TAKE TIME TO READ..... Sejun and Josh are on the same timeline (2019). Justin's time stamp is in the past (2009). While Ken and Stell is in the future (2034). STELL - He likes the girl but unfortunately, the girl is in a relationship with someone else. Before the couple leaves the coffee shop, Stell already accepted his fate. JOSH - He is still stuck up with his past relationship. He gave the red tie to the kid which happens to be the daughter of his past lover. KEN - He obviously likes the girl but the girl likes someone else from the same gender. Ken's graffiti wall art contains the lgbt color, that explains everything. And Ken likes a girl which happens to be the daughter of Josh's past lover. The girl is wearing the red tie that Josh gave when the girl was still young. JUSTIN - He was about to confessed but he did not continue because the girl showed a Scholarship Certificate for Senior High School ABROAD ( so the girl is leaving very soon ) Justin's love is freeing. SEJUN - His part is the most painful one. It tackles about death. Anguish. Sejun and Justin were classmates back in Junior High School days. Justin is included in the photo card that Sejun's holding including both of their Love Interest. 2015 their Batch had a Reunion sadly they met an accident as per the news (news paper) ONLY ONE DIED and it was Sejun's love interest who died. So, 4 years after the tragedy but Sejun is still in pain (2015 Reunion tragedy happened and his timeline is 2019)
@@jhnlrlolvr6410 they we're classmate way back 2009 (which is the timeline of Justin's story just take a look on the part where his writing his Love Letter there's a Date there and it shows 2009 as the year) but Sejun's timeline when he's in his bedroom and crying that's 2019 just watch it again there's a 2019 calendar on the wall inside his bedroom, i hope you get my point :)
Ok so here's the trick: 1. Notice the order of the member's turn in the song first... Every member's turn resembles their Animé character... That's how you would indentify them individually... 2. Take note of the timeline of the boys: - Justin, Sejun, and Josh shared the same timeline (2009 - 2019) - Ken and Stell are of the same timeline (2034) 3. Their Love Interest: - Justin = Allysa who was granted a Scholarship abroad.. - Sejun - Constantine who died on a tragedy during their reunion... - Josh = Athena, a childhood sweetheart who had a family already. - Stell = Unknown but someone who fell on somebody. - Ken = daughter of Athena, The little Girl whom Josh met on the street (gave her a bracelet) ALL OF THIS!!! Non would have matter without the brain of Justin de Dios... His creativity in storyline making is unparalleled... What brilliant young man 👏👏👏 Ofcourse, Pinuno's songwriting prowess is beyond compare... Absolutely brilliant!!!
Notice also how the names are created it was not just a random name Constantine,Alyssa Kristine,and Athena all of it resembles ATIN, so basically it's us who they love so much hanggang sa huli constAnTINe - A'TIN is in the name itself Alyssa krisTINe - ATIN is in the name Athena sounds like ATIN(pronuounced in Filipino) So, if you becomes emotional for the story of the MV, don't ever leave SB19 they deserved to be loved.
every perspective in this mv has their own story connected to the other sb19 songs Tilaluha- Stell is in a coffee shop, it is where tilaluha started on the breakup scene Go Up- Justin's lover pursue her dreams by going ti her dream school which where she got her scholarship Alab- The spray can ken is using on his graffiti art is the colors in alab and also the part where his pre chorus line where he used black spray can, u can see the colors. Hanggang sa Huli- Josh's childhood friend/lover already had a family, and accepted it. Love Goes- Sejun's mourning for her lover.
KEEP STREAMING!!🥺💙 The Hanggang sa huli animated MV deserves 1M Views.. Tips: •Share to your friends(even though they are not a fan of sb19) •share to facebook, twitter,Instgram (The link) •Use alot of phones or use your mom's , dad's , sisters, brother's phone
Like what Josh said, they do not want to spoon feed their fans with all the details about this MV. So yeah, we had to do our home work. And now everyone has his/her own theories. Hahahaha
Yes, the cafe scenes were 2034. The park scenes were 2019. The tragedy happened in 2015. The classroom setting was 2009. They chose 2034 because: 2034 - 2015 = 19...as in SB19.
Take time to READ (this is not a theory) Notice that on the last part of the MV , Stell smiled when he saw his love interest going with another man, Josh smiled when he saw his past lover, Ken smiled to his love interest, Justin smiled on the chair of his love interest even she aren't there, and Sejun smiled on the heaven for his past lover that has been died in the tragedy. This explains so much, "My love for you is 'til the end" , "Pag-ibig ko'y sayo, sayo Hanggang sa huli" , they still love their past lovers and love interests even they left them. That's our boys, that's SB19 💗
I love the fact that #SB19 did not spoon feed us and letting us to use our creative minds. They know that A'Tin are smart enough to understand the whole story of this MV. I stan genius Idols and FAMDOM! 💙🥰
Stell's story is also sad because the rest of the boys had an impact on the life of their crushes but for Stell? He's just a stranger who never had a chance to even be part of it.
This is my theory... I will start with Justin. He has a crush on Aly (the girl in violet hair). Justin is about to confess his feeling to the girl but it's too late because Aly with go abroad for her to get scholarship. Justin and Sejun are friends/classmates. Justin is also the the picture that Sejun is holding. They are both from the past (2009). Sejun is crying because his love died in an accident. The news paper said "Reunion, ended in tragedy" year 2015. That time Sejun and his friends had a reunion and there is an accident happened. It says "1 died, 4 injured" and that 1 is the girl that Sejun loves. As you see at the end, Sejun is on wheelchair because he's also at the reunion and he got injured. Sejun is at the same bus with Josh (year 2019). You will see Josh at the back of Sejun in Bus scene. Josh visited the playground where he and Athena (Josh's love/childhood bestfriend) used to play. When he visited the playground, he saw the tree that he carved says "Josh ≠ Athena Forever". Josh saw a little girl playing a ball. Josh gave the bracelet/string to the little girl. When the little girl goes back to his mom, Josh saw the bracelet of her mom that same as his bracelet. He saw that his childhood bestfriend already have a family. Year 2034, that little girl grew up which became Ken's Crush. When Ken visited the cafe, he saw the girl with someone else that's why he got jealous. Did you notice that the girl has the red bracelet that Josh gave to her? Ken and Stell is at the same year (year 2034) that is why Ken and Stell met at the cafe. Stell is the one that is working at the cafe. He saw his crush at the cafe. Stell knows the her favorite spot that is why he always leave a letter at that spot. At the time when Stell already wants to confess his feeling, he found out that the girl have a boyfriend already. But at the end, he still shows that he's happy for the girl. I don't know what happened to Justin after that but i have a feeling that Aly (Justin's crush) is the mom of Stell because of the glasses that he's wearing.
