Because they dont need to, no one gives a fuck except those shitty piano channels that just put "what the original sound is vs what it actually sound like"
People talking about how the piano is animated correctly... EVERYTHING is! Lip-Sync, Drums, Guitar and Bass! I don't know, why I've just now found this piece of genuinely great art NOW and not years ago, but the nostalgia of the song, characters and animationstyle all hit me in the feels. Suffice to say, you've gained a sub.
So who's ready for a somewhat long, rough interpretation of this amazing animation. This goes back to the alicorn immortality and The MLP FIM/Gen 3 issue so bare with me. After many eons the lands of Equestria have faded and only Celestia, Luna, Cadance, and Twilight are the only ones left from the era of when ponies basically ruled the planet. All that they knew and held dear is gone now, and Twilight's friends have passed away leading her to stray away from the other three alicorns. While Twilight ventures the ever changing world, she comes accustomed to the fact that a new species has control over the planet called humans. She befriends a few of them but it never feels the same as she tries to grasp the memory of her friends from so many years ago. One human she knows pretty well is a washed up pianist and they will sometimes sing music. Unknowing to her human friend the music is the only thing that can help Twilight remember her early life of happiness.
@@onealone-jt8oi well comment from 2 years ago, I think it is most likely due to her never wanting to let go of her friends. After all, with the, gone she only remembers them in memory and doesn’t want to forget them. I think her biggest fear is losing memory of her own friends. While Celestial and Luna are the only ones who knew fully well of losing those you cared for and moving on, Twilight remains stuck on the past: never letting go of the memory of her friends and never moving on. While indeed, she befriended some humans but as main comment above us said, it doesn’t feel the same when she’s with her old friends. Plus, I think there is that underlying fear that Twilight would outlive her new friends, the humans, like she did with her old ones. To me at least, I think Twilight sees being an Alicorn a curse than it is a blessing which is why she strayed away from the three remaining Alircorns.
I can't get over how you show the keys being pressed or with the strings on the guitars when most people just take the easy way and only make it look like they are playing the instrument while never showing the keys or strings of said instruments. I feel you always go above and beyond with your animations. just what I have been looking for. please keep up the amazing work!
Fun fact: When researching how old this song was, I realised how old I am. The earliest memory I have of hearing this song was from around 2006 or 2007.
tbh i found this sfm in a sea of videos all titled "piano is never animated correctly" and this was one of the rare "they animated a piano correctly" and thats just amazing
I never expected TF2 and MLP to be in the same video… ever. But this was pretty good nonetheless. Music was nice, editing on point, and you got another RUclipsr complimenting you on having properly animated the piano keystrokes to match the notes played.
The downside of being a princess, Twilight is so closely tied to her friends it is a part of her cutie mark. The whole story could very well end with her feeling so alone after the last of her most beloved friends inevitably go the same way as Granny Smith, that she leaves Canterlot takes the form most familiar with happier times to grieve.
Detailed animation. Great, mood fitting, lighting. Solid lipsyncing. Great framing. etc, etc. Keep up the fantastic work. One word of advice from on SFMer to another, mostly on the grounds of the lipsyncing, I'd like to see more emotion in the mouth itself. You know, bigger expressions for bigger notes. If they're belting out lyrics on the top of their lungs, their mouth should be much bigger and in turn more expressive. That's my opinion anyways. Overall the lipsync was spot on. Really top notch work. Especially on the sniper playing the piano. That's detail and dedication. Congrats! TL;DR Iz prety gud.
It is a great song, so good choice. Lip sync was spot on. Facial expressions were real and well placed and formed. Body motions were also fluid and not chunky or ridged. Attention to detail was amazing, especially the sniper being on correct keys while playing the piano. I'm a fan now. How to see more soon.
I don't know how or why... But the little pony characters go so well with tf2. Maybe because of their comedic antics? Or the contrasting yet complimentative blend between the gritty and the cute? Or their shared notion of commradery? Either way I like it. And great atmosphere for the song. Keep up the good work!
Holy fuck this is really good. Although there isn't a whole lot going on throughout the majority of the video, the emotion more than makes up for it. Awesome song, great scenery and good animation make this an amazing SFM music piece. Awesome work!
So sniper and twilight went out into the forest, set up a grand piano, and literally sat on a fucking cardboard box while they waited for it to rain so they could begin, lol.
You know what all these SFM pony videos prove right? It is possible to do a 3D version of the show that looks like the 2D show but feels more tangible. That and that people already like this style of animation and would watch such a show. I'm just waiting for Hasbro to notice the potential of an adult-focused MLP show done in this style with more realistic themes and topics.
