Seattle’s "Amazon Tax"

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 май 2018
  • Seattle’s city council passed a new tax Monday. It will charge big companies $275 for every employee.
    The “head” tax is supposed to fund housing for the homeless. Supporters of the tax chanted “housing is a human right!” at a protest lead by City Councilwoman Kshama Sawant, a member of the “Socialist Alternative” party.
    ---------
    Don't miss a single video from Stossel TV, sign up here: johnstossel.activehosted.com/f/1
    Subscribe to my RUclips channel: / johnstossel
    Like me on Facebook: / johnstossel
    Follow me on Twitter: / johnstossel
    ---------
    Seattle homelessness has doubled in the last 8 years. Politicians blame a shortage of “affordable” housing, but John Stossel says that the politicians own bad policies helped create that shortage.
    Seattle’s building code is 745 pages long. (link: www.seattle.gov/dpd/codesrules...) “Welded splices shall be of ASTM A706 steel,” the code notes, in an endless list of rules. The residential building code is another 685 pages.
    Developers can’t build big apartment buildings because in most of Seattle’s residential land area, high-rises are illegal; zoning rules say only single family houses may be built.
    If Seattle just repealed many of those regulations, affordable housing would grow, Stossel says.
    Instead, Seattle’s politicians will tax big tax companies and use the money to buy housing for homeless people.
    That upset Amazon, Seattle’s largest employer. It paused construction of a new office building in Seattle. Construction workers went into the streets to back Amazon, and counter-protest the socialist councilwoman’s pro-tax rally.
    Supporters of big government aren’t used to protesters drowning them out. Sawant accused Amazon of “extortion” and slammed Amazon owner Jeff Bezos on TV: “He said he has so much money that he doesn’t know what to do with it ... I want your viewers to understand who’s the enemy here.”
    The “enemy”? Stossel says: Give me a break! Bezos created the jobs that she now wants to tax.
    This week, Amazon partly won its fight; Seattle’s city council approved a $275 per employee tax instead of the $540 that Sawant and the other leftists proposed.
    Sawant accused Seattle’s Mayor of “dramatically weakening [the] Tax Amazon bill. Grim reminder: working people can't rely on corporate politicians.”
    Corporate politicians? Stossel points out that the $275/head tax will hurt job creation too. No wonder Amazon is looking to build its next headquarters outside of Seattle.

Комментарии • 1,8 тыс.

  • @recoveringnewyorker2243
    @recoveringnewyorker2243 6 лет назад +528

    Give a man a fish you feed him for a day. Teach him how to fish and the socialists TAX HALF HIS CATCH!

    • @chrisconger8975
      @chrisconger8975 6 лет назад +10

      Shepperd November ...only half?

    • @recoveringnewyorker2243
      @recoveringnewyorker2243 6 лет назад +29

      Chris Conger The other half will be confiscated (appropriated) for the homeless!

    • @recoveringnewyorker2243
      @recoveringnewyorker2243 6 лет назад +7

      The Internetz is Broken I viewed it. I didn't know whether to laugh, cry , or get angry! I chose to laugh.

    • @dfw_motorrad1329
      @dfw_motorrad1329 6 лет назад +15

      "Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day.
      Don't teach a man how to fish and you feed yourself. He's a grown man; fishing's not that hard."
      -Ron Swanson
      These weak and unskilled socialists are demanding that successful, skilled people house them, feed them, and give them money. They are the grown man who can't catch a fish.
      We need to just say "no, I work hard to better my life, not yours."

    • @recoveringnewyorker2243
      @recoveringnewyorker2243 6 лет назад +11

      RyanRants Teach a man to fish and the environmentalists will declare the lake a protected wetland and the fish a protected species!

  • @johnpagdilao6075
    @johnpagdilao6075 6 лет назад +457

    Seattle is about to tax it's self out of existence.

    • @inbedwithagoblin8290
      @inbedwithagoblin8290 6 лет назад +26

      But they are like, really progessive.

    • @dm8867
      @dm8867 6 лет назад +11

      Like Chicago

    • @johnpagdilao6075
      @johnpagdilao6075 6 лет назад +7

      dm8867 Not just the city of Chicago but all of Cook County.

    • @Anonymous-zu7dh
      @Anonymous-zu7dh 6 лет назад +10

      John Pagdilao and then comes California

    • @markwest8960
      @markwest8960 6 лет назад +15

      The self-defeating nature of big govt and the leftists that prop them up. What's sad? That neither of them are open-minded enough to see what's so obvious. Seattle, another once awesome city being obliterated by leftist policy.

  • @hardinmichael1981
    @hardinmichael1981 6 лет назад +567

    The problem with socialism is that eventually you run out of other people’s money.

    • @user-tp5yb4hr4w
      @user-tp5yb4hr4w 5 лет назад +4

      which is another reason why women need their rights taken away. because the majority women vote democrat, and are the majority voters. and it's probably the only way of shutting down the welfare state before if sends us into a collapse. but they will still lose their rights when the collapse happens, because nobody has rights when there is no government to govern them.

    • @khalilsommerville9131
      @khalilsommerville9131 5 лет назад +15

      52262 let’s slow it down here

    • @DBK434
      @DBK434 5 лет назад +1

      @Generic Русский thank you lady.men support their woman with love and resources and the woman submits and supports him with other types of work like childcare which is so important for a child but father is equally important

    • @michiganborn8303
      @michiganborn8303 5 лет назад +4

      @Generic Русский don't forget that it was the women's suffrage movement of the early 1900s that creates the 18th amendment.
      The banning the sale and distribution of alcohol.
      We all saw what problem that caused.
      The gangsters ruled during prohibition.

    • @IdahoPatty
      @IdahoPatty 5 лет назад +2

      Well some people don’t pay taxes so maybe we should start taxing them and then see what wonderful things we can do with it.

  • @wesleymills6542
    @wesleymills6542 6 лет назад +43

    "I have never understood why it is 'greed' to want to keep the money you have earned but not greed to want to take someone else's money"
    -Thomas Sowell

  • @jesseward4115
    @jesseward4115 6 лет назад +487

    Head taxes will only make automation happen faster.