The sad part in love is that you know you're not really meant for each other that's why you're letting them go. But you know what's the worst part is? It is the part knowing that you can't have the chance to be with the one you love, because she's dead. Feels like all of the chances you may have were removed because you were not in the same world anymore, she's resting in peace above but you're still there mourning for her loss.
My Theory Different Timeline 2009- Sejun and Justin are Classmates (Aly is the one that Justin like but he did not confess his feelings because Aly got the Scholarship) 2015- They have a reunion but it ends with a tragidy (Constantine Died (the one that Sejun's Like) (Justin did not die because on the newspaper only 1 died and I assume it's Constantine. 2019- present time of Sejun and Josh. Sejun and Josh met at the Bus Scene. Josh saw the Child of Athena (the that he like but it's too late because she has already have a child and husband) Josh gave a Red Bracelet that looks like a ribbon 2034- present time of Ken and Stell. The one that Ken like is the Daughter of Athena (that's why she has a red bracelet) but the girl that Ken likes also like a girl so basically she's a lesbian And for Stell it's too late for him because the one that he like have already a Boyfriend 😭
The MV gave the word "Coincidence" a whole new meaning. I hope they make a Real Life version of this after the Pandemic. It would be amazing to see them showcase their acting skills. (I had to rewatch it, and with the help of the amazing A'TIN's theory, I get to understand the timelines and appreciate it even more..😊 Thank you) Kudos toJustin, Sejun, Stell, Josh and Ken (my bias)❤
my interpretation.. 2009 (date on letter given to Jah) - Jah, Alyssa (Jah's love interest), Sejun, Constantine (Sejun's love interest) and friends, were still in Junior High (shown on the photo Sejun was looking at). Also, Jah was about to confess to Alyssa, but Alyssa was moving out of the country because of the scholarship. 2015 (date on newspaper) - tragedy happened at a reunion as headlined on the newspaper Sejun was crying on.. 1 died (probably Constantine) and others are critically injured as per news article. Sejun was later shown as a crippled man. 2019 (date on sejun's calendar) - sejun is still mourning about the tragedy.. it is the same year as josh' story as seen when he passed behind Sejun on the bus scene. Josh went to his and Athena's old meeting place marked with 'Josh and Athena Forever' then a ball hit Josh' back and he saw a child. He gave that child the red string to find out that the child's mother was actually Athena because of the red string she was also wearing. There are color references on the children playing in the playground on Josh' flashback, with what they are wearing in their present day.. Josh - Red and Athena - Green 2034 (date on Stell's note) - Stell is in love with a girl but was never reciprocated. It turned out that the girl already had someone else. Ken went to Stell's coffee shop and saw his love interest with another girl and they seem to have a romantic relationship. The girl had the red string. With the timeline, she is possibly Athena's (Josh' love) daughter. but in the end, they all chose to accept their fate and love 'hanggang sa huli' (until the end).. i hope i got it right though :)
THE MV IS SAID TO BE CREATED CONFUSING SO THE AUDIENCE themselves WILL TRY TO FIGURE OUT WHAT IS REALLY GOING on,, the MV is indeed deep. SB19 is genius
Every Music Video Concept of SB19 are in connected, Notice the strings of Josh's Red Zone in Alab, You'll notice a string bracelet in Hanggang Sa Huli that was red too. I discover that the theory of Love Goes MV soon will be much connected on Sejun's story of HSH Music Video. The Elegy of Constantine.
Hi kpopsis. Just wanna share my take on the MV. 2009 (past) -- Justin and Sejun are classmates. You can see in the journal written by justin, the date was 2009. Justin loved this girl but choose to not confess to not be a hindrance to her scholarship. 2019 (present) --- Sejun was seen on his bed and was reminiscing the past. Turns out while they are going to their reunion there was an accident that caused the death of his classmates (this may include justin) and his loved one. He went to the memorial of his lover while riding a bus (he can no longer walk) and you can see here that Sejun and Josh was riding the same bus (you can see Josh passing by at the back while Sejun was looking out bus window). Josh on the other hand was visiting her childhood sweetheart which was Athena, maybe to confess his feelings but he have known that his love was already married (which can be justin as well if he didn't die in the reunion accident). So he gave his red string like bracelet to his childhood sweetheart's daughter. 2034 (future) -- Ken likes this girl who turns out to be that daughter of Athena who was Josh's childhood sweetheart, the one Josh gave a bracelet. While Ken was on the cafè where Stell is working he saw that the the girl he likes is with someone already. He gave up his love but still protected her when she was harassed. Stell was on the same timeline as Ken, works at a coffee shop and can't confess his feelings for this girl until that unfaithful day where she was already with someone else.. he gave her one coffee all the time but that time he made two for her. Turns out it was not meant for him.
This suddenly pop on my mind. I think Josh made a promise to Athena that he will come back to her when he is successful. Unfortunately, when the time comes that he comes back to their place being successful (I think he is a CEO) Athena already had a family
I like how Justin designed it to be interesting and deep at the same time. It was made where you need to watch it multiple times to see all the clues and get all the viewers give their own interpretation/theory basing on the what lil' hints they saw. It was fun during the premier, Twitter was full of clues,banter,theories and what not. Feel free to interpret it as well. As they said during their fb live, enjoy the MV and make our own assumptions. Thank you for supporting our boys! Loves lots from a fellow kapatid 💙
You're one of the few real reactors who really spend time to analyze the behind story of each members in this MV. I did appreciate how you really translated the Filipino words into English. I'm actually surprised cause the the power of Atin was so overwhelming that they came up with many theories and even every single detail was spotted. Lol. Thank you so much as always, #KPopSis♥️ #SB19HSHMV
HOPE THIS HELPS since most of the pips in the comment sections know how each member story goes, lets do the timeline base on how I understand the MV, do correct me if you guys think I made a mistake so that all of us can be enlighten in the story. (2009) = Justin and Sejun are batchmates/Classmates with their crush/love interest (girl w/ glasses for Justin and girl with bangs for Sejun) (2015) = when the tragic happened during their reunion during night time at 7 pm, but it says on the newspaper that only 1 died (Sejun crush/love interest), and four others are badly injured/wounded. So it's safe to assume that Sejun is one of those that got injured, and (Justin crush/love interest) is not present for she traveled overseas for the scholarship. The mystery here is where is Justin in the present? Coz I'm pretty sure the last shot of Justin is still in the past. (2019)? = Josh and Sejun are on the same bus, Josh gets dropped first in the playground and reminisce the days he have with his crush/love interest only to find out that she already have a family. He gave the red bracelet to the kid where she and her mom matches, (safe to assume in the past they maybe lovers). It's just a theory, but I guess josh story is different from the other members, he did confess his love and they got together, I'm assuming he has to work overseas or far away, what he failed to do is to proposed to his love one, and when he got back it's too late. Sejun on the other hand went to the place where the accident takes place, and gives respects to his crush/love interest and tried to move on with a smile. I'm assuming the other pictures on the trees represents other passengers that died in the accident. but you see in the news it only said 1 died, but take note the newspaper only covered those who attended the reunion, perhaps there's another vehicle or other passengers. (2034) = Stell is a barista and Ken is a street artist/fighter haha, I'm assuming again that Stell put different notes or quotes to brighten up the day of his crush/love interest, but on the day she could have read the note that Stell likes her, she didn't got the chance to read it for that day she came w/ her BF. Ken on the other hand saw his crush/ love interest with another girl in the coffee shop with the red bracelet, thus we all agree in the theory and assume that Ken's crush/love interest is the daughter of Josh ex lover Athena. main theme of the story? well all members didn't have the chance to say how much they love their crush/love interest, but just like the lyrics said, nothing will change and they will keep loving them hanggang sa huli (until the end).
