My gratitude to Engineer sahib for being available for this podcast. Difference of opinion is essential for the progression of knowledge and accords with Islamic spirit of 'husool e ilm'. I would request all to please keep it civilised. Let's create an enlightened atmosphere for that is need of the hour.
Engineer is favorite because he is not intellectually dishonest like you. Woh dil say baat krta hay. Sahi ho ya ghalat woh alag baat hay. Magar tum aik artificial khotay ho. yeh baat bilkul sahi hay.
Ma-Shaa-ALLAH عزوجل ! ! ! Well Needed PODCAST especially for Intellectuals. Keep on preaching ISLAM without any Sectarianism. May ALLAH guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! ! My Salute for all the TRUTH Lovers. Al-hamduLILLAH ! !
App ko us begairat aurat ke khilaaf attacking Rukh apnana chahiye tha Un ki kitaabon se unke god ram ne bhi 6 saal ki ladki se hi shaadi ki thi Refrence Skanda Purana book 3 bhag (hissa) 2 chap 30 verse 8-9 8-9. The bow of Isvara that was kept in the abode of Janaka, was broken. In his fifteenth year, O king, Rāma married the six-year old [1] beautiful daughter of the king of Mithila, Sītā who was not born of a womb. On getting Sītā, Raghava became contented and happy And ramayana book 3 sarg 47 Flat Earth unki book me hai Pin 📌 Padma Purana book 1 chapter 3 verse 55 55. The beginningless supreme being, then having flattened the earth, piled the mountains on it according to (its) divisions
It seems like this is the first time someone is asking to Muhammad Ali Mirza such questions that have sparked a considerable debate among intellectuals regarding Muhammad Ali Mirza speeches and speaking style. Hats off to Qaisar Ahmed Raja for maintaining his perspective even after meeting Muhammad Ali Mirza and for continuing to ask him questions. Much respect to you, Raja Sahab!
Where ??? Qaser sab was agreed to every explanation Mirza gave, i dont know waht he said which was not known or refuted by Mirza Ali. Waht Raja sab should understand that democracy has been already destroyed in Pakistan and he thinks that one day "his party" will be allowed by "company" to democratically get majority and implement islam that is called day dreaming, and now he seeing this and silent that its Ok for Army to destroy whole democratic system because this time its not JI.
@@ranaumaratiq7540lol ek jawab nhi Diya sirf whataboutry.. aur nupur sharma k sawal par kya bakwas ki engineer sahab ne... last me khud mana k usne gustakhi to karni hi thi....to kyu bola tha ki "tasleem rahmani bada mujrim hai" jab maloom tha k usne gustakhi karni hi thi.. fir ye kyu kaha tha ki "wo to react kar gai kyunki musalman ne uthaya tha" abb ye jhooth bol rha hai aur Puri story change kar diya... fir suno wo jawab
اللہ کا شکر ہے کہ کم از کم آج ہمارے میں ایسے لوگ پیدا ہونا شروع ہو گئے ہیں جو مہذب انداز میں دین کے اوپر گفتگو کرتے ہیں اور اپنی آراہ پیش کرتے ہیں۔ مجھے بہت بہتری کی امید ہے انشاءاللہ۔
@@faizanaslam8687 i think you are over exaggerating. I was just praising the discussion between two highly intellectuals. I suppose you are following people with IQ below freezing point. now the puzzle for you to solve is to find the people in Islam with IQ below freezing point. your mind will be broaden .. I hope so
keun angrezi ki maar rhey ho. uss ne urdu main likha hai. tum bhi urdu main likh do. angrezi main chawal marney se chawal intellectual lagti hai magar hoti chawal hi hai. @@showkathamidmir7920
Absurd Mirza In 4:29, he quotes an ayat about shirk that people were one before they did ikhtelaf. So he says that this ayat is mentioning about shirk and so the people who followed the messengers become successful while the other failed. Then goes on to mentions the two sects, based on two different cities, whose elders erred in their books according to him. So in the context of the ayat he presented, one should dissociate from one group and join other as the ayat mentions acc to him that only one group was successful. So If someone doesn't do this he would fail to act on this ayat acc to him and if someone does follow one group then he is actually advocating for something i.e firqawariyat which he says he is against to and that his aim to dig old books is not to clash against each other. This is how delusional he is
1---Quran me firke banana haram ho fir bhi firkaprast molvi Quran ki haram karda cheej ko halal bataye to usska Quran pr iman kaise hai? 2--Quran ki ek bhi ayat ka inkar krne wala kafir ho sakta hai to firkaprast molvi kufr pr kyu nahi hai? 3--Allah Or Allah ke rasool(s.a.v) ne jb ummat ka nam muslim rakha hai to phir firkaprast molvi jo alag alag nam rakhne pr biddati kyu nahi hai?
tumara ya sab murtad ki bheja rakhi hai AWAZ A HAQ live,qaiser Raza Ahmed, abuzar respond, smile2jannah, Elaina ali, Mufti Yasir Nadeem al wajhidi, Islamic awenking na aur jin murtado ki baat tum kar raha hu na ukna bolo galat information deta hai 😂😂😂
A lot of youtubers, content creators, intellectuals have done a podcast with Engineer Shb but so far I believe that this the best ever podcast highlighting the aspects that were put under the carpet. I hope Raja Shb will come again with more of these type of questions. Hats off to both of you. We really need to preach and practice the teachings of Islam without amy bias and definitely Islam has the solution to all the problems of humanity.
Engineer sahab ki misaal aisay hai jaisay koi kahay "Utho, Mat Betho" phr jab koi pochay ke aap uthny ka q kah rahay hain to wuh comma agay kardetay hain ke mainay to "Utho Mat, Betho" kaha tha, Lakin Sallam hai Qaiser Ahmed Raja Sahab ko jinhun ny ALLAH ke fazal se completely expose kardia...
Not at all reasonable or intellectual. Just big words and loaded questions. He did not even do proper research on Er's stance. PS: I do not agree with Engineer Mirza as well.
I have to admit that this episode genuinely impressed me. It was both refreshing and fascinating to see how both hosts respectfully participated in a substantive argument. Your podcast stands out for promoting open-mindedness and civil discourse, which is becoming an increasingly rare type of content. I appreciate the effort you made to create a space where diverse viewpoints can coexist harmoniously. It's a testament to the quality of your content and the maturity of your discussions. Keep up the excellent work, and I look forward to more thought-provoking episodes.
Watching this after pakistans defeat in asia cup. Match sara bhool gaya. Amazing podcast!! with so much positive opinions from both sides. I can see that now vast majority of muslims especially youth want to be united against division in islam and its very positive sign. Alhumdulilah ❤
Literally, I had never seen a movie without skipping some of the parts but the way this podcast proceeded with Solid Questions by Qaisr Raja, I did not skip even a second of the whole video. Undoubtedly on the other hand the guest Mirza Ali showed good defense that's much appreciated. People need clarification about these types of things, especially Religion. I want to say this was the need of the hour and all the questions were arousing in masses that have been discussed here. Very much appreciation.
At many points Engineer sb was gone speechless and he just changed the topic and qaisar Raja sb was an amazing and tolerant person that I have ever seen, even Engineer sb did not let him speak much but qaisar's questions have explained a lot of wisdom. May Allah protect us all.
First time I'm listening Qaiser Raja sb and for the first time I really enjoyed the sitting or podcast thoroughly. I didn't even feel for a second that I m waisting my time. Don't have words to praise you both. Many more podcast like this are necessary for nation or Muslims. I would urge you both that please arrange this kind of podcast on weekly basis. You can't imagine how great it would be. JazakAllah
This was really a very nice and fruitfil podcast.I love both Engineer Mohammad Ali mirza sahib and Jinab Qaisar Raja sahib.Such people are an asset of Ummate Muslimah.
Best Podcast ever, I'm student of Engineer Mohammed Ali Bhai and I'm proud of it, and I also listen to Kaiser Ahmed Raja Sahab and his Iman Union team, ek Ali Bhai Firqawaiyat ki khilaf kaam kar rahe hai aur dusri taraf Iman Union, Mulhideen aur ethiests #Echmuslms ki khilaaf kaam kar rahe hai., proud of both of you! Lots of love from 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Aray bhai engineer sahab kaha firqawariyat k khilaf kaam kar rhe hai?? Sare maslako ki galati batana firqawariyat k khilaf kaam karna nhi hota hai.. firqawariyat k khilaf kaam karne ka matlab hota hai ki islam ki asal k taraf aao aur furoo'i masle par batna aur ladna choro.. aur uske liye asal batil k matlab ilhaf, kufr aur shirk k khilaf uthna aur ladna hota hai... engineer sahab isme se kuch nhi kar rhe hai.. engineer sahab wahi kar rhe hai jo firkawari barailvi maulvi deonandio k khilaf kar rha hai aur firkawari deobandi Maulvi barailvio k khilaf bol rha hai and so forth.. ye firkawariyat k khilaf kaam karna nhi hai balki ye bolna hai ki market me sab galat hai me sahi hu.. me emaam az Zaman hu
@@divineguidance520jab apnay babo kay naam ka kalma parh waatay ho to phir shirk kidhar jaata hay ya phir qabaro say jab MAANGTAY HO tab kidhar shirk jaata hay Aur ha jab tumhara har gali muhallay ka molvi jummay kay khutbay may apnay babo ki story aur engineee pay lantaan karwa raha ho ho kya usay nahi haq pohonchta kay wo CHISTI RASULULLAH aur ASHRAF ALI RASOOLULLAH wala zakham cheeray taakay awaam ko samajh aayay kay apnay aapko muslim kaho aur quran aur sunnat ko follow aur amal karo instead of following jo aapka molvi aapko kehta hay reference kay baghair aur out of context
This podcast was treat to watch. The true essence of Islam where you can communicate your views without having any harsh feelings. Respect for each other.
This was amazing. This actually felt like two amazing intellectuals sharing their thoughts and respecting each other's point of views which was a treat to watch. Masha Allah!
