I think this is such a brilliant scene! Among the many points of brilliance is the subtle class distinction between Boldwood and Gabriel Oak. Boldwood, a man of Bathsheba's own station, is the only person in the room secure enough to interject into her solo like that. She smiles and welcomes it, of course, which helps, but still, in essence it is an interruption. I can't imagine Gabriel doing the same thing - partly because he is humble and wants to see her shine rather than himself, but also because according to the class structure he doesn't have the "right" to speak up/sing up. And I so love their expressions here. Gabriel looks at her with a deep sense of appreciation and affection; Boldwood looks at her as if hypnotized. I liked Boldwood in the book and in this particular version, but I don't think he understood Bathesheba as a person that well. Dazzled by her beauty and charm, he didn't see her flaws (or personal strengths, like determination, etc.) like Gabriel did. Anyway, all around, such a cool scene!
@Amy Lougheed Thank you for your comment! I agree with you about Boldwood eventually recognizing that Gabriel is a rival. Even though there were some things I wasn't crazy about in regard to this movie (Bathsheba's costumes seemed anachronistic at times and there were nuances in the book that I thought could have been indicated better) the casting is definitely a highlight. And anyway, one can enjoy both the book and the movie and get an even better picture of the story as a whole, considering that some aspects work better on film and some work better on paper (for example, I'm not sure film can capture the kind of surreal quality of the fire Gabriel fights at the beginning of the book, but you'd never get this wonderful meld of music and acting from words on a page!).
Yes!! I ve heard him.sing bits of songs before, but this is unparalleled. He should do more of this type.of singing. Well, his voice is always 😍😍❤️❤️❤️🔥🔥🔥😜😜💞💞❤️❤️❤️anyway
I like how there was never animosity between Oak and Boldwood...jealousy on Oak's part of course but he was gentlemanly about that. Boldwood definitely seemed to respect Oak. Just goes to show rivals don't necessarily despise each other.
@TK Wallace What an excellent analysis of Boldwood and Oak you give. Yes, even though Boldwood was not meant for Bathsheba, he has a refinement of character, an important sense of self that Oak does not have. Oak is not a doormat of course, an honorable and self made man in his own right, but it is not in Oak's character to rise to a position of public prominence like it seems natural for Boldwood to do. Boldwood was made to be the face of respected status whereas Oak does not seek that type of notoriety. He is content to rise and accomplish what it is in his nature to accomplish -- to work with his hands, to honor the commitment to himself and others, but he is not one to want to openly boast about them. That is Boldwood. And that' s not a negative judgment on Boldwood. It's simply right for a man who is Boldwood.
Michael Sheen: sings Everyone at the table: *turn heads* MICHAEL SHEEN CAN SING?! I don't understand how there is literally no movies with him singing, except several minor scenes, when this guy could do with at least a musical.
Lyrics: Come all you fair and tender girls That flourish in your prime Beware, beware, keep your garden fair Let no man steal your thyme Let no man steal your thyme For when your thyme, it is past and gone He'll care no more for you And every place your time was waste Will all spread over with rue Will all spread over with rue The gardner son was standing by Three flowers he gave to me The pink, the blue and the violet true And the red, red rosy tree And the red, red rosy tree But I refused the red rose bush And gave the willow tree That all the world may plainly see How my love slighted me How my love slighted me
@@laurids2007 It's a very old traditional song, passed down the generations, and so no one probably knows who wrote it. A number of folk artists have covered it, e.g., Scottish folk singer, Shelagh McDonald (find on RUclips).
Although musical style is very simple, I'm hardly trying to find a pdf scores with the "original version" but it's very very difficult. All the researches lead to "Far from the madding crowd" version.. As music student, I'd like to find the original... Or I'll write a personal version 😅
@@stephendouglas4870 It's not. It was written by the group Pentangle in the 1960s. It was rewritten here for this movie. Only the first two stanzas are from the original.
