NEW MAYBELLINE SKY HIGH MASCARA VS. L'OREAL TELESCOPIC MASCARA | BEST DRUGSTORE MASCARA 2020/2021

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 сен 2024

Комментарии • 115

  • @katecartermakeup
    @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +16

    thank you guys so much for watching as always!!💗I just put a poll on my community tab about whether or not I should do a review on the new Morphe foundation! Go vote and let me know :)

  • @wiktoriakowalczyk2775
    @wiktoriakowalczyk2775 2 года назад +36

    I love telescopic. It starts out wet but after a week it dries down a bit in the bottle and it’s much better. It’s one of the darkest mascaras I have ever used. Makes my eyes pop

  • @maximaplane8404
    @maximaplane8404 3 года назад +157

    Great review, though let's be honest, when your lashes are this long to begin with, even a dollar mascara will look good x

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +5

      hahahaha that’s true! That’s why I try to focus on the wear test💗

    • @vanessaritchie8823
      @vanessaritchie8823 2 года назад

      Was brill..l bought the sky high about 4 months ago and l don't plan on changing.

    • @lucyxoxo
      @lucyxoxo Год назад +2

      It’s not true I have lashes like her’s and still if a mascara is clumpy u see it and it looks bad and because our lashes are bigger u can see it even more so there’s pros and cons for both sides of the spectrum

  • @megans1178
    @megans1178 3 года назад +62

    The L’Oréal looked so clumpy compared to your sky high lol but it’s still a good mascara. Really excited to see the Thrive on you next to this

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад

      I agree! And me too!! I’m soooo excited to try the thrive mascara!! 💗💗

  • @MissStacie-XO
    @MissStacie-XO 3 года назад +28

    Okey can we just really really admire how long Kate’s lashes are.. makes me soooo sad 😭 🤣
    With the maybelline mascaras I feel like they are really good for separation and thats what I love also.. ✨💛

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +2

      awwww stop I love you!!!❤️ but I totally agree!! I truly think Maybelline has some of the best mascaras from the drugstore!💗

  • @iamahay
    @iamahay 3 года назад +13

    You’re so lucky to have such long and separated lashes! I can’t stand the sky high... like, I get angry just trying to apply it 😂 Zero control as it’s so flexible and bendy. But your lashes cling onto the product.

  • @greenlove1979
    @greenlove1979 3 года назад +107

    The Mabelline sky high looks much better than the L’Oréal telescopic

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +8

      I agree!! Much more wispy and less spidery💕

  • @reichmuth100
    @reichmuth100 2 года назад +8

    I'll never stop using the Loreal Telescopic carbon black, I also don't curl my lashes, I've never had the telescopic carbon black, fall off onto my under eye either. I've fallen asleep in it and it looked great the next day. different strokes for different folks.

  • @KenziesProjects
    @KenziesProjects 3 года назад +13

    I finally got my hands on Maybelline sky high! I'm so excited to try it out and see if it will replace my lash sensational!

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +3

      omg yay!! I can’t believe it’s been sold out everywhere! Let me know if you like it! I swear by it💗💗

    • @madi9664
      @madi9664 3 года назад +5

      Use both!!! lash sensational first for the volume and then the sky high only at the top for length. It works so good

    • @KenziesProjects
      @KenziesProjects 3 года назад +2

      @@madi9664 that's a great idea! I felt that the sky high lacked the volume that I love from lash sensational! Thank you so much, I'm totally going to try that!😀😀

  • @NinaScottt
    @NinaScottt 3 года назад +14

    THANK YOUUUUUU! I've been stalking ur vids looking for mascaras for about 4 days now, I'm so extremely picky and my mascara routine takes about 50 minutes 😭. So I wanted to know which one is the best. I definitely think these are the two that are the best, including the essence princess collection. Tysm for this review, I've been waiting for it 🥰

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +3

      awww thank you!!!! I’m so glad you enjoy my mascara videos💗💗 I absolutely love making them! I’m super picky too about my mascara! But I really have fallen in love with the sky high! :)

    • @NinaScottt
      @NinaScottt 3 года назад +3

      @@katecartermakeup I noticed :P I'm glad you found what u loved 💖

  • @alex13taylor
    @alex13taylor 3 года назад +6

    i still need the sky high mascara wow! its so beautifulll

  • @meghanwilkinson2639
    @meghanwilkinson2639 3 года назад +9

    You have such long natural lashes!

