Doug or Dud? (A Nostalgia Critic Thumbnail Game Show) - PlatinumYoshi

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 дек 2024

Комментарии • 49

  • @DrMario3077
    @DrMario3077 4 года назад +15

    PlatinumYoshi remembers Doug's thumbnails so you don't have to.

  • @YggdrasilAudio
    @YggdrasilAudio 3 года назад +4

    I hate how people are now turning around on Doug because they learnt he "can take criticism", forgetting that he has actively and passively done some pretty serious harm to people he had worked with. And he isn't even that good at taking criticism. All people points to is him laughing at some of the more mild Oney Plays-imitations and that interview when he talks about the Wall backlash, where he misrepresents it so that all his critics look bad. I don't think Doug is unintelligent, but he never takes his own advice

  • @karastears
    @karastears 4 года назад +8

    His Sailor Moon video was the breaking point, where I stop watching him.

    • @PlatinumYoshi
      @PlatinumYoshi  4 года назад +3

      My breaking point should've been his Hocus Pocus video, that one was so shit.

    • @starshinestudiosofficial
      @starshinestudiosofficial 3 года назад +2

      My breaking point was the #ChangeTheChannel controversy

    • @YggdrasilAudio
      @YggdrasilAudio 3 года назад

      @@starshinestudiosofficial Me too. Learning that he put people in danger time and time again made me loose all sympathy for him. Though at that point all I was watching from him was Disneycember.

    • @nicostud916
      @nicostud916 3 года назад

      My breaking point were his "reviews" on the Jurassic Park franchise, especially his Jurassic World review, a review in which was responsible for all the clipless review bullshit.

  • @qavix6089
    @qavix6089 4 года назад +7

    This is some creative content here

  • @OfficialHield
    @OfficialHield 4 года назад +3

    Keep up the great work and don't stop what you're doing!

  • @daelen.cclark
    @daelen.cclark Год назад

    I wonder who designs these thumbnails?
    What happened to you is exactly what happened to me. Even at 13, I knew I’d grow out of it. Thirteen!

  • @elpipeishere3850
    @elpipeishere3850 4 года назад +2

    Congrats for the 1k subs!!!! Is there any especial coming soon?

    • @PlatinumYoshi
      @PlatinumYoshi  4 года назад

      Thank you! I'm still thinking of what to do for a 1k sub special so I'm not 100% sure when it'll come out

    • @elpipeishere3850
      @elpipeishere3850 4 года назад

      @@PlatinumYoshi you could do something like doug or dud, but with your videos, idk if it's a good idea

    • @PlatinumYoshi
      @PlatinumYoshi  4 года назад

      @@elpipeishere3850 Maybe, but I feel like doing something other than a game show

    • @elpipeishere3850
      @elpipeishere3850 4 года назад

      @@PlatinumYoshino problem dude, it's your channel

  • @SuperMarioBrosChnl
    @SuperMarioBrosChnl 4 года назад +5

    Look Gary, there I am!

  • @atistaldi7140
    @atistaldi7140 4 года назад +1

    Once again an amazing video, keep up the good work brother!

  • @Jeman155
    @Jeman155 4 года назад +2

    I'm gonna have nightmares for weeks, thx a lot man

  • @elpipeishere3850
    @elpipeishere3850 4 года назад +3

    There was a time, like a year ago, i found small youtuber, he did not have even 1k subs, but he continued anyways, i watch him grow, reach 10k subs, and now he is going for 20k, and your tipe of content make me wish the same luck for you

  • @ScorePN
    @ScorePN 3 года назад +2

    How bout a part 2? This DID turn out to be a challenge! I got like 4 wrong 🤣

    • @PlatinumYoshi
      @PlatinumYoshi  3 года назад +1

      I've been thinking about doing a Part 2 to this lol. Maybe in the near future, I might.

    • @Gameoyeah
      @Gameoyeah 3 года назад

      @@PlatinumYoshi hey can i be in it 😳

    • @PlatinumYoshi
      @PlatinumYoshi  3 года назад +1

      Maybe 😳

  • @YggdrasilAudio
    @YggdrasilAudio 3 года назад +2

    I'm ashamed to say that I watched the "Family Guy for Kids"-video, but it's actually pretty allright. It's not about Family Guy, but instead discusses a failed pilot McFarlane did for a kids show, that featured characters very similar to Peter and Brian.

  • @holdingpattern245
    @holdingpattern245 2 года назад

    I got 8/10. It wasn't really difficult for the most part because most of the fakes had blatantly incorrect elements, such as having way too much negative space (Doug fears negative space), or not making a huge effort to fit in with the original image (for example in the Mean Girls one, the real Doug wouldn't have made himself less bright than the other characters in the image; and in the H20 one, the real Doug would have darkened the left half of his face instead of the right).