This is a really touching song for me, and this is without a shadow of a doubt my new favorite interpretation of it! Great job good sir! I tip my hat towards you! ;-)
Thanks! I tried to emphasize the major points in the song, like at that point you mentioned. I feel that sad songs like this always fit in a rainy environment, don't know why.
So simple, yet i bet all the minor details you put must ve been a pain to make like the notes synced on sniper's piano. Amazing to see all that care put in this, may be late but still, greatly done dude
Oh My God... I Can't Stop Re-watching This I Just Can't It Almost Drives Me To Tears Each Time I Watch It. I Just Can't Express How Beautiful This Video Is. It's Also The First Video I Have Watched By You And Now You Have One More Subscriber On This Channel. Amazing Work!!
The animation was amazing. I couldn't help but watch the detail you put in, both the lip Sync, the Instruments synchronization was more than just them mimicking the movements, it was like they were actually _playing_ the Instruments, which sadly, few animators do. A wonderful Work of art in SFM form.
I did practice a bit of guitar and bass playing before, so I guess I relate to those parts even more Keep up the good work! You deserve more subscriptions!
the movement are so smooth, and i love the lip sync, it's really fit. Twilight needs more expression though, but that's pretty much all. this is great sfm
This fits so well with Twilight being an Alicorn and the implication that she's immortal and may out live her friends. Even though Megan McCarthy stated otherwise, but still.
Dis is just beautiful......Lightning is fantastic. Lip sync is amazing....Movements are awesome. YOU JUST DID A FANTASTIC JOB ON EVERYTHING. YOU DESVERSE HIGH MANY SUBS AND VIEWS. OH MY GOD, THIS IS AMAZING. THE ANGLES ARE AWESOME. EVERYTHING IS AMAZING
Another good video! Once again Team Fortress and a Pony. This time Twilight singing. I especially liked the effect as she sang, of the cloud partially occluding the Moon. MORE!!! the Frank Gamer
Thanks man! I generally don't use the models with the eye reflections, because the majority of people prefer the look of the eyes with the show-accurate reflections, but I wanted to use it here to see how they work in an animation context.
I mean good annimation... But I can't quite be interested in it simply for the MLP stuff. Good on you for liking it. But makes it hard for me to know how I am meant to feel.
Great job! This song is very nostalgic, but I do have one question. Was Rainbow Dash the one Twilight was singing about, considering her being there in the end, as if she were watching over her?
![The Reason [SFM]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VqtQCtCr2BQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![[SFM] Envelope](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LMnIPxtM_Mc/mqdefault.jpg)
The fact that this TF2 animation animated the piano correct…
Most movies don’t even animate the piano correctly
you too watched amosdoll, eh?
@@idcgaming518 yup!
Because they dont need to, no one gives a fuck except those shitty piano channels that just put "what the original sound is vs what it actually sound like"
Yeah i love how this one SFM is better than what most movies do
Yea
People talking about how the piano is animated correctly... EVERYTHING is! Lip-Sync, Drums, Guitar and Bass! I don't know, why I've just now found this piece of genuinely great art NOW and not years ago, but the nostalgia of the song, characters and animationstyle all hit me in the feels.
Suffice to say, you've gained a sub.
The animator has a background in music. The attention to detail is just amazing.
So who's ready for a somewhat long, rough interpretation of this amazing animation. This goes back to the alicorn immortality and The MLP FIM/Gen 3 issue so bare with me. After many eons the lands of Equestria have faded and only Celestia, Luna, Cadance, and Twilight are the only ones left from the era of when ponies basically ruled the planet. All that they knew and held dear is gone now, and Twilight's friends have passed away leading her to stray away from the other three alicorns. While Twilight ventures the ever changing world, she comes accustomed to the fact that a new species has control over the planet called humans. She befriends a few of them but it never feels the same as she tries to grasp the memory of her friends from so many years ago. One human she knows pretty well is a washed up pianist and they will sometimes sing music. Unknowing to her human friend the music is the only thing that can help Twilight remember her early life of happiness.
This is Absolutely Amazing You Literally Just Blew My Mind and That Should Be an Entire Story
Why is it that Twilight can never make friends with future generations like Celestia obviously did?
Not usually a fan of headcanons but I can get behind this one.
@@onealone-jt8oi well comment from 2 years ago, I think it is most likely due to her never wanting to let go of her friends. After all, with the, gone she only remembers them in memory and doesn’t want to forget them. I think her biggest fear is losing memory of her own friends. While Celestial and Luna are the only ones who knew fully well of losing those you cared for and moving on, Twilight remains stuck on the past: never letting go of the memory of her friends and never moving on. While indeed, she befriended some humans but as main comment above us said, it doesn’t feel the same when she’s with her old friends.
