@@VoicesofthePast As the author, Yu Huan, sadly, was unable to travel far in person, he was obliged to use the reports of others, who were often merchants. They, naturally, reflected their own concerns and the products they had for sale. These were also important to the government which made great profits from taxing the trade with the West.
also, why I LOVE ancient history... please guys, pick an ancient or medieval language just to be literate and read your perspective on humanity increases multitudes
It's so incredible that i can sit here eating chips while reading what a random RUclipsr thought about listening to what a 2000 year old chinese historian thought about the roman empire
@@arthurlecomte8950 It's so incredible that I can sit here drinking my coffee while reading about a random RUclipsr eating chips that was reading what a random RUclipsr thought about when listening to what a 2000 year old Chinese historian thought about the roman empire.
Funnily the Time with 3 years is something he only knew cause the parthians lied to the chinese envoy in order to strenghen their grasp on the trade between china and rome.
It’s gonna look like the same sea, same guys going to take you across all these seas. Tipping is customary. If it seems like he is just taking you back and forth across the same sea, shut up and tip him
Omg imagine a GPS talking like an anchient chinese historian. At least the ancient Europeans as Greeks and Romans gave names for river such as Euphrates, Tigres, Hydaspides, in India 🇮🇳
"There are no bandits on the roads..." AHA! What triumph of civilization and Rule of Law!!! "...and if you are not with a group you will be devoured by lions."
The_Bellend the Roman Empire was huge, especially for the time. There were millions of rivers spread over the whole empire. It doesn’t really make it clear where Rome is by saying it’s on one of those many rivers.
We would have to read the rest of the original text for the context. For all we know, it could simply mean there was a river by the city, as part of the description of the place, and was not meant to specify the location.
The world must have appeared to be a much more magical place back whenever not every square inch was accurately mapped out and connected. When you would hear stories of these far away lands where everything is so different, other massive countries with countless kingdoms, and you're not sure quite how big this world really is and how much it holds.
No no, you misunderstood entirely. He said "and juggle 12 balls with extraordinary skill." So, in ancient Rome, there are only 12 balls that can be juggled with extraordinary skill. The others can only be juggled with ordinary skill.
Not entirely implausible, life today is generally more diverse in interests and talents, while due to the circumstances of living in a limited sphere where the majority of people would probably live and die within a set region through multiple generations, you probably had people whom had extremely developed linear talents. We generally like to think of ourselves as superior in general (through physicality or mental acuity) but I would put forth that juggling didn't need a inter-woven network of people to push forth into the threshold of breaking boundaries and setting records.
Voices of the Past I remember one morning several years ago I was having breakfast and the thought crossed my mind of what might Chinese people have thought of the first Europeans they met; doing some googling I found a paper on a 16th century Chinese mariner’s impressions of several European nations. I was truly transfixed by the notion of people so remote to me and to each other meeting for the first time and then writing down what they saw and felt. I tried to look for similar material but I couldn’t really find much similar, until now just casually getting your videos suggested by YT. Thank you so so much for making them! :D
the words must be thriftly write on bamboo slip. that time paper book is not avaliable. It's fortunately they could have any records in that difficult era.
Meanwhile the first Greek accounts of southern India are like "PeOpLe HaVe ThReE hEaDs", which is probably a fun result of a game of historical telephone mixed with exoticism.
@@OriginMSD "Have a seat, have a seat! And I shall conjure for you...FUN beyond your wildest DREAMS!!" It's probably a loose translation for magic. The concept of magic is pretty ancient and widespread across societies, though in many cases under a loose umbrella of mysticism based on the unknown.
Ancient satellite navigation units: go north until you reach the other big city. Cross the big sea to the west, and go north to the next big city. You have reached your destination.
*sends scout out in Civ* Scout: "I have found another civilization!" Me: "What cities do they have? What military?" Scout: "They have silk scarves, made in the western fashion, and red rugs, and hanging rugs, and carpets of all kinds..."
that's because the Chinese are notoriously business and trade oriented. They care about what kind of resources and goods another civilization can offer them in exchange for their money or resources. The city of Hangzhou in Zhejiang province was the apex of the silk road.
Imagine you're traveling to a country with a completely different language and trying to explain the details of European countries to them with a limited vocabulary.
Considering that the Chinese historian would have likely been relying on second-hand or worse accounts by traders, that wasn't too far off. Impressively close on the geography and political system. I like how he acknowledges how little information he actually has too.
Yeah, it's interesting to see how close he got to the truth from just second-hand accounts. It's also pretty fun to hear where he got it wrong, though. The description of how the Roman Emperors were removed from power was pretty funny, for example. "They. . .release the old king, who does not dare show resentment." 😂 It's not technically wrong, dead emperors *do* tend to find it difficult to show resentment.
@@sprouting_lady I wonder how much he (or his sources) were confusing the Roman Empire with the Roman Republic It makes more sense if the kings in question were in fact Consuls
@@JamesR1986 That's an excellent point! It could be that the information he was getting was outdated and the fact that such relatively peaceful transitions were old news just didn't reach him. He never went to the Roman Empire himself, so he was pretty much writing down what he'd heard through a game of telephone, after all.
He was right to deduce that the Persians were messing with the Chinese to stop their middlemen role being threatened. The rumours about there being a shit load of lions and tigers was likely deliberately spread misinformation.
I can just imagine an 80's family packed in a station wagon trecking through ancient Rome. "Hurry, we might see the twelve ball jugglers" the dad says, as the younger brother makes a joke about balls and his older sister scoffs at him.
I like the barely suppressed shade thrown at the Parthians for the terribleness of the directions. "Look we know it's out there somewhere the fucking Parthians won't tell us where!"
In 1500 years Rome had 115 emperors. 54 have been murdered, 2 poisoned, 6 expelled, 5 committed suicide, 6 forced to abdicate, 1 buried alive, 2 unknown deaths, 2 struck by a lightning, and 37 died by natural death. Oh and i am not counting emperor's relatives that have been killed
@Manuel Sacha Actually no, the Text are from 300AD from the Three Kingdoms Period. This means we are fully in the Era of the Empire Rome with the many murdered Emperors lmao
@@regnbuetorsk What the hell did those 2 unfortnunate enough to be struck by lightning do to deserve that fate? That's actually a disproportionally large number
"It is commonly belived that a fish living in a little stream does not know the size of the Yangtze river and the sea, the May fly for that matter does not know of the changing of the four seasons. Why is this so? Because one lives in a small place and the others life is short. I am for the moment intensively examining Daqin and all the other foreign kingdoms. Alas I am limited to traveling by foot and am left living in the puddle left by the hoofprint of an Ox, besides I don't have the longevity of Peng Zu. It has not been my fate to see things first hand, travelling with the rapid winds, or enlisting swift horses to view distant vistas. Alas, I have to strain to see the three heavenly bodies but, oh, how my thoughts fly to the eight foreign regions!" - Yu Huan, 265AD
It’s worth noting that the Roman "water sheep" silk is actually Sea Silk, produced in what is now Israel, Lebanon and Syria. It isn’t actual silkworm silk, but a silk like fabric made from snail excretions.
@@mephostopheles3752 i heard the guy worked in the chinese army of the time and that kinda got me thinking. Wouldnt he be *really* interested in their military tech and tactics?
It makes sense, he probably got most of the information from merchants traveling from Europe to China along the Silk Road and through the Indian Ocean. They would be most interested in what goods could be bought there to be sold in Asia.
It's so true and kind of sad when in the last 2 min. Yu Huan regrets that he'll never be able to travel to these distant lands and therefore he cannot verify his information first hand. He's so hungry of knowledge, yet he understands that his life is too short and world too vast. 1800 years later I feel the same (but I have internet and channels like this one to satisfy my hunger :)
I had the opposite reaction. As a German I'm flying to New York soon, a huge distance for this man and it will not take me months or years, I'll be there in 7 hours
@@shittymcrvids3119not everyone is as privileged as you. Many people still can’t travel all the world in 2023 for various reasons. You are assuming everyone must have the same same rich white lifestyle as you
Can you imagine these ancient historians and what they would think of the info we have from the internet about history. The info that got destroyed/missing etc
@@Skadi609 I thought of that too. But of course this Chinese historian relying on third hand sources did not get that good a view of the government. And classic though Juvenal was, hie works were not translated into Chinese -- maybe it is time! In any case, it is nice to see there is someone else out there who gets the reference to Juvenal;)
I particularly liked the note at the end, where he mentions how he is limited to second-hand accounts and will never be able to see Da Qin or the other foreign regions for himself.
C V out of all the information he presents for never being in Italy it is surprisingly accurate if these are your only two counter points for a man in an ancient time to be this close who is taking second or third hand accounts is “surprisingly accurate”
One of the most interesting things I find is that the Chinese think the Romans cultivated silkworms. This is not true, the Romans never cultivated silkworms. So why did the Chinese think they did? The Parthian Empire! Basically, when the Chinese sent silk down the Silk Road, they'd pass through quite a few kingdoms and other states. One of them being the Kushan Kingdom, who'd let the Chinese through but for a small fee. However, the Parthians ended up being great at business, because once the Chinese reached the city of Merv, they'd be stopped and convince the Chinese to hand over their goods and have the Parthians take it the rest of the way, to sell at a profit. And they made sure the Chinese went through them, apparently in the entire history of the Han Empire, only one Chinese man ever made it through the Parthians. We'll get back to him later. So, the Parthians took the Chinese silk, which was tightly woven into blankets to the Romans, making sure the two never met. The Romans however, would usually unravel the silk to make it into lighter sheets, similar to what we'd commonly consider silk. They would then end up selling it back to the Chinese, and of course, the Parthians would take it. However, when the Parthians met the Chinese, and the Chinese asked where this silk came from, the Parthians would say it came from Roman silkworms. This was a simple deception, because if the Chinese realised they had a monopoly on silk, they would have been able to sell it for a *huge* mark-up. However, since the Chinese "knew" that the Romans had cultivated silkworms, they weren't able to price it as high. Pretty cool hey? In fact, the fact that the Romans unraveled Chinese silk is actually mentioned by Yu Huan himself. So what about this man who made it through the Parthians? Well, the great general Ban Chao sent an ambassador by the name of Gan Ying to cross the silk road to see the Romans. He made it all the way through Parthia and to the "western sea", likely the Persian gulf, where he planned to take a ship the rest of the way. When he planned to hire a ship, he was told by the sailors: "The ocean is huge, if you encounter winds that delay you it can take two years. The vast ocean urges men to think of their home country, and get homesick. And some of them die." Of course, they neglected to mention the far quicker land route. So what did Gan Ying do? Well he asked the sailors to tell him everything about the Roman Empire. They did, he wrote it down, and took it back to China. I'd venture to guess quite a bit of this work of Yu Huan was derived from what Gan Ying was told by the sailors.
Thank you so much for writing this down! It's really interesting to learn about this interesting "silkworm" the Romans/Parthians craftily used to keep the prices in check!
The Parthians basically became Roman puppets until the rise of the Sassanid Empire, so it's not entirely unfair to call them "Roman." It's not helped by how many powerful Roman families worked to profit from the trade with the East, and being unable to do so somewhat froze people out of politics, so it's easy to see why someone would think Rome was able to make Silk themselves: it would be hard to grasp how "mere" merchants could become so powerful.
The closing remarks of the historian are truly heartfelt. You learn of a man from 18 centuries ago who wanted to travel and know the world, but accepted that it's not possible for him.
Oof. Facts man, but at least he's remembered all this time later, and how he was amongst the most curious scholars We respect his understanding of the situation
If you think about it, even a century ago aviation wasn't sufficiently developed to travel overseas, and Cape Horn was the only choice if you had to travel by sea between the Atlantic and the Pacific. No GPS, so be sure the sea pilot knows how to read the night sky.
I love the fact that he's mainly preoccupied with basic, practical information about politics and tradeable commodities, but stops to talk about some circus tricks he's seen that he thought were really cool. That coda added on at the end about how big and wondrous the world is and how little of it he'll get to see in his lifetime is beautiful, poetic and haunting. Even in today's interconnected, obsessively documented world, it still rings true.
This account is not a firsthand report. The historian in question was too poor to travel, but he has collected lots of first- and secondhand reports and assembled them into this document that is being read here (which explains why so many statements are vague or incorrect).
@@Orillion123456 hmm, yep that probably explains why he went on and on about how many rugs there were in the Roman Empire - these were everything traded from the Roman Empire through the Silk Road that he could have touched in his lifetime
Yeah, I was thinking the same. Each time I read or hear something like this I just wish to be able to bring these people to the present and show them the wonders of the world...they feel very close and relatable in their curiosity about the world, even if separated by centuries.