We are in love with is movie. Yes. Sadly obsessed. I heard today that the legendary novelist Thomas Hardy stopped writing by a critical remark someone threw at him. It must have cut him to the quick and the world is worse off because of some fly away critical comment. A lesson for all of us.
Such a damn wonderful scene of this wonderful movie. My god, Carey Mulligan's voice, the way Michael Sheen and Mathias Schoenaerts look at her... And I love Irish folk songs... My sincere congrats to all the excellent actors and actresses, and of course to Thomas Vinterberg for directing this enterprise so well, with such intelligence, beauty and depth in capturing romantism on screen... And thank you so much Anne-Lorraine Uy-Gothong for sharing this scene with us.
I'm glad to hear someone else say this movie and music are "soothing". I have been watching it or at least had it playing in the background everyday for the past week.😊
I have watched this movie like 5 times already. Absolutely loved it. Loved the book as well, of course, but, to my mind, this ecranisation is very, very successful.
I was impressed by Oack character, when Ms. Everdine refused to marry him and he keep his pride and dignity and didn't run behind her and cry to be with her "if you dont want me either i" He broke my heart when he was leaving at the end i know how the feeling when you have to stay close with someone dont share you the same feeling it hurts forever:'(
In a movie that is almost too good to be true this scene stands out in tragedy mystery and beauty. I've watched the movie literally hundreds of times and listened to the song thousands and I'm still not sure I could explain what's happening. Thus is the perfection. Carey Mulligan is a King.
I have no voice! Carey and Michael did an amazing job! It's a beautiful movie, that I recently saw! I plan to watch it, over and over, again! I also have the song on my iPod!
Such a beautiful scene 😍 it's really gives me goosebumps. Today I heard this song after a long time. This song is so soothing and so is the movie. And if anyone is watching this again and again I'm happy to say you have good music taste !
Come all you fair and tender girls That flourish in your prime, Beware, beware, keep your garden fair. Let no man steal your thyme, Let no man steal your thyme. For when your thyme it is past and gone He'll care no more for you, you. And every place where your thyme was waste Will all spread all o'er with rue, Will all spread all o'er with rue. The gardener's son was standing by Three flowers he gave to me The pink, the blue and the violet too And the red, red rosy tree, And the red, red rosy tree But I refused the red rose bush And gained the willow tree That all the world may plainly see How my love slighted me, How my love slighted me.
She was 18 and he was old enough to be her father. Boldwood really did not understand Bathsheba. He wanted to lavish jewels and clothing and a big house on her but she really didn’t want that. In the novel Boldwood was jealous and obsessive. Gabriel, however, knew her and her faults and still loved her. He stood by her even after she rejected him and never harassed her or asked her again. He accepted her answer which is so respectful. He worked beside her and taught her what she needed to know and supported her dream of running a successful farm. He tried to warn her of how her actions hurt Boldwood and also not to trust the soldier. When she finally reached her goal he was willing to step aside and then go forward with his own life. She is lucky that Gabriel accepted her as a wife after all she put him through. Gabriel Oak is an honorable and loyal character like Atticus Finch from To Kill a Mockingbird.
On request; the full lyrics: Come all you fair and tender girls That flourish in your prime Beware, beware, keep your garden fair Let no man steal your thyme, Let no man steal your thyme. For when your thyme is past and gone He'll care no more for you And in the place your thyme was waste We'll spread all o'er with rue, We'll spread all o'er with rue. A woman is a branchy tree And man's a clinging vine And from her branches carelessly He'll take what he can find, He'll take what he can find, He'll take what he can find.
*+Brenda Brinkley* Thats an incredible generalisation to make - its unfair, untrue & immature. Human civilization and society in general would never have flourished or got this far if your statement were true. I agree 100% with *Jake Deans* reply to you.
Countercanto... When a voice follows a specific melody and then another one follows the first voice with another melody connected, through harmony'S rules, to the first melodies
You know a good actor by how his face can say so much and he's not even moving his lips.
