Planet Nine from Outer Space - K. Batygin - 12/7/2016

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 31 май 2024
  • "Planet Nine from Outer Space" - Konstantin Batygin, Assistant Professor of Planetary Science, Caltech
    Learn more about:
    - Konstantin Batygin's research: web.gps.caltech.edu/~kbatygin
    - 2016 - 17 Watson Lecture Series Season: www.caltech.edu/master-calend...
    - This Lecture: www.caltech.edu/content/konst...
    Produced in association with Caltech Academic Media Technologies. ©2016 California Institute of Technology
  • НаукаНаука

Комментарии • 581

  • @jonwilson6451
    @jonwilson6451 2 года назад +18

    Thank you Konstantin for providing such an engaging, fascinating, and humorous presentation regarding planet 9. I have really enjoyed hearing your interviews about planet 9 via audio, but had not watched a presentation previously and now have an exponentially better grasp on your theories because of the visualizations provided here. Keep at it and I look forward to hearing your name over the coming years and decades and am confident your work will land you in the annals of planetary science history.

  • @crackerjax4330
    @crackerjax4330 4 года назад +11

    This guy is a great public speaker. bravo!

  • @ldinsmore
    @ldinsmore 2 года назад +2

    Came here after Lex's interview. I also picked up The Black Cloud based on Konstantin's recommendation. Freaking loving it.

  • @RyanAustinDean
    @RyanAustinDean 4 года назад +128

    One of the best scientific talks I’ve ever seen.
    (Wipes off cookie crumbs from my t-shirt at 1:00 AM)

    • @macswanton9622
      @macswanton9622 4 года назад +6

      you got cookies?

    • @Encephalitisify
      @Encephalitisify 4 года назад +3

      I buy Girl Scout cookies en masse for these late night escapes on you tube.

    • @Anita_Bath
      @Anita_Bath 4 года назад

      your sense of humor
      pains me significantly
      facepalming hard
      that was a haiku,
      in case you missed it

    • @macswanton9622
      @macswanton9622 4 года назад

      @@Anita_Bath Facepalming REAL hard... would make it a haiku

    • @sandrafrederick4923
      @sandrafrederick4923 4 года назад +1

      For me, 2:00 am, sitting in my car with mini cinnamon swirls. Very enjoyable talk.

  • @mesample1705
    @mesample1705 5 лет назад +10

    I watched this lecture after watching Mike Brown's lecture, Konstantin's project partner. which includes descriptions of a constant language difference struggle. Their partnership and friendship must be joyful. Their project a beautiful example of analyzing the last decade's astronomical data, making predictions, and with existing instrumentation, they are looking for confirmation. I sympathize with the individual having the office which separates these two at Cal Tech.

  • @rolfvansoelen8916
    @rolfvansoelen8916 3 года назад +5

    Very clear, easy-to-follow presentation that never feels dry thanks to his great way of presenting this stuff. It kept me tight to my screen from start to finish. Magnificent job!

  • @katim2644
    @katim2644 6 лет назад +27

    This shit sets my mind on fire! If only I were young. I remember sneaking into the university in town to look up peer-reviewed papers, as a junior high schooler, using a card catalogue. If only women of my generation weren't only taught how to keep a cheque book and cook beef stew. What I wouldn't give to be in Dr. Batygin's class. You guys are so blessed beyond belief! I didn't have a choice, but you do. Don't let me down!

    • @susanh695
      @susanh695 6 лет назад +2

      Kat I M I totally agree with you to never stop learning. I study college lectures and Konstantin Batygin is a favorite educator of mine. Have you tried Coursera? You can download Coursera from Google Play. Mike Brown has a lecture series on our solar system it is so useful. I would love to sit in their classes but my home is in Florida.

    • @normmacdonaldrules4602
      @normmacdonaldrules4602 4 года назад +3

      Have any good Beef Stew recipes?

    • @thefarmersdaughter8235
      @thefarmersdaughter8235 4 года назад +6

      Hey, hey there are women who cook beef stew and enjoy talking about Nibiru!