Scholars like you, is an inspiration for young Muslims like us who want to research about Islam in today's cluttered world. Such an amazing, knowledgeable, thorough podcast with difference of opinions, discussed in a peaceful and well-mannered fashion. Kindly keep making such podcasts, keep inspiring us and keep bringing the positive change. Insha'Allah Islam and Muslims will rise again.
The reason why I appreciate and respect engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza. 1 I was a brailvi and now I am only a Muslim 2 I never read whole Quran in Arabic now I have studied whole Quran with translation. Now whenever anyone tell me anything regarding Islam , I consult Quran I consult Hadees. It's all bcz of listing Ali bhai . He is one man Army . Allah bless him inshallah
Yaar tu x brelvi thaa to tb to tera bunyadi aqeeda Chishti wala jo mirza kehta hy to woh bunyadi aqeeda hy to Tery ghr walay ya Baaqi brelvi Is cheez k krny ka kehty hon gy chishti wali Kahani ka jo mirza Fit krta hy brelviyon py😂😂😂😂😂
Amazing discussion .im listening to Raja sahb first time .I've never seen Him before .im impressed by the question that represents the level of knowledge Raja sahab has . What ever is happening ,is forcing people to start immensily needed critical thinking . By the way i agree with Raja sahb vision to help different sects rather than start a war with them .
I was truly captivated by this exceptional podcast where profound and critical subjects were dissected with an unprecedented level of intellectual rigor. It's worth noting that the depth of discussion in this podcast surpasses any other in its genre, particularly with respect to the nuanced exploration of topics like secularism and Islam. Even if you are well-versed in Islamic studies, this podcast offers a unique perspective that is both enlightening and enriching. I wholeheartedly recommend this podcast to those seeking a more profound understanding of these intricate concepts. It is, without a doubt, a remarkable piece of intellectual discourse. There should be more podcasts of such caliber. MashaAllah Ustaad-e-Mohtaram! ❤️
I just came to know about Qaiser Sahab today. I found them very polite and solid in arguments. This podcast is a perfect example of how a progressive argument should be. whereas Engr Sahab is doing great as always. Thank you for contributing to the UMMAH and fighting this Fiqrawariyat! May ALLAH guide all of us toward his path of TRUTH. Aameen
Many individuals said they would ask new questions, but you truly did, and it expanded our understanding to new dimensions. Qaisar, you have done a fantastic job; keep it up.
A truly exceptional and much needed podcast for youth. The phenomenon which engineer sahab is considering as "impossible" i,e unity of Muslims under one Muslim leader, is a much needed requisite for Muslims these days. Sectarianists should watch these types of programs how two persons with different mindsets, different ideas and different interpretations of religious terminologies, can talk and LIVE peacefully. My gratitude for both of you.
I generally don't comment on any video but I must say this is one of the few times that I have seen a whole pure one and half hour long video. I have always been in a search of history and this host makes an incredibly increase in my intellectual. Hats off to both of you. Btw this is my first time watching Qaiser sb.
How a program is hosted is to be learned from Qaiser Sab. such learned yet so calm letting guest complete his point and then offering his question for further clarification.
Can't get enough of it, One of the best discussions of recent times!! Can you guys please bring out a series discussing and debating the very fundamentals of Islam and modern age menaces.
Excellent Questions by Qaiser bhai ❤ last question was my favourite in which Qaiser bhai politely showed Mirza sahab that he has become enemy of ulemas and favourite of murtads, mulhids and islamophobes. Which is an alarming call for engineer sahab
01:32:10 mere sabse favorite line puri podcast main yai hai. Lekin koi mujhe comment tab tak naa kaa re please jab tak pura video na dek le. Without skipping.
MaShaAllah amazing podcast. Loved every bit of it. Allah hum sab ko hidayat dein or Ummat e Muslimah ko ittehad or Allah or Unke Rasool SAW k dushmanon k khilaf isteqamat ata karen Ameen
I truly appreciate how both attendees managed to engage in a thoughtful and respectful discussion despite their differing viewpoints. It's refreshing to see such decency and mutual respect maintained throughout the conversation. This is exactly the kind of dialogue that promotes understanding and growth. Well done!
Ali bhai nailed it. Sir Qaisar thanks for conducting such an amazing podcast. Be Unite be one ummah Or yh nazariya mjhay 21 sal barelvi rehny sy nhi aaya Ali bhai k smjahany sy hi smjh aaya
I'm just shocked 🤯kaise engineering Mirza ke followers kitnee andhe hai, is video me Mirza ke bahot zyada danti mari hai, Nupur Sharma ka case me, abhi bol ra ke uske Sher padhne se usko mauka mila; jab ki video me ye bola tha the, Us Maulna me pahle inke mazhab ka mazaak uraya, tab jawab me Nupur Sharma ne gustakhi ki, jhoot bole ke nikal gaya, aur do-do baar daawe ke saath bol raha hai ke, mujhe koi regret nhi uske jo video banya tha uspe.🤔, Upar se agar Islamic hukumat aa jaye, magar firq maujood rahe, toh Mirza nhi chahata ke kabhi aise Islamic hukumat aaye 😒, Matlab ke abhi toh na Islamic hukumat hai, aur na is musalmaano ka etihad (unity) Toh kam se kam Islamic hukumat aa jaye, toh isko gawara nhi. Firqa kharam hota jo is almost impossible hai, wo kaam isko pahle karna hai, jab tak ko modernity/ secularism ke aar me job bhi bachi khuchi Islaam hai, wo bhi khatam kar le. Haar baat pe deo-barevli gusnana; Koi bhi Deobandi ya Barelvi ka Kalma Chisti ya Asraf ali Rasoollah nhi hai, phir bhi bol raha hai, ke Ghamdi toh inlogon se behtar hai. Apni koi bhi galti accept mat karo, Qaiser sb. ko bolo ke apni Ghamdi ke video dekhe aapke misunderstanding khatam ho jayegi 🤣, fir bol ra, ke Ghamdi ke khilaaf sabse zyada mere videos hai, .... kuch bhi. Bol raha hai, atheism pe sirf isme videos banaya hai, baad baki koi firka kuch nhi kiya, Islam ke khilaaf kuch bhi ho, ausko yahi address karta hai, har cheez yahi defend karta hai... Bhai Itne mahaan hai Engineering sab, lagta hai, ke Salaf e Saliheen ke baad sirf ek hi banda ayaa wo Hai Mirza 🤣; baki baki imaam khud jiske kitaab padhta hai, jiske jariye Islaam ham tak pahuch, wo log Islaam ko khatam karne pe tule the, kya kya bataon time kam hai, Last me Qaiser Sb ne bol hi diya, ke wo har baat se agree nhi karte 😅,fir bhi kya kare, Qaiser sb chahte to uski chori pe collar pakarte, but unhone se chor diya especially in case of Nupur Sharma. Aur bhi mere ye kahtam hai, apas ke disagreement kabhi khatam nhi hone wale, shuru se itkhteef chale aaya hai, but isko negatively nhi dekha gaya, aur koi problem bhi nhi hua, ye engineering jabardasti sab ko ek understanding pe lana chata hai; Ambiyan A.S ne sirf dawat diya kuch ne qubool kiya kuch ne nhi kiya. But ye toh thaan rakha hai, Ilmi kitabi (Deen-E-Mirza) qubool karna hi parega, begair inke khilaafat ke bare me sochna hi mat. To be practical main Khood ek strict/orthodox Sunni hoon (matlab Barelvi hi ho, magar mere Barelvi ka definition kuch aur hai aur tumhara kuch aur 😅 (actually main Kitabi Barelvi hoon,) jokes apart mujhe khud Deobandi - Wahabi interpretation sahi nhi lagta, jab Quran o Hadees ko dekha toh mera aqeeda jo bana wo Barelvi se zyada match kar tha (you can say I'm purified Barelvi, kyuki bahot sare khurafat logon se apne se izaad ki hai) Main deo-wahab ke puchi namaz bhi nhi padhta. Still I want, ke apas ke itkhtelaaf ko side rakh kar, Islaam ke liya bahot kuch kiya ja skta hai, like Islamic hukumat me kya hi dikkat, raha jo Mirza bol raha hai, ke kafir samjhe gya etc, sab bakwaas hai, He is using logical fallacy; koi kisi ko kafir kuch nhi bole ga. Khair choro kitna baat bole, but Mirza is not benifitting Islam at all, ulta nuqaan dera as is case, ke jabtak firqa khatam nhi hota, tab tak usko Islamic jamhuriyat nhi chahiye. Upar se druv rathee jo khud athiest hai usko promote karta hai, + ulama ke bare me negatively failta rahta hai, + secularism wagaira ko promote kar deta hai (yaha galti chupa raha hai), I really see him as a danger to Islam. And Allah knows the best.
I have been watching lectures and interviews of Engineer Sahib for sometime now and for the first time I saw him on defensive due to your thoroughly researched and highly articulated questions. Kudos for such an incredible interview.
@@easypaisa5719 lol it's very clear... if you were not his blind follower you could have seen. On RSS point alone, engineer had no come back and he was looking lost and came up with nothing but ' Pakistan me bhi RSS ' hai :D. lol that proves he's a juggat baaz of street level which can't comprehend bigger picture or understand what's going on or he's doing everything deliberately... He's clueless about Iqbal and Jinnah's evolution but trying to degrade them and even Pakistan...... Also, his usage of words secular etc in casual way creates problem for him . Qiaser sahab countered him about that then he acted like a immature person and said ' i didn't mean secular in that way' lol. We all know Secular is used only in one sense..... and there are lot more points which totally exposed him. Alhumdulillah.... Truth comes out sooner or later...that's what happening with Engineer Mirza now.. he can't deal with people who are more educated and aware than him
@@easypaisa5719 me ne pura comment kr Diya h. Tmhry Pas ak b jawab ni? Bas pata chal gayi haqeqqat. Blind follower of engineer who's truly exposed now. Alhumdulillah. Truth always comes out. Educated logon k agay ye thehr ni sakta iska rang utar Gaya h Puri video m saaf nazar arha h. Ye sirf apnay jahil tolay k Samny zuban chalata h Jo sir Hilaty rehty Hain dimagh apna band kiye. 😂 Sach Samny AGaya h....
