Spark Vs Katana - Which is The Best Practice Amp?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 июл 2024
- Positive Grid Spark vs Boss Katana 50Mk2. Which is the best practice amp for beginners? I look at these guitar practice amps side by side and compare the features, apps, and tones.
Looking to buy one of them? Support the channel by using one of the links below:
Spark: bit.ly/2GeBlXI
Boss Katana 50Mk2: midlifeguitar.com/BossKatana5...
Use a looper with the Katana: www.zombieguitar.com/using-a-...
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
0:44 Feature Comparison
8:13 Tone Comparison
11:11 Final Thoughts
_________________________________________________________________
🎸 THE GEAR I USE 🎸
► ACOUSTIC GUITAR: Seagull S6 Original - midlifeguitar.com/SeagullS6
► ELECTRIC GUITAR: Fender Stratocaster MIM 2015 (now player series)
► AMP : Boss Katana 50 MK2 - midlifeguitar.com/BossKatana5...
► MIC 1 : Shure SM57 - midlifeguitar.com/ShureSM57
► REC INTERFACE: Focusrite Scarlett Solo - midlifeguitar.com/ScarlettSolo
► CAMERA : Canon SL2 - midlifeguitar.com/sl2 
Видеоклипы
I own the Spark still, but used to own the Katana. Katana is a very good amp and I'd suggest it for anyone on a budget that can only own 1 amp and wants to gig with it. If you want a variety of tones it can't be beat. I also own the Fender Champion 50xl and if you like the Fender sound (they try to model other brands too) and want something simple I think it's really good.
Now the reason I kept the spark...It's a great practice amp because you can leave it just about anywhere and it blends in well. Nobody would think it's anything but a nice Bluetooth player if you don't tell them. It's also plenty loud enough for home practice. I've had it cranked not even close to full volume and it rattled the windows. It's not a toy. If you want to, you can absolutely make your neighbors angry hah
IMO, if I were starting from scratch I'd get the Spark and once I knew what kind of music I wanted to play, what brand I liked, I'd get a tube amp. Unless you are getting the spark does everything you need for home playing. If you're playing solid state it's the only amp you need for most people, at least to start. The only real negative is that it doesn't have an effects loop. That doesn't bother me one bit and I think most beginners shouldn't even worry about what that is for a while. But there are some people that will complain that they can't use their pedals because there is not an effects loop--which most practice amps don't have anyways. To me the beauty of the spark is it has a lot of tones, but it's still pretty easy to lock in on ones you like and leave it at that.
Agree with all of what you said there, thanks for the comment!
Hi Roger & Midlife Guitar - Couple of questions. I'm looking for a practice amp, and the Spark looks good for that. Most of my practicing would be done with headphones and I'm wondering if 1) the Spark has stereo effects (delay, reverb, chorus) and 2) if there are stereo effects, are they stereo when using the headphones.
I do own a Katana, which works fine, but doesn't do either of those things. I used to have one of the Mustang III amps, and the stereo sounds were glorious (I miss that)! Thanks to both of you for the comments and the review!
@@anotherheadlessdemo I haven't looked at the manual or anything, but it sounds stereo in this vid. It also has two 4" speakers. I would guess it has stereo delays, but idk about the other fx. You can also check out the new fender mustang amp. More expensive than katana and spark, but comes with a footswitch and has a diff sound judging from the yt vids I've heard.
Hey! I also own the Fender Champion 50xl, and I’m really interested in the spark amp. You think I should sell the champion 50xl to get the spark?
I"ve got a Spark and a Katana MKII Studio and for just practicing the Spark is much easier to get any tone into. It's so much more work with the Katana due to needing a computer to swap out presets. Sure I have more switchable slots for sounds in the Katana but in a few sec I can search and DL a new tone to the Spark. However I bought the Katana as a future gigging amp that really excels combined with the optional Boss floorboard to switch sounds or swap FX categories on and off. Plus the Katana's power amp input works great for sending in a different modeler (such as Line 6 Helix Stomp) straight to a super-clean, high volume channel. Both Spark and Katana can get some similar sounds but I see their roles differently.
Thank you for the informative demo I just pulled the trigger on the Spark amp. I've been playing for over 35 years and think it's a great tool to learn songs and write. I subscribed!
Thanks for the vid.. I need a new practice amp and have been tossing these two amps around. Your vid was great but even better was the comments People wrote which really helped a lot. Thanks again for the great video, much appreciated.
