ArcMap vs ArcGIS Pro - Comparing these two GIS applications from Esri
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024
- Now is a confusing time for both new and existing ArcGIS users. Esri is in the process of transitioning from the time proven ArcMap application to the new ArcGIS Pro. So existing users are wondering when they should transition and new users are trying to figure which they should learn. Hopefully this video will help you understand the differences between these two desktop GIS application and answer some of your questions.
If you or your organization needs help migrating to ArcGIS Pro make sure to contact us at info@egisassociates.com. We have been assisting organizations throughout the US with migration plans and staff training.
Help us expand our content and improve quality by becoming a patron - / egisassociates
This comparison is very useful. I would like to suggest another one: Arcgis Pro vs QGIS.
Thank you!
Great suggestion!
I've learned just enough ArcGIS Desktop for two years purchased by an organization I consult for to be a little dangerous but am currently looking to purchase my own license to use on an upgraded computer of my own. Looking at the products on ESRI's website I was a little confused on the differences between Pro and Desktop and what it all means. Your video cleared everything up and I'm excited to get started by purchasing Pro and diving into it fully. I'm not too entrenched in Desktop so that the change will kill me. Thank you so much for this great explanation and breakdown of the differences and informing me that Pro is what ESRI is looking to transition to permanently. You've gained a subscriber that needs help from any and all GIS experts he can get!
So glad you found the video helpful.
Dont buy any shit, its already cracked
From Somalia, really it is useful as we are a geologist, need to have more useful lessons about it
Thank you for this great explanatory video!
Meanwhile collage teach us in Arcmap , and i feel like am living in 2005 while learning Arcmap
I understand where you are coming from. However there are still a lot of organization that are still using ArcMap and that will not migrate until they have no other choice. So those skills are still in demand. Secondly, it does take a lot of time to update course materials and since ArcGIS Pro is still being updated and tweaked frequently that complicates it even more. So I would say be a bit understanding for our colleagues in academia
This is a great vid, very detailed (more so than mine lol)
In my experience, I think ArcGIS Pro is better than QGIS, but QGIS (especially current versions) is probably better and more user-friendly than ArcMap. But many people and organizations still use ArcMap and people look down on QGIS as inferior FOSS, while preferring to go with the prestigious ArcGIS brand, even if it means using the older ArcMap
Hell yeah!
Thanks alot, sir I clapped for you, I think this is the best video of the decade for GIS users so far. Thanks again it was really worth it. I just want to know if I make the transition will it allow my personal geodatabase? if I don't want to convert(as you said in the last). And what about relate class, or sqlite database?? will arcGis pro support?
Thank you for the very kind words. So happy you found the video helpful.
Esri is working hard to drop all support for personal Geodatabases. First they did so in Server and ArcGIS Online. Now they have done it with ArcGIS Pro. To the best of my knowledge ArcGIS Pro does not now nor will it ever support personal geodatabases. You are encouraged to migrate any personal geodatabases to a file geodatabase. File Geodatabases, Workgroup Geodatabases and Enterprise geodatabases all support relationship classes. ArcGIS Pro also does support SQLite. Here is a link about that - pro.arcgis.com/en/pro-app/help/data/databases/work-with-sqlite-databases-in-arcgis-pro.htm.
Thank You very much! Great overview!
You are welcome. Glad you liked the video.
Thank you so much. Very helpful.
You are very welcome. Glad you found the video helpful.
at 13:36 you mentioned that ArcMap uses scripting language version 1.9.3 .. Could you kindly clearify? I am using Arcmap 10.5 and it uses 2.7.13 while 10.3 uses 2.7.8 version
Good catch. ArcGIS 10.6 uses Python 2.7.14 and Numeric Python 1.9.3. So there are actually two versions of python in use. You can see the list of python to ArcGIS versions here - support.esri.com/en/technical-article/000013224. Thanks for the comment and catching this one.
tanks sir it is really helpful
I understand how multiple maps and multiple layouts per project can be useful from the perspective of a single user. However, I work in a large organization that often has many people working on a given project (engineering project, not Pro Project, sheesh, bad nomenclature). I'm unclear on what would happen if, say an engineering project had 20 or so maps in a Pro Project and they all needed to be updated in a short period of time. Could multiple users access the Pro Project to perform the work? With the ArcMap approach of one mxd for one map it was easy to divvy up work among multiple people. Could you explain a good approach to distributed work using Pro?
64bit ArcPro still doesnt cut it. All hype no substance
@@marksmit8112 It seems OK for a single-user shop, but for a professional organization it seems to be... lacking.
Hola, puedo instalar arcmap y arcgis pro a la misma la vez???, o sea tener instalados ambos programas...