Sejun's girl/crush died in an accident The woman josh loved is already married. Ken's crush is lesbian Justin's crush got a schoolarship abroad. And justin still didn't confess his feeling to the girl. The girl stell fell in love with already have a boyfriend. Sorry for my english. By the way love your reaction😊
HSH MV - Josh childhood friend/love is already married and have a happy family. - Ken's crush/love is a lesbian. - Stell, he likes a girl but when he already decided to confessed his feelings towards her, the girl is already in a relationship. - Justin is ready to confess his feelings towards her classmate/bestfriend but he don't want to be a hindrance to her dreams. - Sejun's girl is already dead because of an accident/tragedy, the reason why he can't walk.
Hanggang sa huli's mv is so addicting. The more you watch it the more you understands the story. Kudos to all behind this music video. Especially the one who did the storyline of the video, it really left us all thinking.
Finally!!! A reaction vid from my favorite reactors!! Thank you, Meagan and Brianna!!! We all are proud of SB19. And thank you for supporting PPop Music. I love you both! Stay safe always and God bless!
To us Filipinos who understood tagalog, we easily cried the first time we saw that part where the newspaper was shown. The literal translation of the headline was "REUNION ENDED IN TRAGEDY" Additionally, upon loser inspection of the article, it said "...one died, four are in critical condition..." Sejun, Jah and the rest were obviously critical to the point that Sejun ended up being unable to walk anymore, hence he's on a wheelchair. Aside from the obvious heartbreaks, the MV would seem shallow or even confusing at first glance, but there's also that nagging feeling that the video is not as simple as it seems, that it has some things hidden in plain view. There is a deeper, more profound story that interconnected all 5 of the men in the video. Sejun called it "Easter Eggs" during their livestream countdown for the MV's premiere. To those who do not know Justin's tendencies, he loves devicing this kind of stuff. You need to really focus on the details here as well in order to notice who's with who. In fact, Sejun and Josh were together in one scene, but it was deliberately obscure. (Pay close attention. Try to guess which scene~) All of A'TIN spent the whole night yesterday tearing the clues apart to understand the timeline. There are 4 distinctive time points here. And we all eventually built up the story.
Stell has a long crush on a customer who happens to have a boyfriend. Ken has a secret crush on a girl pal. Where in they just can't to be together. Sejun attended a reunion where in it ended in tragedy that causes the life of his girl and friends and made him crippled. Josh went back to I guess their hometown after many years looking for her love who happens to have a family already. He was not able to confess his love. Justin had a crush on his classmate and when he was ready to confess his feelings her classmat moved out of the town for she got a scholarship somewhere.
The kid in Josh's scene is the daughter of the girl she likes, look at the red bracelette that they both have. the girl she likes has her own family when he came back.
As you can see, in sejun's room there are crampled papers. I just remembered the alab mv, in sejun's part. His theme was crampled papers also and he's sitting on that, i think the story was really connected. That color was violet also which signifies death. And sejun'd wardrobe was also the same. The reunion, turned into tragedy- that somehow connected to Love Goes story. All in all, sejun's story was really impactful and painful Just a theory of mine.
The characters in the MV are SB19 members. Each of them tackles heart breaks in different forms crossing different time lines. Starting from the past. Sejun and Justin exist in the past(2009) where apparently they're classmates who fall in love with their friends in the same circle(6 members in total as seen in the photo held by Sejun) but never get to confessed their feelings for reasons that Aly,Justin's love interest needs to go away to study somewhere,and Sejun's because she died in an accident in 2015 for their reunion,and four left injured including Justin and Sejun where he's seen seated on a wheelchair at the end of the video. Aly,apparently wasnt involved in the accident bec.she had moved away. Now present exists where Josh is seen coming back to his childhood place reminisces his young love and visits the place where his never-died love continues. He stumbles upon a young girl who happens to be his never-died love's child. He hands over the promised/couple red thread bracelet to the girl before she goes back to her parents,and the focus pans to the wrist of the mother (Athena,etched on the tree with Josh's name) wearing the same exact bracelet. Josh realises that his love is never coming back as Athena is already settled and happy,so he stretches a subtle smile as his goodbye. Future then comes(2034,shown on Stell's note)where Stell who works as a barista happens to fall for one of their customers,the catch is he has to let go of his feelings as the girl is already taken. Ken as seen making art graffiti is in love with someone who's in love with the same gender,and as a twist of fate,the girl he likes is the child of Athena-Josh's love,she's seen wearing the bracelet Josh gifted her when they met accidentally 19 yrs ago(2015-2034). Ken's graffitis are festooned with different colors with the word LOVE as the main theme/subject that gives a hint that love knows no gender. If you watch the video again,youll realize how the story is well-thought out,how even small details intertwine the five's destiny.#StanSB19❤
Let me tell u guys it's not my first time, I've watched this reaction video for the nth time i dunno why. I just love them. One of my favorite reactors.
Every details of a single frame in this music video has meanings, Justin did really great for directing this MV, it makes you wanna watch it again and again.
What I like this MV of hanggang sa huli is that u have to come up some theory to understand everyone story, and that so genius idea!! Actually this MV tackles every kind of love!! Especially love is no gender!