Wonderful podcast. This should have been the standard of all podcasts. Hats off to Mr. Qaisar and a lot of love and respect for Ali Bhai ❤️ Loved his final answer about legacy.
Aaj tk me ny engineer k jitNy bi vlogs ya podcast sunny hayn., yeh wala behtareen hyn... BEHTAREEN IN TERMS K SAMNY WALA BANDA TAGRAAA BETHA HYN.... JIS NY PAKRRR K RAKHA HYN.... WARNA TO ENGINEER APNI BACHELOR DEGREE KA ROOB HAR PODCASTER BECHARY PAR THOMPTA REHTA HYN K MAI PARHA LIKHA HON., TUSSI KUCH VI NAHI... INTIHAAYE MUFEED BAATYN HOWE HYN... ALLAH BLESS QAISER AHMED RAJA SAHIB... KEEP IT UP....
Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza is the smartest man on this planet right now no one can beat him in terms of logic and facts everything he says is just mind-blowing Allah ALI bhai ki hifazit kry AMEEN
MashaAllah very intellectual podcast !! Emam has very vast knowledge about Deen and as well as Academic !! Pure Gem 💎 And hats off to QAR for conducting this podcast and ask intellectual questions ...
Oh my God! Can't believe that a man (Qaiser Ahmed Raja) can counter question with Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza (my teacher) like this. This is the best ever podcast one ever recorded with the great EMAM. And the way EMAM has listened to every question and responded is just amazing.
This was the best podcast till date, questions were great and the discussion on both sides was also great. Enjoyed watching and learned a lot. Need another session like this with new questions
@@azeemmalik2598 e.g youngsters don't keep a beard due to iqbal. Iqbal supported communism. He is just a student with basic knowledge meant to shock people.
What an Amazing , Thoughtful and Ideological Podcast. Extremely brilliant questioning by Qaisrer Raja sb and excellent clarification by Engr Muhammad Ali Mirza sb 💯
Both of them are golden assets of Islamic Ummah but Mirza sahab is shining 🌟 more in this podcast. The difference of opinion between intellectuals is beneficial for reasoning to evolve. The critical questions of Raja sahab were much necessary for our better understanding of the thoughts of Mirza sahab. Eventually the best podcast (as per my knowledge) of Mirza sahab where same old questions were not repeated. Love them both. ❤
Wherever Raja saab caught engineer next word comes out of his mouth I agree with u. 😂 in past interviews he never said anything like this and he always very aggressive. In this interview Raja saab tamb him. Particularly on issue of socialism, secularism and his ignorant about issues.
@@user-3013 Right, its his toughest. And if theres a winner. For first time its other than Ali bhai Raja sb is very intellectual. I didn't know such people existed in Pakistan.
@@user-3013 most of the times Raja sahab agreed with Mirza sahab, does that mean Raja sahab was caught by him? The difference of opinion within intellectuals is not from today and will not end tomorrow, it will remain, we have to adjust our minds to the reality.
Masha'Allah Masha'Allah ❤ No Mufti, No Other Aalim can answer such intellectual questions. They literally stand no chance against an Engineer. Hats Off to you EMAM
Engineer saheb is neither 100 person right nor 100 per cent wrong. The problem with Pakistan is that what should be discussed and implemented by the governments is being discussed by anyone and everyone. It is so sad to see the collapse of our society in every sphere.
I too loved his confidence while misleading conversation and avoiding the Actual Questions. Solid points were though missing From Engineer Ali Bhai, But Qaiser bhai provided them so all good❤️
@@aqeelaaqeela8941 U sure I'm having Lack of Cognitive Ability? Cuz it seems you weren't able to decipher a simple Comment, I meant misleading conversation to avoid Direct questions and not Misleading ideology of Viewers. But it's a different fact that he does mislead Youth with a lower IQ. Ofcourse I don't mean you have a Low IQ brother, or are you?
All the RUclipsrs with not enough knowledge came to the academy and asked the usual questions with no knowledge of islam, so they could do nothing except accepting the thoughts of eng Muhammad ali mirza. First time a knowledgeable personality sat with him and ended up without accepting all of his answers. Gave a tough time to him and recorded the podcast in very manar environment. Really Really appreciated Raja Sahab 👍👍... Hats off to you 🤞
@@Sushil1974just like a person who will be crossing borders illegally the person will be killed So The sharia court will give a death penalty to the murtad just like that
@@Sushil1974exmuslim kesy... Kya ap ne deen ka theka le rakha he jb tk koi khud ye iqrar na kar de k wo muslim nai ap ksi pe apna tappa ni laga skte sahab
Khayalati dunia sy bahir aain.. engineer sab k karway sch ka samna krin.. wo batin hum hazam ni kr skty jo engineer sab ny ki es ly qaisr sab ap ko chay hoy lag rhy hai
@@deenkihaqeeqat2259 qasir sab agr khalafat k khilaf hoty to PDM PTI ke supporter hoty, sahil adeem or qasir sab ma khilafat ko lanay k method ka faraq ha .... in dono ma khilafat k hawalay sa wohi faraq ha jo JI or Dr israr sab k nazrya ma ha....
I really very happy to see this type of discussion.I think this type of intellectual person should be united at one plateform.specially QAR,Mufti Yasir, Muhammad Ali Mirza,and sahil adeem.
The best podcast i have ever seen in my life , respect to both of men , although i have some differences with engineer sahab but still i love both of them for the sake of ALLAH. may ALLAH bless both of them in this dunya and in akhirah , ameen.
@@WajihaImran-iu3po bhai apki ghalty ni es me. Apki tarbiat sai ni hui. Oper se ap es qadyani murabbi k follower bn gae jis k lye awwaleen shart andha behra or dimagh se khali hona shart he.
Lu ji ya lag khlafet ka nizam la ka ayn gy Jo ilme ikhtalaf par dosroon ko qadiani ya qafer decleyer kar date ha😂Ap log bas khlafat khlafat khail sakte han😂😂😂
As an Indian Muslim, I am disappointed that Engineer Mirza is not concerned with avoiding giving talking points to the Hindutva terrorist organizations like RSS! He says he is not a liberal , but he has the “yeh to Pakistan mein bhi hota hai” attitude for every atrocity against the Muslims in India!
Arey yeh Librandus sab Hinduo ke gulaam hai.😂 Inko hinduo seh support, views aur kuch ko toh funding bhi milti hai. Pata nahi woh ISI kidhar busy hai.... dushman ander bhi hai. Khulke usko indian hindutva sanghiyo seh support bhi araha hai
A very unique podcast and relevant questions rather than the redundant format of other podcasts we have seen of engineer sahab. No disrespect to other podcaster or youtubers but this one was very creative due to its style of questioning and hats off to engineer sahab for coming so forthright with his answers. Salute to Raja sahab for bringing us a differing dynamics in the podcast culture. It was a intellectually sound and spiritually fulfilling conversation. It is an asset for the youth to come. Regards to both of you. On a side note I would add to the last comment by Raja sahab: "Banda iss zindagi which apne app to we mutmahin ho jaave tey badi gal ey!"
Concept of graduality of Qaiser bhai is a gem......... Christianity leads to atheism through the convept of theism ...... Same way..... Islamic secularism leads to secularism leads to liberalism leads to atheism......
Qaisar Sahab has a very balanced mature and intellectually sound approach and is doing excellent work. This podcast helps us understand where Mirza Sahab is coming from and I feel Mirza Sahab would do well to take Qaisar Sahab's advice and that would help him unleash his true potential. Mirza Sahab is capable of a lot of positivity and this podcast helps us see that.
Engineer sahib has a practical prospect. Qaiser sahib has more of the idealistic islamic prospect good for academics but not implement able. Overall as expected both of them are the blessings for whole of the ummah
Your comment is the EXACT point I had in mind while discussing this podcast with a couple of guys on social media. Raja Sahib is very ambitious, but a bit too idealistic in his dream of establishing a khilafat asap in Pakistan. Engineer Ali knows the sectarian system inside out, and therefore believes that sectarianism is the cancer that needs to be removed in order to progress.
Qaisar Ahmad Raja sahb or Engineer Ali mirza sahb dono he apni jgah py bht acha kam kr rhy hen, or meri shadeed khawhish hai k kam az kam in ko ek page py rehna chahiye, aisy log jo deen k sath mukhlis hen in ko apas men ikhtilafaat ko hal kr lena chahiye..
I have watched Qaiser Ahmed Raja's podcast with Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza, Qaiser bhai asked very good questions. If I had met the Engineer Sahib, I would have asked almost the same questions. Qaiser Bhai was trying to talk about something intellectual but Engineer Sahib was in the same mood "I don't know the question but Sectarianism (فرقہ واریت) is the answer". I know sectarianism (فرقہ واریت) is the biggest problem of the Ummah (I also face it almost on a daily basis) but many things are yet to be discussed. And some extremist Hindus in India who use the video of Engineer Mohammad Ali Mirza to defend themselves. Sir, discuss this topic again, if you can speak for 2 hours on Maulana of another Sect, then discuss it at least once. Qaiser Ahmed Raja was trying to convince Ali bhai to talk about this but the Engineer sahib did not take it seriously. Note: This is my opinion, you can agree or disagree with it.