    • @bobbinsthethird
      @bobbinsthethird 6 лет назад +4

      Jesse I feel like this has always been a poor argument.
      I want more automation. America is worse off with people working in jobs that could easily be automated.
      ourworldindata.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/ourworldindata_share-working-in-agriculture-since-1300.png
      I always think of this chart.
      Saying that minimum wage stops people from getting their first job, and setting down a successful career is the problem, not that it introduces more robots.

    • @jesseward4115
      @jesseward4115 6 лет назад +15

      I'm not against automation. The problem is that automation is gonna start killing jobs faster then they are created and we don't need to make it worse by having high minimum wages and head taxes.

    • @andinbriwel1092
      @andinbriwel1092 6 лет назад +8

      Just lower everyone’s pay by $0.27/hr. That’s the reality these people who think increasing taxes is a solution. Watch, Amazon will just reduce pay there. Oh, pass a law against lowering pay? Ok, no more raises now. Oh, pass a law to force companies to give raises? Atlas shrugs, and nobody has a job.

    • @lewisdoherty7621
      @lewisdoherty7621 6 лет назад +3

      That is not true. Automation helps drop prices and the consumers of those services/products have more money to spend on other things they would not have bought or on more of those same products or services, and with lower prices there are more of that product or service bought by other consumers. Inefficient jobs decline while jobs appear in other things or locations.

    • @justmehere6094
      @justmehere6094 6 лет назад +1

      Ah but these are SOCIALIST idiots. They believe they will eventually control the businesses in their fantasy land.

  • @RockyLikesPews
    @RockyLikesPews 6 лет назад +191

    I love that their plan to end homelessness is make it harder for employers to have employees.

    • @squatch545
      @squatch545 6 лет назад +2

      Amazon is creating the homeless problem you fucking moron. God you conservatards are nuts.

    • @thiruvalluvar3880
      @thiruvalluvar3880 6 лет назад +10

      Joe Smith how?

    • @asain3586
      @asain3586 4 года назад +2

      @@squatch545
      Need proof for that

    • @squatch545
      @squatch545 4 года назад +1

      @@asain3586 It's called the market, Einstein. An influx of highly paid tech workers drive up the price of houses and rents, leaving anyone who can't afford the sky high cost of housing to be homeless. Then Amazon lobbies Seattle City council (sending fake counter protesters to rallies) to fight a small tax proposed to help alleviate the homeless crisis. Amazon wins and the city is paralyzed and can't do anything. Do I really have to explain this to you?

    • @squatch545
      @squatch545 4 года назад +1

      @@thiruvalluvar3880 It's called the market, Einstein. An influx of highly paid tech workers drive up the price of houses and rents, leaving anyone who can't afford the sky high cost of housing to be homeless. Then Amazon lobbies Seattle City council (sending fake counter protesters to rallies) to fight a small tax proposed to help alleviate the homeless crisis. Amazon wins and the city is paralyzed and can't do anything. Do I really have to explain this to you?

  • @alcredeur
    @alcredeur 6 лет назад +442

    "Housing is a human right!"
    Umm....I don't think the word "right" means what you think it means.

    • @JeffreyKader
      @JeffreyKader 5 лет назад +66

      You don't have a right to someone else's services. But these people seem believe otherwise

    • @justinz9225
      @justinz9225 5 лет назад +39

      I've never met a leftist who understood the difference between positive and negative rights.
      Or for that matter, the reality that claiming a right does not make goods materialize. You can sit alone on a desert island and claim your right to healthcare all you want, but doctors will not appear. But amazingly your right to free speech, property, and self defense is still intact.

    • @bufftammy735
      @bufftammy735 5 лет назад +2

      Right tell that to the cave men

    • @moustachioification
      @moustachioification 5 лет назад +4

      @Christopher Michos So can I build in your backyard? Or on a state park? Nothing is there

    • @melvinhume9865
      @melvinhume9865 5 лет назад +8

      Yes housing is a human right.. You have the right to work hard and to get the housing that you can get it doesn't mean you get a mansion it doesn't mean you get a fancy apartment it means you get To put forth the effort if you cannot afford it there then you must move n seek employment where you can afford to live

  • @dirremoire
    @dirremoire 6 лет назад +314

    How about everybody at the protest take in a homeless person? There, problem solved.

    • @fookinaye8277
      @fookinaye8277 6 лет назад +13

      No that wouldn't solve the problem at all. You teach a man to fish

    • @tjti2631
      @tjti2631 5 лет назад +28

      woah hold on there with all that logic buckaroo.We don't use that in these parts

    • @TEverettReynolds
      @TEverettReynolds 5 лет назад +23

      ​@@fookinaye8277 > You teach a man to fish For normal people, yes. But these homeless don't want to fish (they want to just keep shooting up), or are mentally unable to fish...

    • @randylavine3003
      @randylavine3003 4 года назад +3

      @@fookinaye8277 Can't teach those whom don't want to learn!

    • @amostake
      @amostake 3 года назад +6

      Universal truth of all left-wing ideology. They never want to help anyone themselves. They want to make other people help other people. You never see a single left-winger say "I demand I pay more to help the poor".

  • @bjkarana
    @bjkarana 6 лет назад +75

    Ha! And I bet the actual homeless will never see a dime of it...

    • @larrykh465
      @larrykh465 6 лет назад +7

      yes they will, more fences to keep them out! up to 32 mil a year now! Seattle cares!

  • @Austinfamily1
    @Austinfamily1 6 лет назад +22

    Sawant needs to be deported. She's ignorant. My favorite thing she said a couple years ago was that Boeing should shut down and make buses instead of airplanes.

    • @Tom_Hadler
      @Tom_Hadler 6 лет назад +1

      Erik A Haha. Oh god I need to look that quote up. We have idiot lefties running the city near me too. Badly, of course.

