World's leading legal EXPERT on GENOCIDE gives his opinion on ISRAEL'S WAR in GAZA.
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 сен 2024
- If you enjoyed the video, do like it and share, thanks! Feel free to subscribe to the channel as well!
William A. Schabas is a Professor of International Law at Middlesex University, London. He is also a Professor Emeritus at Leiden University and the University of Galway, and an invited visiting scholar at the Paris School of International Affairs, Sciences Po.
Recognized as a leading expert on international human rights law, international criminal law, genocide and capital punishment, he is the author of more than 20 books and 400 journal articles on these issues. He is also Editor Emeritus of Criminal Law Forum, the quarterly journal of the International Society for the Reform of Criminal Law.
Professor Schabas was a member of the Sierra Leone Truth and Reconciliation Commission. He also worked as a consultant on capital punishment for the UN Office of Drugs and Crime and drafted the 2010, 2015 and 202 reports of the UN Secretary-General on the status of the death penalty.
A short note on subtitles (in Spanish)
The project "Viva Palestina Libre-Subtitles against the Occupation" collaborates by preparing the Spanish subtitles of several of the interviews. These are usually added 2 to 3 days after the original interview is uploaded. Every time the subtitles of an interview are available it is announced on their instagram account (@viva_palestina_libre). On their blog you can find all the subtitled interviews: memoriapresent...
If you enjoyed the video, do like it and share, thanks! Feel free to subscribe to the channel as well!
✅️
Nice move is this man working working with Navi Pillay, I knew he would start with Bosnia, currently there are only a few cases out there in regards to genocide.
As someone who was in that conflict 91 to 93 , genocide law is limited and tricky.
As I have said to many orgs UN and courts the same thing
In the name of Allah, we invite you to worship Allah alone, so say: I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. These words make you a servant of Allah ....... ..........
Por favor, solicito comedidamente subtitulado en español. Muchas gracias desde Bogotá, Colombia!🥰
esta manana.
@@farydeneme4716
Genocide is taking place and the US who is the only party which can bring a stop to the genocide is complicit due to its inaction.
In the name of Allah, we invite you to worship Allah alone, so say: I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. These words make you a servant of Allah ....... ..........
Oh the US is taking action,its giving them the weapons.
It isn’t just inaction, it is active participation with US taxpayer money. I am livid!
Not just inaction, but US weapons are being used against the civilians in Gaza!
Why must you bring up the names of God? It is written, that God has many names-The Great Spirit? Let's demonize them too? @@Iris-lh7rf
Excellent measured, calm, factually based discussion. I hope this case is taken seriously and goes forward through the courts. Thank you!
Lies and his court case will fail
Excellent discussion, thank you both.
In the name of Allah, we invite you to worship Allah alone, so say: I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. These words make you a servant of Allah ....... ..........
I get pissed when people talk about this like it's some complicated thing. It's looking at Israel's actions, and looking at the definition, and whenever an action corresponds to a criteria of the definition, you check that criteria. If a sufficient number of elements of the definition of genocide are met, then you call it genocide, because it is genocide by definition!!
Exactly
It sure is the g word.
Thanks for your expertise and for speaking up. The world needs honesty and justice.
There are lots of definitions. There is only one correct one.
@@TariqRahman-dt3hn The funny thing is I'm not an expert. I literally just looked up the UN convention on the prevention and punishment of the crime of genocide. And it is not a complicated thing. The complicated part of proving genocide in court--I hear--is proving intent. Luckily for us, Israel has done that for us with all of its genocidal rhetoric.
Thank you both for this discussion.Thank you for understanding the pain of Palestine people .God bless you.war crimes 💯
Thank you for your courage to stand up for humanity ❤
This is the easiest case for genocide ever to be brought before a court ,most israeli officials have said it many ,many time on camera .
It is a strong case and the easiest case to take before a court. Lawyers sometimes fudge the issue but a skilled, honest advocate can make the case. And win.
The purpose of the genocide convention is PREVENTION - allowing UN members to take action when there is a clear possibility that any aggressive action by a State may lead to genocide. Whether a case can be proven or not is irrelevant, the crucial point here is to prevent it in the first place or to stop it if it has already begun. That is what the members of the UN have responsibility for.
Exactly right.⭐ @@valtracey6180
Wrong
Delusional. If it was genocide there would be no Palestinians right now.
