That was one death I can’t forgive her for. It hits too close to home. My twin was stillborn and there’s been an empty hole my whole life. How she could inflict that fate on the twins just killed me. The pain never goes away. You always know something is missing and it’s just awful.
She had to kill somebody that was close to Harry to make it more realistic. When there is a massive battle at least one person dies in a family. That’s just life.
In the book Tonks was bubbly, happy, always had pink hair up until Sirius died, which made her depressed, then after she got with Remus, she was happy again. In the movie she was a punk, weird person who I don’t like very much.
Snape: Expecto Petronum Dumbledore: Lily! After all this time? Snape: Always. Or from the book “Dumbledore opened his eyes. Snape looked horrified. ‘You’ve kept him alive so that he can die at the right moment?’ ‘Don’t be shocked, Severus. How many men and women have you watched die?’ ‘Lately, only those whom I could not save,’ said Snape. ‘You have used me.’ ‘Meaning?’ ‘I have spied for you and lied for you, put myself in mortal danger for you. Everything was supposed to be to keep Lily Potter’s son safe. Now you tell me that you have been raising him like a pig for slaughter-’ ‘But this is touching, Severus,’ said Dumbledore seriously. ‘Have you grown to care for the boy, after all?’ ‘For him?’ shouted Snape. ‘Expecto patronum!’ From the tip of his wand burst the silver doe: she landed on the office floor, bounded once across the office and soared out of the window. Dumbledore watched her fly away, and as her silvery glow faded he turned back to Snape, and his eyes were full of tears. ‘After all this time?’ ‘Always,’ said Snape.” He's not talking about his love for Lily. He's talking about his regret for destroying their friendship and deeply hurting someone he loved. When she died he knew he could never do anything about the damage he had done. He could never make it right. Him Turning on Voldemort and helping Harry despite hating everything about him that reminded him about his tormentor was 100% about trying in some way to make up for hurting Lily all those years ago and taking their friendship from her and hurting her so deeply. For knowing that he not only drove her away and into James' arms but also created the situation where they had to choose a secret keeper that wasn't him likely causing her death. Dumbledore is surprised that Snape still hasn't forgiven himself for what he did to Lily after all this time despite everything he's done. Snape is lost in thoughts of Lily and how he can never forgive himself. I highly doubt he ever did.
@@bendover-sz1sv because it shows that he still loves and cares for lilly because you can have the same patronus as someone else if you're really in love with her or him
I have 8 favorites, snap, Draco malfoy, Harry Potter, Ron, Hermione I think, and hagrid, and the old man who picked up Harry when he was borned at season 1, and the woman mgnongl I don't know but I love them soo much but my favorite favorite was Snape I feel soo bad about this my sister was a big fan of him to
The durselys gave harry a toothpick a coin and a tissue for Christmas The toothpick is the elder wand The coin is the resurrection stone The tissue is the Invisablity cloak Edit:this is the most likes I got thanks guys 💕☺️💕
@@sanjeevreddyar4823 I'm the fake one?It's a joke firstly,and just cuz you don't have a sense of humour you don't have to be rude. Secondly, if you're a real fan you'd know she's homophobic, transphobic and more. We're all against her even though she made the Harry potter books.
I really hated several of the characters getting killed but the one that got me the most, almost no one ever mentions. I was late to the franchise. The last book had just been released when I started them. Several friends on Facebook were into them and had even stood outside bookstores forever to get new releases. I remember screaming when I started the last book and then exclaimed on Facebook, “They killed Hedwig!”
Deaths were normal they were at war deaths made it feel realistic if none of them died then why would they be afraid of voldemort and the death eaters if they couldv’e easily beaten them. I loved everything about the series even if some amazing characters died, imo it made the series even better.
“Arthur being the only good father...” I’m sorry what about Remus Lupin, he maybe didn’t last enough time with Teddy but he was great while it lasted, What about James he and Lily sacrificed themselves for Harry
Kimberly...Remus' son was a tike still in "nappies" as the Brits say, so he didn't have any quality time with son. Anyway, most of the characters, as we say, wouldn't have died in their beds with their desire to fight off evil!
Put your bias and favorites aside. Arthur was a good father. He had a hard job but was always in a good mood. He made and rised six children, instead of abandoning them when times got tough. Even though he wasn't rich with money, he was rich with family, loving and appreciating them. And his curiosity with Muggles makes him like a child, ready to learn. We can't really base good fathers on guys that have such young children, like James and Lupin. They *could have been* great, but there's not enough evidence yet. Even if they're your favorites, doesn't mean your personal headcanon is correct.
@@chatboulon743 6 children? Excuse me? You seem to be forgetting one there. Bill, Charlie, Percy, Fred, George, Ron, Ginny. Thats 7. Which one did you forget?
James Potter didnt sacrifice himself! He simply got killed. Also, we dont know how good he would have been as a father. In book 5 after Occlumency Harry gets shocked for he realises his dad was exactly as boastful and mean as Snape described him.
I think Dudley telling Harry he didn’t think he was a waste of space is a better scene then Petunia saying she was sad about losing her sister. That’s just common sense. Anyone that has a sibling knows about sibling rivals all too well. They also know that most wouldn’t hesitate to donate one of their kidneys to try and save their sibling.
Through out the films Petunia was still fascinated by the Wizarding World. Especially when Harry sent Marge into space. I think deep down she enjoyed it.
@@marinazagrai1623 that's bull, "sisters are much closer" is the biggest load of horseshit i've ever read and i'm dumber for doing so. Nobody can be closer than me and my siblings. they can however be as close. I have brothers AND sisters. 3 each
I agree 2:40. I ACTUALLY cried when I read the part where Lupin and Tonks lay together on the floor. I had to read it a few times. Lupin was my favorite. 😕😔
I'm so sick of everyone making her apologise: I never heard Lucas apologise for Jar Jar, but Rowling has had to apologise for every thing. If you don't like what happens in the story, then don't read or watch it.