I think this is such a brilliant scene! Among the many points of brilliance is the subtle class distinction between Boldwood and Gabriel Oak. Boldwood, a man of Bathsheba's own station, is the only person in the room secure enough to interject into her solo like that. She smiles and welcomes it, of course, which helps, but still, in essence it is an interruption. I can't imagine Gabriel doing the same thing - partly because he is humble and wants to see her shine rather than himself, but also because according to the class structure he doesn't have the "right" to speak up/sing up. And I so love their expressions here. Gabriel looks at her with a deep sense of appreciation and affection; Boldwood looks at her as if hypnotized. I liked Boldwood in the book and in this particular version, but I don't think he understood Bathesheba as a person that well. Dazzled by her beauty and charm, he didn't see her flaws (or personal strengths, like determination, etc.) like Gabriel did. Anyway, all around, such a cool scene!
Wonderful character analysis 😊❤ I loved it.
@@sandavijithminirathnayake7033 Thank you!
@Amy Lougheed Thank you for your comment! I agree with you about Boldwood eventually recognizing that Gabriel is a rival. Even though there were some things I wasn't crazy about in regard to this movie (Bathsheba's costumes seemed anachronistic at times and there were nuances in the book that I thought could have been indicated better) the casting is definitely a highlight. And anyway, one can enjoy both the book and the movie and get an even better picture of the story as a whole, considering that some aspects work better on film and some work better on paper (for example, I'm not sure film can capture the kind of surreal quality of the fire Gabriel fights at the beginning of the book, but you'd never get this wonderful meld of music and acting from words on a page!).
wnderfully commented
@@klcheung1724 Thank you!
I would love to hear Michael Sheen sing more, he has such a beautiful voice!
sarah conant I
He does it in some eps in masters of sex
Yes!! I ve heard him.sing bits of songs before, but this is unparalleled. He should do more of this type.of singing. Well, his voice is always 😍😍❤️❤️❤️🔥🔥🔥😜😜💞💞❤️❤️❤️anyway
Seconded! I wish he would sing more!
He does a carpool karaoke with Matthew Rhys that is very entertaining.
Just here for Michael Sheen. I love his voice.
"I have no voice!" [sings]
*excuse me*
*abni the vague* Yea, that's like Meryl Streep saying "I cant act"!
So typically British
Michael Sheen's voice when he sings "violet true" is just hnhnbghg. I need to find more of his singing!
I think he has some nice songs from "the hobbit"
WE ARE ALL HERE JUST FOR MICHAEL SHEEN RIGHT?
Right? He drops the bass.
@@natashafranco1630 yes....yes we are. Sheen Con is in April 2021. Look on Twitter
??? He wasn’t in The Hobbit.
A female character choosing any other man over Michael Sheen shifts the category of this movie from "historical drama" to "fantasy/science fiction".
lol
I’m with you. I’d chose him in a heartbeat
Truth
Not when matthias is the other option
@ablackbird4574 : a female character choosing any other man over Michael WHO?....I only saw Matthias Schoenaerts... ;)
What a MAN Gabriel is. My heart aches for him!
Eduarda Graciano Also Mr Boldwood, such a gentlemen and so respectful
Yeah, and mr boldwood aswell
I like how there was never animosity between Oak and Boldwood...jealousy on Oak's part of course but he was gentlemanly about that. Boldwood definitely seemed to respect Oak. Just goes to show rivals don't necessarily despise each other.
That's the white man's way.
C Pegg is it jealousy? Or a reminder of how she is out of his league - and a match more fit for a gentleman?
Uh...Oak is clearly jealous . Maybe not "OJ Simpson jealous" , but he's clearly jealous enough.
Well said :) Blessed Easter.
