Supreme Court Cancels Domicile Reservation at Medical PG Level ! | Atul Jain | StudyIQ IAS Hindi
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 фев 2025
- कोर्स में अधिकतम डिस्काउंट प्राप्त करने के लिए 'AJLIVE' कोड का प्रयोग करें!
Hurry Enroll Now: studyiq.u9ilnk...
UPSC IAS Live GS P2I Foundation 2026 Pratigya Hindi Batch : studyiq.u9ilnk...
एडमिशन की अंतिम तिथि 31 जनवरी 2025 | बैच का समय सुबह 8:00 बजे
Hurry Enroll Now : studyiq.u9ilnk...
UPSC IAS P2I Long Term Foundation LIVE 2027 Pratigya Hindi Batch : studyiq.u9ilnk...
एडमिशन की अंतिम तिथि 31 जनवरी 2025 | बैच का समय सुबह 8:00 बजे
Hurry Enroll Now : studyiq.u9ilnk...
UPSC IAS Live SIP+ 2025 January Hindi Batch 2
एडमिशन की अंतिम तिथि 31 जनवरी 2025 | बैच का समय सुबह 8:00 बजे
Hurry Enroll Now : studyiq.u9ilnk...
Super 100 Mentorship Hindi : studyiq.u9ilnk...
UPSC IAS (Mains) Hindi Literature Optional Live 2026 (Comprehensive) Pratigya Batch
बैच 28 जनवरी 2025 से शुरू हो रहा है | बैच का समय दोपहर 1:00 बजे
Hurry Enroll Now : studyiq.u9ilnk...
UPSC IAS CSAT in 100 Days Live January Hindi Batch
एडमिशन की अंतिम तिथि 5 फ़रवरी 2025 | बैच का समय दोपहर 3:30 बजे |
Hurry Enroll Now : studyiq.u9ilnk...
UPSC Prelims Test Series 2024 Hindi - Last Batch
प्रारंभ 13 फरवरी 2024
Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/42C7mOZ
NCERT Live Course In 100 Days September Batch (Hindi)
बैच प्रारंभ 28 सितंबर 2023 | बैच का समय दोपहर 3:00 बजे |
Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3PwAQJs
Buy our Best Selling UPSC CSE Books
From Online Stores
StudyIQ App/Store
bit.ly/44WvFH8
Amazon
bit.ly/3ZkCDEF
Flipkart
bit.ly/3Pmu3k3
📌 Connect with [Our Social Media Platform] :
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Join our Telegram Group:- t.me/Studyiqed...
Whatsapp Channel - bit.ly/3M1i8Ya
Facebook: bit.ly/3PZTJDo
Instagram: bit.ly/48RZNGO
Twitter: bit.ly/48On8t7
Download the App to Subscribe to the Course - bit.ly/Studyiqapp
For any doubt, Call 76-4000-3000 or Click here for Whatsapp Chat wa.me/919838101240
A Mbbs pass easily earns money minimum 50,000 per month, so no need of Caste based reservation also, remove that also
Absolutely right.👍. At this level all are same financially. They got same benefits in medical College. Then why caste quota system....
Literally.....why the hell someone needs reservation after being a mbbs doctor....like seriously???
Reservation must be there. Why should we remove the caste-based reservation, which is provided to the whole family to be empowered? The candidate may earn 50,000 but not the whole family right? The candidate is also expected to take care and contribute to his/her family. Reservation is given to particular communities so that all stratas in the society get a chance to compete equally.
What about language barrier , patients speak different languages in most states .
Stipend inequality among states .
Exactly....we all are indians right then why diff state have diff stipends
By the same logic, caste based reservation should be removed from pg.
Sahi bat sab log Indian h sabko ek jase treat Kiya jana chahiye..koi cast nhi hona chahiye...sab apne naam se cast htao ..apni bhn betiyon ki sadi krwayo ..koi kisi ka bhi damad ban skta h ..
