*HAWAII GIRL First Time Watching* SCHINDLER'S LIST (Movie Reaction) HOLOCAUST
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 авг 2024
- I react to the Iconic Schindler's List Directed by Steven Spielberg (E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial, Jaws, The Color Purple) This story is based on the Holocaust and a business man named Oskar Schindler who employed Jews.
It stars Liam Neeson (Taken, Star Wars , Les Miserables) as Oskar Schindler, Ralph Fiennes (The King's Man, Harry Potter, Skyfall) as Amon Göth, Ben Kingsley (Iron Man 3, The Jungle Book, Shang-Chi and the 10 rings) as Itzhak Stern.
#schindlerslist #stevenspielberg #moviereaction #firsttimewatching #filmreview #drama #germany
12:40 this is honestly quite an offensive thing to say - I'm quite confident in saying that the only thing that resembles your upbringing in a low income area to the Warsaw Ghetto is that they are both called "ghetto". To compare a US "ghetto" to the situation in early 1940s Poland is really quite disrespectful.
She’s using the term broadly, and I understand what she meant. Ghettoizing people is still happening in other countries; it absolutely happened in the United States. There’s no denying it.
@@robjaimes8830no, she's using the term to mean "low-cost housing." She wasn't living in an actual walled-off ghetto that she couldn't leave, as the Jews in Poland were forced to do. Yes, it still happens in other countries, and even in the US, but it did NOT happen to her.
I would never presume to compare my upbringing to that of the warsaw ghetto I just simply meant that I grew up in a housing projects in which there are housing projects all over the world still to this day. I meant no disrespect. Thank you for expressing your opinion.
Согласна с Вами, очень безграммотная
The song the children are singing along to when they were rounded up in the trucks is called "Goodnight Mother" I don't know the exact lyrics but the gist is a little boy whom after his prayers, tells his mother goodnight and begs her to buy him two ponies. Through the verses, he first gets ponies made of marzipan (candy, basically), stuffed toy horses and carved wooden horses, all of which he complains that they aren't the kind of horses he wants. Then he grows up and comes home one day and there four fine black horses in front of his house and learn that his mother has died and the horses are pulling a hearse with her in it. Needless to say, those aren't the kind of horses he wanted either, and is now filled with regret. Honestly I'm not sure WHY that was supposed to be a kids song but then a lot of older children's songs are surprisingly dark. The other song, sung by a children's choir during the liquidation of the ghetto is about a rabbi teaching children the alphabet and one of the verses is particularly haunting: "When you grow older, children, you will understand by yourselves, how many tears lie in these letters, and how much lament."
Wow I had no idea that was some beautiful insight.
While making this movie, Spielberg wouldn't even communicate with the actors playing the Einsatzgruppen. These were actors of the German theater playing these parts. Spielberg would give them direction but he wouldn't make small talk with them as he couldn't get past the Schutzstaffel uniforms. That is until a beautiful thing happened very early in production. A Passover Seder was held at the hotel the cast and crew were staying. Spielberg had all the Jewish actors sitting around at a table, then all the German actors walked in wearing yarmulkes and participated in the rituals of the Passover Seder and Spielberg was moved to tears.
That’s truly a beautiful behind the scenes story! The beauty of the the moments behind filming. I love these stories and thank you for sharing that with me :-)
If dude couldn't get past their costumes thats some fake victomhood nonsense, he wasn't even alive then, what a drama queen
@@jacobhill3302 Nazi uniforms are never costumes, even in a movie. Fuck is wrong with you?
There was no Einsatzgruppen in the Schindler's list. Liquidation of the ghetto was done by SS, SD and Orpo (Order police battalion). In Plaszow and later in Auschwitz there were guards who were part of SS TV or Death Head units. They managed concentration and extermination camps.
Spielberg chose to film in black and white because he didn't want to shy away from the brutality the film depicts, but he also didn't what some of it to come across as gory. In B/W, you don't get the "gore" aspect quite as much but the emotional impact is still there since it's all up close and personal.
This is different from his choice with "Saving Private Ryan" which was in color - although a bit de-saturated. There he wanted the red to be seen as it so often is in battle.
I agree the emotional impact is through out! This film is beautifully made and just top tier all around
Thanks for this reaction! The language you hear during the Sabbath (Shabbat) prayers is Hebrew, a language native to Isreal and commonly used in Jewish prayers and blessings around the world. Yiddish is another Jewish language, I think, used primarily by Eastern European Jews and their descendants. I've been told it's sort of a hybrid of German and Hebrew, but I don't know it well, so I can't tell if anyone uses it in the movie.
