Death of a Game: Warcraft III Reforged
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 окт 2021
- Go to Squarespace.com for a free trial, and when you’re ready to launch, go to www.squarespace.com/nerdslayer... to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
Shout out to Wtiiwarcraft & Grubby for their amazing videos on the subject too.
Merch: teespring.com/stores/nerdslay...
Patreon: / nerdslayer
Amazon: www.amazon.com/?tag=nerdslayer...
Humble Bundle:www.humblebundle.com/monthly?...
Twitch: / nerdslayerrr
Twitter: / nerdslayerg
Discord: / discord
#DOAG . Death of a Game is a series dedicated to uncovering the mysteries surrounding the death of a game or company. nerdSlayer defines the term "death" in the context of the show as either... 1. Literally dead. 2. Had a mass exodus of players and never recovered (expectations etc). 3. The company ceased to exist. We follow a timeline of events, to uncover clues concerning why a game or company doesn't do well, and attempt to put it all together at the end for a deduction explaining how or why the game failed based on the evidence gathered.
Sources:
/ 1224671468715421696
/ 1222293661037273088
/ 1255545020582518785
playwarcraft3.com/en-us/
www.w3champions.com/
• Warcraft 3 REFORGED: I...
www.polygon.com/2020/1/29/211...
www.polygon.com/blizzcon/2018...
www.pcgamer.com/au/warcraft-3...
www.polygon.com/2019/11/1/209...
Warcraft3/status/...
www.gamepur.com/guides/how-to...
www.dexerto.com/gaming/warcra...
www.reddit.com/r/warcraft3/co...
us.forums.blizzard.com/en/war...
www.bloomberg.com/news/articl...
www.blizzard.com/en-us/legal/...
www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain...
www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain...
www.pcgamer.com/warcraft-3-re...
www.polygon.com/2019/12/17/21...
www.ign.com/articles/warcraft...
www.pcgamer.com/warcraft-3-re...
www.ign.com/articles/warcraft...
www.pcgamer.com/warcraft-3-re...
www.techgamingreport.com/bliz...
www.metacritic.com/game/pc/wa...
www.metacritic.com/game/pc/wa...
www.forbes.com/sites/paultass...
www.videogameschronicle.com/n...
www.pcgamer.com/warcraft-3-re...
www.dexerto.com/gaming/activi...
• WC3 Reforged 1 Year La...
liquipedia.net/warcraft/Warcr...
liquipedia.net/warcraft/Patch...
• Warcraft 3 Reforged ON...
• Why Warcraft 3 Reforge...
www.pcgamer.com/blizzard-says...
www.polygon.com/2020/2/3/2112...
www.gamesradar.com/uk/warcraf...
www.pcgamer.com/warcraft-3-re... 
Игры
Go to Squarespace.com for a free trial, and when you’re ready to launch, go to www.squarespace.com/nerdslayerstudios to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. Thanks to Squarespace for sponsoring this video. And thanks to the fans for reaching out to other content creators/devs/experienced players to help gather feedback to make this video THAT much better!
Soon WoW will be on this list at the rate it’s going
Back in 2018 when they announce Reforged will be released in 2019, i have already suspected it is a rushed product. For all the thing they promised at that time, 2021 is a more realistic release day because let be honest RTS games are not trash that you can sh*t out like COD games (making some minor changes, add a story and call it a game).
When they announced the 1 month delay, it was even more suspicious because i remember No Man's sky and all the bad games before with its release being delayed with 1 month or 2 months. One or 2 months delay is actually just shareholder talk because I know if a game development was to ever need extra time, it's because the dev team was pressure by higher up for shareholder's sake and Director's bonus well-being not because it was for the sake of gamers.
Damn you made it. The game that destroyed my fav game :(
Watching threw this and Helms Deep & Wintermaul were my favs!
also pirating... DUH. plus old school private servers with modding.
*"Your father ruled this land for 70 years, and you've ground it to dust in a matter of days."*
Bruh Moment
The fact that people could, and did, accurately react to the situation using Warcraft 3's own in-game quotes was what made this trainwreck gold for me.
"This entire company must be purged"
-Arthas
ActiBlizz:"Very...dramatic,old fans.Give me your vanilla Warcraft III & I'll make sure your suffering ends quickly."
Fanbase:"Vanilla WCIII made you what you are,Blizzard!What-are you going to piss on it one last time before you leave this franchise to rot?"
ActiBlizz:" *chuckle* I didn't know you still cared so much about it. Nor does it matter.I'll do what I came for,one way or another. *proceeds to "update" vanilla* "
Fanbase:" *watches vanilla get ruined* ...We dearly hope there is a special place in hell waiting for you,Blizzard!"
ActiBlizz:"We may never know. *I intend to live forever.* "
@@user-rj2th3yf8o Dammit I just typed something like this and you beat me to it lol.
The best part about blizzard losing dota is that icefrog came to them first, with only two conditions. 1, icefrog had final say in balance changes and 2, that all heroes would be free. He was essentially laughed outta the building. This was in 2009.
Whoops.
And instead of taking that as a lesson and learning from it they just acted spiteful and continued to make the same mistakes. Modern day Activision-Blizzard is a joke.
@@Nuvizzle They're a joke?
Then why aren't I laughing?
@@kazekamiha you’re not the audience of the joke. I can hear Rob Kostich (activision president) laughing from here
2009 is the year after blizzard merged with activison
'How to make a good remake'
Step 1: Don't piss off the fans
Blizzard: *WHOA THIS IS HARD*
It's like that meme with the guy panicking over which button to push, button 1: please the fans, make the game good, button 2: piss off the fans and ruin a classic game lol as he violently pushes button 2.
@@philiproler5572 and yet Blizzard happily let them take over instead of fighting back. How come the Blizzard staff didn't stand up to this? According to the reports this was going on for years, possibly before the Activision buyout
@@Arcademan09 It was Blizzard's then parent company Vivendi that decided to merge with Activision way back when. As a subsidiary aka child company, Blizzard had zero say in the merge.
Well that IS actually hard for companies.
To be fair, that probably is the hardest part for most companies. God forbid you decide to remake someone’s beloved video game/movie/tv show/etc, it seems you just piss off every fan because it’s impossible to please them.
Piracy is literally the only way to play the good WC3 now
sad
Piracy is the only way to live in this wicked world
What do you mean, just play with classic graphics, I played the whole campaign on it and did not encounter a single bug.
@@rogerandersen7046 I'm a mod-maker and I've spent about one thousand hours making an awesome custom campaign for WC3. Would you like to play it? Oh wait, you can't - custom campaigns are missing (see 19:00).
PS: It's extremely sad that nerdSlayer didn't make this point himself. Literally hundreds of thousands, maybe millions, of work-hours were spent on custom campaigns by thousands of modders. All this just annulled.
I dont have the Blizzard Launcher and got a CD of Wc 3 and Throzen Throne. I can still play on that disc.
@@rogerandersen7046 wait you didn't encounter a single bug? Wow that must mean everyone had the same experience as you because you apparently think that since you didn't have issues, everyone saying bad things about it must be utter liars.
