Richard & Dave's vocal harmonies on *echoes are beautiful and unearthly and unequaled in Pink Floyd's long repertoire. A lasting classic for all Pink Floyd fans!
And their respective styles on keyboard and guitar were so distinctive and beautiful, that it is impossible to get the same feel and emotions without both of them playing the piece.
@@megablasterboc7474 I should have read a little further and I would have seen your comment made one month before mine. And I could have replied to your comment. We are on the same page brother. They were the best.
I recall being introduced to: Pink Floyd at Pompeii at age 18 or 19 and being so completely overwhelmed by the strange beauty of it. Echoes especially was nearly tear inducing. I’m nearly 53 now and it’s still a perennial favorite.
@@michaelmorningstar8645 I can't find a source for that. By all accounts, Waters hated Wright and treated him badly, and Gilmour was kind to him, didn't want to fire him, and rehired him when he had the chance. A link to anything that says otherwise would be appreciated.
As it should be...the song is not the same without them both together....it does show David's love and respect for his friend!! 🕊️🕯️🕊️🕯️🕊️🕯️ 💖💖🧸🧸💖💖🧸🧸💖💖
I saw it performed by Mason's band at the Royal Albert Hall and tears of joy welled up. I was going to comment that the voiceover is incorrect that the surviving members don't perform the song but found this comment before I did. It is a great shame that Mason doesn't seem to have plans to release a Blu-ray of what is openly named "The Echoes Tour" as it was a sublime set.
@@ianmccall5840 There are better guitarists and keyboardists than both Dave and Rick around, don't bet on this, just listen to i.e Dream Theater playing Dark Side of the Moon FULLY in concert... It doesn't impedes Dave+Rick creativities and all the beautiful musical ideas they generated, but as pure instrumentists, they're just average. In a 10km radius around my home, there are at least a dozen guitarists playing better than Dave, and I don't live in a city, I'm about 40km south of Luxembourg in a town of about 10k along the river... I even know a pianist who has nothing to blush if compared to Chick Corea, a freaking monster...
Some things , can not be replaced , or just brushed over . Such are the people , We call Dear Friends . One off's , like Richard Wright . I saw a performance in the Royal Albert Hall , I bought the disc set , where Richard played the first notes , & the place just held it's breathe , as do I , every time I watch that clip . Timeless , & yet in honesty , one of the last times played before his death . A wry smile , almost shyly , he knew in that moment , just how special it was to us . Rest in peace , Richard . If David is "Pink" , you my friend , were very much , "Floyd" .
I think the way Waters treated Wright during the latter stages of the Floyd still makes Gilmour's blood boil, and his refusal to play Echoes is his tribute to him.
Rubbish. Gilmour and Mason also voted Wright out of the band. You think Waters had sole say in who could be in the band? Waters never stopped anyone from contributing songs or ideas in the band. The well had run dry for the others so Waters took up the mantle and produced the goods.
It's not true that Echoes is absent from all former Pink Floyd members' live sets - I saw Nick Mason and his band Saucerful of Secrets late last year and they played it; absolutely nailed it too!
Right. This video is nonsense. Feels like it was written by AI or something. As for David referring it as a “duet” is a slap in the face to the other members.
You are absolutely right, Nick and his band knocked it out of the park with their Echoes. Didn’t quite meet the level of Dave and Rick when I saw them in 2006 but it was still spectacular!
@@vileforfeit OMG don't put words in the mans mouth. You have no idea what his comment meant. To him it may have been like a duet, enough said don't you think? He wouldn't be the one to slap the others in the face I will say that for sure!
I feel so privileged to have seen Floyd many times over the years but just one concert way back in 1975 at Knebworth the first time I saw them they did Echoes live the one and only time I have seen and heard it live it was awesome. RIP Rick
Man i agree and respect Gilmore for not playing without wright. Rick was the pulse of Pink Floyd. Rest easy Rick and Syd🙏🏻🎹🎸 Pink Floyd my favourite band and one of the greatest bands in the bloody universe.👍🏻
The original 1972 Pompeii performance was magical, and when I think about it, I understand perfectly… 😢 R.I.P Rick, you were truly great and gracious! 😊
I understand how David feels completely. I've lost friends and there are places I won't go anymore because it just hurts too bad to be there with all of the memories those places bring back. Same with songs. Rick was under appreciated and some treated him poorly, may he Rest In Peace.
