In Class With Brian Cox 2018

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024
  • Join us for an exclusive In Class With session with world-renowned physicist, presenter and former rockstar Prof Brian Cox, as he fields questions from students around Australia.
    Do you want to know more about the formation of our universe? How the human brain is linked to the cosmos? What’s inside a black hole?
    With thanks to our friends at Lateral Events.
    Check out more great science content at Cosmos website: cosmosmagazine...
    SUBSCRIBE to our RUclips channel: bit.ly/RiAusYo...
    ---
    ABOUT
    The Royal Institution of Australia is an independent charity dedicated to connecting people with the world of science through news, videos, events and educational resources.
    Cosmos is all about aiming to inspire curiosity in “The Science of Everything” and make the world of science accessible to everyone.
    ----
    Want to inject more science in your life?
    Sign up to our newsletter: cosmosmagazine...
    Join our community on Facebook: cosmosmag...
    Follow us on Twitter: / cosmosmagazine
    Follow us on Instagram: / cosmosmagazine

Комментарии • 615

  • @sparxy1968
    @sparxy1968 5 лет назад +228

    It is his ability to reply to any question without ever talking down to people and helping raise up the enthusiasm for the kids. Can you imagine if all Physics teachers were like him? We'd have resolved many of the worlds problems e.g. energy crisis, grand unified theory of everything and so so so much more.

    • @koitorob
      @koitorob 3 года назад +3

      I had a great physics teacher at South Bromsgrove High School, Doc Evans, and a total twat of a physics teacher, Mr Peters!

    • @haydndavies2475
      @haydndavies2475 3 года назад +1

      Totally agree.👍

    • @andreclay9324
      @andreclay9324 3 года назад +1

      You prolly dont care but does any of you know a method to get back into an Instagram account..?
      I was stupid forgot my password. I love any help you can give me

    • @ayaangrant4948
      @ayaangrant4948 3 года назад

      @Andre Clay instablaster :)

    • @andreclay9324
      @andreclay9324 3 года назад

      @Ayaan Grant Thanks so much for your reply. I found the site thru google and I'm in the hacking process now.
      Seems to take a while so I will get back to you later with my results.

  • @Willam_J
    @Willam_J 6 лет назад +140

    Brian’s enthusiasm for physics is infectious. He gets so excited when he has the chance to talk about it. I love the way he encourages kids to get interested in physics by telling them that THEY will be the ones to answer the questions that we can’t currently answer. Another thing I really like about him is that he always has new ‘material’. There are a lot of great science communicators out there, but they get a little old to listen to because they never have anything new to say. Brian always has something new and interesting to say.

    • @aldito7586
      @aldito7586 Год назад

      Bill. Sorry. But Brian Cox is wrong. A gravity based theory for the Universe just does not work. Only the electric theory for the Cosmos works.

  • @JJ33438
    @JJ33438 5 лет назад +47

    He makes science so interesting! What a magnificent teacher. I love him.

  • @baronvonfaust
    @baronvonfaust 6 лет назад +49

    Rocking the Bladerunner shirt :D

  • @wolfe1970
    @wolfe1970 6 лет назад +407

    Brian Cox literally makes me want to go back to school and get a decent education

    • @andrejpejcic6067
      @andrejpejcic6067 5 лет назад +7

      Lol, indoctrination you mean.

    • @efgtest
      @efgtest 5 лет назад +2

      I think if you start writing your own imaginations you will do much better.

    • @_charliezard_7218
      @_charliezard_7218 4 года назад +5

      Andrej Pejcic you are the lowest form of life

    • @OriginalPuro
      @OriginalPuro 4 года назад +2

      Brian Cox makes me want to go back to school and get a decent education.
      Tip: a sentence ends with a full-stop, a question ends with a question mark, not ending a sentence at all means you have to go back to school.:P

    • @OriginalPuro
      @OriginalPuro 4 года назад +11

      @@_charliezard_7218 Why do people have a need to be rude and attack the person, rather than their comment?
      Have you ever heard the phrase "slander is the tool of the loser"?
      Discuss the case, don't attack a person, it just makes you seem like the rude one.

  • @RaysAstrophotography
    @RaysAstrophotography 6 лет назад +4

    Awesome show Brian & Team. My best wishes to all Aussie students and amateur astronomers

  • @essy111
    @essy111 6 лет назад +33

    This man Brian never seems to age what scientific secret has he got?