It's truly impressive how Blizzard botched a surefire thing like a Warcraft 3 remaster.
right? the whole thing just needed a refreshener. It wasn't even new. It's like coating a building rather than building it from the ground up.
Blizzard itself is botched.
It wouldnt have worked out even everything panned out correctly.
All they had to do was take the TLC and improvements of Starcraft 2 and add it back into WC3
"A-Blizzard botched a sure-fire"
/rimshot
Not a lot of these manage to effectively kill 2 games at once. Not only killing the easiest RTS remaster you could think of but killing a game that has maintained a solid userbase for 15+ years as well. What a power move.
They are trying to get a triple kill with WoW now
@@MattHatter360 you seen the numbers? Id say they HAVE gotten the triple kill with wow... at this point, everyone who still cares is hoping for a resurrection. To me, that means something is already dead..
wc3 is so good it isn't even dead yet after Blizzard has done their damnest to kill it.
Yeah, the Blizzard of old is dead, now it's just full of weird dbags who just want to hire pretty women to grope and get drunk.
Warcraft is an extremely success title with fanbase and establish lore.
Current Blizzard have great rare talent by manage to bring the title down to its knee. What a bunch of clown... they should just turn themselves into a fruit
IGN scoring it a 7/10 is by far the best thing out of this whole story.
There's a reason they are a joke as reviewers and they keep proving it to us !
"When we opened the exe, it drove my colleague mad. She murdered three other colleagues and ate our manager before exploding in a hideous mess of gore. 6/10."
They are the equivalent of piss
IGN scores 90% of games a 7 or an 8
@@MrAskmannen more like 95% as a 9, so getting a 7 from IGN is like getting bashed in the face with a baseball bat.
Some years ago 2/3 of the rating was just technicalities. If your game looked good, sounded good and had no crippling problems, you would get a 60 - 70% rating.
It's probably still similar today, because it basically ensures better ratings, which makes the game devs/publishers happy, which ensures favorable deals in the future.
Back when I was a kid, and played Frozen Throne and WoW, my dream was to one day become developer and work for Blizzard on these games. How all that changed... Years later, I finished university and become a game developer! Worked for few smaller companies first, learned a lot, progressed. You just explained how much Blizzard changed in that time... Few days ago I got contacted by a recruiter who wanted me to join their company which actually belongs to Activision Blizzard. My response was "if you want people to join you, don't tell them you belong to Activision Blizzard".
It hurt me to say this, because it was a death of a dream for me... Truth is the truth, no matter how painful. This is "the pill" I had to swallow, both as a gamer, and game developer.
Thank you nerdSlayer for this video, at least it gave some closure.
Не знам шта ове компаније тјера да постану јебени монголоиди.
@@Crimson_Edelweiss Pare. Kako sto brze zaraditi sto vise para. Nema veze sta ce biti za par godina.
@@ljubisaavakumovic2835 Али опет не схватам, овако су изгубили милионе муштерија које су се забезекнуте масакром ове игрице, а да не причамо потенцијалне муштерије
@@Crimson_Edelweiss I like how mongoloids is translated perfectly
Well maybe good news as Microsoft bought them and is rumored to clean house of the horrible people ruining both companies
The false advertising is what really got me. "We are updating all the cinematics and making the game you loved 20 years ago a better experience, pre-order now!" and then not even delivering on the additional cinematics and forcing people with the old version to update to the new version? That seems shockingly close to illegality.
The store page still had false promises on it after the game was released. They couldn't be bothered to update the website. It stayed this way until they were being threatened with lawsuits. THEN they updated the store page. They also mass issued refunds to anyone that hit the button, even if you already completed the game. That's how they avoided the lawsuits.
They made one new cinematic lmao, and I'm convinced I could have done it better by myself
@@taylorcorbett8848 Someone already did that for the entire campaign, and it looked better than Blizzard's version which only did 1 mission.
@@Drain-Life-Archive The website with the trailer showing all the stuff we didnt got was availiable like 2-3 WEEKS after release. And then they had the gall to say "We never specificly promised such things! Its all your (community) fault that you expected such thing after we showed you this!"
They should just get sue for misleading scam advertisement
It's not just Reforged but they also deliberately kill the original version as well.
Exactly. I just wish we just had a faithful remaster instead. Then we would have none of these issues and game would be intact.
Yup. Piracy is the only way to play the original. I'm not sure about multiplayer & mods. The base game though piracy is only option. How can they ruin something so bad?
I wish they would at least undo what they did to original. Is there no way to class action lawsuit? I don't remember a ToS except for battlenet. Could be wrong, but if there was no ToS except for online they violated laws by making games people bought unplayable
@@drowningin By not giving a single fuck about the game. Even then art lead was a disrespectful and mocking cuck... and ones who cared were not in power and couldnt do much
I think they needed a reason to cheap out the servers, old one wasn't making enough money.
@@bsherman8236 Not really SC:R is doing fine completely intact on bnet 2.0. Reign of vhaos actually didnt even use a separate server form TFT. They were just to lazy to not ruin its balance by accident every time they done balance changes so they disaled battlenet access for it in 2019. It pretty much shown disregard and lack of care that whole game would receive later
Never seen a better reason to pirate a game. Get an old build, get some "lan over internet" client going. Get the gang together and play custom games for days :D
Some good ole’ canned bread
It's still true today, but it was even more so back then: the pirates had the best versions, even if you owned the game. They performed better due to no DRM and loaded and played faster due to not connecting to servers and/or CDROM hacks steaming content from the hard drive instead.
yes but reforged isnt cracked, classic version is though
@@S4pp don't, if you do connect, your game will be "updated" and you'll be locked out of the classic version, and be restricted in your new version because you don't have reforged.
@@TheOppaiLord oh I see
My “favorite” detail of this debacle is that some features in the original were removed from that version and locked to Reforged only. One such feature? Shadows. Yes, shadows. They removed shadows and paywalled them behind buying the new one. It’s such a petty slap on the face for no reason- who the hell would buy the new version when they already owned the original just for *2 dimensional black blobs*?
To be fair it doesn't REALLY count as "paywalled" since everyone who had the original game got a free "Upgrade" to the new version. So everyone who had that feature before, didn't have to pay any money to get it back. Just play the shittier version of the game instead.
"We want an esports scene, but we're not including a ranked ladder at launch" seems to be a running theme among games on this series. I'm shocked that it's such a common mistake.
“Mistake” Let’s be real here, it isn’t a mistake, it’s the people at the top wanting to put forth the least amount of money possible to make the most amount of profit
😂1;
@@PokeBattlerJaze don't be a bigot bro, they need to cash out that 100 million bonus somehow
@@bsherman8236 10, cause 90 of those are to the poor CEO
@@TYR1139 poor guy just grinding his retirement
"I prefer to remember the temple as it used to be, not the abomination it has become." Akama, Black Temple (2011)
2011? Just a little bit off with that date...
*2007
:0
in a way bilzard's story is almost exactly the story of Arthas. Bilzard was once a good company adored and loved by everyone with limitless potential. Then they accepted the dark power of activision and in so doing gained more powwr but lost who they were. They became a haloo shell of themselves betrayed everyone they cared for and now sit atop there empty place while those who once loved it either now hate it for it's betrayal or wait for it's redemption that they hope for but know it will likely never come
"No king rules forever" How ironic
@@leojamesquiambao1047That line is deep knowing who was the creator Chris Metzen and Thrall's voice actor. Its like he knew, and when he left the company's ongoings, it was a sad day.