Omg thank you so much for informing me! I would love to learn the language as I love different cultures and also my German heritage!
Yiddish adopts words from the nations they are in. Today, Yiddish in Melbourne Aust varies from Yiddish in NYC
Interesting! Thanks - I didn't know that.@@jennifergawne3002
Still, in movie a lot of Polish is spoken.
@@arthurrimbaud-ix5tr That is probably because most of the extras are Polish. I don't think there are many Yiddish and Hebrew speakers in Poland
Arguably one of the most powerful scenes ever filmed, and you talked through it? SMH.
I did unfortunately but it still moved me to tears!
@@123giveit You are the best:)))
1. The language is Hebrew
2.The movie is in black and white because the collective memory of the Holocaust is in black and white.
3. The music is by John Williams. Spielberg asked Williams to compose the music to this movie and after viewing it Williams asked "Isn't there anyone else that can do it?" Spielberg said "They are all dead".
מי שהציל נפש אחת כאילו הציל עולם ומלואו 🇮🇱🇮🇱
Whoever saves a single soul as if he saved the world entire
Wow thank you for that! I love learning more about this film and the history it shows
The little girl in the red coat was portrayed by (3 year old) Polish actress Oliwia Dabrowska, who now assists Ukrainian war refugees.
Thank you for that gem. :)
The ending of the film is the real people with they're actor's
Liam neeson should do more film's like this he's a gifted actor
They dont make movies like this anymore
@@jeromemilne561All Hollywood puts out is ridiculous superhero garbage with over the top cgi.
Great reaction Ava like always, everytime i watch this masterpiece of cinema i cry, its so emotional and touching. In case you are wondering or didn't know, the little girl in the red coat was based off a real person. In the film, the little girl is played by actress Oliwia Dabrowska, who-at the age of three-promised Spielberg that she would not watch the film until she was 18 years old. She allegedly watched the movie when she was 11, breaking her promise, and spent years rejecting the experience. Later, she told the Daily Mail, “I realized I had been part of something I could be proud of. Spielberg was right: I had to grow up to watch the film.” The actual girl in the red coat was named Roma Ligocka; a survivor of the Krakow ghetto, she was known amongst the Jews living there by her red winter coat. Ligocka, now a painter who lives in Germany, later wrote a biography about surviving the Holocaust called "The Girl in the Red Coat." That i suggest you to read. And some other facts about this movie is that, Spielberg refused to accept a salary for making the movie, Spielberg didn't want a movie star with Hollywood clout to portray Schindler. Kevin Costner and Mel Gibson auditioned for the role. Im subcribing to your channel, Keep up the good work.
Thank you for that Marco. It's a very emotional film and Spielberg is nothing short but amazing! The girl in the red coat. I must read it or get the audiobook for sure! Thank you for your wonderful insight and for the sub buddy. :) I appreciate you
@@123giveit it was my pleasure I'm a subscriber in a lot of reaction channels and I'm a movie lover I like to know all the fun facts about, so expect more comments about you reactions with fun facts and story's, keep up the amazing work, I'm sure that your channel will grow.
awwww warms my heart! can't wait to chat with you along the way :) Thank you!@@MarcoMM1
Speilger's most personal film because of his jewish heritage and he put all the profit from this film into starting the shoah foundation that films holocaust survivors testimony
It’s definitely a love letter to his history! It shows
Ava, near the end of the film you asked where Oskar Schindler is buried. His grave is in the Catholic cemetery near Mount Zion in Jerusalem. I have been fortunate enough to visit the grave on two occasions, and it is a beautiful resting place befitting a great man.
Additionally, Ava-it is a Jewish custom for a person visiting a gravesite to leave a small stone at the marker, to show that a visit had been made.
Wow that’s awesome. I definitely have to visit some day soon :-) thank you cliff
I see. That’s such a beautiful thing to know :-)
The childrens loaded on the trucks in Plasow labor camp were gassed to death right behind the Plasow city. There is also unconfirmed information that during that process one SS soldier comited suicide because he couldn't watch it.
I see that now thank you for explaining :-)
Thank you for reacting to this. Subscribed.
I appreciate it and thank you :-)
The reason you don't live in a world like that sweetheart is bc of our brave men who went and fought for you to live in a free world. Don't forget that
Thank you :)
If you are interested in the type of entertainment that existed in Germany in the 1930' s then have a look at the film cabaret
Thank you for the recommendation Anthony :-)
Oscar just helped that boy and saved that girls parents and you wonder when he was going to help people. Lol
Thank you for pointing that out!