Plus, I think there is that underlying fear that Twilight would outlive her new friends, the humans, like she did with her old ones. To me at least, I think Twilight sees being an Alicorn a curse than it is a blessing which is why she strayed away from the three remaining Alircorns.
She'll always have discord, though after flutershy goes that might not be such a good thing
I can't get over how you show the keys being pressed or with the strings on the guitars when most people just take the easy way and only make it look like they are playing the instrument while never showing the keys or strings of said instruments.
I feel you always go above and beyond with your animations. just what I have been looking for.
please keep up the amazing work!
Fun fact: When researching how old this song was, I realised how old I am. The earliest memory I have of hearing this song was from around 2006 or 2007.
ImAFutureGuitarHero's SFM Channel really?I didnt know that.
I have to wonder what precisely (who) would inspire Twilight to sing that sort of song about somepony, lol.
1 word beautiful.
Thanks!
Your welcome.
tbh i found this sfm in a sea of videos all titled "piano is never animated correctly" and this was one of the rare "they animated a piano correctly" and thats just amazing
this would make a good song that Celestia could sing after Luna's banishment.
I know that there is one where Luna sang while her banishment.
That's a very good point.
Facts
There is Rose there is also one that Celestia sings to Luna, a sort of lullaby.
@@paulbaker2183 fr
When Spike runs away and never comes back. But seriously , this made me feel better...I was having a rough day...
BRO THEY ANIMATED THE PIANO CORRECTLY HOW IMPRESSIVE IS THAT
So rare now 😭😭
I never expected TF2 and MLP to be in the same video… ever. But this was pretty good nonetheless. Music was nice, editing on point, and you got another RUclipsr complimenting you on having properly animated the piano keystrokes to match the notes played.
this is for my teo he passed away in April 16th of 2016 i miss him now his in Heaven with God and Jesus
The downside of being a princess, Twilight is so closely tied to her friends it is a part of her cutie mark. The whole story could very well end with her feeling so alone after the last of her most beloved friends inevitably go the same way as Granny Smith, that she leaves Canterlot takes the form most familiar with happier times to grieve.
I fell sad because of twilight puppy eyes
Detailed animation. Great, mood fitting, lighting. Solid lipsyncing. Great framing. etc, etc. Keep up the fantastic work. One word of advice from on SFMer to another, mostly on the grounds of the lipsyncing, I'd like to see more emotion in the mouth itself. You know, bigger expressions for bigger notes. If they're belting out lyrics on the top of their lungs, their mouth should be much bigger and in turn more expressive. That's my opinion anyways. Overall the lipsync was spot on. Really top notch work. Especially on the sniper playing the piano. That's detail and dedication. Congrats!
TL;DR Iz prety gud.
Thank you! It means a lot coming from an established member of the SFM community. I'll try to keep that in mind about the lipsyncing.
I know that before the coronavirus pandemic I sang with the St. Andrew's Episcopal Church choir here in Florida
And also accurate piano playing.
you played the piano right, knew head canon, sniper is amazing at the piano
Very Nice, Animation is solid. Nice Work Man!
Thanks! :D
my eyes are quite drawn to Twilight's theres just something so captivating about them in this video
I'm literally crying right now your work is fabulous
Thanks!
I'm also crying so hard, and that's because I'm going through so many things... 😭😭
I even cry just singing along with it since I feel that the lyrics have such a powerful meaning
It is a great song, so good choice. Lip sync was spot on. Facial expressions were real and well placed and formed. Body motions were also fluid and not chunky or ridged. Attention to detail was amazing, especially the sniper being on correct keys while playing the piano. I'm a fan now. How to see more soon.
Thanks!
I don't know how or why... But the little pony characters go so well with tf2. Maybe because of their comedic antics? Or the contrasting yet complimentative blend between the gritty and the cute? Or their shared notion of commradery? Either way I like it.
And great atmosphere for the song. Keep up the good work!
I'm literally on the verge of tears... this is just too fucking good.
You are incredible man!
Thanks man! :D
I miss MLP 😭
i came from that "the animated the piano correctly?" video
Same, and I'm so glad I did.
I thought that, based on how well done the video was, it would be way more popular. Good job mate, the animation is great quality.
One of if not the best animations from sfm I've ever seen, and lipsyncing also
Thanks! :D
Holy fuck this is really good. Although there isn't a whole lot going on throughout the majority of the video, the emotion more than makes up for it. Awesome song, great scenery and good animation make this an amazing SFM music piece. Awesome work!
Thanks man!