Been waiting your reaction to be uploaded since yesterday and I promised myself to watch it after streaming hanggang sa huli. So, here I am witnessing your genuine reactions of the mv and yeah I am as confused as you guys when I first watch the video 😅 P.S. I'm still figuring out some scenes too
We feel you. Per Justin and Josh during their Facebook live minutes before the MV premier, they made it that way so we could re-watch and figure things out. They know A'Tin are smart and keen observants.
In this MV, SB19 waken up our investigative skills. You need a sharp eyes to cope up in every details. Like to the transition of dates, the newspaper, admission paper, Jah love letter, the calendar that hang on Sejun's room and to the different kind flowers, the red string bracelet wore by Josh, Athena, and the boyish young lady. And also to the Sejun mug with printed heart, same to the heart that Ken printed to his graffitti and many more.😁 Oh I forgot, In Stell post it note, the date of it is his birthday, imagine, on your birthday you're brokenhearted.😁
Justin really likes to play with us Hahaha. Justin is so creative and he also made us confuse. All the story are connected but still made us think how, its because the scenes are not connected or cut i guess. Justin wants to test us. He is still finding the best answers from A'Tin.
There is no theory. It's just stories of love, heartaches, and acceptance. Justin: Studies over love 💙 Sejun: Lost of a loved one 💙 Josh: Past love that is somehow still connected to him 💙 Ken: Liked/love someone who is a lesbian (may never like him back) 💙 Stell: The person he likes already have someone else. 💙 Maybe some are just confused of the timelines and scene transitions. Scene timelines: Justin and Sejun were classmates year 2009 Sejun and Josh year 2019 Ken and Stell year 2034
PLS NOTICE THIS IS THE ANSWER ON THE STORY PUZZLE 2009 *Justin and Sejun are classmates *The girl Justin likes transfered to another school 2015 *Reunion *Sejun's gf died *Sejun got paralyzed because of the accident 2019 *Josh's childhood first love has a family *Sejun's still in pain due to the loss of his gf 2034 *the woman Stell wants already has a bf *the woman Ken wants is a lesbian *the girl Ken likes is the child of Josh's childhood
Is it just me or did anyone noticed another easter egg I found in the form of the knapsack in Pinunong Sejun's room and in the classroom of Director and writter Justin? which only proves that Sejun and Justin are Highschool classmates and at the same time line.
Justin's last appearance was dating back in 2009. Sejun's was in 2019 but he's in most part of the timeline since he appeared in 2009 as High school student in the same class as Justin. In 2015 where he grieved over the death of his crush and in 2019 where he moved on. Josh appeared in the 2019 timeline. Ken and Stell lived in the 2034 timeline where it is speculated that Athena's, Josh's crush, daughter is Ken's crush.
I like your reaction Kpopsis. You have your discussions and exchanging of ideas. How I wish I also have someone to discuss about the MV theories with me.
The Music Video story is about 5 different individual of love with sacrifice. STELL - a barista who is in love with regular customer girl that has already have a boyfriend.💔 JUSTIN - who is in love with his classmate that is already accepted to other school and will no longer his classmate.💔 KEN - who is in love to a girl he saved from a thug and found out she is a tomboy.❤🩹 JOSH - who is in love to a girl in his hometown and when he made visit found out that the girl has already married and have kid.❤🩹 PABLO - who is in love to a girl who died in an accident with him but he managed to survive but disable.💔
TAKE TIME TO READ.....
Sejun and Josh are on the same timeline (2019). Justin's time stamp is in the past (2009). While Ken and Stell is in the future (2034).
STELL - He likes the girl but unfortunately, the girl is in a relationship with someone else. Before the couple leaves the coffee shop, Stell already accepted his fate.
JOSH - He is still stuck up with his past relationship. He gave the red tie to the kid which happens to be the daughter of his past lover.
KEN - He obviously likes the girl but the girl likes someone else from the same gender. Ken's graffiti wall art contains the lgbt color, that explains everything.
And Ken likes a girl which happens to be the daughter of Josh's past lover. The girl is wearing the red tie that Josh gave when the girl was still young.
JUSTIN - He was about to confessed but he did not continue because the girl showed a Scholarship Certificate for Senior High School ABROAD ( so the girl is leaving very soon ) Justin's love is freeing.
SEJUN - His part is the most painful one. It tackles about death. Anguish.
Sejun and Justin were classmates back in Junior High School days. Justin is included in the photo card that Sejun's holding including both of their Love Interest.
2015 their Batch had a Reunion sadly they met an accident as per the news (news paper) ONLY ONE DIED and it was Sejun's love interest who died.
So, 4 years after the tragedy but Sejun is still in pain (2015 Reunion tragedy happened and his timeline is 2019)
Jah and sejun are classmate6
@@jhnlrlolvr6410 they we're classmate way back 2009 (which is the timeline of Justin's story just take a look on the part where his writing his Love Letter there's a Date there and it shows 2009 as the year) but Sejun's timeline when he's in his bedroom and crying that's 2019 just watch it again there's a 2019 calendar on the wall inside his bedroom, i hope you get my point :)
Up para makita ng iba
Up
I did cry on sejuns' part. It still hurt. The MV is indeed great and so touching.
Ok so here's the trick:
1. Notice the order of the member's turn in the song first... Every member's turn resembles their Animé character... That's how you would indentify them individually...
2. Take note of the timeline of the boys:
- Justin, Sejun, and Josh shared the same timeline (2009 - 2019)
- Ken and Stell are of the same timeline (2034)
3. Their Love Interest:
- Justin = Allysa who was granted a Scholarship abroad..
- Sejun - Constantine who died on a tragedy during their reunion...
- Josh = Athena, a childhood sweetheart who had a family already.
- Stell = Unknown but someone who fell on somebody.
- Ken = daughter of Athena, The little Girl whom Josh met on the street (gave her a bracelet)
ALL OF THIS!!! Non would have matter without the brain of Justin de Dios... His creativity in storyline making is unparalleled... What brilliant young man 👏👏👏
Ofcourse, Pinuno's songwriting prowess is beyond compare... Absolutely brilliant!!!
Notice also how the names are created it was not just a random name
Constantine,Alyssa Kristine,and Athena all of it resembles ATIN, so basically it's us who they love so much hanggang sa huli
constAnTINe - A'TIN is in the name itself
Alyssa krisTINe - ATIN is in the name
Athena sounds like ATIN(pronuounced in Filipino)
So, if you becomes emotional for the story of the MV, don't ever leave SB19 they deserved to be loved.