I watched 5 minutes of this, and the vlogger said something ridiculous already…and after what you just posted…I’m going to stop right now.
Girl still gorgeous. Spielberg shot this in black and white to make it look like a documentary. ❤
Thank you :-) yes it did it’s job and is a beautiful film!
well done for watching, we all learn lessons from history and learn who and what we are and that ordinary human beings can turn on each other without that much difficulty given the right circumstances....movies like this only make me want to learn more and with genocide there is so much to learn but it is very dark stuff...but there is always a light at the end of the tunnel...a great series to watch is Band of Brothers which tells us how it was in WW2..
We do indeed! Human history is terrible and beautiful and I love learning more about it!
Oskar Schindler was buried in Jerusalem and I think a lot of the scenes were filmed near or on the site of the former camp where Schindler's factories were I think.
Yes I would love to visit it some time.
I hope you react to other Spielberg historical film's Lincoln and bridge of spies, war horse
I will definitely put that on my list! Thank you
films
My country invented the industry of death. It is still depressing for me today
It’s a tragic story but tragedy like that has happened many times before in the past.
Yeah ...... i think most of that went right over your head.
how so? I really enjoyed this film and it was very moving!
30:50...the song in the background is a german kids song about a boy asking his mom for a little pony.
Thank you for that :-)
“Speaking Jewish “ how would you like if I said your people speak Hawaii? You would be stunned because that’s an ignorant comment, so don’t be making ignorant comments.
Darling we’re all human I meant no disrespect and if you couldn’t allow yourself to give me some grace then that is on you and on that note welcome to my channel!
while you were snacking on those chips, you missed Schindlers turn to humanity,, typical
Thank you for pointing that out. I appreciate your honesty
“Speaking Jewish” 😂😂😂
You mean Hebrew 👍
Thank you :-)
Ich lebte in Hamburg als ich jung war. I lived in Hamburg as a child. Its a beautiful city. Never mention ww2 while you are there! Best of luck!
Thank you! My great grandfathers from there but i appreciate your advice.
oh
The movie is very strong and sad at the same time, I also cried a lot and it reminded me of the 1984 BBC British movie threads, omg that movie when I saw it I cried a lot and in the end I could see the whole movie but it made me sad deep due to the strong scenes of the film, on RUclips no one makes a reaction video of that film because it is strong or RUclips can delete the video due to the explicit violence, what do you think of all this?
I hope you reply to the message and know your opinion, I am a new follower of your RUclips channel please 🙏🏻
I do think know that RUclips sensors some things that are sensitive as I think they are trying to create a safe space for everyone. I will say this that some things are just real life and in this case the holocaust and the atrocities are historical events that affected the world. I think it’s great that we get to share the story and react to the film on RUclips. Also thank you for your sub and I appreciate you! :)
@@123giveitTotally agree with you in your opinion, The film is called Threads and the film is from the United Kingdom, I will leave some of the history, Threads describes the effects of a nuclear war in the United Kingdom and its consequences on the population of the city of Sheffield , after an escalating exchange of intercontinental missiles between the USSR and the United States, in the context of the mutual assured destruction of the Cold War. The main plot centers on two families from Sheffield, the Kemps and the Becketts, who are facing their personal crises as the Cold War degenerates into open conflict. When war finally breaks out, the characters are forced to fight and survive the health, economic, and environmental consequences of a nuclear attack
If you get to do the video reaction of the movie Threads I will be watching your video reaction, I also wanted to tell you that I love and admire your videos very much, You are very adorable and Kind 🥰💕💫🫶🏻
Yeah, I'm sure most of the Nazis had families to return to, while the Jewish and countless others had no idea if theirs were even alive anymore.
All facts a truly tragic side of war and genocide!
Well, do you have any idea how many dead there were on the German side as well, soldiers and civilians? I don't want to justify or equalize anything, okay? Such a war on your own soil then you know what war means!
Please watch Bahubali movie this is also directed by same RRR director SS Rajamouli better than RRR joyfull
I gave 3 idiots coming out this week :) I’ll check out bahubali on my list
My fav Spielberg film's are in no particular order are
Jaws
Hook
Jurassic park
Close Encounters of the
Third Kind
Duel
Raiders of the Lost Ark
Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade
Bridge of spies
The Fabelmans
The BFG
The Adventures of Tintin
War Horse
Lincoln
I have yet to see some of the films here! Can’t wait to see another Spielberg film :-) thank you for the list
Jews need support, stand with ISRAEL, thanks
stand with Palestine 🇵🇸
There is no such place called Palestine, there never was a place called Palestine. So what exactly are you talking about.