I agree with you engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza will become sacrificial lamb if he doesn't clarify himself to greater extent because he'll get misquoted badly
@@openmicconversationofficia714 Sawal hi qaiser aisa poochhte thay k unka sirf ek hi answer hai firqawariyat aur Engineer sahab ne bohot badiya jawab Diya...
engineer sahab sach aur haq baat boltay hain,ye jo baat samjana chahtay hain ,afsoos wo baat hum sab main pehlay sy majood hone chayieh thei,duniya ky her muslim ka ka rastay ek hai bus engineer sab hum sab ko use ek rastay per chalana chahtay hain,inshalla Allah hum sab ko seday aur ek rastay per chalnay ki tafeeq ata krey aur engineer sahab jasay log her jaga farahum krey taqi koi rasta batak na jae
Yes I agree Engineers have very good ideas, let's check them Islam is compatible with Secularism Pakistani Muslims have no chance of winning over Israel Boycott of Israeli product is Against Islam Still if you are going to defend him then frankly speaking, Mirza Ali is a New Baba of his sect
Welldone Sir Qaiser you really showed your intelligence by asking such questions which others couldn’t have asked or have lacked in knowledge regarding those matters.. Great work to have strong minds together to evaluate the facts about the critical topics of era..
After so many 'unimpressive' podcasts in which repetitive questions were being asked,.... here is the genuine interview with attacking questions pushing Engineer sahb really hard,... i hv listened this man, the host, fr the first time and i am impressed by the depth of his knowledge and the approach he applies to understand an issue,... it was a commendable podcast
@@deenkihaqeeqat2259 hum yeh nhi kehtay ky engineer saab ki sare baatai galat ha hum unko bi suntay ha aur iktelaafi raai rakhtay ha unse andi taqleed kay hum kayel nhi hum sab sa ilmi iktelaaf rakhtay ha .inko yeh problem ha ky yeh baataou ko gumatay ha bht zaada yeh baat ka seeda jawaab nhi detay ha
@@Sushil1974 murtadd ka ilaj qiyamat tak nhi ho sakta. Khuda ki zamin par Khuda ki nafarmani. Jo 1 Khuda ko nhi maanta vo majbur me har chiz ko Khuda bana leta he. Majburi n ho to khud hi Khuda ban jata he. Is liye murtadd logo ko pagal khane bhej dena chahiye. Movt tak maanne wale nhi
Ma Shaa Allah Qaiser sahib very nicely amd honest session. As usual Engineer Sahib best introduction is always negative and he Ma Shaa Allah proof everyone wrong. May Allah Subhan o Talaa protect from any type of sharr and keep him strong and full of emaan Ameen
1:05:14 exactly. I am an Indian and this is a fact.. Yahan k musalmano k dilo me ulamao k lie nafrat pida ki jaa rhi.. madaris k lie nafrat paida ki jaa rhi jis wajah se kuch hadd taq musalmandeen ulama aur madaris se door ja rhe. Bahot hi sahi sawal kia aapne..❤ thanks for pointing this out . 1:07:06 kind of this is true in northern India
Bhai agr RSS apko Quran ki aik ayat out of context la kr dkhaye to ap agr usko maan lo ge to ye apki bewakofi ho ge na k Quran main khuc galat hai bhai agr jin ko bi engr ki video bech main se dkhaye ho ge aur woh banda mutmain bi ho jaye to us bande ka farz hai is pe research kre aur agr ap ye bole k akshar log research nai krte to zarori nai woh engr ki short video dkhne se gumra ho jaye woh to Quran ki ayat out of context dkhane se hi gumrah ho jayen ge
But problem unki ha jo out of context clip kaatata hain otherwise Nabi A.s ki kitni ahadith hain k qurb e qayamat musalmaaanon ka ya haal ho jaye ga ya ho ga wo ho ga to iska matkab doosron ko ibraat dilana or mahfooz karna tha k musalmaanon ko mutanafar karna to musalmaan ho jayee madaris or ulama sa mutanafar farq nahiinoarhta baat ya ha Quran o Sunnat sa jura Engineer sahaba ya kah raha hain
But muje Qasir sahab ki muje baat ajeeb lagye k engr shahab ap aik baar condemn kr de bhai agr engr ye bole k RSS wale jo ye video apko dkha rhe hain galat to kia phr RSS wale ja k ye bi show kren ge nai bhai sahi baat ya rah usko hi milti jo dondna chahate hain na k koi khud ba khud milti hai.
@@shamiawan5500 no dear it’s not the matter of like and dislike but fruitful debate progresses intellectually in realm of mutual understanding of standardised terms and it’s paradigms not just to coin self-style definition in way to defend previous bragging.
بالکل صحیح فرمایا ایک سو دس پرسنٹ میں آپ کی بات سے متفق ہوں اس میں کوئی شک نہیں 👍👍👍❤🌹❤ جس انداز سے جواب دیے ہیں جونیئر نے گلی محلوں کا ایک لچا لفنگا بھی اس سے بہتر انداز میں گفتگو کر سکتا ہے
I am from India and I agree with Ali Mirza Saheb, none of his clips are shown in India, he is talking nonsense and blaming Engineer Saheb, keep it up Engineer Saheb.
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
My gratitude to Engineer sahib for being available for this podcast. Difference of opinion is essential for the progression of knowledge and accords with Islamic spirit of 'husool e ilm'.
I would request all to please keep it civilised. Let's create an enlightened atmosphere for that is need of the hour.
He is a blessing for Muslims of sub continent
Qaiser bhai ny kaha isiliye mai kuch nahi kahuga warna bohat iqtalaf hai mera engineer sahab se 🙂
Engineer is favorite because he is not intellectually dishonest like you. Woh dil say baat krta hay. Sahi ho ya ghalat woh alag baat hay. Magar tum aik artificial khotay ho. yeh baat bilkul sahi hay.
@@hiddentruth1424 ye baat ja kr inki stream per Kaho 🙄🙄
@@abdullahrizwan435 more like a fitna
Ma-Shaa-ALLAH عزوجل ! ! ! Well Needed PODCAST especially for Intellectuals. Keep on preaching ISLAM without any Sectarianism. May ALLAH guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! ! My Salute for all the TRUTH Lovers. Al-hamduLILLAH ! !
Ali bhai is comment ko thora bht update kr den. Hr bar copy paste 😂😅😅
Assalam alaikum ustad e mohtram we are truth lovers Alhamdulillah ❤️
Why do you copy paste it every where
@@theroundglobe268No pyarey bhi this is brand ❤
App ko us begairat aurat ke khilaaf attacking Rukh apnana chahiye tha
Un ki kitaabon se unke god ram ne bhi 6 saal ki ladki se hi shaadi ki thi
Refrence
Skanda Purana book 3 bhag (hissa) 2 chap 30 verse 8-9
8-9. The bow of Isvara that was kept in the abode of Janaka, was broken. In his fifteenth year, O king, Rāma married the six-year old [1] beautiful daughter of the king of Mithila, Sītā who was not born of a womb. On getting Sītā, Raghava became contented and happy
And ramayana book 3 sarg 47
Flat Earth unki book me hai
Pin 📌
Padma Purana book 1 chapter 3 verse 55
55. The beginningless supreme being, then having flattened the earth, piled the mountains on it according to (its) divisions
It seems like this is the first time someone is asking to Muhammad Ali Mirza such questions that have sparked a considerable debate among intellectuals regarding Muhammad Ali Mirza speeches and speaking style. Hats off to Qaisar Ahmed Raja for maintaining his perspective even after meeting Muhammad Ali Mirza and for continuing to ask him questions. Much respect to you, Raja Sahab!
He didn't even defend his baba (Allama Iqbal)😂😂
Where ??? Qaser sab was agreed to every explanation Mirza gave, i dont know waht he said which was not known or refuted by Mirza Ali. Waht Raja sab should understand that democracy has been already destroyed in Pakistan and he thinks that one day "his party" will be allowed by "company" to democratically get majority and implement islam that is called day dreaming, and now he seeing this and silent that its Ok for Army to destroy whole democratic system because this time its not JI.
@@ranaumaratiq7540lol ek jawab nhi Diya sirf whataboutry.. aur nupur sharma k sawal par kya bakwas ki engineer sahab ne... last me khud mana k usne gustakhi to karni hi thi....to kyu bola tha ki "tasleem rahmani bada mujrim hai" jab maloom tha k usne gustakhi karni hi thi.. fir ye kyu kaha tha ki "wo to react kar gai kyunki musalman ne uthaya tha" abb ye jhooth bol rha hai aur Puri story change kar diya... fir suno wo jawab
@@divineguidance520 yes I agree on this point
I hate of molvies he cross line line sometime
@@divineguidance520 but overall If you notice Engineer Sab has more autentic points and reasoning. Close to Truth
اللہ کا شکر ہے کہ کم از کم آج ہمارے میں ایسے لوگ پیدا ہونا شروع ہو گئے ہیں جو مہذب انداز میں دین کے اوپر گفتگو کرتے ہیں اور اپنی آراہ پیش کرتے ہیں۔ مجھے بہت بہتری کی امید ہے انشاءاللہ۔
This journalist is a rare gem.only person who gave tough time to engineer sahab. Very positive discussion. We want more podcasts like this
انجینئر علی مرزا کا بچگانہ ذہن بھی مزید واضح کر دیا
@@faizanaslam8687 i think you are over exaggerating. I was just praising the discussion between two highly intellectuals. I suppose you are following people with IQ below freezing point. now the puzzle for you to solve is to find the people in Islam with IQ below freezing point. your mind will be broaden .. I hope so
keun angrezi ki maar rhey ho. uss ne urdu main likha hai. tum bhi urdu main likh do. angrezi main chawal marney se chawal intellectual lagti hai magar hoti chawal hi hai. @@showkathamidmir7920
@@showkathamidmir7920 bro ussy urdu main btao ye sab kuch apna likha hai @faizan ko samjh bhi nhi ai hogi… 🤣
Ali Mirza Sahab pura Ghabraa rahe the😂.
Iss baar koi Asli Banda unke saamne aaya tha.
Lekin dono Islam ke liye kaam kar rahe hai❤
I can't even express my excitement in words. Keep doing Dawat-E-Haq. May Allah bless you all.