    • @sekoivu
      @sekoivu 4 года назад +4

      That's true... he looks completely ageless, although his hair is about starting to get grey.

    • @OriginalPuro
      @OriginalPuro 4 года назад +2

      This man, Brian, never seems to age.
      What scientific secret has he got?*
      It read like shit so I had to fix it.

    • @rryankellyy
      @rryankellyy 3 года назад +2

      @@OriginalPuro You still understood what they meant

    • @johnjohn-cs9eu
      @johnjohn-cs9eu 3 года назад

      "Monkey" adrenal organs. Get with the program: you got RUclips too fhs (for heaven's sake.)

  • @apollombabazi5549
    @apollombabazi5549 5 лет назад +2

    I geatly admire Professor Brian Cox. He is the Isac Newton of our times!

  • @IndranilBiswas_
    @IndranilBiswas_ 9 месяцев назад

    Every time I watch Prof Brain's videos, I learn 100 things and / or better my understanding of something complicated!! Thanks for all the knowledge in your style!

  • @aprilaugust9904
    @aprilaugust9904 6 лет назад +2

    I really admire Brian Cox's dedication, and fun way of answering questions put to him by our budding astrophysicist and scientists! Inquire based education favours and inspires our students.

  • @keithsimon6241
    @keithsimon6241 Год назад

    The way he breaks the numbers down to give us a better concept of how big theese numbers are. Brilliant. Have learned so much waiting for him to tell us where the fountain of youth he found is.

  • @fmlunchbox
    @fmlunchbox 9 месяцев назад

    As an amateur biologist, I love his appreciation for my field. We're both working towards the same goal: understanding. He has such an eloquent way of speaking about all the sciences... I'm such a fan almost immediately. I'm glad I found Brian Cox while he was still alive, lol. I found Hitchens years after he passed and was beyond sad. Two totally different people, but the sentiment is the same.

  • @motif123456
    @motif123456 6 лет назад +5

    Amazing prof brian cox...salutations from india

  • @johnperry5102
    @johnperry5102 2 года назад +2

    that was a very grand production very educational very interesting we would very much like to see more videos like this

  • @sudaknot
    @sudaknot 4 года назад +1

    i could listen to brian cox talk about physics allllllllll day

  • @w00fw00f
    @w00fw00f 4 года назад +13

    Me: What day is it?
    Brian: "Now thats a good question!"

    • @OriginalPuro
      @OriginalPuro 4 года назад

      I would ask which day it is(not "what" day..) and Brian would reply, as per usual, that it is a good question.
      Also, don't make a sentence into 3 lines of text.

  • @colpward
    @colpward 4 года назад +1

    Opened his mind while at and after uni

  • @akuma2892
    @akuma2892 5 лет назад +8

    Thoroughly enjoyed this!

  • @freijnichols
    @freijnichols 3 года назад

    I could listen to him all day😊

  • @ljgarrison6910
    @ljgarrison6910 5 лет назад +16

    Scientists try and disprove theories, this is why their theories become well established facts. Brian, you are a legend and still a rockstar matey

  • @tantiwahopak101
    @tantiwahopak101 6 лет назад +2

    18:20 if we can somehow measure the circumference then we should know the distance from centre to event horizon. Or is it more complex than that?

    • @christophersorensen9580
      @christophersorensen9580 5 лет назад +2

      Well that's what he was saying, since it is so unimaginable dense, the way that it warps space-time itself makes it so that, what we see as the circumference from our position may be skewed because of the warps of space time, the way light bends around it, ect. So we measure the circumference as X, but in reality the space-time that is warped on the inside of the blackhole could be Y. We simply don't know.

  • @easyamp123
    @easyamp123 5 лет назад +2

    There should be way more views on this

  • @Deynora
    @Deynora Год назад +1

    This is Sheldon with social skills :) love it

  • @zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz9
    @zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz9 Год назад

    Such great questions. Well done to all. Well answered, too.

  • @leeplayford6188
    @leeplayford6188 6 лет назад +3

    Absolutely brilliant as usual , love you coxy.