@@iratepirate3896 nah the roman actually respected parthians and other kingdoms, (the numidian for example) they disliked gauls and germans mostly, ironically enough, because they didn't bathe themselves that much and romans were extremely petty and clean freaks basically, and that was considered an extremely bad misdemeanor
@@garn4579 The Parthians and Sassanids were the main real exception, but even they were only respected begrudgingly, the latter far more so than the Parthians.
@@garn4579 they didn't respect anyone in particular and thought of anyone not roman as barbarians, and those who did gain respect were due to much effort on the other's behalf. The romans remained ignorant on China, as they were too far to conquer, thus less time was invested in learning about them.
@@jkjkhardcore666 again not really, they had good relations with greeks and some northern african kingdom (like the numidian), mostly after their help during the second punic wars, the greeks were the one thinking everyone but them was a barbarian
Archimonde Definitely is. China back in those days especially was miles ahead of most other civilizations. Roman Empire was the only one they thought was worthy enough to be considered of any importance. That and maybe some in India as well.
Literally in Chinese Da Qin (大秦) means "Great Qin". Qin was a state who conquered all the other states and formed the united China for the first time, but collapsed only 15 years after the unification. The reason why the successor Han dynasty used Qin to translate Roman Empire was possibly because Qin was the western most state in China, and Roman Empire is also in the west. They were both strong and rich, so maybe these two countries are related. (This is only my guessing, not based on academic research) The word "China" is ultimately from "Qin" (historical reconstructed pronunciation: dsin), but never used by the Chinese people to call themselves. Instead, Chinese people use Han to call themselves (汉人), and many other words to call the geographical region of China (e.g. 中原 zhongyuan "middle lands", 华夏 huaxia, 天下 tianxia "under the sky", etc).
The Avatar Rome back in the day blew China out of the water in all regards. The Chinese, in the context of empire were basically African in comparison. It’s an insult to Rome to be called equal to China.
Landry Du Luzon Cute attempt at downplaying China's advancement during that time period, but nah. It's a worthy praise for Rome to be compared as equal to ancient China
Yu Huan: "I am limited to travelling on foot and living in the puddle of the hoof print left by an ox. But, oh, how my thoughts fly to the eight foreign regions." It's nice to hear an ancient Chinese historian wish to visit a very distant country.
My guess about him 'having to strain to see the 3 heavenly bodies' was him saying he had bad eyes. Too nerdy to travel the wilds of the ancient world, he stayed home and read books instead.
@@jimboblordofeskimos The original is但劳眺乎三辰，而飞思乎八荒耳。 I can only look at 3 heavenly bodies （sun，moon&stars）from a distance，my thoughts fly to the eight foreign regions
It means that he can only afford to see only his horizon which is his local region. Anything further would require imagination as the distance is just too far
When he says that the Romans "originated in China, but left it" I think he is referrencing the Roman founding myth that they descended from Trojans who fled Asia-minor and settled Italy after the Trojan war. The Chinese seem to have only heard "Asia" and assumed that Troy was in Chinese territory. This would explain why they call the Romans "Da Qin" meaning "great China".
The name “Asia” actually once referred to just Anatolia, and was a name used by the Greeks that might have come from Akkadian. After a long time, the name’s meaning became morphed so that “Asia” referred not just to the Anatolian Peninsula, but to the greater landmass beyond as well (what we now know as the continent of Asia). Because of this, Greeks near the end of the classical age started using the name “Mikrà Asía” (Lesser Asia, or as we now know it, Asia Minor) to refer to the peninsula. Basically, this might be a possibility based on my own flawed and incomplete knowledge. It just matters when “Asia” started meaning more than just Anatolia, and when the Chinese first heard the myth of the Trojans and Aeneas.
Realize that meanings are lost in translation, especially when considering historical political contexts crossing territories and cultures. 'King' should be seen as more so a generic title for any ruler/politician (sovereign or not), rather than our modern understanding of hereditary monarchs.
Teringventje (Check yourself before you wreck yourself) On a Rainy Night, Lines to be Sent Forth: “You ask me when I return, but I know not when. The pools here at Pa Shan overflow with rain. When will we trim candles by the western window and the rain of this evening be in our words?” -Li Shangyin (9th century) upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/26/Nestorian_stele_1.jpg
Jonathan Lake Lovelace Here's another description of Rome from our history book: "其人民皆长大平正，有类中国，故谓之大秦。--《后汉书·西域传》" When our ancestors were doing business in this place, they were surprised to find that the local people were tall, strong and polite, and they were very similar to themselves. Naturally, the feeling of kinship emerged in their hearts. So they called it Da Qin.😀
"there's a big sea, then there's a river, then west of that another sea, then a river, the some mountains, then, like, some more rivers and seas and that, and then west of that there's a sea and a river" capiche?
For you information, the original text was part of a historic book written by a government official (not by the government tho). This book is mainly about recording the history of a period called Wei, which was really common in ancient China because each time a dynasty collapsed, the new government would write a historic book to record everything happened on the previous dynasty. These historic books are official, and they have almost the exact same structure. The contents about Roman Empire are included in a chapter that is solely for introducing foreign states (西戎传, "the chapter of western foreigners"), which is routine for every official historic book. Although this book is not an official book, it follows the same structure of contents. This is the reason why the author wrote down the information about the Roman Empire, but had never been to even anywhere outside of China --- this part was the contents that are not "important" according to the author's opinion but a "must" for completing this book. It's kind of like the introduction part of an essay, maybe 99% of its readers would not pay attention to it, you still need to write it down in an essay.
Sounds bit monty python “Nahhh no way youll get past there. very dangerous it is. You’ll need to buy guides. And er.. weapons” “Weapons? I thought there’s no bandits. I can see it from here” “Right yeh. No bandits. But it looks closer than it is. And it’s real dangerous” “How dangerous? What’s there?” “Errr... lions” “Lions?” “Yeh lions. Big huge lions. Man eaters. Loads of em” “I didn’t think there was lions around here” “Loads of lions here mate. You’ll need guides. And weapons. Annndd.. more cloth. Lions hate cloth.”
“That’s just a man in a furry scarf and a fake nose” “Nah that’s a lion. King of the animals. Tear you in two he will” “Roar” I feel a Lost monty python sketch here
A lot of people would never have seen the sea if they didn't live near to it, so they would only really know that it's a huge amount of water, not that it's salty.
CadaverJunky Remember that by that time there was no idea that the world was connected or even that it was rounded. Most of the people living in the world by that time never traveled that far, and “knowing” that in another part of the world there was a sea of drinkable water was huge news. Moreover, it’s the 3rd century. The mythology was rule.
@@frd8798 Still being spoken in France, Spain, Portugal, Italy, Romania, _Latin_ America, much of Africa, Catholic churches worldwide, and plenty more. Very heavily altered versions, yes, but are they not still Romance?
I love how the author is trying to emphasize the similarities with China like post stations and roads. Funny how he mentions tigers and lions, although lions were native to Greece until the 5# century so he's not completely wrong. He's also correct about the nature of the emperor's title and how could it be obtained. Pretty interesting.
Its because they were curious as Middle Eastern traders portrayed Rome as the equals to China. Ancient China saw itself as having no equals, so of course when their told they have an equal at the opposite ends of the world, their interested.
Its so cool hearing an account of Rome from such an alien(to us) perspective. Where we usually learn from the perspective of someone who either lived in the Roman Empire or in its ruins, this is from a completely alien point of view where social customs and culture that are of interest to them are pointed out to us where as most Roman authors wouldn’t have listed things such as juggling at carnivals and types of jade as important.
Heh. The account by Yu Huan in the Weilue also put a lot of focus on various types of cloths apparently. The Romans did that on occasion and even spoke frequently about silk, but the Chinese were obsessed with that sort of thing when talking about the inventories of other known civilizations. It also shows their mercantile priorities and the list of items also demonstrates that the Romans were culturally refined like his fellow Han Chinese.
I agree, It always sounds so magical so mysterious the discretions of ancient Chinese or Japanese or even the accounts of interactions between the Europeans and native Americans. It's almost like reading a fantasy novel. It's almost nostalgic, imaging the world before we completed the maps, back when there still were things to discover.
During the second century, the Chinese court received Syrian/Roman jugglers as a diplomatic gift from one of the Indian Realms (the Saka Kingdom). There was high international demand for exotic performers in the Ancient World. The Chinese saw Roman conjurors before they met Roman envoys...
@@monsterclown4455 barbossa to sparrow : the world is getting smaller (talking about how the world is nearly fully mapped and the rise of beckett) and how the age of piracy is ending.
magma2680 there are pyramids on every continent there was supposedly a ancient cell phone and computer found u don’t think we all had contact at one point rather it be spiritual or physical we communicated just as we as today. It’s a reason Rome history has what they call the dark ages.
Well you have to consider that he probably never heard a roman say what the land is actually called and only heard it from traders so it was translated over and over leading to what the Chinese called it.
@@fiachradillon It's generally accepted by experts, that postman Pat was the originator of the postal service. The Knights Templar are generally associated with creating the modern banking system
In a way, the difference between an advanced civilization and 'other' civilizations is the existence of a reliable means of communication; One that is protected, well managed, consistent, and well respected. Think of the Gauls and other societies on the outskirts of SPQR: They had to meet in person to get anything done, or rely upon trusted couriers who were unpredictable. I love the idea of such pre-industrial societies being so outrageously ambitious with their post. It inspires one to write more letters!
Quite touching to hear the earnest thoughts of the historian as he tried to record his knowledge as much as possible, knowing that some day in the future, other people may read his words.
That part at the end was heartbreaking. To spend your life learning about places you know you'll never be able to see. Makes me wish I could bring him forward in time, he could be in Da Qin in a day.
The vast majority of people today can't just hop on a plane and travel and the vast majority will never leave their own countries. That last part wasn't sad, the author himself said he loved thinking about these other places. He was being pragmatic, much like someone today might admit they'll never meet their favourite singer but they'll read about them online and follow their tweets. That guy was as passionate about places he's never seen as historians are about times they've never lived in or A Song of Ice and Fire fans were before realising the last books will probably never be written - now that's a real tragedy.
Ioso Sop Put the pea as a example of the sun, now put us to scale. The furthest we’ve ever traveled is 1.3cm off of earth, the nearest star is Kilometers away and 2 hour drive, our deepest space probe is 10ft away. Take 3 steps, 4 steps, now for the last step and you’ve overshot and passed the probe. We’re still on the moon task list, just peeking out at mars and deciding which is the best option.
I think he was examining the competition to Chinese silk in this type of the world, I think a lot of his long lists are regarding economy related products.
大秦( Da Qin) means Great Qin. The ancient Chinese thought Roman Empire as another huge nation founded by the people from its previous Qin Dynasty. Unlike Anxi which was translated from Arsi ( official name of Parthia ) , people in 3rd century AD China didn't even know the name of "Roma". All their knowledge about Rome was acquired from Parthia or Sassanid Persia and that is why the later East Roman Empire ( or Byzantium Empire ) was called 拂霖( Fu Lin) which is derived from Persian " Vrum" .
@Konstantinos Palaiologos No - it is good the west was not exposed to the slanted Chinese civilisation - they can keep the one stringed cello, chopsticks and worthless artworks.
@N5ZZ0 But what about Principled Catholic Doctrine like the Papal Bull "Cum nimis absurdum" issued by Pope Paul IV in 1555 to ensure all jews in Rome were walled up in the Roman Ghetto? It takes its name from the Bull’s first words: "Since it is absurd and utterly inconvenient that the Jews, who through their own fault were condemned by God to eternal slavery..." Under the Papal Bull, Jewish males were required to wear a pointed yellow hat, and Jewish females a yellow kerchief and their livelihood limited to dealing in second hand clothes and walled up in a ghetto overnight - up until 1870 when the Italian risorgimento abolished Papal rule in Italy. (The creation of Vatican City and a yearly massive cash donative was later agreed upon by Mussolini and Pius XI in 1929) Mmmm ... sounds familiar ....reminds me of the actions of a certain Austrian Catholic ruler in the 1930s and 40s who resurrected the 3rd Holy Roman Empire, 10,000 of whose followers managed to get to Argentina a bit later with the help of the Vatican..... errr....where the Pope is from….errrr….which is obviously a total coincidence. Nothing to see here. Let’s move on. Ehrrmmmm…..as I was saying - let us continue to adore the One Holy Apostolic Church - that made Bolivia, Peru, El Salvador, Nicaragua, Honduras, Guatemala and Paraguay into those ‘shining cities on a hill’ and inspired the youthful morality of Rodrigo Borgia, Dr. Joe Mengele, Hugo Chavez, Carlos The Jackal,, Heinrich Himmler, Mel Gibson, Adolf Hitler and Che Guevara. Bravo !! Well done Rome !! Of course, having said that, I must say that my favorite Dear Leader is Chairman Mao. He Purged 70 million thought-criminals from China, more than any other Dear Leader anywhere else - also Pol Pot because he liquidated 1/3 of his beloved nation Kampuchea. Bravo again !!