@TK Wallace What an excellent analysis of Boldwood and Oak you give. Yes, even though Boldwood was not meant for Bathsheba, he has a refinement of character, an important sense of self that Oak does not have. Oak is not a doormat of course, an honorable and self made man in his own right, but it is not in Oak's character to rise to a position of public prominence like it seems natural for Boldwood to do. Boldwood was made to be the face of respected status whereas Oak does not seek that type of notoriety. He is content to rise and accomplish what it is in his nature to accomplish -- to work with his hands, to honor the commitment to himself and others, but he is not one to want to openly boast about them. That is Boldwood. And that' s not a negative judgment on Boldwood. It's simply right for a man who is Boldwood.
The best singing movie scene in this ten years
SKubric You said it buddy. 25 years.
The Irish singing scene in "Brooklyn" is better. Both of these are great, though.
0:32 i think i just fell in love
1:30 i think i just fell in love (again)
1:55 i have pledged my soul to this man
2:13 deceased
I want a Mr Boldwood in my life, beautiful, handsome, lovely, fine man
It seems that there are many of us that had those same "side effects". This is just... 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥😜😜😜😜😜😜🔥😜😍😍😍👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻💖💖💖💖💖💞💞💞💞💞💞💞❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
😂😂 OMG, yes!
I’d have married Mr Boldwood like a shot if he promised to sing to me like that every day.😍
😂😂😂
Does anyone else just repeat the ending? Michael singing is my happy pill
1:55
That harmony made my heart go 🎊
This is one of the best romantic films I have watched.
What's name of film?
Michael Sheen: sings
Everyone at the table: *turn heads* MICHAEL SHEEN CAN SING?!
I don't understand how there is literally no movies with him singing, except several minor scenes, when this guy could do with at least a musical.
He's a Welshman, of course he can sing.
Of course he can sing - he's Welsh.
Carey too
oh my god.. Michael Sheen's voice...
Lyrics:
Come all you fair and tender girls
That flourish in your prime
Beware, beware, keep your garden fair
Let no man steal your thyme
Let no man steal your thyme
For when your thyme, it is past and gone
He'll care no more for you
And every place your time was waste
Will all spread over with rue
Will all spread over with rue
The gardner son was standing by
Three flowers he gave to me
The pink, the blue and the violet true
And the red, red rosy tree
And the red, red rosy tree
But I refused the red rose bush
And gave the willow tree
That all the world may plainly see
How my love slighted me
How my love slighted me
It's really beautiful
💞💖💞💞💞
Who composed this song?
@@laurids2007 It's a very old traditional song, passed down the generations, and so no one probably knows who wrote it. A number of folk artists have covered it, e.g., Scottish folk singer, Shelagh McDonald (find on RUclips).
Although musical style is very simple, I'm hardly trying to find a pdf scores with the "original version" but it's very very difficult. All the researches lead to "Far from the madding crowd" version.. As music student, I'd like to find the original... Or I'll write a personal version 😅
C trės beau merci 💕💕💕
@@stephendouglas4870 It's not. It was written by the group Pentangle in the 1960s. It was rewritten here for this movie. Only the first two stanzas are from the original.
We are in love with is movie. Yes. Sadly obsessed. I heard today that the legendary novelist Thomas Hardy stopped writing by a critical remark someone threw at him. It must have cut him to the quick and the world is worse off because of some fly away critical comment. A lesson for all of us.
Honestly it's worth watching this movie JUST for this perfect scene.
Such a damn wonderful scene of this wonderful movie.
My god, Carey Mulligan's voice, the way Michael Sheen and Mathias Schoenaerts look at her...
And I love Irish folk songs...
My sincere congrats to all the excellent actors and actresses, and of course to Thomas Vinterberg for directing this enterprise so well, with such intelligence, beauty and depth in capturing romantism on screen...
And thank you so much Anne-Lorraine Uy-Gothong for sharing this scene with us.
English folk songs...
what makes you think this song is Irish?
We women should all be so lucky to have those two sexy men stare at us 😊
1:25 they begin to duet
Everybody except one person :cheer
hahaha true
Carey Mulligan and Michael Sheen: *start to sing togheter*
me, a bisexual: *explodes for too much beauty*
Same here. 100 percent.