  • @bozenasamek480
    @bozenasamek480 2 года назад +1

    Nie znam niestety języka angielskiego. Chciałam tylko powiedzieć że przeczytalam Jego dwie książki które zostały wydane w Polsce. Bardzo gorąco Go pozdrawiam. Od dziecka interesowałam się Kosmosem. ALE niestety nie skończyłam studiów z astronomii. Ale Bardzo mnie interesuje astronomia . Pozdrawiam Briana Coxa i czekam na nowe wykłady.

  • @RPKGameVids
    @RPKGameVids 2 года назад

    BC has a very soothing voice.

  • @jossbelle5137
    @jossbelle5137 3 года назад +4

    He literally looks about twenty five how is he double that

  • @alberteinstein1452
    @alberteinstein1452 5 лет назад +3

    I have that same celesteon telescope in the background of the video. Nice. SCIENCE

    • @kendavison5
      @kendavison5 5 лет назад

      Albert Einstein nexstar 8se?

  • @berndkemmereit8252
    @berndkemmereit8252 3 года назад +1

    Love the book from Carl Sagan on the shelv...

  • @sb9889
    @sb9889 6 лет назад +2

    Is that a Celestron Nexstar 6SE

  • @johnperry5102
    @johnperry5102 2 года назад

    i very much wish i could have become an astronomer
    Mr. Coxs is a grand motivator

  • @coisalinda2424
    @coisalinda2424 6 лет назад +5

    Nice 👍🏽

  • @M.C.Escher2018
    @M.C.Escher2018 6 лет назад +1

    Is a Star Gate possible?

  • @mansubbasnet8500
    @mansubbasnet8500 6 лет назад +1

    Can you please ask Brian cox about curved part of spacetime

  • @CrispyBaked
    @CrispyBaked 6 лет назад +11

    Seems like Brian was talking to a different camera most of the time. Come on editor dude.

    • @EpicSlaxGuy
      @EpicSlaxGuy 5 лет назад +3

      Crispy Baked it’s called B-roll and it adds dynamics and interest to standard interviews u walnut

    • @danoliver3053
      @danoliver3053 5 лет назад +1

      @@EpicSlaxGuy In your opinion...

  • @matthewfisher-sp5fq
    @matthewfisher-sp5fq 19 дней назад

    I think Arthur .c. Clarke said that the centre of Jupiter may be a massive diamond? .I like it when Brian and Jim get together on RUclips . With the moon being nearer to us than Mars wouldn't it be better to try and Colinnise the moon.😊

  • @marajaded2051
    @marajaded2051 3 года назад +1

    "When Brian Cox talks, just shut up and listen." - Mark Twain

  • @mikebellamy
    @mikebellamy 2 года назад

    Prof BRIAN COX ON LIFE FALSIFIES THE BIG BANG
    1. When speaking of the chance origin of life Prof Brian Cox said the following
    2. _"All it takes is a system far from equilibrium with a flow of energy and a spark"_
    3. What he did not say was what he actually meant by _"far from equilibrium"_
    4. What he meant by "spark" is a random improbable event favouring a molecular replicator
    5. But _"far from equilibrium"_ in thermodynamics means in a state of *ORDER*
    6. That is from one state of *thermodynamic order* some energy may be directed to create more *order*
    7. Directed energy in thermodynamics is called *work* but its creation is inefficient producing heat
    8. Therefore the former state of order is always greater than the latter state of order it may create
    9. That means the work which created the former state of order must have come from a higher state of order still
    10. Such a regression must stop at an original state of maximum order consistent with a creation and the second law
    11. The Big Bang creates a state of *HIGH DISORDER* as indicated by the smoothness of the CMBR (equilibrium)
    12. The Big Bang is falsified as a violation of the second law of thermodynamics. Q.E.D.

  • @joedanero5360
    @joedanero5360 5 лет назад +1

    Brian Cox and Rodney Mullen need to do a series or at least one hangout. Skateboarding and physics go together like wine and cheese.

    • @bigniper
      @bigniper 5 лет назад

      Joe danero
      Damn you must be good if you can do Physics Experiments while riding a Skateboard. As for Cheese and Wine, Love Cheese but hate Wine.

  • @traceysayar7523
    @traceysayar7523 6 лет назад +1

    awesome

  • @michaeloderda4513
    @michaeloderda4513 Год назад

    Too many commercials couldn't finish

  • @controversialchristian2378
    @controversialchristian2378 6 лет назад +1

    Professor Cox, is it possible to see Uranus without a telescope?