This video deserves a sequel: 'Death of a game producer: How Blizzard is slowly digging their own grave'
Well they were digging slowly for the last decade, but since last summer they decided to speedrun that shit.
They are more interested in shoving leftist politics down our throats than developing quality games
its called it merged with Activision and that changed how leadership managed the company
"We're sorry to those of you who didn't have the experience you wanted." is _not_ an apology. It's expressing sympathy. They didn't even apologize for the experience being poor. It's them saying that some of our expectations were too high, despite the hype that they put out. It's them using "experience you *wanted* ", instead of using words like expected or deserved or anything that holds them up to a standard.
It is not even sympathy. Merely condescending corporate babble that they believe will mollify the consumers. Bullshit china debacle all over again. "We're sorry for nebulous reasons (WHAT REASONS), we will try to do better (DO BETTER REGARDING WHAT). ...Oh yeah, check out the new games coming out! Overwatch 2! Diablo! Hype! Consume! Yaaaaaaay".
They pulled that same bullshit when they kicked a protester from a tournament. "Were sorry you feel that way" is not an apology.
they never admit mistake. this must be some sort of hard company policy, because it is ridiculous what they do to avoid it literally anywhere
Blizzard loves non-apologies, which are corporate drivel made to look like an apology but does nothing of the sort. It's just meaningless words.
Its activision-blizzard no? They are too high over there heads in Dough 💵 to care about the consumer.
25:42 "Patch Notes: Naga units now have footprints" . That's right! *Snake people with no legs apparently still leave footprints.* This pretty much says it all.
Tailprint? :)
@@DmytroBogdan slitherprints!
Footprints just refers to all to all trails left behind by units. Naga "footprints" are actually tailprints. But they were missing at launch for some fucking reason.
Imagine being devs of the game,
and listing patch of A F*ing footprint, even when their game are bombarded with all the shit.
@@Lichelf we get it but wanted to point out the magnitude of problem.
Imagine a house sinking underground but the inspection writing in report than home is missing a welcome mat.
Dude, I loved playing custom maps. I loved the Helms Deep custom map. I also played a lot of Azeroth Wars and DaoW. I was always skeptical about Reforged, but I told myself "at least I was always have the classic game. There is no way they would touch that". Then they sowed the two games together in true Frankenstein fashion. I was fucking livid as fuck.
However, thanks to people online, I realized I could just reinstall the game using my disc and then I manually updated to the last safe update (1.27b) before Activision takes over and forces you to download Reforged.
I'm happy I saw this comment, definitely trying this out on my disk.
Will look for an original disk and 1.27b update to support the community without supporting the rotting mess that is ActiBliz (or I guess MicroActiBliz now)
Will look for an original disk and 1.27b update to support the community without supporting the rotting mess that is ActiBliz (or I guess MicroActiBliz now)
you can also pirate the game
Its what i did back in 2018
Exactly what I did, screw their greed and backstabbing.....
It needed to be done, but this Death of a Game might be one of the most significant and devastating to behold.
It also marks my transition towards "fuck these corporations ruining my favorite games". I don't have any love left for them tbh.
A clear example of what happens when the passion for games is exchanged for passion for money
Capitalism:(
It's legitimately depressing to think about far Blizzard has fallen, when their games have been such a big part of your life.
It is. Me, i actively boycott Activision
I used to be able to confidently say that if Blizzard was making a game, it would be high quality and I was going to love it. Sadly, that’s not the case anymore.
@@scorchedamber and so do i with great satisfaction
@@yellowcard8100 at least they admit it and gonna do better. they had one real fuckup, that's it. Bethesda is far superior in terms of being an awesome game company
@@yellowcard8100 well, yeah, you got some points there. let's say "awesome compared to Activision" lol. I do have to say though that ESO being dissapointing was certainly the case but it also had a sky high expectations. I still thought it was a great game upon release and had tons of fun. Certainly not a fuck up when compared to what Acti shits out on a typical release
"This isn't for all players, only players playing reforged"
God I wish I had that level of innocence and naivety.
Funny how Rockstar made all of these mistakes too with GTA Definitive edition. Industry learned nothing from the failure of WC3R.
At least GTA Definitive edition doesn't replace classic GTA3, Vice City, and San Andreas
@@Masonicon they tried to do it
All the old games were delisted, and only brought back amid user backlash
The fans honestly weren't that vocal about story changes. That was 100% an excuse from Blizzard to cover up for their mistakes.
Plenty of people in my circles were horrified by the possibility that the modern WOW writers would get their claws around WC3's story. Maybe that was more of a Horde concern.
You should probably introduce a new series for this one, Stillborn of a Game.
Killed the mother, and the bun in the oven. Blizzard(in name only) incompetence knows no bounds. The company people remember and talk about hasn't existed for over 15 years. It's insane anyone expects anything from this garbage wearing the mask of a once great company.
Like people honestly have hope for Diablo 4. They'll preorder, cry, and do it all again the next game cuz blizzard fans are weird af & don't learn
@@drowningin Its not just ActiBlizz fans (just writing that phrase makes me cringe). Its consumer sheeple in general. Its no wonder the industry & its old guard have all gone to the dogs. Whats the point of wasting time,money and effort on making your products actually good when you have plebs paying top dollar for you to take a dump on them?
@@drowningin there are no fans, dumb people just follow influencers, most influencers are easily bought with hype, clout and sponsorship.
@@user-rj2th3yf8o And that's why I've turned to the Indie game scene.
Technically it's the death of Warcraft 3 classic.
What frustrates me the most is that there are zero consequences for those responsible for this. Those at the top got their bonuses, the devs are burned out and depressed by the bad scores and unfinished work, and the community managers were sacrificed to burden the backlash. And then nothing changes and we move on to the next broken game to get angry about.. it sucks
There are those of us who remember. I remember how much crap Blizzard pumped out over the years. I remember the Blitzchung controversy, I remember "Do you guys not have phones?", I remember Diablo Immortal, I remember OW1 getting canned for the sake of a game that was ultimately canceled, I remember the frat boy culture lawsuits, I remember the diversity algorithms.
I see people praising Diablo IV all around and the taste of bile fills my mouth because I remember. Creators who made an audience talking about how Blizzard sucks for years now suddenly change their tune because Diablo IV is the cool new thing. They have no substance, no heart, no dignity, they will change their opinion in a heartbeat if it means the general public agrees with them.
Honestly, Blizzard is such a shitshow of a company that it singlehandedly opened my eyes to how rotten internet discourse is, and to how shameless AAA studios/publishers are. Nowadays I pretty much only support indie devs, everything else is acquired through sailing the seven seas, and I've never been a happier consumer.
@@Erick-tv8oqconsoomer
When you realize this shit isnt exclusive to the video game industry.. you'll shit bricks
Pretty much every LAN party we had in the 00's involved WC3 custom games, a good portion were wholly consumed by them. ActiBlizz has truly perfected the art of shitting on long-time fans and cannibalizing their own legacy.
