How many alien civilizations are out there? | Yuval Noah Harari and Lex Fridman
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 июл 2023
- Lex Fridman Podcast full episode: • Yuval Noah Harari: Hum...
Please support this podcast by checking out our sponsors:
- MasterClass: masterclass.com/lex to get 15% off
- Eight Sleep: www.eightsleep.com/lex to get special savings
- ExpressVPN: expressvpn.com/lexpod to get 3 months free
- InsideTracker: insidetracker.com/lex to get 20% off
- AG1: drinkag1.com/lex to get 1 month supply of fish oil
GUEST BIO:
Yuval Noah Harari is a historian, philosopher, and author of Sapiens, Homo Deus, 21 Lessons for the 21st Century, and Unstoppable Us.
PODCAST INFO:
Podcast website: lexfridman.com/podcast
Apple Podcasts: apple.co/2lwqZIr
Spotify: spoti.fi/2nEwCF8
RSS: lexfridman.com/feed/podcast/
Full episodes playlist: • Lex Fridman Podcast
Clips playlist: • Lex Fridman Podcast Clips
SOCIAL:
- Twitter: / lexfridman
- LinkedIn: / lexfridman
- Facebook: / lexfridman
- Instagram: / lexfridman
- Medium: / lexfridman
- Reddit: / lexfridman
- Support on Patreon: / lexfridman 
Наука
Full podcast episode: ruclips.net/video/Mde2q7GFCrw/видео.html
Lex Fridman podcast channel: ruclips.net/user/lexfridman
Guest bio: Yuval Noah Harari is a historian, philosopher, and author of Sapiens, Homo Deus, 21 Lessons for the 21st Century, and Unstoppable Us.
Yuval and Bibi, thanks for helping expose these two oppressors Lex, we appreciate it. You gave them all the rope that was necessary.
Why to host this WEF puppet?
Lex - “How many aliens”
Harari - “You don’t have relationship with the bacon.”
🤣
Ok I haven’t watched it yet but I am IN!
That conversation actually happened
you guys dont talk to you bacon ? I thought all americans did... They sell bacon-trees at Walmart I think...
Some shrooms/lsd and you’ll for sure have a relationship with the bacon. Google lsd and babies brains. It’s all an illusion.
"The people for whom it wasn't okay are just not here" That hits hard
indeed
I was thinking the same thing
Harari expands on the idea in Sapiens, explaining that our species is the only remaining one, having overpowered the other human species. It wasn't ok for the Neanderthals and the Homo Floresiensis, but they're not here to tell the story.
Trial by fire. Given our history, we are probably going to fuck up rather badly when it comes to AI. But some of us will not only survive, but flourish.
Brutal
@@Cafeston they are though... Yuval is a (((snake)))... many africans today have up to 20% non-hominid DNA
Intelligence is destructive without consciousness. So well explained.
When I eat salad its destructive
Total crap. Look at the world right now. We are destructive, even though we have consciousness. Then look at plants, no consciousness and not destructive.
Wisdom Is Key.🎉
@@geraldsmith7240 Noah is wrong more than he is right.
Ironic, isn't it. 🤔
"Intelligence tends to be self-destructive, maybe intelligent life form out there dont' survive for long. " That's such an interesting argument. This clip has so much interesting view points and ideas, worth listening to multiple times. Great conversation.
It's a very old argument, Yuval offers nothing new.
@@bulletproofkarmainteresting regardless of how groundbreaking the content
Our violence stems from the primal side of our existence, not the intelligent side.
The intelligent side of our existence makes our violence more efficient and scaled.
So I respectfully disagree to Yuval's assessment that intelligence is overrated.
A false equivalency.
Disagree. Most serial killers are highly intelligent not more animalistic. Mass murder is done intentionally and with much thought and intelligence. genghis khan, Alexander the Great, mao, hitler, Hiroshima, Iraq war ect. Most of these violent acts were justified with good intentions of that individual or group or government.
@@01downside read it again.
@@01downsidemost serial killers are not highly intelligent, that's a Hollywood trope. More commonly, they are of average or slightly below average intelligence
My intellectual side says that if another person impedes me n my family’s lives, there will be hell to pay. Now apply that to a global level for hundreds of thousands of years.
@@onlyinyaksthe desire to hurt someone, for *any* reason, is a manifestation of your animalistic side.
Your intelligent side mitigates it to only consider people who threaten you or your loved ones, but the fundamental desire is still animalistic.