  • @sonicrising6614
    @sonicrising6614 5 лет назад +2

    Why would we try and bring back Mars' atmosphere instead of trying to prevent the destruction of ours?

    • @hueytlatoani1177
      @hueytlatoani1177 4 года назад +1

      @SonicRising: Because we're humans, we're stupid.
      We know that smoking is bad for us, but we do it anyway, same with alcohol and drugs.
      When I say stupid, of course I mean who is doing it.

  • @yourmuwantssum8886
    @yourmuwantssum8886 5 лет назад

    I think considering how big the universe is there most probably is life out there maybe unusual types of life forms or possibly humans just like us they could be life more advanced or less or planets full of strange animals but it is very likely to have life out there which we could never ever know seeing how far apart there are

  • @Brian_ON
    @Brian_ON 2 года назад +2

    Brian could read the dictionary to me and I’d find it interesting.

  • @mikedavis1084
    @mikedavis1084 4 года назад +1

    He is as cool as Carl Sagan

  • @lanr67
    @lanr67 3 года назад +1

    The farthest point from a point in space is the point itself?

  • @Mom_sBasement
    @Mom_sBasement 2 года назад

    Brian: I could answer your questions if I had google.

  • @libertybellgaming6551
    @libertybellgaming6551 3 года назад

    Where did you get the Barnett done mate? I fancy a 70s haircut 😄😄

  • @srijunair
    @srijunair 3 года назад

    Is black hole is actually the high concentration of black matter?

  • @redmed10
    @redmed10 3 года назад

    Light waves or particles of light?
    That is the question.

  • @401files4
    @401files4 5 лет назад +1

    This interviewer is like the David Brent of the science world. He asks Brian a question, gets his answer, not quite happy with the answer he starts giving his own input. 🤦🏻‍♂️

  • @teachnaduinn3134
    @teachnaduinn3134 6 лет назад +2

    Blade runner Top, Image of Unicorn in paper.

  • @bozenasamek480
    @bozenasamek480 2 года назад

    Chciałabym być studentką Briana Coxa. Pdziwiam go i mamy

  • @HENRYFOLEY
    @HENRYFOLEY 5 лет назад +1

    So maybe we are the alien's and other civilization's are looking for us, will there be any chance of any contact in any form ?

  • @venkatbabu1722
    @venkatbabu1722 3 года назад

    Do Usually black holes have spiral spawns on different planes. Billions of unseen galaxies is what is black hole is it true. The larger the unseen galaxies the larger the black holes. Merge is a cross over section of galaxies.

  • @hendrixtimestwo
    @hendrixtimestwo 3 года назад

    10:28 - A public service announcement from Brian Cox.

  • @L1VE3V1L
    @L1VE3V1L 10 месяцев назад

    I want a telescope now.

  • @jaridwilliams739
    @jaridwilliams739 6 лет назад

    wew this lad like a young henry cavil damn

  • @BOSS_MOTO
    @BOSS_MOTO 5 лет назад +1

    The way the interviewers accent fluctuates is worrying haha

  • @timytimeerased
    @timytimeerased 4 года назад

    Too late Brian, I did electronics underwater, didnt went well !

  • @djflossy9508
    @djflossy9508 2 года назад

    i wonder how many kids have been electricuted since watching this video jeeze

  • @malcolmscrawdyke1868
    @malcolmscrawdyke1868 5 лет назад

    Good to see greater lesbian visibility in the media.

  • @Pobsta-de7hb
    @Pobsta-de7hb 2 месяца назад

    Arr way back when Brian was only 50 lol No but seriously he is still so much older than he looks

  • @vinnytaranova6163
    @vinnytaranova6163 6 лет назад +38

    Brian is so enthusiasts about his interests and his oratory abilities are fun to listen to because of it.
    Great science communicator.

  • @sergiozdrums
    @sergiozdrums 6 лет назад +132

    I love how Brian expresses and explains the ideas

    • @janinasimons8533
      @janinasimons8533 5 лет назад +1

      +Sergio you have watched too much idiot box.... this pretty boy, cant give you any evidence only theories, maybes etc.... and he is in for a very rude awakening as are many others..
      There is history, archology, real science not this pretty boy tv stuff..... and bottom line,,,, you cant make something out of nothing.... if you could these great scientists instead of talking would be making new planets to live on .... but no all they do is talk and theorise and have no proof... SAD that people have stopped using their own brain...