The real twist of the knife for me was the fact that they changed the voice acting. Including the Russian dub which is so iconic for the entire Russian-speaking internet community, being memes before memes.
And they not only changed voice actors and some translation choices but also removed a bunch of jokes and changed the lines to be less "risque". That had nothing to do with "modernizing" the game or pro scene.
Same with the Polish dub.
Sadly that has nothing to do with the failure of the developement but the political era of the US.
What jokes did they remove?
@@prussiangermansoldier2987 There could be a huge list, but what I remember, Sorceress use to flirt with the player, they cut the punchline from the Priest's joke because it was about alcohol, Bat Rider had political a joke about visiting those who didn't believe in democracy implying air strikes, Dryad had a joke about luring enemies into forest by mimicking the voice of a lonely human female and so on.
@@demilung
Why even remove the none sexual ones?
This stuff hits way too hard, chief. They really did ruin this part of our childhoods pretty hard, didn't they?
Not really, we're lucky we were on the CD era. There are WC3 Isos floating around and more than enough Bnet clones and private ladders. It'll suck for sure to the online-only era kids tho
ActiBlizz ran us through with Refunded like Arthas did his father.
@@user-rj2th3yf8o Not even a big WC3 fan(more a SC guy) and that feels pretty accurate haha.
Hit me aswell. Damn, no story in gaming so far made me as sad as this one.
@@chefnerd And the thing is, none of the people who worked on this game would have wanted it to go down this way. Can you imagine putting so much time and effort into something like this and to have management screw everything up? And after all the rush jobs and crunching you do, you're then told you have to drop this project you've worked years on after less than a year. It's just sad all around.
"back in the day" Blizzard has cancled projects if they didn't meet their own quality standard, like the StarCraft shooter featuring Nova as a playable character. We got a trailer, some footage and eventually the cancelation notice.
The Blizzard of today did release 'WarCraft 3 - Reforged' to make money of pre-orders.
Blizzard was never as shiny or good as ppl want to believe, nostalgia is a hell of a thing... but the Blizzard of today is a differnt company and it seems they don't care about their product or consumers at all.
@@philiproler5572 it’s kind of the life cycle of just about any creative product. You start with a visionary with a passion project. They impress someone with money who becomes their patron. Then when the visionary finds success and glory the investor says to themselves “I did this! If it weren’t for my decision to support this artist, this product would not exist. Clearly I know what’s best for the product, the artist is just a means of production, I am the one earning here!”
And then they kill the goose that laid the golden eggs and wonder why they stopped making money. Then they look for more people with good ideas.
well at least they didn't release some broken lackluster game just for cash-grabbing back in the day.
Blizzard cancelled Ghost because they were dumb.
They thought that the game wouldn't become successful and they have to abandon it and make more updates for WoW.
I was gonna comment something like this. Blizzard was never the good guy. They may have started that way, but success poisoned them ultimately. They were decent at best, a long time ago. Being bought up by Activision only brought everything that was bubbling under the shell up and out finally. And that's not even mentioning all the toxic workplace stuff.
The worst thing about all of this is that WC3 was in a really fantastic state right before it was pulled and replaced with Reforged. The devs had been regularly updating the game before it was pulled. Such a damn shame all that work is gone forever.
There is a thing about russian voice acting in old WC3. It was very different from original english version, but it was unbelievably cool. All actors done their best and gave their souls to characters they voiced. Especially Arthas, who was voices by Vladimir Vihrov. Just awesome. And when we heard their new russian voice-acting in reforged... We were pissed off. Untalented, lazy and so dull... On that stage lots of russian players understood, that this company gives no sh*t about their fans in different countries.
Same thing for Polish voices
Don’t worry they don’t care about us in their own country either
@@lvsoad22 They don't even care about their own workers
Gosh, so true. I remember comedy shows making sketches around those voices. Such good voice acting it had!
update: here is the link, it's ridiculous
ruclips.net/video/AlqeCeRoPQI/видео.html
@@vanyaliveshere Вечная классика и ностальгия. Эх.
Oh yeah and they forced to stream the "reforged" game. This often resulted in crashes during official tournaments. I remember there was a game between same 2 people restarted 2-3 times until they reversed to old gfx. Truly a blizzard experience
This was ultimately the straw that broke the camel's back for me with Nu-Blizzard. I had begun to sour on my relationship with them with Diablo 3's later patches and the incident with Blitzchung, but this was just a desecration of the years I put into it and told me exactly what their business strategy going forward would be.
Yeah, the Blitzchung incident pissed me off something fierce, what with Blizzard bending the knee to a communist dictatorship and all. That was my last straw with Blizzard, and I was kinda bummed because I was looking forward to Reforged at the time but stuck to my guns.
Thank God I dodged that bullet!
Its more funny when you realize that they said they don't condone political messaging... While months later standing with BLM (another communist movement) and the LGBT community.
When I was a kid, and my parents went away on a business trip for about a week, I had spent 3 days in a row playing footmen frenzy, without any sleep. Then I attended my weekly tennis training session, then went back to play footmen frenzy for another full day. I don't know where I found the stamina but I did. Absolutely insane.
The original: One of the most important PC games of all time, created WoW and MOBAs and inspired so many others, still had community after 17 years
The remake: One of the biggest failures in history of PC games, actually MADE THE ORIGINAL WORSE somehow
For sure, this has to be THE least succesful remake of all time, or at least in the top 5 or something
This was bad enough to make *God bless game Piracy* best
I've grown up with Quake3 and Warcraft3.. seeing both franchises in the nerdSlayer graveyard kinda breaks my heart.
Quake 3 is almost 30 years old dude. That shouldn't be heartbreaking lol its just reality man
@@sunburst8810 I think he meant Quake Champions since its basically Q3.
I think Quake still has a future, it just needs to be given to the proper developers to make it something.
@@Garethsmod Quake Champions was basically id side project in terms of production size, but; DOOM Eternal has several nods hinting that the next game from the core id team could be Quake - either a Quake game proper or DOOM / Quake crossover. In any other game I'd wave the nods off as Easter eggs, but I did that mistake with DOOM '16 (fool me once...).
Personally, I'd heart-attack of giddiness if we get the Slayer going up against Lovecraft monsters and - possibly - the Ranger.
*"Final Tier... Xaero."*
Every time you include a piece of Warcraft's music as a short interlude, I feel shivers going down my spine.
++
That customer service agreement is very much an emotional and bitter statement from the company over losing DotA to Valve. Any DotA player who was following what happened with that situation at the time knew that Icefrog was looking for a standalone successor to the WC3 mod. There was a catch to this situation, Icefrog was going to bring the DotA game over only with the condition that he had full control without anyone above him telling him how to develop his game, this arrangement was never going to happen with Activision Blizzard, therefore he went to Valve to help create Dota 2 along with the legal battle that came between Blizzard and Valve afterwards. Activision Blizzard with Warcraft 3 Reforged made sure another Dota would never happen again on their platform. They really thought Icefrog would have signed over his work to the company with no strings attached, he's not an idiot.
