One of the greatest scenes in the history of cinema in my opinion...to never cut during that entire take with hundreds or maybe thousands of extras doing different things is just incredible
As good as Nolans Dunkirk was, the desperation and hopelessness in this scene tops the entire Dunkirk. To know that McAvoys character does not get home alive is heartbreaking.
@@ophelia4236 Seriously lol. Theyre watching a video on youtube of a specific scene in a movie thats over 13 years old now, and theyre complaining about spoilers in the comment section?
@@hiyaman2 because this is Dunkirk on that week in May to June of 1940 not the queue line bs Nolan intended heck even the film reels showed it was crowded and lots of panic
@@ophelia4236 Thx for pointing that out, i lost an overview over the replies. And yeah, why is someone complaing about a 10+ year old film, a specific memoreable scene from that movie and is than wondering when something is spoilerd? xD
I think a really under appreciated part of this scene is the age range of the actors. You can see it especially well with the choir. Some soldiers look as young as 16-17 while others look to be as old as mid 50s-60s with everything else in between. This truly was a war that consumed everyone.
Fun fact: They never intended to make it a long take but had to due to only having the extras and set for a limited time it would have taken longer to a million set ups so they did it in one long setup (take), it wasn't planned but it works so bloody well
The way that the score merges seamlessly with the choir, and that unbearable rise in the music as the camera moves around the front of them is just shattering.
I'm from Belgium and whenever I go swimming in the sea in Nieuwpoort in the evening I look at Duinkerke, and think of the men who made it possible for me to swim in the ocean without war.
'Dear Lord and Father of Mankind... Forgive our foolish ways.." When you consider this is Briony's retelling of Robbie's final days you realise this isn't just the soldiers singing for forgiveness for all the horrible acts they have had to do in war or for the fact that man has created such a horrific mess, those are the lyrics and the words of the writer also asking for the same forgiveness for the terrible deed she did - a forgiveness which she knows is unlikely to be given just as it is unlikely to be given to those who created the mess which Robbie finds himself in...
What we can hear from the choir: With that deep hush subduing all Our words and works that drown The tender whisper of Thy call, As noiseless let Thy blessing fall As fell Thy manna down. Drop Thy still dews of quietness, Till all our strivings cease; Take from our souls the strain and stress, And let our ordered lives confess The beauty of Thy peace. Breathe through the heats of our desire Thy coolness and Thy balm; Let sense be dumb, let flesh retire; Speak through the earthquake, wind, and fire, O still, small voice of calm. Dear Lord and Father of mankind, Forgive our foolish ways! Reclothe us in our rightful mind, In purer lives Thy service find, In deeper reverence, praise. Rise up and follow Thee.
One of the most impressive and haunting sequences in British cinema. Dario Marianelli's music here breaks your heart as you remember all those who never made it back and all those who did but were so horribly scarred. The sequence was famously filmed on Redcar beach with the locals as extras. This morning at 9 am (23 11 22) the blast furnace at the steel works that can be seen in the background was demolished by controlled explosion and the last vestiges of Redcar's biggest employer was no more. I guess as well as being an Elegy for Dunkirk this is now an Elegy for Redcar...
I love the mixture of Dario Marianellis soundtrack with a church song, the lyrics and the only men voices giving the apocalyptical end of war scene that is shown an even more dramatic undertone. My favorite movie scene of all really :) Also so sad because that is the last time he sees daylight before he leaves this world.
Very insightful comments. I turned on subtitles to understand this hymn more. Not sure if lyrics was a turning to the lord or a call to arms, but it sounds haunted, yet beautiful
My grandfather was evacuated through Dunkirk. He almost never spoke about it. But what he did speak of, was the chaos, the uncertainty and desperation. I feel the brief description he gave me, reflects this. A great piece of cinematography.
This is probably one of the most beautiful things I ever viewed in the a film. Just watching it again on RUclips leaves me in awe. Horribly sad to think about all the men who died on that beach.