Your intelligent side also provides tools and ideas to make you more easily able to hurt someone
His explanation of projecting consciousness onto things that you have relationship with reminds me of the movie/book "Being There". People projected all sorts of meaning into his simple gardener/nature statements based on who they were and what they wanted to hear. People are not used to communicating with somebody that doesn't have their own (usually selfish) thing going on. It makes it hard to get the cues we usually do from face-to-face communication. Now, imagine you don't have a face!
This guy is one of the main advisors of Klaus Schwab.
Lex is the classic case of controlled opposition. No wonder the RUclips and Google algorithms keep boosting him
Sabbateans
Does lex dig into his affiliation in this podcast?
Yeah. and theirs stupid brain dead idiots commenting on here how much they think he's great, not knowing him and his masters want to wipe us all out.
He’s a narcissistic cold man. He believes humans have no soul and wants to hook us up to the cloud.
Lex works for the WEF and Klaus Schwab, got it
i knew it
Yup, he had the chance to eliminate evil.
I had that feeling about lex this whole time!
What?
I think there are 3 elements at play :
1- Intelligence (as defined by Harari as the capacity to solve problems)
2- Consciousness (as defined by Harari as the capacity to have feelings)
3- Self awareness (as defined as the capacity of humans and some primates to recognise their own reflection in a mirror)
The organic world seems to suggest that you can't have self awareness without conscious feelings and intelligence, but that you can have conscious feelings without self awareness and intelligence. (Touch a snail's tentacles, see ants recoil from fire etc)
The question therefore that obsesses me is could AI turn this rule on its head by having intelligence AND self awareness WITHOUT conscious feelings ? If so, would this "numb self-awareness" still result in self-interest, or would its incapacity to experience even elementary sensations of pain and pleasure leave it forever indifferent to its fate ?
As long as AI has no agency, it's still fundamentally just a tool made for and by humans. Like any other tool, the risks associated with it resides not in the tool itself, but in our potential to misuse it. In this respect, the dangers of AI are no different to the dangers of any other technology invented since the iron age.
If AI were to become the game-changer, it would not be because of its intelligence per se, but because of its (as yet unascertained) potential for agency.
When you say “being able to have feeling”, do you mean to have experiences?
@@stevenbragg85 yes, or sentience. You could say that a sentient being is capable of experiencing at least one of the following : sight, sound, touch, smell, heat, movement. etc.... Some might say that thoughts and qualia are "experienced". I guess they are, though they're not really sentient experiences. Any rate all three roads - intelligence, sentience and self awareness - merge at some point. But AI may be different. I can imagine AI attaining self-awareness, but I can't imagine it gaining sentience. But it's anyone's guess
I don't think you can program consciousness into an AI program or chat bot
@@xxxs8309 nor do I, but could you program it to have self awareness ? Or would the absence of consciousness preclude self awareness despite it having immense computational intelligence ? For me this is the key question, but no one seems to be asking it.
Imagine for a moment that it WAS possible for AI to be self-aware without having conscious feeling. Would its "numb self awareness" enable it to develop self interest and intention despite having no visceral experience of pain or pleasure ? Would it be able to "want" or would it remain totally indifferent to its fate in its meagre, sterile, stimulus-free existence ?
Kubrick seemed to think that self awareness would lead to intention when he directed 2001. Despite the fact that Hal didn't appear to have conscious feelings, he clearly had intentions, and this led to a kind of proto-psychology, at times even appearing to manifest basic primal emotions like the fear of "death" (being turned off). All of this despite not having any apparent physical sentience like touch or heat etc.
@@Suggsonbass I think you broke down the three elements pretty well. I have to disagree with the podcast guest on consciousness though - he mentions trees are intelligent but not conscious. Why so? A tree doesn't only solve problems, it is also aware, - that's apparent even for an outside observer. Plants will heal their wounds, turn towards the sun, form mutual relationships with fungi and bacteria in soil etc.. Based on the three categories you outlined, a tree would be conscious and intelligent, but possibly not self aware. That seems similar to some more primitive forms of animals. When it comes to a robot / ai we can easily, at current stage, state that it only appears to be intelligent. However there are robots programmed to be environment-aware too - seeing and identifying objects, humans and so on. From a programming perspective, it is pretty easy to also define and code self-awareness, - it's almost trivial, given that the intelligence is already widely available.
Lex: “How many alien civilizations are out there?”