Guys....
There is a positive note to the story.
on numerous repositories over the internet there are Saves of the 1.31 ptr build.
Its basically a classical warcraft3 that supports custom games,campaigns has original lan capabilities but its widescreen and has the latest pre reforged balance.
And because it was a test build its technically legal to download and play it (provided you got original war3 keys to activate it).
If you like War3 download it and share it.
Please if you're willing to spend the time give full instructions on how to do it, step by step guides as well as avoiding updating the game by accident or automatically etc.
It would help me a lot cause i plan on reviving the original lawsuits be damned cause i am planning on something fantastic.
Could you perhaps give a hint on where to find this download? I'd love to get back into WCIII after all these years but I can't possibly support Reforged
Yeah you kinda can get one from hive, they archived other old build before this mess of a game
Copyright law lets you have a backup if you have a master copy meaning Warcraft 3 cd key. The backup copy can be modded changed for a diff OS. So it is legal. I love this law but there is talk of getting rid of it :( As you can not sell used pc game but you can buy get crack play del sell new.
@@kardoxfabricanus7590 to avoid updating the old build. DO NOT LOG ON TO BATTLENET or it will update. And you'll need to rever the patch again
Activision really does poison everything that it touches. It’s like a reverse midas touch, instead of turning something to gold it turns it into a pile of crap.
And yet because of mass stupidity it makes just as much money
it does turn into gold, but gold for bobby kotic, becuse you fools give them money.
Turdy touch?
@@zix1257 Us? No, we don't give them money. Thats why they shifted focus into making games for uninformed masses that never browse youtube, reddit, twitter, news about the game, or dont play the game at all. Thats where they make big bucks for. And these same people then go, defend and excuse Activision.
The era when games were made for fans and enthusiasts is long gone my friend
Ah yes. The Sadim Touch.
i just realized my childhood playing warcraft 3 was actually not the campaign because it was too hard for me and i don't understand yet.
it was just me playing warcraft 3 having fun trying each custom maps from the community, i remember playing an rpg like custom map where you just grind to get good equipments, forgot what was the name but it was one of my favorite
I can’t say I was devastated by this “remaster” that’s a very strong word. However, I was dumbfounded, truly and totally dumbfounded. I like millions of others I got into WoW through WC3. This remaster could have, and should have been a massive boon to the waning WoW. I was speechless, how could Act/blizz not see the potential.
@@philiproler5572 Haha well said, it’s so bad it is impressive.
You're wrong about the Activision merger date. In 2008, Vivendi (who had owned Blizzard for over a decade) bought Activision and merged it with Vivendi games to create Activision Blizzard. But Vivendi still controlled it until 2013, when Kotick and others bought out Vivendi's shares in the company, removing them from ownership. 2013 is when Kotick fully took control. From 2008-2013 the ownership was the same (Vivendi), only the name changed.
So basically is like Vivendi ate a rotten piece of meat containing a zombie virus that took control of the host
Then Vivendi and Blizzard were already rotten to the core before Activision took hold. Never forget Diablo 3. Game balanced and build around a mandatory real money auction house for items, with a droptable carefully crafted to make it so you only got stuff you couldn't use to be forced to sell that on the auction house and buy stuff for your class instead. That was in 2011.
@@EskChan19 Yes and no. While Activision didn't get full control until 2013, Bobby Kotick had some input on the direction of the company as far back as 2008, when Vivendi merged Activision into Vivendi Games (creating Activision Blizzard). 2013 was when Kotick bought out Vivendi's share of the company, giving himself 100% control.
@@BuffoFesss Canned Frostmourne.
Arthas is a more sympathetic villain than Bobby Kotick
Tichondrius is a more sympathetic villain than Bobby Kotick.
Despite it all, Arthas just wanted to do good for his people. Botick doesn't even have that going for him
Emperor Palpatine is almost more sympathetic
Arthas is not a villian
One important note for old WC3 fans: The classic competitive scene is alive and well and that would have been a nice outro. The guys at Back2Warcraft on twitch are putting in serious work.
This is the greatest video in detail of anything I ever needed to hear and know about. Fantastic and well researched and narrated video. I appreciate this. It’s a hard pill to swallow. I’m 32. I loved and lived it all. Thank you for the closure.
It takes a special level of incompetence and carelesness to make a 20 year old game WORSE then when it originally released
30:00 That tournament gets WORSE!. . . The problems were SO bad they had to finish the stream/competition with paper rock scissors o-0
18:05 You know you fucked up when you make the Master Chief Collection look competent
The only positive that came of this was we were spared any of christie goldens rewrites.
When your CEO looks and acts like a Goblin, things aren´t going to be as smooth as could be
Bobby Kotick is a real-world Jastor Gallywix, but even worse
Gallywax is real
And he runs blizzard
sounds pretty anti-Semitic
Wish I thought of that one lol somebody should photo shop him and make it official lol
@@grimkaizer8417 Am I missing something here????
How could they mess this up so badly? We've seen *so many* great RTS remasters and remakes over the past decade: Age of Empires & Mythology, StarCraft, Seven Kingdoms, even EA with Command & Conquer! Age of Empires even does what they planned with loads of balance changes and expansions to shake up the old game. The road map to a successful RTS remake is so well established at this point that they have no excuse. RIP WarCraft 3.
This is what actually hurts the most. Out of all, EA mangaes to create a very very good remaster of C&C. And they didnt even do much. They scaled up the graphics, remade the cinematics, added a couple comfort options in controls and thats it. Everything else stood the same and as far as i can tell, most people love it. And it was basically a success, because there have been multiple announcements that EA also want to remake further C&C-titles.
If you have to advice Blizzards devs to take a note on EAs work, you know times have changed drastically!
Other game remasters are separate products from original ones, unlike Warcraft 3
@@Randleray I also remember the CnC remaster really started with a reddit post ! and including the community from day ONE ! and even getting a few hardcore fans envolved
Throw in Fire Emblem Echoes into that list
Well not really. C&C remastered is quite a mess in multiplayer with terrible input lag, slowdowns, only 1vs1 ranked mode and changes in gameplay to please the newbies (which are not present anyway). Beside you need a very powerful gaming pc to play it in a semi decent manner for the new 4k graphic which is not the main point for an rts with such small units. It has been abandoned after less than one year by the developers... However unlike Warcraft3 we can still play the original games on C&C net with user made improvements, ranked games ans much mote. So basically the fan base checked the remastered, abandoned it after a while, got back to have fun with the old versions of the game :) like we are going since 1992 :)
I used to draw war craft 2 map strats in high-school. Couldn’t wait to test them out when i got home from school.
This one hit hard, goes to show how “Blizzard” is gone.
WC3 after Blizzard picked it up again:
"That's it. I'm dead."
This make "God Bless game Piracy" best
If you check Twitch almost no one is playing with Reforged graphics, I still play custom games at times and there are still awesome developers who are working for classic graphics. I mean, you're forced to download like 30gbs of a assets you won't use. Many good friends with potatoes pc stopped playing or just went to private servers or even tried out Netease, do you know that that's? Is a chinese client for classic WC3 wich let's you customize your hud and observe games being played live.