An intensely moving moment when at 01:34... Dear Lord and Father of mankind, Forgive our foolish ways! Reclothe us in our rightful mind, In purer lives Thy service find, In deeper reverence, praise. In simple trust like theirs who heard Beside the Syrian sea The gracious calling of the Lord, Let us, like them, without a word Rise up and follow Thee. O Sabbath rest by Galilee! O calm of hills above, Where Jesus knelt to share with Thee The silence of eternity Interpreted by love! With that deep hush subduing all Our words and works that drown The tender whisper of Thy call, As noiseless let Thy blessing fall As fell Thy manna down. Drop Thy still dews of quietness, Till all our strivings cease; Take from our souls the strain and stress, And let our ordered lives confess The beauty of Thy peace. Breathe through the heats of our desire Thy coolness and Thy balm; Let sense be dumb, let flesh retire; Speak through the earthquake, wind, and fire, O still, small voice of calm.
Espectacular. Vi 2 veces la peilcula "Atonement", buen argumento y buena pelicula. Pero esta escena de Dunkirk se roba el show. Lastima que fueron los ultimos momentos del muchacho, antes de morir y no poder regresar a Inglaterra.
The tender whisper of Thy call As noiseless let Thy blessing fall As fell Thy manna down As fell Thy manna down Drop Thy still dews of quietness Till all our strivings cease Take from our souls the strain and stress And let our ordered lives confess The beauty of Thy peace The beauty of Thy peace Breathe through the heats of our desire Thy coolness and Thy balm Let sense be dumb, let flesh retire Speak through the earthquake, wind, and fire O still, small voice of calm O still, small voice of calm
when someone finds out I've lost a child, they say they can't imagine....I play them this....I've been searching....looking.......composing with no result worthy for 29 years to somehow capture in music the feelings.....Dario Marianelli succeeded albeit not his goal....this treasure continues to haunt me.....and it's never enough.
That year it competed, the field was quite loaded -- No Country for Old Men, There Will Be Blood, Juno and Michael Clayton. I actually liked all of them (in a top all-time type of way) so I didn't mind who ended up winning.
Nolan's dunkirk is intense, outstanding, and heart stopping. But this scene is breathtaking and pure melancholy. There's no way comparing two complete different things.
@@L24-h8ie can't compare. Different feelings were developed in the 2 movies : nostalgia in the one hand, fear in the second. They both did well. Thanks to Mr Nolan for chosing Dunkirk to film btw.
I swear, everytime I watch this scene or hearing that choir song, I cried. there's tears in my eyes. Especially seeing the fat man with bandage on his head, the old man in the back and the boy behind him, I just cant. I imagine that if they're the men I know, my family, friends, neighbors, I just can't watching them just like that.
Marinello made a masterpiece ... this is so touching deep and deeper ... better is not possible to show the fear and also the hope "I am coming home" (all the time within the choas) 😧
After the deadly storm of doomsday swept through, the setting sun stretched Dunkirk's beach in a long, narrow shadow. Dark bloodstains adorned the muddy military attire, while souls and body fragments lay scattered on the ground. The acrid smoke of gunpowder carried away mournful spirits, which dissipated amidst the requiems of the remaining young soldiers. On the rickety Ferris wheel, the rotating carousel of endless reincarnation, and the stranded sunken ships, one can still see bullet holes and rust stains, carving the eternal crimson scars on the hearts of the lost.
He must have stolen it from a dead German. It makes you wonder about this extra's story. Did he score that kill, or does he like to brag that he did? I'm sure it's technically against dress code to wear it, but I'm sure none of the officers mind as it's obviously a morale booster. And... it's this exactly sort of tiny, humanizing detail that makes this scene work.