Attorneys are a trip. I appreciate this one making an online appearance and answering Frank's interesting questions. Also appreciate the answers that gave clues on how Genocide is viewed, treated & discussed in his circles. Its actually eye opening and indicative of why all the serious crimes continue today, not just in Gaza, but worldwide.
The legal industry within the UN is an EPIC FAIL & needs deep reform towards lasting widespread peace.
In the name of Allah, we invite you to worship Allah alone, so say: I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. These words make you a servant of Allah ....... ..........
The resolutions aren't binding and there isn't an international force capable or willing to enforce the UNs judgments. They can be full of Johnny Cochranes and Chuck McGills, it doesn't matter if their rulings cannot be enforced...
I haven't the stomach to listen to that!!
@@Iris-lh7rf your religious beliefs are your right, but keep them to yourself and your religious community. I like many people have no inerest in hearing about it unsolicited!
@@Iris-lh7rfReligion is a very personal thing - it has no place in politics and even less in governance. You have been indoctrinated in one, I in another, and the rest of the world in many more. I won’t inflict my beliefs on anyone else and I would respectfully ask that no one tries to inflict their beliefs on me.
If we all think we are right, then the only certainty is that we are all wrong.
Excellent video👏👏👏♥️♥️♥️ and free Free Palestine 🇵🇸♥️🇵🇸♥️
Biden stated that Israel should stop indiscriminate bombing. However, he also said that he will not stop it.
Biden should not be funding genocide and with the American taxpayers' money. We the American people, do not want this!!!! Not in our name!!!
Biden is talking out of both sides of his ass. He is the ENABLER of this Genocide. He gave them the bombs, ffs!
No, because he wants Hamas cleared out just as much as Israel does, but he wants Netanyahu to take the wrap for it. Fall on his sword etc
But it is clearly getting very uncomfortable for him.
The Big Guy is stupid, there is nothing indiscriminate about IDF bombing. Specific targets are hit, every time.
If it’s targeted how can it be indiscriminate.
We all see what Israel is doing! Unbelievable that they have been allowed to commit this genocide. My heart breaks for the people of Gaza
Did the hamas propagandist mention that 7 members of Hamas were just arrested in Europe for planning terrorists attacks in Germany Denmark and the Netherlands
because you do not admit the wrongness of Oct 7 massacre and the remaining civilian hostages taken by hamas
@@gemmalee3032Palestinian genocide started 75 years ago by racist oppressive settler colonizers, don’t act like this just started Oct 7!!
I watched a video on Novara media,it showed idf thugs setting fire to a truck full of water and food for people who need it badly! Despicable war crimes,should be getting sanctioned not applauded!🏴🇵🇸
Thank you for inviting this great MAN! This man is BRAVE!!!
On the side of Palestinian people. On the side of conscience and truth.
on the side of Arab settler colonialist and Islamonazis
viva Palestine
on the side of BS
Why is your guess slandering Israelis? Baseless claims and accusations. I guess he is allowed to lie as much as he wants.
Always.
Are there any implications for the US after Bidon describing the bombings as 'indiscriminate' given that indiscriminate bombings are a war crime?
Very interesting and sober discussion. The suggestion of not getting bogged down into a discussion about whether or not this fits all the legal criteria of a genocide and focusing on the fact that Israel is clearly committing legally liable war crimes is an interesting one. As is the suggestion that the US is clearly failing in its obligation to prevent genocide.
There is a case pending against Trudeau too. Canada has a navy...we could send food and aid. We could take a lead diplomatically, but he has done nothing while allowing Canadian weapons to be sold to them. Certainly Canadians have told him enough times.
Well it meets the criteria of genocide, but I don't know if it's genocide. That's what listening to him talk about that is like for me.
Viva viva Palestina.
The ICJ ruling in the case of Bosnia and Herzegovina vs Serbia was a joke. A lot of evidence that was used in the Milosevic trial wasn't used in the case of B&H vs Ser. Serbia was very much involved and complicit. In May of 1992, Serbia's military formally left Bosnia and Herzegovina, but weaponry and men were left there, they just changed the emblem on their uniforms. Besides, Serbia organized paramilitary forces, sent their own special police forces, sent weapons and money, helped mobilisation to the formally Bosnian Serb army, which was really Serbia's army. Serbia was paying wages and later also pensions to soldiers and officers. It was a very clear cut case, which was partly botched by the Bosnian side, and the ruling was partly political, because it would have been too costly for Serbia due to reparations that Bosnia and Herzegovina would have the right for, which could push Serbia closer into the arms of Russia, instead of European integrations.