As a fan since 69' and as much as Echoes means in the history of PF, I get where Gilmore is coming from and I'm cool with it. Something about Echoes without the twin voices of Gilmore and Wright would be obviously missing something. From 72' to 75' I saw PF 4 times and Echoes was a major part of their set. As much as the song never gets old, I'll miss hearing it live but I'll have good memories to still make me smile. There is however one thing that does make me sad and that is with each passing day there are fewer and fewer of us who saw PF perform Echoes live and one day there will be none of us left. Somehow I hope the song finds a way to out live all of us and the future finds value in it. If so, we done good! RIP Rick, we miss you.
Fans will just have to make do with the YT videos to see performances of Echoes. Not playing it anymore is a respectful tribute to his friend and bandmate. David's guitar and Rick's haunting keyboards are what makes Pink Floyd unique.
I could hear that magic from “Remember That Night “ the ESP call and response of Dave and Rick that was palpable in the way the song flows, they played off of each other and it really was a moment in time I will never forget. My respect to you Sir David. And at 63 now I love your music and the special way that you present it.
The very best version of “Echoes” is from the 2007 release of “Remember That Night” recorded in 2006 at the Royal Albert Hall. It was the last time David and Richard played it together and it was like they knew it.
I was lucky enough to see PF over 30 years ago in concert and there is no comparison to any other band. I’m just happy I got to see them once in my lifetime.
For me it started with One of These Days... The white noise and synth stuff... Bought Meddle in Prague CZ on a vacation, still got that album. Later bought Pompeii on DVD. It is for me the pivoting point of Pink Floyd. When they found their new sound with Gilmour. As an amateur synthesizer player, kudos to Richard Wright. Pink Floyd for me started with white noise from one of his synths (EMS?). It was one of these days, I was about eight years old when I heard that song for the first time...
I saw PF in Dallas at Mc Farland auditorium in 73, playing the entirety of Dark Side of the Moon-which I had not heard yet; I was still basking in the sounds of Meddle. Second set was a bunch of long classics. At one point, someone yelled out Echoes! Roger turned around and pointed his finger at the guy, but they didn’t play it…that is until the encore. My favorite rock vocals of all time are David and Richard singing together.
in the mid 70's I i bought my first "stereo" and the first thing I heard on the FM airwaves was Echoes. I was blown away by it and thus began my love of incredible music all almost all genre's .
As soon as I read the video title I figured that it was going to be a Rick Wright connection. One of the music industries true gentlemen and one of the few whose passing brought me to tears. His solo album, Wet Dream, is quite wonderful and well worth people seeking out.
Every good thing has an end, for us Floydians, we know what has been done, and what once was. I am honored that I was at Pink Floyd's concert and to have the privilege to live at the same time as they did. Thank you to you for publishing this one, to Pink Floyd for the happiness, to each member of PF as human and of course, to the millions and millions of fans of the past, the present and those who will keep the legacy going in the future.
Echoes is definitely one of (or possibly) my favourite song from the band. A great constructive piece from all four, but David & Rick really shine. Not just because of their vocals, but their music and soul. I actually got to see Nick Mason's Sauceful Of Secrets last year and they played Echoes through its entirety. Highlight of the night and maybe of 2023 for me. I'm grateful that I got to hear the song from one of the original members. R.I.P. Richard Wright - My favourite member of the band
I grew up on Pink Pink Floyd still enjoy listening to four PF cd's Darkside wish you were here echoes..animals David still plays a mean guitar! yes Respect Dave understand his emotional Ties to Richard with echoes we all miss rip Richard
Echos is probably one of Gilmore's greatest songs. I was always curious why he never played it again, now it makes sense looking back. Richard was definitely the foundation of that whole song.