Just my opinion and experience: I can appreciate what everyone's experience has been with these amps. As a gigging musician for years, I have some amazing amps and pedals that I use out. But when I'm at home, I don't necessarily want to set all of that up to practice. I played the Katana in the store and wasn't that impressed with it. The Spark on the other hand has inspired me to practice more. Alot of folks are complaining of the "grounding" noise while not playing, which you would and do get using the real rig setup. The Spark app allows you to tweak and configure whatever amp and pedal combo you might want, which includes (as i did with my gigging rig) adding a noise gate pedal on my Spark pedalboard, which took care of the "grounding" noise. The Spark lets you try out some very good simulations of high end amps and pedals for electric, bass, and acoustic guitar (which can all be individually knob tweaked to your taste) at a great price, you are able to practice with tons of prerecorded jam tracks as well as search your favorite songs and figure out that lead lick that's been driving you nuts by looping that section of the song and/or slowing it by .5x and gradually increasing the speed until you are able to play along at full speed, AND you can do it all without waking your family or having the neighbors call the cops on you! The Katana seems great for someone wanting to play around with a few different tones and have a small venue/back up amp, but the Spark checks all of the boxes for a great practice amp that actually inspires you to play and improve as a guitarist.
Thanks for the input, I’ve been curious about how people are handling the ground issue on the spark and if the noise gate worked, your comment gave me clarity.
That was long
I really appreciate this feedback on your experience with the Spark. I'm a beginner and want something that will not only get a lot of different sounds, but also encourage me to play and learn. Spark sounds like the ticket. 👍👍👍
Nice feedback, you gave me a lot of clarity on the "grounding noise" thing, thanks a lot
My spark is powed by à 18v milwaukee drilles batterie, no noise and i practically not used thé 120 v ac power and wireless!!!!!!!
Best gear review I've seen. Honest,
clear, comprehensive, concise, cuts
the B.S., and gives a verdict ! Thankx,
Great job mate !
I'm 45 and I've been playing for fun for a long time but mostly acoustic. When decided to go electric I went to a couple of modeling amps and settle with the Katana because I can use it without an app. Just plug and play and get great tones. My previous experience with modeling amps and downloading apps and sounds was a little bit overwhelming. I guess both are great amps but I love the simplicity of the Katana.
That's awesome! I find the spark even easier to be fair. You can play around with tones on both though to make your heart content.
I own the Katana MK 100 and the Spark and after the honeymoon phase with the spark, I find myself using the Katana more again. I love the simplicity of it and not having to deal with an app to get the sounds I want.
Fair enough, it does sound great 🤘
I bought the Spark 40 but it malfunctioned right out of the box while updating the firmware. Seems like they would do that at the factory. I'm not happy with it so I'm sending it back and buying a Katana, Orange Crush 35RT, or the UGLY Yamaha Thr5. I don't need 7,200 tones (that's 7,150 hair-splitting tones) and I don't want to have to use an app.
I to had a none functional amplifier spark out of the box never worked as a guitar amplifier.i had a false fix and ran past 30day return time now they are refused to refund my money
@@silverbushman You'd think with all the competition out there, including companies with such rich pedigrees as Boss, you'd think Positive Grid would want to help out thier new customers. I'll stick with my Boss.
@@timdouglas620 they are trying to avoid the manufacture problems and make it seem fult of use...
What a great post. Great info for any beginner but especially for us older beginners who think that part of the phone is being able to emulate the tone of the song you're trying to learn. Thanks to all those who gave their opinions on the Katana. That's the next amp I think I will get. But after a few days I've changed my mind! Ordered the Spark after all.
Glad it was helpful!
Nice to see a beginner ( like myself) doing a review for a change.
I have both and have been playing guitar for about 30yrs. Had the katana first and love it but to get certain tones take time. The spark changed everything. Just push a few buttons on your phone or tablet and dial in every tone you ever wanted! The spark is amazing!!
Thanks for a nice review and comparison. The Spark needs a few things before I further consider it.... 1) battery power, 2) stereo speaker out, & 3) additional XLR input for mic or recording.
Great review. I was looking for a solid comparison and this was it.
Been playing 25 years. Love my Spark!! So easy to use, sounds awesome, and can't beat its value.
Thanks for the review. I purchased a Spark through your link.
Thank you, I appreciate it and I hope you enjoy it 👍
Thanks! I’ve had both as well and I’m really enjoying the spark. I’m also in the same boat as you - started playing guitar just over 2 years ago at 40 years old and I’ve jumped all in. Tons of fun.
Agree, the Spark is so much fun that the Boss isn't getting much attention at the moment 😂 Sounds like you and I have a similar story with guitar, it is addictive once you get in to it!
Im 55 and just started in April 2020 made sure something good to come out of COVID memory’s. I’m obsessed with playing and determined to get at decent. About 400 hours in since April. I’m sure there’s many of us out there. May all of you have a great journey. My heart thinks bigger is better , but if I want in living room and make my wife happy it would be the spark.
With the Spark - I had humming on all channels it drove me crazy. I reached out to their customer service and they sent me a new plug. This has fixed it. If you are having the same issue, I encourage you to do the same.
Amazing. The exact video I was hoping to find. As someone who hasn’t played electric in years and is getting back into it I haven’t been able to decide on which of these to get. Leaning toward the spark before watching this. Now let’s see.