CrimZon Pegasus no one gives a shit about what I typed just fucking say this is a good animation bitch and get this I'm black
no one gives a shit what I wrote all to much shity shit
I meant u not i
Whatever
"Sniper's a good job mate, as well as pianist"
The video animated the piano correctly, impressive work!!
So sniper and twilight went out into the forest, set up a grand piano, and literally sat on a fucking cardboard box while they waited for it to rain so they could begin, lol.
And that is precisely why logic never works well with anything like this. :P
ImAFutureGuitarHero's SFM Channel
But it made the background story of the video more enjoyable, and thus I liked it more.
Me: Twilight Sparkle on Lead Vocal.
Red Sniper on Piano.
Red Scout on Electric Guitar.
Red Spy on Bass.
Red Soldier on Drums.
man, this song brings memories... makes me even more sad thinking bout the mlp community that is unfortunatly dying out....
Outstanding job, breathtaking and heart felt. You deserve more followers.
Thanks! :D
This is beyond amazing, keep up the good work =3
And rip Sniper
You know what all these SFM pony videos prove right? It is possible to do a 3D version of the show that looks like the 2D show but feels more tangible. That and that people already like this style of animation and would watch such a show. I'm just waiting for Hasbro to notice the potential of an adult-focused MLP show done in this style with more realistic themes and topics.
This is a really touching song for me, and this is without a shadow of a doubt my new favorite interpretation of it! Great job good sir! I tip my hat towards you! ;-)
Thanks man!
Beautiful, people like you are who got me in to this fandom
Nice, I really love the lighting in this one. And the way she flares her wings at 1:04, along with the thundercrash... fantastic! :D
Thanks! I tried to emphasize the major points in the song, like at that point you mentioned. I feel that sad songs like this always fit in a rainy environment, don't know why.
Yes indeed. The rain is a perfect complement
Holy shit dude... that was fantastic!! Loved the cinematography :D
oh btw, SUBSCRIBED
Thanks man! :D
So simple, yet i bet all the minor details you put must ve been a pain to make like the notes synced on sniper's piano. Amazing to see all that care put in this, may be late but still, greatly done dude
Oh My God... I Can't Stop Re-watching This I Just Can't It Almost Drives Me To Tears Each Time I Watch It. I Just Can't Express How Beautiful This Video Is. It's Also The First Video I Have Watched By You And Now You Have One More Subscriber On This Channel. Amazing Work!!
YOU ANIMATED THE FINGERS!! THE MUSICIAN IN ME IS SCREAMING!!! THANK YOUUUUUU
Thanks! As a musician myself I wanted to go into detail with those parts of the animation.
I love music as well and I have perfect pitch
I bet every tf2 character is good at some instruments
I believe so too. 😌
The animation was amazing. I couldn't help but watch the detail you put in, both the lip Sync, the Instruments synchronization was more than just them mimicking the movements, it was like they were actually _playing_ the Instruments, which sadly, few animators do.
A wonderful Work of art in SFM form.
Gah... so much regret in her expression... I'm depressed now...
EonOfTheNeon Makes you wonder what happened to her to leave that pain on her face.
and even I have regrets about things that have happened in my past as well
Wow this is the best sfm music video I've ever seen
Thanks man! :D
Rest In Peace, MLP and Rick May.
MLP still alive
@@Patryk2098 Yep, Gen 5 is coming! I can’t wait!
That lipsync is amazing, spot on.
Thanks man!
It's making me cry 😢
It's beautiful
@@mhaqueenb7112 yes it's beautiful
im sorry but how is a candle burning in the rain XD
Magic! :D what a sec... MERASMUS!!!
Michael Bobb lol damn it merasmus
Magic
that is funny 😂 usually you would think that a wick on a candle wouldn't produce a flame when any moisture gathered on it
This. Is. Amazing. I'm being overwhelmed with nostalgia from the pones and from the music. Help.
Embrace the nostalgia :D
I'm supposed to be reading Frankenstein right now dangit! Now I'm watching pony videos!
that is funny 😂
I do not know anything about playing a piano, but the detail of each of Sniper's fingers playing each key looks very good!
Thanks! Being a musician myself, I try and put as much detail into the instrument playing as in the rest of the animation.
I did practice a bit of guitar and bass playing before, so I guess I relate to those parts even more Keep up the good work! You deserve more subscriptions!
Amazing. Sorry it took me this long to find you. keep up the awesome work.
Oh Twilight, I feel deeply for you. Just...just be safe during Season 9, please!!!
Still to this day I watch this video and it brings tears to my eyes. Live Twilight and this Video!
NOOOOOOOO!!!! SNIPER!!!! Did ya get him to Medic?!