    • @stevedavenport7281
      @stevedavenport7281 Год назад

      he is an excellent professor, the kind that inspires to students to lifelong learning.

    • @stevelenores5637
      @stevelenores5637 Год назад

      Did you know planet Vulcan was predicted by the most famous French astronomer at the time. Planet 9 is likely to share the same fate. If I were representing caltech I'd pull this video and any copies of it.

  • @dennissalisbury496
    @dennissalisbury496 4 года назад +14

    Excellent presentation, really smart people have interesting insights.

    •  2 года назад

      Thanks.

  • @IanValentine147
    @IanValentine147 2 года назад +3

    After his interview with Lex Freidman this lecture is an amazing revelation.

  • @kristinowens899
    @kristinowens899 3 года назад +7

    This is so fascinating to me!!
    This man explains everything so well!!!
    Really like this guy, and he looks so young!!

    • @mtklaric
      @mtklaric 2 года назад

      He is a great marketing prop for more money grants...

  • @akesha4138
    @akesha4138 3 года назад +7

    Thank you for this very fine, well planned presentation. You are very good at keeping listeners interested.

  • @physicsodyssey6578
    @physicsodyssey6578 6 месяцев назад +1

    Very entertaining and educational. Thank you Konstantin. My high school physics students have enjoyed it. Been playing it since 2016. Hope you find it!!
    I think of chaos theory and say to myself that it is remarkable that these odd asteroid Kuiper belt orbits showed up in so many of the simulations.

  • @BeastyDub
    @BeastyDub 3 года назад +9

    Sad that talks like this 5 years later still doesn’t have even 600k views but dumb tiktok video gets millions in like a week.

    • @Brian-vk6tz
      @Brian-vk6tz 5 месяцев назад +1

      It's ALL THEORY 😂, its NOT FACT

    • @fareemvenosa3774
      @fareemvenosa3774 3 месяца назад

      ​@Brian-vk6tz so is White privilege, but they still get millions of views.

  • @ezekielbeckett5396
    @ezekielbeckett5396 4 года назад +5

    Awesome presentation.. a nice blend of science and humor.

  • @Brian-zo1ll
    @Brian-zo1ll 4 года назад +7

    One of the most interesting lectures Ive heard in a while.

    • @Big.Ron1
      @Big.Ron1 4 года назад

      Agreed. If my professors had lectured like this i might have got better grades. I helps i suppose that this is a interesting topic to me.

  • @lucidfiredragon77
    @lucidfiredragon77 4 года назад +2

    We are looking for something like ourselves. Something consistent, yet forever changing.

  • @user-sq9gr8qu4l
    @user-sq9gr8qu4l 5 лет назад +53

    This is probably the most pleasant presentation i have ever seen! Very well done!

  • @huntster1701
    @huntster1701 7 лет назад +75

    Fantastic lecture, and humorous too!

  • @barrywhite9114
    @barrywhite9114 3 года назад +2

    This could explain the polar reversals every 500,000 to 700,000 years, the magnetic North Pole moving into Siberia & everywhere else, global warming as a result of the loss of our Van Allen Protective Shield. Taking all the planetary & solar angular planes in computer analysis Will indicate where to look for the approach of Planet Nine.

  • @nomcognom2332
    @nomcognom2332 7 лет назад +41

    Great presentation! I really enjoyed it.

  • @cindyloutaylor3842
    @cindyloutaylor3842 4 года назад +28

    Wow! That is one of the best presentations I've ever seen! I bet his students love him

    • @beautifulcrazy
      @beautifulcrazy 3 года назад +1

      I'd flirt with him. such rosey cheeks. Awesome presentation.

  • @contingenceBoston
    @contingenceBoston 5 лет назад +23

    This guy is actually funny; not just like, _TedX slideshow clipart pun_ funny. Fascinating lecture 👍

  • @thecosmologist
    @thecosmologist 4 года назад +9

    Thanks for an interesting and thoroughly enjoyable lecture.

  • @0371998
    @0371998 Год назад

    He is a good speaker, I cant go out When He speaks. He is very good into his interactive process.