People who say that they prefer this amount of rubble and destruction on the beaches of Dunkirk obviously haven't looked at actual footage of the beaches. Nolan's movie is faithful to what the pictures define, so it's a stupid argument to say his movie isn't accurate compared to this. That doesn't discount the incredible power and sorrow of this scene in Atonement however. Even though the scene isn't incredibly accurate when it comes to scenery, it's a monumental shot.
It's not meant to be historicall accurate, it's Briony's thinking/writing of how she thinks it went down, it's even more chaotic because of her guilt 🙄 the two movies have zero in common stop comparing them.
Not actually true. You're looking at a specific group of pictures. Dig a little deeper and you will see how messy the beach was for most of the area. Even if Nolan wanted to show the surreal reality, it still didn't hit anywhere near close as this. Proving that maybe focusing on the cleanness of the beach was a poor choice in the end as it made the film look staged rather than real.
Because they can't bring the horses with them and don't want to leave them for the Germans. It's the same reason they're breaking all the vehicles and burning all of their papers as well.
I get that Atonement never got the recognition it deserved from the masses like Dunkirk did so now people gotta over-correct and bash Dunkirk because it was the “popular” depiction. But anytime someone whines about Dunkirk on an Atonement video, they come across as a contrarian and elitist. Like, we get it. You like the things that aren’t as popular.
Or and hear me out here, they are making valid complaints about Nolan not accurately depicting the war time conditions of Dunkirk because he was too busy obsessing over practical effects. And you calling anyone who points that out and elitist just makes you sound like a blind Nolan Fanboy. Which is much worse.
@@kingkiller5325 Lmao I actually think Atonement is the superior film overall and that Nolan is a good filmmaker, not great. Also, I never called fans defending Atonement’s depiction of Dunkirk elitists lol Read my comment again and this time, try to fully comprehend it.
If an Empire had to be broken against an enemy, Nazi Germany was a worthy cause. India, Canada, Nepal, New Zealand, Australia, South Africa gave their lives against a dark and terrible enemy. Perhaps that was the purpose of the Empire - to be there at that time. As a legacy, perhaps that will do.
This song sang by the soldiers made me tear up so much… i miss you Ifeanyi,rest in peace my friend… I miss u *tears*
One of the greatest scenes in the history of cinema in my opinion...to never cut during that entire take with hundreds or maybe thousands of extras doing different things is just incredible
Senorgusanos indeed an epic shot
No need to cut when you have digital photoshop *taps head*
I agree, this is a masterpiece of cinema.
Totally agree
Absolutely agree.
As good as Nolans Dunkirk was, the desperation and hopelessness in this scene tops the entire Dunkirk. To know that McAvoys character does not get home alive is heartbreaking.
Dude you´ve spoilt me :(
No offense but it isn't exactly smart to read a comment section on a video like this before watching the film.
@@ophelia4236 Seriously lol. Theyre watching a video on youtube of a specific scene in a movie thats over 13 years old now, and theyre complaining about spoilers in the comment section?
@@hiyaman2 because this is Dunkirk on that week in May to June of 1940 not the queue line bs Nolan intended heck even the film reels showed it was crowded and lots of panic
@@ophelia4236 Thx for pointing that out, i lost an overview over the replies. And yeah, why is someone complaing about a 10+ year old film, a specific memoreable scene from that movie and is than wondering when something is spoilerd? xD
_To all the soldiers who sacrified their lifes in wars throughout history, may they rest in heavenly peace._
I felt the exact same thing when watching this scene. It's incredibly sad...
I think of all the soldiers who never came back and I cry
most of them did horrible things.
shut the hell up@@asenturk7579
I think a really under appreciated part of this scene is the age range of the actors. You can see it especially well with the choir. Some soldiers look as young as 16-17 while others look to be as old as mid 50s-60s with everything else in between. This truly was a war that consumed everyone.
My father ( now passed) a ww2 veteran said it was an honor to serve along side the British soldiers. He said they were the bravest men he ever saw.