It's the part of the song where they go back and forth and look at each other. But we all know that in all of their other songs, that Rick conveyed the different feelings throughout. He can always go back On an island to catch up with Rick and play their song again.
Richard Wright was the background soul of Pink Floyd.. There is one album where he is absent and we can feel the lack of music in that .. the final cut..
I must say, for me, the Pompei recording of Echos is one of the purist, finest pieces of music I have ever had the pleasure to hear. Each time I listen it's like the first time all over again, it is an unexplainable mystery to me how this piece is so powerful each and every time. I guess that makes it better than sex!!!
I am listening "Echoes" from my PA really loud enough like as if it was live! The "Pink Floyd" are standing around playing with the trees and the birds", (including Syd Barrett)! Thank you 🌈Pink 🌈🌈Floyd🌈!
I feel the same Richard Wright and David Gilmore where always in one at all times. Rechard would wear a tercouis braclet. It took me years to find one. I found it two years ago and wear it daily. In menory of Richard. RIP Peace Out and Love MMLZZZ
its seems a shame to retire such a great song. I wonder if RW would like to deprive future generations the joy of hearing it live. Almost like locking away the paintings of a great master once they've passed. I understand DG sadness but let it ring out as celebration of the man that left us.
I saw Gilmour and Wright play Echoes in Chicago 18 years ago today. It remains my fondest live music experience and is likely never to be surpassed for me. In fact, I skipped Gilmour’s 2016 tour because I knew it wouldn’t be the same.
You could not watch Pink Floyd without seeing the connection between them. David was always looking over to Rick. I can see why he doesn't want to do it. I should have expected it.
He still plays Syd's and Rick's compositions and has included recordings of Rick from the jam sessions on his new album, as well as The Endless River album, to ensure their legacies live on and to ensure their estates (family), still have an income from royalties. While I've seen Nick Mason's Saucerful Of Secrets perform Echoes and I have to say they did it great, it just didn't have the same feel as either the Live in Pompey or Live at Gdansk recordings, with the latter being so much more emotional, especially the final minutes where they're talking to each other with their instruments for the last time, as if they knew and were saying goodbye.
He said the song was like a conversation between the two, and you can hear it when they go back and forth between guitar and organ improvs after the first two verses. In the "groovy" part that then fades off into the "dark realm" sounding bit.
RICK AND DAVE'S VOICES TOGETHER ON THAT SONG, BEST SOUNDING VOCAL HARMONY IN HISTORY OF MUSIC. They should have used ricks voice more, it could have really beautified the wall and final cut.
Nick Mason's band and their approach is a refreshing change from Gilmour & Waters. That said, I TOTALLY understand why Dave feels that he can no longer perform "Echoes." I miss Rick.
just goes to show how highly David thought of Richard
R.I.P. Richard sadly missed never forgotten
They did some great stuff together on Obscured By Clouds. Mudmen is a fantastic track that they co wrote
I thought Wot's... Uh the Deal? , was the standout song on that album.
Well miss you, RW
@@securityrobot one of my favorites
@@securityrobotthat’s from Obscured By Clouds not Meddle
Richard & Dave's vocal harmonies on *echoes are beautiful and unearthly and unequaled in Pink Floyd's long repertoire. A lasting classic for all Pink Floyd fans!
And their respective styles on keyboard and guitar were so distinctive and beautiful, that it is impossible to get the same feel and emotions without both of them playing the piece.
@@megablasterboc7474 I should have read a little further and I would have seen your comment made one month before mine. And I could have replied to your comment. We are on the same page brother. They were the best.
I totally agree with David and understand completely.
Liar
@@David-vg8lxare you on your period? 🩸
@barneymiller6204 nob head
Idiot
You'll be happy to hear that they're replacing it on the set list with the theme from Barny Miller! Bom.... da da dom ...da da dom .....😅
I respect his decision, and don't blame him. It's a piece of music that has emotional ties for him. RIP Richard 🙏❤
I’m glad he changed his mind and i’m gonna see him live, Madison Square Garden November 5th, got my ticket already )))
@@NiceguyEddie2828 Fantastic, I'm happy for you 👍
@@ZippyThePinhead Thanks:/))
Gilmore not only beautiful and a genius but a gentleman with class and sensitive.