  • @ritajean2695
    @ritajean2695 Год назад

    Excellent presenter. I first noticed him on Lex Fridman. He has a way of humbly delivering knowledge while keeping one's attention with humor. Love it! Adore him!

  • @jamescreek1319
    @jamescreek1319 4 года назад +6

    Planet 9 or Planet X or nibiru is out there and it comes around to the near earth elliptical orbit every 3.600 years and is Due to come back in 2036 or 2046 something like that it’s coming from behind the sun but should be able to know for sure that it’s there soon.

    • @normawaller785
      @normawaller785 2 года назад

      People its true i heard about this planet 6 years ago nobody believed but here it is. My daughter goes on tik tak. And shoes pictures of this thing shows of on her camera on her phone. You can see it in a clear sky she points the camera st the sun and you can see it plain as day try it you'll see it yourself. Please get your heart right with JESUS we don't have much time left ask Jesus to come into your heart. And to forgive you for all your sins. Ask him to be the lord of your live . When you do this you will be born again. And will go to heaven. To be with him for eternity. A lot of people will die when this planet comes by the earth. God bless and trust the lord all the way.

    • @marcel84marcel
      @marcel84marcel 2 года назад

      From behind the sun? 🤦🤣

  • @GhostDrummer
    @GhostDrummer 4 года назад +3

    Ok, I barely understand anything math and science. Science wasn’t difficult, but in a private homeschool program, I never had science classes; just some text books on basic science, no experimenting or anything hands on. Math though, math was always a challenge...but not challenging. I know, that may not make a lot of sense. Math was a constant struggle because I didn’t have teachers for each subject. Anytime I needed help, I would be told to figure it out. I’m not ignorant about math; I know the basic functions of math, I just never was able to grasp it. I don’t think I’m dyslexic, but the textbooks I had to use would have a page of simple instructions and examples, which got me started out ok, but as soon as that little sample page was done, the following pages exploded into massively complex problems that the previous examples didn’t explain. I simply could not grasp any of it.
    But looking back on my life, I’ve discovered that I have always been a hands on person. As a kid I would tinker and take things apart and reassemble them. Most jobs were all hands on training. Never attended college or trade schools, but I’ve worked in hospitals, dialysis clinics, surgery centers, diesel mechanic, and ultimately LE where I was medically retired in 2013. Now, I’ve had extensive training for LE, but honestly, I just took a test, was 6th out of 250 applicants, got hired, and then after 8 months working off in house training, I was sent out for classroom and tactical training.
    I taught myself to play the drums, kind of learned the piano, bass/acoustic guitar, singing, mix sound, and pretty much anything music. Learned how to wrench on cars out of necessity more than desire due to not being able to afford a repair bill. Learned how to fix things around my house for similar reasons. I know I’m not the only one who’s done the exact same thing...but my point to all of this is, had I been taught by people such as Konstantin, I most likely would have been able to grasp math.

    • @Moon-zc2yk
      @Moon-zc2yk 4 года назад

      Nice vent to the internet girly

    • @GhostDrummer
      @GhostDrummer 4 года назад

      Zempathys if that’s venting, you’re a pussy...see, I can be a keyboard warrior too.

  • @atomiclemon77
    @atomiclemon77 5 лет назад +21

    Fantastic lecture, well delivered.

  • @klausgartenstiel4586
    @klausgartenstiel4586 7 лет назад +43

    very entertaining! i want to see more from this guy.

    • @user-qs9kd3ir4p
      @user-qs9kd3ir4p 3 года назад

      if you could understand russian , I would be really impressed by his interview in famous channel:" вДудь"!! Greatest conversation I've ever seen

    • @xcidgaf
      @xcidgaf 2 года назад

      @@user-qs9kd3ir4p Thanks for the tip. The interview is perfectly translated to English btw

  • @khalidrashid2092
    @khalidrashid2092 3 года назад +2

    Great lecture on the mystery sorrounding the ninth planet. Wonder of the planet has been found? From a retired physics teacher

  • @brainstormingsharing1309
    @brainstormingsharing1309 3 года назад +4

    Absolutely well done and definitely keep it up!!! 👍👍👍👍👍

  • @freenational
    @freenational 3 года назад +2

    That's amazing. How many people have scanned the sky with their naked eyes and observed the belt of Orion, as if it was home.