Fun fact: They never intended to make it a long take but had to due to only having the extras and set for a limited time it would have taken longer to a million set ups so they did it in one long setup (take), it wasn't planned but it works so bloody well
i don't understand how would this shot work with cuts !
The way that the score merges seamlessly with the choir, and that unbearable rise in the music as the camera moves around the front of them is just shattering.
Very well put.
I'm from Belgium and whenever I go swimming in the sea in Nieuwpoort in the evening I look at Duinkerke, and think of the men who made it possible for me to swim in the ocean without war.
'Dear Lord and Father of Mankind... Forgive our foolish ways.."
When you consider this is Briony's retelling of Robbie's final days you realise this isn't just the soldiers singing for forgiveness for all the horrible acts they have had to do in war or for the fact that man has created such a horrific mess, those are the lyrics and the words of the writer also asking for the same forgiveness for the terrible deed she did - a forgiveness which she knows is unlikely to be given just as it is unlikely to be given to those who created the mess which Robbie finds himself in...
Samuel Cox you do realise this is a real hymn composed in the 1800s
@@separatist123 Yes I do haha but it was chosen specifically by no accident I'm sure by the writers...
My God yes, I'd never thought of that. Thank you
come on, that's clearly not what he was saying@@separatist123
What we can hear from the choir:
With that deep hush subduing all
Our words and works that drown
The tender whisper of Thy call,
As noiseless let Thy blessing fall
As fell Thy manna down.
Drop Thy still dews of quietness,
Till all our strivings cease;
Take from our souls the strain and stress,
And let our ordered lives confess
The beauty of Thy peace.
Breathe through the heats of our desire
Thy coolness and Thy balm;
Let sense be dumb, let flesh retire;
Speak through the earthquake, wind, and fire,
O still, small voice of calm.
Dear Lord and Father of mankind,
Forgive our foolish ways!
Reclothe us in our rightful mind,
In purer lives Thy service find,
In deeper reverence, praise.
Rise up and follow Thee.
Thank ❤
One of the most impressive and haunting sequences in British cinema. Dario Marianelli's music here breaks your heart as you remember all those who never made it back and all those who did but were so horribly scarred. The sequence was famously filmed on Redcar beach with the locals as extras. This morning at 9 am (23 11 22) the blast furnace at the steel works that can be seen in the background was demolished by controlled explosion and the last vestiges of Redcar's biggest employer was no more. I guess as well as being an Elegy for Dunkirk this is now an Elegy for Redcar...
What a very moving comment. I am very sorry for Redcar today, many months later.
The steelworks were digitally removed in this scene…
I love the mixture of Dario Marianellis soundtrack with a church song, the lyrics and the only men voices giving the apocalyptical end of war scene that is shown an even more dramatic undertone. My favorite movie scene of all really :) Also so sad because that is the last time he sees daylight before he leaves this world.
Very insightful comments. I turned on subtitles to understand this hymn more. Not sure if lyrics was a turning to the lord or a call to arms, but it sounds haunted, yet beautiful
@@danreedy9061 "Dear God and father of mankind". Look up this hymn.
You are so right, it makes it so powerful. This take is beyond me. Baffled by how perfect it is.
My grandfather was evacuated through Dunkirk. He almost never spoke about it. But what he did speak of, was the chaos, the uncertainty and desperation. I feel the brief description he gave me, reflects this. A great piece of cinematography.
This scene cannot be watched just once... Or even just 10 times. Every time you see something new.
Like peeling back the layers of cheese.
If life was a movie scene, this would be it.
This is probably one of the most beautiful things I ever viewed in the a film. Just watching it again on RUclips leaves me in awe. Horribly sad to think about all the men who died on that beach.
Absolute mad lad at 2:46 holding onto the ferris wheel. As emotional this whole scene is..that particular moment always makes me smile.