Absurd Mirza
In 4:29,
he quotes an ayat about shirk
that people were one before they did ikhtelaf. So he says that this ayat is mentioning about shirk and so the people who followed the messengers become successful while the other failed.
Then goes on to mentions the two sects, based on two different cities, whose elders erred in their books according to him. So in the context of the ayat he presented, one should dissociate from one group and join other as the ayat mentions acc to him that only one group was successful.
So If someone doesn't do this he would fail to act on this ayat acc to him and if someone does follow one group then he is actually advocating for something i.e firqawariyat which he says he is against to and that his aim to dig old books is not to clash against each other.
This is how delusional he is
1---Quran me firke banana haram ho fir bhi firkaprast molvi Quran ki haram karda cheej ko halal bataye to usska Quran pr iman kaise hai? 2--Quran ki ek bhi ayat ka inkar krne wala kafir ho sakta hai to firkaprast molvi kufr pr kyu nahi hai? 3--Allah Or Allah ke rasool(s.a.v) ne jb ummat ka nam muslim rakha hai to phir firkaprast molvi jo alag alag nam rakhne pr biddati kyu nahi hai?
Murtado ko Jine Do
Exmuslim Sahil, Sameer, Adam Seeker Urdu, Zafar Heretic on You Tube
tumara ya sab murtad ki bheja rakhi hai AWAZ A HAQ live,qaiser Raza Ahmed, abuzar respond, smile2jannah, Elaina ali, Mufti Yasir Nadeem al wajhidi, Islamic awenking na aur jin murtado ki baat tum kar raha hu na ukna bolo galat information deta hai 😂😂😂
A lot of youtubers, content creators, intellectuals have done a podcast with Engineer Shb but so far I believe that this the best ever podcast highlighting the aspects that were put under the carpet. I hope Raja Shb will come again with more of these type of questions. Hats off to both of you. We really need to preach and practice the teachings of Islam without amy bias and definitely Islam has the solution to all the problems of humanity.
❤
😂
Yes i agrees with u. its an intellectuals podcast.
@@rajumaja1992 mirza jahannumi ty intellectual puttar bund dho apni maa di ja k 😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🌶️🌶️🐷🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🐷🐷🐷🐷🐷💩💩💩💩💩💩💩 goohn khaan aalyo sooro
سخت سوالات پر انجنئیر چھا گیا دو بہت مشکل سوال نورپور شرما اور غامدی جہاں انجنئیر پھسا لیکن صفائی سے نکل گیا
Engineer sahab ki misaal aisay hai jaisay koi kahay "Utho, Mat Betho" phr jab koi pochay ke aap uthny ka q kah rahay hain to wuh comma agay kardetay hain ke mainay to "Utho Mat, Betho" kaha tha, Lakin Sallam hai Qaiser Ahmed Raja Sahab ko jinhun ny ALLAH ke fazal se completely expose kardia...
😂😂😂 Masha Allah intellectual level h bhai apka to😂 akal nai te moja hi moja
Mirza Ali Mechanic neem rafazi neem Youthia is whataboutism. Darling of Liberals and Hindues
First time someone ask reasonable and intellectual questions with proper homework..Heads off to Qaiser Sir..
Not at all reasonable or intellectual. Just big words and loaded questions. He did not even do proper research on Er's stance. PS: I do not agree with Engineer Mirza as well.
Blkul theek
hat's off *
@@factandfunOFFkeep cry
Mirza ke phat k hath may aa gae hai
I have to admit that this episode genuinely impressed me. It was both refreshing and fascinating to see how both hosts respectfully participated in a substantive argument. Your podcast stands out for promoting open-mindedness and civil discourse, which is becoming an increasingly rare type of content. I appreciate the effort you made to create a space where diverse viewpoints can coexist harmoniously. It's a testament to the quality of your content and the maturity of your discussions. Keep up the excellent work, and I look forward to more thought-provoking episodes.
Sheikh gpt
Watching this after pakistans defeat in asia cup. Match sara bhool gaya. Amazing podcast!! with so much positive opinions from both sides. I can see that now vast majority of muslims especially youth want to be united against division in islam and its very positive sign. Alhumdulilah ❤
Same bro
Same
Was watching together match with match on mute
Same here
But I'll say boys played really well.
High level discussion that required two highly intelligent intellectuals. Hats off to both of you guys.
Sawal karny wala kamal ka tha or jawab dayna wala bhi kamal ka tha....
Very informative and knowledgeable podcast
Ma Sha Allah!
❤❤
From 57:15 Eng. Sb. Summed it all. Brilliance at its peak. MashaAllah
Greatest intellect and living legend. May Allah protect you. Ameen.
It was a brilliant podcast but i can seem to let go of the fact that Raja sahab was talking to idealistically.
😂😂😂😂😂 nice jokr
Literally, I had never seen a movie without skipping some of the parts but the way this podcast proceeded with Solid Questions by Qaisr Raja, I did not skip even a second of the whole video. Undoubtedly on the other hand the guest Mirza Ali showed good defense that's much appreciated. People need clarification about these types of things, especially Religion. I want to say this was the need of the hour and all the questions were arousing in masses that have been discussed here. Very much appreciation.
Yar ye Banda Mera favorite hy❤❤❤itni acchi tarha Sy logically baat karta hy❤❤❤ salute to engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza❤❤❤
Baba banega ye v
@@wakilahmad333kese banega baba zara btana?
@@farazkhan21fierce Uske babe maududi k baad next baba yahi hai
Hr baat Jo aqal ko theek zaroro nhi thek ho
@@farazkhan21fierce Apna naya firqa to bana hi liya hai isne firqa e maududiyat..
Isi firqe ka baba banega aik deen ye plumber
This podcast was more awaited than indo pak match😂
Me too bro 😂
Me too bro 😂
Right bro
Absolutely Right. 💯❤❤
really g !!
btw me too
At many points Engineer sb was gone speechless and he just changed the topic and qaisar Raja sb was an amazing and tolerant person that I have ever seen, even Engineer sb did not let him speak much but qaisar's questions have explained a lot of wisdom. May Allah protect us all.
They both tried their best and it was fruitful
@@asher8828 only qaiser bhai. Bhagora engineer is secular in the sheepa clothing. Just like lawerence of arabia
@@BookBook-yw1krKeep barking
Babi spotted @@BookBook-yw1kr
First time I'm listening Qaiser Raja sb and for the first time I really enjoyed the sitting or podcast thoroughly. I didn't even feel for a second that I m waisting my time. Don't have words to praise you both. Many more podcast like this are necessary for nation or Muslims. I would urge you both that please arrange this kind of podcast on weekly basis. You can't imagine how great it would be. JazakAllah
Zindagi barbad hai apki k aap qaiser raja ko phli bar sune
This was really a very nice and fruitfil podcast.I love both Engineer Mohammad Ali mirza sahib and Jinab Qaisar Raja sahib.Such people are an asset of Ummate Muslimah.
Best Podcast ever, I'm student of Engineer Mohammed Ali Bhai and I'm proud of it, and I also listen to Kaiser Ahmed Raja Sahab and his Iman Union team, ek Ali Bhai Firqawaiyat ki khilaf kaam kar rahe hai aur dusri taraf Iman Union, Mulhideen aur ethiests #Echmuslms ki khilaaf kaam kar rahe hai., proud of both of you! Lots of love from 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Aray bhai engineer sahab kaha firqawariyat k khilaf kaam kar rhe hai?? Sare maslako ki galati batana firqawariyat k khilaf kaam karna nhi hota hai.. firqawariyat k khilaf kaam karne ka matlab hota hai ki islam ki asal k taraf aao aur furoo'i masle par batna aur ladna choro.. aur uske liye asal batil k matlab ilhaf, kufr aur shirk k khilaf uthna aur ladna hota hai... engineer sahab isme se kuch nhi kar rhe hai.. engineer sahab wahi kar rhe hai jo firkawari barailvi maulvi deonandio k khilaf kar rha hai aur firkawari deobandi Maulvi barailvio k khilaf bol rha hai and so forth.. ye firkawariyat k khilaf kaam karna nhi hai balki ye bolna hai ki market me sab galat hai me sahi hu.. me emaam az Zaman hu
جیسے عمرانڈو نیازی ریاست پودینہ بنا رہا تھا مرزاجونیئر جہلمی ویسے ہی گروہ واریت کے خلاف کام کررہا ہے ۔۔۔😢
@@divineguidance520jab apnay babo kay naam ka kalma parh waatay ho to phir shirk kidhar jaata hay ya phir qabaro say jab MAANGTAY HO tab kidhar shirk jaata hay
Aur ha jab tumhara har gali muhallay ka molvi jummay kay khutbay may apnay babo ki story aur engineee pay lantaan karwa raha ho ho kya usay nahi haq pohonchta kay wo CHISTI RASULULLAH aur ASHRAF ALI RASOOLULLAH wala zakham cheeray taakay awaam ko samajh aayay kay apnay aapko muslim kaho aur quran aur sunnat ko follow aur amal karo instead of following jo aapka molvi aapko kehta hay reference kay baghair aur out of context
Yay nahi pata chalta us time kay nabi pak nay qabaro ko pakka aur qabaro pay imarat bananay say mana farmaya hay
Allah hidayat in logo ko hidayat day ameen
This podcast was treat to watch. The true essence of Islam where you can communicate your views without having any harsh feelings. Respect for each other.
Loved the ambiance of this conversation created and carried out by Raja sb. Masha Allah. May Allah give you more power and protect you from all evil.
Murtado ko Jine Do
Exmuslim Sahil, Sameer, Adam Seeker Urdu, Zafar Heretic and YASMIN KHAN...
This was amazing. This actually felt like two amazing intellectuals sharing their thoughts and respecting each other's point of views which was a treat to watch. Masha Allah!