*Gilmour
🤣😂🤣
yes not so roger tho, sad.
*sensitivity. "Class and sensitivity".
I'm tired of living in a country populated by idiots.
Very true.@@wout123100
I recall being introduced to: Pink Floyd at Pompeii at age 18 or 19 and being so completely overwhelmed by the strange beauty of it. Echoes especially was nearly tear inducing. I’m nearly 53 now and it’s still a perennial favorite.
Yes, it was life changing. It made me research the history of Pompeii,Stephen Hawking,what a division bell is used for. It's music and so much more.
'Nearly'?
I call that respect and true friendship. My hats off to Mr,David Gilmour.
It's PR BS.
Replying to Mr. Morningstar: How is *not* playing a song a PR stunt? Anyway, hasn't Gilmour always shown respect to Wright?
@@stvartak7164 No. He called him the c word and fired him.
@@michaelmorningstar8645 I can't find a source for that. By all accounts, Waters hated Wright and treated him badly, and Gilmour was kind to him, didn't want to fire him, and rehired him when he had the chance. A link to anything that says otherwise would be appreciated.
@@stvartak7164 Read a book.
As it should be...the song is not the same without them both together....it does show David's love and respect for his friend!! 🕊️🕯️🕊️🕯️🕊️🕯️
💖💖🧸🧸💖💖🧸🧸💖💖
Nick Mason's Saucerful of Secrets played Echoes on his 2022 tour, which played Toronto. It sounded great!
I saw them do it live in Indianapolis, and it was truly mind-blowing, the highlight of an already awesome gig.
Nick & Saucer's version a lovely tribute. Wonderful really. BUT. You will never beat David & Richard @ Gdansk IMO.
@@ianmccall5840Pero es obvio hermano...
I saw it performed by Mason's band at the Royal Albert Hall and tears of joy welled up. I was going to comment that the voiceover is incorrect that the surviving members don't perform the song but found this comment before I did. It is a great shame that Mason doesn't seem to have plans to release a Blu-ray of what is openly named "The Echoes Tour" as it was a sublime set.
@@ianmccall5840 There are better guitarists and keyboardists than both Dave and Rick around, don't bet on this, just listen to i.e Dream Theater playing Dark Side of the Moon FULLY in concert... It doesn't impedes Dave+Rick creativities and all the beautiful musical ideas they generated, but as pure instrumentists, they're just average. In a 10km radius around my home, there are at least a dozen guitarists playing better than Dave, and I don't live in a city, I'm about 40km south of Luxembourg in a town of about 10k along the river... I even know a pianist who has nothing to blush if compared to Chick Corea, a freaking monster...
Some things , can not be replaced , or just brushed over . Such are the people , We call Dear Friends . One off's , like Richard Wright . I saw a performance in the Royal Albert Hall , I bought the disc set , where Richard played the first notes , & the place just held it's breathe , as do I , every time I watch that clip . Timeless , & yet in honesty , one of the last times played before his death . A wry smile , almost shyly , he knew in that moment , just how special it was to us . Rest in peace , Richard . If David is "Pink" , you my friend , were very much , "Floyd" .
That must be Remember that night, my favourite concert DVD.
I saw David at the RAH in 15 and 16 fantastic
@@rogerbeattie2263 It was , indeed !
I think the way Waters treated Wright during the latter stages of the Floyd still makes Gilmour's blood boil, and his refusal to play Echoes is his tribute to him.
You’re probably right there mate , I know I would be if I was in that position
Hear hear
Waters is a See You Next Tuesday
Rubbish. Gilmour and Mason also voted Wright out of the band. You think Waters had sole say in who could be in the band? Waters never stopped anyone from contributing songs or ideas in the band. The well had run dry for the others so Waters took up the mantle and produced the goods.
@@newcoatresurfacing5477 hi Roger
I LOVE David G and Pink Floyd. I also truly love Brit Floyd. They played Echoes a few years ago and it was magical!