I never noticed that
The slightly chubby dude resting on the sand is my favorite. He's just chillin'.
aleays makes me tear up...such an emotional scene
It should with any red blooded Brit too!..
Best Epic scene ever... Perfect music synchro between Denouement theme and 'Dear Lord and Father of Mankind'. Touchable sadness.
Great scene. I love how music slowly blends with singing soldiers. Marvelous and very sad scene.
One of the most beautiful and moving scene ever filmed
An intensely moving moment when at 01:34...
Dear Lord and Father of mankind,
Forgive our foolish ways!
Reclothe us in our rightful mind,
In purer lives Thy service find,
In deeper reverence, praise.
In simple trust like theirs who heard
Beside the Syrian sea
The gracious calling of the Lord,
Let us, like them, without a word
Rise up and follow Thee.
O Sabbath rest by Galilee!
O calm of hills above,
Where Jesus knelt to share with Thee
The silence of eternity
Interpreted by love!
With that deep hush subduing all
Our words and works that drown
The tender whisper of Thy call,
As noiseless let Thy blessing fall
As fell Thy manna down.
Drop Thy still dews of quietness,
Till all our strivings cease;
Take from our souls the strain and stress,
And let our ordered lives confess
The beauty of Thy peace.
Breathe through the heats of our desire
Thy coolness and Thy balm;
Let sense be dumb, let flesh retire;
Speak through the earthquake, wind, and fire,
O still, small voice of calm.
this was filmed on my local beach- my mam use to go watch them set up when she was pregnant with me :)
And I still think of it as a recent film!
For this cinematography should'be won the Oscar.
No hay palabras para describir esta secuencia, simplemente magnífica!
Espectacular. Vi 2 veces la peilcula "Atonement", buen argumento y buena pelicula. Pero esta escena de Dunkirk se roba el show. Lastima que fueron los ultimos momentos del muchacho, antes de morir y no poder regresar a Inglaterra.
The tender whisper of Thy call
As noiseless let Thy blessing fall
As fell Thy manna down
As fell Thy manna down
Drop Thy still dews of quietness
Till all our strivings cease
Take from our souls the strain and stress
And let our ordered lives confess
The beauty of Thy peace
The beauty of Thy peace
Breathe through the heats of our desire
Thy coolness and Thy balm
Let sense be dumb, let flesh retire
Speak through the earthquake, wind, and fire
O still, small voice of calm
O still, small voice of calm
this movie is a masterpiece!
Elena Abelina except when the ending ruined it
when someone finds out I've lost a child, they say they can't imagine....I play them this....I've been searching....looking.......composing with no result worthy for 29 years to somehow capture in music the feelings.....Dario Marianelli succeeded albeit not his goal....this treasure continues to haunt me.....and it's never enough.
May peace be upon you and your child :)
One seamless take. Extraordinary.
No Country For Old Men is amazing, but this film should have won the Oscar for Best Picture!
I love this scene. I think it’s very moving.
It’s shameful we had to abandon our French allies.
How on earth did Atonment not win best picture?
That year it competed, the field was quite loaded -- No Country for Old Men, There Will Be Blood, Juno and Michael Clayton. I actually liked all of them (in a top all-time type of way) so I didn't mind who ended up winning.
it won BAFTA, so that's good
My favorite scene in the movie.
I have not seen Nolan's Dunkirk but Atonement's Dunkirk looks amazing.. Thank you for uploading..this is brilliant
Singing over the strings...heartbreakingly good.
christopher nolan dunkirk should be like this
and it's not quite like this, I think this scene it's actually more dramatic than Nolan's
I loved Dunkirk, I think it's an awesome movie, but this scene of Atonement it's a powerfull, nostalgic and incredible scene, both are unique.
Nolan's dunkirk is intense, outstanding, and heart stopping. But this scene is breathtaking and pure melancholy. There's no way comparing two complete different things.
Rico Fauzan well if it was a love story with no battle scenes or practical effects it probably would have.