@@Vinay-d8thaa to tum apni behn ki shadi dom se karwaoge
Na munna na😂 sarkar palat jayegi
@@Vinay-d8ttoh tu karle shadi lower caste 😂😂😂😂tere ko ya tere baap ko roka kisne hai 😂😂😂😂
Exactly sbko same treat krenge toh sbko equality feel hogi aur fir ussi din se reservation band ho jana chi e bhai @@Vinay-d8t
Toh phir caste reservation bhi hata do post-graduation ek specialization hai.
Pg me cast reservation nhi hota
@@mahesh8770neet pg me caste reservation hai
remove caste reservation first then these nonsense decison about state quota removal
Caste reservation interview में caste favour jaise corruption का antidote है
Collegium system wale hatayenge?
There should not caste based reservation in all PG courses and promotions in job. Also reservation should be finished by giving ultimate date, there after special assistance by study and coaching allowance may be given to candidates of such castes.
@@AjitSingh-i2w2t yes exactly....
Why not start with removing surnames?? Isn't that logical??
Yes, Surname must be removed and such practices should be banned, Nothing is important and needful other then removing castism to strengthen our nation and society.
Same way.. Why need vidhan sabha elections.. keep only lok sabha elections... We all are indians citizens right.. why we need states too?
We need states
NEET ko hi hata do. 50% Reservation is right and should not be removed. The local population have the right to get admission in the universities locally and must not be forced to travel outside. The colleges and universities opened in a particular district intends to serve that local students first. Students face difficulty to travel away from home, places additional burden on the parents to pay for huge allowances. Even for post-graduate colleges, the students must be allowed to get admission in the same college and must not move out just because there are other students who 'want' to pursue education in this college. Post-graduate courses must also be encouraged to pursue the degree in their own states. In medicine, students must not be forced to go to another states, learn a new language to interact with the patients and face difficulty to adjust to the new cities. The 50% reservation by the states was right and the Supreme Court is wrong to scrap it. Counselling exists so that the local students can take admission within their own state and avail benefits of scholarships and schemes from their own states. All the states must stand against this move. NEET is only an exam to determine the merit. The state colleges must be allowed to maintain domicile reservation!
SC ST OBC should also banned for PG education
Reservation must be there in India
What about langauge barrier...how can hindi guy effectively interact with patients in Tamil Nadu when he doesn't know Tamil...this will have severe impact in history taking and diagnosis...Bad decisions
Exactlyyyy
It Means there will be only all INDIA ranks.. No state ranks..
What about language barriers.... ragging and toxic environment...Interaction with patients Will hamper a lot with patient care , diagnosis and treatment.
Stipend n bond ka kya hoga !! Maanlo tamilnadu ka doctor uttrakhand mei pg karta …. Ek toh stipend kam … dusra 2-3 years ka bond service post pg … wo toh zindagi k 5-6 saal tak fas jayega !!
Fir toh dusre states k doctors ko rokne k liye har state govt bond service badha degi … kyuki pg pass hone k baad zyadatar log apne state wapas chale jaytey han … bohot problem hone wali hai …iss verdict se … abhi dekhna tamil nadu Maharashtra … reappeal karengae !!
Merit my foot .
Give 100% reservation to people who won’t go and mint money in private practice .
It means same stipend all over india 😅
व्यक्ति निर्माणके लिए एक अच्छा डॉक्टर बनने के लिए एक अच्छा जज बनेके लिए एक अच्छा टीचर बनने के लिए आरक्षण की कतई आवश्यकता नहीं यदि कहीं कोई पढ़ नहीं पा रहा है तो उसे आर्थिक सहायता दी जाए यही एक अच्छा रास्ता हो सकता है अन्यथा व्यक्ति व्यक्ति में भेदभाव की भावनाअति प्रबल हो जाएगी वोट बैंक की राजनीतिके चलते आरक्षण को यूं हीबनाए रखना समाज में संवेदना और समग्र विकासके लिए एक कैंसर केसमान
State quota अगर समाप्त हो रहा है तो ऐ बकवास decision है ...
और ये state के अधीकारों का हनन है ....
State funded hospital and students का क्या होगा ?
Patient - doctor language barrier भी होगा ...
Doctor की सुरक्षा ...पश्चिम बंगाल केस .