Yeah right👌
Well anyway for me the first thing i notice is JOSH got TALL.. Hahakk👏👏👏👏 NICE one JUSTIN
Ang husay talaga ni BUNSO dun
@@mang-jose i prefer it to be
Alyssa- alay sa
Athena- atin
Constantine hermosa- constantly beautiful
woah i thought they are in the same time line,i didn't knew than🤯🤯🤯
@@12araratchristinejune50 nope hehez, sb19 is really good
They made it that way since they know A'TIN were intelligent enough to come up with theories.
yes definitely!
Exactly 💙🙌
every perspective in this mv has their own story connected to the other sb19 songs
Tilaluha- Stell is in a coffee shop, it is where tilaluha started on the breakup scene
Go Up- Justin's lover pursue her dreams by going ti her dream school which where she got her scholarship
Alab- The spray can ken is using on his graffiti art is the colors in alab and also the part where his pre chorus line where he used black spray can, u can see the colors.
Hanggang sa Huli- Josh's childhood friend/lover already had a family, and accepted it.
Love Goes- Sejun's mourning for her lover.
wow galing, grabe ang sb19 pinapatheory talaga tayo sumakit tuloy yung ulo ko ng konti..at tsaka hindi ko naisip yan
Ah kaya pala may Huling Kabanata na nakalagay sa teaser photo nila. Wow
same naisip ko tlga connected ung mga songs nila d2 pero on point ung sayu.
Grabe ngayon ko lang 'toh narealize ayst
@Schnook Schneider lmaoooo ang kaibahan lang wala akong bangs
KEEP STREAMING!!🥺💙
The Hanggang sa huli animated MV deserves 1M Views..
Tips:
•Share to your friends(even though they are not a fan of sb19)
•share to facebook, twitter,Instgram (The link)
•Use alot of phones or use your mom's , dad's , sisters, brother's phone
Like what Josh said, they do not want to spoon feed their fans with all the details about this MV. So yeah, we had to do our home work. And now everyone has his/her own theories. Hahahaha
That's what makes it interesting, kaya na shookt talaga ako
Everyone feels the same way😊
Maaaa thats true ! Amazing Mv
Yes, the cafe scenes were 2034. The park scenes were 2019. The tragedy happened in 2015. The classroom setting was 2009. They chose 2034 because:
2034 - 2015 = 19...as in SB19.
Wait what- i need time to process this
Take time to READ (this is not a theory)
Notice that on the last part of the MV , Stell smiled when he saw his love interest going with another man, Josh smiled when he saw his past lover, Ken smiled to his love interest, Justin smiled on the chair of his love interest even she aren't there, and Sejun smiled on the heaven for his past lover that has been died in the tragedy.
This explains so much, "My love for you is 'til the end" , "Pag-ibig ko'y sayo, sayo Hanggang sa huli" , they still love their past lovers and love interests even they left them. That's our boys, that's SB19 💗
"Omygod, is that the sexiest man in the philippines?" idk but i laughed so hard here
I love the fact that #SB19 did not spoon feed us and letting us to use our creative minds. They know that A'Tin are smart enough to understand the whole story of this MV. I stan genius Idols and FAMDOM! 💙🥰
Stell's story is also sad because the rest of the boys had an impact on the life of their crushes but for Stell? He's just a stranger who never had a chance to even be part of it.
A'TIN kaway kaway👋 nood kayo react vid para trending HSH ng SB19 hehe💙🤘
THE SONG IS ALL ABOUT ACCEPTANCE, THAT'S WHAT SEJUN SAID AND THAT IS WHAT IS SHOWN IN THIS VIDEO
This is my theory...
I will start with Justin. He has a crush on Aly (the girl in violet hair). Justin is about to confess his feeling to the girl but it's too late because Aly with go abroad for her to get scholarship. Justin and Sejun are friends/classmates. Justin is also the the picture that Sejun is holding. They are both from the past (2009). Sejun is crying because his love died in an accident. The news paper said "Reunion, ended in tragedy" year 2015. That time Sejun and his friends had a reunion and there is an accident happened. It says "1 died, 4 injured" and that 1 is the girl that Sejun loves. As you see at the end, Sejun is on wheelchair because he's also at the reunion and he got injured. Sejun is at the same bus with Josh (year 2019). You will see Josh at the back of Sejun in Bus scene. Josh visited the playground where he and Athena (Josh's love/childhood bestfriend) used to play. When he visited the playground, he saw the tree that he carved says "Josh ≠ Athena Forever". Josh saw a little girl playing a ball. Josh gave the bracelet/string to the little girl. When the little girl goes back to his mom, Josh saw the bracelet of her mom that same as his bracelet. He saw that his childhood bestfriend already have a family. Year 2034, that little girl grew up which became Ken's Crush. When Ken visited the cafe, he saw the girl with someone else that's why he got jealous. Did you notice that the girl has the red bracelet that Josh gave to her? Ken and Stell is at the same year (year 2034) that is why Ken and Stell met at the cafe. Stell is the one that is working at the cafe. He saw his crush at the cafe. Stell knows the her favorite spot that is why he always leave a letter at that spot. At the time when Stell already wants to confess his feeling, he found out that the girl have a boyfriend already. But at the end, he still shows that he's happy for the girl. I don't know what happened to Justin after that but i have a feeling that Aly (Justin's crush) is the mom of Stell because of the glasses that he's wearing.
The sad part in love is that you know you're not really meant for each other that's why you're letting them go. But you know what's the worst part is? It is the part knowing that you can't have the chance to be with the one you love, because she's dead. Feels like all of the chances you may have were removed because you were not in the same world anymore, she's resting in peace above but you're still there mourning for her loss.
Why are you being so deep? Now you made me hella sad 😭😭😭😭😭😭
;(((((
My Theory
Different Timeline
2009- Sejun and Justin are Classmates (Aly is the one that Justin like but he did not confess his feelings because Aly got the Scholarship)
2015- They have a reunion but it ends with a tragidy (Constantine Died (the one that Sejun's Like)
(Justin did not die because on the newspaper only 1 died and I assume it's Constantine.
2019- present time of Sejun and Josh. Sejun and Josh met at the Bus Scene. Josh saw the Child of Athena (the that he like but it's too late because she has already have a child and husband) Josh gave a Red Bracelet that looks like a ribbon
2034- present time of Ken and Stell. The one that Ken like is the Daughter of Athena (that's why she has a red bracelet) but the girl that Ken likes also like a girl so basically she's a lesbian
And for Stell it's too late for him because the one that he like have already a Boyfriend 😭
The MV gave the word "Coincidence" a whole new meaning. I hope they make a Real Life version of this after the Pandemic. It would be amazing to see them showcase their acting skills.