  • @SploderianRich
    @SploderianRich 2 года назад +1

    We need Part 2

  • @riasg-b9w
    @riasg-b9w 2 года назад +1

    I got a perfect score on this I have brought dishonor to my family

  • @chackbro1
    @chackbro1 2 года назад +3

    I played this with my fiancé. We tied with 4 each. It was fun for both of us and we talked a lot about this content creator that fell off

  • @d-manthecaptain1382
    @d-manthecaptain1382 4 года назад +4

    I decided to play along, my man.
    My answers:
    Real. (Right. I knew the first was real not because I remembered the thumbnail itself, just because I recognized the video's title.)
    Real. (Right.)
    I was unsure about the thumbnail itself, however I certainly remembered the review, so Real. (Wrong.)
    Real, seems that's all I am capable of saying, eh? (Right.)
    Real, I remember it. (Right.)
    Real, I remember a lot of these, maybe I should've stopped watching his schlock sooner. (Right.)
    Fake, such a rusty crop job on that head. (Right.)
    Fake. (Right.)
    ???, fake I suppose. (Right.)
    Fake. (Right.)
    9 Points, I'm pretty cool.

    • @PlatinumYoshi
      @PlatinumYoshi  4 года назад

      Wow, almost a perfect score. Good job!

    • @YggdrasilAudio
      @YggdrasilAudio 3 года назад +1

      Not even joking, I got the exact same result. For the exact same reasons.

    • @d-manthecaptain1382
      @d-manthecaptain1382 3 года назад

      @@YggdrasilAudio Nice.

  • @crystalclearstar889
    @crystalclearstar889 3 года назад +4

    this is better than that quiz show doug made, this has more production value than doug's tbh

  • @EnnEmmEee
    @EnnEmmEee Год назад +1

    I got all of these right…
    Doug is a drug and I’m addicted.

  • @SploderianRich
    @SploderianRich 4 года назад +2

    That was a journey

    • @LupinticDream
      @LupinticDream 2 года назад

      Guess you could say it was... a nostalgia trip.

  • @RenaNeraLuv
    @RenaNeraLuv 4 года назад +1

    "Fuck you Rena" Seth, I literally don't know what I did-

  • @SuperTiaanBro
    @SuperTiaanBro 4 года назад +1

    You should do more of these

  • @BillyBob125
    @BillyBob125 3 года назад +1

    Now I'm tempted to do a game like this with my friends...
    Alright, here are my answers and score.
    1. My answer: Real. Correct answer: Real
    2. My answer: Real. Correct answer: Real
    3. My answer: Fake. Correct answer: Fake
    4. My answer: Fake. Correct answer: Real
    5. My answer: Real. Correct answer: Real
    6. My answer: Real. Correct answer: Real
    7. My answer: Fake. Correct answer: Fake
    8. My answer: Fake. Correct answer: Fake
    9. My answer: Real. Correct answer: Fake
    10. My answer: Fake. Correct answer: Fake
    Final score: 8
    Wow. I know his thumbnail style and videos better than I thought, I was able to tell the validity of some thumbnails by the quality of some Doug Walker photos used in the thumbnails and what Nostalgia Critic videos I have watched though...

  • @hippieskye8794
    @hippieskye8794 4 года назад +2

    Wowza

  • @vail6087
    @vail6087 4 года назад +5

    It's better than Ellen's game show

  • @ThatOneLebaneseGuy
    @ThatOneLebaneseGuy 4 года назад +2

    Damn, i wished i would of joined during the game but that’s ok.

  • @andyknapp
    @andyknapp 4 года назад +2

    I got too many of these right...

  • @RivasMakesStuffForYou
    @RivasMakesStuffForYou 4 года назад +2

    who's doug

  • @cartoonosaurus
    @cartoonosaurus 4 года назад +2

    I got 5 points

  • @RenegadeAngel
    @RenegadeAngel 2 года назад +1

    Used to watch a lot of Nostalgia Critic years ago, but they became rather predictable and probably grew out of them too. Did not remember them being that terrible, but yikes. His videos used to get millions of views and it is a complete mystery why he does not outsource thumbnails to somebody that can make engaging thumbnails. It does not make much sense to do thumbnails if you increase your views by 10% and get from 1000 to 1100 views. If improved thumbnails could increase the clickthrough rate of a regular Nostalgia Critic review video with 2 million views then that would mean 200 000 monetized views. We are talking about lost revenue in at least 4 digits. Your thumbnails tend to be better than his. Perhaps you should recommend him to hire you...hehe😁

  • @janko1
    @janko1 3 года назад

    I got 7