I am like you, going back into playing after about 50 years, I own the katana 100 watts single speaker, what an unbelievable sound, the power adjustment is a great feature, you put it in low power and play at home when everyone is sleeping and it sounds clear, warm and doesn't inconvenience anybody, if you want to be heard then 50 watts and if you are in public the 100 watts, also you can download all kinds of stuff etc, if you are really serious to be a good player the katana will give you everything you need to get into it and a lot more. There is a believe to always go small to learn, if it is the first time playing and you may drop out then yes limit yourself to cheap guitar etc, but you know what you want and is to develop that skill again and not to find yourself stuck in a low level situation because your purchase wasn't the right one, so good luck and go for the Katana is a high quality amp with a beautiful sound at a very very reasonable price and for almost limitless capabilities. Good luck and wish you the best
Purchased and am waiting for my Spark to arrive!
The suspense was killing me
Lol
Thanks for the video,mate!
Eric
Hey Eric. I ordered the spark and got it in 5 days. I love the amp. Great for practice and playing with backing tracks. Have not done any recording. But looks straight forward
Very thoughtful review. I went with the Spark and the only drawback I find is the inability for a Line Out. You can use the headphone jack but when the sound guy at a venue hands you a 1/4 inch plug you better have the adapter or the look on his face when he has to mike your amp is not pleasant.
Much more flexibility with the Spark. The backing tracks are good practice and you can play along with almost any song as it feeds you the chords. But the real power is the downloadable tones. Almost any sound you can think of is in there.
I have both. I prefer the tones from the Katana, but like the "practice" and ease-of-use features of the Spark. If I were to have just just one: Katana.
I’ve had my katana for a few years & I absolutely love it. I just ordered the white spark amp on preorder, Just for what the hey.
I tried both and ended up going with the Spark, mainly because its more portable and functions as an acceptable bass amp. I actually think the Katana sounds better, and would probably recommend it over the spark if it was going to be your only amp, but you can't beat the spark as a portable practice solution.
Great review thank you!
I use the Katana at home on the .5 watt setting, volumes just under half, and I am very happy with the sounds I get, clean and crunch. To get the same crunch/rock to metal type of sound on my tube amp requires many pedals and more volume. I love'em both, but I like the Katana at home.
The .5 setting is already mad loud. As an absolute beginner I thought it would be a very low volume when i bought the amp. In reality, I have not even used the 25 or 50w setting, except for a bit of fiddling to see how loud it goes and even then I didnt dare to crank it up. I live in an apartment so this .5w setting is ideal for me.
Hello. Thanks for the review. I have just bought the Spark to play around with at home.
Good choice! Hope you enjoy it.
I agree with your summary. The spark has a lot of great practice features, the heavy base sound is bad though (better with headphones) and the Bluetooth connection never works without a lot of faffing about. The Katana (100 in my case) is terrific too but less geared towards practice features and absolutely fine for gigging.
Difficult to evaluate tones because limited to the device used to view the video. Analysis of features is very valuable. To tell the truth, I need a practice amp for practice. If in the future I need an amp for performing, can go the $ for another amp. Good analysis. Enjoy and appreciate all your videos. Kudos and thanks.
Great review thank you
Great review, thanks for posting.
Thanks for watching!
Another mid life beginner here (2 years now !) for anyone reading this please please just start with an amp like the katana or spark . I spent way too much on a tube amp and pedal board before finally realizing all I needed was a damn Katana. The katana is amazing.
Great to hear you are similar in experience to me. I have yet to go down the tube amp path and explore it but from my experience keeping it simple when learning is key. There is plenty of time down the road to explore tones.
Yep, well said.
@@MidlifeGuitar Wife would hate it, but can always try something like the blues jr or monoprice/harley benton amp (has other brand names too idk offhand). They're a diff beast, and I feel like a tube amp snob. I knew you didn't use traditional tube amps when you were talking about the bass on the spark and katana as something like a fender tube amp is super mid rangey. Btw I have a spark and katana. Both are great!
@@MidlifeGuitar a great alternative to the tube path is a roland blues cube I own a few valve amps plus modellers yhe blues cube is very organic feeling. Gigged it a fair bit brilliant
The spark is great only really lacks battery option
For my needs, the Spark is awesome. I can so much tones with my Charvel with Seymour Duncan P-Rails and the Spark alone. There is a footswitch in the works for it too!
Owned both. Both are great. I kept the spark though and sold the Katana. Only reason being the Spark is smaller and looks better in a living room setting which is what I wanted it for. The Katana is a more versatile amp you could use to gig. However I already have that and it wasn’t what I was looking for.
A really nice video!
I think I will also go for the Spark, I have been playing acoustic for 4 months now and I have promised myself an upgrade when it is my birthday and have delivered enough sweat.
Currently level 4 Yousician.
Also a mid life giaar hero - 46 in March
Go for it!
Great job! Thanks!