"Anshi", I always wondered how that name came about. But then I remembered that Parthia was only called "Parthia" by the Romans; to foreigners, they were "Arsaces", the Arsacid Empire, a term that can explain the Chinese name by contraction: Arsaces becomes Arsci, becomes Anshi.
Can we just take a moment to appreciate the massive works translators and historians have gone through in modern time to figure out which countries/cities these ancient scrolls refer to? Amazing.
@Lord Farquaad Doesn't necessarily mean "Long Live" Just means "be well". Like, good health to caesar. It's also just a generic polite greeting. Its direct English equivalent is "hail" as in hail mary or hail traveller.
@Lord Farquaad I know, that literally means the same... They are wishing long live to their "king". They were not kings, of course, but to that Chinese man there was no difference.
@@xmaverickhunterkx Caesar is Gaius Julius Caesar's cognomen. The Caesares were a branch of the Julia family. The Name became associated with the Caesar we know today, and after his successor, the emperor Augustus adopted it, with the idea of kingship and ruling
This is quite incredible to listen to. It doesn't sound like a man talking about another civilisation of other men; it sounds like a man talking about an alien civilisation from another planet haha. It must have been quite the thing to hear these accounts of far away places back when most people's worlds were so much smaller
It's also interesting how merchants influenced historical writing. Since he got most of his information, and the information was mostly used for other merchants, much of what he tells is: How to get there, what they produce, is it in a state of peace and what is their political system.
What also amazes me about this scholar is his regret of not having the means nor the lifetime to visit the places told to him. It may be an "alien" place, but you can tell his desire to see and experience it firsthand. A true scholar indeed!
@@TheFissionchips the fact that we have a chinese perspective on Rome, a civilization on the other side of the world is astonishibg and highly interesting. That is the blessing
This is so interesting. Makes you think about all those cultures about which we have only or mostly outside sources. How many misconceptions do we have because of that? Nice bit of introspection from the author at the end. It would be easy to make fun of him writing about bamboo and tigers in Italy, but he was clearly trying to learn and describe as much as he could of the vast and mysterious world, realizing how greatly limited he was in this endeavor. Edit: I meant to post this comment simply under the video, instead I somehow ended posting it as a response to Aron's. I guess it actually works too.
Riot Breaker the first part of the scroll has a painting of the historian himself with a shocked look on his face in the foreground, and in the background is a blurred painting of a naked lady
As the author admits he is retelling from other sources, not an eyewitness, it is interesting how accurate the description is (and isn't). The way he describes the ruler's frequent replacement points toward republican Rome, though this was written 200 years into the imperial period. I also wonder if the Romans actually possessed silk worms.
@ExVeritaeLibertas There were periods of frequent changes in rule under the Empire, too. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crisis_of_the_Third_Century was close to the time this historian was writing about and had a *lot* of change in Emperor.
@@dato_4527 As you point out, *the* silkworm moth had to be smuggled out of China. This took place only as late as the 6th century. But there are other testimonies (already mentioned somewhere in this thread, too) to Romans using wild moths to get an inferior silk. That might have been what this historian heard about. Oh, and it also needs to be stressed: yes, the Chinese guarded their sil secrets closely, but as usually happens with trade secrets, the secrets were leaked over time. There are very few companies that have guarded their trade secrets well enough to continue to profit. Intel and the Coca Cola Company come to mind as examples.
It is true, though, Hellenistic and Roman era Greeks in places like Syria were renowned for having talented jugglers, who often found themselves entertaining foreign royal courts and traveling to places as distant as Burma and, as we see here, China.
"They have appointed 36 leaders, or generals, who discuss evens frequently. If one leader does not show up, there's no discussion." Sounds an awful lot like modern senates as well! Thanks, Romans.
Uhh, yeah... did you not know that most of the American political institutions were lifted from Rome and Greece? Democracy, republic, senate, various political terms like oligarchy, dictator, etc.
@@Littlegoatpaws Largely because dying was still quite the dark art at this time. Virtually all dyes were derived from plants (the purple derived from snails being a notable exception), and were not very colour fast, so you'd have to have coloured fabrics redyed when they faded, or continually buy more. It's not until the rise of industry, and chemistry (rather than alchemy) that you find mordants and true colour fast dyes, which is a good millenium in the future at the time of writing
@@lordforlorn9766 That mankind has actually been using asbestos cloth that long is a surprise to me, actually. And yes, it's a real thing. Favored for it's fire proof qualities.
A couple reasons that I'd guess: - he's getting his info from merchants and traders, who'd likely not interact with military beyond law enforcement - he's not a military scout getting info for war, so this info is not very useful to what he's writing for - probably wanted info that would be useful for trade, or cultural relations in case China wanted to send embassadors some day
@@NMahon The Roman army was definitely superior, although individual soldiers may not have been. This was written after the Marian Reforms and well into the Imperial period, when the army had transitioned into a true professional military. They were also probably the only army in the world that made regular use of field artillery at this time
"They say they originally came from China, but left it" I'm guessing this is a misinterpretation of the story of Aeneas, a Trojan who fled to Italia after the fall of Troy and who is the ancestor to Romulus.
@@jomolololo4398There are indeed many possibilities. It could be propaganda as you say; the Romans had organized laws, a rich culture, and advanced technology such that the author might have felt unable to dismiss them as "barbarians", so perhaps claiming the Romans were Chinese was how he could justify their being so civilized by his standards.
Firstly, I love this channel. I always loved ancient history. I love the maps in these in particular. They are very clear and easy to see. Thank you so much. I am 78 yrs of age.
Read about the Franklin Expedition. They were almost three years on a boat, two of which stuck in the ice whilst suffering from severe lead poisoning, scurvy and everyone died.
"There are no bandits or thieves but there are fierce tigers and lions. If you are not in a group, you cannot get through." I see you've heard my grandpa's stories of how he used to go to school back in his day...
Not fated to travel the rapid winds or ride swift horses to actually see for himself, but, filled with curiousity for the eight foreign regions. I know the feeling ancient Chinese brother! The wonderful curiosity!
@@adamyooz Considering the Middle Kingdom is called that, I can see what you mean. I mean, seriously. Discount Middle Earth doesn't even have elves and dwarves!
He was definitely right about the “middle men” who handled trade between east and west being anxious to prevent contact outside of them (understandably, but probably unnecessarily so).
The part where he talks about lions and tigers attacking while traversing the trade routes was definitely made up by middlemen if you ask me. Those trade routes were heavily used and guarded by many powers and definitely were not that unsafe lol.
The ancient world is actually more connected than you think. They are heavily dependent on barter trade in between nations. And should any trading nation were to block trade or at war, the whole trading network is disrupted
It was partially true. It was recorded in the time of Augustus that a virgin with a bag of gold around her neck could ride from (modern day) Naples to Rome on a horse along the Appian Way without being harassed by bandits.
@@stugrant01 actually it was mostly propaganda.The newspapers were told to run stories praising fascist efficiency. Sometimes the trains were still late, but that was never reported on.
Some kid should use this a reference for his essay on Rome. 'Julius Caesar was a 7 ft tall fire-breathing king who grew his own silkworms and used a spoon made out of rock.'
Harry he’d probably disagree with you. You just say that because you’re accustomed to your history and traditions, so the outside looks a lot more interesting in comparison. But look at the hellenic mythos, the legends and history of the Roman world. The twins Remus and Romulus, raised by a she-wolf, who came to found the greatest empire Europe has ever seen. The three god brothers born from a titan ruler of time, who competed between themselves for the dominion of the heavens, the seas and the underworld. The young ruler of Makedon, Alexander, permanently marked in history as the Great, who conquered the known world of the time in a little over a decade. The great Julius Caesar and his legendary triumphs and his equally legendary assassination. Look at Egypt and its mysterious pyramids and mythical pharaos. Plenty of epicness and adventures to go around.
R B J ah, I see. I just assumed he meant “our world” to be the western world at the time, since the original comment mentioned that he felt bad that he couldn’t see Rome at the time.
I can't imagine how hard it was for this traveler to overcome the language barriers crossing almost 10 different cultures (just imagine languages and local dialects) in his way to Rome
I bet there was a lot of pointing involved, mixed with some seeming to be gibberish. Possible some sketching going on. Wouldve been a funny thing to see, but an awesome thing to be apart of
The time when China discovered the west was after Alexandra the great conquered Persia and Afghanistan, so I guessed maybe they only needed to find someone who knows Greek and that was fine all the way down to Greece
Thanks for watching! Don’t forget to subscribe for new videos every single week! & Let us know in the comments what you’d like to see covered in the future.
Great, thanks. Is there any speculation on why the Chinese names for the various cities/countries bear no resemblance to the local ones? I would have expected their name for Rome would sound at least somewhat similar.
@@QuigleTheGnome Pretty much the beginning of the end for the Roman Empire. It has its highs and some really fucking bad lows. But it was the beginning .
@@QuigleTheGnome The Roman Empire officially survived until the 1400s actually. But by then it was just a small city and not a massive empire. The 3rd century was actually an alright time though for the empire.
Yu Huan’s reflections at the end of his report were quite poetic. Thank you for bringing his words to us through RUclips. (I wonder what he would have said about *that*)
@The Jester - Fool Of Hearts He was talking about how big the world is, and how little they know about it. He recognizes that with limited knowledge, ability to travel and lifetime, there is no way he can explore all of the lands. But he still imagined what it would be like to be able to travel and see all of the lands.
My take on this: "We don't give our ancient peers enough credit for the stuff they knew, the things they did and discovered, especially those ancient alien guys which think that the egyptians couldn't have build the pyraimds, or any other culture their own prestige projects." I already knew that there used to be ancient trade routes that reached to china but we still tend to underestimate the achievements and mental acrobatics that were done during these times, well done to raise awareness.
@ 27 with a full awareness of how time is passing, I went to the techstore yesterday needed a new keybord, bought a usbstick, that's when I realized that time was passing faster then I had thought. Remember those times when 8GB was the gold standard? Or when 16 became the new 8? 32GB one upping that followed by almost immeasurably big 64GB? I found a 128Gb stick for 19,99€ and the department guy told me yeah and over there we have sd cards with 256GB and 512GB the first for about 60-80€ the later about 80-100€. If you're talking about how I was aware, we have realy good documentaries in Germany, not this US weirdness they call that.
@Doomer The neet gloomer Well I wasn't there for the dark ages, but considering how you commented I'd say you miss the good times you had with the inquisition?
Depends on your world view. There are those of us that believe that humans are getting smaller, dumber and living shorter lives than we used to. The achievements of the past are litanous, coupled with the prevalence of polymaths like Da Vinci and others in times past, it's hard to argue against. I point to megaliths as evidence of advanced humans rather than space aliens.
@@CaliforniaCarpenter7 Well remember, we only really see the huge successes of the past. It's due to survivor bias. Like a good example is all the classical music. Most of the classic music we know of is only a few select composers and even then we only really care about a very few of their dozens of composures.
@Douglas Williams That's true, but I'd like to see a modern equivalent of Chopin. Better yet, maybe a modern equivalent of Liszt seeing as the two were alive at the same time. Liszt could sight read Chopin's best work. Chopin wrote Etudes and Nocturnes that will survive forever. I'm large enough that I've been able to keep my wisdom teeth, most people aren't. Seems to me that there was a time when we all could. Especially going along with the conventional narrative that 10,000 years ago we dwelled in caves without any kind of dentistry. Either way, I stick with my view. We weren't capable of lifting Baalbek sized stones until very recently, we still couldn't fathom actually transporting them anywhere. "Ancient, primitive ShrewPanzees" managed the feat with regularity, and this says nothing about the precision with which they were assembled. Apologies for rambling.