There's a difference here... Rowling apologizes for killing off her characters, because she's connected to them. It's what good writers do. When I'm writing, I make the hard decision to kill off some of my characters, if only to develop another from the tragedy. Lucas is just a greedy fucker who wants money. Actually sold everything to Disney for *money*. 🤑 Jar Jar is an abomination and he knows it...
jk Rowling did a good job with making you fall in love with characters and then making you extremely sad when the characters died That's life itself and the rollercoaster of emotions that we experience I'm glad she didn't hold back
I'm surprised people hadn't realised that they were related, Tom's grandfather is said to prise the ring which contains the stone and was more interested in his linage than anything else, and the cloak comes down father/mother to son/daughter. Making both Harry and Tom related to two of the bothers and therefore to eachother.
I cry my eyes out when I was reading the books when dobby and lupin were kill off. To the point my brother came in and asked what happened when he realized I was reading the 7th book he walked off he was still on the 5th book at that time
People saying they can't forgive J.K. Rowling. On the other hand I admire her talent. Like she created an entire magical universe with so much of time and work. Not everyone can do this. Yes those deaths made me sad, but that's what stories are, it shows that not everything happens according to your wish. Reality is always different.
I had always thought that Petunia Dursely treated Harry the way she die, because she blamed him for her sister's death even though Harry was a baby at the time. Possibly she blamed him as his father's son, because his father wasn't alive to blame.
No, she was sick with jealousy of Lily and her magic. When you really want something and can't have it, that love can easily turn to hate. That hate spilled over onto Harry, especially when he showed signs of having magic toom
I think she was just straight up jealous of her sister. Lilly was special and she was ordinary. It can be hard when you are the older sister and you are overshadowed by your younger because she has something you can never have. It’s actually sad in someways as it caused the breakdown of the sister’s strong friendship. Jealousy can be awful thing
I didn't mind Sirius' death that much...it was Harry's grief that made me cry. But starting with Hedwig, then on to Dobby, Lupin, and Fred, Deathly Hallows destroyed me. (Lupin hit me hardest...he had such a rough life and was only just starting to experience happiness)
I remember one of the comment said that “Harry gave a flower to Petunia when he was 4, Petunia ran up the stairs and cried, the flower was a lily” Idk if that’s true, I just found a comment said that
Despite the sadness, I think the end of Lupin was somehow right. It meant that no one from the Marauders' generation was left at all. To me this is symbolic of the Wizarding World shedding its links with the past.
I really appreciate that you pointed out those differences. P.S, I knew them already. But I really really wish that the scene from the book, Harry Potter and the goblet of fire when the Weasleys visited the Dursleys, ( more like blew apart their living room) SHOULD have been included in the film. Trust me, it would have been hilarious
well...the bad thing about being a Potterhead for so long...it's hard to find some "secret" facts I didn't know already... come on, I need new shocking stuff about Harry Potter!
Isn’t Draco Malfoy Harry’s cousin because Serious’s cousin is Belatrix Lestrange and her sister is Malfoys mom Edit: omg i didn’t think I would get this many likes
hey umm can i just point out that it was emma watson that wanted to leave the set on the 4th film because she wanted to finish her education and NOT rupert grint. just saying you really need to check your facts more often 😁
Daniel admitted that he also wanted to leave after the 3rd movie and Rupert considered leaving after 4th movie and Emma was also about to leave after 4 th movie
hey umm can i just point out that it was emma watson that wanted to leave the set on the 4th film because she wanted to finish her education and NOT rupert grint. just saying you really need to check your facts more often 😁
Lol ill never understand her fans. Did they truly believe that Battle of Hogwarts would result in no deaths? Or that meddling with the darkest wizard of all time would also result in no deaths? Plenty of movies/shows/books have characters die. But somehow JK is the only one apologizing for it. Grow up
Do we think no one would die? No. Probably the only deaths I am upset about, the ones I cried for, were Cedric's and Fred's. So do we know that there is going to be deaths? Yes. Did it have to be Fred? No.
As long as the deaths are meaningful and not added for shock-factor, I have no problems people dying. Take the death of Fred: she could have opted for Percy, which at the moment the explosion happened would also have a strong impact. Was it needed to go the extra mile and kill of a part of the twin? Not really.
OF COURSE WE KNEW! But it hurts!! And yes, she doesn't have to apologize but it does hurt in ANY book! These are a million tears that we have had because of these!! You don't have to be so insensitive!
I totally get that, but it also shows how amazing she did with character design. I am a big fan and I don't actually mind the death, it adds more to the story and makes it more realistic.
When I read Dumbledore's death I cried at midnight for like a half hour and my mum rang my aunt because she thought that Dumbledore was Voldemort! 🤦♀️
I read Deathly Hallows part 2 in 4 days through tears for everyone who died. That was the worse part after getting to know & love most of them. Dumbledore, Fred & Dobby were the most heartbreaking. Losing a twin must be terrible. I know Tom Riddle was supposed to be twisted, but I wonder how Tom Riddle would have been if he hadn’t been bullied by other children for being different. It just goes to show you, even in fantasy bullying is bad. 💕🐞💙⚡️🧑🏻🏫
I wouldn't he acted like a jerk to hermione and harry so yeah at the moment he yelled at harry I thought he was as much as a prat as Percy in that moment so pls don't hate
@___________________ Thank you for saying this. The movies really tone down Hermione's vindictiveness, condescending and judgmental attitude, as well as Harry's anger and snark compared to the books. Also, Harry thinking how he's better than Ron and deserved to be Prefect instead is completely missing from the film. The movies handed all of Ron's positive traits to Hermione and he's left with mostly his flaws, while Harry and Hermione are made to look squeaky clean in comparison.
From the moment I read H.P.A.T.P.S, I knew that Petunia was truly jealous of Lilly. I called it the moment she says, "I was the only one who saw her for what she was - a freak! But for my mother and father, oh no, it was Lily this and Lily that, they were proud of having a witch in the family!’ To me it came as no surprise that was so jealous, that she wrote to Professor Dumbledore to be part of the magical world. The fact that she was rejected, was enough for her to build such a hatred against anything magical that of course she would later on say that it is a freak school and completely deny that there was ever a magical world. I think she whole heartedly mourned Lily's death, she never got the chance to make amends and be the sisters they might once have been.