I have a line 6, 1- 12 spider 40w valve, a vox valvtronx 40w and Spark. Can’t practice at home with the line 6 to loud, the vox is limited on configurations but the spark is exactly what I needed. I have become a better musician with all the app options. I play worship at church this last Sunday, first time using the spark in a live setting. I miked it, it was outstanding, our church meets at a memorial hall we have no monitors I could hear my self no problem and only had it 1/8 volume. Love the sounds you can create with it.
I already got the Boss Katana mķ11 50 and i wont regret it. For me it sounds amazing and it has the tone and featurings that i need. I already ha a tuner, i also got a metronome and I wanted a fearly easy amp for home use..and maby in future for gigs. I can get almost any types of tones with it...plus the brown sound witch a famous sadly gone guitarist made famous for, thats a setting that no other amps got...as long as you dont get the real expensive EVH amp.
Comparing the Spark with the Katana Air would have been a better comparison, but I still gave it a thumbs up because you gave good sound comparisons.
While i agree theyre more similar amps as far as features the air has a hefty price at over 450 bucks where the katana 50 and spark are under 300
Ive had the Spark for about 3 months and its so great for me just playing at home.I've been playing for 30 years and since I've had it I have been using the Spark probably 80% of the time.It is just so easy to get so many sounds on my phone.Of course if I want my tube sound I go to a tube amp that I have but so much avalible on the Spark.Also It's been 5 or 6 years since ive used my desktop so the Katana is no use for me
I settled on the Yamaha THR 10ii W which also is a brilliant choice for a desktop size modeling amp. Brilliant review!
Nice one! I would like to try that out.
Have this one too and like it a lot, great option for desktop amp!
Excellent and honest review. I've owned and gigged with the Katana and to be perfectly honest it's far too fiddly with stuff I'd never use, thousands love it but not for me, far happier with something more simplistic like a Fender Blues Junior or Pro Junior for a live environment, rather have a more straightforward platform and add pedals. Totally agree with your thoughts on The Spark for home use, aesthetics are important in the living room and The Spark does have a cool look and looks to have excellent features too, I will certainly be checking it out after watching your review, other great amps worth looking at exclusively for home use are The Yamaha THR, and Blackstar Beam.
So much brilliant gear these days but guitars, amps etc are all down to personal choice. Very informative channel. Stay safe. Stu
Whenever I use my katana I'm just on the crunch channel using it as a blues jr basically with a boosted/slightly overdriven tone.
I love where the guitar industry is at as far as amps and modeling software. No more hauling heavy , expensive equiptment anymore. I can literally bring a Hss strat, my ipad, a cheap interface and some cables and get whatever sound I want at the tap of a finget
You dont need cables anymore
@@maxs.5163 you dont even need a guitar anymore
I ordered the spark a long time ago couldn't wait to get it, now it sets on a shelf.
☹
can I have it?
Wanna sell?
I finally started using it. Got a mini jackson guitar so I can sit in a recliner and play without a full size guitar taking up more chair than me. I got sick and have cancer and can't stand up and play anymore. The little guitar and the spark keeps me playing where I don't think I could if I had to use anything else. It helps keep my sanity now and gives me something to think about other than the pain. It just seemed like a gimmick at first but I love it now because I really use it now.
@@alanshadyvally glad u like it, cant wait for
Mine! Hope you get better btw!
Call me a luddite but after the initial excitement of exploring modelling amps I've found myself more often returning to my Vox Pathfinder 15 and Pignose! They're two great sounding amps that I can just plug into and play without having to think about options, options, options!
really neat video man!
Glad you liked it!
The Spark is cool, but the sound of the Katana is a lot better to me. I own one and I love it. Lots of value for just over $200 US. BTW I’m 67 and took up guitar last winter and I am really enjoying it. It’s a lot different than the drums I have been playing for 50 years lol. Wish I had started years ago! Nice review.
Thanks, I agree it has a slightly better sound overall but it is just the ease of use of the Spark that wins it overall for me. Great to hear you picking up the guitar, your timing is probably excellent having played the drums. I am really working on it at the moment using a metronome.
Various drum issues in a amp doesn't interest me. I'm happy with available built into them. Set it and forget it LOL.
From my end boss sound is far superior.
I agree
I have the spark and I can assure the boss sounds way better.
@@beardedrancher I had a spark and got rid of it. Its just a cheap shitty practice amp and the tone is horrible.
@@adelaidedrummer I don't the the crunch tones are too bad and it has some cool features but they should've just spent some time on the cleans. It's just not up to par with the other stuff thats out there. The bugera v5 costs about the same and is way better on the clean tones. I just use mine as a Bluetooth speaker now for the most part, but I'm working on trying to dial something in.
The spark sounds like dog water. Literal ass. Katana massacred it.
We’re in a golden age with all the awesome gear available nowadays for not a lot of money. I’ve been playing for 20+ years when I was a kid and back then everything was crazy expensive and sounded bad unless you had a really good tube amp. Same with guitars. Now after years of having GAS (gear acquisition syndrome) and collecting nice pieces of gear I find myself using a Katana to practice for it’s simplicity of use. Take advantage kids.