(I had to rewatch it, and with the help of the amazing A'TIN's theory, I get to understand the timelines and appreciate it even more..😊 Thank you)
Kudos toJustin, Sejun, Stell, Josh and Ken (my bias)❤
I’M NOT CRYING, YOU’RE CRYING... let’s be real here, we’re both crying :”)
my interpretation..
2009 (date on letter given to Jah) - Jah, Alyssa (Jah's love interest), Sejun, Constantine (Sejun's love interest) and friends, were still in Junior High (shown on the photo Sejun was looking at). Also, Jah was about to confess to Alyssa, but Alyssa was moving out of the country because of the scholarship.
2015 (date on newspaper) - tragedy happened at a reunion as headlined on the newspaper Sejun was crying on.. 1 died (probably Constantine) and others are critically injured as per news article. Sejun was later shown as a crippled man.
2019 (date on sejun's calendar) - sejun is still mourning about the tragedy.. it is the same year as josh' story as seen when he passed behind Sejun on the bus scene. Josh went to his and Athena's old meeting place marked with 'Josh and Athena Forever' then a ball hit Josh' back and he saw a child. He gave that child the red string to find out that the child's mother was actually Athena because of the red string she was also wearing. There are color references on the children playing in the playground on Josh' flashback, with what they are wearing in their present day.. Josh - Red and Athena - Green
2034 (date on Stell's note) - Stell is in love with a girl but was never reciprocated. It turned out that the girl already had someone else. Ken went to Stell's coffee shop and saw his love interest with another girl and they seem to have a romantic relationship. The girl had the red string. With the timeline, she is possibly Athena's (Josh' love) daughter.
but in the end, they all chose to accept their fate and love 'hanggang sa huli' (until the end)..
i hope i got it right though :)
It is a story of past present and future... they are separated through different time zone...
watching anime series is a hobby of ken now he's already an anime character of their own mv.
THE MV IS SAID TO BE CREATED CONFUSING SO THE AUDIENCE themselves WILL TRY TO FIGURE OUT WHAT IS REALLY GOING on,, the MV is indeed deep. SB19 is genius
Every Music Video Concept of SB19 are in connected, Notice the strings of Josh's Red Zone in Alab, You'll notice a string bracelet in Hanggang Sa Huli that was red too. I discover that the theory of Love Goes MV soon will be much connected on Sejun's story of HSH Music Video. The Elegy of Constantine.
Hi kpopsis. Just wanna share my take on the MV.
2009 (past) -- Justin and Sejun are classmates. You can see in the journal written by justin, the date was 2009. Justin loved this girl but choose to not confess to not be a hindrance to her scholarship.
2019 (present) --- Sejun was seen on his bed and was reminiscing the past. Turns out while they are going to their reunion there was an accident that caused the death of his classmates (this may include justin) and his loved one.
He went to the memorial of his lover while riding a bus (he can no longer walk) and you can see here that Sejun and Josh was riding the same bus (you can see Josh passing by at the back while Sejun was looking out bus window). Josh on the other hand was visiting her childhood sweetheart which was Athena, maybe to confess his feelings but he have known that his love was already married (which can be justin as well if he didn't die in the reunion accident). So he gave his red string like bracelet to his childhood sweetheart's daughter.
2034 (future) -- Ken likes this girl who turns out to be that daughter of Athena who was Josh's childhood sweetheart, the one Josh gave a bracelet. While Ken was on the cafè where Stell is working he saw that the the girl he likes is with someone already. He gave up his love but still protected her when she was harassed.
Stell was on the same timeline as Ken, works at a coffee shop and can't confess his feelings for this girl until that unfaithful day where she was already with someone else.. he gave her one coffee all the time but that time he made two for her. Turns out it was not meant for him.
This is more accurate than the one I've read..
Did not even noticed Josh was actually riding the same bus as Sejun! I had to watch it again for me to see it myself! Thanks!
This suddenly pop on my mind. I think Josh made a promise to Athena that he will come back to her when he is successful. Unfortunately, when the time comes that he comes back to their place being successful (I think he is a CEO) Athena already had a family
I noticed that Athena has the red bracelet. It could've been from Josh.
Yes i agreee
Stell confessed on his birthday. ToT Imagine confessing to someone you like and just getting rejected. What a nice birthday gift. :(
I like how Justin designed it to be interesting and deep at the same time. It was made where you need to watch it multiple times to see all the clues and get all the viewers give their own interpretation/theory basing on the what lil' hints they saw. It was fun during the premier, Twitter was full of clues,banter,theories and what not. Feel free to interpret it as well. As they said during their fb live, enjoy the MV and make our own assumptions. Thank you for supporting our boys! Loves lots from a fellow kapatid 💙
You're one of the few real reactors who really spend time to analyze the behind story of each members in this MV. I did appreciate how you really translated the Filipino words into English.
I'm actually surprised cause the the power of Atin was so overwhelming that they came up with many theories and even every single detail was spotted. Lol.
Thank you so much as always, #KPopSis♥️
#SB19HSHMV
HOPE THIS HELPS
since most of the pips in the comment sections know how each member story goes, lets do the timeline base on how I understand the MV, do correct me if you guys think I made a mistake so that all of us can be enlighten in the story.
(2009) = Justin and Sejun are batchmates/Classmates with their crush/love interest (girl w/ glasses for Justin and girl with bangs for Sejun)
(2015) = when the tragic happened during their reunion during night time at 7 pm, but it says on the newspaper that only 1 died (Sejun crush/love interest), and four others are badly injured/wounded. So it's safe to assume that Sejun is one of those that got injured, and (Justin crush/love interest) is not present for she traveled overseas for the scholarship. The mystery here is where is Justin in the present? Coz I'm pretty sure the last shot of Justin is still in the past.
(2019)? = Josh and Sejun are on the same bus, Josh gets dropped first in the playground and reminisce the days he have with his crush/love interest only to find out that she already have a family. He gave the red bracelet to the kid where she and her mom matches, (safe to assume in the past they maybe lovers). It's just a theory, but I guess josh story is different from the other members, he did confess his love and they got together, I'm assuming he has to work overseas or far away, what he failed to do is to proposed to his love one, and when he got back it's too late.