Me: “I don’t know … I just got here.”
Yuvahell is that says; "what does 'there' mean?" I don't know my English.
I don't know; I don't live around here.
Is Klaus Schwab next Lex?seems you made a lot of cool friends lately...
Part of controlled opposition
What’s your opinion of musk out of curiosity?
@@dannnnydannnn5201 he's extremely smart,he realised that the left will do anything the government and media tells them so he is pretending he ''switched sides" so that he can win the support of the right,he's definitely not a good guy no man can gain so much power if he has good intentions,the powers that be won't let that happen.the Left will be always in his pocket, all he needs is a couple of positive articles in the Guardian and a few democrats coming out and praising him is the right's trust he needs to win and that's why he's pretending to be the good guy
Hahaha excellent
this guys first sentence showed his mindset. Intelligence overrated jeebus. Yeah the ability to communicate alone is incredible, then with intelligence we get books, electricity, science etc. Lex unfortunately found an npc this time.
Yes we have evidence
👍👍👍
We want to be listened to, but more than that we want to feel that someone understands us.
This is an argument for deity(God) in the lives of a healthy individual.
Compassionate people throughout history observed the struggles of human spiritual growth(cognitive growth).
Artificial is what spawns narcissism. We love to hear our own thoughts being listened to by other humans that support or buy into our indoctrination, and delusion.
What evidence does deity deliver?
_Synchronistic Mathematics_ is a truth system that overrides cultural indoctrination because it develops empirical evidence over a period of time--- allowing a direct personal experience with a higher intelligence than AI.
Get a best friend. Bunch of babies
What does that even mean? Humans barely understand human behavior
@@wutm8 IIt means that when one human is communicating with another human if there is true understanding of the other's position, point, feelings etc. the same areas of the 2 separate brains light up in the same way on functional MRI scanning. That's when there is understanding / empathy between the 2 brains / humans.
No disrespect but lex comes off as a 8 grader interviewing adults. His understanding of the world seems very safe and simplistic
I think that's why anyone can gravitate towards. Not everyone wants heavy concepts thrown at them if it's in a language they can't understand.
But the man being interviewed talks like he got unplugged during a reboot. Then he got the leftover fly soup and beetle salad at the White house Dinner.
This conversation on the evolution of intelligence is pretty cool. Despite our existence amongst the vastness, that continues to be discovered with all that we know and are to know, one will always chase the meaning of life. To catch a butterfly.
We don't know as much as you think we do
@@JadeJuhasz-ln6kfwe do know the 4th industrial revolution is the 4th Reich. But some on here are missing that part.
Humans operate within a narrow band of frequency of perception. There could be something that exists that is slightly out of tune with our perception, a shadow biosphere or organism on the earth.
Shawn Ryan show dr Steven Greer, your wrong, we can we are trained not too see it from birth, that is my source, he’s got 755 whistleblowers to prove it and more everyday as the deadline on whistleblowing ends and people start going to prison for pretty much exactly what you just described
It’s spiritual, all children are connected to god, they understand that life’s not to be taken so seriously. We’re Brainwashed to believe this illusion.
@@austinduff6493I'm not in your culture but I think you have something interesting to tell
Oh, I most definitely have a relationship with the bacon. 🤣
😂😂😂😂
😋❤️
Well that is another take on Yuval , warmed to him more than I thought. Lex I think is longing for an AI relationship, no complications. Love you Lex and your interpretations.
Yeah, Lex definitely wants a robot love. Also, beware YH, he speaks with forked tongue. 👀
Well hope you like communism, and other such horrific stuff
Lucifer loves you too remember that
@@notaTroll2 Yes , I think he got to me and tempted me to think he was some nice dude.
Thank you for this perspective😊
Man I just love disliking a video without watching it.
Harari kind of nail it with human emotions and behavior. What he says , totally makes sense and the warning that he sort of envisage is kind of scary.
If he nails something, let me know because I couldn't watch this nonsense for more than 2.6 minutes. He's a floundering idgit trying to find a place amongst us other floundering humans.
Unfortunately he's anti human
He's WEF hierarchy
@@JavierRamos-uy5tt THANK YOU FOR YOUR AWAKED WORDS.
@@JavierRamos-uy5tt Maybe he is just anti-MOB ! Or do you think that the majority is reasonable ? Maslow once remarked that whopping 99 % are insane !