Just to clarify the "Chinese think Roman were also Chinese" part, which is mentioned by many comments and could bring some discomfort. I don't think that's true, the narrator's source might have some minor translation error. I looked into Chinese history book and the record is "The Da Qin people were tall, big, kind, dignified, just like us." Maybe the ancient Chinese back then seldomly see nourished, civilized foreigners, which must amazed them. Here's the original script :"其王无有常人(King changed all the time)，皆简立贤者 (chose the wise ones)。国中灾异及风雨不时，辄废而更立，受放者甘黜不怨 (climate omens can dispose kings, and the banished ones donot complain)。其人民皆长大平正，有类中国，故谓之大秦 (these people look tall, big, kind, dignified, just like us Chinese, so we name them Da Qin)。"
I sat here and rewinded several times trying to understand why he would say that. My guess was he was envious of Rome so he wanted to "claim" them. Or partly take credit for their achievements. But what you said is much more practical.
@@VirtualVictoryTM I've searched some modern historian explanations, which indicated basicly the middle Asia nomad people thought China and Rome were the same thing: big, strong empires. So it could be them telling the Chinese this. Hence the misunderstanding. I can assure you ancient Chinese wouldn't be "envious" of any other nations, 100%. It's just not our way of thinking.
We just going to ignore he said DRAGONS BLOOD! Like a dragon a mythical beast that commonly breaths fire. Mythical... a myth and these guys got is blood. Eh tell me how?
@@Kakuretaka Dragon's blood is a red resin extracted from the dragon tree (Dracaena draco), which grows wild in Morocco and the Canaries. It is now used as a precious varnish for things like violins, but I think it was also attributed medicinal properties.
"There are too many small kingdoms to describe. Now, let me list in detail all the rugs they use."
Loves cloth so he does
@@VoicesofthePast As the author, Yu Huan, sadly, was unable to travel far in person, he was obliged to use the reports of others, who were often merchants. They, naturally, reflected their own concerns and the products they had for sale. These were also important to the government which made great profits from taxing the trade with the West.
lmao
also, why I LOVE ancient history...
please guys, pick an ancient or medieval language just to be literate and read
your perspective on humanity increases multitudes
Typical Chinese. Not very interested in people but more so in clothings & fabric ;)
it is so incredible that i can sit here eating lunch while listening to what a chinese historian 2000 years ago thought about the roman empire
ThePainkiller9995 hard to believe isn't it.
It's so incredible that i can sit here eating chips while reading what a random RUclipsr thought about listening to what a 2000 year old chinese historian thought about the roman empire
@@arthurlecomte8950 It's so incredible that I can sit here drinking my coffee while reading about a random RUclipsr eating chips that was reading what a random RUclipsr thought about when listening to what a 2000 year old Chinese historian thought about the roman empire.
@Sean C it's good in general don't knock it, don't blame the algorithm if it keeps recommending cat videos.
How far we came I'm I right!🤘😳
He obviously met alot of textile merchants when compiling his research.
That's who did most of the trading. Persian and Parthian textile traders.
silk road...
Too bad he wasn't an alcoholic, then we'd know what they drank.
He is chinese. Chinese do business.
@S, Lianis You obviously don't know any Chinese people.
ancient GPS be like: turn left and cross two seas, you will arrive at your destination in three years with no wind
SPEED = DISTANCE / TIME.
@@oldi184 ok
Funnily the Time with 3 years is something he only knew cause the parthians lied to the chinese envoy in order to strenghen their grasp on the trade between china and rome.
You really had to have alot of faith back then lol
@@oldi184 ok?????
Go straight ahead, cross a big sea, turn left, cross another big sea..
@Gacha cookie monster Remind me not to get lost in Asia...
@Gacha cookie monster Must be why they are exceptional drivers ;)
......And you're there! Thanks for watching Rick Steve's Europe. Keep on Traveling!
It’s gonna look like the same sea, same guys going to take you across all these seas. Tipping is customary. If it seems like he is just taking you back and forth across the same sea, shut up and tip him
Omg imagine a GPS talking like an anchient chinese historian.
At least the ancient Europeans as Greeks and Romans gave names for river such as Euphrates, Tigres, Hydaspides, in India 🇮🇳
"There are no bandits on the roads..." AHA! What triumph of civilization and Rule of Law!!!
"...and if you are not with a group you will be devoured by lions."
@@alanstehlik3514 even tigers were spread in the european plains?
@@Casioo24 potentially, but there would also be mountain or cave lions and lynx that could be mistaken for tigers
@ocelot. FYI Male European lions had no mains!!l...A totally different species that is now unfortunately extinct.
@Josip they were. What about the Nemean Lion then...
ocelot. Yes Lions are Humans natural enemies, that is why we hunted them to extinction.
this is what travel blogging was like 2000 years ago
Damn this guy would have made some quality ass vlogs
@@turnttaco7661 I can imagine him making a series of "unrolling and test-sitting local carpets".
2020: "2/5 I don't recommend : No Wi-Fi"
220: "2/5 I don't recommend: Half of group eaten by giant packs of lions and tigers"
Check out my quill and sailing equipment in the links below!
I just wish we could read the comments too
Chinese historians: "The seat of the ruler is by a river"
Everyone: "Do you have any idea how little that narrows it down?"
i dont get it, please explain lol
@@doni654321 you need fresh water for a city, so almost all cities are near rivers
The_Bellend the Roman Empire was huge, especially for the time. There were millions of rivers spread over the whole empire. It doesn’t really make it clear where Rome is by saying it’s on one of those many rivers.
I presume he meant Rome
We would have to read the rest of the original text for the context. For all we know, it could simply mean there was a river by the city, as part of the description of the place, and was not meant to specify the location.
The world must have appeared to be a much more magical place back whenever not every square inch was accurately mapped out and connected. When you would hear stories of these far away lands where everything is so different, other massive countries with countless kingdoms, and you're not sure quite how big this world really is and how much it holds.
The same way we see the universe today.
@@knife-wieldingspidergod5059 Not quite. Don't know of any foreign cultures up there.
@@knife-wieldingspidergod5059 Yeah not quite. Most scientist believe that its quite empty... others believe that its so big...
Colin Boxall don’t know but doesn’t mean they ain’t there!!!
basically, the feeling someone gets when they play a dark souls game for the first time, at least that's how I felt.
"and juggle 12 balls"
dude, the current world record is 11. either someone miscounted or the romans were better than we are
No no, you misunderstood entirely.
He said "and juggle 12 balls with extraordinary skill." So, in ancient Rome, there are only 12 balls that can be juggled with extraordinary skill. The others can only be juggled with ordinary skill.
Not entirely implausible, life today is generally more diverse in interests and talents, while due to the circumstances of living in a limited sphere where the majority of people would probably live and die within a set region through multiple generations, you probably had people whom had extremely developed linear talents. We generally like to think of ourselves as superior in general (through physicality or mental acuity) but I would put forth that juggling didn't need a inter-woven network of people to push forth into the threshold of breaking boundaries and setting records.
@@Kaosu10 ...
On the other hand, someone probably exaggerated.
Roman men liked juggling balls
@@SoulWinner1986 and diddling little boys
The internet has finally met my specific needs
Welcome!
Yes there is some good out there
Angie Kether saaaaame this is such a precious channel
Voices of the Past I remember one morning several years ago I was having breakfast and the thought crossed my mind of what might Chinese people have thought of the first Europeans they met; doing some googling I found a paper on a 16th century Chinese mariner’s impressions of several European nations. I was truly transfixed by the notion of people so remote to me and to each other meeting for the first time and then writing down what they saw and felt. I tried to look for similar material but I couldn’t really find much similar, until now just casually getting your videos suggested by YT.
Thank you so so much for making them! :D
I never knew I needed historical ASMR, but here I am.
“So what kind of clothes do the westerns wear?”
“Western clothes”
the words must be thriftly write on bamboo slip.
that time paper book is not avaliable.
It's fortunately they could have any records in that difficult era.
@Jack Lynd the chinese had paper at this point
So what flavor is Japan's tea?
"Japanese"
"Yes but tell me more about the ten types of glaze"
They wear pants real low
I like how the Chinese account was like, "Yeah, the Romans are really awesome, but they're basically our descendants so it makes sense."
Which is untrue as fuck
While the other side called them barbarians shows the difference lol 😂
If I had to guess, it's a bastardized retelling of the Aeneid, where Trojans from the east went west to found Rome.
Meanwhile the first Greek accounts of southern India are like "PeOpLe HaVe ThReE hEaDs", which is probably a fun result of a game of historical telephone mixed with exoticism.
Dixie anglo American Exactly... black people were your ancestors... SON!
* Sees a roadside attraction *
“These people have a tradition of amazing conjuring.”
"And then the Fire nation came!"
Chinese roadside attractions include balancing skills, and extreme flexibility or martial arts so blowing fire is conjuring for them
Maybe conjuring is a loose translation of entertainment.
@@OriginMSD "Have a seat, have a seat! And I shall conjure for you...FUN beyond your wildest DREAMS!!"
It's probably a loose translation for magic. The concept of magic is pretty ancient and widespread across societies, though in many cases under a loose umbrella of mysticism based on the unknown.
@@OriginMSD Translation is always fickle thing.
Ancient Historians: There is a sea. There is a city west of the sea, which is why we call the sea "west of sea". There is another big sea.
supleted hmmm yes I see
Ancient satellite navigation units: go north until you reach the other big city. Cross the big sea to the west, and go north to the next big city. You have reached your destination.
*_hm, yes, the sea appears to be made out of sea_*
That part had me for a minute 😂
I think it's kind of nice. There's no little details they just tell you straightup where everything is
*sends scout out in Civ*
Scout: "I have found another civilization!"
Me: "What cities do they have? What military?"
Scout: "They have silk scarves, made in the western fashion, and red rugs, and hanging rugs, and carpets of all kinds..."
Also they unceremoniously kill their rulers, are circus performers, and there are lots of tigers
He didn’t go there. He ended up near Egypt and just asked what they were like. Therefore a lot of info is economic
Hahaha
that's because the Chinese are notoriously business and trade oriented. They care about what kind of resources and goods another civilization can offer them in exchange for their money or resources.
The city of Hangzhou in Zhejiang province was the apex of the silk road.
Imagine you're traveling to a country with a completely different language and trying to explain the details of European countries to them with a limited vocabulary.
Considering that the Chinese historian would have likely been relying on second-hand or worse accounts by traders, that wasn't too far off. Impressively close on the geography and political system. I like how he acknowledges how little information he actually has too.
Yeah, it's interesting to see how close he got to the truth from just second-hand accounts. It's also pretty fun to hear where he got it wrong, though. The description of how the Roman Emperors were removed from power was pretty funny, for example. "They. . .release the old king, who does not dare show resentment." 😂 It's not technically wrong, dead emperors *do* tend to find it difficult to show resentment.
@@sprouting_lady I wonder how much he (or his sources) were confusing the Roman Empire with the Roman Republic It makes more sense if the kings in question were in fact Consuls
@@JamesR1986 That's an excellent point! It could be that the information he was getting was outdated and the fact that such relatively peaceful transitions were old news just didn't reach him. He never went to the Roman Empire himself, so he was pretty much writing down what he'd heard through a game of telephone, after all.
He was right to deduce that the Persians were messing with the Chinese to stop their middlemen role being threatened. The rumours about there being a shit load of lions and tigers was likely deliberately spread misinformation.
@@iratepirate3896 no, that was accurate. Lions used to roam freely from africa to asia and numbered in the millions.
who needs gps when you have a 2000 year old chinese historian guiding you
I replied to your comment because it was all alone by itself poor comment :'/
I can just imagine an 80's family packed in a station wagon trecking through ancient Rome. "Hurry, we might see the twelve ball jugglers" the dad says, as the younger brother makes a joke about balls and his older sister scoffs at him.
I like the barely suppressed shade thrown at the Parthians for the terribleness of the directions. "Look we know it's out there somewhere the fucking Parthians won't tell us where!"
Yeah,... Those were the good old days.
trafalgar gunner go west at big sea
"They uncerimoniously replace him" how delicate 😆
"who does not dare show resentment" :D
@@andrewcath4615 Because he is dead xD
In 1500 years Rome had 115 emperors.
54 have been murdered, 2 poisoned, 6 expelled, 5 committed suicide, 6 forced to abdicate, 1 buried alive, 2 unknown deaths, 2 struck by a lightning, and 37 died by natural death.
Oh and i am not counting emperor's relatives that have been killed
@Manuel Sacha Actually no, the Text are from 300AD from the Three Kingdoms Period.