  • @lartele9517
    @lartele9517 4 года назад +1

    Thank you very much
    and all the best!

  • @peesweezy4553
    @peesweezy4553 3 года назад +1

    Love this guy he was on Veritasium

  • @bimmjim
    @bimmjim 6 лет назад +2

    Excellent Lecture. I must get it to my Astronomy Club members.

  • @zioo3117
    @zioo3117 4 года назад +2

    1) Does magnetism (gravitational pull) vary with the temperature of the heavier elements? (Also something to do with density). 2) Now I know how sometimes, when I get a bolt cross-threaded, as it heads into the engine block, it has everything to do with Planet 9. I appreciate having made this determination on the basis of planet 9. What are the odds that any other star/planet system are just like ours. It is pretty cool that Planet 9 can be determined to be the reason that our sun has a 6 degree inclination, or whatever those degrees off of Zero. Some one told me that every thing is in the Orion Constellation. AF

  • @andreynova4490
    @andreynova4490 Год назад +1

    Astronomer and stand up comedian 2-in-1. Great work!

  • @MMAoracle
    @MMAoracle 7 лет назад +5

    Awesome lecture

  • @whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
    @whaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa 4 года назад +5

    Somewhere out there Konstantin is still being introduced.

  • @veronicastewart1112
    @veronicastewart1112 4 года назад +1

    This was really fascinating.

  • @pmudub517
    @pmudub517 4 года назад +2

    Fantastic presentation 👏

  • @MaximRedin
    @MaximRedin 3 месяца назад +1

    So nice presentation. It was nice to watch it, enjoyed watching... Thanks. And i am sure, Konstantin is very talented. Please go on investigation. Btw, I am watching you from Russia

  • @DerekR1983
    @DerekR1983 3 года назад +1

    great presentation

  • @danielbaenziger6476
    @danielbaenziger6476 4 года назад +1

    This kid came so far since slaying that vampire gang in Santa Cruz. Remarkable.

    • @danielbaenziger6476
      @danielbaenziger6476 4 года назад +1

      In a more sober top - I really appreciate the research this man and his team are conducting. Thanks ya'll!! Clear skies! Hope you find it!

  • @xpepchaoticx
    @xpepchaoticx 7 лет назад +8

    Wow. I am looking at orion right now. Dec 29th 3am. Had my eyes have huge sensitive detectors built in behind them I'd be looking at it! Do find it Doc!

  • @user-og5fc5rt8g
    @user-og5fc5rt8g 5 лет назад +17

    perfect talk, funny and persuasive, after that I can only believe anything he says....thank you

  • @astrazenica7783
    @astrazenica7783 3 года назад

    I like the sound of CalTech

  • @subhamoytarafder1163
    @subhamoytarafder1163 2 года назад

    Excellent presentation

  • @danconser6709
    @danconser6709 4 года назад +28

    Make the Solar System Great Again.... Hysterical!!!

  • @DudesRights
    @DudesRights 4 года назад

    Nicely put together

  • @mildredmarbach5937
    @mildredmarbach5937 4 года назад +1

    BRILLIANT!!!

  • @Dagnabit888
    @Dagnabit888 2 года назад +1

    16 y.o. me : who cares
    28 y.o. me : falls asleep to these fascinating lectures

  • @hadamerryweather577
    @hadamerryweather577 6 лет назад +9

    Very clear presentation of data. Gifted researcher indeed.

  • @sagezen6414
    @sagezen6414 4 года назад +1

    Great Video!

  • @zblackrider
    @zblackrider 6 лет назад +4

    Great intro

  • @Lovepeachesss
    @Lovepeachesss 4 года назад +8

    just came here after wathcing his interview on russian youtube channel Вдудь and i did not see that coming how really smart and comical he is. Why i havent heard about him before

  • @bobibest89
    @bobibest89 7 лет назад +14

    Awesome. Great dude.