Sorry, I do not speak Spanish. However, if Google translator is working, I believe you have asked if it is possible to install and run both ArcGIS Pro and ArcGIS Desktop on the same computer at the same time. The answer is Yes. You can do that. I am doing it right now.
@@eGISAssociates thanks, gracias por la información...
GREAT
I.DON'T.WANT.TO.GO.TO.THE.RIBBON.
Just like in the early 2000s when we did not want to go away from our Command Line and AMLs, Esri is not going to give you a choice. However it will still be a couple of years before ArcMap is completely gone.
Difference is one is mature technology and the other glitchy clunky buggy overrated garbage. ArcPro does 3D and SaaS well but thats about it
Arcmap is so slow
@@somebodyandthem depends on hardware, versions used and function but generally, yes, the 64bit architecture and 16GB RAM should be faster and is in most cases.
Meanwhile, the company I work for still uses ArcView 3.2 and 3.3. lol.
And ArcGIS 9.3.1. AutoCAD Map 3d 2010 and Land Desktop 2009.
We're using 10-20+ years old software and to be honest, I'm worried about compability problems in 5-10 years in the future.
This will become a total nightmare for IT Admins.
Yes that is a very real concern. Not to mention that support for most of those versions has been dropped. So no more bug or security fixes. Heck Land Development Desktop and ArcView are not even an active products anymore. On the good side, if you are accustom to using the old ArcView GIS application, ArcGIS Pro should be pretty easy for you to pick up. In my opinion ArcGIS Pro is what ArcView would have become if it had remained an active product.
Another functionality afforded by Arc Pro, that I was unable to perform with ArcMap, was creating a scene layer package to upload a 3D point cloud (*.las file) to ArcGIS Online.
Good point.
This was exactly what I was looking for, many thanks!
You are very welcome
I honestly cannot understand why anyone who ever worked ribbon-free, would love ribbons. First we got those Ribbons in AutoCad, and the first thing most of experienced AutoCadists do, is getting rid of them ribbons and their so-called "intuitive" approach (along with the measurable performance draw). Next, we got Ribbons in Office, and for most of our time we were searching for all our once easily found functions, so we ordered a "classic menu" plug-in in order to keep our workflow flowing. And yes, a Ribbon means graphically hunting through (simply different than before) ordered functions.
What I will do first in ArcMap Pro is to try to get rid of the Ribbon, if that's possible. I have work to do and my least priority is to inhale and adopt new and poorly tested workflows dictated by the software. Remember that ArcMap is a software which functional workflow was once dictated by the tasks it were expected to fulfill.
Also, I doubt that ArcMap only supports 4GB.
I did not follow the complete video, but I saw that Pro eliminates ArcScene and ArcGlobe. But does it eliminate 3d Analyst, which is feeding ArcScene & Arcglobe with data through its tools ?
Thank you for your comments. I have used AutoCAD since R12 and ArcGIS since it was first released. So I have worked ribbon free. Personally, I am good either way as long as I know the environment. Having said that, you can customize the ArcGIS Pro interface. Not sure you can turn off the ribbon but maybe you can make adjustments that make it work better for you. I can say new users do find the new ribbon much easier to navigate compared to the lost in toolbars of the older ArcMap. As the question about the Spatial Analyst and 3D Analyst extensions, they are still there. However ArcGIS Pro does not require them to work in 3D. That means you can edit and view data in 3D natively. If you want to perform 3D analysis you still need the extension. But with the extension, you can still work directly in ArcGIS Pro. No need to have yet another application. Also because ArcMap is a 32 bit application, it will only recognize 4 GB of RAM. That is a limit for all 32 bit applications. If you install the 64 bit geoprocessing patch, some geoprocessing tools will be able to use more than 4 GB of RAM.
Thank you for posting this. I've been looking for something that compares the two, and this video is thorough and succinct.
Very informative👍
Thank you.
Thanks for making this video. I’m just becoming aware of ArcGIS and needed an birds eye view of the tool and this overview has help immensely. Sub’d from Oakland CA.
So glad you found it informative and helpful.
Sir help me regards plotting borehole data in arcgis
2:38
Technically, we're still in the early 2000s.
As of April 2021, ESRI says ArcMap will be supported into 2026 but the last release is 10.8.1 therefore migration is still a must for the long term. I'm looking forward to migrating!
Good to hear. I have heard the same thing.
thanks, bill murray
Very good your comparing
Great video easy to follow, I personally think geocoding or more importantly rematching is much easier and better in Arc Map. In Arc Map, you can sort the records and you can pick a point on the map if you know the xy coordinates but its not in your network dataset. Rematching is more limited in Arc Pro.
i guess Im randomly asking but does any of you know a method to log back into an Instagram account??
