AHHH, Two in one week!! Feeling spoiled here! I love cookies and have never tried either places!! Love the comparisons and you both explained everything so well, I could almost taste them!! I just made a strawberry vanilla cookie cake today, for my nieces 4th birthday (her exact request, lol) You guys both rock my fellow twins!! Much love and have a great week!! 😍🔥🙌
Put in some overtime to get ‘em both out to ya 😁 so thrilled you’re enjoying ‘em! Oh dang, strawberry vanilla cookie cake? Sign is up 🤤 Always appreciate the kind comments! Much love to you, Christa!
It's hard to compare some of these - because the cookies are kind of different (ie choc. crumbcake filled with oreo vs filled hot fudge sundae are fundamentally different types of cookies). But I absolutely LOVE your videos! (and you're so funny ("are you using the whole container? might as well." lol).
Hi Nate! Hi Pete! This was very refreshing to watch because it wasn’t the typical type of video that you guys make usually! I really love cookies and this certainly got me wanting some right now! Hope you both are having a fabulous weekend! Much love 💙
Great video! Going in I already had a favorite between these two, Insomnia. To me Crumbl isn't even a cookie, they're all flattened cake. It's good but when I want a cookie I want an actual cookie!
So happy there’s a second video this week! I’m confined to my bed with a severe kidney infection and this cheered me up! All these cookies looked delicious, it’s a shame we can’t get them here in England 😩 keep up the good work guys!
Once I discovered Crumbl over a year ago I haven’t been back to Insomnia 👀 I will say I’m not a fan of their milk chocolate chip but oooh the maple glaze and Oreo from this week were so good! I can’t wait for you guys to try more of their flavors
As usual, no disappointment with the video and the choice of food. Better than any of your competitors videos. Hope to see you with million subscribers soon.
Love this challenge guys! Would love to see a bagel one from your next where you compare your city’s best mom & pop bagel shops with more commercialized places like Dunkin Donuts and store bought. Maybe the cream cheeses of these places too.
Loved this video! I agree these places couldn’t be any more different. Both very good in very different ways. Next time you go to insomnia get the cookie nachos lol now that’s a party.
i’ve been waiting for this video! great video once again, that maple cookie looked delicious🤩 i’ve never tried crumble cookie, this may be a sign to give in and finally try it lol
I’ve never had cookies from either of the two places, but this video makes me want to try some! So jealous. I might just have to look for a shop next time I’m in the US. 😁 Thanks for the great video!
Yay - 2 videos in one week. 🥳🎉 Your spoiling us! Sorry I was out last night so I’m late commenting. Both companies cookies looked fab! That fruit cake/cookie looked absolutely delicious 😋 but the confetti one also looked so yummy! Much love 💗
We love hearing you’re enjoying the videos, Neuza! We always appreciate the kind words and love 😃 That PB cookie is a 10/10 for the PB cookie lovers out there! 🙌
The fruit cookie is totally a fruit pizza cookie. In the Midwest we make fruit pizza with a sugar cookie crust, lemon cream cheese "frosting" topped with fruit...grapes are definitely appropriate on it. 🤭
You twins are in my head and I absolutely love it🙂🙂🙂 I love making homemade cookies loaded with oats, chocolate chunks, bits of Oreo, banana, creamy peanut butter and coconut. Absolutely delicious. Great job Pete and Nate.