    • @TheShaniqua1992
      @TheShaniqua1992 6 лет назад +2

      and I bet you she calls donald trump a fascist.

  • @hunterellis9848
    @hunterellis9848 6 лет назад +75

    Oh...wait the 15$ minimum wage, "is going to fix the problems with poverty".

    • @rfzwi3437
      @rfzwi3437 6 лет назад +17

      I mean, obviously you clearly don't understand how it would solve all the problems.
      Look, $15 minimum wage is affordable because businesses can just print more money. How dare you even suggest a person with no skill, poor life choices, and a lack of motivation to improve and climb up the working ladder by acquiring a in-demand skill, doesn't deserve $15 an hour!
      How will they feed their family of 12 and work part time at McDonalds 18 hours a week? I bet you're a fucking republican.

    • @SEAL341
      @SEAL341 5 лет назад +1

      So lower wages is going to solve the problem? How so?

    • @aoeu256
      @aoeu256 5 лет назад +11

      @@SEAL341 Lower wages will allow more businesses to start up (especially with less regulation) and the higher supply of services will lower costs allowing the low wage earners to have almost the same life style that they would have had with higher wages. Except with the lower wages you can have internships/jobs that allow people to earn wages and get skills, but with higher wages people who want entry-level jobs can't get them. Ship the unemployed to Vietnam, Thailand, Phillipines, or China and see how much easier it is for them to get jobs, and live even with very low wages. Go try to make a company in the US vs over there as well.

    • @Afurthyclays
      @Afurthyclays 4 года назад +2

      aoeu256
      Talking sense like that usually doesn't permeate the liberal mind, though I admire you for trying. Hopefully it sinks in with Mr braddock, but who knows?

  • @gm45_62
    @gm45_62 6 лет назад +35

    Amazon will just move, then Seattle will have to tax middle class, middle class leave, Seattle breaks down both physically and politically

    • @evacody1249
      @evacody1249 6 лет назад +6

      GM45 _ Seattle will just become Detroit.

  • @merendell
    @merendell 6 лет назад +93

    I still say amazon and all the other big buisness should just pack up shop and move elsewhere. Let seattle find out how bad the homeless problem gets when there are no big employers providing jobs and all the little employers also go out of buisness because theres not enough folks with jobs to patronize them. Very quickly the only ones that will have jobs will be government employees, at least till the city goes bankrupt.

    • @andinbriwel1092
      @andinbriwel1092 6 лет назад +2

      Merendel go on, Atlas... shrug.

    • @cvn6555
      @cvn6555 6 лет назад +6

      All they have to do is take a field trip to Detroit.

    • @delmusingle2338
      @delmusingle2338 6 лет назад +2

      Merendel "I still",,,,, and most government employees vote Democrat along with creating polices to subvert the 'intent of law' when it goes against the socialist agenda.

    • @pyroman6000
      @pyroman6000 6 лет назад +1

      Be careful what you wish for. Many Rust Belt cities are just now beginning to recover from the loss of the Steel and automotive industries- and that mostly happened in the 1970's and 80's. You don't want another Gary, IN or Detroit MI out there... (as much as we'd all love to see all these Marxist "progressives" forced to lay in the beds they've made for themselves)

    • @BaltimoreAndOhioRR
      @BaltimoreAndOhioRR 6 лет назад +3

      Just like Detroit.

  • @jamesg1367
    @jamesg1367 6 лет назад +150

    Too bad. Amazon should have rejected the deal. Seattle needs a lesson in civics, but most of all in economics. I fled that city 20 years ago, and have only seen my decision validated over and over and over again.

    • @homewall744
      @homewall744 6 лет назад +11

      If you owned a home 20 years ago, you'd be much much richer today.
      Amazon has no say in tax policies. The communist-leaning city council doesn't negotiate, they think there's a "billionaire" class that they must hate with all their small minds.

    • @bartsimpson3799
      @bartsimpson3799 6 лет назад +11

      JamesG i was raised in Spokane. The minimum wage hike is killing small mom and pop places. We fell like we have no voice in the state.

    • @jamesg1367
      @jamesg1367 6 лет назад +6

      I live in Central WA. One would think we were somewhat insulated from the big-city madness. Yet every day I see the impact of boneheaded policies emanating mostly from the extremist politics of the Olympia/King County/west coast region. These people are an authoritarian nightmare. They seem to have no concept of the precepts of liberty and representative government that are the foundation this country.

    • @fakebrake
      @fakebrake 6 лет назад +3

      JamesG I left California in 94. I could never afford to own a home there and the politics!!! Doing well in Texas.

    • @avocares
      @avocares 6 лет назад

      Demand in Seattle is growing, now the cost to have a large business there is growing too. Makes sense to me.

  • @roa4969
    @roa4969 5 лет назад +27

    "Housing is a human right" shut up with that, work for a house like all other people

    • @samuelbekele3601
      @samuelbekele3601 3 года назад +3

      Or at least push to get rid of these nonsense regulations. I could build just as good a house for a fraction of the price of this regulated nonsense.

  • @AKHUNTERX
    @AKHUNTERX 6 лет назад +14

    The irony of a government official, who’s actively extorting companies, accusing amazon of extortion

  • @collinprice5320
    @collinprice5320 6 лет назад +208

    No Head Tax! No Head Tax! I love it. Finally people representing opinions that differ from the mainstream narrative. Keep up the great work John!

    • @squatch545
      @squatch545 6 лет назад

      'No Head Tax' IS the mainstream narrative you fucking moron.

  • @keithroy7884
    @keithroy7884 6 лет назад +115

    I love that they pass a law to take someone's money, then call the victim extortionist. 😂😂

    • @bmw803
      @bmw803 6 лет назад +13

      That's leftist ideology. Backwards, stupid, contradictory, hypocrite and finally ignorant. All those added together, creates INSANITY.

    • @BaltimoreAndOhioRR
      @BaltimoreAndOhioRR 6 лет назад +9

      Liberalism is a mental disorder.