Gross.
The way, Matthias was looking at Carey, the whole time! While, she was singing! He never got over her. I was very happy! When, they ended up together!
As a massive Thomas Hardy fan this film didn't quite reach my expectations but I thought this scene was perfect.
Do you prefer the 1968 version of this movie with Julie Christie?
Love both Mr. Boldwood and Mr. Oak, how is a girl to choose!!
I'm glad to hear someone else say this movie and music are "soothing". I have been watching it or at least had it playing in the background everyday for the past week.😊
I'm not aware Ms Carey Mulligan possesses such a beautiful voice and could sing so beautifully.
She also sang in Inside Llewyn Davis. Sublime cover of Five Hundred Miles! I’m sure you can find it on RUclips😊
@@nlorens good to know. Thank u.
I have watched this movie like 5 times already. Absolutely loved it. Loved the book as well, of course, but, to my mind, this ecranisation is very, very successful.
WOW! Carey Mulligan is such an incredible talent. I have not seen this movie, but I will most certainly be looking for it, now.
Michael Sheen please sing more!!!!
I was impressed by Oack character, when Ms. Everdine refused to marry him and he keep his pride and dignity and didn't run behind her and cry to be with her "if you dont want me either i"
He broke my heart when he was leaving at the end i know how the feeling when you have to stay close with someone dont share you the same feeling it hurts forever:'(
Che bella voce che ha Michael Sheen😍
E FOSSE SOLO LA VOCE
I am just going to sit here and loop this video indefinitely.
In a movie that is almost too good to be true this scene stands out in tragedy mystery and beauty. I've watched the movie literally hundreds of times and listened to the song thousands and I'm still not sure I could explain what's happening. Thus is the perfection. Carey Mulligan is a King.
Oh my god I’m so in love with this scene
Watching him go from fascinated fondness to suddenly falling in love is really lovely. Poor bastard didn't have a chance.
i purposely searched for michael sheen singing and i'm not disappointed
I could listen to these two all day, every day
Well I have never ever Felt so much with every fckn look Mathias gives. He is fckn KILLING ME
i'm so in love with this movie ❤❤❤
i'm just sitting here, crying ??????? this was so beautiful ????????????????
I have no voice! Carey and Michael did an amazing job! It's a beautiful movie, that I recently saw! I plan to watch it, over and over, again! I also have the song on my iPod!
The movie was not as good as it could be but this scene and the cast are absolute perfection
1:55 gave me chills
Such a beautiful scene 😍 it's really gives me goosebumps. Today I heard this song after a long time. This song is so soothing and so is the movie. And if anyone is watching this again and again I'm happy to say you have good music taste !
Bittersweet so true these lyrics so very true....
A beautiful scene ....marvelous
I was blown away...even after watching this again
-Adding this to my To Watch list-
Watched the movie. My god, Mr. Sheeran is a very good Mr. Boldwood
Breathtaking scene
This is so moving.
I loved the foreshadowing of the song warning girls of men who would take from and use them, then Bathsheba falling for Frank Troy
Desde que o mundo é mundo, existem homens más, porém ainda temos os homens bons, a questão é se preservar para as moças não serem enganadas.
Just love this song , and the movie with such brilliant acters ! 🤩👌
Oh my gosh I'm just seriously in love with this❤
Thank you for posting this!
I love this scene and song so much.
+IhaveKilledMyPanda yes i agree. shes wonderful . a breath of fresh air .
+IhaveKilledMyPanda yes i agree. shes wonderful . a breath of fresh air .
Great advice for young women, let no man steal your 'time'...
Didn't love the movie, but this scene blew me away
Come all you fair and tender girls That flourish in your prime,
Beware, beware, keep your garden fair.
Let no man steal your thyme, Let no man steal your thyme.
For when your thyme it is past and gone
He'll care no more for you, you.
And every place where your thyme was waste
Will all spread all o'er with rue, Will all spread all o'er with rue.
