It seems like they're slowly adding it into more and more setlists, since they finally debuted it live on the Cold And Black And Infinite tour... let's hope it becomes an closing track... twould be absolutely perfect!!!!!...
I cried when he played this. I wasn't expecting it, and it's been like my depression anthem since....well...I won't get into that. Regardless, it was a cathartic release, and I am forever greatful it was on the setlist.
can we get some love for Allesandro Cortini, the first openly Italian member of NIN, having the belligerence to look how i feel when listening to this song, while also playing this song? Yeesh. shut up and take my money already.
@@kanyefuck7018 there are more of us than you think. hiding in plain sight. be careful what you speak in hushed tones when you think the italians aren't listening
The only time Trent did this for us. So grateful. It’s sad he can’t hit the falsettos from The Fragile days, for sure some of my favorite parts in this song. Changes how I feel when I hear the song. NIN live usually is preferable over album songs by many. I appreciate you Trent. One of my favorites.
Thank you so so much for posting this! Easily my most listened to NIN song and that's hard to believe for me. The Fragile era was so important in my life and would die to see this live in person.
I was there. Whole set list was great. Besides Closer, Head Like a Whole I could have changed those. Was hoping they would play Wish at some point...then crowd would have went ballistic.
Nice work again... may I ask what you shooting with? The audio is really clip prone, don't you think? Regardless, none of the shows in NA fit with any of my availability (Cleveland was close, but fat chance at getting tickets for that =) ), so living vicariously through your video work is much appreciated. Thanks, again.
"can this world really be as sad as it seems?" No, it's FAR worse. Not the world but absolutely this species. It's more than disgraceful, it's FUCKING EMBARASSING! *wastebin takes flight*
"Now I'm gonna play some really depressing music..."
*Proceeds to play one of the saddest songs ever written 😥
This needs to be a setlist staple.
must be enacted by law.
Agreed. Was so incredible to have witnessed this.
This is a very important NIN song, I believe. I too would like it to be a regular on the setlist.
No, but I understand why you would feel that way.
It seems like they're slowly adding it into more and more setlists, since they finally debuted it live on the Cold And Black And Infinite tour... let's hope it becomes an closing track... twould be absolutely perfect!!!!!...
yup, that "finally" at the beginning speaks for all of us
I just got emotional. I can’t believe they did this live.
Dude dudeee me too likeee likee *cries*
💔💔💔
Robin is so majestic.
Yea holy shit he had that beyonce hair flow goin. Wasn’t expecting that lol.
I cried when he played this. I wasn't expecting it, and it's been like my depression anthem since....well...I won't get into that.
Regardless, it was a cathartic release, and I am forever greatful it was on the setlist.
Me too ♥️
Same here. I understand. I got the chills when I heard it start. Never thought I’d hear it live.
Same here also!!!...
This is the only song left that I want to see NIN play live, because it may be my favorite Nine Inch Nails song.
That guitar riff is not just being shredded. It's literally in tears. Never heard a more painful, simple guitar riff 3:47
can we get some love for Allesandro Cortini, the first openly Italian member of NIN, having the belligerence to look how i feel when listening to this song, while also playing this song?
Yeesh. shut up and take my money already.
Were there closeted Italians before?
As an italian, I appreciate this comment
Though it’s written Alessandro ;)
@@kanyefuck7018 there are more of us than you think. hiding in plain sight. be careful what you speak in hushed tones when you think the italians aren't listening
Thanks so much for this. My absolute favourite NIN track
I understand that NIN's Guitar tone is supposed to be loud and distorded but they Should've used the "Still" Guitar tone, that tone was majestic.
Right? I totally agree
My favorite NIN song
They still have it ! Sounds better than ever......
That Bass 🤌👌
Underrated Song
this enter directly in the history of music
Omggg I love this song so much….
Was so glad they played this song, one of my favorites
The only time Trent did this for us. So grateful. It’s sad he can’t hit the falsettos from The Fragile days, for sure some of my favorite parts in this song. Changes how I feel when I hear the song. NIN live usually is preferable over album songs by many. I appreciate you Trent. One of my favorites.
He's played this several times.
Trent is UNIQUE🖤🖤🖤
Thank you so so much for posting this! Easily my most listened to NIN song and that's hard to believe for me. The Fragile era was so important in my life and would die to see this live in person.
I was at this show, it was phenomenal
Shut up and take my feelings
Really nice recording... Thank you.
Absolute fucking chills
Thank you so much for uploading.
Man this is hits deep emotions. It’s just come at you 🌑
Song is me. All my tattoos are connected to this song
That quality!!
Great song. Thanks for sharing
I was there. Whole set list was great. Besides Closer, Head Like a Whole I could have changed those. Was hoping they would play Wish at some point...then crowd would have went ballistic.
I was hoping they played with too, I was looking forward to the strobe lights
wish*
@@burybee i saw wish live, the strobes were amazing and they extended the outro with the drums, it was one of the best songs i’ve seen live
Wow , that's amazing , my friends !🏅🏆👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👍🏻🎩👌🏻
Perfect music for goodbye...
So great
THANK YOU
I would adore to see them live.
Holy shit! I hope I get to see them play this song just once! I still have time (I hope).
Increíble, espectacular, emocionante, genial ❤❤❤❤vaya temazo 🔥 una de las canciones de mi vida.Gracias trent .
Una de mis favoritas, que bueno que no la escuche cuando andaba para la mierda hubiera quedado peor
@nineinchnails play this at boston calling please. This is epic
SSSSSLLLLLLAAAAAAAYYYYYYYEEEEEERRRRRR!!!!!!
Nice work again... may I ask what you shooting with? The audio is really clip prone, don't you think? Regardless, none of the shows in NA fit with any of my availability (Cleveland was close, but fat chance at getting tickets for that =) ), so living vicariously through your video work is much appreciated. Thanks, again.
niiice
Mi favorita
When did they do this song? I left around 11 or so after they did Hurt and do not remember this being played. I didn't miss it did I??
They played it right before Hurt, lol.
had a curfew didja then, lol.
Oh mannnn why whyy did you leave?
2:45 ♥
“Into dust” cover, I think it would work…
Chio te extraño
I'm happy when I'm depressed.
💔💔💔
sounds better live
Love this song! Guitar at the beginning is not good though lol
lol . he played it sloppy but i think the guitar tone could use some more work
The guitar is out of tune, they need a better guitar tech@@Unorthodox666
"can this world really be as sad as it seems?"
No, it's FAR worse. Not the world but absolutely this species. It's more than disgraceful, it's FUCKING EMBARASSING! *wastebin takes flight*
I really really love that song... except the guitar solo part. It really breaks the atmosphere
So good, I would kill to see this live, one of the best NIN songs ever