    • @squatch545
      @squatch545 6 лет назад +1

      Keith Roy. I love how you think Amazon isn't the one taking someone's money by paying so little that worker's have to go on food stamps to survive, and by driving up real estate prices that no one can afford to rent. But if you feel any tax is unjustified, please stop using tax funded services, you fucking hypocrite!

    • @keithroy7884
      @keithroy7884 6 лет назад +14

      Joe Smith I love how you equate people giving them money voluntarily in exchange for desired commodities, with taxation.
      Since I actually dislike Amazon, I refuse to use their service, and no one tries to force me. If I try to refuse to use or pay for the "services" that Seattle "provides", it will be forcibly taken from me, with the power of lethal force, if necessary. Many jurisdictions are criminalizing going off grid, or any other way of not using these services of which you speak.
      Who is the hypocrite?

    • @keithroy7884
      @keithroy7884 6 лет назад +12

      Joe Smith Your argument is also nonsensical in another way. In Silicon Valley, real estate prices were driven up by companies paying high wages. In Seattle, apparently according to you, real estate prices were driven up by a company paying too low wages.?.?

  • @billashby7858
    @billashby7858 6 лет назад +27

    I have an idea to the politician who wants the "head tax" move to Venezuela!

  • @paulmartin7334
    @paulmartin7334 6 лет назад +26

    Amazon should have just proven a point and left the Seattle area. The citizens of Seattle would have had the council’s heads on a stake the next day.

    • @williamhomann4894
      @williamhomann4894 4 года назад +1

      Unfortunately Paul, no they would not. Kshama Sawant(the Socialist Council member in the piece) was re-elected as well as most of the City Council.

  • @captainstrangiato961
    @captainstrangiato961 6 лет назад +172

    > "HOUSING IS A HUMAN RIGHT! TAX THE BIG BUSINESSES!!!"
    > "Wtf? Why are there robots now!?!?!? Why are all these businesses leaving?!??!"

    • @OmegaTou
      @OmegaTou 6 лет назад +14

      Captain Strangiato
      I long for the days when people knew what human rights were.

    • @GretchentheAlligator
      @GretchentheAlligator 6 лет назад +15

      Hawaii’s minimum wage is $10.50 and most fast food places and other businesses are laying off people and adding more kiosks, but hey liberals know best!

    • @homewall744
      @homewall744 6 лет назад +3

      Nobody is leaving yet, and the homeless are flocking to our socialist wet dream.

    • @imulippo5245
      @imulippo5245 6 лет назад +1

      If housing is a human right, why doesn't it apply on desert island?

    • @PumpkinKingXXIII
      @PumpkinKingXXIII 6 лет назад

      Imu Lippo, no one to tax?

  • @natehahn85
    @natehahn85 6 лет назад +38

    The American taxpayer
    Were the first people punished
    The last people considered

    • @orppranator5230
      @orppranator5230 6 лет назад

      Nate Hahn yes. That’s because women, as a whole, have more voting power than men.

    • @squatch545
      @squatch545 6 лет назад

      Awwww....you poor victim.

    • @yulfine1688
      @yulfine1688 6 лет назад

      Joe Smith Joe Smith you can leave move to Norway would ya tell me how well they're doing or Canada do tell

    • @manictiger
      @manictiger 6 лет назад

      I do sometimes feel bad for honest, hard-working people, because they really do get the short-end of the stick EVERY TIME.
      I'm a stock trader for that reason.
      I knew, long ago, I did not want to be an 'honest, hard-working person'. I wanted to be a card-counter and use the rest of my free-time to enjoy life, instead of being stuck in a traffic jam trying to get to a dead-end job I hate, but that I've conned myself into thinking will lead to something better. How does that help anyone? If anything it just makes the traffic jam worse!
      Everything aimed at stealing from the rich actually just winds up stealing from the employees, sometimes taking all their jobs away. (See Detroit for details.)

    • @squatch545
      @squatch545 6 лет назад

      Eara Soulous. I live in Canada, and have relatives in Norway, two countries that are doing much better than your sh*thole country.

  • @nonmagicmike723
    @nonmagicmike723 6 лет назад +4

    "If you don't give us more of your money, it's extortion." Is this a joke?

  • @ed6164
    @ed6164 6 лет назад +70

    I'll tell you something about the homeless. If you build it (shelters, food kitchens, medical, etc,.) they will come - more and more of them . After all, if you were homeless, wouldn't you go where all the services were? It's a smart survival decision...but it costs everyone else...what do you do?

    • @richardrodriguez1742
      @richardrodriguez1742 6 лет назад +2

      answer, quit feeding the animals DA ?

    • @dylan-5287
      @dylan-5287 6 лет назад +14

      The company I work for has contracts with the city to do certain types of "emergency" construction and board ups. Occasionally an empty house will get 'taken' over by a group of homeless, usually drug addicts. Cops bust in and get them out, then we try to repair where they broke in and seal it from further entry. I've seen so much nasty shit from the homeless, I've just lost all sympathy. Before starting the job I definitely had sympathy, thought it was the world against them, but through experience I've come to realize it really does just come down to laziness and lack of any effort whatsoever.

    • @darthneph4900
      @darthneph4900 5 лет назад +1

      You poison what you offer them. Done deal..

    • @guitarsANDcars39
      @guitarsANDcars39 4 года назад

      Let private businesses run it, NOT THE GOVERNMENT NOT THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT. PRIVATE BUSINESSES HAVE TO RUN IT.

    • @Afurthyclays
      @Afurthyclays 4 года назад

      How else will they ever understand the necessity of being self reliant?
      If they're able bodied, you eventually have to cut the umbilical cord.

  • @Tjp361
    @Tjp361 6 лет назад +41

    No wonder Amazon is looking for a 2nd HQ.....

    • @Tjp361
      @Tjp361 6 лет назад

      Liberty Tree yeah I live just north of ft. Worth. I think the Austin and dallas areas have been widely looked at. I honestly don't think Dallas or Ft. Worth will get it because our tech sector is not as mature as Austin's or other cheap metros.