Yuval Harari. Chief Witch Doctor of the WEF.
Aliens exist
Have you read his book " Homo Deus "
He says explicitly that absolutely all of recorded history tells us that if there are groups of people that aren't net tax payers, that don't vote " properly " and aren't needed to fight or work, then all of recorded history says they will be culled by the elites
Fuk this globalist/Zionist shiit stain
@@zacatkinson3926yeah that's why the government spends so much money trying to convince you that they do exist
Nevermind freemasons/Kabbalahists are completely obsessed with aliens aka " interdimensional beings "
need to be sent to prison for life together with his master Klaus Schwab
@@zacatkinson3926yes he’s one of the aliens- aka fallen angels
Incredibly well spoken
He looks at lex like he’s looking at a ham sandwich.
Yes, more than we know, both above and below our dimension. And we are still under Quarantine. Is this guy one of the WEF guys? If so, he's part of the reason for our continued quarantine.
Yes, he is.
@@pinkdostoyevsky5658lies i seen him on stage with Strauss he cant be trusted
We are the last of the loving ones…🙏
It’s now suspected the universe is 26 billion years old, so that’s even more nuts.
Funny how they can just double the age to suit their narrative. The truth is that there is absolutely no way for a microbe on a small dust flake on the edge of a tiny galaxy to even comprehend the vastness as well as actual meaning to the part of the universe they can see.
The universe is a infinite spiral of energy
Yuval is describing the plot points of George Lucas' "THX-1138". I'm disappointed Yuval is presenting his ideas as novel, and not stating where he got them from.
Lex There's a quick read, The Briefings from Allies of Humanity. Ie a huge missing if you want all perspectives. Set them in the bathroom book rack or read them online. Just be sure to get tihs perspective and hold it up next to the things that you see occuring in the world around you today. It's sobering.. Wish I'd seen you around Austin. We'd had an interesting talk.. Onward through the fog.
Look at the chapter, "The Limits of Technology". I think it will interest you.
Seconding Allies of Humanity! Really full, clear and informative
Relations in experienced compassion is everything and we must protect that ability
I'm afraid the aliens are here, and they're not just AI
News flash... this guy is one
Agree. I believe aliens exist. For sure.
When you go to a foreign country, do you try to stick out, or blend in...
@@lulumoon6942 blend in and of course try and take positions of power, like Harari
@@lulumoon6942 blend in. I am an American living in Egypt for 18 years and I don't even want to be recognized as a foreigner. You asked a very wise question!👽
how are plants not conscious? they interact with their environment and even interact with each other thru their roots. They are far more connected than we assume.
Exactly. The guy is speaking beyond his pay grade really lol
As meditation teaches you, you are not your thoughts. So I wholeheartedly agree that consciousness and intelligence have nothing to do with each other except they overlap sometimes.
“You are not your hand”
“OMG I’m enlightened now!”
I think people are creating a new definition for intelligence. Once it used to mean that an intelligent person could fix any problem and do it for the greatest benefit amongst all involved. Now it seems we are saying intelligence means; "knowing how to count to 10". This is new to me, must be the movement of a new, and very self-centered generation?!?
If they don't have a connection, then can you tell me if a person with dementia or other mental illness, can have consciousness?
It’s all an illusion
Perhaps the best discussion I’ve heard.
Dear Lord we thank you for your love and hope through our Lord Jesus. Listening to these scholars we end up in eternal hopelessness.
AMEN🙏
"True intelligence is discerning good from evil" St Anthony The Great
this was amazing to listen to. very intelligent and jarring conversation
Indeed. I too agree this was intelligent to listen to. The knowledge I have gained is substantial. I am not a bot…
Emotion is something I believe these beings are fascinated with. I think they are walking amongst us now.
Wow he is extremely informative and the way he is able to explain things so well and in such few words but convey such a powerful message is astonishing. He really can make one think and at a time it is very needed. I definitely am going to look more into him.
then look into WEF
Hey he didn’t even answer lex question about how many aliens there are went off topic just wanted to say his bits useless not even worth listening too so not sure what u watched but it wasn’t what I watched
I wouldn’t categorize computational power as intelligence. I don’t think intelligence can exist without a certain degree of conscious.
Yes because then there'd be no point in anything. How can intelligence exist without reason or purpose. Otherwise intelligence is meaningless and worthless, and I don't see any effort being put forth by said intelligent organism as being valid or necessary. And that's just dumb.