It's impressive how fans are keeping this game alive
it's like still depending on garena in 2021
and WC champions of course
@@Booklat1 garena did their job well enough
Please sauce?
I need it for... "Research..."
Pretty please? Also i plan on helping resurrect the community.
@@withoutthehihatehappiness413 garena was good, lots of fun there but still, kinda sucked that we used garena for functionality over bnet
I'm a little late to see this episode, but I love these deep dives you take. Amazing sleuthing!
It's quite fitting in a way: What Reforged did to Warcraft 3 is what Activision did to Blizzard.
Just like what EA did to it's Intellectual Properties
@@Masonicon of what DICE did to Battlefield 2042
such a tragedy, WC3 is one of the most important games in gaming history. Not only was it a fantastic entry in a strong franchise, not only did it lay the foundations for WoW, but the custom campaign community was either the birth place or inspiration of many successful games and even entirely new genres. DOTA2 and League of Legends for example can trace their lineage directly from the WC3 battlenet community. Which puts WC3 among other gaming titans like Half Life 1-2, Quake, Doom, Unreal, exemplifying not only fantastic games for their time, but also the primordial soup that would give rise to entirely new games and genres that would go on to spawn their own noteworthy successes.
I cannot understand this! so fucking sad and frustrating. I can just pop in my old PS1 games, or nintendo games, or install my old discs of classic PC games. But WC3 has been razed to the ground. Such fucking selfish greed on the part of the execs, makes me sick!
@@DruNature yeah, hope the company dies, for real
@@DruNature except when we pirate Warcraft 3
without WC3 and CS there wouldnt be even such a thing as esports.
The virgin WC3: Reforged vs the chad AoE2: Definitive edition
This still pisses me off to this day. They really did us dirty with WC3
AoE2 DE makes this so much worse. Microsoft hit the jackpot with it, revitalised an old series and created growing playerbase and ccommunity, which I'd imagine pays off quite a lot, creating a community and creating a launching pad for new games in the series (hiya, AoE4!). And AoE was always less popular than WC. Actiblizz could've achieved so much, but they just went and threw it all away.
Great video, but more than that, and I meant to say it for a long time: GREAT intro to your videos.
I know it's not new or anything, but I really, really enjoy it every time, and it is just brilliant how clever it is.
Custom games were my childhood and deeply beloved to my heart. The hours I could spend in the World Editor alone, let alone with friends on a weekend, are literally uncountable. I felt a visceral reaction in my gut when you showed Hive and those brief clips of custom games. I would've bought WC3:R specifically for those custom games, especially now that I'm older and can play much more than when I was younger on my brother's computer. It was heartbreaking to hear about what they had done to custom games, and as you said killed my interest in purchasing it right then and there.
I wasn't exactly glued to the hip as others might have been to Blizzard, but they were in an almost exalted state to my younger self; getting a job there was a dream of mine and while I abandoned that after realizing the reality behind game development, they're still one of the main names behind my passion and love for fantasy games. It hurts to see all the vitriol directed at them as they are now.
"We just wanted to make the game better!"
Bro, it was already considered one of, if not the, greatest RTS ever made WTF do you mean?
Instead we got a Remaster that was so bad, it killed the original. And that's the most unforgivable of sins.
Personally, this was the nail in the coffin. I will never buy an Activision or Blizzard game again after this shit.
Evil cannot create, only corrupt
And you only notice this now?
When Diablo 3 released I already knew that I'm never going to buy another game from them...
@@SkullboyTV Amen to this. I saw the writing on the wall as soon as that was coming out, while my other D2 friends were hyped about it. I refused to purchase it at launch, let alone pre-order it. I never liked activision, and I consider Blizzard dead and buried in 2002.
@@bloodlustshiva1 why 2002? they didn't merge with Activision till 2008.
@@sirpieman300 Because that was the last product I got from them, and will remain that way.
The positive note: Torrents
And thanks for the video, NS! This death was one of the saddest...
I _still_ haven't managed to properly pirate the game. :/
Only mostly for those that can't reach their old pirated copies of warcraft 3
I feel very bad for the developers of Reforged. They were so clearly thrown to the wolves intentionally having to keep up company appearances with fake apologies while not really being allowed to acknowledge the company's screwups. They also took a LOT of the heat of the fanbase's wrath, but I don't think they deserve it. This video doesn't go into it but around the release of Reforged a lot of patches came out that honestly kinda revolutionized Warcraft 3 mapmaking. The World Editor now supports using Lua script as well as introducing many new native functions that allow for custom UI and so many other things, giving a level of freedom we never had before. That doesn't mean it wasn't still messy - the World Editor is buggy to this day, as for example it occasionally just wipes your imported files - but that, along with the balance patches that were sorely needed in a game that had long become stale, makes me confident that there were people working on this project that absolutely knew what they were doing and just didn't have the time or resources to go all the way with it.
Warcraft 3 refunded was outsourced almost completely, we didnt even see any of real developers. All we got fake apologies from fake developers.
@@amai2307 they outsourced it to southeast asia and china devs that shows
reforged still makes my blood boil
i stil remember my very first night playing frozen throne the first two night elve missions and some early game of founding of durotar
one of few my strongest gaming memories
I have never played Warcraft 3 before and even then i could feel immense pain by watching this video
Oh, it was a fun time, lots of cool custom campaigns, and some very creative custom game modes, pretty cool singleplayer too. If it ever interests you, you can probably still play the original game, if you get your hands on an older copy and use one of the backed up patches that the community has preserved. The people will always be around, even if the game is no longer with us in an official capacity.
I've never played it, but my eyebrows shot up and my jaw nearly hit the floor when I saw the part about the "Forced upgrade" of the _*original WC3*_. I'm just.... WAT THE FUCK?!
@@internetzenmaster8952 Yeah, I've never seen or heard of anything like this happening with a game re-release, like... ever. Honestly I think it is a contender for most baffling, most bizarre decision to be made in the making of a game.
There has to be a reason, right? Maybe to not split their playerbase? Or so that people won't go like "nah I'll stay with the old one, thanks mate" and then sales are shit?
@@glanni One shouldn't try to *force* people to play the remaster, that's the easiest way to get them to respond badly to it, but I guess that may have not been as clear to the person who ultimately made that decision.
I think the best way to not split the playerbase in this case is to make the two versions of the game crossplay compatible, but I guess the internal architecture of the game has changed too much for that to be possible at this point. I don't actually know, I would like that to be possible.
I still remember seeing boxes of these games in the computer section of best buy around 2005-2007. Classic title. That and Second Life.
Who else play WC3 for the custom games? LOAP, Hero Wars, LOTR Castle Def, HvH, Sheep Tag, etc. God I miss those days.
Meanwhile all 3 age of empires receive their best versions ever with DE getting new dlc civs and increasing the player base
I'm so glad Microsoft did justice to age of empires
@Order & Chaos I wish I could forget EE3 but sadly I still own a copy which I stupidly bought myself for Christmas (Parents took me to Circuit City and allowed me to pick out 3 PC games and that was one of them)
And Age of Mythology continues to get semi-consistent support, despite not being as popular as AoE
AoE3 DE isn't perfect, I must say
@@mickethegoblin7167 yeah I agree i tried to play it yesterday but disconnected 3 times
The word "modernize" sends a cold chill down my spine.