I made a family tree for all of them when I was younger and told all the potter fans that litterally alll of them are connected in some way- appearntly Bellatrix Lextrange is family with Voldemort without marriage. Idk where the tree is now. I would love to share it some day
My favourite cut scene is Draco throwing his wand to Harry in the last battle between him and Voldemort, it would have represented the boy with no choice :D
I already knew about Umbridge having a muggle mother and a squib brother. The thought is that it's Fitch. I knew about Harry and Voldy being related. I also knew how powerful Dumbledore was and that he could always see Harry. He stopped seeking power. Just imagine how much more powerful he would have been? He was beyond endless talent and power. However, I love the fact he stopped seeking it. I know about ALL of the deleted scenes, even the hidden ones.
I never thought of that, but it makes so much sense! Despite first appearances, Filch and Umbridge actually have a lot in common: they both love rules; they're both cruel, and enjoy tormenting students; and they both have a soft spot for cats!
It is quite striking that 'halfbloods' like Umbridge, Snape and even Voldemort himself, were prominent Death Eaters. While the Death Eater's cause was to exterminate or oppress anyone who wasn't a 'pureblood'.
Seriously why take Sirius away from Harry, even after that happened I thought well at least he still has Lupin who’s like an uncle to him and then boom he’s killed off as well 🤦🏻♀️💔😞
I just wanted to share this with you all : In Quidditch through the Ages there was a page in the beginning with comments from some people like Lockhart , Bagman and Bagshot . Rita Skeeter said " I have read worse " 😂😂
Come on, once we knew that Harry's invisibility cloak was the 3rd Hallow, it was obvious that he and Voldemort were related. At least to anyone who read the books, since Harry had already seen the memory where Marvolo Gaunt said that he and his family were descended from the Peverells.
Number 10 is actually all in the books... Harry finds out in Deathly Hallows that he is a descendant of Ignotus Peverell, the original owner of the invisibility cloak. And Voldemort is of course related to Cadmus Peverell, the original owner of the resurrection stone. Since his mother's family was the House of Gaunt, the Ring with the Stone was passed down for generations until Voldemort made it into a Horcrux, that was then destroyed by Dumbledore (and gave him the curse).
The end when mrs.dursley said she lost a sister I mean anyone could clearly see snape loved harry but mrs.dursley you could have never known by the way her character was portrayed
@@ziahusnain3948 he didn't abuse harry get your facts straight zia its called being tough (chocking)have you never heard that saying tough love I'm that way with my nieces it's called being strict and stern and teaching them right bye bye
The scene with Petunia was included in a Christmas marathon I watched this year, and every video where they talk about deleted scenes they say this made her look more human, but for me it did the opposite. If this woman had any feelings for her sister she would’ve treated her nephew better.
No Dumbledore cannot see through the invisibility cloak! Even he wouldn't be able to trick the most powerful invisibility cloak! The spell Homenum Revelio just reveals the location of a person, not makes them visible.
The fact that in the book draco cried when dobby died because dobby was his only real friend- like draco played with him when he was a child and told him everything, that's why when dobby appeared at Harry's house telling him not to return to Hogwarts was because dobby had been told that by draco :(
I always believed Petunia was going to take on a much more significant role in the conclusion of the story, sadly she just evacuated with the other Dursley’s.
@@yvonneburns2786 Actually not likely to happen. Although for a time Rowling did toy with the idea of one of Dudley's children becoming a wizard and them being seen on 9 3/4 in the epilogue, she ultimately decided that no magic could survive being so closely related to Vernon. (Maybe in a few generations the Dursley blood will be diluted enough for magic to get through?) I believe she's said that Harry visits Dudley so their kids can know each other, but they are awkward family visits without much talking between the two, and I think the kids are perhaps indifferent towards each other at best. I can't remember exactly what was said about the kids' relationships though. Figured I'd say something since you're a recent viewer to this old video, like me. :)
I'm actually suprised that there are so little deads from the war. In the book, every death eater is dead at the end, so how is there only a few good people? And in the film: there are so many bad guys, so, again, how so little deads?
J.K. Rowling: I didn’t kill off one good father so I had to kill off someone with that structure Me: what was killing Sirius about then! He was good to Harry! Video: J.K. Rowling also revealed Voldemort was part of Harry’s family Me: I already knew that and I thought I was one of the only people!
Actually, I don't think Harry and Voldemort could be relatives. I thought about it the moment I first read The Three Brothers in Deathly Hallows but afterwards I thought that it wasn't possible because the second brother passed away without a child. The woman he loved had already died before their marriage and when he tried to resurrect her with the Resurrection Stone, she wasn't completely in her human form: neither ghost nor human but something in between as it is revealed when Harry tries to resurrect his parents, Sirius and Lupin before going to meet Voldemort at the final battle. So, when the second brother's lover didn't feel good to be in the human world because she belonged to the other world now, he let her go and committed suicide to be reunited with her, leaving no heir. So, Voldemort and Salazar Slytherin can't be possibly descended to the second brother, which means that Voldemort isn't related to the Peverells and so, he isn't Harry's distant cousin either. This is my theory. What do you think?
In the picture Harry and Hermione shows very close and suddenly they show Harry loves Ginny . JK Rowling said she also wants earlier Harry to marry Hermione but if Harry and Hermione come close then Ron will be left alone. That's only thing I don't like about the franchise otherwise I love the franchise very much.
Actually in the books harry and hermione were always like siblings.. The books never promoted harry and hermione as a couple.. It was always ron who was jealous of hermione being with someone else.. And not harry..
Emma wanted to stop for education but couldn't imagine someone els play Hermione the plan was to kill Ron and let Fred live, so Fred would have been Hermiones love Dame Maggie Smith had cancer during the 6th (i Believe it was the 6th) movie, she was really sick, but like the Dame she is, she went on with filming anyway and don't we all love her?
So ur telling me.... I for some reason feel a different way for umbridge now that I know her past I mean... yeah nevermind it’s gone now the feelings gone 😂😂
Harry Potter Franchise is the Best Fantasy Adventure Franchise in the World
It really is. But Percy jackson isn't bad either.
Only second to Lord of the Rings.
Definitely
@@yomommasofatthanoshadtosna3479 OH yes! The books are awesome!