Scholars like you, is an inspiration for young Muslims like us who want to research about Islam in today's cluttered world. Such an amazing, knowledgeable, thorough podcast with difference of opinions, discussed in a peaceful and well-mannered fashion. Kindly keep making such podcasts, keep inspiring us and keep bringing the positive change. Insha'Allah Islam and Muslims will rise again.
Qaiser sahab is just pure genius ❤ may Allah help him in his endeavours❤
tun tate utha qaiser ke
Podcast ❌
Engineer's clarifications ✅
Raja shb is a mature Person .....
Every point is a valid point , He has
The reason why I appreciate and respect engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza.
1
I was a brailvi and now I am only a Muslim
2
I never read whole Quran in Arabic now I have studied whole Quran with translation.
Now whenever anyone tell me anything regarding Islam , I consult Quran I consult Hadees.
It's all bcz of listing Ali bhai .
He is one man Army . Allah bless him inshallah
what about his lies
But better learn Arabic then understand the Qur'an, you will feel much difference
teak hai yea sub kam ap na kia hai laken engineer both jhoot bolta hai haq ko jhoot ka sath mix karta hai us ka lea ap ko dean seakna parta hai
Yaar tu x brelvi thaa to tb to tera bunyadi aqeeda Chishti wala jo mirza kehta hy to woh bunyadi aqeeda hy to Tery ghr walay ya Baaqi brelvi Is cheez k krny ka kehty hon gy chishti wali Kahani ka jo mirza Fit krta hy brelviyon py😂😂😂😂😂
مرزا خود قادیانی ہے دعا کر اسی کے ساتھ انجام ہو تیرا آمین کہ دینا
one of the best podcast of my life thanks Qaisar Ahmed Raja and Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza
Murtado ko Jine Do
Exmuslim Sahil, Sameer, Adam Seeker Urdu, Zafar Heretic and YASMIN KHAN.....
Amazing discussion .im listening to Raja sahb first time .I've never seen Him before .im impressed by the question that represents the level of knowledge Raja sahab has .
What ever is happening ,is forcing people to start immensily needed critical thinking .
By the way i agree with Raja sahb vision to help different sects rather than start a war with them .
I was truly captivated by this exceptional podcast where profound and critical subjects were dissected with an unprecedented level of intellectual rigor. It's worth noting that the depth of discussion in this podcast surpasses any other in its genre, particularly with respect to the nuanced exploration of topics like secularism and Islam. Even if you are well-versed in Islamic studies, this podcast offers a unique perspective that is both enlightening and enriching. I wholeheartedly recommend this podcast to those seeking a more profound understanding of these intricate concepts. It is, without a doubt, a remarkable piece of intellectual discourse.
There should be more podcasts of such caliber.
MashaAllah Ustaad-e-Mohtaram! ❤️
No doubt an amazing podcast
Kafi bhari English hai apki??
I just came to know about Qaiser Sahab today. I found them very polite and solid in arguments. This podcast is a perfect example of how a progressive argument should be. whereas Engr Sahab is doing great as always. Thank you for contributing to the UMMAH and fighting this Fiqrawariyat! May ALLAH guide all of us toward his path of TRUTH. Aameen
Them?? Lgtv+ vibes😵💫
@@naqaabposh4872 Choose what is right, not roots !!
Many individuals said they would ask new questions, but you truly did, and it expanded our understanding to new dimensions. Qaisar, you have done a fantastic job; keep it up.
ماشاءاللہ قیصر بھائی بہت ہی اچھا اللہ تعالی اپ کو جزائے خیر دے
A truly exceptional and much needed podcast for youth. The phenomenon which engineer sahab is considering as "impossible" i,e unity of Muslims under one Muslim leader, is a much needed requisite for Muslims these days. Sectarianists should watch these types of programs how two persons with different mindsets, different ideas and different interpretations of religious terminologies, can talk and LIVE peacefully. My gratitude for both of you.
I generally don't comment on any video but I must say this is one of the few times that I have seen a whole pure one and half hour long video. I have always been in a search of history and this host makes an incredibly increase in my intellectual. Hats off to both of you. Btw this is my first time watching Qaiser sb.
There is an other video of the same level
How a program is hosted is to be learned from Qaiser Sab. such learned yet so calm letting guest complete his point and then offering his question for further clarification.
@@mustajab2088 give me its link, i would love to watch
@@laiqakbar1989 exactly 💯
@@talhashaahh ruclips.net/video/8DZ6h3LcF6o/видео.htmlsi=OAMO9dGZZCwmmlnw
It's on the Pakistan experience channel
Can't get enough of it, One of the best discussions of recent times!! Can you guys please bring out a series discussing and debating the very fundamentals of Islam and modern age menaces.
Qasir Rajab sahib zaberdast. Allah AP ko es naik kaam ka ajer dy. Engineer ke hoob chatrool ke ga.
Excellent Questions by Qaiser bhai ❤ last question was my favourite in which Qaiser bhai politely showed Mirza sahab that he has become enemy of ulemas and favourite of murtads, mulhids and islamophobes. Which is an alarming call for engineer sahab
Ulama❤
Imaanunion❤❤
01:32:10 mere sabse favorite line puri podcast main yai hai.
Lekin koi mujhe comment tab tak naa kaa re please jab tak pura video na dek le. Without skipping.
One of the Best Podcast i have watched, Top Logical Questions and Answered Intelligently. HATS OFF TO BOTH, THE HOST AND ENGINEER MUHAMMAD ALI MIRZA.
MaShaAllah amazing podcast. Loved every bit of it. Allah hum sab ko hidayat dein or Ummat e Muslimah ko ittehad or Allah or Unke Rasool SAW k dushmanon k khilaf isteqamat ata karen Ameen
I truly appreciate how both attendees managed to engage in a thoughtful and respectful discussion despite their differing viewpoints. It's refreshing to see such decency and mutual respect maintained throughout the conversation. This is exactly the kind of dialogue that promotes understanding and growth. Well done!
Ali bhai nailed it.
Sir Qaisar thanks for conducting such an amazing podcast.
Be Unite be one ummah
Or yh nazariya mjhay 21 sal barelvi rehny sy nhi aaya Ali bhai k smjahany sy hi smjh aaya
😂😂
I'm just shocked 🤯kaise engineering Mirza ke followers kitnee andhe hai, is video me Mirza ke bahot zyada danti mari hai, Nupur Sharma ka case me, abhi bol ra ke uske Sher padhne se usko mauka mila; jab ki video me ye bola tha the, Us Maulna me pahle inke mazhab ka mazaak uraya, tab jawab me Nupur Sharma ne gustakhi ki, jhoot bole ke nikal gaya, aur do-do baar daawe ke saath bol raha hai ke, mujhe koi regret nhi uske jo video banya tha uspe.🤔,
Upar se agar Islamic hukumat aa jaye, magar firq maujood rahe, toh Mirza nhi chahata ke kabhi aise Islamic hukumat aaye 😒,
Matlab ke abhi toh na Islamic hukumat hai, aur na is musalmaano ka etihad (unity)
Toh kam se kam Islamic hukumat aa jaye, toh isko gawara nhi.
Firqa kharam hota jo is almost impossible hai, wo kaam isko pahle karna hai, jab tak ko modernity/ secularism ke aar me job bhi bachi khuchi Islaam hai, wo bhi khatam kar le.
Haar baat pe deo-barevli gusnana; Koi bhi Deobandi ya Barelvi ka Kalma Chisti ya Asraf ali Rasoollah nhi hai, phir bhi bol raha hai, ke Ghamdi toh inlogon se behtar hai.
Apni koi bhi galti accept mat karo, Qaiser sb. ko bolo ke apni Ghamdi ke video dekhe aapke misunderstanding khatam ho jayegi 🤣, fir bol ra, ke Ghamdi ke khilaaf sabse zyada mere videos hai, .... kuch bhi.
Bol raha hai, atheism pe sirf isme videos banaya hai, baad baki koi firka kuch nhi kiya, Islam ke khilaaf kuch bhi ho, ausko yahi address karta hai, har cheez yahi defend karta hai...
Bhai Itne mahaan hai Engineering sab, lagta hai, ke Salaf e Saliheen ke baad sirf ek hi banda ayaa wo Hai Mirza 🤣; baki baki imaam khud jiske kitaab padhta hai, jiske jariye Islaam ham tak pahuch, wo log Islaam ko khatam karne pe tule the, kya kya bataon time kam hai,
Last me Qaiser Sb ne bol hi diya, ke wo har baat se agree nhi karte 😅,fir bhi kya kare, Qaiser sb chahte to uski chori pe collar pakarte, but unhone se chor diya especially in case of Nupur Sharma.
Aur bhi mere ye kahtam hai, apas ke disagreement kabhi khatam nhi hone wale, shuru se itkhteef chale aaya hai, but isko negatively nhi dekha gaya, aur koi problem bhi nhi hua, ye engineering jabardasti sab ko ek understanding pe lana chata hai; Ambiyan A.S ne sirf dawat diya kuch ne qubool kiya kuch ne nhi kiya. But ye toh thaan rakha hai, Ilmi kitabi (Deen-E-Mirza) qubool karna hi parega, begair inke khilaafat ke bare me sochna hi mat.
To be practical main Khood ek strict/orthodox Sunni hoon (matlab Barelvi hi ho, magar mere Barelvi ka definition kuch aur hai aur tumhara kuch aur 😅 (actually main Kitabi Barelvi hoon,) jokes apart mujhe khud Deobandi - Wahabi interpretation sahi nhi lagta, jab Quran o Hadees ko dekha toh mera aqeeda jo bana wo Barelvi se zyada match kar tha (you can say I'm purified Barelvi, kyuki bahot sare khurafat logon se apne se izaad ki hai)
Main deo-wahab ke puchi namaz bhi nhi padhta.