It's basically a religious term. It means "we're going to censor the hell out of this, and make it as unattractive as possible".
100%
The only time I used that word positively was when I described back 4 blood where described it as modernized left 4 dead
@@badasscrusader lmao, that is one of the perfect examples of how it can be used negatively....
@@mickethegoblin7167 okay let me put it like this,it has a modernized leveling system and cosmetics,but its gameplay doesn't benefit or get hampered by the leveling system
I love the game,but it is flawed
This was supposed to be my treat game for having to go through a really painful surgery with a long recovery time. Not only did Blizz fail, the surgery failed, so I had to have it again, but this time w/o even the false hope of reforged. I had a lot riding on this as my friends were mainly SC1 fans. SC2 MP balance was really wonky, the campaign basically War3 reskinned, so getting an actual War3 re-everything would be what helped me get my friends on board, we were planning a big ol' gaming night. Obviously...never happened. No way in hell am I buying a WarCraft 4. I wouldn't buy a StarCraft 3 either.
Glad to know I am not the only person waiting on Warcraft IV.
"Death of a Game: Warcraft III Reforged"
Wait, that was alive to begin with?
Undeath of a game is more like it.
Since it is essentially a patch with a rename. Yes the og w3 was alive.
The tragedy is that it killed the classic with it.
It absolutely sold like hotcakes.
they used necromantic power and turned in to this monstrosity
It's crazy that we're watching the death spiral of Blizzard unfold before us. 10 years ago, this would have been an unconceivable thing. No king truly rules forever.
10 years ago they started this spiral with Diablo 3 and the real money auction house. This was the first time we should have known Blizzard was gone.
Only darkness - arthas menethil
The helms deep mod was incredible. It is by far my best memory from Warcraft III
Fantastic video. Keep up the good work.
One thing that I just remembered: this game was released just a few months after Nintendo's remake of Link's Awakening. I know they're totally different games, but at the same time, the descrepency in the quality of the remakes is night and day.
Not only that but you also had the Demon's Souls remake come out not too long after made by a studio who have become reknowned for remakes after having worked on the awesome Shadow of the Colossus remake. Showing how to do a remake right.
dont forget age of empires 2 definitive edition.
Such a good case of how poorly a remake/remaster could be handled. Completely bizarre decisions that gave off so many red flags before it was released. If any good came out of the tragedy that was Reforged is that it opened the eyes to a number of people about how different Activision Blizzard was as a company. Hopefully they get their act together soon or Activision might just do away with them at some point.
Not sure which is worse, Silent Hill HD Collection or this...
its weird how sc 1 was a success , wc3 reforged was a fail and seems d2 res seems like a success
@@Ameerzmadi Only because D2R was made by a completely different company since it was Viracious Visions and not Blizzard that made it. lol
I remember when many people want to work in Blizzard, it's considered dream job during that time.
Hope they get sacked and all the ip's are sent to new blood
the competitive multiplayer space was insanely popular in the hay day. use to go home friday night and login. it was the first online game i played with my friends
SpoonyOne said it best: "BETRAYAL!"
Thank You for pointing out that Blizzard doesn't exist anymore, it's basically an I.P. and not a real company anymore. I figured once the movie was made, it was downhill from there.
It was shit right when D3 released which, concidentally, is when Activision already has taken over
@@hazardeur *In-game real money auction house*
“What? Don’t you guys gave wallets?”
@@bcbitchkkv you think you only pay for the game once. but you don't
God that movie was trash. My friends keep saying it was not too bad, dude, a warcraft movie shouldn't be "not too bad", it should be epic af.
@@hazardeur also Blizzard: adds Garrisons and turns them into one big mobile game countdown mechanic.
Players: “But.. we want to play the game.”
J. Allen Brack: “You think you do, but you don’t.”
This fuckup was so epic it's hilarious. I loved War 3 but I dont think I ever had as much fun playing it as reading about reforged
like Arthas claIming frostmourne, Blizzard had become a mere puppet, a vessel, for a much darker master
The Custom Map policies are something that were experimented as far back as Starcraft 2: Wings of Liberty. Left 4 Dead was taken by Blizzard and Nexus Word Wars was removed for having the word "cunt" in it. Blizzard had been going very hard against the custom map scene for a long time. There's quite a few parallels to Bethesda prior to the Microsoft buyout with their paid mods.
I agree as well
I was doing some research the other day about Blizzard's history with modding since I've been super frustrated with the way they're handling D2R. I want to learn how some other big companies handle it and was looking into Bethesda since they seem to be very much "anything goes." Could you point me to where I should start learning about some of these parallels? I really want to learn more
@@IntoTheSkyy ruclips.net/video/MJwErFv5enU/видео.html This is a good starting place for the initial paid mods controversy, which would be followed by Creation Club. It's just aggressive pushes against the modding community.
I wouldn't be surprised is ES6 and Starfield have Creation Club built inside of both games, and requires people to run through those services in order to mod either.
Having followed Grubby, one of the last remaining active pro player, that was highly involved in the promotion and testing another huge problem that he pointed out from the very beginning was/ is that with the colours being desaturated and the new models resembling more east asian mobile games rather than the characteristic warcraft blocky humanoid style vidual unit identification became extremely difficult which caused even pro players that have continuously played the game for 2 decades to have difficulties in observing, controlling of and reacting with their units in larger engagements, which is besides the other downgrades a huge problem for multiplayer matches as it forced anyone not wanting to play with a disadvantage to opt out of the only actual improvements done to the game by habing to turn the graphics back to the original settings
@Juan C. Pretty sure his post lays out the reason why bro
Honestly that's something they would have gotten used to. It's a change, but one that just takes some practice. And honestly, competitive players play almost all games on lowest settings anyway
Got recommended the channel by a Poker Night at the Inventory vid. I've only watched Telltale and this so far, but they've been very enjoyable, informative vids. Thanks for documenting these absolute crimes.
I remember the thing that made me "nope out" of WC3R was the ToS update about custom maps. Seemed it worked out well.
When I was replaying the campaign and got 3/4 the way through when Reforged hit then all my saves were erased and all campaigns locked until I re-complete them.
It just not only scrapped campaigns. My custom games folder got overwritten and emptied. With over a 1000 maps - some made in private just for friends at LAN parties and with many obscure maps and versions, that you won't find at internet databases anymore. Those are GONE FOR GOOD AND FOREVER because one day Blizzard Activision decided to reinstall WC3 without asking or prior notice and replace it with an inferior, bloated version.
@@theshinken I feel ya man, I was collecting so many maps for my friends to play with, over ~4years of actively playing the game and then... reforged hits...
i dont feel like collecting all 600+ maps again... Rest in peace people's creativity and effort
I never "upgraded" to Reforged, so I can still enjoy the actual WC3 experience.