  • @kateshend
    @kateshend 4 года назад +1

    I am so happy to find him on YT, an outstanding speaker, watched all the videos with him. Wish him luck in finding this 9 th planet

  • @skysky-mx1cz
    @skysky-mx1cz 4 года назад +1

    Thankyou. Your Wise.

  • @kembaraoverlandexplorer7689
    @kembaraoverlandexplorer7689 3 года назад

    Right now we found Planet 9.
    Maybe in year by year ,we have another 90 soon.
    They are coming to us closer day by day.

  • @tertiusthiart8417
    @tertiusthiart8417 4 года назад +1

    A great guy !!!

  • @paulneilson6117
    @paulneilson6117 4 года назад

    You nailed it boss.

  • @Gatazaf
    @Gatazaf 6 лет назад +33

    Scientists are entertaining these days :-D Excellent presentation!

    • @lazurm
      @lazurm 4 года назад +4

      Physicists have always been very entertaining. Feynman is but one example as are many others.

    • @raidermaxx2324
      @raidermaxx2324 4 года назад +2

      Lol, republicans would have us believe they dont know what they are talking about, and science bad!!!

    • @summeronio9751
      @summeronio9751 4 года назад

      Faraday?

    • @futavadumnezo
      @futavadumnezo 3 года назад

      Gordon Freeman is one of the most entertaining scientists.

  • @DownhillAllTheWay
    @DownhillAllTheWay 4 года назад +4

    I can accept how the position of a new planet can be found from the perturbations of the orbit of the previous planet - but what were the techniques, so long ago, for _measuring_ the perturbations of the previous planet. It's not as if it did an orbit in the meantime - it only moved a little bit, and in that small distance, they already had determined where it was vs where it should have been. How?

    • @kimlarso6622
      @kimlarso6622 3 года назад

      Great question!......Reset theory comes to mind=Makes sense so I always stay open minded

  • @itskill1082
    @itskill1082 4 года назад +57

    Вдудь раскрутил космос круче чем Рогозин!!

    • @tputopora7133
      @tputopora7133 4 года назад

      Только не наш, а американский 😆

    • @turtle207
      @turtle207 4 года назад

      Зато рогозин круче раскрутил коррупицию.

    • @AverageAmerican
      @AverageAmerican 4 года назад

      Вы не слышали? Он плоский! Иисус так говорит. Кристендом разрушит Наса. И сведи Строителя Башни вниз. Он не будет подниматься на Небеса в ближайшее время. Кроме того, инопланетяне являются субназемных ... Сумасшедший мир.

  • @gracevalentine1666
    @gracevalentine1666 6 лет назад +4

    May I ask if and where I can get a transcript of this video, especially the introduction by "Dave." I would give everything to have a mentor like that, and to be introduced in the way Professor Batygin was.

    • @zoeholzer3084
      @zoeholzer3084 5 лет назад

      RUclips has transcripts for its subtitles, although these are not always completely accurate.

  • @papacowboy
    @papacowboy 4 года назад

    Interesting lecture, fun lecture

  • @stage274
    @stage274 7 лет назад +3

    Awesome bro.. Congratulations on the discovery!!! Um, I am just wondering, how fixed is the orbit? Can it be longer like 24 or 25 thousand years?

  • @michaelmills9105
    @michaelmills9105 3 года назад +1

    Huh. I missed all the visuals. It came on by accident, through my Bluetooth while I was driving. I almost shut it off. But I couldn't. It was fascinating! Quick hour! I like how they gave credit to those who weren't there that contributed to this finding.
    "Everything has to do with planet 9"

  • @augievegas
    @augievegas 7 лет назад +7

    Great job, best luck finding the planet. Very entertaining and interesting lecture.

    • @SK-to4ls
      @SK-to4ls 6 лет назад

      augievegas go check a channel called expitaly the planet's have been found

    • @atriciacannon4579
      @atriciacannon4579 4 года назад

      How about talking about the approach of the planet "X" system.💀

  • @AAYTQN
    @AAYTQN 5 лет назад +1

    Very very good🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

  • @ToriMoto
    @ToriMoto 4 года назад +1

    Does Planet 9 have any relationship to the comet - C/2019 Y4 (ATLAS) - currently passing through our solar system?

