Winter'
Winter: 'i love you too yeri'
Yeri: 'oh,i was say for the season Winter'
Winter: :|
😂😂😂
Anyways,i love them voice is so so beautiful 😍❤️ love you girls!
I THOUGHT THAT-
Sm truly knows how to satisfy Thier fans
Red Vespa
한 겨울의 사이다 소리
Ningning whistle note 😭😭👀
Well Done! Red Velvet
☃️🎋❄⛄
Merry Christmas 🎅 🎄 🤶
9 CHICAS HERMOSAS!
9 VOCALISTAS 9 RAPERAS Y 9 BAILARINAS!
RED VELVET Y AESPA NUNCA NOS TRAICIONA!
ELLAS SIEMPRE VAN A SER LAS REINAS DEL K-POP!
RED VELVET Y AESPA FOREVER!
REVELUV Y MY FOREVER!
😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
SO SWEET!
It may be August but I just discovered this existed so I have to listen obviously
1:37 its Giselle and Karina
So pretty Red Velvet and aespa
Irene - Leader, Lead Dancer, Lead Rapper, Sub Vocal, Center, Visual
Seulgi- Main Dancer, Lead Vocal
Wendy - Main Vocal
Joy - Lead Vocal, Sub Rapper
Yeri - Lead Rapper, Sub Vocal
Karina - Lead Dancer, Lead Rapper, Sub Vocal, Visual
Giselle - Main Rapper, Sub Vocal
Winter - Lead Vocal, Lead Dancer, Visual
NingNing - Main Vocal, Maknae
@@artesdeprincesas aww a joy fangirl ❤, idk red velvet that well but I agree! the very few times I watch joy perform, she radiates elegance and is very striking
I thought theirs going to be joy-ningning moment
Ningning deserve more line
She has the most lines here. And she finally got what she deserves ♥️
Ningning deserves better treatment from SM honestly
@@jayvlv3800 no she's not, I can tell winter, seulgi, karina and even joy got more lines than her
Ningning actually has decent amount of lines on here considering there’s 9 people singing in a 3min32sec song. She sung in the 1st verse, 2nd verse, prechorus, bridge, has a couple of shared lines and adlibs.
@@alexally2769 I think maybe they want ningning to have more line since she is main vocal just like wendy
winter！！！
Wendy ❤ ningning
2:36 3:24 웬디가 찢었다..👍
So good
well both songs are composed by the same person, if that makes sense
@@beabyun807 oh I don't know that thanks 🫂💟
@@jaeeun0-0 ur welcome, I wish you and your family to have a Beautiful Christmas this year😊
@@beabyun807 you too >
Hot & Cold upload plz🥺❤️❤️❤️
My Bias Red Velvet & Aespa : Seulgi, Wendy & Ningning ❤❤❤
i hate christmas songs but this ate
Merry Christmas
Ice Age 2002 Kristin Chenoweth as Zeke Red Velvet Aespa Beautiful Christmas
0:47
gaganduhhhhh!!!
Intro: Winter, Wendy, Giselle, Joy]
Hold on!
Yeah, ah, can you see what I see?
Uh-huh
Hoo
[Verse 1: Irene, Karina, (Yeri), Joy, Seulgi & Ningning, *Giselle*]
Han jang nameun dallyeoge
Gwaenhi mami dugeundae
Gidaryeoon gyejeol
Naega saranghaneun winter (I love winter)
Gipeun naui otjang sok
Ppalgan yangmal kkeonaebwa
Neomu gidaryeoon sunganiya
*neomu meotjingeol, ooh-ooh*
[Verse 2: Winter, Seulgi, All, Ningning, *Wendy*]
Jingle bell, jingle bell
Jingle bell all the way (Uh-huh)
Caroli ullineun geori
Iksukan radio melody
Ah, that's right, that's right, yeah
Eorin aicheoreom nan
Ttwinora everywhere (Oh, yeah)
Here and there, out there
*aswiwotdeon sungando*
*da useumyeonseo bonaellae*
[Pre-Chorus: Winter, Joy]
Hayan nuncheoreom gadeuk ssain chueok sok, oh
Hamkkehae jwoseo cham gomawo, oh
[Chorus: All]
Everybody come have yourself a (-self a)
Beautiful Christmas
Uri himkkeot dallyeoon one year
Majimageul jeulgyeo
Everybody come have yourself a (-self a)
Beautiful Christmas
Uri hamkke haneun oneuri
The best time of the year
[Post-Chorus: All, Giselle, Yeri]
Huin nuncheoreom (Ooh-ooh-ooh)
Gidaryeotdeon (Ooh-ooh-ooh)
I sungandeul (Ooh-ooh)
Best time of the year
Best time!