Judicial system भी पुरे देश की एक हि होती है ....
तो तालूका जिल्हा न्यायालय के judges का transfer अलग अलग state मे क्यों नही होता ?
जब महाराष्ट्र के district judge का transfer तामीलनाडू के किसी district मे होने लगे तब doctor के बारे मे सोचना ...
मि. लॉर्ड ...पहले आप
Not only south india even Maharashtra bengal locals not know hindi .only town people understand hindi not all..
Thanku super explanation ❤❤❤❤
Koi delhi ka student ko jitna preparation mai help hoga PG mai..utna hi help kya koi v aur state ka government clgs mai padhne wale bachhe ko milega?....
Lekin ek hi clg mai padhke ek hi ek hi salary pake...same khana kha k v..kisika surname k waje se 50k rank upar neche se v dream clg dream branch mil rha... Wahhh kya nyayyy hai ..
Artical 14...Right to Equality...No discrimination on the basis of Caste,Creed, Relegion,Gender...In education, employment.....MBBS graduate earns atleast 60k...So how can he be economically backward?..He has taken advantage of caste in UG.. then how he can be labeled Backward for his whole life?...Here is the catch.....Remove reservation in PG Courses... should be discussed in Court
Yup..let's try removing surnames..let's start with pande maybe
Exactly....like kya sochte hai ye rule pass karne se pehle
Stop all reservation
अनु०_ 14 सिर्फ मेडिकल शिक्षा में ही क्यों बाकी के पोस्ट ग्रेजुएशन में भी लागू होने चाहिए
I think either all reservations should go or at least aiims graduate students must get reservations in pg in their states according to domicile
*This will not be implemented because this is major issue because many are in state obc list and in all india form filling they have to apply for unreserved and during counseling of state they registered as state obc* ,,,myself state obc from Andhra Pradesh,,,,,I apply in unreserved during form filling of exam but during state counseling in obc. If 100% all india counseling then what about caste reservation? In tamilnadu 70% are in state reserved list and many of them are unreserved at central list....this will create more problems
डोमेसाइल आरक्षण केवल केन्द्र सरकार के विश्वविद्यालयों, उच्च शिक्षा शिक्षण संस्थानों, पोस्ट ग्रेजुएट मेडिकल शिक्षा में नहीं हो सकता है जो केन्द्र सरकार के पैसे से चलती है । लेकिन राज्य चाहें तो अपने राज्य के लोगों को डोमेसाइल आरक्षण संवैधानिक दृष्टि से सकतीं हैं । सुप्रीम कोर्ट का उक्त फैसला संवैधानिक दृष्टि से बिल्कुल गलत है जो एक राज्य के अधिकारों को बगैर उचित संवैधानिक विफलता के रोक लगा सकती है । अन्यथा एजूकेशन, हेल्थ समवर्ती सूची से हटाकर केन्द्रीय सूची में डाल दिया जाये जहां राष्ट्र के प्रत्येक नागरिकों हेल्थ और एजूकेशन दोनों केन्द्र सरकार सुनिश्चित करेगी ।
Yes.... South ke state jaruur review petation dalenge.