@@Ds-nu1nm Yeah, the movies are such a shame... But I'm so dam excited for the series that will come out on Disney +!
so you’re telling me she didn’t regret killing fred?! i never forgive her for that i love him like he’s my fav the twins
That was one death I can’t forgive her for. It hits too close to home. My twin was stillborn and there’s been an empty hole my whole life. How she could inflict that fate on the twins just killed me. The pain never goes away. You always know something is missing and it’s just awful.
Fr. Wow just I have absolutely no words.
@@andreagriffiths3512 Oh my gosh.... I'm so sorry....
She had to kill somebody that was close to Harry to make it more realistic. When there is a massive battle at least one person dies in a family. That’s just life.
She actually cried while writing the part where fred died
Tonks was really underrated in the movies.....
ya it is very depresing
There were a lot of things that were underrated in the movies. I appreciate the movies for what they are; but, I very much prefer the books.
In the book Tonks was bubbly, happy, always had pink hair up until Sirius died, which made her depressed, then after she got with Remus, she was happy again. In the movie she was a punk, weird person who I don’t like very much.
@@marklethesparkle3493 she did not had much lines too in the movies. In the books she was funny and cool.
I KNOW SHE’S ONE OF MY FAVORITES
Snape: Expecto Petronum
Dumbledore: Lily! After all this time?
Snape: Always.
Or from the book
“Dumbledore opened his eyes. Snape looked horrified.
‘You’ve kept him alive so that he can die at the right moment?’
‘Don’t be shocked, Severus. How many men and women have you watched die?’
‘Lately, only those whom I could not save,’ said Snape. ‘You have used me.’
‘Meaning?’
‘I have spied for you and lied for you, put myself in mortal danger for you. Everything was supposed to be to keep Lily Potter’s son safe. Now you tell me that you have been raising him like a pig for slaughter-’
‘But this is touching, Severus,’ said Dumbledore seriously. ‘Have you grown to care for the boy, after all?’
‘For him?’ shouted Snape. ‘Expecto patronum!’
From the tip of his wand burst the silver doe: she landed on the office floor, bounded once across the office and soared out of the window. Dumbledore watched her fly away, and as her silvery glow faded he turned back to Snape, and his eyes were full of tears.
‘After all this time?’
‘Always,’ said Snape.”
He's not talking about his love for Lily. He's talking about his regret for destroying their friendship and deeply hurting someone he loved. When she died he knew he could never do anything about the damage he had done. He could never make it right. Him Turning on Voldemort and helping Harry despite hating everything about him that reminded him about his tormentor was 100% about trying in some way to make up for hurting Lily all those years ago and taking their friendship from her and hurting her so deeply. For knowing that he not only drove her away and into James' arms but also created the situation where they had to choose a secret keeper that wasn't him likely causing her death. Dumbledore is surprised that Snape still hasn't forgiven himself for what he did to Lily after all this time despite everything he's done. Snape is lost in thoughts of Lily and how he can never forgive himself. I highly doubt he ever did.
Idc what anyone says, Snape has a love for Harry deep down, you just have to scratch the surface a bit
then why did he show his patronus
@@bendover-sz1sv because it shows that he still loves and cares for lilly because you can have the same patronus as someone else if you're really in love with her or him
yes 🤧
Isn't it love that changes a patronus? Regret is never mentioned as the emotion that does that.
I would never forgive j.k Rowling for allowing a death eater to kill sirus'
Dobby has no owner he is a free elf
I would never forgive her to kill Fred
Gacha Girlz yeah :(
Or Remus, best two characters in my opinion ;(
Never.
let’s just agree that we don’t like jk rowing
I feel so sad Alan Rickman died 😭😭 . AGREED ?
ik snape was good
@@-pixie-9734 she means irl idiotic
@@hello_hi5196 I didn’t know he passed away, that’s sad to hear
I have 8 favorites, snap, Draco malfoy, Harry Potter, Ron, Hermione I think, and hagrid, and the old man who picked up Harry when he was borned at season 1, and the woman mgnongl I don't know but I love them soo much but my favorite favorite was Snape I feel soo bad about this my sister was a big fan of him to
@@shin_Ryujin143 Professor McGonagall I’m pretty sure
I actually cried when dobby died in the book-
My mom did to she told me because I asked her about the books and she siad she cried when dobby died
I love Dobby he was always so kind to Harry. And I liked how all the funny bits in the book reference him. Hes a LEGEND
Am I the only one who didn’t cry when Dobby died? I cried for three deaths. Snape. Fred. And Sirius.
Orchid Malfoy SAME DUDE
Omg same- Dobby is my fav character
The durselys gave harry a toothpick a coin and a tissue for Christmas
The toothpick is the elder wand
The coin is the resurrection stone
The tissue is the Invisablity cloak
Edit:this is the most likes I got thanks guys 💕☺️💕
Genius 👍
Wow😳😳
That petty good 👍
He gave the coin to Ron ^^
Do you have an interpretation for that too?
@@larafranke1802 Ron can bring Fred back from the dead
She was gonna kill Ron,Arthur and she was planning George would die instead of Fred...WHAT DOES SHE HAVE AGAINST THE WEASLEYS?!?!?!
Excuse becuz of her we have Harry Potter world so it’s her choice srrsly your so fake!
@@sanjeevreddyar4823 I'm the fake one?It's a joke firstly,and just cuz you don't have a sense of humour you don't have to be rude. Secondly, if you're a real fan you'd know she's homophobic, transphobic and more. We're all against her even though she made the Harry potter books.
Idk
I am sooo agree with it. After i watched this video i became a hater of J.K. Rowling. 🥺
@@annstars4208 dude are srrsly the world created by her
I really hated several of the characters getting killed but the one that got me the most, almost no one ever mentions. I was late to the franchise. The last book had just been released when I started them. Several friends on Facebook were into them and had even stood outside bookstores forever to get new releases. I remember screaming when I started the last book and then exclaimed on Facebook, “They killed Hedwig!”
Deaths were normal they were at war deaths made it feel realistic if none of them died then why would they be afraid of voldemort and the death eaters if they couldv’e easily beaten them. I loved everything about the series even if some amazing characters died, imo it made the series even better.