    • @TheFatSteez
      @TheFatSteez 5 лет назад

      Janina Simons Hey Janina, just wondering what makes you think he should be able to create new planets?
      Edit: Name typo

    • @janinasimons8533
      @janinasimons8533 5 лет назад

      @@TheFatSteez What an interesting comment, but maybe it was for James not for me.....better repost for James :)

    • @slylataupe1697
      @slylataupe1697 5 лет назад +2

      Janina Simons : you are way to harsh on the boy! Brian has legit diploma in physics and he is very good for simplification of concepts for the profanes like me.

    • @thegiantpumpkin5903
      @thegiantpumpkin5903 5 лет назад +1

      Janina Simons What’s this “rude awakening” then fucktard? By the way, your use of punctuation is unsettling, please learn to type English properly before criticising someone.

  • @kaydavis5796
    @kaydavis5796 6 лет назад +83

    Brian's charm is probably even more than his considerable knowledge. He's a joy to listen to and learn from.

    • @DylRicho
      @DylRicho 3 года назад

      @Pil Gor "Kath David" seems to have an issue with science. They have been posting toxic comments all over this video.

  • @istvantoth7431
    @istvantoth7431 5 лет назад +36

    Such a great lad! Funny to notice that even adults enjoy the answers to questions asked by children. You gotta love science!

  • @PaulSteenOriginal
    @PaulSteenOriginal 5 лет назад +12

    I LOVE these questionaires! They really put things into perspective. Thank you Brian and Alan for being so clear, and thank you to everybody who makes these things happen ♥ :) Hope I can be part of it soon!

  • @Lithrilla
    @Lithrilla 6 лет назад +28

    So in about 5 minutes Cox managed to teach me stuff that schools have tried to teach me for years.

    • @RealParadoxed
      @RealParadoxed 2 года назад

      The best teachers can summarise an answer

  • @TheDjackso1
    @TheDjackso1 5 лет назад +12

    Great questions. Good to see science is alive and well in australian schools

  • @montaguemetal3416
    @montaguemetal3416 3 года назад +7

    As always, Professor Brian Cox continues to make science totally accessible to the public, from school children through to Adults with any level of knowledge. For me it's his enthusiasm about science in general that is so captivating and ensures that you really want to listen to whatever he is saying when he talks.

  • @MilesColtrane.
    @MilesColtrane. 5 лет назад +7

    As people here might have already experienced, listening to Brian Cox talk and explain things is a great pleasure, he’s so brilliant at explaining things and giving so much inspiration.
    I just bought his book called “Why does E=mc^2?” And oh my god, it’s so good. Reading him is just as good, might even be better. I definitely recommend that book to anyone interested in relativity, it’s amazing...

  • @abshirkhalif5376
    @abshirkhalif5376 6 лет назад +12

    brilliant prof brain

  • @markwilliams9600
    @markwilliams9600 3 года назад +6

    Brian Cox you are awesome 'i love your passion and excitement for the universe that we live in! I also appreciate your simple explanations about the things we do and don't know which makes it easier for people like me to understand! Thank you for all your hard work and you are and always will be a legend 👌💪👍

  • @ririyuri7290
    @ririyuri7290 4 года назад +5

    Is there a bad question in the universe?
    Bc: Well we actually dont know but that is a good question

  • @Thomes-Maisling
    @Thomes-Maisling 5 лет назад +3

    I was going to say take a shot every time Brian grins, but actually fuck it he never stops grinning just down the fucking bottle now.

  • @charmerwatt1329
    @charmerwatt1329 3 года назад +3

    How often does Brian polish his face?

  • @HeyItsKora
    @HeyItsKora 6 лет назад +10

    Question two was absolutely fantastic. I love kids for the brilliant original questions they ask!!

  • @3DLL.
    @3DLL. 6 лет назад +83

    The bloke is a genius

    • @sherlockholmeslives.1605
      @sherlockholmeslives.1605 6 лет назад +1

      Me too!