I have enjoyed my Katana 50 for over 2 years now and have to say it has been my favorite amp since I sold my Peavey Speciqal 130 back in the late 80's. My only regret is I wish I had the foresight to have purchased the 100 watt Katana because of the pedal loop feature which the 50 does not have.
use a looper?
Great comparison. I’d love to see how the Fender Mustang GTX compares as well. The Mustang seems to be the best of both worlds... Bluetooth and simple app interface for customizing like the Spark, but takes pedals and has a looper like the katana, spring reverb, and even XLR outputs. I’m just not sure if the tones are as good as the Katana and Spark.
I'm 48 and don't gig out, just play at home. I have the Katana 50 Mk1 and the Katana 50 Mk2, connected by a Radial Big Shot ABY for wet/dry. Big and solid sound, and loads of features onboard. The Spark was interesting for a few minutes as I watched, but I'm already pretty covered for most things.
I heard so much hype about the spark however being a vintage valve type of guy I ignored it for ages, I mean how could a solid modelling amp touch a Marshall 62 blues breaker or even an orange tiny terror etc... but they did such a good marketing campaign ... well... I bought one just to see what all the fuss was about. it cost me about £260 inc a free bag (be aware the price shown online is before tax)... I've had mine about 2 weeks now and im blown away with how good it is.. it does have a trillion shite settings online etc.. its no way any good for a show even if its a small gig.. no line out apart from headphones.. works great with headphones but you can't put it through a cab etc... but for what it is.. a small practise amp with loads of sounds and a few extra fun things play with...its great.. no its brilliant ... I was so doubtful and thought if nothing else its an audio interface for getting ideas down with a DAW... trust me for the price you won't regret buying one (takes 3 weeks to arrive though.. not good) and if for some reason you do sell it on eBay as I've seen them going for £300 with no bag (cool bag as well would cost £40 separately)... don't get me wrong if your after an amazing tone this is great but it scant compete with a real valve amp with kt66's at full volume but it will give you a very close alternative without taking the roof off your wigwam... id give it 95 out of 100 for sounds and fun but 99% for what it basically is... a small lunchbox amp with great sounds and loads of other fun stuff... I should be getting paid by the amp makers for such a nice review I think but I doubt they really need my help to sell them.. peace, wils
If you put the Spark through a Electro Harmonic 44 via the headphone jack you can put in through any guitar speaker cab. The EH 44 has an output of 44 watts so going through say a Marshall 2x12 cab or 4x12 cab the setup would be plenty enough for gigging.
I own the kat and the regular spark and also mini spark,I would choose the kat over the others for pure sound and simplicity.The sparks are great but very muddy and struggle if you push them a bit with overdrives/distortion/fuzz even if you trim the bass and gain.The kat feels more like a real amp where the spark feels like a practice tool that is extremely easy to use.I also feel that the built quality will mean my kat will be around a decade from now still going strong where I get the idea that the spark will be long gone by then.Both are amazing for different reasons.
I have the boss katana100 MK II and love it. For the money it can't be beat. It's a amp beginners can afford and stay with you once you get good enough to gig.
Im an older beginner also and find this video and channel extremely useful and interesting, keep the videos coming its appreciated
Thanks, will do!
Midlife Guitar oploå
Waiting for the spark. Play for my own enjoyment and non judgemental friends and family. Having access to different amp tones and some pedal sounds should make playing more fun.
Spark shipped. Harley Benton arrived today. Life is pretty good.
@@kompst are You enjoying it?
thanks.great info
Glad it was helpful!
I pretty much agree with your thoughts on these two amps. I currently have a BOSS Katana MKII, 100 watt for practice and small gigs and I love it! I tried my friends 'Spark 40' and fell in love with all its features making it the perfect home practice and recording amp. So, I ordered one for myself and look forward to using it and the Katana both. If I could only own one amp, it would be the BOSS Katana as it is powerful enough to play small to medium gigs. I don't think you can go wrong with either amp.
Excellent review. I have been looking for a new practice amp. Had a Roland Micro Cube, it was awesome, will always be sorry for selling it. Roland doesn’t make the 40xl with the looper anymore, dang. I’m practicing with a Fender Mustang, it’s ok, but not great. I’ve been considering the Vox Mini Go 10 & 50... both have input, mic in, aux in, phones, looper (45 seconds) & foot switch jack. THEN I stumbled upon this Positive Grid Spark amp with lots of positive GOOD (pun) reviews, it’s lightweight, easy to use, and looks like a really FUN practice tool and amp. Think I might be leaning towards the SPARK now.