U guys are unbelievable every single video exceeds the other plus really enjoyed the snickers video put in consideration a series of chocolate with the same snickers theme
Insomnia's oatmeal/walnut cookie would be the one for me I think...Wowza...I don't think I wanted to know the calories of these things...worth it for sure! Loving the spontaneous posts❤❤
Please do a Lindt Lindor chocolate challenge!! I’m a new subscriber and i can’t stop watching you videos! You guys are so Underrated. Keep it up!!!❣️❣️❣️
insomnia is definitely better. I’m a cookie monster and crumbl was just too much … I think it’s the frosting on their cookies and the cakey texture (which is fine every now and then). Crumbl was overhyped
In the end, different people will gravitate towards one or the other. It’s more a matter of personal preference than one being definitively better than the other in our opinions. It’s like the difference between people who gravitate towards traditional donuts and those that love the over the top brioche ones that have become increasingly popular over the years. Different people, different preferences 🙏
Didnt expect the outcome to be like that. Especially since Crumbl isnt even the texture of actual cookies. Its like if you made "cookies" from cake mix. So what this tells me is that you prefer cakes over cookies apparently. Lol
so yall really just sat there and ate that much food, oh my god im mind blown, yall have the metabolism of gods, i thought yall are going to share halves 😂
If you order on the app you can walk past everyone in line and get your order first. Figured that out the first time I went there waiting in line for a hour watching all these people walking by me picking up their cookies. The cookies are great but one is like eating a full meal. Heavy. Great video as always
We found out the same but pre orders were closed for the way by the time we went so we were stuck waiting 😬 We were lucky we got them all because they were almost sold out! We wish just one would sit our stomachs like a full meal 😅 These stomachs are more of a curse then they are a blessing lol! Glad you enjoyed the video, David 🙏
We don’t have these brands in Australia and I so want to try them! I’m more of a classic cookie person. My usual go to cookie is the choc chip cookie from Subway . Heat it for 8-10 seconds in the microwave and it is so good! 😋
i basically felt the same EXACT way y’all did from watching these different videos and from only having tried insomnia. but i’m coming away with the same thoughts about the crispy outside soft gooey buttery inside of insomnia (which i’ve tried and am probably slightly biased to/like more) and that crumbl (which i haven’t tried) is more of this soft baked cookie that can resemble a very soft/cakey texture which i don’t not like, just think insomnia is the better COOKIE matches that texture and everything. id prolly go to insomnia over crumbl more given how warm gooey and crispy they are. but ye i would prolly go to crumbl when they have some crazy one in a lifetime or really standout flavor i like since insomnia has less variety since crumbles changes every week.
OK I have to admit I wasn't familiar with these brands, but now I've seen them I sooo want to try them! You guys are really lucky to have so much amazing food over there 😋 Brilliant video especially as it's new to me, it was really interesting to watch👍 Much love to you both ❤️❤️
So glad you enjoyed and we were able to introduce ya to a few new brands 😁 now if you’re ever in the states you’ll have few more places on the list to try 😜 Much love right back to ya, Caroline!
I've never had Crumbl, or Insomnia but I'd love to give it a go sometime.. the calories are super high though! Like WOAH! My max calories for a cookie is 280.. and thats a Quest Protein cookie! I think I'd rather try Insomnia over Crumbl.
Personally I’d go to Insomnia before going to Crumbl just because like you mentioned the consistency in the menu options with the occasional seasonal flavor. Plus Crumbl relies more on the exterior toppings than the actual cookie base and Insomnia’s is more of a traditional cookie with mix ins which is downright outstanding! I wish there was a Nothing Bundt Cakes store near you so you could try them would love to see your reactions/review!
We’ve been blown away each time we’ve tried them! They may not be as pretty to look at and “instagramable” but geez do they hold up. We entirely support your decision there 👏👏 Hopefully one of those opens one day! If they do, we’d expect to see them on the channel lol
Bro the only thing I'm surprised about is how they managed to consume all that sugar lol!!!?, Because crumbl's cookies are super sweet and I couldn't even eat that many without feeling sick
also i notice the swap to smaller meals since youre doing more videos. Follow your heart fellas. I do like these videos as they lend themselves more to rating based videos and you cant do much of a food challenge with half the calories. Good pivot I think. I will say that candy ratings are a bit dull imo. Thanks for the video
I just viewed and read the lawsuits Crumbl filed on two cookie companies. The cases are Crumbl vs. Dirty Dough and Crumbl vs. Crave Cookies. On social media this is known as the Utah cookie wars. Today I tune in and you have Crumbl on your channel. What are the odds?
