@TwxceGlxw Why are you so defensive and naive... of course there are differences between their singing techniques/skills. It just happens that Wheein does have the healthiest SINGING TECHNIQUE, and that does not necessarily mean the other members' techniques are bad, it's just hers is somewhat better. Mamamoo members are all great singers, but it just happens that Wheein has the healthiest singing technique. And by saying this, it doesn't make me (or anyone that shares the same opinion) a hater or rude... If by saying one's singing technique is better than other's is rude, boi, how are you even gonna survive society.
@@moonlightsomnia yes, there shouldn't be any fanchants during yhy sketchbook, but in this case prob there are some new moos in the audience who don't know the rules & decided to do the chants per usual
@@alainachanel08 honestly not to drag twice into this but ive seen them lacking in their new performances..and mamamoo wins in a lot of categories vs twice(not a hater just saying) and hwasas stage presence can honestly sustain a whole ass group
Damn this song is hard to sing, I was expecting at least one shaky breath, BUT DAMN WHEEIN AND SOLAR PROVED ME WRONG (Edit) ty for the likes I appreciate it! (Edit) sorry I didn’t know that it wasn’t in falsetto
sorry but when do you hear falsetto in this song? (I love Mamamoo and I’m not doubting them - I’m just curious because I wouldn’t use that term for anything in this song, it’s mostly in comfortable chest voice range, only that bit in the prechorus goes higher)
@@fsjukebox the click me click me part is falsetto. Also the "hae" in hihihihip hae hip part. The song isn't "mostly" falsetto but it still has some falsetto parts.
jumping, turning and difficult choreo doesn't excuse for unstable and bad vocals 💀 Britney spears, Freddie Mercury, Michael Jackson got stable voices.. (didn't mean to get mad or smth but s. korea needs to stop debuting rookie idols just for their looks if they wanna go worldwide ngl)
This is one of the reasons why Mamamoo is my favourite K-pop female group. It's because they can actually sing & harmonize live. Pretty much what makes one a singer/vocalist.
@@Flopped69 no I got what she meant, I found some FAKE mr removed videos of Queendom from a spesific channel. I think they want to protect their idol or something. But they made a fake one for Mamamoo too. In fact, they just took the original audio from mv and add lots of noises
@@nadie-qm8rq not this one of course.... This one is legit hahaha. Unfortunately I forget the channel name 🤦 It made so many Queendom participants's fake mr removed if you curious.
@@Flopped69 Apart from this perf and for the last few weeks, they've stopped using the 5.1 channel system, therefore clean extraction on the center channel (the channel in 5.1 where live vocals are on sketchbook) isn't possible and other extreme methods usually used for music shows (music bank, show champ, music core etc etc) and all that is being used :/ its still live though
moonbyul: the one that is beautiful and stable wheein : the one that is beautiful and stable hwasa: the one that is beautiful and stable solar: the one that is beautiful and stable
@@james-yj5xp Dance around and make a countious sound like a flute and now make the same experiment while talking and then tell which one sounded more breathy. Singinging and rapping are still two enities you can't compare. So yea moonbyul was still stable dispite rapping.thnky you for my ted talk.
yeah, they killed it, mamamoo don't need mr removed hahaha Although I believe that hand microphones favor them more, their voices are heard clearer, the headbands are uncomfortable and in most idol shows their voices are not heard🤔🤔
When it comes to mamamoo, I wonder why I still even bother to check the mr removed vids. Of course, they'll do great. But, maybe, I'm just addicted on how amazing their live performances are.
I thought it will be shaky breathing but is not that bad ( khatu ) and the rap ( moonbyul ) Was the best for my opinion All did good like a hard dance while singing is just amazing 😉
In the other mr remove, they're a little bit shaky. They already built their stamina here.😊 Beside from praising mamamoo's talent and hardwork, i also want to praise the one who made this clean mr remove
if the mere FOUR of them can sing this well live, i will never understand how groups with upwards of 5 members cant sing well live. i understand having difficulty when youre the only onstage, but when you have so many people to share lines with, the burden mustve been made significantly lighter...
Y’all need to stop criticizing them. I know that I’m gonna get hate for this but at lest they aren’t lazy and they all do the dance to their fullest and they try to sing the best they can while dancing and the can actually sing live unlike some groups
It is true that the REAL BEST KPOP G-GROUP for me is formed in 4 members only 😊❤ and I only know 3 G-Girl Group in my entire life and that is: -MAMAMO -BLACKPINK -2NE1 3 Groups with 4 members that is truly talented. We can't deny it and they really deserve to shine and be appreciated more.
jj p all three of these groups were and are very popular. How can Blackpink be appreciated more if they are literally the most popular Kpop girl group?