Still I want, ke apas ke itkhtelaaf ko side rakh kar, Islaam ke liya bahot kuch kiya ja skta hai, like Islamic hukumat me kya hi dikkat, raha jo Mirza bol raha hai, ke kafir samjhe gya etc, sab bakwaas hai, He is using logical fallacy; koi kisi ko kafir kuch nhi bole ga. Khair choro kitna baat bole, but Mirza is not benifitting Islam at all, ulta nuqaan dera as is case, ke jabtak firqa khatam nhi hota, tab tak usko Islamic jamhuriyat nhi chahiye. Upar se druv rathee jo khud athiest hai usko promote karta hai, + ulama ke bare me negatively failta rahta hai, + secularism wagaira ko promote kar deta hai (yaha galti chupa raha hai), I really see him as a danger to Islam.
And Allah knows the best.
@@mdibrar831 Bhai ese hi Hein engineer ke followers 🥲🥲
I have been watching lectures and interviews of Engineer Sahib for sometime now and for the first time I saw him on defensive due to your thoroughly researched and highly articulated questions.
Kudos for such an incredible interview.
Is that defensive? From which angle. ?
and he failed to answer multiple questions.. that just exposes him
@@easypaisa5719 lol it's very clear... if you were not his blind follower you could have seen. On RSS point alone, engineer had no come back and he was looking lost and came up with nothing but ' Pakistan me bhi RSS ' hai :D. lol that proves he's a juggat baaz of street level which can't comprehend bigger picture or understand what's going on or he's doing everything deliberately...
He's clueless about Iqbal and Jinnah's evolution but trying to degrade them and even Pakistan...... Also, his usage of words secular etc in casual way creates problem for him . Qiaser sahab countered him about that then he acted like a immature person and said ' i didn't mean secular in that way' lol. We all know Secular is used only in one sense.....
and there are lot more points which totally exposed him. Alhumdulillah.... Truth comes out sooner or later...that's what happening with Engineer Mirza now.. he can't deal with people who are more educated and aware than him
@@goals27 I suspest you are bilid follower of Qaiser Raja
@@easypaisa5719 me ne pura comment kr Diya h. Tmhry Pas ak b jawab ni?
Bas pata chal gayi haqeqqat.
Blind follower of engineer who's truly exposed now. Alhumdulillah.
Truth always comes out.
Educated logon k agay ye thehr ni sakta iska rang utar Gaya h Puri video m saaf nazar arha h. Ye sirf apnay jahil tolay k Samny zuban chalata h Jo sir Hilaty rehty Hain dimagh apna band kiye. 😂
Sach Samny AGaya h....
Wonderful podcast. This should have been the standard of all podcasts.
Hats off to Mr. Qaisar and a lot of love and respect for Ali Bhai ❤️
Loved his final answer about legacy.
Aaj tk me ny engineer k jitNy bi vlogs ya podcast sunny hayn., yeh wala behtareen hyn... BEHTAREEN IN TERMS K SAMNY WALA BANDA TAGRAAA BETHA HYN.... JIS NY PAKRRR K RAKHA HYN.... WARNA TO ENGINEER APNI BACHELOR DEGREE KA ROOB HAR PODCASTER BECHARY PAR THOMPTA REHTA HYN K MAI PARHA LIKHA HON., TUSSI KUCH VI NAHI... INTIHAAYE MUFEED BAATYN HOWE HYN... ALLAH BLESS QAISER AHMED RAJA SAHIB... KEEP IT UP....
Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza is the smartest man on this planet right now no one can beat him in terms of logic and facts everything he says is just mind-blowing Allah ALI bhai ki hifazit kry AMEEN
Apke anusar....smartest man Ali mirja ,,
Mere anusar app ho .....🎉
😂
Hope this is sarcasm
@@mrstickman6718 If that's a thing QURAN PAK, SHAHIH MUSLIM, SHAHIH BUKHARI entered the chat 😂
@@businessinQmirja is near to Rafzi /shia....... He's rafzi from inside.
MashaAllah very intellectual podcast !! Emam has very vast knowledge about Deen and as well as Academic !! Pure Gem 💎
And hats off to QAR for conducting this podcast and ask intellectual questions ...
ماشاء اللہ۔ علی بھائ کے کیا کہنے۔ قیصر راجہ صاحب کے اچھے اور مشکل سوالات کے کیا زبردست جوابات دئے ہیں۔ بہت معلوماتی پوڈ کاسٹ ہے۔
Qaiser Ahmad Raja is so calm .....guftagu ka andaz bahut hi soothing aur calm❤
I had huge rather 99% differences with Mr Morza but what he said in this podcast is very practical and true about sectarianism.
Oh my God! Can't believe that a man (Qaiser Ahmed Raja) can counter question with Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza (my teacher) like this. This is the best ever podcast one ever recorded with the great EMAM. And the way EMAM has listened to every question and responded is just amazing.
Pls do some homework. He is misguided Emam of yours.
@@AbdullahKhan-ln8to Elaborate
This was the best podcast till date, questions were great and the discussion on both sides was also great. Enjoyed watching and learned a lot. Need another session like this with new questions
Best ever podcast. Salute to Engineer Sb for telling the truth.
You simply cannot hide facts just because of your country or Muslim's honor
Gustakhi ka samandar
Kia truth, he just lacks knowledge about a lots of subject
@@badart88like what
@@jio5456tumhare dil me😂
@@azeemmalik2598 e.g youngsters don't keep a beard due to iqbal. Iqbal supported communism.
He is just a student with basic knowledge meant to shock people.
What an Amazing , Thoughtful and Ideological Podcast. Extremely brilliant questioning by Qaisrer Raja sb and excellent clarification by Engr Muhammad Ali Mirza sb 💯
Ali Bhai has appeared in several podcasts in recent years but undoubtedly this was best of the best... Mashallah 👍🏻
ma sha ALLAH
Both of them are golden assets of Islamic Ummah but Mirza sahab is shining 🌟 more in this podcast. The difference of opinion between intellectuals is beneficial for reasoning to evolve. The critical questions of Raja sahab were much necessary for our better understanding of the thoughts of Mirza sahab. Eventually the best podcast (as per my knowledge) of Mirza sahab where same old questions were not repeated. Love them both. ❤
Wherever Raja saab caught engineer next word comes out of his mouth I agree with u. 😂 in past interviews he never said anything like this and he always very aggressive. In this interview Raja saab tamb him. Particularly on issue of socialism, secularism and his ignorant about issues.
@@user-3013
Right, its his toughest. And if theres a winner. For first time its other than Ali bhai
Raja sb is very intellectual. I didn't know such people existed in Pakistan.
@@user-3013 most of the times Raja sahab agreed with Mirza sahab, does that mean Raja sahab was caught by him? The difference of opinion within intellectuals is not from today and will not end tomorrow, it will remain, we have to adjust our minds to the reality.
Murtado ko Jine Do
Exmuslim Sahil, Sameer, Adam Seeker Urdu, Zafar Heretic
@@Sushil1974 kaun maar raha hai unhe?
Masha'Allah Masha'Allah ❤
No Mufti, No Other Aalim can answer such intellectual questions. They literally stand no chance against an Engineer. Hats Off to you EMAM
Hhaha. Engineer lurhak kr gir gaya and fools think that he has responded the questions asked
Engineer saheb is neither 100 person right nor 100 per cent wrong. The problem with Pakistan is that what should be discussed and implemented by the governments is being discussed by anyone and everyone. It is so sad to see the collapse of our society in every sphere.
Log bs isky confidently bolny k style se impress hoty hn, reality me I think ksi b question pe engineer apny aap ko defend ni kar saka
Bhai ye Zahil h...
@@abdullahzafar4401han jahil logo ki kami ni hy,Jo is plumber ko Sahi samhjty hy
Welldone !! Muhammad Ali Mirza shb
The way you answered all questions with solid points and confidence
I too loved his confidence while misleading conversation and avoiding the Actual Questions. Solid points were though missing From Engineer Ali Bhai, But Qaiser bhai provided them so all good❤️
@@Gthbso how it's misleading?
I think there can be 2 reasons that you're saying this.
Either lack of Islamic knowledge or lack of cognitive ability.
@@aqeelaaqeela8941 U sure I'm having Lack of Cognitive Ability?
Cuz it seems you weren't able to decipher a simple Comment, I meant misleading conversation to avoid Direct questions and not Misleading ideology of Viewers.
But it's a different fact that he does mislead Youth with a lower IQ.
Ofcourse I don't mean you have a Low IQ brother, or are you?
very well explained by you @Gthbso
Er. Ali Mirza was humiliated here and he looks knowledge less 😢
Allhamdulillah! It was worth watching it. Very much loud and clear. No redundancy.
Jazahumullahu khairan kaseera ❤
All the RUclipsrs with not enough knowledge came to the academy and asked the usual questions with no knowledge of islam, so they could do nothing except accepting the thoughts of eng Muhammad ali mirza. First time a knowledgeable personality sat with him and ended up without accepting all of his answers.
Gave a tough time to him and recorded the podcast in very manar environment. Really Really appreciated Raja Sahab 👍👍...
Hats off to you 🤞
Right. Ali Mirza will have more tough time if he sits with Good scholars of deen.
Qaisar sahab jaisi islam ki knowledge to kisi maulvi ko nahi
What a superb podcast!
Kudos to Qaisar Raja sahb for conducting such a great session!
😊❤
Murtado ko Jine Do
Exmuslim Sahil, Sameer, Adam Seeker Urdu, Zafar Heretic and YASMIN KHAN
@@Sushil1974kyo jine do?
@@Sushil1974just like a person who will be crossing borders illegally the person will be killed
So
The sharia court will give a death penalty to the murtad just like that
@@Sushil1974exmuslim kesy... Kya ap ne deen ka theka le rakha he jb tk koi khud ye iqrar na kar de k wo muslim nai ap ksi pe apna tappa ni laga skte sahab
قیصر راجا صاحب سلامت رہیں
آپ نے ہر گمراہ کو لا جواب کیا ہے
Khayalati dunia sy bahir aain.. engineer sab k karway sch ka samna krin.. wo batin hum hazam ni kr skty jo engineer sab ny ki es ly qaisr sab ap ko chay hoy lag rhy hai
Kis trhn janab mujy b smjao????