I was forced too :(
I don't get it because the Starcraft remaster was fantastic, it kept the gameplay and charm of the original game; and it also improved exactly on ONLY what needed to be improved - the presentation and way of running on modern systems. They didn't replace the voice acting for no reason, nor mess with the story (e.g. add an SC2 character inexplicably into the SP1 campaign for no reason)
So on the whole the SC1 remaster was incredible. Playing it on my 4k 48.5" monitor honestly made me feel like an 11 year old boy playing the single player again for the first ever time. They say playing a good remaster, should be like playing the original game as you remember it in your 11 year old brain, and that's what it was like.
But there was still the good old cut corners, LAN play crashes out more than it works, and the singleplayer skirmish is an afterthought of an afterthought - you can't play a 2 v 2, you and a PC vs 2 PC players; you have to start a LAN game 3 or 4 times (to get past the crashes), start a multiplayer LAN game, add the allied/enemy computer players you want, then hope the game starts without crashing. All because Blizzard couldn't be bothered to put more than the melee option in the single player "custom game" options screen.
So it's baffling about this WC3 reforged. It should have been made just like SC remastered - redo the art assets, textures, map geometry, maybe some balance updates - look at AOE2:DE which is a fantastic remaster. Or the C&C remaster - which is literally just a visual overhall - you still have the ancient 20+ year old gameplay and mechanics of the very first real RTS came ever made, C&C1 - but people were still happy with the C&C remaster because it did exactly what it was marketed to do - present you C&C and Red Alert, exactly as your childhood brain remembered it when it came out back in the mid 1990's.
Cuz when other games got remastered, their remasters are separate products from original ones, unlike Warcraft 3
It is rather weird. They put the bar so high that EA went full blast on the C&C Remaster. Swallowing their pride and approaching the westwood Alumni studio Petroglyph to handle the coding, approaching the same artists at Lemon Sky who updated Starcraft's graphics for C&C and even getting Kucan for a quick few promotional videos as Kane. Returning hope to a franchise that was believed as dead and beaten a dead horse could be.
All because of SC:R and yet.... THIS happened...
There is also a version of reality where they actually went good on the promise to change things in a coherent manner, and we got a different version of warcraft 3 with significant but well integrated changes.
The disaster wasn't in the vision itself. It was in every single step of that execution, from beginning to end.
Warlords Battlecry 3 mods are living long and strong!
I'm so happy you included the Blizzcon gameplay footage. A group of my friends and I went to that one (our first and last as we ended up swearing off Blizzard forever after years of being die-hard fans after that) and were raving about how excited we were for it only for the final product to be so insanely far from what we were promised.
I was one of those that I feel they were aiming for. I missed warcraft where my introduction of its lore was through friends, Hearthstone and HOTS. Quite curious I binged some videos and stories to get up to speed, but still curious to play. Yet so many red flags popping up while friends said it was normal. This is fine. Don't worry(and so on). Further deepening my stance of waiting till after launch to buy games, seeing the shit show around everything made me briefly smug on matters. Then felt terrible for those invested in this, forever destroyed a legendary part of not just one franchise or company. But a benchmark as well as historical greatness in games past. I have checked off anything from blizzard for awhile, I just hope more players find a better game studio. Blizzard is long dead with Activision pulling more and more strings. Just like other beloved studios that fell in recent memory.
Used to love playing the custom mode 'Gladiator', getting a full team of people for that and fighting the AI, grabbing upgrades was so much fun.
Original dubbing for non english version was lost aswell, also visually Reforged is also frankly just repulsive, its as illconceived and horrible approach as everything else about it. It may be detailed but it looks nothing like original game and is an insult to Samwise Didier's work on the original game. What we should've gotten is exacly the same as Starcraft Remastered and have just refined version of original visuals on same animations and artstyle, something that was partially done in Starcraft II, as War3HD asset package.
Also i can blame some....Brian Sousa was an utter moron and completely unfit to be an artlead, with very bad and disrepectful outlook on warcraft III, mocking it on every occassion. He only done a decent job with SC:R because he was FORCED to do it faithfully, and complained about it during his GDC panel presentation also showing lots of disrespectful remarks about it and og artists aswell...
Yeah the sad thing is, there is way two many people out there like Brian Sousa. Who don't respect the works of others. Who think they are hotshot creators but in the end, more often than not the truth is they are just leeches who can only leech off the success of others or merely destroy things beloved by many. Along with questioning, who the heck idea was it to leave this person in charge of something they clearly give zero care about?
@@tacticianAlexandra Sadly...he also jumped off the ship before launch to pretend he quits game dev business to just merily go to another company. Consequences are incredibly severe as game looks nothing like it should, tousands of hours of effort got wasted on completely wrong approach to remaking the games assets and it split the community of warcraft in a very polarized and mutually exclusive way. Instead of seeing and enjoying one and the same game just at various fidelity settings its like 2 totally different games one beig uprooted by the newer "definitive" depiction...
This SO MUCH. Not enough people talk about the completely butchered artstyle for some reason. Reforged looks absolutely awful in comparison to the original artstyle. Completely mismatching, not fitting and frankly an insult, like you said.
@@arkaua Glad i aint alone with this :)
I am quite annoyed by people calling them "good". In vaccum as some assets for blizzard's take on Assasin's Creed or Shadow of Mordor when well animated they could be "impresive" but here being so agggrrssively not warcraft iii nor even Warcraft overall(since it doesnt even look like WoW which is closest to wc3 in its artstyle also being drawn and matte). Even spell effects are awful.
All of it being both uglier and far less readable than og art. Level up for instance doesnt have the same glow and brightness as itvdid in wc3 and wow, and are weirdly animated. If anything wc3 should have a mild detail bump to something slightly above WoW Classic keeping the style and animations.
@Magne M It was but it aint the main reason why it tuend out so bad. Its the Art lead they just done what he wanted of them. They done semi decent job for Overwatch and Starcraft Remastered so its not like they couldnt do good job and be faithful to the design and artstyle of og game. It's all on that slimeball Brian Sousa...
Activision Blizzard started hunting for that E-Sports gravy train thinking their name could carry them to glory. They forgot that the reason they had a good name was because people enjoyed playing their games. I played BW for years - thousands of games and less than 100 ladder games. Custom maps were where it was at and where the community resided. Admittedly though, I'd pick up W3 if it wasn't 30$. I bought it when it was new on shelves, not paying half the original retail value for a game that old. Hell, at least allow me to put my CDKey on block chain in exchange for a new copy of Reforged.
Activision Blizzard wants to hunt for these e-sports that have these 10-20 year long-term grass roots competitive communities (Dota, CS, League, SC) overnight. It's a long term investment that takes making a good game first lol. A game being a popular e-sport not up to them, it up to the fans and the gamers. They aren't the only ones who do this, but the companies that try to establish an e-sport from day one is very naive, you don't know if it's going to catch on and you don't know if its going to be something entertaining for the viewers. Overwatch is a great example of this. It's a great and fun game, it's a clusterfuck to watch a competitive match. It has the worst aspects of a MOBA and FPS in a game that you can't follow at all what's going on.
Ikr I don't know why companies try to hunt for an eSports scene BEFORE cementing a popular, competitive and actually fun game
This one hurt. I was at least somewhat excited for this, which is extremely rare as I've been depressed for years. I just wanted some childhood nostalgia. Blizzard is truly dead, and not just to me.