This means we are fully in the Era of the Empire Rome with the many murdered Emperors lmao
@@regnbuetorsk What the hell did those 2 unfortnunate enough to be struck by lightning do to deserve that fate? That's actually a disproportionally large number
"It is commonly belived that a fish living in a little stream does not know the size of the Yangtze river and the sea, the May fly for that matter does not know of the changing of the four seasons. Why is this so? Because one lives in a small place and the others life is short. I am for the moment intensively examining Daqin and all the other foreign kingdoms. Alas I am limited to traveling by foot and am left living in the puddle left by the hoofprint of an Ox, besides I don't have the longevity of Peng Zu. It has not been my fate to see things first hand, travelling with the rapid winds, or enlisting swift horses to view distant vistas. Alas, I have to strain to see the three heavenly bodies but, oh, how my thoughts fly to the eight foreign regions!" - Yu Huan, 265AD
Touching, more so to read it in Classical Chinese
10:38
It’s worth noting that the Roman "water sheep" silk is actually Sea Silk, produced in what is now Israel, Lebanon and Syria. It isn’t actual silkworm silk, but a silk like fabric made from snail excretions.
Fascinating, thank you--I'd not heard of that!
Lol I was really confused about the term "water sheep" thanks for clarifying
This proves that the Council of Watersheep has been a power-player for thousands of years. Someone needs to tell Felix...
This is the stuff people go looking for in the comment section.
Than you
It’s an extremely rare skill nowadays
Totally love how this slowly evolves into a merchant shopping guide lol
Makes sense. What’s the point of going all that way if you’re not gonna take anything valuable back with you?
@@mephostopheles3752 i heard the guy worked in the chinese army of the time and that kinda got me thinking. Wouldnt he be *really* interested in their military tech and tactics?
Ads are getting smarter
It makes sense, he probably got most of the information from merchants traveling from Europe to China along the Silk Road and through the Indian Ocean. They would be most interested in what goods could be bought there to be sold in Asia.
Silk game was strong back then lol
We need the reverse: the Roman writings about China
Planning right now!
@@VoicesofthePast God video btw
Thanks pal!
"bar bar bar bar"
@@VoicesofthePast I'll be waiting.
It's so true and kind of sad when in the last 2 min. Yu Huan regrets that he'll never be able to travel to these distant lands and therefore he cannot verify his information first hand. He's so hungry of knowledge, yet he understands that his life is too short and world too vast. 1800 years later I feel the same (but I have internet and channels like this one to satisfy my hunger :)
I had the opposite reaction. As a German I'm flying to New York soon, a huge distance for this man and it will not take me months or years, I'll be there in 7 hours
I wish he were able to visit Rome at the height of the Empire (around 100 AD)
@@shittymcrvids3119not everyone is as privileged as you. Many people still can’t travel all the world in 2023 for various reasons. You are assuming everyone must have the same same rich white lifestyle as you
@@enricomassignani Also wish Rome lasted a few more centuries and a Roman explorer could’ve visited China at its height (~650 CE Tang Dynasty)
Can you imagine these ancient historians and what they would think of the info we have from the internet about history. The info that got destroyed/missing etc
Fire breathing, jugglers, lions, and brightly colored cloths for the tents. Someone just described a circus to this guy haha
@necronomitom Where did you think the word 'circus' came from? It is a Latin word!
@@SpectatorAlius "Panem et circenses" 😉
@@Skadi609 I thought of that too. But of course this Chinese historian relying on third hand sources did not get that good a view of the government. And classic though Juvenal was, hie works were not translated into Chinese -- maybe it is time!
In any case, it is nice to see there is someone else out there who gets the reference to Juvenal;)
SpectatorAlius just learned something new.
Some what street preformers!
"They unceremoniously remove him."
I thought there were ceremony involving daggers?
Too soon
@@IMPERATOR-EL It's been over two thousands years.
@@juliendacoolien3454 still too soon
@@juliendacoolien3454 insensitive.
Et tu Brutus?
I particularly liked the note at the end, where he mentions how he is limited to second-hand accounts and will never be able to see Da Qin or the other foreign regions for himself.
@Joe Blow no it isn't
Like he says that there are no bandits but travelers can be attacked by lions and tigers
C V out of all the information he presents for never being in Italy it is surprisingly accurate if these are your only two counter points for a man in an ancient time to be this close who is taking second or third hand accounts is “surprisingly accurate”
C V and what is so wrong about that?
@@gabor7524 Bandits were a big problem in the Roman times although not everywhere and all the time
C V: Are those soldiers wearing animal skins? 🤔
One of the most interesting things I find is that the Chinese think the Romans cultivated silkworms.
This is not true, the Romans never cultivated silkworms. So why did the Chinese think they did? The Parthian Empire!
Basically, when the Chinese sent silk down the Silk Road, they'd pass through quite a few kingdoms and other states. One of them being the Kushan Kingdom, who'd let the Chinese through but for a small fee. However, the Parthians ended up being great at business, because once the Chinese reached the city of Merv, they'd be stopped and convince the Chinese to hand over their goods and have the Parthians take it the rest of the way, to sell at a profit. And they made sure the Chinese went through them, apparently in the entire history of the Han Empire, only one Chinese man ever made it through the Parthians. We'll get back to him later.
So, the Parthians took the Chinese silk, which was tightly woven into blankets to the Romans, making sure the two never met. The Romans however, would usually unravel the silk to make it into lighter sheets, similar to what we'd commonly consider silk. They would then end up selling it back to the Chinese, and of course, the Parthians would take it. However, when the Parthians met the Chinese, and the Chinese asked where this silk came from, the Parthians would say it came from Roman silkworms.
This was a simple deception, because if the Chinese realised they had a monopoly on silk, they would have been able to sell it for a *huge* mark-up. However, since the Chinese "knew" that the Romans had cultivated silkworms, they weren't able to price it as high.
Pretty cool hey? In fact, the fact that the Romans unraveled Chinese silk is actually mentioned by Yu Huan himself.
So what about this man who made it through the Parthians? Well, the great general Ban Chao sent an ambassador by the name of Gan Ying to cross the silk road to see the Romans. He made it all the way through Parthia and to the "western sea", likely the Persian gulf, where he planned to take a ship the rest of the way. When he planned to hire a ship, he was told by the sailors:
"The ocean is huge, if you encounter winds that delay you it can take two years. The vast ocean urges men to think of their home country, and get homesick. And some of them die."
Of course, they neglected to mention the far quicker land route. So what did Gan Ying do? Well he asked the sailors to tell him everything about the Roman Empire. They did, he wrote it down, and took it back to China.
I'd venture to guess quite a bit of this work of Yu Huan was derived from what Gan Ying was told by the sailors.
Thanks for taking time to write this bro very interesting stuff.🤝
Thank you so much for writing this down! It's really interesting to learn about this interesting "silkworm" the Romans/Parthians craftily used to keep the prices in check!
The Parthians basically became Roman puppets until the rise of the Sassanid Empire, so it's not entirely unfair to call them "Roman."
It's not helped by how many powerful Roman families worked to profit from the trade with the East, and being unable to do so somewhat froze people out of politics, so it's easy to see why someone would think Rome was able to make Silk themselves: it would be hard to grasp how "mere" merchants could become so powerful.
For the Roman silkworms, I guess the merchants told Chinese this because they could bargin a better price.
Huh
The closing remarks of the historian are truly heartfelt. You learn of a man from 18 centuries ago who wanted to travel and know the world, but accepted that it's not possible for him.
Well, if he only knew in 18 centuries after, u could get there fairly easily
If you only knew 18 centuries from now people will write that about you
Oof. Facts man, but at least he's remembered all this time later, and how he was amongst the most curious scholars
We respect his understanding of the situation
It's still the same thing now. We still have same pain, not of exploring the world, but in space.
If you think about it, even a century ago aviation wasn't sufficiently developed to travel overseas, and Cape Horn was the only choice if you had to travel by sea between the Atlantic and the Pacific. No GPS, so be sure the sea pilot knows how to read the night sky.
Chinese: How do you call this city?
Greek: Alexandria.
Chines: You mean Wuchisan? Got it.
To be fair, in old chinese that could be pronuncied something like *qaː ləj sˤanʔ(烏遲散), cfr. "Wuyishanli" *ʔˤa lək srar raj (烏弋山離)...
@@marcocampa94 cool
Ok, a few people have made this kinda comment here. And I have to wonder: what does everyone think ancient "China" called itself?
@@neutralrobot
Zhong Guo in broad sense 中國 or Tianxia 天下 in an even more broader sense.
Sic et simpliciter.
@@neutralrobot I wonder in general, why there are different names for countries and cities in each language. Learn to pronounce, lazy fucks.
The humility of this historian at the end is inspiring
@David Jones I think he'd be stumped hearing that it was a sphere, before you even got to any troll pseudoscience.
Gave me chills, really gives a bit of perspective on how connected we are today.
It is said that a wise man knows that he doesn't know everything.
@TheVaultdweller The wisest know nothing and are comfortable in ambiguity
I wish I understood his cultural references. “Living in the print of an ox hoof” must be a Chinese idiom.
I love the fact that he's mainly preoccupied with basic, practical information about politics and tradeable commodities, but stops to talk about some circus tricks he's seen that he thought were really cool. That coda added on at the end about how big and wondrous the world is and how little of it he'll get to see in his lifetime is beautiful, poetic and haunting. Even in today's interconnected, obsessively documented world, it still rings true.
This account is not a firsthand report. The historian in question was too poor to travel, but he has collected lots of first- and secondhand reports and assembled them into this document that is being read here (which explains why so many statements are vague or incorrect).
@@Orillion123456 hmm, yep
that probably explains why he went on and on about how many rugs there were in the Roman Empire - these were everything traded from the Roman Empire through the Silk Road that he could have touched in his lifetime
amazing read, and can feel the palpable regret in his words of the difficulty of travel in those days.
the chinese Marko Polo
Yeah, I was thinking the same. Each time I read or hear something like this I just wish to be able to bring these people to the present and show them the wonders of the world...they feel very close and relatable in their curiosity about the world, even if separated by centuries.
A possible three year voyage across the Indian Ocean!
@@alanpennie8013 Middle men exaggerate the journey to prevent two wealthy civilizations from connecting directly.
You can tell he has a lot of admiration, it’s cool to see an ancient cultural respect
It's pretty astonishing. The Chinese (and the Romans too) saw little to admire in other civilisations.
@@iratepirate3896 nah the roman actually respected parthians and other kingdoms, (the numidian for example) they disliked gauls and germans mostly, ironically enough, because they didn't bathe themselves that much and romans were extremely petty and clean freaks basically, and that was considered an extremely bad misdemeanor
@@garn4579 The Parthians and Sassanids were the main real exception, but even they were only respected begrudgingly, the latter far more so than the Parthians.
@@garn4579 they didn't respect anyone in particular and thought of anyone not roman as barbarians, and those who did gain respect were due to much effort on the other's behalf. The romans remained ignorant on China, as they were too far to conquer, thus less time was invested in learning about them.
@@jkjkhardcore666 again not really, they had good relations with greeks and some northern african kingdom (like the numidian), mostly after their help during the second punic wars, the greeks were the one thinking everyone but them was a barbarian
Da Qin: the other china, literal translation. A more florid prose would call it "the empire across the earth"
That's some incredible praising to be considered an equal by the Chinese.
Archimonde
Definitely is. China back in those days especially was miles ahead of most other civilizations.
Roman Empire was the only one they thought was worthy enough to be considered of any importance.
That and maybe some in India as well.
Literally in Chinese Da Qin (大秦) means "Great Qin". Qin was a state who conquered all the other states and formed the united China for the first time, but collapsed only 15 years after the unification. The reason why the successor Han dynasty used Qin to translate Roman Empire was possibly because Qin was the western most state in China, and Roman Empire is also in the west. They were both strong and rich, so maybe these two countries are related. (This is only my guessing, not based on academic research)
The word "China" is ultimately from "Qin" (historical reconstructed pronunciation: dsin), but never used by the Chinese people to call themselves. Instead, Chinese people use Han to call themselves (汉人), and many other words to call the geographical region of China (e.g. 中原 zhongyuan "middle lands", 华夏 huaxia, 天下 tianxia "under the sky", etc).
The Avatar Rome back in the day blew China out of the water in all regards. The Chinese, in the context of empire were basically African in comparison. It’s an insult to Rome to be called equal to China.