  • @magnoliamike
    @magnoliamike 4 года назад +2

    The greatest “Bad” movie of all time
    by the great Ed Wood

    • @kenlieck7756
      @kenlieck7756 4 года назад

      And Steven Spielberg's blockbuster about a homesick space alien!
      (plan *ET* nine from outer space)

  • @macswanton9622
    @macswanton9622 4 года назад +4

    If he sings "Pop Goes the Weasel" at the end, or plays a conga drum, I'll bust a gut.

    • @macswanton9622
      @macswanton9622 4 года назад

      All likes agree he looks like Andy Kaufman

  • @robertootero8535
    @robertootero8535 3 года назад +2

    Hello I wanted to ask you a question can Voyager 1 and 2 spot planet nine at its current position

  • @moonpuppy9291
    @moonpuppy9291 6 лет назад +1

    Awesome

  • @MagnusThatShinyUmbreon
    @MagnusThatShinyUmbreon 2 месяца назад +1

    We finding Planet 9 with this one
    I dont know what to say. Im watching this in March 2024. My dream is to try and pick up where Mike Brown and Konstantin Batygin and try to find it, that is if they don't find it first. I believe that in my lifetime, we'll find it

    • @Variant1on1
      @Variant1on1 7 дней назад

      Probably. How old are you?

    • @MagnusThatShinyUmbreon
      @MagnusThatShinyUmbreon 7 дней назад +1

      @@Variant1on1 Me rn: 13 years old

    • @Variant1on1
      @Variant1on1 6 дней назад

      @@MagnusThatShinyUmbreon That’s amazing that you’re interested in such important things and have such great aspirations at your age. Follow your dreams! ✨ 🪐

    • @Variant1on1
      @Variant1on1 6 дней назад

      @@MagnusThatShinyUmbreon And I think they’ll find it in your lifetime too!

    • @MagnusThatShinyUmbreon
      @MagnusThatShinyUmbreon 5 дней назад +1

      Thank you

  • @SafirJamil
    @SafirJamil 7 лет назад +20

    What happened to the q&a?

  • @dejagerjossy8717
    @dejagerjossy8717 4 года назад +4

    Hope to see more of this guy, really good.

  • @infocat13
    @infocat13 7 лет назад +1

    Can kepler-2 observe 20 degrees to look for this objects ?

  • @pajlisthoj9898
    @pajlisthoj9898 4 года назад

    Good stuff

  • @deejames6371
    @deejames6371 4 года назад +2

    Great Presentation, once again!.....
    Is there any work being done to actually map Our Local Group Birkeland Electric Field Pathways?

    • @EthelredHardrede-nz8yv
      @EthelredHardrede-nz8yv 4 года назад +1

      "y map Our Local Group Birkeland Electric Field Pathways?"
      Its been done already. They are entirely imaginary.

  • @Severe_CDO_Sufferer
    @Severe_CDO_Sufferer 4 года назад +3

    @48:18 did he say "current?"
    Because if you aren't considering "currents" (as in electrical / Birkeland currents) then You Should Be !!!

  • @asustablet7115
    @asustablet7115 4 года назад +2

    Hello from Kazan!

  • @olr3654
    @olr3654 4 года назад +4

    Where would it have been about 12500 years ago?

    • @olr3654
      @olr3654 4 года назад

      @witkrieg todd I have read repeatedly your message, so much info, trying to understand it, wish you did a video on it

  • @kaycejay2168
    @kaycejay2168 3 года назад +2

    Great presentation. Any new developments? :)

  • @anijahxreer
    @anijahxreer 3 года назад

    So how do you by part the history of kemetic sciences

  • @michaelexman5474
    @michaelexman5474 4 года назад

    nice!!!