@@oya3163 well it's just for me hahaha I'm just sayin and highlighted the fact that the true best of best GG is formed in 4 members not 6 nor 7 ect. Hahaha don't hate me. I just love the 3 groups I'm just being a fan tho.😊
![[MR Removed | 엠알제거] 190315 MAMAMOO (마마무) - gogobebe (고고베베) MR제거](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yDNcp2ffvHg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MR Removed | 엠알제거] 190315 MAMAMOO (마마무) - gogobebe (고고베베) MR제거](/img/tr.png)
![[MV] MAMAMOO (마마무) - HIP](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KhTeiaCezwM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MR Removedㅣ엠알 제거] BLACKPINK (블랙핑크) - Pink Venom (핑크 베놈) MR제거 220827](/img/1.gif)
Follow me on::
Twitter: twitter.com/nako__mi
Instagram: instagram.com/nako__mi
Thanks!✨
Please stop praising mamamoo because I'm so tired to pressed a like button
Hahaha damnn xD
Hahaha facts
🤧i will never be tired
SAAAAAME
Mood
Wheein always got the most difficult lines (not highnotes)
Sometimes the difficult parts are not the high notes but the ones with an especific dance move or that need extra stability
Lol Solar and Wheein both have the same lines. Wheein just use harder technique than Solar
Solar has it hard too, because she has to be extra stable, especially in that first line.
They can all slay, they are queens
@@MDNgueyn how is it different? 🤔
이번 노래는 춤도 어렵고, 다른 아이돌들에 비해 멤버 수가 적으니까 더 힘들텐데.. 맘부심 생긴다 증말
ㅇㅈ이요 오늘부로 무무입니당
웰컴
@@ziyeop 어캐 아셨죠
춤이 쉬워서 라이브 잘하는거라 했던 놈들 누구냐
님엄마일수도있음
@@천재비제이 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 갑자기 시비 터는거 존나 웃기네 ㅋㅋ
리아킴이랑 상담해야 하는놈들
@@천재비제이 그분은 고마운 분이시네 마마무 실력 재평가도 해주시고
@@천재비제이 왜 시비 터누 ㅋㅎㅋㅎㅋㅎ mr제거 보러 왔으면 걍 곱게 쳐봐 ㅋㅎㅋㅎㅎㅋㅋ
Weein's range was insane and she was so stable!
Tommy Nguyen, Wheein Mix is the most healthiest among the rest ✌🏻
TwxceGlxw lmao you don’t gotta day “wtf wrong w you”
@TwxceGlxw i think they meant that she has the healthiest singing technique, i don't think that's rude
@TwxceGlxw they definitely do (although i'm not one to say since i don't understand singing), just that i don't think the comment was rude
@TwxceGlxw Why are you so defensive and naive... of course there are differences between their singing techniques/skills. It just happens that Wheein does have the healthiest SINGING TECHNIQUE, and that does not necessarily mean the other members' techniques are bad, it's just hers is somewhat better. Mamamoo members are all great singers, but it just happens that Wheein has the healthiest singing technique. And by saying this, it doesn't make me (or anyone that shares the same opinion) a hater or rude... If by saying one's singing technique is better than other's is rude, boi, how are you even gonna survive society.
the mr removed cant even get rid of moomoos fanchants bc we’re so loud hsmdnsndnsns
MR Removeds don't get rid of fanchants, they only clear out the background music.
And this is yu huiyeol's sketchbook, there are no fans chanting or cheering lol
@@moonlightsomnia yes, there shouldn't be any fanchants during yhy sketchbook, but in this case prob there are some new moos in the audience who don't know the rules & decided to do the chants per usual
I think we all know just how stable they are. And agree that their vocal and now their dancing is their strong suits.
As well as rapping!! Idk why people always forget to mention it.
The best part would be their stage presence. Not a lot of girl groups that can get close to their level.
,@@alainachanel08 I don't agree
@@alainachanel08 I guess you've probably just seen more girl groups than me.
@@alainachanel08 honestly not to drag twice into this but ive seen them lacking in their new performances..and mamamoo wins in a lot of categories vs twice(not a hater just saying) and hwasas stage presence can honestly sustain a whole ass group
Damn this song is hard to sing, I was expecting at least one shaky breath, BUT DAMN WHEEIN AND SOLAR PROVED ME WRONG
(Edit) ty for the likes I appreciate it!