That hurt me.
I only cried on Hedwig and Dobby’s death 💔
You all are soacting good at aging
🙂
Hedwigs death hurt.
“Arthur being the only good father...” I’m sorry what about Remus Lupin, he maybe didn’t last enough time with Teddy but he was great while it lasted, What about James he and Lily sacrificed themselves for Harry
Kimberly...Remus' son was a tike still in "nappies" as the Brits say, so he didn't have any quality time with son. Anyway, most of the characters, as we say, wouldn't have died in their beds with their desire to fight off evil!
Put your bias and favorites aside. Arthur was a good father. He had a hard job but was always in a good mood. He made and rised six children, instead of abandoning them when times got tough. Even though he wasn't rich with money, he was rich with family, loving and appreciating them. And his curiosity with Muggles makes him like a child, ready to learn.
We can't really base good fathers on guys that have such young children, like James and Lupin. They *could have been* great, but there's not enough evidence yet. Even if they're your favorites, doesn't mean your personal headcanon is correct.
But they arnt alive in any of the books. And remus barely saw teddy as he was fighting
@@chatboulon743 6 children? Excuse me? You seem to be forgetting one there. Bill, Charlie, Percy, Fred, George, Ron, Ginny. Thats 7. Which one did you forget?
James Potter didnt sacrifice himself! He simply got killed. Also, we dont know how good he would have been as a father. In book 5 after Occlumency Harry gets shocked for he realises his dad was exactly as boastful and mean as Snape described him.
Sometimes the best way to get someone's attention is to stop giving them yours.
-Shazistic
That’s goooooooooooood
True
They should've included the scene with aunt petunia on hp7
A simple google search shows that quote to have also been plagiarized by Jeffree Star, Wiz Khalifa and Dr Anne Brown
I think Dudley telling Harry he didn’t think he was a waste of space is a better scene then Petunia saying she was sad about losing her sister. That’s just common sense. Anyone that has a sibling knows about sibling rivals all too well. They also know that most wouldn’t hesitate to donate one of their kidneys to try and save their sibling.
You're...brothers are a different breed, but sisters are much closer because they do not compete (unless they're stupid) as guys/brothers do!
Through out the films Petunia was still fascinated by the Wizarding World. Especially when Harry sent Marge into space. I think deep down she enjoyed it.
i blame horcruxe harry.. fornthem being nasty
@@marinazagrai1623 that's bull, "sisters are much closer" is the biggest load of horseshit i've ever read and i'm dumber for doing so. Nobody can be closer than me and my siblings. they can however be as close. I have brothers AND sisters. 3 each
@@arctrog I don’t have brothers, but that’s what I have observed in other families…
They should've included the scene with aunt petunia on hp7
what about the Dudley scene from the books??
When I watched the movie I see that scene.... I’m so confused
THEY ALSO SHOULDHAVE ADDED THE BABOONS BACKSTIDE SCENE WHERE THEY FIRST MEET LUNA INTO THE MOVIES😭😭😭😭😭
I loved that bit in the books
I agree. And when she talks about the dementors.
Yup
“Does this shed a new light on Umbridge”
Me: No, sorry I must not tell lies
I hate Umbridge and nothing will change that.
Yup
That sounds cool.And I feel the same about the Umbridge in the book...but sorry for the actor.
Yes it does... and I dislike her even more than I did (if that is even possible)
Hedwig. That killed me. Threw the book across the room lol.
I stopped reading for a week because I was so upset
Broke my heart it did. She was there all through the books.
This. Actually went downstairs to complain to my mum.
7 during the flight to Tony’s parents house
Yep. That was rough. I had to reread that over and over again.
does that information make you view umbridge in a new light?
NO ABSOLUTELY NOT
"Does that information makes you view Umbrige in a new light?"
No
My thoughts exactly lmao
That's right
Never.
@Matthew Litster me too
did you know that, even though death eaters can't produse a protronus, Umbrige can because her happiest memories are of torturing people.
It can’t be just me who wants an extended edition of the movie’s??
I can get it lol, i was so confused why everybody was like "they should've kept it in" then i realised
i do toooo. they wanted to make one but daniel radcliffe was thinking of turning down the offer. idk whats happening now
@@mariajavoroski ik thats so sad
There is one I think
@@CDPLAYS7127 what no way how haven’t I heard of it.... I must search and if there is one I am going to find it 🥸
I agree 2:40. I ACTUALLY cried when I read the part where Lupin and Tonks lay together on the floor. I had to read it a few times. Lupin was my favorite. 😕😔
Yeah
Yep
Whoever reading this is Unique!
I saw your comment somewhere else too
Bot Also I’m not “Unique” I’m the boy who lived
@@JediKnight-cw9uf You're the chosen one 😂
So are you!
@@JediKnight-cw9uf hi big fan
I'm so sick of everyone making her apologise: I never heard Lucas apologise for Jar Jar, but Rowling has had to apologise for every thing. If you don't like what happens in the story, then don't read or watch it.
Well yea, but it does hurt to all of these fans
There's a difference here... Rowling apologizes for killing off her characters, because she's connected to them. It's what good writers do. When I'm writing, I make the hard decision to kill off some of my characters, if only to develop another from the tragedy.
Lucas is just a greedy fucker who wants money. Actually sold everything to Disney for *money*. 🤑 Jar Jar is an abomination and he knows it...
jk Rowling did a good job with making you fall in love with characters and then making you extremely sad when the characters died
That's life itself and the rollercoaster of emotions that we experience
I'm glad she didn't hold back
I'm surprised people hadn't realised that they were related, Tom's grandfather is said to prise the ring which contains the stone and was more interested in his linage than anything else, and the cloak comes down father/mother to son/daughter. Making both Harry and Tom related to two of the bothers and therefore to eachother.
yes because they share a common ancestor from about 1000years back. How many of us are related to each other if you want to go that far back?
I realised tho
We didn't have to realize it...it's right in the books that they are both descendants of the Peverell brothers.
@@julieeverett7442 I am your 97th cousin 27x removed.
@@andrewsparadise considering how far back I can trace both lines, could be, hello cousin!