The gardener's son was standing by Three flowers he gave to me
The pink, the blue and the violet too
And the red, red rosy tree, And the red, red rosy tree
But I refused the red rose bush And gained the willow tree
That all the world may plainly see
How my love slighted me, How my love slighted me.
I watched this movie ... very beautiful story 💕😍 and This song is very sweet🎶
So Beautiful, So sweet, So Nice ❤️
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Rufus wainwright, eres un MAGO. me encanta, todo lo que haces.
love love love this!!!
I love this song, the movie is fantastic too!
Am I the only one who’d chose mr boldwood ina heartbeat?
She was 18 and he was old enough to be her father. Boldwood really did not understand Bathsheba. He wanted to lavish jewels and clothing and a big house on her but she really didn’t want that. In the novel Boldwood was jealous and obsessive. Gabriel, however, knew her and her faults and still loved her. He stood by her even after she rejected him and never harassed her or asked her again. He accepted her answer which is so respectful. He worked beside her and taught her what she needed to know and supported her dream of running a successful farm. He tried to warn her of how her actions hurt Boldwood and also not to trust the soldier. When she finally reached her goal he was willing to step aside and then go forward with his own life. She is lucky that Gabriel accepted her as a wife after all she put him through. Gabriel Oak is an honorable and loyal character like Atticus Finch from To Kill a Mockingbird.
Wow so this is what honey sounds like
I thank God for You. Love, Light, Peace, Music and Joy
Oh that was amazing ,I love his voice ❤️
Michael Sheen can sing?!
Yes he can. I didn't realise this until I saw the end of episode 3 (3rd series) of "The Good Fight" last week.
m.youtube.com/#searching
My fav type of songs 🍃🌼
Love this movie ❤❤
On request; the full lyrics:
Come all you fair and tender girls
That flourish in your prime
Beware, beware, keep your garden fair
Let no man steal your thyme,
Let no man steal your thyme.
For when your thyme is past and gone
He'll care no more for you
And in the place your thyme was waste
We'll spread all o'er with rue,
We'll spread all o'er with rue.
A woman is a branchy tree
And man's a clinging vine
And from her branches carelessly
He'll take what he can find,
He'll take what he can find,
He'll take what he can find.
Love her sing voice 🌟👑💎📷💥🎥❤❤❤❤
Poor lonely Boldwood - he didn't stand a chance of withstanding that smile.
❤Far From the Madding Crowd❤
Mochael Sheens harmonies 😢💞
Beautiful
J'adore ce passage
Foarte frumos 💐💐💐💐
Carey you are so besutiful and sings perfect!
I loved the movie
KILLING ME !!!!!!!!
I AGREE !!
What a MAM Matthias Schoenaerts is! His eyes!
Both men are great💋
Matthias schoenaerts...🌷❤
how breaking no contact after years has me feeling like
Let No Man Steal Your Time
After this scene I wanted to Marry William omg ... poor baby, I've got a soft spot for men who become hopelessly in love.
E degjo 10 here ne dite dhe nuk ngopem e manitshme
Oak... ‘welll... damn!’
❤❤😊اجمل مقطع
Una bella melodia, che evoca vecchie ballate medievali
👍👍👍👍👍
If that is her voice, pretty amazing. She doesn't hold a candle to Jaqui McShee and Pentangle, but still.
Beautiful! But sad and so true...men just take what they want and leave the woman...not what I signed up for!
*+Brenda Brinkley* Thats an incredible generalisation to make - its unfair, untrue & immature. Human civilization and society in general would never have flourished or got this far if your statement were true. I agree 100% with *Jake Deans* reply to you.
Teşekürler zeyno😘
me at a party screeching at the host: A SOnG 0:00
🌹💗
🌻🌻🌻🌻
Where can I watch it for free?
What this style of signing called a high tone and then a lower one??
I was wandering the same...
Harmonies
Countercanto... When a voice follows a specific melody and then another one follows the first voice with another melody connected, through harmony'S rules, to the first melodies