My Spark had a bad speaker and then it died. I just didn’t feel like they deserved a second chance considering I gave them more than a year to work out their QC issues. I was really enjoying it, but it is strictly a practice amp, so I ended up being glad to get the less expensive Katana. Something about the 4” speakers always bugged me, but the sweet 12” speaker in the Katana is a winner IMO. What I found with the Spark was that despite all the cloud sounds, I really just preferred to always use one or two of my favorite sounds, so so don’t miss having a thousand options (although I do still have BiasFX plug-in). I do miss being able to switch tones from my phone instead of having to go to the amp, but truthfully, I should probably not be switching that often and practicing more instead. So for me Katana is a clear winner because it is about $40 cheaper and has a more professional speaker. I doubt I’ll ever play out, but it is nice to know I won’t need to buy another amp if I do.
Spark for practice, Boss for gigging. Spark's features make it a lot more fun. Your playing is coming on at a great rate btw.
Yes! That pretty much sums it up! and thanks for the compliment 👍
It’s simple, if you are in a budget and starting off with the hope of joining a band or jamming with friends then it’s a katana. If you just want to get lay at home by yourself then the spark. If they put a speaker out on the spark that could change everything.
I practice sets at home just as I play in a band so I need a foot controller for channel switching
The katana 100 head is perfect for this, plus I can use it live too with the same settings, you're right about the tone studio it's a bit of a faff, the spark sounds fantastic
I think it's a fantastic product
It's all horses for courses
Great video, just to say since this review SPARK have updated the firmware that adds an EQ so that gets rid of rhe bass-heaviness and a footswitch for those needing it.
Thank you!
I don't have either one of these amps. I've been playing acoustic for about 1 1/2 years and use a 12" Kustom for that. I've recently started playing an electric 3 months ago which is a lot of fun (Sultan's of Swing is quite an advanced lesson to learn!) I have a 10w beginner amp for that but am I'm leaning towards the Spark since i'm still a beginner.
I'll give my opinion ... my Katana 50 is now unplugged and will stay that way. I love my new Spark.
I have both. I'm always interested to hear what newer players think of them. A lot of vids on which one is best, but they're at a price point where they're both worth getting.
I tried a friend’s spark and it was an absolute noise fest, any amount of gain and it was just a mess. The power supply doesn’t have a ground, so I assume that probably has something to do with it. Is that your experience though? I see all these people raving about it, but it feels unusable to me, makes me wonder if they are all just being paid.
Can you plug the spark into the aux of the boss?
@@awothers72 maybe he got a lemon? I heard the quality control on the spark was iffy.
@@awothers72 mine came with a grounded plug. I think the first run came ungrounded
@@awothers72 Spark is more a gimmick vs a guitar amplifier. The sound of positive grid is more like an expensive radio vs an amplifier. Spark chord play along doesn't match the
song chords I find 50% of the time. The Spark software only runs on Apple or Android for most home users in this age is not realistic.
Positive Grid needs to develop a windows client. Katana is more like a guitar amp vs Spark is a bluetooth jukebox.
Really enjoyed listening to your commentary. English isn't my first language but its really easy to follow and understand the way you speak. I might just learn and use your technique for work presentations! But also your playing has clearly progressed. I can see that you're holding the Justinguitar A major chord! Nice one man. Thinking about getting the spark amp.... mmmm maybe during Christmas time to see if there's any discount on offer... Thanks again for a really good video! Enjoyed that!
Glad you enjoyed it! Never thought I would help someone with their work presentation by doing this 😂 but that is awesome! It's a great amp so if you go ahead I would love to know what you think 👍
You lied about your English not being very good man!
I just picked up a Spark. Very happy with it. I don't feel like the tones shown here are real accurate to the quality it achieves. To have so many effects, amps, everything to play with, you are going to find a sound you like. It's also very inviting to play. I've had it for about a week now and I can't stop playing through it. Excellent practice amp. (I'm not sure I'd ever gig with it) But I'm sure if you really wanted to, you could.
I think you a right. Recording guitar is very new to me and I haven't been playing very long so I don't show what the amp can really do. The point of this video was to determine the best practice amp but most comments I get focus on the tone only and miss, in my opinion, what is most important to a beginner, that being how it can help you learn.
Can you hook the spark up to the PA for a gig?
I got my spark 40 and wireless foot pedal yesterday for the reason to perform with, I can fly out/travel with a small footprint and got a mini jack to 1/4 phone jack cable to go direct from headphone out to console
Own the Spark. Used to own Katana 100. My main amp is a Vox. I used the Katana and now the Spark in the living room as a practice amp when the office is occupied by my wife. I prefer the Spark because of its size. I also like the fact I can control it from across the room. The Spark sounds good but I do think the Katana sounds a little better and a lot louder but for my purpose the Spark sounds fine and is less obvious and more suitable for my purpose.
Both good. Really depends what you are using it for.
Thanks for the Side by Side comparison. Really helped in seeing the features and the sound quality when you played the same riffs! Thanks again from this Older Newbie!
I'm diggin' the Spark. I like the size of the Spark & every time I hear it in a recording I'm not disappointed. All this did was make me realize I need to ditch my first electric and get something better so I actually play it :D I still want to see the Spark play more in depth with acoustic.
It's a great amp Rich, highly recommend it. What 's wrong with your current electric guitar?