My heart was broken when Lupin and Tonks died. But poor Lupin finally reunited with his best friends.
With Padfoot AKA Snuffles and Prongs
I cry my eyes out when I was reading the books when dobby and lupin were kill off. To the point my brother came in and asked what happened when he realized I was reading the 7th book he walked off he was still on the 5th book at that time
People saying they can't forgive J.K. Rowling. On the other hand I admire her talent. Like she created an entire magical universe with so much of time and work. Not everyone can do this. Yes those deaths made me sad, but that's what stories are, it shows that not everything happens according to your wish. Reality is always different.
I had always thought that Petunia Dursely treated Harry the way she die, because she blamed him for her sister's death even though Harry was a baby at the time. Possibly she blamed him as his father's son, because his father wasn't alive to blame.
No, she was sick with jealousy of Lily and her magic. When you really want something and can't have it, that love can easily turn to hate. That hate spilled over onto Harry, especially when he showed signs of having magic toom
I think she was just straight up jealous of her sister. Lilly was special and she was ordinary. It can be hard when you are the older sister and you are overshadowed by your younger because she has something you can never have. It’s actually sad in someways as it caused the breakdown of the sister’s strong friendship. Jealousy can be awful thing
When your early and you dont know what to say: I like harry potter
Edit: ty for all these likes i have never had this many before
*I love "Harry Potter". Wonderful.*
So amazing
I literally cried when Fred, Sirius and Dobby died in the book
My heart was broken 😭💔
I didn't mind Sirius' death that much...it was Harry's grief that made me cry. But starting with Hedwig, then on to Dobby, Lupin, and Fred, Deathly Hallows destroyed me. (Lupin hit me hardest...he had such a rough life and was only just starting to experience happiness)
@@laurab5750 yh all those deaths made cry too
I remember one of the comment said that “Harry gave a flower to Petunia when he was 4, Petunia ran up the stairs and cried, the flower was a lily”
Idk if that’s true, I just found a comment said that
I bet Voldemort's face is flat as he ran into the wrong wall in the train station😂
🤣
lol, good joke, but the actual reason was because Tom Riddle was cursed.
Despite the sadness, I think the end of Lupin was somehow right. It meant that no one from the Marauders' generation was left at all. To me this is symbolic of the Wizarding World shedding its links with the past.
But wasnt fair to Harry, he should had to survive
I really appreciate that you pointed out those differences. P.S, I knew them already. But I really really wish that the scene from the book, Harry Potter and the goblet of fire when the Weasleys visited the Dursleys, ( more like blew apart their living room) SHOULD have been included in the film. Trust me, it would have been hilarious
Ikr , the book was so funny 😂
Read this again last night..i was the only one up in my house trying to muffle my laughter...
And the postage stamps and dudley's tongue 😂😂😂
@@todayisagreatday9712 Hey, can you tell me in which chapter of the book this scene happens?
@MoonyAlice22 I had found out that myself already, by the way thanks 👍
@@todayisagreatday9712 OH GOD!!! HOW CAN I FORGET THE "ENOUGH STAMPS" ON THE LETTER
To whoever Is reading this hi Heather
HeLLO kAReN
Hi werido
Shut up heather
Hey weirdo
Hiiiii
well...the bad thing about being a Potterhead for so long...it's hard to find some "secret" facts I didn't know already... come on, I need new shocking stuff about Harry Potter!
The dudley's were such unpleasant people, because they were constantly exposed to the effects of one of voldemort's horcrucses.... Harry...
@@erytrohaem That can't be true, Ron and Hermione were as well, but they weren't horrible people.
Ikr
OMGGG
@@erytrohaem I knew that already 😅 but thank you 😁
Isn’t Draco Malfoy Harry’s cousin because Serious’s cousin is Belatrix Lestrange and her sister is Malfoys mom
Edit: omg i didn’t think I would get this many likes
No as Siruis isn't related by blood he is just a god father
Yes there cousin but distant cousins as well as the weasley's
No because sirius and harry aren't related by blood. Sirius is harrys god father
But voldemort and harry and distantly related as they both are descendents to Salazar
@@jenniferandthings yes they aren’t but since he is related to Sirius ( not by blood ) but by being his god father it technically still counts
hey umm can i just point out that it was emma watson that wanted to leave the set on the 4th film because she wanted to finish her education and NOT rupert grint.
just saying you really need to check your facts more often 😁
Exactly!! The directors changed the schedules of EVERYTHING just for Emma so she would stay!
Daniel admitted that he also wanted to leave after the 3rd movie and Rupert considered leaving after 4th movie and Emma was also about to leave after 4 th movie
@@sofiaaa9169 Emma wanted to leave after 4th not 5th but that's true
Yeah true
hey umm can i just point out that it was emma watson that wanted to leave the set on the 4th film because she wanted to finish her education and NOT rupert grint.
just saying you really need to check your facts more often 😁
The only reason I accept her getting rid of Remus is because he would've otherwise been the only living marauder, I feel like they should all go :/
eh idk i want remus back
Reunited in heaven
@@-pixie-9734 same
Yeah... imagine his pain if he continued living without his friends... he would blame it all on himself...
@@ziahusnain3948 Peter Pettigrew went to heaven after betraying James and Lily Potter and then bringing back Voldemort? I don't know about that.
Lol ill never understand her fans. Did they truly believe that Battle of Hogwarts would result in no deaths? Or that meddling with the darkest wizard of all time would also result in no deaths? Plenty of movies/shows/books have characters die. But somehow JK is the only one apologizing for it. Grow up
Do we think no one would die? No. Probably the only deaths I am upset about, the ones I cried for, were Cedric's and Fred's. So do we know that there is going to be deaths? Yes. Did it have to be Fred? No.
As long as the deaths are meaningful and not added for shock-factor, I have no problems people dying. Take the death of Fred: she could have opted for Percy, which at the moment the explosion happened would also have a strong impact. Was it needed to go the extra mile and kill of a part of the twin? Not really.
Imagine if George R. R. Martin felt the need to apologize for every death. The tweet would be longer than the series.
OF COURSE WE KNEW! But it hurts!! And yes, she doesn't have to apologize but it does hurt in ANY book! These are a million tears that we have had because of these!! You don't have to be so insensitive!