Also, I believe that the term "ethnic cleansing" was coined in relation to the war in Bosnia and Herzegovina, mainly because the international community didn't want to use the word genocide, because then they would be obliged to act, or at least lift the embargo on weapons import and allow the Bosnian government and army to arm themselves and be able defend their country and people. If that happened, I wouldn't be in diaspora now, and several members of my family and friends would very likely still be alive.
Thank You For Sharing 💯🎯🙏🏼👍🏼
World is still sickening
@@tayibahussain It sure is. What's happening in Gaza is worse than Bosnia and Herzegovina (if we objectively and by numbers measure things), and we're all seeing it happen live. And those who have the power are only interested in status quo. A few days ago, there was a headline about the US whatever office being concerned about rising settler violence being a danger to stability. Their idea of stability is Israel going from 100,000 illegal settlers in the occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem in 1993, to 700,000 today. Permanent occupation, dispossession, apartheid and massacres is stability?
The world & courts are currently run by weapons salesmen. They don't want talk about Genocide ending their guaranteed income stream. Lotsa bodies still walking the planet, so lots more to order. The more I learn on international legal views the sicker🤮 I get of the Dominate-the-World jokers of the West. I see why they are also called Predator-class🤑
Correct all of that was planned and implemented in Belgrade.
Just imagine what Israel would be screaming and saying if someone was doing to them, what they are doing to Gaza.
❤
Excellent discussion and meeting of both of you men here, first time viewer of your channel. Boy do I look forward to the February ICC case against Israel with anticipation!!! Thanks, subbed.
I hope this video goes viral. Your guest speaks truth to evil and it is greatly appreciated.
Thank you Frank for bringing this gentleman with knowledge and experience. He has been very thorough and clear. Thanks to him.
You don't have to be an expert to see that's what exactly is happening
You have to be an idiot to fall for Hamas propaganda
As much as I agree with your analyses in terms of Srebrenica and Ukraine, this time around I find it extremely hard not to characterize it as genocide. Not just in the colloquial use of the term.
At the highest judicial levels the deicision as to whether something is genocide or not is likely to be a political decision cloaked in legal rationale.
excellent interview.
In the name of Allah, we invite you to worship Allah alone, so say: I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. These words make you a servant of Allah ....... ..........
@@Iris-lh7rf be forreal tho.... how much does Israel pay you to troll? 😂
Thank you Mr Barat. Your voice of humanity is very important.
We don't need an opinion. We need action to stop it.
Kudos, gentlemen. A very informative discussion. 🙏❤️
SOS Gaza children and babies died no food no water many poeple died.poeple of usa stop this War please please
Nethanyahu made a clear reference to the Palestinians as Amalech.
#Nuremberg
Justice for Palestine.
The EU, the US and all complicit governmens must be held responsible.
All war crimes and crimes against humanity, against the indigenous people of Palestine since 1947 must be taken to ICC.
Balfour Declaration must be taken to ICC.
What kind of nonsense are you talking about? Are you high or something? What EU and US would be held accountable for? For not bombing pallies? Yeah, they should drop some bombs on gaza also. You really do talk just like tiktoker. All words that dont make any sense. Genocide, occupation, war crimes, crimes against humanity. Indigineous people? You mean the jews? Because before the arabs occupied that land, it was Judea. So you should be happy that arab occupiers are being kicked out and indigenous jews are coming back?
Free Palestine
Frank, your interviews are very good and contribute a lot of wisdom to the conflicts from Chile, thank you for this wonderful program
Best talk on genocide from a genocide expert
Thank you for educating us all
Very very informative about law to us, American's and Israel'es are above the worldly law.Will they ever ever ever be penalised. God only know's. Thank you both for the important dis ussion, may god bless both of you.
In the name of Allah, we invite you to worship Allah alone, so say: I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. These words make you a servant of Allah ....... ..........
Excellent interview
In the name of Allah, we invite you to worship Allah alone, so say: I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. These words make you a servant of Allah ....... ..........
huh? wtf is that! Go away, I'm Egyptian and I'm sure I know about Islam more than you do, & no thanks I don't want your invitation, and Palestine isn't an Islamic struggle, go away and don't spam the people standing with Palestinians with your crazy shit. @@Iris-lh7rf
The world has failed Palestinians ppl. All focus now on Gaza, but there is ongoing crimes in west bank against civilians including children.