  • @mer1001
    @mer1001 Год назад +2

    I think the sky high looks better up close, but when you zoom out and when i minimized the screen the telescopic looked a lot better than sky high.

  • @lucyxoxo
    @lucyxoxo Год назад

    Thank you for your honest reviews I love your videos!

  • @trishawilson7428
    @trishawilson7428 3 года назад +8

    I can’t get the sky high to look like that on my lashes, I can try again and just keep swiping through maybe I’m not doing that enough. Telescopic works great on my lashes I do have to keep swiping with that one to get volume too but I like to pair it with a volume mascara. Hey you just gave me a good idea lol!!!!!! I’m going to try telescopic for length the add the sky high on top of that to see what that looks like. Love the video!

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +5

      omg yes!! Combine them and let me know how it goes!💗 and hmmm maybe really push the sky high into the base of your lashes and work your way up. I find it so interesting that mascaras work so differently on everyone! But I hope they work well when you combine them!! :)💕

    • @trishawilson7428
      @trishawilson7428 3 года назад +1

      @@katecartermakeup yes i will try that too at the base of my lashes. I will get back to you on the combo, maybe if it turns out well you could demo that one. I would do You tube but I don’t know I’m camera shy lol!!!!!! Will see how this goes, I really want to buy the thrive mascara I can’t wait to see your demo with that one.

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +1

      @@trishawilson7428 I’m so excited to try the thrive mascara!! Everyone seems to love it! :) and I totally get that when I made my first video like 6 years ago I was sooooo shy but you get used to it! :)💗 I’m excited to hear how it goes I’m definitely also going to try it out!

    • @trishawilson7428
      @trishawilson7428 3 года назад +1

      @@katecartermakeup cool!!!! Well I like watching your stuff make up is kinda of a hobby of mine and trying different things. 😊

    • @stephaniegarsow6220
      @stephaniegarsow6220 3 года назад +1

      I cant get the Sky High to look like that either. Telescopic works better for me paired with other mascaras. I had high hopes for Sky High.. my lashes are short straight and fine. Love your drugstore mascara comparison videos though. You should do one comparing Loreal Butterfly and the original Lash Sensational

  • @MissStacie-XO
    @MissStacie-XO 3 года назад +3

    Well hellooo you beautiful person ✨✨💛
    Kate I just bought this mascara the sky high.. I haven’t used it yet so I’m soooo excited but I really want to get the telescopic too I love how much length you get with it...every mascara you love and recommend I buy 🤣 I trust your opinion sooooo much ✨✨💛 so Thankyou ♥️

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +1

      Awww thank you!! You’re the best!! I’m so glad you trust my opinion! I can’t wait for you to try the sky high I literally love it!💕💕 thank you SO MUCH for your support! :)

  • @bythewayxily
    @bythewayxily 3 года назад +25

    DAMN GIRL, THOSE ARE SOME LONGGGGG LASHES. i don't think it would matter what mascara you use cause your lashes are already great, hahahaha.

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад

      hahahahah UR THE BEST!❤️❤️

    • @bythewayxily
      @bythewayxily 3 года назад +3

      ps, thanks for making this review because i totally was going to go get the telescopic and after watching this i decided to get the sky high one instead! i'm excited to try it!! :)

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад

      @@bythewayxily of course!!! Let me know how you like the sky high!! It’s still my favorite💕

  • @sofiash
    @sofiash 3 года назад +3

    Wow. Your lashes are amazing!!!

  • @shenalee5572
    @shenalee5572 3 года назад +6

    The sky high did to me what the telescopic did to you. It separated my lashes too much and was very spidery. BUT the fact that it didn’t smudge was very nice.

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +1

      that’s too bad!! I noticed it can separate my lashes too much sometimes but when I start from the base and work my way up it looks more wispy! But the fact that it rarely smudges is amazing!💕

    • @shenalee5572
      @shenalee5572 3 года назад +1

      It is very amazing!!! I noticed that too sometimes it’s more wispy which I prefer and sometimes it separated too much.

    • @mediterranea1983
      @mediterranea1983 2 года назад +2

      @@katecartermakeup hi. So which one is better? I mean for lengthening and volume?

  • @margaretlovesmakeup6441
    @margaretlovesmakeup6441 3 года назад +3

    Hi Kate. I love your lashes! The Sky High wins!