Sejun on the other hand went to the place where the accident takes place, and gives respects to his crush/love interest and tried to move on with a smile. I'm assuming the other pictures on the trees represents other passengers that died in the accident. but you see in the news it only said 1 died, but take note the newspaper only covered those who attended the reunion, perhaps there's another vehicle or other passengers.
(2034) = Stell is a barista and Ken is a street artist/fighter haha,
I'm assuming again that Stell put different notes or quotes to brighten up the day of his crush/love interest, but on the day she could have read the note that Stell likes her, she didn't got the chance to read it for that day she came w/ her BF.
Ken on the other hand saw his crush/ love interest with another girl in the coffee shop with the red bracelet, thus we all agree in the theory and assume that Ken's crush/love interest is the daughter of Josh ex lover Athena.
main theme of the story? well all members didn't have the chance to say how much they love their crush/love interest, but just like the lyrics said, nothing will change and they will keep loving them hanggang sa huli (until the end).
Sb19 youtube fanfesttttt
SB19 always like a roller coaster of emotions
once you know everything in the story you'll get chills everytike u see this mv
Sejun's girl/crush died in an accident
The woman josh loved is already married.
Ken's crush is lesbian
Justin's crush got a schoolarship abroad. And justin still didn't confess his feeling to the girl.
The girl stell fell in love with already have a boyfriend.
Sorry for my english. By the way love your reaction😊
Yes got cha 🇵🇭❤️
Tama to. Yung iba dito, masyadong pinakokomplikado yung mv. No need for theories.
HSH MV
- Josh childhood friend/love is already married and have a happy family.
- Ken's crush/love is a lesbian.
- Stell, he likes a girl but when he already decided to confessed his feelings towards her, the girl is already in a relationship.
- Justin is ready to confess his feelings towards her classmate/bestfriend but he don't want to be a hindrance to her dreams.
- Sejun's girl is already dead because of an accident/tragedy, the reason why he can't walk.
Hanggang sa huli's mv is so addicting. The more you watch it the more you understands the story. Kudos to all behind this music video. Especially the one who did the storyline of the video, it really left us all thinking.
Director: Justin de Dios
Writer: Justin de Dios
We are proud of you Jah
THIS MV HAS A GREAT MEANING.
1. Learn to accept things that we can't control anymore.
2. Show yourself(feelings)
3. Move on and keep going
My fav reactor of SB19! Yeey! I really have fun watching SB19 contents with you guys.
Thank you Meagan ang Briana, A'tin loves you..
Finally!!! A reaction vid from my favorite reactors!! Thank you, Meagan and Brianna!!! We all are proud of SB19. And thank you for supporting PPop Music. I love you both! Stay safe always and God bless!
Super proud of the writer and director of this MV and its myloves Justin, im sooo inlove haha
Im so crying the story of #SB19😭😭😭😭 good job more bless ....
To us Filipinos who understood tagalog, we easily cried the first time we saw that part where the newspaper was shown. The literal translation of the headline was "REUNION ENDED IN TRAGEDY"
Additionally, upon loser inspection of the article, it said "...one died, four are in critical condition..." Sejun, Jah and the rest were obviously critical to the point that Sejun ended up being unable to walk anymore, hence he's on a wheelchair.
Aside from the obvious heartbreaks, the MV would seem shallow or even confusing at first glance, but there's also that nagging feeling that the video is not as simple as it seems, that it has some things hidden in plain view. There is a deeper, more profound story that interconnected all 5 of the men in the video. Sejun called it "Easter Eggs" during their livestream countdown for the MV's premiere. To those who do not know Justin's tendencies, he loves devicing this kind of stuff.
You need to really focus on the details here as well in order to notice who's with who. In fact, Sejun and Josh were together in one scene, but it was deliberately obscure. (Pay close attention. Try to guess which scene~)
All of A'TIN spent the whole night yesterday tearing the clues apart to understand the timeline. There are 4 distinctive time points here. And we all eventually built up the story.
Stell has a long crush on a customer who happens to have a boyfriend.
Ken has a secret crush on a girl pal. Where in they just can't to be together.
Sejun attended a reunion where in it ended in tragedy that causes the life of his girl and friends and made him crippled.
Josh went back to I guess their hometown after many years looking for her love who happens to have a family already. He was not able to confess his love.
Justin had a crush on his classmate and when he was ready to confess his feelings her classmat moved out of the town for she got a scholarship somewhere.
I have to repeat the music video for 5 times. So I can understand. 😍
And I'm crying 😢 wil watching it. 💙
#SB19
THE UNDISPUTED PPOP KINGS #SB19💙💙💙💙💙
The kid in Josh's scene is the daughter of the girl she likes, look at the red bracelette that they both have. the girl she likes has her own family when he came back.
AlyssaAthena= Alay sa A'tin
💙
As you can see, in sejun's room there are crampled papers. I just remembered the alab mv, in sejun's part. His theme was crampled papers also and he's sitting on that, i think the story was really connected. That color was violet also which signifies death.
And sejun'd wardrobe was also the same.
The reunion, turned into tragedy- that somehow connected to Love Goes story.
All in all, sejun's story was really impactful and painful
Just a theory of mine.
The characters in the MV are SB19 members. Each of them tackles heart breaks in different forms crossing different time lines. Starting from the past. Sejun and Justin exist in the past(2009) where apparently they're classmates who fall in love with their friends in the same circle(6 members in total as seen in the photo held by Sejun) but never get to confessed their feelings for reasons that Aly,Justin's love interest needs to go away to study somewhere,and Sejun's because she died in an accident in 2015 for their reunion,and four left injured including Justin and Sejun where he's seen seated on a wheelchair at the end of the video. Aly,apparently wasnt involved in the accident bec.she had moved away. Now present exists where Josh is seen coming back to his childhood place reminisces his young love and visits the place where his never-died love continues. He stumbles upon a young girl who happens to be his never-died love's child. He hands over the promised/couple red thread bracelet to the girl before she goes back to her parents,and the focus pans to the wrist of the mother (Athena,etched on the tree with Josh's name) wearing the same exact bracelet. Josh realises that his love is never coming back as Athena is already settled and happy,so he stretches a subtle smile as his goodbye. Future then comes(2034,shown on Stell's note)where Stell who works as a barista happens to fall for one of their customers,the catch is he has to let go of his feelings as the girl is already taken. Ken as seen making art graffiti is in love with someone who's in love with the same gender,and as a twist of fate,the girl he likes is the child of Athena-Josh's love,she's seen wearing the bracelet Josh gifted her when they met accidentally 19 yrs ago(2015-2034). Ken's graffitis are festooned with different colors with the word LOVE as the main theme/subject that gives a hint that love knows no gender. If you watch the video again,youll realize how the story is well-thought out,how even small details intertwine the five's destiny.#StanSB19❤
5 different kinds of heartbreak and letting go, different kind of love... but at the end acceptance is the key “ NO ONE CAN STOP SOMEONE TO LOVE “
Stan talents
Stan Sb19!!!!!