Thank you for taking concrete steps. Your efforts, weather victorious or not are essential. ❤
Here is someone who knows the truth but doesn't want to get fired. Frank missed an opportunity to get more from him.
Why is he so reticent to conclude it's genocide? If you use the UN convention on the prevention and punishment of the crime of genocide. Intent is clearly established, and Israel's actions meet 2 of the 4 acts, that constitute genocide. Actions calculated to bring destruction in whole or in PART, and killing or inflicting psychological harm--among other things--in whole or in PART. If you can't see that the sufficient conditions for the UN convention on the prevention and punishment of the crime of Genocide have been met, then it really calls into question his expertise and credentials as a lawyer. It's seriously so clear by law. What the hell is going on here? It's not even a nuanced example of meeting the definition of genocide. Just so clear.
Maybe, because winning at court is not about justice prevailing but about “convincing” the judges.
Then there are“arm twisting” and threats behind the scenes to take into consideration
He's reticent and rightly so, because it is bad actors within countries that have to be accused of crimes against humanity, not whole nations. All your bluster is based on emotional appeal, which of course no-one working in any reputable criminal court anywhere would demonstrate. In your desperation to paint a whole nation as war criminals you conveniently leave out the real evil in the room, which is a medieval death cult called Hamas and the 70% of Arabs in Gaza who recently stated their support for the atrocities carried out on Oct 07th. Stuff that up your emotions.
Agree 100%.
I call into question his motives.
Second Intifada and 10/7 among countless other Palestinian attacks on Israel are by the same definition considered genocide.
The Russell Tribunal on Palestine session held in Cape Town in 2011 found that Israeli government conduct towards Palestinians meets the international legal criteria of apartheid as a crime against humanity in terms of the Rome Statute 7 (1)(k). The RToP session in New York in 2012 found that Israel was engaged in "incremental genocide". The RToP session in Brussels in 2014 confirmed that Israel's war on Gaza met the criteria of "war crimes". This year's 2023 Israeli genocide in Gaza has clearly and deliberately intended to kill 2.3 million Gazans by bombings (supplied by the US), starvation and illnesses.
Thank you Frank. How about SWIFT sanctions against Israel (IL) banks to suspend all financial transactions to and from Israel until the Israeli government agrees to a ceasefire and negotiations with Palestinians, including Hamas? SWIFT as you know is headquartered in Brussels, and falls under the jurisdiction of Belgium -- with the Belgian government having already called for sanctions against Israel.
Thank you for this interview. These experts give hope in times where we have no or little hope.
Among the horrific images coming out of Gaza, are images of children and babies who have required amputation of damaged limbs, something that, if you can even survive without adequate aftercare (sanitary conditions and antibiotics to prevent deadly infections) will leave.these.children (estimated at over a thousand so far) permanently disabled. My question is who, or what entity, will be responsible now for their care as disabled children,? Many are also orphaned by the indescriminant bombings. Since the supply of bombs comes from the US, making the US a facilitator of this brutality, isn't it the US who is obligated to support and care for these victims? Maybe the US also.has earned the responsibility to take care of all the survivors of this ethnic cleansing atrocity?
Who will put pressure on the United States government?
🤷♂️
Excellent conversation and informative. Thank you.
Everyone should please watch Chris Hedges"THE GENOCIDE IN GAZA "
In the name of Allah, we invite you to worship Allah alone, so say: I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. These words make you a servant of Allah ....... ..........
An excellent video, I've watched it twice. I think having been there on numerous occasions including standing at the Raffa crossing this time, he can bear witness to what is going on far better than these two who are only viewing it through a tick box of criteria lens.
@@judithmackay7158 yes that's true and it dives deeper into the truth and reality of the issue...He makes you understand that Palestinians are humans just like you and I...it was very emotional and touching. I feel like many people don't know what has and is still going on over there and that we can be a voice for the voiceless
Thanks for this discussion!
In the name of Allah, we invite you to worship Allah alone, so say: I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. These words make you a servant of Allah ....... ..........
@@Iris-lh7rf While I do support the Palestinians, I am non-religious. All the best though! I wish you peace!
@@tayrowellnothing to do with religion.
@@JacintaPalerm I was just responding to someone trying to make it that way, is all.
