The divided brain - interview with Iain McGilchrist | VIEWPOINT

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024

Комментарии • 46

  • @benedicamusdomino8546
    @benedicamusdomino8546 5 лет назад +3

    China has implemented a scoring system like that, if you frown too much your score can go down significantly which limits your ability for good health care or decent hotel or to even bill to travel. They refined their AI to be able identity a person even when their face is covered by looking at a persons gait or their ears (ears are as unique as fingerprints). My friend lives in China and I worry for him....

  • @katladyfromtheNetherlands
    @katladyfromtheNetherlands Год назад +2

    can never get satisfied with too much grasping

  • @robertsmuggles6871
    @robertsmuggles6871 5 лет назад

    Split personality. Can you see yourself in this image ?

  • @nancyhope2205
    @nancyhope2205 5 лет назад +17

    I have read this book through twice and I intend to read it again because I am only a bear of small brain. This is a wonderful interview which clarifies so much. I stand in awe.

    • @plekkchand
      @plekkchand 3 года назад +1

      @Praxis Of Logos Yes- it's a good idea to distract yourself as much as possible when you're trying to understand a book. This is excellent advice.

    • @justincase6683
      @justincase6683 Год назад +1

      @@plekkchand Not to mention that playing games on your phone is a well known cutting-edge learning technique, used in the very best schools

  • @christinagiannaros9817
    @christinagiannaros9817 4 года назад +1

    I find it interesting that Iain McGilchrist only mentions right handed people in the two presentations I've watched, I know they represent approx 90% of the population but I'd be interested to know his view on how being lefthanded impacts if there is any difference, r/handers get used for all of the studies i've read due to consistency and theories of language function predominantly residing in the left hem and being variable in around 30% of lefties so they are excluded. His theories don't concur with this view from what I can see.

  • @deroconnor4621
    @deroconnor4621 4 года назад +1

    A masterful summary. When I studied martial arts the Chinese described the alternation between left and right brain cultures as an alternation between bureaucratic over pacified culture and active outgoing strong culture.

  • @Jacob011
    @Jacob011 4 года назад +1

    This cannot be overshared!

  • @yassinemotaouakkil3530
    @yassinemotaouakkil3530 5 лет назад +15

    Probably the most interesting book since Maps of Meaning

    • @mrshah2043
      @mrshah2043 5 лет назад +2

      Science Set Free by Rupert Sheldrake is another interesting book that honestly probes nature while bucking the incurious orthodoxy that has taken over Western scientific minds. I highly recommend it.

    • @mmhmmm2
      @mmhmmm2 5 лет назад

      Also, Tony Wright's research is very interesting. He looks at the development of the brain all the way back to Homo Erectus. I hope to see Iain and Tony have a discussion someday.

    • @mmhmmm2
      @mmhmmm2 5 лет назад

      His theory is called "Left in the Dark."

    • @mirnajafalikhan9216
      @mirnajafalikhan9216 4 года назад

      @@mmhmmm2 m

    • @mirnajafalikhan9216
      @mirnajafalikhan9216 4 года назад

      @@mmhmmm2 ppl loop loo. No

  • @Jacob011
    @Jacob011 5 лет назад +1

    First like, then watch!

  • @monstersoftheid4693
    @monstersoftheid4693 3 года назад

    Gilchrist chides readers who bring a modern sensibility to authors whose narratives were fashioned by a passé sensibility. ( "he was a racist, and a sexist, and a...whatever) However, Gilchrist then laments that 'we are trained to distend to things that are not explicit and that are not in the foreground, and actually the interest is going on in the background". A tad schizophrenic--what?

  • @colingeorgejenkins2885
    @colingeorgejenkins2885 5 лет назад

    When we realise what enistine done by opening the old door to the hive how the mind of the child was before ?

  • @BalthasarCarduelis
    @BalthasarCarduelis 3 года назад

    17:00 minor technical critique: History is not the sum of human experience. Rather, it is the sum of human experience multiplied by the sum of human expression, multiplied again by a certain decay factor.

    • @plekkchand
      @plekkchand 3 года назад

      Please let the world know your equation- particularly the variable that contains the "sum of human expression" in the proper units. You will help us a great deal. It's about time we had a concise equation for "history".

    • @BalthasarCarduelis
      @BalthasarCarduelis 3 года назад

      @@plekkchand sorry bro, I had the proper units recorded on a wax cylinder but it melted.

  • @ExtremeBogom
    @ExtremeBogom 5 лет назад +3

    Great discussion.

  • @mpbh6672
    @mpbh6672 5 лет назад +2

    This was awesome

  • @yassinemotaouakkil3530
    @yassinemotaouakkil3530 5 лет назад

    Ian McGilchrist needs to read Bjorn Lomborg

  • @plaguedoct0r
    @plaguedoct0r 5 лет назад

    "Everything has an asymmetrical neronal structure. Why?"
    Umm...because having two of the exact same thing in the brain would be useless? That would be like having two arseholes.
    But holy shit he's saying shit I've been thinking. I'm schizophrenic and this is fitting the bill really well.

    • @classiqueliberal8576
      @classiqueliberal8576 5 лет назад +2

      You have two eyes, two ears, two nostrils, two hands, two legs, two gonads... Having two of the exact same thing can be redundant, but it is not "useless." Much of our anatomy is symmetrical while much of it is not...

    • @plaguedoct0r
      @plaguedoct0r 5 лет назад

      @@classiqueliberal8576 Eyes, nostrils, arms and legs have obvious functional purposes for being mirrored. The same cannot be said for brain functions, and therefore you have not provided a single argument against anything I said.

    • @plaguedoct0r
      @plaguedoct0r 5 лет назад

      @@taranperry5013 Do you mean to imply that parts of the brain get mirrored and slightly altered?

    • @TaranPerry
      @TaranPerry 5 лет назад

      @@plaguedoct0r yea fam. It doesn't explain the increase in brain size but if some confounding variable( like increase in body size) or something genetic causes an increase in size, then the "rebellion" against symmetry could be a factor in evolving consciousness

  • @davekohler5957
    @davekohler5957 5 лет назад +5

    Haha, this kid believes in man made global warming... This kid needs to look at world history to find the truth about global temperatures.

    • @veeshan6164
      @veeshan6164 5 лет назад +3

      You spared me the trouble to say it. Thumbs up

    • @PieterPatrick
      @PieterPatrick 5 лет назад +1

      Uhm, we did nothing wrong, we didn't schrew up the future of our kids.
      We do not need to change our behavior or feel any guilt.
      It doesn't even matter because it is not our problem but that of our kids.
      And most important:
      You can sleep well.

    • @davekohler5957
      @davekohler5957 5 лет назад +1

      Let's say the myth of man made global warming is true, is it really a bad thing?

    • @veeshan6164
      @veeshan6164 5 лет назад +1

      @@davekohler5957 Great channel of a skeptic : ruclips.net/user/TonyHeller1videos he makes a pretty convincing case.

    • @Jacob011
      @Jacob011 5 лет назад +4

      He actually didn't say anything of the sort. Just FYI.