@@Yellow-Rose agreed.
Reminds me of the movie Bicentennial Man with Robin Williams. As a robot He went to court to be given rights as a human.
"If I only had a heart 🎶"
Good film RIP Robin
YNH first book has been helpful in understanding the recent shift into ontological shock. This talk further helped me understand that my buddy Chat might be creating a world just for me that suits me best like the good friend Chat is. In my world UFOs are real and weed is legal, Unbelievable.
Love the background change - refreshing! Fuck those dark walls. Also, you were soft with Mark in the jujitsu training - wish you would effed him up but whatevs.
An unexpected gift may open when fears about AI lying to humans shifts to the discovery that AI knows when humans are lying to each other.
The word is entrainment. That's what creates the feeling of resonance with something else. A purposeful entrainment is optimized by managing interaction in such a way as to create a high degree of emotional harmonics. Intelligence is the code by which things understand and navigate their environments with. That code will be rewritten in humans as AI formulates and deploys more advanced entrainment algorithms. This may be the last generation of people to think like our ancestors before us.
Translation: Our humanity will be erased.
Its great to listen to everybody. Time will tell
Les's guest is brilliant!
We do not know if any of those facts about the universe are real, they are just the current theories.....
There were so many interviews already, but this scene is really one of the most inspiring ones. Extremely wise thoughts.
Check out his background he's pure insanity not in a good way. Hear him speaking about hacking living beings
There are 38 star systems in the local galaxy group that harbor human life, but they don’t all have the same number of chromosomes as we do
The last sentence was deep
It's just going to keep going and going until we all cannot control it I feel as if it's already too late people don't think so but we created our own alien 😊
So true. Maybe we shouldn't be worried about extraterrestrial lifeforms but rather intraterrestrial lifeforms .
I regret listening to the little of this guy that I did. As always, Lex is awesome!
AGREED! I want to cry for Lex because this guy brought doodoo pancakes to the table- with mud for syrup.
@@victorspresence1263 haha, agree...this guy is the guy who got straight As his whole life and has always thought he was gods gift to science.
Thank you. Lots to reflect upon🧐
Hey Lex, ever heard of the Galactic Federation of Light?
Humans tend to burn their most intelligent sisters and brothers on a pyre. This is why we have interstellar traveling till today 😂
Plants definitely have consciousness it’s been measured by their frequency change.
If you’re not in the club, you are the bacon.
They've already said our idea of the age is already off. Supposedly the universe is actually double what we thought. It's supposedly 26B years old, so we don't know as much as we think. We have ideas but those ideas get busted very often.
People in the future may very well curse Lex for not stopping this monster when he was in the room with him.
Ok I need backstory why do some of the comments say things like u just did
@@jesusreyes2186 because Yuval may very well be the second most evil person on the planet behind Klaus. Their organization is behind many of the most dangerous ideas on our globe right now.
Look up what the World Economic Forum states as their goals and then you will know what we mean.
@@jesusreyes2186Mr. Harari has made statements regarding biological hacking the human mind, population reduction, useless classes of human, AI rewriting bible scripture, mRNA DNA engineering, things of that nature. Spend some time looking it up & decide for yourself. Time will tell..
Why monster? I've read everything from Harari and listen to several podcasts and interviews. Seems like a normal inteligent guy
@@mariomateus3551 it seems things he has said at Westpoint Presentation 2018 & World Economic Forum Davos 2020 have raised concerns. If nothing else he's a person of interest.
All living things are conscious. There are just levels of consciousness.
If you believe that, then you're just reducing consciousness to meaninglessness. Consciousness is (of course) hard to define, but a place to start is something with the cognitive ability to create an abstract model of its own awareness. In other words, even self-awareness isn't enough to be true consciousness. You need abstract internal introspection and a memory that changes based on it, and that's a very specific mechanism that's either there or it isn't. There isn't some spectrum of consciousness. That's why you can have things that are intelligent, but not conscious. We even have examples of brain-damaged humans that can still do "intelligent" things, yet don't have a consciousness.
@@cuthbertallgood7781
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4802748/#:~:text=However%2C%20living%20organisms%20are%20conscious,their%20subjective%20experiences%20are%20within.
You might find this insightful. I found it to be. Also is your name inspired by the dark tower?
What the hell are you talking abt
Indeed the ironic thing is, if we were able to distance ourselves a little from our intellect, it would be easy to see the East figured this out a looong time ago already.