#SB19
YAAASSSSS I'VE NEVER CLICKED SO FAST
Animators here in the PH paid the lowest, I appreciated how the animators work for this
Legit!!
Among those reactions about their MV you interpret it the closes to all the Filipinos interpretations.Nice...
You figured the connection between sejun story & love goes all by yourself 😊
Hanggang sa huli👍
Great and Intelligent Concept, Despite of Pandemic.
We stan WISE MEN
#SB19 gave us an assignment to decipher the video.
Let me tell u guys it's not my first time, I've watched this reaction video for the nth time i dunno why. I just love them. One of my favorite reactors.
Director Justin wants us to Watch it again and again and again!
Maegan you look so cute with those curls!
Every details of a single frame in this music video has meanings, Justin did really great for directing this MV, it makes you wanna watch it again and again.
Im also only one waiting your reaction to my idol SB19🥰🥰thank you mga ate PpopSis😊😊
My fave reactors..thanks again for reacting to new MV of SB19 HANGGANG SA HULI💙
What I like this MV of hanggang sa huli is that u have to come up some theory to understand everyone story, and that so genius idea!! Actually this MV tackles every kind of love!! Especially love is no gender!
This was the mv reaction that I was waiting for! Haha
Just saw this in FB but they did feature their symbolisms of love from Alab in this MV. And that's freaking cool.
Talent overload Justin
Been waiting your reaction to be uploaded since yesterday and I promised myself to watch it after streaming hanggang sa huli. So, here I am witnessing your genuine reactions of the mv and yeah I am as confused as you guys when I first watch the video 😅
P.S. I'm still figuring out some scenes too
OOOHH LOOKS AT MEGAN’S CURLLSSSSSS
Let's make it to the billboardcharts again
We feel you. Per Justin and Josh during their Facebook live minutes before the MV premier, they made it that way so we could re-watch and figure things out. They know A'Tin are smart and keen observants.
In this MV, SB19 waken up our investigative skills. You need a sharp eyes to cope up in every details. Like to the transition of dates, the newspaper, admission paper, Jah love letter, the calendar that hang on Sejun's room and to the different kind flowers, the red string bracelet wore by Josh, Athena, and the boyish young lady. And also to the Sejun mug with printed heart, same to the heart that Ken printed to his graffitti and many more.😁 Oh I forgot, In Stell post it note, the date of it is his birthday, imagine, on your birthday you're brokenhearted.😁
the woman in the park is Athena( the girl that has her name carved on the tree with Josh) who is now a married woman
Also, the little details of social awareness they added are so on point...
Petition for real life re enactment huhu
Oohhh... I am one day late for this one. I got excited to see this reaction. ♥️🎉🙏♥️
The red ribbon has a significance
my two fav. reactor miss you ladies,
Check one comment in their Hanggang sa Huli mv, the storyline is really mind blowing. It's one of the comments that really hits what this mv is about
Sb19 watch your video💙💙
I'm just happy watching and reading other people's theory
Hi Kpopsis, Can't wait to react you guys on YTFF performance of SB19💕
this is the one I have been waiting for 🥺👉👈 love youuuuu po!!💜
I've been waiting for this reaction since yesterday yepeyy love you both
We miss you KPOPSIS! #SB19
So the girl that ken likes is the little girl with the ball. Josh gave her the bracelet and the girl ken likes was wearing it.
Justin's plan really works. Viewers are watching it again.
Justin really likes to play with us Hahaha. Justin is so creative and he also made us confuse. All the story are connected but still made us think how, its because the scenes are not connected or cut i guess. Justin wants to test us. He is still finding the best answers from A'Tin.
There is no theory. It's just stories of love, heartaches, and acceptance.
Justin: Studies over love 💙
Sejun: Lost of a loved one 💙
Josh: Past love that is somehow still connected to him 💙
Ken: Liked/love someone who is a lesbian (may never like him back) 💙
Stell: The person he likes already have someone else. 💙
Maybe some are just confused of the timelines and scene transitions.
Scene timelines:
Justin and Sejun were classmates year 2009
Sejun and Josh year 2019
Ken and Stell year 2034
PLS NOTICE THIS IS THE ANSWER ON THE STORY PUZZLE
2009
*Justin and Sejun are classmates
*The girl Justin likes transfered to another school
2015
*Reunion
*Sejun's gf died
*Sejun got paralyzed because of the accident
2019
*Josh's childhood first love has a family
*Sejun's still in pain due to the loss of his gf
2034
*the woman Stell wants already has a bf
*the woman Ken wants is a lesbian
*the girl Ken likes is the child of Josh's childhood
I've been waiting for you reaction ♥️
Is it just me or did anyone noticed another easter egg I found in the form of the knapsack in Pinunong Sejun's room and in the classroom of Director and writter Justin?
which only proves that Sejun and Justin are Highschool classmates and at the same time line.
Its a story of past lives love. That's why it has forever. And hanggang sa huli seems to never end. Just a theory teehee!
Yey ive been waiting for this!!!🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭💙💙💙💙💙
Justin's last appearance was dating back in 2009.
Sejun's was in 2019 but he's in most part of the timeline since he appeared in 2009 as High school student in the same class as Justin. In 2015 where he grieved over the death of his crush and in 2019 where he moved on.
Josh appeared in the 2019 timeline.
Ken and Stell lived in the 2034 timeline where it is speculated that Athena's, Josh's crush, daughter is Ken's crush.
That's why there are some theories out there that something happened to Justin as well during that reunion tragedy.
I like your reaction Kpopsis. You have your discussions and exchanging of ideas.
How I wish I also have someone to discuss about the MV theories with me.
Congratulations to the animator.... Justin DeDios
The Music Video story is about 5 different individual of love with sacrifice.
STELL - a barista who is in love with regular customer girl that has already have a boyfriend.💔
JUSTIN - who is in love with his classmate that is already accepted to other school and will no longer his classmate.💔
KEN - who is in love to a girl he saved from a thug and found out she is a tomboy.❤🩹
JOSH - who is in love to a girl in his hometown and when he made visit found out that the girl has already married and have kid.❤🩹
PABLO - who is in love to a girl who died in an accident with him but he managed to survive but disable.💔