  • @MaximRedin
    @MaximRedin 3 месяца назад

    Let's name the planet 9 as "Yugoth" (as in Howard Lovecraft 's books). It can be scary, but it worth this name

  • @tyronescott9009
    @tyronescott9009 3 года назад

    How can i get involved in helping with science events because im an event planner this is what il do forever

  • @kentitus7550
    @kentitus7550 3 года назад

    Our space force has been out there since the early fifties and have visited many planet since then. This looking for planets with a telescope is like horse and buggy days stuff. Looking for planets with a telescope is now obsolete. For a hobby though I guess it is OK. Find something else to do with your time but then again it is your time. We also already have colonies on other planets. I thank you for taking what is a dull subject for me and made your talk interesting.

  • @49fa75
    @49fa75 4 года назад +1

    The resemblance of his charisma with that of Feynman's is uncanny.

  • @aresmars2003
    @aresmars2003 7 лет назад

    If planet nine have aligned the eTNO over billions of years, and then say another star "captured" P9 from the solar system, how long would it take for the eTNO alignment to destabilize? (That could be a reason we've not seen it, if it was lost 10 million years ago for instance.)

  • @daledelatte9607
    @daledelatte9607 4 года назад

    So what is the status of the search? Any news?

  • @chetanp07
    @chetanp07 7 лет назад +3

    One thing I noticed in your simulations, that you kept the orbit of Planet nine constant. it's orbit must be deviated during 4.5 billion years? If Planet nine deviated or affected the orbits of other bodies then other bodies must have had affected the orbit of planet nine because of large solar bodies or planets like Neptune?

    • @Erkynar
      @Erkynar 7 лет назад +2

      Chetan Patil
      The co-author of the paper, Mike Brown, comments on that in one of his talks, in the Q&A part. It should be in the suggested viewing queue.

    • @kev.6149
      @kev.6149 4 года назад

      Chetan Patil great comment. If you think of where Jupiter, Saturn, Neptune and Uranus are in our solar system. In theory they are in the wrong place. At the beginning of our solar system the Hydrogen and Helium cloud which made up our Sun and gas planets started in the centre of our system. Why are these gas giants now the outer planets? Pretty much all the solar systems which have been found have these gas giants very close to their sun. Something put our gas giants into the outer orbits. Planet X?

  • @davehallett3128
    @davehallett3128 4 года назад

    Ed wood is proud you remembered his movie

    • @doughyjoey_8742
      @doughyjoey_8742 4 года назад

      That gravestone fell over!
      "Nobody will ever notice that. Filmmaking is not about the tiny details. It's about the big picture."

  • @TheMaitreya777
    @TheMaitreya777 5 лет назад +2

    Why not call planet 9 Pluto? It will go very well with the explanation of Pluto in Astronomy as well: A mysterious planet that is hard to fathom (like Scorpion it represents). These Characteristics were falsely given to the old Puloto. Now we know that small dwarf planet did not deserve it. So we can call old Pluto: Dwarf Pluto (or maybe Pluto wants to be:), or something else).

  • @zapfanzapfan
    @zapfanzapfan 7 лет назад +28

    Awesome lecture! "Is DR30 a street drug?" :-)

  • @HiR0SHi.the.D0G
    @HiR0SHi.the.D0G 4 года назад +2

    That's a strong case for Planet 9, or as I call it, "Planet 9b"

  • @yourhealinghome8812
    @yourhealinghome8812 4 года назад +2

    From the perspective of an interested bystander, (factory laborer) it seems to me that the Orbits of these distant bodies are responding to the entire solar system as a point source of gravity as one of the foci of their orbital elipses. Could there be another field of gravity drawing the many elipses of their orbits to that region of space where their other foci seem to gather?

    • @sarahvegangarden4822
      @sarahvegangarden4822 4 года назад

      Dude, join an astronomy discussion group on Reddit or a good university or wherever, so you can meet intellectual peers online and contribute to knowledge. Posting a question like that here probably won't get you what you need. It seems to me you need more interaction with people who understand and can address your comment properly. Best of luck!

    • @versewriter8123
      @versewriter8123 3 года назад

      @@sarahvegangarden4822
      Sometimes smart people can hypothesise correctly & don't need a mortor board & gown. Actually, both Einstein & Tesla spoke of receiving knowledge intuitively - sometimes even in dreams