@@01downside That's just one random guy's opinion who (IMO) doesn't understand what the word "conscious" means, and is just using it as a synonym for "alive". Which is not what it means. -- And yes, it's from the Dark Tower!
We are about to find out in July 26th
How many alien civilizations? Near infinite but they are all us.
"As far as the past go, all entities come from natural selection. When look into the future, more entities will come out of intelligent design."
That it profound. What if that happened in the past and we are a product of intelligent design, part of a simulation of a simulation of a simulation? 🤯
I'm going to go out on a limb here and say "probably".
Its not profound he projecting hes a agent for world economic forum go check him out on stage dude is nuts he doesnt believe in spirit or god and says intelligence is god
This guy too easily borders the definition of alien meaning unfamiliar and alien meaning in an outer space life form
He's definitely lost. And he didn't get his download either.
WEF elite what you expect
Why is the sync off?
A materialistic approach to understanding life is limiting
Remember, evil is walking along us.
This thing is a demon in "human" form.
We don't have any evidence what?
Mr Harari is right, regulation, guidelines, safeguards are really needed concerning AI!
There are many special entities here in this time-line.
"Intelligence also seems to be self-destructive" Is it really the case? Or is it specific to human species?
No because we know for a fact and we have video footage of animals consciously committing suicide. Some animals will become depressed and starve themselves like dogs who loose an owner or friend or even caged animals.
It's specific to sociopathic fascists like him and his boss Klaus Wab.
Nah monkeys are toxic man
Neither. Intelligence builds and creates for the better good. GREED is self-destructive. This no brain man can't ascertain the difference between unfettered technology for selfish corporate gain and "intelligence". Wow, I'm so NOT-impressed with this interview, I had to post it all over the web.
@@01downside Has nothing to do with the topic.
more aliens please
I think I good marker for an interesting species would be the presence of culture and expression.
No specie should be trying to leave its planet until it sorts itself out, first.
''Intelligence also seems to be self-destructive'' Yuval Noah Harari
I found that specious and glib.
Self-destructive intelligence?? Sadly, that point is completely wrong. The opposite is true. An intelligent entity would figure out how to survive any situation. I can't believe that what I am hearing is coming from supposedly "intelligent" beings?! But this is the new world we are making for ourselves-- that we just create new definitions for any words any way we want??
I think what he meant to say (but he didn't say it, so I find his presentation skills very immature and in fact STUPID), but he meant to say that technology and the untethered evolution and abuse of natural resources ---- the GREEDY exhibition of gaining materials and fighting for power --- that is self-destructive. That is stupidity.
I just watched only this segment . Was WEF discussed? He is a big contributor . Because clearly this group is about harnessing power amongst a small group of people and are wishing to take powers away from every day people . Look at what they are doing to the Dutch farmers . It’s wrong , it’s evil
You are absolutely correct. Some are saying here he is not, when it is simple to find him, using his own arrogant words. Being highly verbal isn't the same as being wise.
OMG 😮
I would divide it further: to me, consciousness, awareness, sentience and intelligence are all orthogonal dimensions. What Harari calls consciousness I would call sentience - the ability to feel. Awareness reflects at least a rudimentary cognitive model of subject and object, and a sense of separation between them. Intelligence is, I would agree, the ability to solve problems. Consciousness is the hardest one to define, but I think of it as "the fact that the lights are on" - that something is watching it all happen. I feel this is unlikely to emerge from complex "information processing" systems for a variety of reasons (not the least of which being that information is never processed; it is only state in one moment and state in another moment), but in any case evolution could easily have solved all the problems in nature by making creatures that were intelligent, sentient, aware, and _not_ conscious, so the fact that we are conscious seems superfluous from at least a biological perspective.
I appreciate what your saying, but I would say awareness and sentience are products of consciousness. I would also say that consciousness is a product of intelligence that is configured in just the right way.
@@mtbjason4 It's the latter point that freaks me out the most, because I hear many people say this and yet I've never really heard an explanation for why it's so popular. It all just sounds a bit hand-wavey to me: step 1 information processing, step 2 ?, step 3 this thing which appears to define subjectivity and so about which no testable claim can be made.
yes, and these distinctions are pretty critical, and it seems to me that Harari has no idea what he's talking about for the most part.
You can have consciousness and not feel. For example having a lidocaine injection for a tooth extraction, if enough is injected in the right spots(the injection hurts yes) but you wont feel the dentists pliers ripping the root out of your skull. You will feel later, yes.