    • @krassimirpetrov7131
      @krassimirpetrov7131 6 лет назад

      It’ll end up being the HQ at the rate Seattle is chasing them

  • @08fighter08
    @08fighter08 6 лет назад +225

    These people need to learn how business and finance work, and how regulations affect things. Then, they claim Amazon is pitting workers against workers. You did that because of bad policy making. You all have to work together and compromise to get deals that benefit everyone.

    • @beancounter5434
      @beancounter5434 6 лет назад +7

      Random Jasmine
      Government and business are two separate things, and should be run as so. This idea that government should be run like business is not a good one. I want my government to be concerned with the welfare of the public, and not to have a profit motive.

    • @donabrahamson7922
      @donabrahamson7922 6 лет назад +7

      Bean counter. If the gov't doesn't count it's beans there's no welfare for anyone... The headcount is a losing plan. Everyone will b unemployed, even gov't.

    • @johnharrison1429
      @johnharrison1429 6 лет назад +4

      Well said.

    • @redTanto
      @redTanto 6 лет назад +7

      This is not a compromise situation, never compromise with the aggressor. Even a $1 head tax would be counter intuitive.

    • @mattvalon4674
      @mattvalon4674 6 лет назад +8

      Bean Counter /
      Government should be run like a business. Right now there aren't any consequences for politicians if something goes wrong. They cash in and if things go south, they just resign and take the next gov. gig.
      They should give politicians a low fixed salery and high commissions if we see the desired results.

  • @KILLER171865
    @KILLER171865 6 лет назад +14

    Hope Amazon gives them the finger and moves out of town to a better state.

  • @prdeacon974
    @prdeacon974 6 лет назад +13

    There should be a “picket sign tax”.

  • @GoldenGrenadier
    @GoldenGrenadier 6 лет назад +47

    I just hope this nonsense doesn't spread to Bellevue WA where Valve is headquartered.

    • @ShanicuaTV
      @ShanicuaTV 6 лет назад +11

      yeah. If they do, who knows when we would receive Half Life 3: the Card Game.

    • @jason200912
      @jason200912 6 лет назад +1

      it won't. bellevue belongs to the old people. their city is also extremely clean and well managed in comparison.
      Also disturbingly polite like Canadians. those guys wait in straight lines for the bus (even if it' reaches 50 feet long) while in Seattle we just make a mob at the front.

    • @jason200912
      @jason200912 6 лет назад +1

      what don't you like about washington? the laws are always reasonable so it's not like communist california or as unjust as texas. ranked 2nd in legal juries in the country with delaware ranked 1st. the state is very similar to Vermont and Virginia. Has good protection of rights but never on the extreme sides of politics. The only bad thing are the sales taxes at 10%, but most states have 7% already.

  • @MalleusDei275
    @MalleusDei275 6 лет назад +14

    No,housing is not a human right, but earning a living is.

    • @sergioesamayoa
      @sergioesamayoa 6 лет назад +1

      Seems that you haven't your concepts right.
      "housing" perse is not a right but you are free to buy one or build one and nobody (even the government as long as you pay for it) can stop you. Right meas "you can"but doesn't means "government (or other) must provide.
      Same as "earning a living": You have the right to do so (as long as you are not a criminal) or to sit and do nothing but DOES NOT mean that somebody MUST give you a job.

  • @Blakelysworld358
    @Blakelysworld358 6 лет назад +3

    Hard working dudes that actually build everything standing firm to protest for a change. It's about time!

  • @bazookajoe8904
    @bazookajoe8904 6 лет назад +7

    Leave it to government if you want a project to take longer and cost more....

  • @utcnc7mm
    @utcnc7mm 6 лет назад +18

    You want find this story in the main stream news media. As has been said the problem with Socialism is "sooner or later you run out of other people's money".

    • @squatch545
      @squatch545 6 лет назад

      Sooner or later capitalism runs out of slaves.

  • @failure2flinch876
    @failure2flinch876 6 лет назад +10

    for Politicians too much is Never Enough!

  • @GlennNichols1
    @GlennNichols1 6 лет назад +7

    Got the top 50 or 60 companies to move out of state together, Seattle will be singing a different toon real fast.

  • @kylewathen1070
    @kylewathen1070 6 лет назад +12

    Hey look it's Seattle it's going to be the next California

  • @canny8228
    @canny8228 6 лет назад +13

    Chanting is a human right!

  • @HobomanMC
    @HobomanMC 6 лет назад +46

    Oh yea why not raise taxes for other people? As long as it is not me it's ok.

    • @GretchentheAlligator
      @GretchentheAlligator 6 лет назад +1

      Sup Gavin, I’m Gavin

    • @lumox7
      @lumox7 6 лет назад +2

      Don't tax you, don't tax me, tax that man behind that tree!

  • @boostedmaniac
    @boostedmaniac 6 лет назад +3

    If I was amazon I’d just move to Texas.

  • @Xonid1
    @Xonid1 6 лет назад +7

    The climate is good in the south. Amazon. Come on down.

  • @vicsrealms
    @vicsrealms 6 лет назад +18

    Hey, more jobs for states like Texas. Just leave the lefties where you found'em.

    • @squatch545
      @squatch545 6 лет назад

      There are even more homeless in Texas. It's not a capitalist paradise.

    • @vicsrealms
      @vicsrealms 6 лет назад +1

      Very funny. As of the 2017 Census, California is at 24.28% (134,278) and Texas is only at 4.26% (23,548)

  • @Ljrod95
    @Ljrod95 6 лет назад +5

    wtf now housing is a human right too? When are we getting smartphones and internet as one too?

  • @fredrm6023
    @fredrm6023 6 лет назад +20

    I thought Amazon was coming to Las Vegas.