Missed hearing this song...high school memories.........I FEEL OLD!!!
Theres just something about the moon and the rain that makes the setting just so much more fitting for the song.
Amazing Animation. I can't really say much more than that it is amazing... I'm really impressed
Thanks!
I know it would be an extremely remote possibility, and call me crazy, but I would absolutely LOVE it if Amy Lee was a guest star on the show!
This.....is beautiful ;~;
That's a good piece of work :)
Thanks!
the movement are so smooth, and i love the lip sync, it's really fit.
Twilight needs more expression though, but that's pretty much all. this is great sfm
Thanks! That seems to be a main thing with this, people are saying that Twilight wasn't animated with enough expression.
it's not that bad though, just didn't got the feel that much. Still pretty cool music video
This fits so well with Twilight being an Alicorn and the implication that she's immortal and may out live her friends. Even though Megan McCarthy stated otherwise, but still.
That is exactly the thing I was hinting at with having Twilight as the focus of the video :)
Dis is just beautiful......Lightning is fantastic. Lip sync is amazing....Movements are awesome. YOU JUST DID A FANTASTIC JOB ON EVERYTHING. YOU DESVERSE HIGH MANY SUBS AND VIEWS. OH MY GOD, THIS IS AMAZING. THE ANGLES ARE AWESOME. EVERYTHING IS AMAZING
Thanks man! :D
Yw!
only the live version from Paris is more beautiful. I cry every time ;_;
When twilight is so sad she breaks the 4th wall with humans. Seriously this was fantastic!!!
This song was playing on the radio, as one of my beloved horses died in my arms.
Such a painfully sad memory! :(.
rw:funeral music for me:U_U: or even when MLPFIM had officially ended.
On another note, that ending was hilarious!
Хоть я и русская, но дажэ я понимаютчто это очень жиздненный и прекрасный клип!
Great work also the ending was perfect xD
Thanks!
I used to think SFM was talentless and not real animation, but watching videos like this changed my mind with how smooth and natural the movemeant is!
animation is flawless
Thank you for making this. This is one of my favorite songs and it brings a tear to my eyes every time I hear it.
same with me whenever I try singing along with it in my own octave
All awesomeness of the video aside but SPY HAS A GUITAR MY LIFE IS COMPLETE.
I cried at this. Beautiful work
HE PLAYED IT RIGHT BOYS
WHAT....! You have one dislike. That person clearly does NOT no telent. For a 16 year old you never cease to amaze me son. Keep up the good work.
Once again I have to say your work is amazing, your animations are always so clean and precise!
Thanks man!
The rain and the thunder fit in perfectly, nice
I loved everything about this.
wow what a beautiful song man great job and this song brings tears to my eyes listening to this song
Another good video! Once again Team Fortress and a Pony. This time Twilight singing. I especially liked the effect as she sang, of the cloud partially occluding the Moon. MORE!!!
the Frank Gamer
wow this is really perfect animated!! Better than I really expected!
Awesome job! ^^
Twilight's eyes are beautiful ✨
Who would knew sniper had such a gentle piano hand touch?
AMAZING video
Why is it the videos I watch they always make me cry or feel sad but at the same time i love it. Also great work my Friend.
my heart melted this is just amazing
amazing work its really smooth!
Thanks man! :D
Yup, this is also one of the Four of yours in my 'favorite SFM' folder.
Keep making 'em!
the Frank Gamer
Masterpiece
Madre mía, mordo!!!
it looks amazing! I like those realistic reflections on eyes! Perfect face animation, and atmosphere is beautiful too!
Thanks man! I generally don't use the models with the eye reflections, because the majority of people prefer the look of the eyes with the show-accurate reflections, but I wanted to use it here to see how they work in an animation context.
That lip syncing is downright God Tier.
I mean good annimation... But I can't quite be interested in it simply for the MLP stuff. Good on you for liking it. But makes it hard for me to know how I am meant to feel.
you can feel the emotion. Songs like these make me cry and I'm a man.
jeez man that was very impressive!
Thanks man!
The best sfm
Great job! This song is very nostalgic, but I do have one question. Was Rainbow Dash the one Twilight was singing about, considering her being there in the end, as if she were watching over her?
Thanks! And no, the only reason Rainbow is there is because I felt like putting a pony there :P
ImAFutureGuitarHero's SFM Channel No problem ;)
I got to say that this is one of your best work! Keep doing what you're doing dude and stay awesome! :)
Thanks man!
ImAFutureGuitarHero's SFM Channel No problem man i am looking forward what you'll upload next! :)
You make the most amazing sfm work I've ever seen you are truly an amazing person
Thanks man!