Landry Du Luzon Cute attempt at downplaying China's advancement during that time period, but nah. It's a worthy praise for Rome to be compared as equal to ancient China
Yu Huan: "I am limited to travelling on foot and living in the puddle of the hoof print left by an ox.
But, oh, how my thoughts fly to the eight foreign regions."
It's nice to hear an ancient Chinese historian wish to visit a very distant country.
My guess about him 'having to strain to see the 3 heavenly bodies' was him saying he had bad eyes.
Too nerdy to travel the wilds of the ancient world, he stayed home and read books instead.
@@jimboblordofeskimos Actually, '3 heavenly bodies' is symbolic of sun moon and star in Chinese
@@jimboblordofeskimos The original is但劳眺乎三辰，而飞思乎八荒耳。
I can only look at 3 heavenly bodies （sun，moon&stars）from a distance，my thoughts fly to the eight foreign regions
It means that he can only afford to see only his horizon which is his local region. Anything further would require imagination as the distance is just too far
It's a long long way to Ba Sing Se, but the girls in the city all look so pretty
When he says that the Romans "originated in China, but left it" I think he is referrencing the Roman founding myth that they descended from Trojans who fled Asia-minor and settled Italy after the Trojan war. The Chinese seem to have only heard "Asia" and assumed that Troy was in Chinese territory. This would explain why they call the Romans "Da Qin" meaning "great China".
the warner channel That is the most adorable case of national ego I have ever seen
the warner channel I think he was referring to the Chinese historian not you
@@thewarnerchannel7285 yeah I was totally referring to the Chinese
I really doubt the Chinese knew they were living in "Asia". Asia was really Turkey in that time.
The name “Asia” actually once referred to just Anatolia, and was a name used by the Greeks that might have come from Akkadian. After a long time, the name’s meaning became morphed so that “Asia” referred not just to the Anatolian Peninsula, but to the greater landmass beyond as well (what we now know as the continent of Asia). Because of this, Greeks near the end of the classical age started using the name “Mikrà Asía” (Lesser Asia, or as we now know it, Asia Minor) to refer to the peninsula.
Basically, this might be a possibility based on my own flawed and incomplete knowledge. It just matters when “Asia” started meaning more than just Anatolia, and when the Chinese first heard the myth of the Trojans and Aeneas.
I like how he describes the governors of provinces as smaller kings and how the consuls are kings too
Small correction not important at all. I think he named the councils "generals".
Rome had several client kingdoms, he could be talking about those.
Realize that meanings are lost in translation, especially when considering historical political contexts crossing territories and cultures. 'King' should be seen as more so a generic title for any ruler/politician (sovereign or not), rather than our modern understanding of hereditary monarchs.
Well it's a cultural difference, in China Emperor > Kings > Princes > Lords > Nobles > peasants, so the kings he refers to are basically princes.
You're dead, bro.
Yu Huan to the Romans:
*Ah i see, you're a man of another culture as well*
Teringventje (Check yourself before you wreck yourself)
On a Rainy Night, Lines to be Sent Forth:
“You ask me when I return, but I know not when.
The pools here at Pa Shan overflow with rain.
When will we trim candles by the western window
and the rain of this evening be in our words?”
-Li Shangyin (9th century)
upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/26/Nestorian_stele_1.jpg
It's funny how they didn't have a term for elected leader and referred to senators as generals
makes sense considering that's the closest comparison the chinese would have had. The republic system must have seemed totally alien to them.
@@samcavanagh7993 yeah I understand it, it's just a funny insight
To this day, they havent found out what an elected leader means XD
@@lokeshn8850 fuck, what a burn lmao
@@lokeshn8850 oooooo snap jsksjskakskajsa underrated comment.
I love how he sounds like he's just brainstorming out everything he's ever read or heard about "Da Qin," with hardly any organization.
So gay, you're SO gay.
@ so stupid, you're SO stupid
Jonathan Lake Lovelace Here's another description of Rome from our history book:
"其人民皆长大平正，有类中国，故谓之大秦。--《后汉书·西域传》"
When our ancestors were doing business in this place, they were surprised to find that the local people were tall, strong and polite, and they were very similar to themselves. Naturally, the feeling of kinship emerged in their hearts. So they called it Da Qin.😀
Marco Polo did the exact same thing
@@albertweber1617 *plus lots of lying about having gone their himself and straight cut and pasting from popular fiction of the time.
"there's a big sea, then there's a river, then west of that another sea, then a river, the some mountains, then, like, some more rivers and seas and that, and then west of that there's a sea and a river" capiche?
I took a wrong turn and now in madagascar........fuck
Got it. Meet you by the fourth tree from the little waterfall in let's say 173 days?
@@CapyMartinBara yeah, you're not the first. You must have missed the third "river by a sea" part!
@@Biomirth 👌will be there
@61gisele did you get the bit about the river, mountains, the sea, the river and the mountains? Your grammar nazi ways won't help you on this journey!
For you information, the original text was part of a historic book written by a government official (not by the government tho). This book is mainly about recording the history of a period called Wei, which was really common in ancient China because each time a dynasty collapsed, the new government would write a historic book to record everything happened on the previous dynasty. These historic books are official, and they have almost the exact same structure.
The contents about Roman Empire are included in a chapter that is solely for introducing foreign states (西戎传, "the chapter of western foreigners"), which is routine for every official historic book. Although this book is not an official book, it follows the same structure of contents.
This is the reason why the author wrote down the information about the Roman Empire, but had never been to even anywhere outside of China --- this part was the contents that are not "important" according to the author's opinion but a "must" for completing this book. It's kind of like the introduction part of an essay, maybe 99% of its readers would not pay attention to it, you still need to write it down in an essay.
Thanks James.
@@VoicesofthePast 9:34 is that kingdom supposed to be Vietnam? Khmer aka Cambodia or Cham ?
@@VoicesofthePastDa Qin is not Rome!
@@VoicesofthePastDa Qin is not Rome you pr1ck!!
Sad ending. Gives a feeling how much he wanted to see places but simply didn't have the transport and age to see more
I can totally imagine the bandits going "Guys the Chinese traders are coming, release the lions" and then offering their "protection services"
Just some guys in a lion costume.
And the Chinese traders are wondering why there are no night watchers.
Sounds bit monty python
“Nahhh no way youll get past there. very dangerous it is. You’ll need to buy guides. And er.. weapons”
“Weapons? I thought there’s no bandits. I can see it from here”
“Right yeh. No bandits. But it looks closer than it is. And it’s real dangerous”
“How dangerous? What’s there?”
“Errr... lions”
“Lions?”
“Yeh lions. Big huge lions. Man eaters. Loads of em”
“I didn’t think there was lions around here”
“Loads of lions here mate. You’ll need guides. And weapons. Annndd.. more cloth. Lions hate cloth.”
“That’s just a man in a furry scarf and a fake nose”
“Nah that’s a lion. King of the animals. Tear you in two he will”
“Roar”
I feel a Lost monty python sketch here
@@paddyb3510 Well, it's Italy and the Balkans after all, we have traditions going back to roman times :D
"The sea water is bitter and unable to be drunk."
As opposed to WHAT other kind of sea water, chinese dude?
How clever you are....try that on your own.
@@jeremyripton .. try what? Drink salt water? What are you asking me
Water in Qing Hai? Qinghai means blue sea or green sea, a lake in Qinghai/Tibet
A lot of people would never have seen the sea if they didn't live near to it, so they would only really know that it's a huge amount of water, not that it's salty.
CadaverJunky Remember that by that time there was no idea that the world was connected or even that it was rounded. Most of the people living in the world by that time never traveled that far, and “knowing” that in another part of the world there was a sea of drinkable water was huge news.
Moreover, it’s the 3rd century. The mythology was rule.
This is actually quite sad in a way, he wanted so desperately to see things that for us are one or two plane journeys away.
@ and yet space beckons.
ULOIRAR or just a one to three word search
You still can't visit all the places in the world in one lifetime. You can read a bit about them or watch youtube but that's about it.
@@Windrake101 it's just not the same though...
@@andrewjennings7306 how so? Whole worlds to explore. None are humanity.
Millions of dead Romans all cried out in anguish at the term "king" haha
Sic semper tyrannis!
@@hannibalbarca9832 Latin is a dead language bro
BeggyBoss Yes and no
Not really, Romans hated the Senate they liked the Emperors, only the senate p@arasites wanted a Republic not the Roman people
@@frd8798 Still being spoken in France, Spain, Portugal, Italy, Romania, _Latin_ America, much of Africa, Catholic churches worldwide, and plenty more. Very heavily altered versions, yes, but are they not still Romance?
I love how the author is trying to emphasize the similarities with China like post stations and roads. Funny how he mentions tigers and lions, although lions were native to Greece until the 5# century so he's not completely wrong. He's also correct about the nature of the emperor's title and how could it be obtained. Pretty interesting.
Its because they were curious as Middle Eastern traders portrayed Rome as the equals to China. Ancient China saw itself as having no equals, so of course when their told they have an equal at the opposite ends of the world, their interested.
@Sander Skovly
I don't know, but it's possible.
@@stanleysmith7551 Remember that for him, Egypt and the Middle East are part of Rome and that is where most of his info probably came from.
The lions in the Roman coliseums were the European lion, now extinct because of man.
Asiatic Lions stalked caravans on the frontiers of Syria and Caspian Tigers killed pack animals in Iranian caravans.
Your reading of this was absolutely superb. Edited to add: It was a performance, not merely a "reading".
poetic to me.... enjoyable to listen to
Felt like the traveler was talking to me
Its so cool hearing an account of Rome from such an alien(to us) perspective. Where we usually learn from the perspective of someone who either lived in the Roman Empire or in its ruins, this is from a completely alien point of view where social customs and culture that are of interest to them are pointed out to us where as most Roman authors wouldn’t have listed things such as juggling at carnivals and types of jade as important.
Heh. The account by Yu Huan in the Weilue also put a lot of focus on various types of cloths apparently. The Romans did that on occasion and even spoke frequently about silk, but the Chinese were obsessed with that sort of thing when talking about the inventories of other known civilizations. It also shows their mercantile priorities and the list of items also demonstrates that the Romans were culturally refined like his fellow Han Chinese.
I agree, It always sounds so magical so mysterious the discretions of ancient Chinese or Japanese or even the accounts of interactions between the Europeans and native Americans. It's almost like reading a fantasy novel. It's almost nostalgic, imaging the world before we completed the maps, back when there still were things to discover.
During the second century, the Chinese court received Syrian/Roman jugglers as a diplomatic gift from one of the Indian Realms (the Saka Kingdom). There was high international demand for exotic performers in the Ancient World. The Chinese saw Roman conjurors before they met Roman envoys...
I totally agree. I had a similar thought
Dr Raoul McLaughlin Oh shit. Never thought I’d see you here dude, love antiquity videos man.
"When unusual disasters strike, they unceremoniously replace him"
Well he's not entirely wrong
The last part gave me goosebumps when the author speaks about how the world is big
Yes, in ancient times with the lack of techonology the world used to be "bigger"
@@monsterclown4455 barbossa to sparrow : the world is getting smaller (talking about how the world is nearly fully mapped and the rise of beckett) and how the age of piracy is ending.
Monster Clown mis-claimer we where actually smarter then.
@@trureef2319 Individualy that may be so but communally we have much much more information now than ever before.
magma2680 there are pyramids on every continent there was supposedly a ancient cell phone and computer found u don’t think we all had contact at one point rather it be spiritual or physical we communicated just as we as today. It’s a reason Rome history has what they call the dark ages.
Europeans: this place is called...
China: No no no, that won't do at all, it's called...
Europeans again, several centuries later: THIS PLACE IS CALLED...
Rome: actually our name is Ro-
China: *You Da Qin now!!!*
@@sabotabby3372 true!
Well you have to consider that he probably never heard a roman say what the land is actually called and only heard it from traders so it was translated over and over leading to what the Chinese called it.
@@maxitouring hmmm, yes, probiably, that does make sense.
The post office sure is a long lived institution
Still waiting on my colored glass delivery from 300 AD, they say it's in Parthia now
@@grantkeller4634 sorry it is all rome, for the glory of the brutii
I thought the post office was started by the Templar's. Maybe I'm wrong 🤔
@@fiachradillon It's generally accepted by experts, that postman Pat was the originator of the postal service. The Knights Templar are generally associated with creating the modern banking system
In a way, the difference between an advanced civilization and 'other' civilizations is the existence of a reliable means of communication; One that is protected, well managed, consistent, and well respected. Think of the Gauls and other societies on the outskirts of SPQR: They had to meet in person to get anything done, or rely upon trusted couriers who were unpredictable. I love the idea of such pre-industrial societies being so outrageously ambitious with their post. It inspires one to write more letters!