@@L24-h8ie can't compare. Different feelings were developed in the 2 movies : nostalgia in the one hand, fear in the second. They both did well. Thanks to Mr Nolan for chosing Dunkirk to film btw.
been rewatching this movie for years, why is it so fucking good
Never seen this movie but this scene is absolutely spectacular
That part with the horses always gets to me. Especially when it looked like that one horse didn’t die instantly
No horses were shot or killed. The horses were trained to fall to the ground at the sound of the blank firing.
@@Nebkheperure837 I mean, I'm sure they know the horses didn't *actually* 'dye'
I swear, everytime I watch this scene or hearing that choir song, I cried. there's tears in my eyes.
Especially seeing the fat man with bandage on his head, the old man in the back and the boy behind him, I just cant. I imagine that if they're the men I know, my family, friends, neighbors, I just can't watching them just like that.
Really a gut wrenching movie and scene. A testament to how much music adds to film. ❤
Marinello made a masterpiece ... this is so touching deep and deeper ... better is not possible to show the fear and also the hope "I am coming home" (all the time within the choas) 😧
Didn't care much for the rest of the movie but this single scene portrayed the hopelessness of the situation much better than Nolan's Dunkirk did.
Was looking for this! Thank you for uploading it..
one of the best scenes in all the war films ❤👌
Makes me cry everytime without fail
Brilliant scene from a brilliant movie. Seen it many times and it never ceases to move me.
WHAT.A.SCENE.
not a single cut. so impressive
What sacrifices they made. Blessings upon them always x
This scene is defination of ART.
The peak of humanity’s achievement.
Joe Wright's direction, Dario Marianelli's score OH JESUS THIS BROKE ME
Exquisitely moving...
i cry every time...
Epic. The soldier at 2:18 was singing something else entirely 😂
I d pay a ticket to watch this 18 times in a row, instead of Nolan's "epic"
Well most of the movie also isn't this, although this is a good movie. Watch this one with your lady, watch Dunkirk with the boys
This scene only is better than all Dunkirk (2017).
The scene is so beatiful.
What a scene....
Perfect reconstruction. So powerful. All of Nolan's Dunkirk can't capture this emotional scene. I keep coming back over and over to rewatch this.
After the deadly storm of doomsday swept through, the setting sun stretched Dunkirk's beach in a long, narrow shadow. Dark bloodstains adorned the muddy military attire, while souls and body fragments lay scattered on the ground. The acrid smoke of gunpowder carried away mournful spirits, which dissipated amidst the requiems of the remaining young soldiers. On the rickety Ferris wheel, the rotating carousel of endless reincarnation, and the stranded sunken ships, one can still see bullet holes and rust stains, carving the eternal crimson scars on the hearts of the lost.
Gorgeous scene.
Epic
*“Take from our souls the strain and stress and let our ordered lives confess the beauty of thy peace”*
Everybody gangsta till the sky starts speaking German.
Where you would have been if you were a british soldier in Dunkirk ? I think I would be drinking laid naked down in the floor 1:20
Сцена с поющим солдатом в "1917" явно была вдохновлена этой сценой! Ну и сам фильм Искупление просто вау!
You now realise someone is hanging from the wheel at 2:50
Mesmerising!!! Well done to all involved. Wonderfull movie
that French soldiers uniform in 0:31 on the right is so cool. What is the name apart from the Adrian helmet?
Blitzofthereich It's the model 1935 uniform with a cloak
thanks
Filmed in my home town
The lyrics... wow... Something I want played at my funeral
God is good.
"...and to dust you shall return.."
One of the soldiers walking with Robbie is wearing an Iron Cross
He must have stolen it from a dead German. It makes you wonder about this extra's story. Did he score that kill, or does he like to brag that he did? I'm sure it's technically against dress code to wear it, but I'm sure none of the officers mind as it's obviously a morale booster.