I was dumb forgot the password. I appreciate any tips you can give me.
@Bentley Darwin instablaster :)
@Elliott Brendan i really appreciate your reply. I got to the site thru google and I'm in the hacking process atm.
Looks like it's gonna take quite some time so I will get back to you later when my account password hopefully is recovered.
@Elliott Brendan It worked and I now got access to my account again. I am so happy!
Thank you so much you saved my account !
@Bentley Darwin Happy to help :D
Thank you finally an answer... new user I was so confused. Thx for this post !
So happy you found the video helpful.
Superb video clearly explained...........Many thanks
So glad you found it informative.
Thank you so much. The side by side comparison was really helpful.
You are very welcome.
Thank pro for your very useful video!
ArcGis Pro 3.1 works very smooth and fast.
Please help me! When in order to change meters to degrees (in status bar) I go to Layers>Properties>General>Units>Degrees Minutes Seconds My coordinates go to other places i mean go wrong something like 160° 80' 32" instead of 81°57'40" why is this happening help me please?
Great video easy to follow, I personally think geocoding or more importantly rematching is much easier and better in Arc Map. In Arc Map, you can sort the records and you can pick a point on the map if you know the xy coordinates but its not in your network dataset. Rematching is more limited in Arc Pro.
I know they have been working on the geocoding process. Hopefully, future releases will continue to improve. Geocoding is always a pain thanks to incomplete, non-uniform formatting or just bad data. Not having all the tools only makes it a bigger night mare.
Very good and useful information. Thank you.
Arcgis pro exports can import to auto cad or cityengine? I make 3D model in arcscen but can't export to auto cad or civil 3d or cityengine or sketchup . I need it for my university research please help me I must send my 3D model to cityengine
ArcGIS Pro with the 3D Analyst extension will export 3D data to a lot of different formats. If your data is a multipatch, then it should export directly to an AutoCAD DWG which can be opened in plain AutoCAD or Civil 3D. So I would start with ArcGIS Pro and the 3D analyst extension.
great video! Destroys any crap found on udemy
So glad you liked it.
What a great video
So glad you liked it
I need help for A to Z video of ArcGIS Pro related to watershed Management and USLE related only
I appreciate your request. However, Watershed management is outside my experience so I not sure I could make a good video on that topic.
ARC map, you can use, driven data pages, to make many lay out . in a single project. what is the different. The onlu different is that asr scene and arcmap are in the same app.
Thanks for the comment. Data driven pages does allow you to print multiple page map books from a single MXD but that is not the same as having multiple independent layouts. With data driven pages, the layout must be the same size and orientation for each page and the location of elements is fixed. ArcGIS Pro allows you to create as many independent layouts as you want in a single project very similar to the way ArcView GIS did if you go back that far. Each layout in ArcGIS Pro has its own size, orientation and unique elements. ArcGIS Pro also support data driven page functionality but it is called map series. Hopefully this helps explain the difference between layouts in ArcMap and the multiple layout capability of ArcGIS Pro. Thanks again for your comment.
tampilannya mirip office ya
Yes it does look like Esri modeled the interface off Microsoft Office. Autodesk has done the same thing with AutoCAD. It seems to make using ArcGIS Pro more user friendly and less intimidating. At least that is what my experience teaching new users has indicated. Thanks for the comment.
Thanks for the video and knowledge presented.
So glad you found the video valuable.
Regarding the options that use credits, does it let you know the cost before you use it?
No, it doesn't because the cost can be variable depending on the options you select. For example, if I publish a map to ArcGIS Online the cost if I make it dynamic versus tiled will be different. Even if I make it a tiled map the cost will differ depending on where I create the tiles, ArcGIS Online or on my own computer and then upload them. Hope that makes sense.
This is Great and very detailed. i was hesitant for more than a year at least to migrate into ArcGIS Pro. but your video have convinced me to do it. thank you very much. since this video is more than two years old, there is probably some major changes that have occurred within Pro. i guess it would be for the better.
Glad you enjoyed the video. I have done a newer one comparing ArcGIS Pro 2.6 and ArcMap 10.8.1 - ruclips.net/video/NEAzDVW6CsQ/видео.html. ArcGIS Pro has continued to improve with each version. I now rarely use ArcMap. The only time I really use ArcMap is when I need to support a client that has not migrated yet.
can i open the srtm data with extension .hgt in arcmap version 10.2.1 instead of Arc GisPro?