I totally get that, but it also shows how amazing she did with character design. I am a big fan and I don't actually mind the death, it adds more to the story and makes it more realistic.
When I read Dumbledore's death I cried at midnight for like a half hour and my mum rang my aunt because she thought that Dumbledore was Voldemort! 🤦♀️
I read Deathly Hallows part 2 in 4 days through tears for everyone who died. That was the worse part after getting to know & love most of them. Dumbledore, Fred & Dobby were the most heartbreaking. Losing a twin must be terrible. I know Tom Riddle was supposed to be twisted, but I wonder how Tom Riddle would have been if he hadn’t been bullied by other children for being different. It just goes to show you, even in fantasy bullying is bad. 💕🐞💙⚡️🧑🏻🏫
I still won’t forgive j.k Rowling for making them delete that scene :(
If Ron died I would probably stop watching the movies.
I wouldn't he acted like a jerk to hermione and harry so yeah at the moment he yelled at harry I thought he was as much as a prat as Percy in that moment so pls don't hate
@@ginnyweasley4908 nooo, mah baby Ron
@@potatosack7492 my opinion but I think it true
@My Musical Journey sorry but it still kinda my opinion sorry
@___________________ Thank you for saying this. The movies really tone down Hermione's vindictiveness, condescending and judgmental attitude, as well as Harry's anger and snark compared to the books. Also, Harry thinking how he's better than Ron and deserved to be Prefect instead is completely missing from the film. The movies handed all of Ron's positive traits to Hermione and he's left with mostly his flaws, while Harry and Hermione are made to look squeaky clean in comparison.
I googled Voldermort and after like 10000000 times of redirections, I found out that Voldermort was related to Harry and I was like: Wait... wha-?!
From the moment I read H.P.A.T.P.S, I knew that Petunia was truly jealous of Lilly. I called it the moment she says, "I was the only one who saw her for what she was - a freak! But for my mother and father, oh no, it was Lily this and Lily that, they were proud of having a witch in the family!’
To me it came as no surprise that was so jealous, that she wrote to Professor Dumbledore to be part of the magical world. The fact that she was rejected, was enough for her to build such a hatred against anything magical that of course she would later on say that it is a freak school and completely deny that there was ever a magical world. I think she whole heartedly mourned Lily's death, she never got the chance to make amends and be the sisters they might once have been.
I made a family tree for all of them when I was younger and told all the potter fans that litterally alll of them are connected in some way- appearntly Bellatrix Lextrange is family with Voldemort without marriage. Idk where the tree is now. I would love to share it some day
So the cursed child franchise was all mess? And the daughter of voldemort was Belletrix's so...
Home sweet Alabama
@@speedwagon_69 haha, yes appearntly somehow the golden trio are related with out marrying eachother. I wish I could show you it. It's quite odd
1:19 "There's only one Ron Weasley"
My Starkid-obsessed brain: *and that's Joey Richter*
My favourite cut scene is Draco throwing his wand to Harry in the last battle between him and Voldemort, it would have represented the boy with no choice :D
Invented for the movie. Total BS
I love almost everyone in Harry Potter and it was so sad when some of them died but the thing is, the only death that I cried over was Dobby's 😢😭
Rupert’s acting in The Servant! 👏🏽 I am glad he continued!
I already knew about Umbridge having a muggle mother and a squib brother.
The thought is that it's Fitch.
I knew about Harry and Voldy being related.
I also knew how powerful Dumbledore was and that he could always see Harry.
He stopped seeking power. Just imagine how much more powerful he would have been?
He was beyond endless talent and power.
However, I love the fact he stopped seeking it.
I know about ALL of the deleted scenes, even the hidden ones.
I never thought of that, but it makes so much sense! Despite first appearances, Filch and Umbridge actually have a lot in common: they both love rules; they're both cruel, and enjoy tormenting students; and they both have a soft spot for cats!
"Does that information make you view Umbridge in a new light?"
Not one bit.
Everyone being sad about freds death
me: why did she have to kill dobby😭😭😭😭😭
It is quite striking that 'halfbloods' like Umbridge, Snape and even Voldemort himself, were prominent Death Eaters. While the Death Eater's cause was to exterminate or oppress anyone who wasn't a 'pureblood'.
I cried at every death. I get attached too easily. It would've been nice if at least one of teddy's parents lived
they should release the unmuted scream when sirius black died. I wanna hear it
My favorite sene that was cut was draco saying “Pottah!” When Harry dropped out of hagrids arms
And when Draco threw Harry his wand
@@chloep8565 that did not happen in the books Draco was too coward to do anything like that
Seriously why take Sirius away from Harry, even after that happened I thought well at least he still has Lupin who’s like an uncle to him and then boom he’s killed off as well 🤦🏻♀️💔😞
When I saw the cut scene with Petunia I thought it made her seem to be an even bigger #itch for treating Harry the way she did.
*"Voldemort and Harry are related"*
Me: *My whole life was a lie*
I just wanted to share this with you all :
In Quidditch through the Ages there was a page in the beginning with comments from some people like Lockhart , Bagman and Bagshot . Rita Skeeter said " I have read worse " 😂😂
Come on, once we knew that Harry's invisibility cloak was the 3rd Hallow, it was obvious that he and Voldemort were related. At least to anyone who read the books, since Harry had already seen the memory where Marvolo Gaunt said that he and his family were descended from the Peverells.
Dobby, Sirius, Lupin.....they weren’t supposed to die 😭😭😭
Number 10 is actually all in the books... Harry finds out in Deathly Hallows that he is a descendant of Ignotus Peverell, the original owner of the invisibility cloak. And Voldemort is of course related to Cadmus Peverell, the original owner of the resurrection stone. Since his mother's family was the House of Gaunt, the Ring with the Stone was passed down for generations until Voldemort made it into a Horcrux, that was then destroyed by Dumbledore (and gave him the curse).