Something like this didn’t actually get tough for us - we’re quite conditioned for this volume. In bigger challenges, it’s just willpower and embracing the discomfort until you either succeed or fail. Nothing more to it than that really.
We assume that’s why most people either only get one a week or share them with friends/family. In the end, it all just comes down to weight though. As people who have had to weigh and do the math for a looot of baked goods for our videos, pretty much all cookies are nearly the same calories for the weight. Like if you buy a 250 calorie cookie from somewhere else, it usually just means it’s also half the size/weight of these. In the end we wouldn’t say anything isn’t worth trying once in your life though based off calories alone if you think you’d enjoy it... But to each their own own 🙏
the sheer AMOUNT of cookies being consumed in this video is nuts… I can’t even handle ONE crumble cookie… subscribed.
I wish I was like that but I could take down 4 crumbl cookies. Wish I was filled after only 1 for my health!
Bro I am so full after eating one Crumbl cookie. How did you manage to eat so many. I’m impressed
They are always in sync when they bite and chew :D
AHHH, Two in one week!! Feeling spoiled here! I love cookies and have never tried either places!! Love the comparisons and you both explained everything so well, I could almost taste them!! I just made a strawberry vanilla cookie cake today, for my nieces 4th birthday (her exact request, lol) You guys both rock my fellow twins!! Much love and have a great week!! 😍🔥🙌
Put in some overtime to get ‘em both out to ya 😁 so thrilled you’re enjoying ‘em!
Oh dang, strawberry vanilla cookie cake? Sign is up 🤤
Always appreciate the kind comments! Much love to you, Christa!
It's hard to compare some of these - because the cookies are kind of different (ie choc. crumbcake filled with oreo vs filled hot fudge sundae are fundamentally different types of cookies). But I absolutely LOVE your videos! (and you're so funny ("are you using the whole container? might as well." lol).
Hi Nate! Hi Pete! This was very refreshing to watch because it wasn’t the typical type of video that you guys make usually! I really love cookies and this certainly got me wanting some right now! Hope you both are having a fabulous weekend! Much love 💙
These ones are so fun for us to make so we appreciate the feedback and are happy you enjoyed it, Alison 💙
More to come!
Have a wonderful weekend 🙂
petes face and editing at 4:37 is so funny
Great video! Going in I already had a favorite between these two, Insomnia. To me Crumbl isn't even a cookie, they're all flattened cake. It's good but when I want a cookie I want an actual cookie!
You’re both such polite eaters. You never see that on RUclips. Made the video that much nicer to watch
I'm obsessed.. so excited whenever the twins put out another one. Instant likes and replaying. Thanks for the incredible content ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
3 days this week!!! you guys are the best! best channel definitely! I started subscribing a while ago for the challenges but stayed for you guys!!
So happy there’s a second video this week! I’m confined to my bed with a severe kidney infection and this cheered me up! All these cookies looked delicious, it’s a shame we can’t get them here in England 😩 keep up the good work guys!
Did you guys eat anything else the rest of the day? Each cookie was around 500 calories!
so what?? Their only cookies, not main courses..
@@tonye.5410wdym so what? They consumed over 1 pound of cookies 😭😭
I’ve been waiting for this challenge!! almost like y’all ready my mind 😅
Hope you enjoyed it!
Most satisfying food review ever ❤ SUBSCRIBED 😋
I love the way you describe things. I loved this video ! And i love the big head effect 😂 super fun ! Have a nice sunday 😘🤗😘
Once I discovered Crumbl over a year ago I haven’t been back to Insomnia 👀 I will say I’m not a fan of their milk chocolate chip but oooh the maple glaze and Oreo from this week were so good! I can’t wait for you guys to try more of their flavors
That was a great video! I have heard of insomnia cookies but never crumbl...now i want to try both!! Haha, great job once again
Straight to the point! Love the editing!
Reall enjoy your guys' takedown tuesday and weekend eating challenges keep it up Pete and nate🤙
Glad you’re enjoying the videos, Joshua! We appreciate the encouragement 🙏
How do you eat in tandem like that?! I mean, it’s like watching ballet!! ❤❤ 😂 Love you guys!!