  • @GaldiA
    @GaldiA 5 лет назад +3

    Amazon should leave

  • @clallen2000
    @clallen2000 6 лет назад +15

    Socialist never fully think out the ramifications of their demands and actions. Every country that has ever been socialist makes this mistake.
    I do agree that homelessness is a problem but more taxes is not the solution. More taxes will make the problem even worse.
    If the city's excessive building is what is causing the artificial supply shortage then they need to be simplified more to get builders to build more. They should meet with builders and find out why they are not building and what the government can do to help speed up the process.
    More taxes will cause companies to relocate to a lower tax area which will cause a lot of unemployment not for just the workers of Amazon but in places where Amazon workers spend money. The ripple effect is normally about 8 times greater than the money lost in that area.
    Another way that Amazon could save is by eliminating as many human workers with robots and AI that make financial sense. A $500 tax could be the tipping point that causes the company to leave or start eliminating human workers. I am sure that Seattle would put a head tax on all robot workers so it would be best for them to relocate elsewhere.

    • @hardinmichael1981
      @hardinmichael1981 6 лет назад +1

      Could not agree more. It's very simple. Anything you tax, you get less of. Anything you subsidize, you get more of. Taxing jobs to subsidize homelessness will create less jobs and more homelessness.

  • @wkdravenna
    @wkdravenna 6 лет назад +129

    I don't care what anyone says in a reply, no one can make me not love The Donald.

    • @johnnywang206
      @johnnywang206 6 лет назад +22

      #MAGA

    • @markwest8960
      @markwest8960 6 лет назад +17

      wkdravenna....I wasn't a fan of him originally and I didn't vote for him in 2016....but in 2020....he has my vote.

    • @markwest8960
      @markwest8960 6 лет назад +19

      jockoboy 46 .....added jobs across the US, black unemployment at historic low, stock market at historic high, decades long Korean War ending and more progress made there than the past 50 years combined......yeah....The Donald is suckling ass. You must absolutely hate America. Feel free to leave.

    • @wkdravenna
      @wkdravenna 6 лет назад +2

      everydayidie alilmore you are most likely the patron saint of some European country. 😁

    • @redTanto
      @redTanto 6 лет назад +3

      What if I told you he had a pizza party and didn't invite you? I cant think of any thing more cruel.

  • @charcounsel4432
    @charcounsel4432 5 лет назад +3

    Amazon come to Texas. We will give you tax breaks and love. I just ordered something from Amazon today. We order from Amazon ALL THE TIME. Texas loves Amazon...and Toyota cause we got that too now. God bless Texas.

  • @mfchimichanga
    @mfchimichanga 6 лет назад +7

    They're looking more and more like California.

  • @ur_cowboy
    @ur_cowboy 6 лет назад +11

    Amazon should move hq to detroit. Can you imagine

    • @jason200912
      @jason200912 6 лет назад +1

      yay daily robbery. just kidding, they move to wherever they get the biggest tax exemption or lowest expenses in general.

    • @lumox7
      @lumox7 6 лет назад

      They could buy 100% of Detroit.

    • @robertbarr6954
      @robertbarr6954 6 лет назад

      Carbon Addiction yes they need to go where they will be appreciated.

    • @maxdecphoenix
      @maxdecphoenix 6 лет назад

      Why the fuck would they move to Detroit? Detroit had the reputation it does because of the same idiots now destroying Seattle. They're still there, they never left; the same idiots who destroyed Detroit are still there. Fighting over the vacant buildings, crumbling infrastructure and 'revenue' which doesn't exist. They're crying about companies who left the state 50 years ago! Completely oblivious to why things are the way they are. Yea, property's cheap, but then what?

  • @kygent508
    @kygent508 6 лет назад +3

    I thought amazon was a social justice company and if they are shouldn't they be glad to pay and if they are a social justice company they should pay a lot more.

  • @brandonlesko8195
    @brandonlesko8195 6 лет назад +16

    2:44. Help the “homless” spell gooder.

  • @solideogloria9320
    @solideogloria9320 6 лет назад +1

    they are demanding - under penalty of the law - 500 bucks a head for having full time employees, and then accuse amazon of extortion.

  • @rickyv4616
    @rickyv4616 5 лет назад +3

    Don't bite the hand that feeds

  • @ennad4516
    @ennad4516 6 лет назад +14

    Has anyone bothered to look at how much their bike lanes are costing tax payers? That is plenty of money to house the homeless....

    • @chrisrawr6177
      @chrisrawr6177 5 лет назад +1

      Only $12 million per mile for less then %3 of the population paid for by higher fees for tabs on cars.

    • @thurstonrider
      @thurstonrider 5 лет назад

      For the anti bicycle crowds, leave the topic of bike lanes out since it does not belong in response to the housing crisis. Shame to those who are discriminating against any politician who is not a white Male NY business tycoon and president of the old USA.

    • @thurstonrider
      @thurstonrider 5 лет назад

      @Charming Billy, yes you are right when you mention about taxes and the relation to such applications. However I do believe people can deal with problems in relation to socioeconomic changes without discrimination. And yes I do ride a bike for the sake of saving on gas costs and reducing my carbon footprint--it actually doesn't hurt and it's more enjoyable than driving on our outdated infranstructure with heated tempers flaring behind the wheel.

  • @IdahoPatty
    @IdahoPatty 5 лет назад +2

    Your right John, why should the worlds richest man who owns the worlds most profitable company pay any taxes at all? I mean he doesn’t pay any federal taxes... and he makes billions in profit every year... That $275 per head might put him out of business.
    The fact that he doesn’t build buildings with accessible bathrooms or lunch ares for his employees is all because he HAS to save a few buck because of all of those TAXES...
    Oh wait... I said he doesn’t pay taxes...
    🤔

  • @robertphillips6296
    @robertphillips6296 3 года назад +1

    If the Politicians wanted to give Homeless People a place to live then they should invite them into their own homes.

  • @mattatat1138
    @mattatat1138 6 лет назад +4

    #TaxationIsTheft

  • @mattvalon4674
    @mattvalon4674 6 лет назад +7

    Best thing you can do is to leave the state. Go to a state that produces jobs and have low sales & income tax. Goodluck!

  • @secretsecret179
    @secretsecret179 5 лет назад +1

    She want's to extort the money, but when they refuse to pay she calls it extortion.