@@MidlifeGuitar just a cheap Epi that doesn't sound good nor is really inspiring. It works, I'm just not that in to it like I am with my acoustic.
Can't wait to get my spark amp. I'm a beginner so I won't be gigging anytime soon, if ever lol.
It's a lot of fun!
I like the spark because you can access a bunch of amps, pedals/effects, as well as tones directly from your phone with a app it’s easy and convenient unlike using a pc which will require major storage for the katana effects.
I like the spark in every way except for the tones. That's a big bummer, I would most likely buy one otherwise.
Thanks. Now, after this Video I will take the Spark. It Sounds much better and has more posibility I think.
I have already the Spark mini and it Sounds awesome.
Good to see you back Luke. Perfect topic as I have been looking at the Boss lately. It’s weird the Spark never got suggested to me; very interesting product thanks.
Thanks Nico, I think either is a great choice but the ease of use with the app means the Spark wins out for me even though the sound of the Boss might be slightly better to my ears.
Midlife Guitar the size is a compelling point too
Lots of hype going on for the Spark. It was ok , had a lot of features..... but I returned mine .
I'm still hesitating to resell it... It's muddy as hell! Very bad as a BT speaker, too because of this muddiness. Mayne mine is a lemon. But I saw that some people replace the speakers by Hi-fi car spakers to get clarity.
I have both. Katana is superior in every way.
Spark is good on a coffee table or in an office. It's not a real serious amp.
Spark is also buggy and can’t be depended on. Katana has been out for like five years and is on v2, and is a stable platform. Spark is more for beginners, not adult musicians IMO. It is a cool gadget though, and I love the BiasFX engine-the Spark platform is just not up to snuff.
Nice review. not too long, just right. One of each: a Katana for me, and a Spark for my neighbour...
The integrated Bass feature on the spark makes it my choice. I have a Bass as well, and whole I don't play it much, it's fun at times, but I don't want an extra amp in my small apartment. The spark can do it both, although the Bass feature obviously isn't too great, but good enough to actually hear what you're playing.
What is the bass feature? Does it make your guitar sound like a bass?
@@Rockandrollgeerage no, the spark amp has a bass modeler. usually you would need a different amp for your bass and guitar
I had the boss katana and giged with it and it was amazing it was only on 25watts and it was loud enough so me personally would go for the boss katana
Great video ! Just out of curiosity how did you capture the sound from both amps ? What's the wiring involved ? 😊
I connected them direct in to the laptop using USB leads. You can record this way or there are others that I talk about here ruclips.net/video/kEaj8Pgj0oM/видео.html
I never went the Katana route and jumped straight for the Spark as my new practice amp. I'll be growing into it, but I love the amp thus far. I just wish that the grounded power supply would arrive and my promised bag.
Well that was a great choice as there is just so much to it that you can explore. Hope you get the replacement power supply and bag soon.
@@MidlifeGuitar I hope so. I have used it to create a few videos (using it as an audio interface, 3 things I don't like and a quick video about the app (subscriber requests mostly)) but otherwise I am leaving it until I get the proper power supply for the UK. I have been waiting a while though and starting to get a little impatient and cannot wait to get into the amp properly. Especially for when learning songs.
BTW - Congrats on your channel. You seem to be getting some great traction at the moment off of the back of some great videos, really well thought out and presented.
@@SypherLXVII-MySixStringJourneyYou could try a laptop charger that might work? forum.positivegrid.com/topic/4085/hum-problem-and-power-supply-specs/13 and I left a message on your video about using the ASIO4All driver that might sort out your low level audio issues. I can understand the impatience and hope it gets resolved soon. The channel has leapt up a bit recently, thanks for the compliment. Trouble I find is consistency of uploading as it takes time to make videos and when I do it takes me away from playing.
@@MidlifeGuitar Thanks Luke. I had read about the laptop charger lead and some people have also suggested simply plugging the amp into a laptop via a USB lead to ground it. However, PG said a couple of weeks ago, that they would send me a new grounded power supply and I would prefer to use their officially supported supply if at all possible. Hopefully it will arrive soon.
I did try several of the drivers but only the ASIO driver seemed to work for me. I do not recall seeing or trying the ASIO4ALL driver, so I'll have to give that a go later today. Thanks for the heads up on that. I'll let you know how it goes.
UPDATE. I got the new power supply and it has made all the difference. So pleased with my amp now.
I have a before and after video on my channel for anyone else that gets the hum/noise issue.
Gee…I have the Spark and was getting ready to buy a Katana…until I saw this. Thanks! Great post / analysis!
Nicee new video! I was wondering what had happened to you cause I hadn't seen a video from you in a while lol I figured you were busy. Thanks for the video bud
EDIT: i see your barre chords are coming along a lot better lol niceee! Mine are getting better also! I just need to learn more songs
Yep life got in the way a little 😂 and these videos take a bit of time to do for me. I find barre chords a lot easier with the electric, transitioning between them and some chords can still be tricky though.