As usual, no disappointment with the video and the choice of food. Better than any of your competitors videos. Hope to see you with million subscribers soon.
Couldn’t mean more! So happy you’re enjoying ‘em 😃🙏
Just found your channel 🙂 I look forward to your videos so much! They really help with my anxiety. So much fun to watch, thanks!
We’re so thrilled you found the channel and that the videos help in some way! 😃 much love to you!
Love this challenge guys! Would love to see a bagel one from your next where you compare your city’s best mom & pop bagel shops with more commercialized places like Dunkin Donuts and store bought. Maybe the cream cheeses of these places too.
Loved this video! I agree these places couldn’t be any more different. Both very good in very different ways. Next time you go to insomnia get the cookie nachos lol now that’s a party.
I have never heard of either of these bakeries before. So, thanks for sharing!
i’ve been waiting for this video! great video once again, that maple cookie looked delicious🤩 i’ve never tried crumble cookie, this may be a sign to give in and finally try it lol
Definitely worth giving a shot! Hopefully that maple makes a return some day 😍
This is the most fruit I've seen in any of your videos, a few berries and a grape :D
What's the next video? fruity bakes and cakes challenge
I has that maple glaze the other day and LOVED it! You boys are dropping content like crazy. Enjoying every minute 🥳
The Comparison We’ve Been Waiting For! Thanks Guys 🙏👏
Great video as always🤩
I’ve never had cookies from either of the two places, but this video makes me want to try some! So jealous. I might just have to look for a shop next time I’m in the US. 😁
Thanks for the great video!
Yay - 2 videos in one week. 🥳🎉 Your spoiling us! Sorry I was out last night so I’m late commenting. Both companies cookies looked fab! That fruit cake/cookie looked absolutely delicious 😋 but the confetti one also looked so yummy! Much love 💗
AWESOME! i love your videos, you guys are the best! 😁
Those cookies looked so good! 🤤
I would love to try the PB cookie so much, damn! ❤️
We love hearing you’re enjoying the videos, Neuza! We always appreciate the kind words and love 😃
That PB cookie is a 10/10 for the PB cookie lovers out there! 🙌
Love how you eat in sync!!
Now I have to go to both, thanks guys great video!!!
I think regardless of who’s better we can all agree that cookies are bomb
Straight FACTS!
Dreams come true is how I feel right now 🥰🫶😂😂😂😂thank you guys for this wonderful video 🤤
I love that they eat the whole cookie. How do they do it lol
i like how they eat the cookies at the same time
Great review fellas!! I’m ordering insomnia now 🤭
Gem of a channel! Glad I found you guys!
Crumbl "cookies" seem more like small free-form (pan-less) cakes rather than traditional cookies/biscuits, but that doesn't mean they aren't tasty
The fruit cookie is totally a fruit pizza cookie. In the Midwest we make fruit pizza with a sugar cookie crust, lemon cream cheese "frosting" topped with fruit...grapes are definitely appropriate on it. 🤭
You twins are in my head and I absolutely love it🙂🙂🙂
I love making homemade cookies loaded with oats, chocolate chunks, bits of Oreo, banana, creamy peanut butter and coconut.
Absolutely delicious.
Great job Pete and Nate.
They sound awesome!
Thanks, Ben 🙏🙏
@@TheTakedownTwins you're very welcome, stay awesome guys 🙂
U guys are unbelievable every single video exceeds the other plus really enjoyed the snickers video put in consideration a series of chocolate with the same snickers theme
We couldn’t appreciate the kind words more, Nora! 😃🙏
I’m just watching this in awe. How in the world did you guys down all those cookies and not even ACT full or even bothered Lmaoo literally mind blown
Insomnia's oatmeal/walnut cookie would be the one for me I think...Wowza...I don't think I wanted to know the calories of these things...worth it for sure! Loving the spontaneous posts❤❤
Im definitely impressed with how y'all eating all these damn cookies
I was literally on Crumbl’s website when your notification came for this video. Thank you for doing this video.