I think you mean Hebrew. I don't know what Jewish means
@@patriciadurr7245 indeed I meant Hebrew
This is one of the most graphic heartbreaking movies ever made, I've yet to meet anyone who was as detached and unaffected as you were. You watched as tho it was a fictitious story on TV, and not the reality it was. You are aware it really happened in ww2? Nazis unfortunately were real and not characters in a video game? And don't talk over the whole movie. Kind of ruins the reaction part of the channel if we can't see or hear what you're reacting to. You have a nice channel but you need to learn to listen and show what you're feeling.
You are aware that she knows it really happened and said so? You did see the tears? Yes, her voice is grating and sounds flippant which makes it a bit irritating to listen to, but unless you know her personally, you're not the one to make a judgement call as to how someone is, or isn't reacting to ANYTHING. Or how they run or don't run their channel. Calm down.
I appreciate your comment and for being here. This movie affected me and moved me to tears. I can only say what I really felt even though it didn't translate to you! Thank You again and welcome to my channel!
9:22 Giggity...
He’s buried in Jerusalem
Thank you :)
YOU ARE NOT THE SHARPIST TOOL IN THE BOX ARE YOU ?
"I'm a slow learner but I learn."
@@123giveit👍👏
Spielberg really had to tone down Amon Goeth as he was truly monstrous and he thought nobody would believe it. Ralph Fiennes who played Goeth took time in between takes to comfort the Schindler Jews on set as his performance and mannerisms were so much like him it caused panic attacks in some of them. If you ever look him up Ralph Fiennes did do a truly amazing job as its a mirror image of him.
The little girl in the red coat was to say about the world knowing about the holocaust but not doing a single thing until it threatened them.
Wow, thank you for that beautiful behind the scene gem. It’s must’ve been so emotional to be apart of that on set.
Speaking Jewish? What?
I honestly didn’t know lol.
@@123giveit Perhaps you meant Hebrew or Yiddish?
Eating during a film about the existence of concentration camps, hunger and extermination is very inappropriate.
My experience watching this film is my own and you are by far way off with your assumption. I appreciate you being here and thank you for stopping by.
Hiiii.... How r u..... Any plans for.... Sardar udham...... Movie????
I’m great and thank you! I’m doing 3 idiots this week which I’m excited about. I’ll check that trailer out
@@123giveit hmm that's also a very good movie... But i will wait for... Sardar udham.... Movie
@@123giveit😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮
More than 3 months
I’m gonna watch this reaction just for the laughs.
Movie is 25 years old, and vlogger says Liam hasn’t aged at all.
He looks amazing these days in his current films and he looks the same in Schindler’s List.
Speaking Jewish? Lol There's no such language.
lol, thank you for that. I honestly didn't know.
Hello
Its only iconic because you can’t tell the difference between history and propaganda 💩
I still appreciate you for stopping by and thank you for your feedback.
"that is like genocide". Duh, that was genocide ... Are you sure of your grand father's past ?
Yup pretty sure!
you mean speaking Yiddish...not "jewish"....its not a language! Talking way too muchhhh!!
Yes, thank you for educating me and I appreciate your feedback!
Amon was the best part from the Movie,, he is the GOAT!
@@123giveit After watching this film, how can you love and laugh at this comment? I just need to understand the disconnect here. You seemed, while watching this film, to care about what was happening. But "ha ha" Amon Goeth was the greatest of all time? I'm so disappointed. This colors how I feel about your whole reaction. I guess, seeing how you feel about Goeth, that you probably won't care, but - - just wanted to share that anyway. Shit, I feel duped. Oh, well.
@@jillk368 omg I misunderstood Amon for Schindlers Jewish business partner. I haven’t really used Goths first name only his last. It was an honest mistake
@@123giveit Ohh. Okay. That makes a whole lot more sense. Thank you for getting back to me with this, it means a lot. I thought it was weird, because you did such a thoughtful reaction - - and then - - okay, got it. Yeah, I guess all the German names can be a bit confusing when watching this for the first time. Thank you again.
@@jillk368 indeed the movie was a masterpiece work and I loved the history. Also thank you for commenting on my video and I appreciate you being here.
Woman, you talk too much
Lmfaaoooo I’m apologies I was just expressing myself 😂
Shhh…….you’re talking too much
Reaction Video?!🤷♂️
He need some milk...
Possibly!
Stop with that voice.. as for that great reaction and good for you for asking about the things you don't know about it.. just stop with the kid on voice
Thank you and I appreciate the feedback
He’s buried in Jerusalem
Thank you for that. I would love to visit someday