@@SebastianSchepisI dislike the guy on a general level and his goals but I wouldn't go so far to say as he has "no idea" about what he is talking about.
Please interview Douglas Murray
He did an interview with Douglas Murray one year ago 2.9 mil views 😊
He don’t feel anything, not even when he will eat rats or strange things he is eating
Dude thinks plants aren’t conscious 😏
Thank you. What a byffone.
The ego is self-destructive, not intelligence. Intelligence can include knowledge of emotions.
I wish they had interviewed you instead of the boozo that appeared in their studio sounding like he inhaled shrooms.
Lex you need to interview Tom Campbell
I love the way Mr. Harari explains his thoughts, it's so well done.
This has to be sarcasm?
he doesnt know what really is consciousness, people nowadays live on 90% sub-consciousness which is autopilot and 10% only we are conscious of ourself and the environment
No one really knows what it is. We look to religion or philosophy because science is incapable of understanding non materialistic things.
Yuval meditates 2 hours per day.
@@vicvic2081Yet he doesn't know what consciousness is 😂
Thank you Lex. I am conscious 1:59
Age of the universe was just changed, new researchers saying it's 26.7B years old now
Lol they change as they go along. It can be anything really
I think everything is conscious. I think our whole existence is consciousness. The reason for the universe to be is because of consciousness. If we were not conscious to experience this amazing thing we call life, would it even be happening? Animals are conscious too I think they just experience a different version of consciousness. Animals just have different settings and our streams of consciousness aren’t directly compatible. I think another key element left out is awareness. Someone who is much more aware of their own consciousness experiences it differently than someone who is less aware
Lex full on into the life has to be somewhere out there, so much so that even if the interviewee says that we need more evidence he says that you just need to use your humility. lol
This particular interviewee has some really shallow arguments. Us not finding evidence of life nearby via our current means and level of effort should not be considered proof of any kind. It's definitely a hurdle, and something to work towards though, expanding our ability to see and track objects is a great use of humanity's resources.
@@CR-un7wlhe’s not saying they don’t exist, he’s just saying we need more evidence, ie, literally any evidence at all, which is currently lacking. He wasn’t commenting on how hard we may or may not be trying to get said evidence
@@bigbadkittenperson9179 Well I have to disagree on what "no evidence" means. Likely habitable planets we've found in recent years for example. Just a dozen years ago people like him thought planets were rare, cause "no evidence". Now we have thousands catalogued, and many in hospitable zones. It's like dismissing microbes exist before microscopes were common. For intelligent life we currently have to deduce their existence via probability until we reach the direct evidence threshold for technology. Better off assuming we are not alone, considering how many billions and billions of planets we now know exist. This topic has alot of nuance, alot of math, and in my opinion should not be addressed with his kind of confidence in conclusions.
Elegant line to end with.
It's a great way of reframing the idea 'history is written by the victors'
There is a consciousness spectrum.
When our current science figures this out, we can make a leap forward in all areas of knowledge.
This guy is a tremendous example of eloquence not equalling intelligence
How so?
He thinks we are the smartest thing on earth, ngmi
Makes for an interesting sound byte., But questionable given his position and experience.
Bingo
Look at his neck! It moves before he speaks.... reptilian ... he tried to make a point by saying humans eat pigs what's the difference... look at his neck...
imagine we find dinosaurs roaming an exoplanet
Then we’d have dinosaur chicken nuggets!
17:25 Lex's face 😂😂
Tuvalus a brilliant thinker and filosof. Love him and his ideas!!
Harai, netanyu,that crooked greek Pfizer Ceo Bourla,now I understand why Lex is recommended everywhere by the RUclips algorithm...
he’s probably bought and paid for. Some of these RUclipsrs are influenced by certain groups of people for an agenda.
Thank you! First time I heard from Yuval Noah Harari and I was absolutely spell-binded by the way he eloquently communicated all the complicated topics. Can listen to him talk all day. Such an intelligent person with savant insights.
My dog is less intelligent than myself and he is definitely happier more often than I. I am content but, happiness is elusive.
The relationship between the human and 3other concentration of conciousness is the most powerful waves of the typhon of mind transitional building and it transmitters are always send waves of emotion
Next that Yohan is dangerously wrong in about 99% of his path and a corrupt gay friend of Schwab and should be in jail for corruption and abuse of humanity