I sincerely believe that account is not an everyday citizen and practicing Muslim. Although, they seem to really want us to think otherwise. The accounts comment history that is visible when you click their pic is just the same phrase repeated in replies to random comments, nothing else. This "person" only recites religious musings while providing no context? What does that communicate to other commentors? This person has a brain that is singularly focused on their religion with no other thoughts or opinions... even on the topic of genocide. My hunch is that this youtube channel's practice of consistent, good faith conversations and engagement with reality (as opposed to mainstream medias prevailing practice of gaslighting citizens with half truths or flat out false narratives) has likely aroused suspicion from those who would prefer the world continue believing that the core issue stems from Muslims irrational hatred of Jewish people. I know thats a lot to assume from very little to go on, but my gut feeling is hardly ever wrong. Even when my hunches are proven accurate, I still cant articulate what led me to my conclusions. I think its some kind of subconscious pattern recognition perhaps? I dunno, I could be wrong, just throwing it out there anyway.
Joseph Goebbels "Oh, look, they are just like us ..."
Where is the human rights now
In the name of Allah, we invite you to worship Allah alone, so say: I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. These words make you a servant of Allah ....... ..........
Never mind the rigths, WERE ARE THE HUMANS?
There is no doubt that this is a terrible genocide.
What was the gist of this expert's opinion that he submitted? That doesn't seem to get covered. Much of the time he is being so pessimistic and skeptical that it's frustrating to watch. The interviewer should have done more to mitigate the grumpy-old-white-guy-who-has-no-horse-in-the-race personality and bring the focus away from this repitious vague hedging. There's so much skepticism here it seems he could just as easily write an opinion that supports the dismissal of any charges. Not that he should be banging on his desk insisting Biden and Bibi be dragged out of office and into a gulag; the interviewer should have done more to get to something more concrete and less deconstructive. You guys can afford the skepticism and pessism, especially about the dessimation of a non-european culture that people were barely giving attention. But many of us do not have that luxury and privilege so please in future indulge us better and don't be so nervous about making clear statements of your opinions and position.
Grumpy? White? At least he is trying something and I guess it's going to fail. We can see it as something but the court / judge decids.
@@dvegule920 If you've never met a grumpy old white guy you haven't lived. I live in the UK and have met a great many. I even know how they vote and how they feel about foreigners. I know how they treat people around them. I know what distinguishes them from grumpy old people of other cultures, because you see "white" is not a race, it's a culture.
💔
I heard they have already sold the oil rights in North Gaza to BP.... HOLY PEOPLE
Asswipe Gaza was part of Israel until 2005 when they gave it up in a peace deal Then in 2006 hamas showed up and first thing they did was fire rockets into Israel If Israel wanted the oil of which there is none they wouldn't have given up Gaza to begin with
Also investigate Oct 7. Most killings involved IDF soldiers indiscriminate bombing. Eye witnesses should be questioned
Excellent report - thank you for this information.
The US direct involvement in other atrocious wars in Middle East and Eastern Europe should also be thorougly investigated alongside the latest gruesome atrocity and holocaust commited in Gaza.
Please stop the atrocities committed by the hell on poor indigenous people of Palestine.
Great interview. Eloquent and well informed expert on the legal aspects of genocides and ICJ.
Mr Schabas , I wish you good health, and take care also about your mental health
In the name of Allah, we invite you to worship Allah alone, so say: I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. These words make you a servant of Allah ....... ..........
I wonder why our international institutions and organisations for human rights don't have the necessary executive power. Could anybody explain, please?
Because it hamas propaganda
@@collins48lcHasbara
Our international courts were set up by a few Western powers who wanted to make sure they stayed on top.
This is great news, I'm glad somebody is at court trying to do something about this.
One observation: cutting off the water and electricity. I looked at photos of a large number of buildings bombed by Israel. And suddenly I understood why they had cut off the water and electricity. Destroyed electric cables are exposed in many of the bombed buildings. If the electricity and water had not been cut off, there would have been massive electrocutions, with cut cables whipping around in the streets, and flooding caused by broken water pipes would have spread the electrocutions. Therefore, when Israel cut off the water and electricity, it knew it was going to bomb Gaza to rubble, and it didn't want its ground forces to face electrocution. In other words, cutting off water and electricity is an admission of intent to reduce Gaza to rubble. MENS REA.
Once Israel told gazans to flee back north into the demolished area they had told them to flee from, it was all over.
Palestine will be free
In the name of Allah, we invite you to worship Allah alone, so say: I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. These words make you a servant of Allah ....... ..........