[Verse 3: Winter, Irene & Yeri, Seulgi, Giselle, *Karina & Giselle*]
Ding-ding-dong, eoseo nolleo wa
Ije uril wihan party time
Check it wishlist, jeogeoboja miri
Myeot gae jeogeosseo? du soni mojara
Gajang majimagui aswiumgwa
Dagaoneun seollem
12wori naege deouk uimi inneun geon
*kkeuteun tto dareun sijakseon*
[Pre-Chorus: Wendy, Ningning]
Dasi doraon yeogi olhae gyeouldo, oh
Neowa hamkkera deo ttatteuthae, oh
[Chorus: All]
Everybody come have yourself a (-self a)
Beautiful Christmas
Uri himkkeot dallyeoon one year
Majimageul jeulgyeo
Everybody come have yourself a (-self a)
Beautiful Christmas
Uri hamkke haneun oneuri
The best time of the year
[Post-Chorus: All, Karina]
Huin nuncheoreom (Ooh-ooh-ooh)
Gidaryeotdeon (Ooh-ooh-ooh)
I sungandeul (Ooh-ooh)
Best time of the year
[Bridge: Joy, Karina, Irene, Winter, Giselle, Wendy]
Tto neowa ireoke
Teuri apeseo, oh, holy night
Jeonhago sipeun mal
To the ladies
I'm wishing you a happy Christmas
More than anyone
To the fellas
Oh, yeah, urideurui 1nyeon
More than happiness
To my friends and to my family
You mean to me the Christmas time
[Post-Bridge: Yeri, Seulgi]
Oh, yeah, everybody clap your hands, come on!
Uh-uh, it's the best time of the-
It's the best time of the year
[Chorus: All]
Everybody come have yourself a (-self a)
Beautiful Christmas
Uri himkkeot dallyeoon one year
Majimageul jeulgyeo
Everybody come have yourself a (-self a)
Beautiful Christmas
Uri hamkke haneun oneuri
The best time of the year
[Post-Chorus: All, Yeri, Winter, Irene]
Huin nuncheoreom (Ooh-ooh-ooh)
Gidaryeotdeon (Ooh-ooh-ooh)
I sungandeul (Ooh-ooh)
Best time of the year (The best time of the year)
Saranghaneun (Ooh-ooh-ooh)
Neoui gyeote (Ooh-ooh-ooh)
Neul hamkkehae (Ooh-ooh)
It's the best time
Baby, it's the best of the year
Ahhhh😭❤️🔥
❤❤
I think 0:42 are Yeri and Giselle too.
افضلل بناات
🥺🥺💖
Shame it wasn't entirely in English- it would've become a global hit.
First
I PURPLE YOU💜💜
❤🎉
How are you guys so fast…
Hey
0:55~1:21
Winter
Wendy
Giselle
Irene
Karina
Yeri
Joy
Seulgi ning 2
Giselle
Winter
Seulgi
Giselle
Ning 2
Wendy
Winter
Joy
ALL
Giselle
winter
Yeri irene
Seulgi
Giselle winter
Wendy
Ning 2
ALL
Karina
Joy
Karina
Winter
Irene
Giselle
Wendy
Yeri
Seulgi
Ning 2
ALL
Yeri
Wendy
Karina
Irene
♡
*Massive* missed opportunity for Winter to have gotten the pre-chorus instead of Joy. For fuck's sake, her name is literally Winter…
so fast
💗💚❤️🧡💙💗💛💜🩵
I love this song but why it gives Twice vibes 😭
Nyanyi ini bikin bengek
Jaeguchi too fast wkwkwk
카리나 파트 왜이렇게 없냐..ㅜㅜ
디즈니 노래같다
I'm first❤️
췩 잇
Why cant sm just give the english parts to Giselle, winter voice doesnt sound good in those parts they need to stop with the favoritism
I think Winter suit that part. It's not favoritism. What's so special having English parts?
@@ae-Michael it is favoritism its just that many of us is not ready for that discussion ever since savage era.
Keep barking, winter will always be famous
@@savage_0217the favoritism started since debut tho remember she got a mama solo days after debuting yet mys didnt say a thing karina got hers 2 years after debuting and mys are still calling her the sm princess when its crealy winter because she is yyjs daughter or whatever
@@yukikuran1115 im talking about the lines in savage era.
FIRSTT (pin?)
JOY IS THE REAL LEAD RAPPER NOT YERI
not so good
nobody asked ya
do I care
it is for us so. What you think don't natter really
Go listen to backpink then
you're just jealous cuz your faves can't sing this good
❤❤
2:35
❤❤❤❤