(Edit) sorry I didn’t know that it wasn’t in falsetto
:o that was fast
And about hwasa and byulie.??
What do you expect, it's mamamoo 👑
sorry but when do you hear falsetto in this song? (I love Mamamoo and I’m not doubting them - I’m just curious because I wouldn’t use that term for anything in this song, it’s mostly in comfortable chest voice range, only that bit in the prechorus goes higher)
@@fsjukebox the click me click me part is falsetto. Also the "hae" in hihihihip hae hip part. The song isn't "mostly" falsetto but it still has some falsetto parts.
이제 맘무 안무쉬워서 라이브잘하는거라고 절대 못깜
jumping, turning and difficult choreo doesn't excuse for unstable and bad vocals 💀
Britney spears, Freddie Mercury, Michael Jackson got stable voices..
(didn't mean to get mad or smth but s. korea needs to stop debuting rookie idols just for their looks if they wanna go worldwide ngl)
They are eating CD again 😂
No,not CDs...THE STUDIO,THEY EAT THE ENTIRE STUDIOO 😂
무무 perniment mamamoo diet
Someone get them some proper food 😭
봤냐 울언니들은 춤이 격해도 잘부른다.
어머 수련씨 시즌2에서 꼭 살아오세요 그리고 그 말씀 인정합니다
입안에 녹음해둔거 틀고 립싱크하는게 학계의 두루미
학계의 두루밐ㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
휜 음색 대박이다...... mr제거로도 선명하게 들리네......
아니 화사언니 칵퉤까지 안해도 되는데ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
춤이 쉬운것 같으면 춰봐라 나 친구들이랑 힙연습하다가 뒤지는줄
쌉인정
저것도 마마무니까 하는거지 아무나 못함
힙 30번 따라추고 거의 다 외움 .. 너무 힘들어서 1시간 간격으로 함 ..
쉽다는 애들 리아킴이랑 1ㄷ1 상담해야함
괜히 췄다가 다리 아작나는줄..앉았다 일어나는거 개 많아서..초반부터 허벅지 터지는줄...;;
근데 왜 귀엽냐..ㅎㅎ글고 노래넘잘하는듯 춤이 많이 격한데
이쯤되면 mr제거가 검증용이 아니라 음색듣기용인듯 답답할때 들으러오면 속 뻥뻥 뚫림ㅋㅋㅋ
This is one of the reasons why Mamamoo is my favourite K-pop female group. It's because they can actually sing & harmonize live. Pretty much what makes one a singer/vocalist.
SOPE World love your name
@@ulmnum Thanks! Like yours too!
이제 마마무는 못건들이겠네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
마마무는 mr 제거하든 말든 발은 또박또박하고 잘들리고 가창력도 빠지는 것 하나 없다
This is we called mr removed, not like the other channel hahaha
Sketchbook's mr removed videos are always clean because of their high quality sound system so don't blame it all on the other channels
@@Flopped69 no I got what she meant, I found some FAKE mr removed videos of Queendom from a spesific channel. I think they want to protect their idol or something. But they made a fake one for Mamamoo too. In fact, they just took the original audio from mv and add lots of noises
@@Bongi344 wait wait I got confused, which one is fake? This one is not fake right?
@@nadie-qm8rq not this one of course.... This one is legit hahaha. Unfortunately I forget the channel name 🤦 It made so many Queendom participants's fake mr removed if you curious.
@@Flopped69 Apart from this perf and for the last few weeks, they've stopped using the 5.1 channel system, therefore clean extraction on the center channel (the channel in 5.1 where live vocals are on sketchbook) isn't possible and other extreme methods usually used for music shows (music bank, show champ, music core etc etc) and all that is being used :/ its still live though
The clearest MR Removed I've heard! Thank you so much
if you think this is clear checkout Minayo's MR removed channel, her's are absolutly fantastic
Wheein's voice silky smooth 😢
moonbyul: the one that is beautiful and stable
wheein : the one that is beautiful and stable
hwasa: the one that is beautiful and stable
solar: the one that is beautiful and stable
The perfect guide to new moomoos haha
마마무는 노래도잘해, 얼굴도예뻐, 춤도 잘춰
부족한게 없는 그룹
Moonbyul rap 😻
She's not stable
@@james-yj5xp did i hear something crashing from bad stability?
@@moonsunismarried she's like out of breath it's just sound look like me running because my mom will hit me hahaha
@@james-yj5xp Dance around and make a countious sound like a flute and now make the same experiment while talking and then tell which one sounded more breathy. Singinging and rapping are still two enities you can't compare. So yea moonbyul was still stable dispite rapping.thnky you for my ted talk.