  • @MissStacie-XO
    @MissStacie-XO 3 года назад +1

    Thankyou for a great review once again ♥️
    Lysm ♥️

  • @anavictoria8958
    @anavictoria8958 3 года назад +9

    you should try the maybelline lash discovery for your bottom lashes if you haven’t already ! the wand is super tiny and does a great job on the lower lashes ☺️

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +2

      oooo really!! I have never heard of that! I used to use the Clinique bottom lash mascara but i didn’t want to keep spending the money. Thank you for the suggestion I’ll definitely try it out!💗

    • @anavictoria8958
      @anavictoria8958 3 года назад +2

      @@katecartermakeup ofc ! i think it’s only like $7-8, i would recommend the waterproof version though bc the non-water proof transfers a little on me

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +1

      @@anavictoria8958 ooooo I’ll try the waterproof one then! I bet it’s so easy to apply :)

    • @amandagn4753
      @amandagn4753 2 года назад

      The waterproof one is super waterproof That’s the mascara I use for my lower lashes too

  • @MissStacie-XO
    @MissStacie-XO 3 года назад +10

    I’m sooooo excited to try the sky high now 🙌🏼 yeyyyyy I’m so happy I got it ♥️
    Oh Kate I got that highlight too 😻 ♥️

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +1

      Omg really!!! I’m so excited for you to try both!!! Let me know how u like them!💗💗

  • @tonkacat
    @tonkacat 3 года назад +5

    How are your lashes that long? Do you use some sort of serum? I absolutely love the sky high. Just amazing

  • @irinaermolaeva5520
    @irinaermolaeva5520 3 года назад +5

    You make the best mascara showdown. But sorry I can’t trust your review because you already have very beautiful long lashes 🥰🥰

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад

      Hahahaha thank you!!!! But I understand that!💗💗

  • @emelemel1201
    @emelemel1201 3 года назад +4

    İ bought the sky high one but it doesnt make my lashes long as yours

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад

      my lashes are naturally really long so that could be it :( have you ever tried the loreal telescopic?

    • @emelemel1201
      @emelemel1201 3 года назад +1

      @@katecartermakeup no i will trt that one by the way ilove your videos❤️👑

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад

      @@emelemel1201 thank you so much!!💗

  • @jasminmedina6315
    @jasminmedina6315 3 года назад +1

    Can you compare these two but instead of regular the waterproof versions ??? Pls

  • @annettef.5654
    @annettef.5654 3 года назад +3

    I need to get that mascara!!!

  • @Sayo7MaE
    @Sayo7MaE 3 года назад

    Your bottom lashes are longer than my upper lashes hahahahaha (Crying inside...) thank you for the comparisson :)

  • @siamelizabeth
    @siamelizabeth 3 года назад +8

    try sky high vs teloscopic vs essence lash princess :)

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +3

      I have a wear test on the essence lash princess on my channel! The sky high and telescopic 100% beat it! It doesn’t last well throughout the day on me💗💗

  • @dahyanafernandez1299
    @dahyanafernandez1299 3 года назад +1

    On ur lashes the sky high looks so good but i have seen other reviews and in other people looks so spider legs. Idk why. Now I do not know which one im gonna buy 🤔

  • @TheTinkili
    @TheTinkili 3 года назад +3

    I'm gonna get the Sky High as soon as it's released in Germany. Sadly I have to wait till March 😭

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +1

      oh wow you have to wait till March! That’s such a long time! I bet it’ll be worth the wait though!💗

    • @TheTinkili
      @TheTinkili 3 года назад +1

      @@katecartermakeup Yes!!

  • @arditazeqiri6243
    @arditazeqiri6243 3 года назад +1

    You have such beautiful lashes thanks

  • @farahfuffy3701
    @farahfuffy3701 9 месяцев назад

    How you clear it

  • @annjohnson9187
    @annjohnson9187 2 месяца назад +1

    Do you use the last serum because your lashes are so long or do you naturally grow Them out

  • @candicegaddy1674
    @candicegaddy1674 2 года назад

    How do u think it would look if applied both together?

  • @busrakjh
    @busrakjh Год назад

    Kirpiklerih normalde uzun mu zaten? Greetings from Turkey

  • @argeliacervantes7736
    @argeliacervantes7736 2 года назад

    Did you recommend this in waterproof? Or washable one? Please and thank you.