153 right Vs 1 wrong. Wrong wins this is the situation in UN.
Thank you for highlighting,
There plan is to take the land of Palestinian and put more settlers
...truly enlightening
As per Wikipedia : "Schabas was born in Cleveland, Ohio, with strong roots in an Ashkenazi Jewish background".
Which explains his facile comments towards the end about Israel annexing Gaza and turning it into a tourist destination for Europeans.
Not all immigration ends badly. Leaving gaza will most probably benefit their lives
Israeli, you mean? After this I don't see future of Israel there. Just look at the map.
Thank You 💚 Sir !
Spot on!
Excellent presentation and program
If it looks like a duck, walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, then it just may be a duck
PERFECT... the description correspond at the declaration of minister, and ambassador in England..!
Happening only 1-2 hours from Europe. if Europe is ever destroyed in a war it can hardly define itself in positive manner and may find itself in a situation currently being experienced by the Palestinians.
Excellent interview.
You don't need an expert to tell you if there is a genocide. This is not a complicated.
Thank you!!!!!!
The population in Gaza is growing at 1.99% annually, 39th highest globally
These days will be remembered as some of the darkest days in human history. The world is watching the killing of children and women by the Israeli army in the most horrific ways, and the human conscience has died.
Your world legal expert on genocide never spoke about what happened to all Jews living
in the Muslim world,nor did he speak about Curds, Inuits, Oigurs etc. Are all these
populations not existing?Does what happens today to Bosnian Serbsand to Kossovar Serbs,
what happens today to almost 2 millions Afghans brutally expelled from Pakistan not interest
him?
International law is not about law but about national interests. Since there are many more Arab and Muslim countries than the one Jewish state, Muslim and Arab interests dominate in international legal fora
That is not at all how legal influence in the international court works. Look at the last vote about Israel and Hamas and who voted how.
@@Tyiion which international court in particular are you referring to?
@@masambeni I am referring to the ICC. It is considered a puppet court and Israel lobbied to get its current prosecutor selected. And he has dragged his feet when it comes to anything related to Israel. But you can look at the US’s lone veto against a ceasefire to give you an indication of how the UN actually works.
Thank you
In the name of Allah, we invite you to worship Allah alone, so say: I bear witness that there is no god but Allah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. These words make you a servant of Allah ....... ..........
Profoundly disagree with this lawyer. All the elements of the crime of GENOCIDE have been met in the case of Israel. I question either his courage or his motives.
He said it’s easier to charge them with war crimes to avoid giving them a chance to play on words that they did not commit genocide.
LISTEN to the end.
keep what ever is left of their homes, please please stop the occupation and land grab now
They deserve to keep what ever is left of their homes, please please stop the occupation and land grab now
Why US was against South Africa appartheid and is not against Israel appartheid?
Frank, thanks for your wonderful programs
So is Rishi Sunak, and the West.. 😢
Egypt should let the Gazans leave. but they hate Gazan's.
No they don't, other countries know if they leave they will never to be able to return. Like all that have left since 1948 that ate in Jordan, Egypt, Lebanon, Syria, they were never allowed to return to their land! The zionist should return to Europe and US!
I liked Williams background of books in his office much betteer than your later blurring out his background. Not sure why you decided to do that?
from the beautiful city of CAPE TOWN PLEASE NO TO A TWO-STATE
It's not even a serious idea.
Can't happen.
Israel would exist within Palestine as the west Bank and Gaza aren't connected.
That just makes no sense.
One democratic state is the only way forward
Wow, that's odd. Early into this video, I hit thumbs-up. I just looked back and saw my thumbs-up was gone. I put it back.
Maybe not genocide. Israel is exceptionally special and gets a pass?
14:45, theres nothing new about their methodology, its a direct ripoff of the British 'Terra nullius' policy that they used to justify the attempted extermination of the First Australians.
nO FOOD NO WATER NO ELECTRIC NO MEDICATION
Few words for freedom. There was a music festival of love and freedom. Gaza slaughtered 600 members of them. They were civilians all over the world dancing and singing. If one of the pro-palestinians was there, he also been gone. When Gaza talks about freedom, they are talking about world without you and me. This protestors don't know nothing about history, values and common sense. Peace.
Someone should pass this info on to the BBC before it shuts down Olly Alexander
What is the complete name of this fantastic legal expert?
Still got plenty of Palestinians in the rest of the world. Not the end of a race.