There are instances when people have raised their voices about partiality and regional bias in Pg medical colleges like Jipmer when students have face unruly behaviour by faculties in duty allotment and marks provisions in exams, so the residents of central India prefer to stay here only , while South Indian even try to do forged entry because we are impartial
Schedule cast ke students par jati ke adhar par bed bav hota hai agar SC kaisa bhi reservation hatata hai to jativad system ko badana hoga
90% जज ब्राह्मण
80% विधायक ब्राह्मण
90% कैबिनेट मिनिस्टर ब्राह्मण
साथ साथ आरक्षण विरोधी RSS मोदी सरकार
अभी भी भारत में अफसर शाही राज्य कायम है
इसका मतलब दलित जहां है वही रह जाएगा😢😢
जय भीम
जय संविधान
Source: Trust me bro
भाई,sc st & obc की वोट लगभग 80 प्रतिशत हैं। फिर आपके नेता क्यों नहीं बनते, मैं बताता हूं,वोट या तो बेच देते हैं या दारू के बदले दे देते हैं। जो कि दुर्भाग्य पूर्ण है।
इसका मतलब ये नहीं कि जनरल वाले नहीं बेचते,बेचते है पर उनकी संख्या बहुत कम है।
इसलिए दूसरों को ब्लेम मत करो, उससे कुछ नहीं होगा।
सबको एकजुट करो और अपने लीडर बनाओ।
🙏🙏🙏
Itna Gyan kahan se late
Paswan ji aajkal mulli pe jyada dhayan dete hai....mulla gulf me duty karta hai ...mulli paswan Jee pe phida hota hai
Then give same stipend in all states and remove caste based reservations
Remove caste first
आगे बढा कर पिछे करना है |जो कम नंबर लाकर आरक्षण लेकर एमबीबीएस किया है, वह pg नहीं कर पाएगा |
Central university students suffer after their one or two attempts in their university. Then they don't get any thing in the state they belong or the university they did MBBS from😢
Bhai university kota bhi hota h
@Vinay-d8t only for two attempts. State qouta is not having this limitation as far as I know, please enlighten.
@@nishat251 I am not sure about attempt..
समानता का अधिकार कैसे हो गया अगर इसमें समानता का अधिकार है तो जाति जनगणना में क्यों नहीं होता अगर उसमें नहीं होता तो इसमें भी नहीं होना चाहिए🎉
यदि पोस्ट ग्रेजुएट मेडिकल कालेज यदि राज्य अपने राज्य के नागरिकों के अपने पैसे से किसी क्षेत्र में विशेषज्ञता देना चाहते हैं जिसके धन का स्थानीय राज्य और उसके नागरिक करते हैं उसे सुप्रीम कोर्ट कैसे रोक सकती है । क्या सुप्रीमकोर्ट यदि राजस्थान सरकार मान ले अपने नागरिकों को फ्री हेल्थ और एजूकेशन की व्यवस्था करती है तों ,क्या ऐसी व्यवस्था उत्तर प्रदेश सरकार और उड़ीसा सरकार के उपर जबरन थोप सकती है कि नागरिक राज्य के नहीं बल्कि राष्ट्र के होते हैं । सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने यह जो फैसला दिया है वह संवैधानिक रूप से गलत है क्योंकि भारत एक फ़ेडरल स्टेट हैं एजूकेशन , हेल्थ, ला एंड आर्डर स्टेट सब्जेक्ट हैं, जब तक स्थानीय राज्य ,केन्द्र सरकार से इस सम्बंध में हस्तक्षेप करने की अनुमति या मदद नहीं मांगतीं है तो केन्द्र सरकार ऐसे मामलों में सीधा हस्तक्षेप नहीं कर सकती हैं । जब तक कि वह राष्ट्र की संप्रभुता के लिए खतरा नजर नहीं आ रहा हों । मेडिकल क्षेत्र में पोस्ट ग्रेजुएशन में डोमेसाइल आरक्षण राष्ट्र की सम्प्रभूता को चोट नहीं पहुंचा रही थी । आज नहीं तो कल दूसरा राज्य इसे सुप्रीम कोर्ट के संवैधानिक पीठ में अवश्य चैलेंज करेगा जो उक्त फैसला उसकी सीमाओं के अन्तर्गत रहने वाले जो उसकी बिधान सभा के लिए वोट करते हैं उसके नागरिकों के हितों के विरुद्ध हैं ।
Garib students dusre state me ja ke kharcha karke parai kaise karega? BJP ko aur mauka milega ghotala karne ka aur apna logo ko seat dilane ka.
NEET UG se bhi hataao domiclile wala reservation
Not satisfied with your explanation.
It is not applicable for domicile but students persuing their study in state medical College will be eligible for state quota reservation. e.g. AIQ 15% will not be eligible for their native state. But where they are studying will come under state quota....
One nation one domicile right decision ❤
Supreme court ne Ews kaarkshan cancel karo na
wo 5 saal k baad bhi pdhna k liya ider udra ghumta rharaga kiya 😢
पढ़ाई और नौकरी के लिए आरक्षण
For neet pg ,will aiq quota seats become 75% now as opposed to 50% in the past and states will get 25% for institutional quota?