    • @sherlockholmeslives.1605
      @sherlockholmeslives.1605 6 лет назад +2

      Lol! Having said that, I am a poor reader.

    • @c.j.2272
      @c.j.2272 6 лет назад +3

      haha hes nothing but a bellend!! total bullshit! but you just carry on sucking up that shit mate!😂😂

    • @DarrenSaw
      @DarrenSaw 6 лет назад +1

      Johnny yuma Fuck off flattard, you aren't funny or clever.

    • @sherlockholmeslives.1605
      @sherlockholmeslives.1605 6 лет назад +4

      Brian Cox may even have a higher IQ than I have!

  • @gregoryduggins1069
    @gregoryduggins1069 6 лет назад +24

    One of the greatest teachers.

  • @tristanp1983
    @tristanp1983 3 года назад +3

    The questioner's accent is an incredible mix of Aussie and, I think, Northern Irish!

  • @zezumi1120
    @zezumi1120 2 года назад +4

    One thing I love about Brian is there is no dumb question to him, and that he constantly acknowledges how great these questions are! Regardless if he's answered the question many times, his answer always feels personable because of his acknowledgments!

  • @rickquest6385
    @rickquest6385 4 года назад +5

    You nailed it Brian! (one of my favorites)

  • @Bob-ep2sv
    @Bob-ep2sv Год назад +1

    Just realised Brian is wearing a Blade Runner shirt - what a legend!

  • @garyjaensch7143
    @garyjaensch7143 3 года назад +2

    Forget the science , why can’t you see the shadow of Brian’s head?

  • @saimounikasudula1747
    @saimounikasudula1747 6 лет назад +4

    Thanks for this good quality of questions. I'm glad you didn't just ask about Aliens.

    • @Jonixx95
      @Jonixx95 5 лет назад

      saimounika sudula thats what we humans want to know more xD

  • @swapnil3845
    @swapnil3845 3 года назад +1

    I'm straight, but these two gentlemen make me weak

  • @essy111
    @essy111 6 лет назад +3

    How on earth can Brian Cox have the answer to some of those questions.

  • @ninjanerdstudent6937
    @ninjanerdstudent6937 2 года назад +1

    That makes sense for people too. Obese people live considerably shorter lives than thin people. Stars are a lot like people.

  • @Lyonessi
    @Lyonessi 2 года назад +3

    Brian's character and his attitude to physics is what keeping the child in you alive looks like. What an inspiration.

  • @adamjohnston5250
    @adamjohnston5250 2 месяца назад +1

    Isn’t it time people like Brian cox where household names and heroes , instead of sleazy footballers

  • @cheebaroni_5173
    @cheebaroni_5173 4 года назад +3

    I’ve learned more from Brian cox than I’ve learned from anyone else in my life. This stuff kind of consumes me now.

    • @johnjohn-cs9eu
      @johnjohn-cs9eu 3 года назад

      Can you list 3 things you've learnt please?

  • @kitersrefuge7353
    @kitersrefuge7353 6 лет назад +4

    "Arrrroiind" == Around.

  • @WAN0N0
    @WAN0N0 5 лет назад +3

    Very kool guy with great ideas and explanations. 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

  • @leightonmacmillan3396
    @leightonmacmillan3396 11 месяцев назад +1

    I love how he can speak proper England. No "like", "you know", I'll just go ahead and", "umm...um, like, ya know, really", "goin" instead of "going", and all the other moronic speech affectations one hears today, even from commentators. Illiteracy is rampant. He speaks with confidence, clarity and enthusiasm. I'd still be going to school if I had professors like him.

    • @alexwilson2268
      @alexwilson2268 10 месяцев назад

      Well said, mate. Wish I knew more people like you.

  • @MrMunk89
    @MrMunk89 5 лет назад +3

    Wish it had danish subtitles, so my son could try to appriciate this knowledge.

    • @widjadija
      @widjadija 5 лет назад +1

      MrMunk89 if you know danish you can add the subtitles for him

  • @paulbultje9740
    @paulbultje9740 5 лет назад +2

    could quasars be a "teleporting" dumping point for the singularity in a black hole?

  • @ADANTHEGIANT
    @ADANTHEGIANT 3 года назад +1

    “In principle” - used to indicate that although something is theoretically possible, it may not actually happen
    Notice how he says this about supposed accepted scientific narrative...hmmm