And... it's this exactly sort of tiny, humanizing detail that makes this scene work.
People who say that they prefer this amount of rubble and destruction on the beaches of Dunkirk obviously haven't looked at actual footage of the beaches. Nolan's movie is faithful to what the pictures define, so it's a stupid argument to say his movie isn't accurate compared to this. That doesn't discount the incredible power and sorrow of this scene in Atonement however. Even though the scene isn't incredibly accurate when it comes to scenery, it's a monumental shot.
that's not entirely true. In many pictures of the aftermath, this picture is actually more accurate.
Dunkirk was bombed to smithereens during the evacuation. This is far more accurate to what it looked like
It's not meant to be historicall accurate, it's Briony's thinking/writing of how she thinks it went down, it's even more chaotic because of her guilt 🙄 the two movies have zero in common stop comparing them.
Not actually true. You're looking at a specific group of pictures. Dig a little deeper and you will see how messy the beach was for most of the area. Even if Nolan wanted to show the surreal reality, it still didn't hit anywhere near close as this. Proving that maybe focusing on the cleanness of the beach was a poor choice in the end as it made the film look staged rather than real.
Never forget
It's a remarkable scene.
Powerful scene...
Why are they shooting the horses?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
Because they can't bring the horses with them and don't want to leave them for the Germans. It's the same reason they're breaking all the vehicles and burning all of their papers as well.
Yep, war forces men to do the necessary. I'm such an animal lover so I hate seeing that but it is what they had to do.
animal lover or "animal lover"??
especially since Germany was very reliant on horses for logistics and transport during the war.
Either or
3:44 that building has recently got turned into a cineworld
Very nice ..
Une pensée pour nos français, malheureusement eux n'avaient pas le temps de chanter...
2:57 "Anyone seen Blake?"
Freedom for all of us and all animals....love is the answer 💖please let us stop every war...
Superb 💜
Lives long in the memory.
Эта композиция так глубоко в душу зашла
"HOW TO WIN AN OSCAR FOR ORIGINAL MUSIC SCORE.......IN ONE SCENE !!
I get that Atonement never got the recognition it deserved from the masses like Dunkirk did so now people gotta over-correct and bash Dunkirk because it was the “popular” depiction. But anytime someone whines about Dunkirk on an Atonement video, they come across as a contrarian and elitist. Like, we get it. You like the things that aren’t as popular.
Complaining about people complaining. This is pure irony my friend. Well done.
Lol found the elitist. Well done, my friend.
Or and hear me out here, they are making valid complaints about Nolan not accurately depicting the war time conditions of Dunkirk because he was too busy obsessing over practical effects.
And you calling anyone who points that out and elitist just makes you sound like a blind Nolan Fanboy. Which is much worse.
@@kingkiller5325 Lmao I actually think Atonement is the superior film overall and that Nolan is a good filmmaker, not great. Also, I never called fans defending Atonement’s depiction of Dunkirk elitists lol Read my comment again and this time, try to fully comprehend it.
I first heard this song in Cinemix and thought this was Dunkirk 2017... Took me literally 3 months to realize it was another movie. o.O
Please someone tell me where to find the lyrics of what the soldiers sing please !!!!!!!
Dear Lord And Father of Mankind
This clip should've included their conversation with Bill Tennant and his staff.
If an Empire had to be broken against an enemy, Nazi Germany was a worthy cause.
India, Canada, Nepal, New Zealand, Australia, South Africa gave their lives against a dark and terrible enemy.
Perhaps that was the purpose of the Empire - to be there at that time. As a legacy, perhaps that will do.
For Elizabeth. R.I.P
why was this not in the film ??
Amazing. There Is more drama in this scene than in the whole Nolan`s movie
This+alcohol=🥺
Who is christopher nolan?
What is the song the choir sings at 1:53? It is incredibly heart warming..
Dear lord and father of mankind
@@centurionsam Thankyou