Quite touching to hear the earnest thoughts of the historian as he tried to record his knowledge as much as possible, knowing that some day in the future, other people may read his words.
That part at the end was heartbreaking. To spend your life learning about places you know you'll never be able to see. Makes me wish I could bring him forward in time, he could be in Da Qin in a day.
The vast majority of people today can't just hop on a plane and travel and the vast majority will never leave their own countries. That last part wasn't sad, the author himself said he loved thinking about these other places. He was being pragmatic, much like someone today might admit they'll never meet their favourite singer but they'll read about them online and follow their tweets. That guy was as passionate about places he's never seen as historians are about times they've never lived in or A Song of Ice and Fire fans were before realising the last books will probably never be written - now that's a real tragedy.
Bring him to a anime convention.
It still applies to modern day humans, but now, our version of far off lands are other planets and solar systems.
Ioso Sop
Put the pea as a example of the sun, now put us to scale.
The furthest we’ve ever traveled is 1.3cm off of earth, the nearest star is Kilometers away and 2 hour drive, our deepest space probe is 10ft away.
Take 3 steps, 4 steps, now for the last step and you’ve overshot and passed the probe.
We’re still on the moon task list, just peeking out at mars and deciding which is the best option.
No. He could be in modern Iraly in a day . He wouldn't be able to see ancient Rome any better now than during his lifetime.
"we don't know much about them" CLOTH TIME
I think he was examining the competition to Chinese silk in this type of the world, I think a lot of his long lists are regarding economy related products.
need me some asbestos cloth
@@Birdman369 Also, sources of knowledge being traders probably means that it's was very popular topic among certain people.
大秦( Da Qin) means Great Qin. The ancient Chinese thought Roman Empire as another huge nation founded by the people from its previous Qin Dynasty. Unlike Anxi which was translated from Arsi ( official name of Parthia ) , people in 3rd century AD China didn't even know the name of "Roma". All their knowledge about Rome was acquired from Parthia or Sassanid Persia and that is why the later East Roman Empire ( or Byzantium Empire ) was called 拂霖( Fu Lin) which is derived from Persian " Vrum" .
I am from Parthia - we are still call ourselves total Arses.
arseman arse: it’s necessary for riding.
@Konstantinos Palaiologos No - it is good the west was not exposed to the slanted Chinese civilisation - they can keep the one stringed cello, chopsticks and worthless artworks.
@N5ZZ0 But what about Principled Catholic Doctrine like the Papal Bull "Cum nimis absurdum" issued by Pope Paul IV in 1555 to ensure all jews in Rome were walled up in the Roman Ghetto? It takes its name from the Bull’s first words: "Since it is absurd and utterly inconvenient that the Jews, who through their own fault were condemned by God to eternal slavery..."
Under the Papal Bull, Jewish males were required to wear a pointed yellow hat, and Jewish females a yellow kerchief and their livelihood limited to dealing in second hand clothes and walled up in a ghetto overnight - up until 1870 when the Italian risorgimento abolished Papal rule in Italy. (The creation of Vatican City and a yearly massive cash donative was later agreed upon by Mussolini and Pius XI in 1929)
Mmmm ... sounds familiar ....reminds me of the actions of a certain Austrian Catholic ruler in the 1930s and 40s who resurrected the 3rd Holy Roman Empire, 10,000 of whose followers managed to get to Argentina a bit later with the help of the Vatican..... errr....where the Pope is from….errrr….which is obviously a total coincidence.
Nothing to see here.
Let’s move on.
Ehrrmmmm…..as I was saying - let us continue to adore the One Holy Apostolic Church - that made Bolivia, Peru, El Salvador, Nicaragua, Honduras, Guatemala and Paraguay into those ‘shining cities on a hill’ and inspired the youthful morality of Rodrigo Borgia, Dr. Joe Mengele, Hugo Chavez, Carlos The Jackal,, Heinrich Himmler, Mel Gibson, Adolf Hitler and Che Guevara.
Bravo !! Well done Rome !!
Of course, having said that, I must say that my favorite Dear Leader is Chairman Mao. He Purged 70 million thought-criminals from China, more than any other Dear Leader anywhere else - also Pol Pot because he liquidated 1/3 of his beloved nation Kampuchea. Bravo again !!
arseman arse you need to leave those drugs alone.
"Anshi", I always wondered how that name came about. But then I remembered that Parthia was only called "Parthia" by the Romans; to foreigners, they were "Arsaces", the Arsacid Empire, a term that can explain the Chinese name by contraction: Arsaces becomes Arsci, becomes Anshi.
安息
Chinese Pronunciation in Han Dynasty:
* ˤa[r/n] sək
which is an almost exact replica of "Aršaka/Arsaces"
0:23 this is how primitive GPS sounded like 'Continue straight, you will reach your destination perhaps in one year.'
"Perhaps in three, if there's no wind."
This sounds like someone's worldbuilding project.
XD
Sounds like George RR Martin describing Sothoryos or the Yi Ti.
Lol with terrible directions.
You will fucking reach the ROMAN empire... never
It's the other way around, worldbuilding is an exercise in trying to replicate history :)
( Game of Thrones Intensifies )
I really like his disclaimer at the end. Wisdom is knowing you don’t know everything
Can we just take a moment to appreciate the massive works translators and historians have gone through in modern time to figure out which countries/cities these ancient scrolls refer to? Amazing.
“Long live your ki...”
“ *WE DON’T DO THAT HERE* “
Both these comments are underrated. 🤣
But that's literally what "Ave Caesar" means.
@Lord Farquaad Doesn't necessarily mean "Long Live" Just means "be well". Like, good health to caesar. It's also just a generic polite greeting. Its direct English equivalent is "hail" as in hail mary or hail traveller.
@Lord Farquaad I know, that literally means the same... They are wishing long live to their "king". They were not kings, of course, but to that Chinese man there was no difference.
@@xmaverickhunterkx Caesar is Gaius Julius Caesar's cognomen. The Caesares were a branch of the Julia family. The Name became associated with the Caesar we know today, and after his successor, the emperor Augustus adopted it, with the idea of kingship and ruling
This is quite incredible to listen to. It doesn't sound like a man talking about another civilisation of other men; it sounds like a man talking about an alien civilisation from another planet haha. It must have been quite the thing to hear these accounts of far away places back when most people's worlds were so much smaller
Well, that's what the word "alien" primarily means right? even today in formal and legal documents.
10:30 its strange to look thru his perspective of not knowing what the world looks like
It's also interesting how merchants influenced historical writing. Since he got most of his information, and the information was mostly used for other merchants, much of what he tells is: How to get there, what they produce, is it in a state of peace and what is their political system.
What also amazes me about this scholar is his regret of not having the means nor the lifetime to visit the places told to him. It may be an "alien" place, but you can tell his desire to see and experience it firsthand. A true scholar indeed!
This is a blessing
No, it's just an inaccurate account from 1800 years ago.
@@TheFissionchips the fact that we have a chinese perspective on Rome, a civilization on the other side of the world is astonishibg and highly interesting. That is the blessing
Thanks pal!
This is so interesting. Makes you think about all those cultures about which we have only or mostly outside sources. How many misconceptions do we have because of that?
Nice bit of introspection from the author at the end. It would be easy to make fun of him writing about bamboo and tigers in Italy, but he was clearly trying to learn and describe as much as he could of the vast and mysterious world, realizing how greatly limited he was in this endeavor.
Edit: I meant to post this comment simply under the video, instead I somehow ended posting it as a response to Aron's. I guess it actually works too.
Couldn't agree more
Sailors on the Mediterranean ships: "Its my way or the Haibei!"
You deserve more likes.
😭😭😭
I translated the title for modern audiences:
*Roman Empire **_REVIEW_*
Riot Breaker the first part of the scroll has a painting of the historian himself with a shocked look on his face in the foreground, and in the background is a blurred painting of a naked lady
@@LawrenceReamon don't forget the giant red circle with an arrow pointing to an obvious Coliseum
Regular Empire Reviews
@@espvp Getting dysentery to unleash the BROWN!!!
Roman Empire Unboxing
As the author admits he is retelling from other sources, not an eyewitness, it is interesting how accurate the description is (and isn't). The way he describes the ruler's frequent replacement points toward republican Rome, though this was written 200 years into the imperial period. I also wonder if the Romans actually possessed silk worms.
@ExVeritaeLibertas There were periods of frequent changes in rule under the Empire, too. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crisis_of_the_Third_Century was close to the time this historian was writing about and had a *lot* of change in Emperor.
@@dato_4527 As you point out, *the* silkworm moth had to be smuggled out of China. This took place only as late as the 6th century. But there are other testimonies (already mentioned somewhere in this thread, too) to Romans using wild moths to get an inferior silk. That might have been what this historian heard about.
Oh, and it also needs to be stressed: yes, the Chinese guarded their sil secrets closely, but as usually happens with trade secrets, the secrets were leaked over time. There are very few companies that have guarded their trade secrets well enough to continue to profit. Intel and the Coca Cola Company come to mind as examples.
@@SpectatorAlius China guarding trade secrets....imagine that... long before they discovered forced technology transfer...
My theory is that that the middle easterners told the Chinese that the Romans had silk in order to drive the Chinese silk price down.
@@SpectatorAlius Those changes of rule weren't very peaceful though... or willing.
Love it, those Romans and their juggling!!
It is true, though, Hellenistic and Roman era Greeks in places like Syria were renowned for having talented jugglers, who often found themselves entertaining foreign royal courts and traveling to places as distant as Burma and, as we see here, China.
I'm imaging the senators surrounding Caesar and he's just juggling 10 balls at once
Jugglers.. and Firebreathers!
Someone obviously witnessed an entertaining troupe.
They're great with their balls
@@surperian4340 I imagine the juggling of 12 bowls at once refers to spinning plates on a stick like we see today still in some circus acts.
"They have appointed 36 leaders, or generals, who discuss evens frequently. If one leader does not show up, there's no discussion."
Sounds an awful lot like modern senates as well! Thanks, Romans.
Aren't modern senates based off the roman senates? S'why the "SPQR" exists. 'Senatum Populusque Romanum' meaning 'Senate and the Roman People'
Uhh, yeah... did you not know that most of the American political institutions were lifted from Rome and Greece? Democracy, republic, senate, various political terms like oligarchy, dictator, etc.
"We get it bro, they have cloth"
Brightly colored cloth and fine fabric was the mark of wealth, and the ultimate way of showing it in his time.
@@Littlegoatpaws Largely because dying was still quite the dark art at this time. Virtually all dyes were derived from plants (the purple derived from snails being a notable exception), and were not very colour fast, so you'd have to have coloured fabrics redyed when they faded, or continually buy more. It's not until the rise of industry, and chemistry (rather than alchemy) that you find mordants and true colour fast dyes, which is a good millenium in the future at the time of writing
They had asbestos cloth. 🤔
@@lordforlorn9766 That mankind has actually been using asbestos cloth that long is a surprise to me, actually. And yes, it's a real thing. Favored for it's fire proof qualities.
He was getting a lot of his info from merchants , it almost sounded like a catalogue of what was on offer.
And all without mentioning roads, gladiators, or the army.
@@big_slurp4603 the Roman army was hardly superior at this time?
@@SpectatorAlius my internal thoughts would be that he was referring to roadside inns
A couple reasons that I'd guess:
- he's getting his info from merchants and traders, who'd likely not interact with military beyond law enforcement
- he's not a military scout getting info for war, so this info is not very useful to what he's writing for
- probably wanted info that would be useful for trade, or cultural relations in case China wanted to send embassadors some day
@@NMahon The Roman army was definitely superior, although individual soldiers may not have been. This was written after the Marian Reforms and well into the Imperial period, when the army had transitioned into a true professional military. They were also probably the only army in the world that made regular use of field artillery at this time
@@NMahon Sounds like the late Republican period. Which means the Romans had a pretty good sized and well equipped army.
"They say they originally came from China, but left it"
I'm guessing this is a misinterpretation of the story of Aeneas, a Trojan who fled to Italia after the fall of Troy and who is the ancestor to Romulus.