  • @TonyPerezDFWRE
    @TonyPerezDFWRE 4 года назад +1

    There was a time when Bank of America and Wells Fargo were headquartered in San Francisco. The pioneered the "tax them until they move away" process of creating huge economic problems for their communities. I'm sure Seattle leadership thinks "That could never happen to us!" I'm the meantime, there's a steady stream of business moving out of states like that and into those states who show appreciation for the jobs businesses provide.

  • @iidkwhatnameuse
    @iidkwhatnameuse 6 лет назад +4

    i love u stossel. even though i disagree with a lot of the things you say, i love that you use facts and theories and calmly state in an educated manner your opinion which is why i love listening to you. both the left and the right have the problem of just screaming and not presenting facts, but you do not, which is why I love watching/listening to you all the time.

  • @X9Diamond
    @X9Diamond 5 лет назад +3

    Good old Socialism, destroying bussineses and blaming it on the free market.

  • @mattias1234
    @mattias1234 3 года назад +1

    "Collecting more taxes than is absolutely necessary is legalized robbery."
    (Quotes from President Calvin Coolidge)

  • @SkinnyCow.
    @SkinnyCow. 5 лет назад +1

    Amazon and Walmart destroyed many self employed small business people, putting them out of business. The former business owners then have to work for the big corporations at half what they used to earn as corporate profits continue to rise.

  • @lukeadamek685
    @lukeadamek685 6 лет назад +4

    Ok guys, I'm a Seattlite. I was born in Seattle in 2001 when the average house price was $230,000 and now, 17 years later the average price of a home is almost at $900,000. The school systems here require teachers to have masters degrees in teaching. These teachers are then only paid $55,000 a year. That's not even enough to get by with most apartments. I have a few teachers that have a 1 hour+ commute to work each day. Seattle's big "boom" with Amazon has hurt my city. Houses prices have increase exponentially and us Seattle natives are being pushed out of our homes. Alot of Amazon employees are not from the north west. Our beautiful city has only been hurt by Amazons growth.

    • @homewall744
      @homewall744 6 лет назад +1

      Don't believe that. A new teacher just started and brings home more than $60,000/year. www.seattletimes.com/business/student-loan-debt-stresses-out-a-new-elementary-school-teacher/

    • @sergioesamayoa
      @sergioesamayoa 6 лет назад +1

      > The school systems here require teachers to have masters degrees in teaching. These teachers are then only paid $55,000 a year
      If that were true you should have one of the better nation wide results but as everywhere else in US I only can find BAD THINGS about Seattle's school system.
      > That's not even enough to get by with most apartments.
      Bad for them but if they are good and have master degrees would be easy for they to get a better job elsewhere, isn't?
      > I have a few teachers that have a 1 hour+ commute to work each day.
      Most people have that problem.
      > Seattle's big "boom" with Amazon has hurt my city
      So this new tax is an invitation for then to leave?
      > Houses prices have increase exponentially
      Simply offer and demand - What the HELL they teach you in schools nowadays? Is BASIC ECONOMICS!
      > us Seattle natives are being pushed out of our homes
      So they (non natives) kicked out by FORCE to the natives? So the police (and city counsel) allowed that?
      Or perhaps they SOLD to newcomers?
      > A lot of Amazon employees are not from the north west.
      So what?
      They use their salary to CONSUME goods and services in Seattle, isn't?
      That means more grocery stores, restaurants, medics, gas stations, etc. > COMMERCE! BUSINESSES!
      > Our beautiful city has only been hurt by Amazons growth.
      You are a STUPID KID full of BULL SHIT - if you really are 17 is not you, is what your parents or elder family members believe.

    • @Rambleon444
      @Rambleon444 6 лет назад

      $61,800 according to the article. Also, remember teachers work 185 days a year. Giving them time to make more in the summer or holiday seasonal work. A top-notch educator can also make $85 an hour for tutoring too.

    • @lukeadamek685
      @lukeadamek685 6 лет назад

      Sergio Samayoa as housing prices increase so does taxes. Basic stuff right? Owning a house in Ballard (a shitty neighborhood 20 years ago) would cost $350,000.
      Nowadays it costs $1,200,000. Personally I like living in the same house my whole life instead of having to move because of the increase in property taxes

    • @lukeadamek685
      @lukeadamek685 6 лет назад

      Sergio Samayoa also please don't be hostile. We are here to learn not to argue. Save that for your d&d group

  • @aliecat1999
    @aliecat1999 6 лет назад +11

    You cut off the quote about the steel a bit
    "Welded splices shall be of ASTM A706 steel
    reinforcement."
    Its a certified grade of steel reinforcement in concrete so your building doesnt fall down. If you have a problem with the American Society for Testing Materials then I suggest you make a more cohesive argument than "why does the meany government not want buildings to fall in on people"

    • @Levitiy
      @Levitiy 6 лет назад +25

      Construction companies wouldn't want buildings to fall on their clients either.
      Don't pretend building codes can't be riddled with favors to connected suppliers.

    • @aliecat1999
      @aliecat1999 6 лет назад

      if you can demonstrate this happening stopping it should be an easy bipartisan decision

    • @lisaadler507
      @lisaadler507 6 лет назад

      911?

    • @RezaQin
      @RezaQin 6 лет назад +3

      The problem is that there is never a bipartisan solution. The Democrats in our government are so heavy handed and the Republicans are feckless. Even if the Repubs stepped up and actually took control and turned the direction of the government actually conservative, the Democrats would whine and cry about how they didn't have a bipartisan choice. If it were the other way, the Democrats would scoff and not care if the Repubs said the same thing.