  • @sudeatila4811
    @sudeatila4811 3 года назад

    Hangi makarayı tercih edersin

  • @jocekhiy626
    @jocekhiy626 3 года назад +1

    The thing scaring me is the wand I heard is weak and break in tube. I was looking for dupes for benefit yes they're real and this one comes up.

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +1

      Oh really? Is it the sky high’s wand that’s breaking in the tube? Or the lash sensational? I haven’t had any problems yet :)

    • @jocekhiy626
      @jocekhiy626 3 года назад +1

      @@katecartermakeup oh oops I meant the telescopic from loreal lol don't know where my brain went . Yeah I chose sky high more even tho I felt telescopic was similar results and less product to achieve. The telescopic has flimsy wand. That many reviews online say easily breaks so I was careful with it .

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +3

      @@jocekhiy626 yes I totally agree with that!!! The telescopic wand is super flimsy I struggle putting it back in the tube. It’s never broken on me though💕

  • @amywaters106
    @amywaters106 2 года назад

    Where are your hoops from please?

  • @stanislavazivkovic4821
    @stanislavazivkovic4821 3 года назад

    Koja je bolja mej bilajn ili teleskopik?

  • @Barmiley
    @Barmiley Год назад

    they are originally Chinese formula

  • @MissStacie-XO
    @MissStacie-XO 3 года назад +3

    #LashQueen 👑

  • @elizabethschwab8778
    @elizabethschwab8778 3 года назад +1

    Is the telescopic lightweight?

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +4

      yes I would say so! Especially with just one coat :)

  • @nalleligarcia9068
    @nalleligarcia9068 3 года назад +1

    How did u grow your lashes

  • @Ася56
    @Ася56 3 года назад

    Ачууметь! У вас в Америке у всех такие ресницы?

  • @jellloooo
    @jellloooo 3 года назад +2

    i wore mascara primer with my sky high mascara and it completely ruined the wand and mascara just clumps up on it😭 i’m getting a new one and i’m not gonna use the primer so i hopeee that it doesn’t mess up again

  • @freeyoumh227
    @freeyoumh227 Год назад

    your lashes are eveything!!! They are so longgg

  • @Davis1211
    @Davis1211 3 года назад +1

    Have you tried the honest beauty 2-in-1 mascara?

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад

      no I haven’t, is it good? :)

    • @Davis1211
      @Davis1211 3 года назад +1

      @@katecartermakeup haven’t tried either but super intrigued bc it seems so popular! I feel like it’s supposed to be good for lengthening / separating but idk about volume? It’s a bit pricey for drugstore so kinda been hesitant to try haha. although to be fair you’re getting 2-in-1 with the primer and mascara with it so maybe it’s fair? plus so many people seem to like it?? would love to see you test it at some point❤️ also curious about covergirl supersizer and nyx on the rise!

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +1

      @@Davis1211 oooooo that sounds interesting! Now that you mention it im pretty sure someone else mentioned how much they like the honest beauty mascara!! I’ll look into it!!💕 I’m pretty sure I used to use the covergirl supersizer but I forget what it’s like! I need to pick it up snd try it out again :) but I’ve never even heard of the nyx! I can’t believe there are so many mascaras out there!!! I’ll try to pick up at least one of these to try!❤️❤️

  • @Ms_Mia357
    @Ms_Mia357 2 года назад

    Your lower lashes are longer than my top lashes! Lol

  • @lisaromero9144
    @lisaromero9144 3 года назад

    This mascara had such a chemical smell that it was unbearable. I smelt it as soon as I opened the tube.

    • @Ruve19
      @Ruve19 10 месяцев назад

      Which one?

  • @DanielaRolo
    @DanielaRolo 3 года назад +4

    Do u have like an eyelashes care routine? Your lashes are super pretty and long 🥺

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +2

      I actually don’t :( my mom has super long lashes and I got them too!💕

  • @lillianacanales8562
    @lillianacanales8562 3 года назад +4

    i love the sky high mascara! 🤍

  • @jamesroy3125
    @jamesroy3125 3 года назад +2

    I got mine today its very good thanks for recommendation

    • @katecartermakeup
      @katecartermakeup  3 года назад +1

      Yay!! That makes me so happy I’m so glad you like it! It’s my FAVORITE!💗

  • @deannag9397
    @deannag9397 3 года назад +1

    I tried the telescopic and I hated it. Making sure I get a good one instead of putting it to waste.