@@mcd2.061 sis ofc you will say that because you're fan of them lmao 😂 but for me she's not stable at all mamamoos are overhyped by their fans.
이제 cd 그만 먹자 응? 노래 왜이리 잘 불러
Mamamoo be like: what is an mr?
Wait whats that i really dont understand😐
love yourself pls mr stands for music removed so you can only hear the voices of idols singing.
@@Rida_06 ooh ok thx
춤 쉬운거 아님 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 라스에서 리아킴이 말한 영상 봐보셈 어렵게 만들고 한두개 빼줄랫는데 마마무가 다 소화했다고..
Wow mamamoo’s worst is better than other groups best
Yeah,we stan powerful women
i swear !!
I think, they don't even have a worst.
ikr tbh HIP is always the worst Mr Remove to me as they need to sing while having strong dance moves but still better than many other groups
Solar sounds so good despite the difficult moves! Queen!!
Hwasa's lines give me life
Nobody:
Hwasa: kah tou
Me: *replays*
nobody going to talk about moonbyul? it’s her birthday🥰
a.k.a one of the best rappers in the kpop industry
the “click me” parts have me dying they sound so cute
You know it's live because even their accessories are producing sounds. ☝️👏
이 춤이 쉽다고 느껴지면 춰보거라
그래도 쉽다고 느껴지면 자신의 춤 영상과 마마무 춤 영상을 비교해봐라
그래도 쉬우면 노래도 같이 불러봐라
MR제거 제일 잘하시는듯..
Even if you watch the original vid you'll they didn't lipsync (sorry for my horrible english please)
yeah, they killed it, mamamoo don't need mr removed hahaha Although I believe that hand microphones favor them more, their voices are heard clearer, the headbands are uncomfortable and in most idol shows their voices are not heard🤔🤔
yes! they are amazing.
oh your english is pretty good, what´s your first language? i am brazilian so my first language is portuguese
진짜 ㄹㅇ 내가 사랑하는 걸그룹.. 표정연기나 디테일 빠지지 않고 서도 저렇게 열정적으로 부르는게 정말 멋짐..
다른데는 mr제거 똑바로 안된느낌인데 여긴 제대로 된거같네요!
stability at it's peak
트와이스꺼 보다가 여기 오니까 힐링된다 와 너무잘해
Moonbyullllll😭😭💙💙
세상에서 제일 쓸데없는 짓
마마무 mr제거 하는일
마마무 사랑해💚
내생각엔 맘무 mr 넣는 일인듯 너무 잘해서 mr이 필요가 없어ㄷㄷ
이 춤 개빡센대
엠알제거는 마마무가 짱임
춤이 쉬어서 노래 잘부르는거거렠ㅋㅋ 시발 저게 쉬어보이니 ㅠㅠ
쉬어 × 쉬워ㅇ
i love how they are NOT forzing their voices, they are authentic artists :D
실력파들은 mr제거해도잘부르는데
연습을 얼마나했을까..ㅠ 그생각 하니까 눈물나네..ㅠ
Good job girls, despite with hardest moves they sounded amazing
If you question mamamoo's stability in live performances in 2019 then congrats you finally got your degree from the clown university
God Wheein! 💯
흐아아아...너무좋아용💕
QUEENS!
The dislikes are people who can't accept they can sing
이게 MR제거라고??? 아니 거의 똑같은데 언니들 CD씹어먹고 오셨어요? 진짜 대박
마지막 숨소리로 라이브란걸 깨달았다
When it comes to mamamoo, I wonder why I still even bother to check the mr removed vids. Of course, they'll do great. But, maybe, I'm just addicted on how amazing their live performances are.
누가 마마무 춤 쉬워서 노래 잘한대 ? 리아킴이랑 마마무 꼽주냐 ? ㄹㅇ 니네가 이거 추면서 불러봐 어디 나대 마마무 화이팅 !
I will never leave this fandom, haha. ❤
진짜 mr제거 맞아?완전 미친거 아냐?대박이다 ㄹㅇ
plain amazed by these girls. stable voice, strong moves.