Thanks for watching!
Love having two a week! This was a great one!
Please do a Lindt Lindor chocolate challenge!! I’m a new subscriber and i can’t stop watching you videos! You guys are so Underrated. Keep it up!!!❣️❣️❣️
How can they do this without feeling sick?
insomnia is definitely better. I’m a cookie monster and crumbl was just too much … I think it’s the frosting on their cookies and the cakey texture (which is fine every now and then). Crumbl was overhyped
In the end, different people will gravitate towards one or the other.
It’s more a matter of personal preference than one being definitively better than the other in our opinions.
It’s like the difference between people who gravitate towards traditional donuts and those that love the over the top brioche ones that have become increasingly popular over the years. Different people, different preferences 🙏
Didnt expect the outcome to be like that. Especially since Crumbl isnt even the texture of actual cookies. Its like if you made "cookies" from cake mix. So what this tells me is that you prefer cakes over cookies apparently. Lol
The fruit ones I would never try 😯. Tye rest of them look great though 😁
I love Crumbl Cookies I’ve never tried Insomnia Cookies but I will try them. Thanks for the Review ❤
I want you to try the doughnut version😋
We’re cookies over doughnuts here but we’re sure it’ll happen sooner or later 🙂
so yall really just sat there and ate that much food, oh my god im mind blown, yall have the metabolism of gods, i thought yall are going to share halves 😂
If you order on the app you can walk past everyone in line and get your order first. Figured that out the first time I went there waiting in line for a hour watching all these people walking by me picking up their cookies. The cookies are great but one is like eating a full meal. Heavy.
Great video as always
We found out the same but pre orders were closed for the way by the time we went so we were stuck waiting 😬
We were lucky we got them all because they were almost sold out!
We wish just one would sit our stomachs like a full meal 😅 These stomachs are more of a curse then they are a blessing lol!
Glad you enjoyed the video, David 🙏
Good night guys 🤩🤩 thanks
I would feel so incredibly nauseous eating that many of those enormous cookies. My limit before nausea is about 2 Crumbl cookies.
Me want cookie 🍪
The ultimate takedown twin cookie monsters 👍👍I want some cookies 🍪 😋 they all look and sound delicious 😋 😍 love it guys👍👍😊😊
This makes me want to revisit insomnia!😋🍪
Crumbl is good for sure, never had the other place!
Been waiting for this vid!!!!
🙌🙌
I can't even eat one complete cookie
We don’t have these brands in Australia and I so want to try them! I’m more of a classic cookie person. My usual go to cookie is the choc chip cookie from Subway . Heat it for 8-10 seconds in the microwave and it is so good! 😋
Lol wow what all those cookiessss!!! Share!!!
I almost got Diabetes just watching this. I hope these guys took breaks in between cookies 😂
That Video came unexpected :D 20 min of entertainment incomming🤟
😃 hope you enjoyed it!
i was legit just recently debating this question WOW the timing!
i basically felt the same EXACT way y’all did from watching these different videos and from only having tried insomnia. but i’m coming away with the same thoughts about the crispy outside soft gooey buttery inside of insomnia (which i’ve tried and am probably slightly biased to/like more) and that crumbl (which i haven’t tried) is more of this soft baked cookie that can resemble a very soft/cakey texture which i don’t not like, just think insomnia is the better COOKIE matches that texture and everything. id prolly go to insomnia over crumbl more given how warm gooey and crispy they are. but ye i would prolly go to crumbl when they have some crazy one in a lifetime or really standout flavor i like since insomnia has less variety since crumbles changes every week.
For the price it's hard to beat a giant cookie from BJ's snack stand.
It takes me 3 days to eat one Crumbl cookie. How on earth do you eat so many in one sitting?!