@@MidlifeGuitar yess i feel you. If its moving the chord around its fine but changing the shape of it I tend to stumble. Well great video as always and look forward to the rest!
Good video buddy.looking to buy but poor as dirt,so again,shopping around I guess.one day,BUT THESE DO SEEM TO BE THE TWO BIG RIEGHING CHAMPS..
Is there a way to control how much "gain/sound" is going into the direct USB line. Basically do i need to have the speaker's really loud if i want to get a decent input signal on garageband (for example)? I've seen videos of people not receiving a loud enough signal when going directly into a DAW.
I have a spark and love the thing. I tried the katana and loved that too but the spark to me was just the better amp. Also buddy the Hendrix tone you pulled in with the spark was not one of the better ones. But hey man thanks for the great video.
That Hendrix tone is digital sounding crap
Very useful review, especially for recreational players. In my opinion, you touched some really good points. Beginners or not so advanced players (who would I summarize as recreational players) are really not interested in getting the perfect tone of a particular amp (they don’t even know), nor do they care about any particular pedal. It is about practicing with an acceptable tone not the perfect copy of original sound (which often is not possible without ridiculous efforts). So looking for a good matching tone in a cloud database will do the job. As you explained, in this respect, the spark is superior...at least for now👍 The jamming option is also perfect for beginners. From the examples, I would prefer the tone of the spark. Thanks 🙏 PS:I am not sure whether you guitar was really tuned when you played the examples (in particular with Black Bird)
Thanks I agree, most people commenting here were concentrating on the tone rather than the overall features of the amps for practice from my (late) beginner perspective.
I just purchased the spark amplifier. What appealed to me is an all in one solution to practice. The online features for sound and genre selections is outstanding. I’m a bass player, 40+ years. I’ve always they’ve done playing the guitar but never dove into it. I learned to play back in the 70s by ear sheet music and a 12 inch vinyl album that you wore out! This is a great concept to make learning fun. Some of the posts I’ve read site issues that this amp is not designed for. It’s not in my opinion in and you’re going to take out in gig with the guys! It’s a learning tool. It makes learning fun and encourages you. You learn at your pace your speed without the inconvenience of trying to get in front of a teacher every week. I think it was well worth the money and serves the needs of a novice or beginner. I would highly recommend.
The katana head would be a better comparison as it has a built in speaker for practice. It’s actually surprisingly good sounding!
I think I have to slightly disagree at 4:57. I think it's super nice as a beginner to have a bit more raw access to fiddling with sounds so you know what any presets could actually mean. I think, like you said, it's important for you to not necessarily focus on that too early and let it take time away from actual practice, but getting a feel for how each setting changes output is part of the learning process imo. Maybe im a katana fanboi... idk
Spark 100%! It's really hard to find a music mobile app without bugs and that is stable. But not only that, it's very feature-rich. Creating tones, jamming, even has a tuner and metronome built in. I can tinker around with this thing literally all day long and never get bored or tired of it. And you cannot beat the price for this level of excellence.
Thanks! Great video ,,Do I need to subscribe to be able to use all the tones with the Spark40?
🤘
Good review. Just bought the spark for a student of mine. PS you are playing Blackbird the hard way.
Spark sounds like the guitar you hear post-production. Katana sounds like an amp.
Thats how I've always felt about the Katana. Definitely doesn't make me want a spark then!
I own both. The tones and capability on the Spark are awesome but it wasn't loud enough to really play with an enthusiastic drummer. So I just connected the headphone out of the spark to the MP3 in on the Katana ( I have the gen 1) and wow! Suddenly I think it is plenty loud for practice and probably for small gigs. Hell if you mic it you could gig the Spark by itself but this is another solution.
@Howardsend88 On a video I would agree. In person , the Sparks Reverb is freaking amazing. The Katana's is OK but there are issues with the Spring reverb. What you always have to remember is that tone hounds are not the typical audience. The audience will be happy if the sound is "close to the radio version".
As for the Katana...It's a really decent amp that I can feel just fine about leaving in my car all day at 15F and fire right up without having to worry about thermal issues with tubes. It's cheap enough that if someone stole it I wouldn't be heartbroken or broke. I'd just go buy another one and load it with the same tones I backed up from the first.
I now own a Spark which arrived a few days ago. Already owned a Katana 100 MK2 with GAFC.
At the super low volume I need (talking volume) the Spark is way better. I also actually find it easier and quicker to get a good tone whether using the app or the panel.
The Katana is a great amp if you play at louder volumes and plan to gig especially with the GAFC, but for super low sensible volume the Spark is better for me. Even in 0.5w mode I can't get a decent tone from the Katana unless I crank it up to the point where it's too loud for home use. Katana will be on eBay this weekend.
I have both and both are great - yes Katana is capable of gigging, but the spark is easier to get great sounds happening straight away.
Spark Smart James still needs a bit of work. I give it a -1 versus 5 for Digitech Trio