I thought it will be shaky breathing but is not that bad
( khatu ) and the rap ( moonbyul )
Was the best for my opinion
All did good like a hard dance while singing is just amazing 😉
이런 격한 춤을 추면서도 라이브를 잘한다니.....ㄷ ㄷ
확실히 실력은 마마무야
믿듣맘무란 말이 괜히 나왔겟냐
마마무는 CD를 먹은게 아니라 사람 자체가 CD인듯
Let's talk about Moonbyul. She slayed it *-*
비답이 진짜 언제까지 우리 언니들 안 맥일거냐
우런니들 얼마나 배고팠길래 CD를 진탕 먹으셨네..
밥대신에 cd를 줬다는 학계의 전설
와..이게 벌써 1년 전 노래냐.... 말도 ...안..돼애액..애...
춤 어렵다던데 음정도 안 흔들리고 힘든 기색도 안 보임.역시 믿듣맘무
MOONBYUL KILLED IT I LOVE HER 💜🔥
마마무언니들은 격한 안무이든 덜 격한 안무이든 노래 너무 잘 불러...게다가 다 이쁨....
아 뭐야 댓글에 사람들이 춤추면서 노래 불러보라 그래서 해봤는데... 껌이네?
아, 제가 껌됐다구요.. 비켜가세요 밟지말고..
I'm proud of Mamamoo😊They're doing great!! ٩( ‘ω’ )و
The Queens of everything included in kpop 💞💞💞😌
when some idol dont even sing main melody probably, mamaoo even sings all the bg notes (hip,hip,hip~~
마마무는 천상계죠 찌를게 없음
아니 개어이 없네;;
어떻게
4명 다 잘하냐
첨부터 끝까지 다부르네.....대박
In the other mr remove, they're a little bit shaky.
They already built their stamina here.😊
Beside from praising mamamoo's talent and hardwork, i also want to praise the one who made this clean mr remove
if the mere FOUR of them can sing this well live, i will never understand how groups with upwards of 5 members cant sing well live. i understand having difficulty when youre the only onstage, but when you have so many people to share lines with, the burden mustve been made significantly lighter...
They say they don't do hard choreo that's why they had clean mr removed NOW they had harr choreo .. now what?? Ahahhaha they're still THE BEST
they’re so stable
Mixermoo here!
Posei Drey REY??????
@@riplove13 WHO R U
Posei Drey GUESS
@@riplove13 MUH
Stan Queens 👑 ✨
Vocal queens 🤩
다른 영상에서 댓글에 아이돌mr 논란 때문에 궁금해서 아이돌mr제거 싹보다 맘무 궁금해서 오긴 왔는데 약간의 의심을 했던 나를 매우 치세요....
자 원곡들었으니 mr제거 보여주시져?
wheein darling, ur so stable😌😳☺
문벼리.. 의상 미쳐벌여 개미허리 롱다리 쭉죽 뽐내주시고 너무이쁘다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 찰떡이다 진짜루 퓨ㅠㅠㅠ 긴생머리에 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 크롭쓰 ㅠㅠ 나 이런거 조아하나바ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Queens
Gerçek ses işte ❤
I think I just saw a perfection
이해안가는데 안티들은 문별님 랩 보고 너무 남자 목소리 같다는 걸 봤는데 그게 매력이죠 타고난 거니까 그러는 거 아닌가요? 계속 까세요 마마무와 무무는 성장해서 우주 대대스타까지 갈거니까여^^
@@ziyeop 그러니까요 ㅋㅋㅋ 저는 문별님 랩 보고 입덕 한건데 출구는 없네요
어머 귀가 잘못됬네여!
???:귀를 열어야되여!!
Y’all need to stop criticizing them. I know that I’m gonna get hate for this but at lest they aren’t lazy and they all do the dance to their fullest and they try to sing the best they can while dancing and the can actually sing live unlike some groups
so.. this is how mamamoo heard their members sing in stage.. interesting 😫
no matter how many times i watch them live/mr removed i will always be impressed with how well moonbyul raps live
To think they were so busy with Queendom and other activities. They're the best!!!!
It is true that the REAL BEST KPOP G-GROUP for me is formed in 4 members only 😊❤ and I only know 3 G-Girl Group in my entire life and that is:
-MAMAMO
-BLACKPINK
-2NE1
3 Groups with 4 members that is truly talented.
We can't deny it and they really deserve to shine and be appreciated more.
jj p all three of these groups were and are very popular. How can Blackpink be appreciated more if they are literally the most popular Kpop girl group?
@@oya3163 well it's just for me hahaha I'm just sayin and highlighted the fact that the true best of best GG is formed in 4 members not 6 nor 7 ect. Hahaha don't hate me. I just love the 3 groups I'm just being a fan tho.😊
wheein stole my heart this comeback 😭