It's not true that Echoes is absent from all former Pink Floyd members' live sets - I saw Nick Mason and his band Saucerful of Secrets late last year and they played it; absolutely nailed it too!
Right. This video is nonsense. Feels like it was written by AI or something. As for David referring it as a “duet” is a slap in the face to the other members.
@@vileforfeitCome on man, he was speaking of their combined vocals and he is absolutely right, that is the definition of a duet!
You are absolutely right, Nick and his band knocked it out of the park with their Echoes. Didn’t quite meet the level of Dave and Rick when I saw them in 2006 but it was still spectacular!
@@nnahlerfair point. it does seem a stitch disrespectful though.
@@vileforfeit OMG don't put words in the mans mouth. You have no idea what his comment meant. To him it may have been like a duet, enough said don't you think? He wouldn't be the one to slap the others in the face I will say that for sure!
Long live to The Master of Psychedelic Keyboard, Mr. Richard Wright. ❤
Mr David is such a class act, & true gent to those he reveres as family!
Respect is something that this world is sorely lacking. Thank you David.
Beautiful song
I feel so privileged to have seen Floyd many times over the years but just one concert way back in 1975 at Knebworth the first time I saw them they did Echoes live the one and only time I have seen and heard it live it was awesome. RIP Rick
I've seen them live only once. In Chicago in 1977 during the Animal tour. Unforgetable!
Man i agree and respect Gilmore for not playing without wright. Rick was the pulse of Pink Floyd. Rest easy Rick and Syd🙏🏻🎹🎸 Pink Floyd my favourite band and one of the greatest bands in the bloody universe.👍🏻
A lot of people didn't realize how close Richard and David were, it's totally being considerate to his true friend. RIP Mr. Wright!!!
There's such a thing as loyalty and that track was timed exactly to there harmonys
The original 1972 Pompeii performance was magical, and when I think about it, I understand perfectly… 😢
R.I.P Rick, you were truly great and gracious! 😊
I agree with his decision. So glad I got to see Dave & Rick live doing Echoes in Toronto.
Echos was perhaps Pink Floyd's greatest work.
100% agree!
Nothing compares to Ummagumma's studio LP, but you need to be wrapped enough tight to understand what's happening...
I understand how David feels completely. I've lost friends and there are places I won't go anymore because it just hurts too bad to be there with all of the memories those places bring back. Same with songs. Rick was under appreciated and some treated him poorly, may he Rest In Peace.
Who’s here after buying tickets for his tour this year?
1.10 Rome 🤩
David is a class bloke respect his decision RIP Rick you absolute genius.
As a fan since 69' and as much as Echoes means in the history of PF, I get where Gilmore is coming from and I'm cool with it. Something about Echoes without the twin voices of Gilmore and Wright would be obviously missing something. From 72' to 75' I saw PF 4 times and Echoes was a major part of their set. As much as the song never gets old, I'll miss hearing it live but I'll have good memories to still make me smile. There is however one thing that does make me sad and that is with each passing day there are fewer and fewer of us who saw PF perform Echoes live and one day there will be none of us left. Somehow I hope the song finds a way to out live all of us and the future finds value in it. If so, we done good! RIP Rick, we miss you.
Fans will just have to make do with the YT videos to see performances of Echoes. Not playing it anymore is a respectful tribute to his friend and bandmate. David's guitar and Rick's haunting keyboards are what makes Pink Floyd unique.
I could hear that magic from “Remember That Night “ the ESP call and response of Dave and Rick that was palpable in the way the song flows, they played off of each other and it really was a moment in time I will never forget. My respect to you Sir David. And at 63 now I love your music and the special way that you present it.
The very best version of “Echoes” is from the 2007 release of “Remember That Night” recorded in 2006 at the Royal Albert Hall. It was the last time David and Richard played it together and it was like they knew it.
That is the one at Gdansk
He's one of my favorite guitarists
I was lucky enough to see PF over 30 years ago in concert and there is no comparison to any other band. I’m just happy I got to see them once in my lifetime.
This man is an ambassador to music. Incredibly talented and an honourable human being.