AIQ 100%
खुद विभाजन कर आप एकीकरण की अवधारणा कैसे सरकार पर कर पाओगे
To fir aiims mein kyun hai aur caste reservation kyun pg mein jb sabhi mbbs doctor ban gaye
What about University qouta of central College??
Now stipend will be equal
Neet pg equal centred stipend
Then this must be discussed along with all other reservations as well… along with all other exams.. not just medical exams..
Yup with all the surnames as well
Ab jo admission ho rahi hai kya usme bhe lagu hoga?
केवल आर्थिक सहायतादो
Sir jo AIIMS se MBBS kar rahe hain unka kya hoga
Kaaat gya unka
Caste reservation ko bhi hatao . Sabhi exam me . Barna tallented bache ghar bete rehe jaenge
Teri category ke talented bacche college mein hi hain
@@Chris-bo2zs agar hai to reservation bale Kahan jate hai .khet me .hagne 😂😂😂😂
Jo ab third councelling hogi usme kya hoga..kya usme bhe je lagu hoga.. please tell
Ye decition only PG ke liye hia ya MBBS ke liye bhi hai???
Only pg
bilkul nhi h 😮
Is AIQ 100% NOW ?
Good caste ka bhi hata do ab
Caste hi hata do..or muslims ka minority status bhi
What's about service quota under state quota ? 😈
already 50%quota is there
What about FMG ?
Neet mai b reservation hata do .....non deserving student get such pretentious medical collages easy while the talented minds suffer .....if nation wants to grow india must remove such unconditional reservations
Aur bhai agar aapka selection nhi hua toh so pls stop blaming reservation.
that reservation policy is totally baseless ....come on ...now all of the people get same education same facilities...infact reserved people live more sophisticated life than any other but still they enjoy this reservation and get undeserved seats ....By this most of the talent has died in india .....India will never realize its true potential untill and unless this shitty reservation policy is removed .....
@@rujhanrather4511 what about management kota .. private seat..NRI Kota
.did u know their ranks and speacilty thay are doing..last year neet pg cut off was zero percentile.. person who has scored negative marks can get top medical branch like radio..only due to money and so called sarkar ki sath ganth
@@rujhanrather4511 reservation doesn't affect any kind of quality or efficiency.. people who enter through any kind of reservation or gen way ..when thay passed their specialization thay are as competent as their there colleuge bcz passing criteria and duties are same for all..
@@rujhanrather4511 in ss( super specialization )their is no reservations but many category people cracking the exam and doing well in their fields..
Bht ism abhi bht clue ..MS delhi ya up se krne waly ko 1 lakh per month milta h ..wahi jharkhand m 60 k milta ..sab satet m alg alg bond and penalty h ..insbkankya hoga
not clear
जिन बच्चों ने AIIMS से mbbs करी उनको रिजर्वेशन h kya usi clg me
Aadhe adhure decision UG mein kyon nahi
Is this domicile quota same as state quota Or not?
It’s same
Bhai Mera sc cast certificate (Maharashtra state) hai to mai ra aarakshan khatam hoga kya
No bro@@Sjdkdkdbd
Fmg konse state me state quota lega ?
From America
What about Institutional quota ?
I welcome to this decision of Hon'ble SC and i fully agree with the arguments .
😂mujhe nahi samjhta jab pvt college Accha hai to iska virodh kyu.
Good news for abroad mbbs student
Neet UG se v Remove kr do bhai
What about caste reservation
Same as your minority status..both should be removed
If you did mbbs from that state fir bhi aap eligible nahi honge
Eligible honge
Eligible honge yadi mbbs ki hai toa dont worry ... only domicile criteria remove hua hai
Neet ka bhi reservation hata do
You need reason to do that?? What is your reasoning..don't come up with "there is no caste based discrimination in modern India"
Ekdm bakwas faisal h ..ase to university kota hota h..NRI Kota hota h ..in sbka kya sahi h ..