Or early propaganda , or they said theh came from the east , and he wrote it as china , many possiblities
@@jomolololo4398There are indeed many possibilities. It could be propaganda as you say; the Romans had organized laws, a rich culture, and advanced technology such that the author might have felt unable to dismiss them as "barbarians", so perhaps claiming the Romans were Chinese was how he could justify their being so civilized by his standards.
Tarim Basin mummies
I mean he's not not not wrong 😂 look if Jesus could have a Chinese brother why not?
Ocelotl Chimalpahin the ancient world was probably a lot more connected than we believe it was
Firstly, I love this channel. I always loved ancient history. I love the maps in these in particular. They are very clear and easy to see. Thank you so much. I am 78 yrs of age.
Imagine spending 3 years on a boat
Without wi-fi
@@harunsuaidi7349 hell nahh
Read about the Franklin Expedition.
They were almost three years on a boat, two of which stuck in the ice whilst suffering from severe lead poisoning, scurvy and everyone died.
Berserk
It's how the Navy still operates
This is how my nephew gives instructions on how to reach his pre-school.
LOL
LOL
LOL
This is a fantastic comment. I laughed so hard.
In m nephew's day he had to cross three oceans to get to school!
"There are no bandits or thieves but there are fierce tigers and lions. If you are not in a group, you cannot get through." I see you've heard my grandpa's stories of how he used to go to school back in his day...
His descriptions postulate his intrigue. You can tell this man was a true traveler at heart.
Not fated to travel the rapid winds or ride swift horses to actually see for himself, but, filled with curiousity for the eight foreign regions. I know the feeling ancient Chinese brother! The wonderful curiosity!
Lucky we have NatGeo for that
Ja Ha lucky we have RUclips lol
Clearly had not anticipated the Lycoming TEO-540-A1A and experimental light aircraft combo.
Near the end, the author starts to sound like Bilbo Baggins
THAT is why I loved this.
Jane Eyre has a similar quality to it's writing too.
I love the adventure.
Tolkien was well read. I believe Bilbo more likely sounds like early travel history than the other way round.
@@Biomirth Sure
Biomirth No, this Chinese historian ripped off Tolkien
@@adamyooz Considering the Middle Kingdom is called that, I can see what you mean. I mean, seriously. Discount Middle Earth doesn't even have elves and dwarves!
He was definitely right about the “middle men” who handled trade between east and west being anxious to prevent contact outside of them (understandably, but probably unnecessarily so).
The part where he talks about lions and tigers attacking while traversing the trade routes was definitely made up by middlemen if you ask me. Those trade routes were heavily used and guarded by many powers and definitely were not that unsafe lol.
The magnificent buildings of Petra in the middle of the desert practically, were carved into the sandstone rock because of that monopoly.
@@kurtk7521 Not at all! Several poets mention lions preying on sheep. There used to be lions in Europe
@Brandon the Asiatic lion. There used to be a lot of those around central Asia, but now it's been hunted to near extinction.
@@kurtk7521 Could be , but lions and tigers could have co-existed in some places. We know there were lions from Middle East to Persia
So I've only seen two videos... and after 10+ years of browsing youtube, this is now my favorite channel.
Emperor to minister : Give me a report in the morning about this place out west I heard of.
@arnold jayeola Emperor to minister: take a boat, have a lot of paper and ink, go west, and good luck
The ancient world is actually more connected than you think. They are heavily dependent on barter trade in between nations. And should any trading nation were to block trade or at war, the whole trading network is disrupted
Yeah but you don't actually get to see it . You only know OF it which is where the mystery comes from
It was partially true. It was recorded in the time of Augustus that a virgin with a bag of gold around her neck could ride from (modern day) Naples to Rome on a horse along the Appian Way without being harassed by bandits.
They said the same thing about Genghis Khan's Mongol Empire
@61gisele * finger guns *
A very common myth about strong rulers. I believe the modern version is, "he made the trains run on time!"
@@ctrlaltdebug Mussolini making the trains run on time wasn't a myth.
@@stugrant01 actually it was mostly propaganda.The newspapers were told to run stories praising fascist efficiency. Sometimes the trains were still late, but that was never reported on.
Some kid should use this a reference for his essay on Rome. 'Julius Caesar was a 7 ft tall fire-breathing king who grew his own silkworms and used a spoon made out of rock.'
Unfortunately he was eaten by a tiger when he tried to travel alone.
@@micha2909 than after 9 months, he came out of the tigers body ripping it apart and grew into a 6 handed sky dragon
I feel bad for him. I wish he could have seen it all.
Agreed. He seems so enthusiastic and... Yearning. He'd appreciate it more than most, ever.
Harry he’d probably disagree with you. You just say that because you’re accustomed to your history and traditions, so the outside looks a lot more interesting in comparison. But look at the hellenic mythos, the legends and history of the Roman world. The twins Remus and Romulus, raised by a she-wolf, who came to found the greatest empire Europe has ever seen. The three god brothers born from a titan ruler of time, who competed between themselves for the dominion of the heavens, the seas and the underworld. The young ruler of Makedon, Alexander, permanently marked in history as the Great, who conquered the known world of the time in a little over a decade. The great Julius Caesar and his legendary triumphs and his equally legendary assassination. Look at Egypt and its mysterious pyramids and mythical pharaos.
Plenty of epicness and adventures to go around.
R B J ah, I see. I just assumed he meant “our world” to be the western world at the time, since the original comment mentioned that he felt bad that he couldn’t see Rome at the time.
@Harry It's not your fault friend, the grass always seems greener on the other side.
Bruh, feel bad for him? I WISH I COULD SEE IT ALL
I can't imagine how hard it was for this traveler to overcome the language barriers crossing almost 10 different cultures (just imagine languages and local dialects) in his way to Rome
I bet there was a lot of pointing involved, mixed with some seeming to be gibberish. Possible some sketching going on. Wouldve been a funny thing to see, but an awesome thing to be apart of
The time when China discovered the west was after Alexandra the great conquered Persia and Afghanistan, so I guessed maybe they only needed to find someone who knows Greek and that was fine all the way down to Greece
According to Wikipedia, the guy never actually left China, he compiled books of informations that were already known in China
basstard13 he says as much at the end
Back then this was usually solved with daisy-chained translators.
Thanks for watching! Don’t forget to subscribe for new videos every single week! & Let us know in the comments what you’d like to see covered in the future.
Can you read us about ibn Fadlan accounts about the people of scandinavia (vikings) and or the chinese.
the vikings account of north amarica would be cool.
@@theriddler2277 Already done Leif Erikson. Check out the Vikings playlist.
Great, thanks. Is there any speculation on why the Chinese names for the various cities/countries bear no resemblance to the local ones? I would have expected their name for Rome would sound at least somewhat similar.
I'm smelling a bit of bulshit on this video
"Ancient Chinese Historian Describes The Roman Empire" Oh cool I cant wait to hear the perspective on Ro-
"3rd century"
....
*ohno*
Derpass Twahtskie wait wasn’t that around the time it collapsed
@@QuigleTheGnome Pretty much the beginning of the end for the Roman Empire. It has its highs and some really fucking bad lows. But it was the beginning .
Derpass Twahtskie rip at least Eastern didn’t fall for another 1000 years
@@QuigleTheGnome The Roman Empire officially survived until the 1400s actually. But by then it was just a small city and not a massive empire. The 3rd century was actually an alright time though for the empire.
Default Profile Picture RIP
Yu Huan’s reflections at the end of his report were quite poetic.
Thank you for bringing his words to us through RUclips. (I wonder what he would have said about *that*)
He gets surprisingly profound at the end. It goes from amusing to a little sad.
He wanted to see it all, but understood that his capabilities were not enough and he would be unable to understand all that he saw.
actually quiet taoist i think，taoism's skeptical、self-effacing thoughts are vary important tradition of the culture
@The Jester - Fool Of Hearts He was talking about how big the world is, and how little they know about it. He recognizes that with limited knowledge, ability to travel and lifetime, there is no way he can explore all of the lands. But he still imagined what it would be like to be able to travel and see all of the lands.
My take on this:
"We don't give our ancient peers enough credit for the stuff they knew, the things they did and discovered, especially those ancient alien guys which think that the egyptians couldn't have build the pyraimds, or any other culture their own prestige projects."
I already knew that there used to be ancient trade routes that reached to china but we still tend to underestimate the achievements and mental acrobatics that were done during these times, well done to raise awareness.
@ 27 with a full awareness of how time is passing, I went to the techstore yesterday needed a new keybord, bought a usbstick, that's when I realized that time was passing faster then I had thought. Remember those times when 8GB was the gold standard? Or when 16 became the new 8? 32GB one upping that followed by almost immeasurably big 64GB? I found a 128Gb stick for 19,99€ and the department guy told me yeah and over there we have sd cards with 256GB and 512GB the first for about 60-80€ the later about 80-100€.
If you're talking about how I was aware, we have realy good documentaries in Germany, not this US weirdness they call that.
@Doomer The neet gloomer Well I wasn't there for the dark ages, but considering how you commented I'd say you miss the good times you had with the inquisition?
Depends on your world view. There are those of us that believe that humans are getting smaller, dumber and living shorter lives than we used to. The achievements of the past are litanous, coupled with the prevalence of polymaths like Da Vinci and others in times past, it's hard to argue against. I point to megaliths as evidence of advanced humans rather than space aliens.
@@CaliforniaCarpenter7 Well remember, we only really see the huge successes of the past. It's due to survivor bias. Like a good example is all the classical music. Most of the classic music we know of is only a few select composers and even then we only really care about a very few of their dozens of composures.
@Douglas Williams That's true, but I'd like to see a modern equivalent of Chopin. Better yet, maybe a modern equivalent of Liszt seeing as the two were alive at the same time. Liszt could sight read Chopin's best work. Chopin wrote Etudes and Nocturnes that will survive forever.
I'm large enough that I've been able to keep my wisdom teeth, most people aren't. Seems to me that there was a time when we all could. Especially going along with the conventional narrative that 10,000 years ago we dwelled in caves without any kind of dentistry.
Either way, I stick with my view. We weren't capable of lifting Baalbek sized stones until very recently, we still couldn't fathom actually transporting them anywhere. "Ancient, primitive ShrewPanzees" managed the feat with regularity, and this says nothing about the precision with which they were assembled.
Apologies for rambling.
I am a Chinese, I am very happy that this RUclipsr can show the obscure and forgotten records of ancient Chinese history, I am very happy, thank you🙏
Just to clarify the "Chinese think Roman were also Chinese" part, which is mentioned by many comments and could bring some discomfort.
I don't think that's true, the narrator's source might have some minor translation error. I looked into Chinese history book and the record is "The Da Qin people were tall, big, kind, dignified, just like us."
Maybe the ancient Chinese back then seldomly see nourished, civilized foreigners, which must amazed them.
Here's the original script :"其王无有常人(King changed all the time)，皆简立贤者 (chose the wise ones)。国中灾异及风雨不时，辄废而更立，受放者甘黜不怨 (climate omens can dispose kings, and the banished ones donot complain)。其人民皆长大平正，有类中国，故谓之大秦 (these people look tall, big, kind, dignified, just like us Chinese, so we name them Da Qin)。"
This.
thx for clearing that up
I sat here and rewinded several times trying to understand why he would say that. My guess was he was envious of Rome so he wanted to "claim" them. Or partly take credit for their achievements. But what you said is much more practical.
@@VirtualVictoryTM I've searched some modern historian explanations, which indicated basicly the middle Asia nomad people thought China and Rome were the same thing: big, strong empires. So it could be them telling the Chinese this. Hence the misunderstanding.
I can assure you ancient Chinese wouldn't be "envious" of any other nations, 100%. It's just not our way of thinking.
@@zeflute4586 Chinese aren't envious? What was the whole war over the "holy horses" in Bactria about if not envy?
"Tortoise shells, black bears, dragons blood, and MONGOOSES."
He misheard More gooses and there you go.
But then again the myth how Rome was saved by mongooses would be also interesting to read.
We just going to ignore he said DRAGONS BLOOD! Like a dragon a mythical beast that commonly breaths fire. Mythical... a myth and these guys got is blood. Eh tell me how?
I think it refers to a particular resin (tree sap) that was used as a pigment, medicine (tummy aches, and respiratory problems).
You have clearly versalized the wrong word here...
@@Kakuretaka Dragon's blood is a red resin extracted from the dragon tree (Dracaena draco), which grows wild in Morocco and the Canaries. It is now used as a precious varnish for things like violins, but I think it was also attributed medicinal properties.
the little fish doesn't know the size of the yangtze..
You have eyes but fail to recognize Mt Vesuvius.