OK I have to admit I wasn't familiar with these brands, but now I've seen them I sooo want to try them! You guys are really lucky to have so much amazing food over there 😋 Brilliant video especially as it's new to me, it was really interesting to watch👍 Much love to you both ❤️❤️
So glad you enjoyed and we were able to introduce ya to a few new brands 😁 now if you’re ever in the states you’ll have few more places on the list to try 😜
Much love right back to ya, Caroline!
I've never had Crumbl, or Insomnia but I'd love to give it a go sometime.. the calories are super high though! Like WOAH! My max calories for a cookie is 280.. and thats a Quest Protein cookie! I think I'd rather try Insomnia over Crumbl.
Personally I’d go to Insomnia before going to Crumbl just because like you mentioned the consistency in the menu options with the occasional seasonal flavor. Plus Crumbl relies more on the exterior toppings than the actual cookie base and Insomnia’s is more of a traditional cookie with mix ins which is downright outstanding!
I wish there was a Nothing Bundt Cakes store near you so you could try them would love to see your reactions/review!
We’ve been blown away each time we’ve tried them! They may not be as pretty to look at and “instagramable” but geez do they hold up. We entirely support your decision there 👏👏
Hopefully one of those opens one day! If they do, we’d expect to see them on the channel lol
Bro the only thing I'm surprised about is how they managed to consume all that sugar lol!!!?, Because crumbl's cookies are super sweet and I couldn't even eat that many without feeling sick
also i notice the swap to smaller meals since youre doing more videos. Follow your heart fellas. I do like these videos as they lend themselves more to rating based videos and you cant do much of a food challenge with half the calories. Good pivot I think. I will say that candy ratings are a bit dull imo. Thanks for the video
I know I’m late to this, but you both just are 7,420 calories worth of cookies. That’s insane😭😭😭
Rematch please on
CRUMBLE vs INSOMNIA 💯💯💯💯😊😊😊
FINALLY DOOPEEE VIDEO 🤞🤞💖
Could you do brownies next
I absolutely dislike soft cookies🥴…I need that crunch🥰
Insomnia would definitely be a touch better for you in that case. Still no truly crunchy cookies from either though!
How are y’all eating all them cookies 😮
Love Love Crumbl but never tried Insomnia
Crumbl was a ez dub
Oh I had my first crumble and it was delish
Video two of me asking for the messiest food challenge lol
Gonna hit you with some direct honesty here and let you know now not to be waiting around for that one 😆
@@TheTakedownTwins well I tried
Cooooookie!!! Lol they all looked so good!!
No one can beat crumble
Crumbl is 100x better to me
I just viewed and read the lawsuits Crumbl filed on two cookie companies. The cases are Crumbl vs. Dirty Dough and Crumbl vs. Crave Cookies. On social media this is known as the Utah cookie wars. Today I tune in and you have Crumbl on your channel. What are the odds?
Wow, very interesting! Imagine we side-by-sided Crumbl and on of those companies 😆
You can't compare Crumbls milk choc to Insomnia's semisweet. Try Crumbl semi vs Insomnia semi. (Crumbl's milk chocolate isn't good!)
Insomnia is better and Tiff Treats are delivered warm and better than both.
When the eating gets tough… how do you continue, how do you Will yourself to still eat?
Something like this didn’t actually get tough for us - we’re quite conditioned for this volume. In bigger challenges, it’s just willpower and embracing the discomfort until you either succeed or fail. Nothing more to it than that really.
@@TheTakedownTwins thanks for the answer… love your videos!!!!
Crumble cookies is the 💣 there really good trust me they are worth getting
Facts
Hmmm I have never heard of insomnia..!
500-600 calories each.....not worth it.
We assume that’s why most people either only get one a week or share them with friends/family.
In the end, it all just comes down to weight though.
As people who have had to weigh and do the math for a looot of baked goods for our videos, pretty much all cookies are nearly the same calories for the weight. Like if you buy a 250 calorie cookie from somewhere else, it usually just means it’s also half the size/weight of these.
In the end we wouldn’t say anything isn’t worth trying once in your life though based off calories alone if you think you’d enjoy it... But to each their own own 🙏
yal just each ate 3 days worth of calories 😂