Harry Potter is one of the greatest things ever created I really love your Harry Potter Videos
The end when mrs.dursley said she lost a sister I mean anyone could clearly see snape loved harry but mrs.dursley you could have never known by the way her character was portrayed
(Chocking )Snape loved harry so he abused him for 6 years
@@ziahusnain3948 he didn't abuse harry get your facts straight zia its called being tough (chocking)have you never heard that saying tough love I'm that way with my nieces it's called being strict and stern and teaching them right bye bye
@@truckercaje2452 have you have read the books he abused him not only him but also Hermione and Neville so much that Neville lost his self confidence
There is no such thing as a Harry Potter secret that J.K. Rowling did not want everyone to know
you could use this in another video: Dolores Umbridge's outfit changed to a darker pink every time she gained more power
i think dumbledore told harry about the 10th one in that white kings cross, at least in the books...maybe not
The scene with Petunia was included in a Christmas marathon I watched this year, and every video where they talk about deleted scenes they say this made her look more human, but for me it did the opposite. If this woman had any feelings for her sister she would’ve treated her nephew better.
No Dumbledore cannot see through the invisibility cloak!
Even he wouldn't be able to trick the most powerful invisibility cloak!
The spell Homenum Revelio just reveals the location of a person, not makes them visible.
That's why i came down here! Thank you!
Plot hole - Mad eye was able to see beneath the cloak in Goblet of Fire. Something later said to be impossible
The fact that in the book draco cried when dobby died because dobby was his only real friend- like draco played with him when he was a child and told him everything, that's why when dobby appeared at Harry's house telling him not to return to Hogwarts was because dobby had been told that by draco :(
So you are making up random stuff now😂
I always believed Petunia was going to take on a much more significant role in the conclusion of the story, sadly she just evacuated with the other Dursley’s.
But just think on this perhaps Harry's cousin will have a child with magical powers, it could you know.
@@yvonneburns2786 Actually not likely to happen. Although for a time Rowling did toy with the idea of one of Dudley's children becoming a wizard and them being seen on 9 3/4 in the epilogue, she ultimately decided that no magic could survive being so closely related to Vernon. (Maybe in a few generations the Dursley blood will be diluted enough for magic to get through?)
I believe she's said that Harry visits Dudley so their kids can know each other, but they are awkward family visits without much talking between the two, and I think the kids are perhaps indifferent towards each other at best. I can't remember exactly what was said about the kids' relationships though.
Figured I'd say something since you're a recent viewer to this old video, like me. :)
while i hate the character deaths, i love all the raw emotions the books made me feel.
How different and amazing it would have been if Professor Snape was actually a vampire.
That Petunia scene hit deep! It really showed a new light on how this whole thing affected everyone around Harry.
I bridge is like Bellatrix Voldemort and Snape with no face but the actor of her is beautiful
The thing about Petunia I dont think I ever saw her as a person before you told me about that deleted scene
This makes me miss Harry Potter world.
I'm actually suprised that there are so little deads from the war. In the book, every death eater is dead at the end, so how is there only a few good people?
And in the film: there are so many bad guys, so, again, how so little deads?
I love movies 3, 4, 5, 7, and 8.
They're the best ones.
Omg same
I don't love the movies, the books are much better imo
What about 6
And 1 and 2 and 6.
@@neera3167 1 & 2 are looking more and more dated and don't hold up as well as they did and 6 was just boring the more and more I look back on it.
I love your channel!
Great job!
When you are early and don't know what to say : I like Harry potter
You figured out what to say
J.K. Rowling:
I didn’t kill off one good father so I had to kill off someone with that structure
Me:
what was killing Sirius about then! He was good to Harry!
Video:
J.K. Rowling also revealed Voldemort was part of Harry’s family
Me:
I already knew that and I thought I was one of the only people!
Actually, I don't think Harry and Voldemort could be relatives. I thought about it the moment I first read The Three Brothers in Deathly Hallows but afterwards I thought that it wasn't possible because the second brother passed away without a child. The woman he loved had already died before their marriage and when he tried to resurrect her with the Resurrection Stone, she wasn't completely in her human form: neither ghost nor human but something in between as it is revealed when Harry tries to resurrect his parents, Sirius and Lupin before going to meet Voldemort at the final battle. So, when the second brother's lover didn't feel good to be in the human world because she belonged to the other world now, he let her go and committed suicide to be reunited with her, leaving no heir. So, Voldemort and Salazar Slytherin can't be possibly descended to the second brother, which means that Voldemort isn't related to the Peverells and so, he isn't Harry's distant cousin either. This is my theory. What do you think?
I literally I cried when Sirius died and Remus lupin and nymphadora tonks😭
I knew that he was related to Voldemort and I knew that last one
I hate the “I lost a sister, ” scene and I'm glad it got cut. Petunia didn't give a shit about Lily.
In the picture Harry and Hermione shows very close and suddenly they show Harry loves Ginny . JK Rowling said she also wants earlier Harry to marry Hermione but if Harry and Hermione come close then Ron will be left alone. That's only thing I don't like about the franchise otherwise I love the franchise very much.
Actually in the books harry and hermione were always like siblings.. The books never promoted harry and hermione as a couple.. It was always ron who was jealous of hermione being with someone else.. And not harry..
@@nikitasingh0511 in movie also
I am laughing so hard right now because there’s a fanfiction with a vampire named trocar who becomes defense against the dark arts teacher
I really wish that scene with Harry and Petunia wasn't cut
I still can't get past the "you have your mother's eyes," in the movies. (Doesn't stop me from watching them over and over.)
Awesome video 👌
Umbridge is like Bellatrix Voldemort and Snape with no face combined but the actor of her is actually very very pretty!!!!
That’s very tru thumbs up
Emma wanted to stop for education but couldn't imagine someone els play Hermione
the plan was to kill Ron and let Fred live, so Fred would have been Hermiones love
Dame Maggie Smith had cancer during the 6th (i Believe it was the 6th) movie, she was really sick, but like the Dame she is, she went on with filming anyway
and don't we all love her?
So ur telling me.... I for some reason feel a different way for umbridge now that I know her past I mean... yeah nevermind it’s gone now the feelings gone 😂😂
Yay more Harry potter stuff!
WAIT JK WANTED TO KILL RON AT SOME POINT- BLOODY HELL!
IK
SO TRUE
It's interesting to find out this stuff behind the scenes