I have not had the pleasure of working with that type of data. However after doing a little digging, it appears you can use SRTM data in ArcMap. Looks like Esri added support for that data with ArcMap 10.0. Here are a couple links which talk about it. Hope they help.
gis.stackexchange.com/questions/57012/how-to-use-srtm-dem-files-for-shaded-relief-in-arcmap
community.esri.com/thread/55597
desktop.arcgis.com/en/arcmap/10.3/manage-data/raster-and-images/list-of-supported-raster-and-image-formats.htm
Please help me! When in order to change meters to degrees (in status bar) I go to Layers>Properties>General>Units>Degrees Minutes Seconds My coordinates go to other places i mean go wrong something like 160° 80' 32" instead of 81°57'40" why is this happening help me please?
@@DM-fs2vq Daulet are you using ArcGIS Pro or ArcMap?
@@trippcorbin8850 ArcMap
@@DM-fs2vq I believe you are experiencing this because your map is in a projected coordinate system and you are trying to enter a position from a geographic coordinate system. Change the coordinate system for the map to a geographic coordinate system such as WGS 84. Then try entering the location. Changing the coordinate system of the map does not change the coordinate system of the underlying data. ArcMap projects the data on the fly.
I was a little bit worried about transfering from ArcMap to ArcGIS Pro...but after 1 year of ArcGIS Pro i have to say...the one of the best choice i ever did...i just must install aditional RAM, because 4 GB wasnt enough...and now with 2.7 version is ArcGIS Pro much better than ArcMap
Yes ArcGIS Pro has come a long way since it was first released. It has my go-to desktop GIS software now.
Hi am new to use this ArcMap and its sooo difficult to learn and has so errors and bad interface, do you think arcPro is easier and gives the same results??? Please
@@hosamfadel5440 definetly less errors
LOL okay, so ArcGIS Pro is basically a MS Word interface with CAD-like features? I'm here for it!
Don't think I have ever heard it put that way but yes in general terms that is correct.
Its like revit interface
Hi, may I know where i can download ArcMap?
downloadly.ir
downloadly.ir › software › es...
دانلود ESRI ArcGIS Desktop v10.8.2 + Extensions x64 - دانلود رایگان نرم افزار
Quick question: Do I need to download the whole link to run the program?
Not sure I understand your question. You do need to download the entire installation file and then install the program on your computer to run it. ArcGIS Pro is not a cloud program. It must be installed on a Windows computer. Hope this helps.
Done already. Thank you for your informational video.
Arcgis pro have crack?
I assume you are talking about the process that breaks features and inserts vertices and not the drug..... There is not a specific Crack command in ArcGIS Pro. Several geoprocessing tools will crack features such as intersect. Also when you validate a topology it will crack intersecting features based on the cluster tolerance.
Lol he means a pirated version that's free😂
@@musondachalungumana9982 Exactly hahaha
While I see the specifications are different, is a different performance noticeable?
Thanks for sharing.
Generally ArcGIS Pro is faster for most functions. It also handles larger datasets much better.
Could you please explain the difference between ArcMap and ArcView??
Hey could you please explain the difference?
Sure thing. ArcView actually can refer to two things. The first was Esri's first real Windows application, ArcView GIS. It was first released in 1991 and was discontinued with the release of ArcGIS in 2002 at version 3.3. When Esri released ArcMap, ArcView was one of the license levels. It was equivalent to the Basic license level we have now. When ArcMap, part of ArcGIS Desktop, was first released the three license levels were ArcView, ArcEditor, and ArcInfo. At version 10.0 Esri renamed those license levels to Basic, Standard, and Advanced.
@@eGISAssociates thank you so much for replying .Now am gonna download arcview ,and instead of using arcmap I will be using arcview.does it make much difference??
@@njcreations6928 ArcView will only work with shapefiles. Some processes are pretty slow, but for its time and what it is, it is actually a very fast program. I still use it occasionally with old avenue scripts. I tried converting them to modelbuilder and the new scripts kept getting broken by updates to ArcGIS Desktop, so its actually easier to keep using the old avenue scripts. You can't install 3.3 on a windows 10 computer, but if you had it installed on an xp or earlier machine you can copy the files over or to a usb stick and the program will run.
Thanks
Welcome
Thanks for lovely video!!!
We want more......!!
Trying as best we can. Glad you enjoyed the video.
My project had to switch to ArcGIS pro, because ArcGIS desktop is not compatible with C2PC. Unfortunately this change has made it nearly impossible to publish a map to a map server, and their instructions are very difficult to follow :/
So what map server are you trying to publish too? Is it ArcGIS Server or something else. ArcGIS Pro does now allow you to publish content to ArcGIS server. First you need to establish a publisher or admin connection to the ArcGIS Server. Once you have done that, then you right click on the server connection in the Catalog pane and select publish. This will launch a wizard that is similar to the one in ArcMap. The primary difference is you first must select the map in the ArcGIS Pro project you wish to publish to the server.