    • @aliecat1999
      @aliecat1999 6 лет назад +1

      You got it backwards. The democrats are spineless, moderate cowards that give every concession to the republicans just to be spat on

  • @ericwsmith7722
    @ericwsmith7722 6 лет назад +3

    "The problem with socialism is eventually you run out of other peoples money" --- Margaret Thatcher

  • @nwblader6231
    @nwblader6231 3 года назад +1

    “Head tax” great way to 1) drive away companies and 2)encourage companies to automate jobs getting rid of those jobs for ever

  • @trevorthefilthyrat3742
    @trevorthefilthyrat3742 5 лет назад +1

    "When injustice becomes justice resistance becomes every Americans duty to throw off all oppressors foren or domestic"
    Thomas Jefferson...
    And that goes for corrupt corporations that think they can make up laws that only benefit them and hurts the middle class.

  • @nementerc7316
    @nementerc7316 6 лет назад +1

    Always logical and clarifying. Good job!

  • @bono894
    @bono894 6 лет назад +1

    I wonder how much of this homelessness can be attributed in some way to the $15 minimum wage in Seattle.

  • @leonelhernandez220
    @leonelhernandez220 4 года назад +1

    They meant to say... free everything is a human right! Bunch of BS

  • @Smiles4UFL
    @Smiles4UFL 6 лет назад

    Why in the world would a business be helped responsible for the shortcomings of City Hall, I will never know! This is ridiculous!!

  • @secretsecret179
    @secretsecret179 5 лет назад +1

    Councilwoman: "Let's keep fighting"!!! Getting opposition. "But if we fight among each other..."

  • @jaybee3165
    @jaybee3165 2 года назад

    great segment john. keep it up.

  • @banno6938
    @banno6938 5 лет назад +1

    Guess what folks , you're now working 39 hours & 59 minutes a week.

  • @renrosemary9882
    @renrosemary9882 4 года назад +2

    "Supporters of big government aren't used to having workers drown *them* out."
    😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂😂

  • @isaackrementsov2029
    @isaackrementsov2029 6 лет назад

    Thank you, John Stossel.

  • @Friedrich-Wilhelm-1980
    @Friedrich-Wilhelm-1980 6 лет назад +1

    if i was the owner of amazon i would pull up all stakes and get the hell out of dodge that is just a temporary agreement and the second amazon comite they will nail them to the wall

  • @theilluminati7287
    @theilluminati7287 4 года назад +1

    So basically its the government trying to solve the problems it created

  • @someguynamedpaul
    @someguynamedpaul 4 года назад

    This $500 head tax is one of the stupidest things I’ve ever heard in my life! I can’t believe they thought this would’ve been a good idea.

  • @fathertimeandmothernature6627
    @fathertimeandmothernature6627 6 лет назад +3

    "Homelessness has doubled in the last 8 years"
    Gosh who was the POTUS for most of that time? I'm having trouble recalling his name. It was slightly terrorist sounding yet people kept calling him the Messiah. Can someone help me with this?????

  • @derekperry1745
    @derekperry1745 5 лет назад

    That tax is utterly irresponsible! How did nobody realize before it was passed that it would encourage companies to either hire less workers, or leave the city altogether!? What an idiotic tax.

  • @charlesmascari8197
    @charlesmascari8197 6 лет назад

    I don't think politicians who have never had a "real" job and mismanage their own city's finances, should be telling businesses how to do business.

  • @drewconway7135
    @drewconway7135 6 лет назад +1

    I live in Seattle, and I agree with you. This tax is ill-conceived, and is going to scare away businesses. This happened once before, and Boeing moved its headquarters to Chicago. People don’t learn.

  • @ClubMayview
    @ClubMayview 6 лет назад +1

    That's what amazon gets for going to a unfriendly city.

  • @Tom-iv2gj
    @Tom-iv2gj 5 лет назад

    Your the best John. Thanks for the videos

  • @nonebiz2132
    @nonebiz2132 4 года назад

    The people creating this problem are the land investment companies, who also happen to have most of the politicians in the city in their back pocket. The properties they own go up in value, while they don't have to do any work or put out a dime.
    Restructuring rentals and taking the obscene profits out of them is really the only thing this country needs to dramatically raise the standard of living for every citizen.

  • @mikram2613
    @mikram2613 5 лет назад

    The city officials at the top are making 400,000 to 500,000 a year, so they tax businesses on top of the taxation to pay for the homeless, come on man!!!

  • @adamcarlone
    @adamcarlone 6 лет назад

    Punishing companies for hiring people doesn't make any sense, how does that fix anything?

  • @treepizzle
    @treepizzle 4 года назад +1

    Haha. Amazon is leaving Seattle for Bellevue. Love it.

  • @Overlordpaco
    @Overlordpaco 6 лет назад +2

    I loved it when the construction workers showed up xD

  • @joelklimkowski1643
    @joelklimkowski1643 6 лет назад

    The money they spent on picket-signs could feed the Homeless for a few months. How Virtuous and Brave they seem.

  • @Avalanche2
    @Avalanche2 6 лет назад

    And when the businesses leave, they will have the audacity to act shocked and pretend they don't know why.

  • @mrade5321
    @mrade5321 6 лет назад

    It's not just going on in seattle. People are getting taxed left, right and centre all over the place. I done an extra shift at work and got an extra £53.Because of that, my council tax payment for next month increased by just over £56. It actually cost me money to go and do an extra days work. The company I work for and the council are better off and I am worse off. WTF?

  • @Mars-rl1vt
    @Mars-rl1vt 5 лет назад +1

    Denver will slowly but surely be the economical capital of the USA.

  • @justing7490
    @justing7490 6 лет назад

    Isn't it crazy how there's ton of homeless people in areas where politicians approve tons of big government policies?

  • @Sirhc2023
    @Sirhc2023 6 лет назад

    That shouldn't be corporate problem to bail out local government issues.

  • @bruceeferry940
    @bruceeferry940 6 лет назад

    The real problem is greedy people raising rents just because they can. Seattle and all of western Washington really should enact rent controls.

  • @markdodds1110
    @markdodds1110 6 лет назад

    Around 4 years ago I decided to never accept work where I would have to interact with the City of Seattle again. My stress level dropped and my gusto for life returned. I use the term "government abuse" whenever I talk about the City of Seattle and their outrageous regulations and governmental review policies.