For me it started with One of These Days... The white noise and synth stuff...
Bought Meddle in Prague CZ on a vacation, still got that album.
Later bought Pompeii on DVD.
It is for me the pivoting point of Pink Floyd. When they found their new sound with Gilmour.
As an amateur synthesizer player, kudos to Richard Wright. Pink Floyd for me started with white noise from one of his synths (EMS?).
It was one of these days, I was about eight years old when I heard that song for the first time...
I saw PF in Dallas at Mc Farland auditorium in 73, playing the entirety of Dark Side of the Moon-which I had not heard yet; I was still basking in the sounds of Meddle. Second set was a bunch of long classics. At one point, someone yelled out Echoes! Roger turned around and pointed his finger at the guy, but they didn’t play it…that is until the encore. My favorite rock vocals of all time are David and Richard singing together.
in the mid 70's I i bought my first "stereo" and the first thing I heard on the FM airwaves was Echoes. I was blown away by it and thus began my love of incredible music all almost all genre's .
As soon as I read the video title I figured that it was going to be a Rick Wright connection. One of the music industries true gentlemen and one of the few whose passing brought me to tears. His solo album, Wet Dream, is quite wonderful and well worth people seeking out.
So pleased I saw an echoes performance with Ric at the Albert Hall. 2006. Astounding version. ❤
I went to all three nights and it remained such a moment to hear that first note pinging out every night, very special.
He has 8 shows coming up!
It's harder for me to watch these guys get old than it is to watch myself get old.
Echoes is a masterpiece. I have loved since I first heard it back in the '70's in the concert movie Live in Pompeii.
Every good thing has an end, for us Floydians, we know what has been done, and what once was. I am honored that I was at Pink Floyd's concert and to have the privilege to live at the same time as they did. Thank you to you for publishing this one, to Pink Floyd for the happiness, to each member of PF as human and of course, to the millions and millions of fans of the past, the present and those who will keep the legacy going in the future.
He played 'Echoes' during his On an island Tour with Richard Wright at keyboards
I was lucky enough to see David and Rick on David's on an island tour where they played echoes. I will never forget that night.
Nick Mason performs Echoes. It should be seen as a tribute. RIP Rick but the song should never die.
R.I.P. Richard Wright ❤🇦🇺
The glue has moved on to the next world ❤ RIP ❤
Respect.❤❤❤🙏🙏🙏
Very good short documentary, amazing word choice, a pleasure to hear.
He played it one final time with Richard before Richard left us.
Amen.
Well, you got one thing wrong. Nick Mason is playing Echoes with his band during Saucerful of Secrets tour almost every night
Echoes is definitely one of (or possibly) my favourite song from the band. A great constructive piece from all four, but David & Rick really shine. Not just because of their vocals, but their music and soul.
I actually got to see Nick Mason's Sauceful Of Secrets last year and they played Echoes through its entirety. Highlight of the night and maybe of 2023 for me. I'm grateful that I got to hear the song from one of the original members.
R.I.P. Richard Wright - My favourite member of the band
I grew up on Pink Pink Floyd still enjoy listening to four PF cd's Darkside wish you were here echoes..animals David still plays a mean guitar! yes Respect Dave understand his emotional Ties to Richard with echoes we all miss rip Richard
Richard is the true sound of Pink Floyd! Every other member could have been replaced!
Much respect for Gilmour--a moving tribute, which Wright would cherish. Friendship Rules. 💓💓
Echos is probably one of Gilmore's greatest songs. I was always curious why he never played it again, now it makes sense looking back. Richard was definitely the foundation of that whole song.
David has a kind face and kind eyes.
Two great musicians
It's the part of the song where they go back and forth and look at each other. But we all know that in all of their other songs, that Rick conveyed the different feelings throughout. He can always go back On an island to catch up with Rick and play their song again.
Respect 🙏
Simply, that’s the strongest meaning of RESPECT. Period.
Richard Wright was the background soul of Pink Floyd.. There is one album where he is absent and we can feel the lack of music in that .. the final cut..
I got to see them perform Echos in 1977. Good thing.
Who knows about the future.
Check out Echoes on Gilmour's Live in Gdansk show featuring Rick's final live performance. Also has the best ever version of Comfortably Numb.
I must say, for me, the Pompei recording of Echos is one of the purist, finest pieces of music I have ever had the pleasure to hear. Each time I listen it's like the first time all over again, it is an unexplainable mystery to me how this piece is so powerful each and every time. I guess that makes it better than sex!!!
Awesome. I am just impressed by this.
Absolutely love all PF and Dave Gilmours work. Just wish he would have done something from Animals live.
Got to see Wright and Gilmour do Echoes in LA 2006. So sad in retrospect. RIP Rick
I am listening "Echoes" from my PA really loud enough like as if it was live!
The "Pink Floyd" are standing around playing with the trees and the birds", (including Syd Barrett)!
Thank you 🌈Pink 🌈🌈Floyd🌈!
Wet Dream will always be one of my favorite albums few have ever mentioned
I feel the same Richard Wright and David Gilmore where always in one at all times. Rechard would wear a tercouis braclet. It took me years to find one. I found it two years ago and wear it daily. In menory of Richard. RIP Peace Out and Love MMLZZZ
Fair enough, and I admire David for being so honest about it
Nick Mason plays it as part of his solo act. It’s good too
At least we got Saucerful of Secrets to play it. A mighty fine version of it too I might add.
I agree and understand why i would feel the same way in his shoes
its seems a shame to retire such a great song. I wonder if RW would like to deprive future generations the joy of hearing it live. Almost like locking away the paintings of a great master once they've passed. I understand DG sadness but let it ring out as celebration of the man that left us.
Echoes sounds like a warm up for the songs on dark side of the moon
I saw Gilmour and Wright play Echoes in Chicago 18 years ago today. It remains my fondest live music experience and is likely never to be surpassed for me. In fact, I skipped Gilmour’s 2016 tour because I knew it wouldn’t be the same.
That's a shame because that's probably one of the "top three" most requested live songs from the Floyd.
He did resurrect it acoustic on his solo show quite a while ago…
I respect him even more.
That song gives me the strangest feeling, wish I could describe. Mood
Some things just belong to a time and aren’t meant for other times.
You could not watch Pink Floyd without seeing the connection between them. David was always looking over to Rick. I can see why he doesn't want to do it. I should have expected it.
David Gilmore has provided the music that is the soundtrack. To my life he is one of a kind
He still plays Syd's and Rick's compositions and has included recordings of Rick from the jam sessions on his new album, as well as The Endless River album, to ensure their legacies live on and to ensure their estates (family), still have an income from royalties.
While I've seen Nick Mason's Saucerful Of Secrets perform Echoes and I have to say they did it great, it just didn't have the same feel as either the Live in Pompey or Live at Gdansk recordings, with the latter being so much more emotional, especially the final minutes where they're talking to each other with their instruments for the last time, as if they knew and were saying goodbye.
OK....I get it. I wish you would sing some songs from your first David Gilmour solo album. Like there no way out of here.
Such an absolutely fabulous band. My love and appreciation for Pink Floyd continuously grows as I do.
He said the song was like a conversation between the two, and you can hear it when they go back and forth between guitar and organ improvs after the first two verses. In the "groovy" part that then fades off into the "dark realm" sounding bit.
Dave is such a nice bloke RIP Rick
David is a class act. I’m grateful for whatever he gives me.
Richard William Wright was is and will forever be part of my life
He has played Echoes live. good lord, easy to find
RICK AND DAVE'S VOICES TOGETHER ON THAT SONG, BEST SOUNDING VOCAL HARMONY IN HISTORY OF MUSIC. They should have used ricks voice more, it could have really beautified the wall and final cut.
Nick Mason's band and their approach is a refreshing change from Gilmour & Waters. That said, I TOTALLY understand why Dave feels that he can no longer perform "Echoes." I miss Rick.
😢. He is just absolutely the best.
Nick Mason plays it as part of his Saucerful of secrets band.
to us they are great songs... to them they are pieces of themselves individually and collectively.
Very understandable David