@@HassanRaza1-i3mtu rehnay de bhai
Wo to bt kr rhe TM niklo gumrahi se
One of the best Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza podcasts. ❤❤
Who wants next podcast with SAHIL ADEEM? Vote👇
Koi jarurat nehi hai
@@deenkihaqeeqat2259it's already done.
Search kar len pehle ho chuki hai.
@@deenkihaqeeqat2259 qasir sab agr khalafat k khilaf hoty to PDM PTI ke supporter hoty, sahil adeem or qasir sab ma khilafat ko lanay k method ka faraq ha .... in dono ma khilafat k hawalay sa wohi faraq ha jo JI or Dr israr sab k nazrya ma ha....
Already did
Murtado ko Jine Do
Exmuslim Sahil, Sameer, Adam Seeker Urdu, Zafar Heretic....
Deen wohi hai Jo quran aur sunnat hai, what a line Mirza Sahab❤
Kya naya h isme? 🤣
Mujhe koi firqa bta de jisne ye kaha ho ki quran o Sunnat islam nhi ya iske ilawa bhi islam h matlab kuch bhi 😂
@@zaidchowdhary2436right 😂there yeh nobe inko pata hi nhi Islam
Thank you so much sir qaiser for doing a proper podcast with Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza unlike a traditional
"han mein han milana wali podcast"
Right
I really very happy to see this type of discussion.I think this type of intellectual person should be united at one plateform.specially QAR,Mufti Yasir, Muhammad Ali Mirza,and sahil adeem.
aur Amir Bhai bhi♥
And furqan qureshi blog
@@AtomsToCosmosAbhi unhe aur door jaana hai, In Sha Allah.
@@silentlips7103Who is he ?
Who is Mufti Yasir ?
The best podcast i have ever seen in my life , respect to both of men , although i have some differences with engineer sahab but still i love both of them for the sake of ALLAH. may ALLAH bless both of them in this dunya and in akhirah , ameen.
بہت اعلی قیصر احمد صاحب اس مرزا جونیئر کی چھترول ایسے ہی چاہیئے تھی
What chitrol, ji ji kr ra ha eng sir k agay ap Ka qaqa qaiser
@@WajihaImran-iu3po bhai apki ghalty ni es me. Apki tarbiat sai ni hui. Oper se ap es qadyani murabbi k follower bn gae jis k lye awwaleen shart andha behra or dimagh se khali hona shart he.
مرزا علی جہلمی کذاب جاہلوں کا سردار @@WajihaImran-iu3po
Lu ji ya lag khlafet ka nizam la ka ayn gy Jo ilme ikhtalaf par dosroon ko qadiani ya qafer decleyer kar date ha😂Ap log bas khlafat khlafat khail sakte han😂😂😂
Ya acha jawb tha 😅😅 Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza is the best Islamic scholars in the world@@Mudassarali-b2h
As an Indian Muslim, I am disappointed that Engineer Mirza is not concerned with avoiding giving talking points to the Hindutva terrorist organizations like RSS!
He says he is not a liberal , but he has the “yeh to Pakistan mein bhi hota hai” attitude for every atrocity against the Muslims in India!
He's a coward Hypocrite
Stop Using my beloved country's name… Remove Indian from your comment
He want islamic Pakistan then why we don't want and talk about hindutva and Hindu country??
Arey yeh Librandus sab Hinduo ke gulaam hai.😂
Inko hinduo seh support, views aur kuch ko toh funding bhi milti hai.
Pata nahi woh ISI kidhar busy hai.... dushman ander bhi hai.
Khulke usko indian hindutva sanghiyo seh support bhi araha hai
If there was any candidate for (go to pakistan then)। OP is definately one of them
A very unique podcast and relevant questions rather than the redundant format of other podcasts we have seen of engineer sahab. No disrespect to other podcaster or youtubers but this one was very creative due to its style of questioning and hats off to engineer sahab for coming so forthright with his answers. Salute to Raja sahab for bringing us a differing dynamics in the podcast culture. It was a intellectually sound and spiritually fulfilling conversation. It is an asset for the youth to come. Regards to both of you. On a side note I would add to the last comment by Raja sahab:
"Banda iss zindagi which apne app to we mutmahin ho jaave tey badi gal ey!"
Aisa lag raha hai aaj se pahle mujhe podcast ke naam par kuch aur dhikhaya gaya 😢
Ise kahte podcast salute to both kings 👑👑👑
Concept of graduality of Qaiser bhai is a gem......... Christianity leads to atheism through the convept of theism ...... Same way..... Islamic secularism leads to secularism leads to liberalism leads to atheism......
Alhamdulillah.. A productive podcast ,amazing question,honest answers, civilised discussion ...may Allah bless u both ..Allah qabool farmayae...
Unable to answers any questions
Qaisar Sahab has a very balanced mature and intellectually sound approach and is doing excellent work. This podcast helps us understand where Mirza Sahab is coming from and I feel Mirza Sahab would do well to take Qaisar Sahab's advice and that would help him unleash his true potential. Mirza Sahab is capable of a lot of positivity and this podcast helps us see that.
Engineer sahib has a practical prospect. Qaiser sahib has more of the idealistic islamic prospect good for academics but not implement able. Overall as expected both of them are the blessings for whole of the ummah
Your comment is the EXACT point I had in mind while discussing this podcast with a couple of guys on social media. Raja Sahib is very ambitious, but a bit too idealistic in his dream of establishing a khilafat asap in Pakistan. Engineer Ali knows the sectarian system inside out, and therefore believes that sectarianism is the cancer that needs to be removed in order to progress.
True 100 percent
Qaiser sb did great job, boht tahamul se expose kia janab ne.
😂
The best and thought provoking podcast, salute to both, respect for both. I pray may we become one muslim ummah insha Allah
قیصر راجا صاحب کمال کے انسان ہیں... اور علی مرزا صاحب بھی... سوالات بھی بہترین تھے اور جوابات بھی... اور طرزِ گفتگو کا کہنا ہی کیا... ماشاء اللہ... ۔
sawal ik or jawab koi or deraha ha!
Bht bada jahil hai ye insan
Or iske ulte seedhe bayan se humko india me koi fark nahi padhne wala
سوال تو اچھے تھے لیکن جوابات میں تکبر تھا۔
Koi example iss video main se@@universeunveiled765
سوال گندم جواب چنا
Masha'Allah. This is how the discussion should be done on difference of opinion. Amazing!
Murtado ko Jine Do
Exmuslim Sahil, Sameer, Adam Seeker Urdu, Zafar Heretic and YASMIN KHAN.....
Qaisar Ahmad Raja sahb or Engineer Ali mirza sahb dono he apni jgah py bht acha kam kr rhy hen, or meri shadeed khawhish hai k kam az kam in ko ek page py rehna chahiye, aisy log jo deen k sath mukhlis hen in ko apas men ikhtilafaat ko hal kr lena chahiye..
Engineer ki boht si baaton se mutafiqq hu liken secularism wali baat pe Qaiser bhai is right..
Yeah. Engineer sahab does not have a deep study in this subject. He should avoid using such terms.
The reason is secularism has different definitions in west and Here.
@@emmk4992 Definition is exactly the same. But layman's understanding is what Engineer Sahab is talking about.
@@letmespeakthetruth1601 no its not same. You need to look it to again.
@@letmespeakthetruth1601 just like how right wing in west is more liberal than left wing here.
I have watched Qaiser Ahmed Raja's podcast with Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza, Qaiser bhai asked very good questions. If I had met the Engineer Sahib, I would have asked almost the same questions.
Qaiser Bhai was trying to talk about something intellectual but Engineer Sahib was in the same mood "I don't know the question but Sectarianism (فرقہ واریت) is the answer".
I know sectarianism (فرقہ واریت) is the biggest problem of the Ummah (I also face it almost on a daily basis) but many things are yet to be discussed.
And some extremist Hindus in India who use the video of Engineer Mohammad Ali Mirza to defend themselves. Sir, discuss this topic again, if you can speak for 2 hours on Maulana of another Sect, then discuss it at least once. Qaiser Ahmed Raja was trying to convince Ali bhai to talk about this but the Engineer sahib did not take it seriously.
Note: This is my opinion, you can agree or disagree with it.
26.10 is best answer to this... Firqawariyat is indeed the root cause. It affects society multidimensionally. Tht what Engineer is tryinh to point.
Murtado ko Jine Do
Exmuslim Sahil, Sameer, Adam Seeker Urdu, Zafar Heretic and YASMIN KHAN.......
I agree with you engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza will become sacrificial lamb if he doesn't clarify himself to greater extent because he'll get misquoted badly
No one cam beat engineer sahib
He’s intellectual level and how he countered all the questions and rebutted logically just mind blowing
Lmao 🤣🤣
The guy who runs from a debate 🤣
Ali mirza na bilkul bewaqoofon waly jawab diyee ... kai jgah par ali mirza was literally knocked out.
Haan haan isse pata chalta ha tumara ilmi level
@@openmicconversationofficia714 Sawal hi qaiser aisa poochhte thay k unka sirf ek hi answer hai firqawariyat aur Engineer sahab ne bohot badiya jawab Diya...
😂😂😂
Agreed with Qaisar sb. He is one of the blessings of Pakistan. He is a proud Pakistani. May Allah help us to spread true Islam. Ameen.
engineer sahab sach aur haq baat boltay hain,ye jo baat samjana chahtay hain ,afsoos wo baat hum sab main pehlay sy majood hone chayieh thei,duniya ky her muslim ka ka rastay ek hai bus engineer sab hum sab ko use ek rastay per chalana chahtay hain,inshalla Allah hum sab ko seday aur ek rastay per chalnay ki tafeeq ata krey aur engineer sahab jasay log her jaga farahum krey taqi koi rasta batak na jae
Yes I agree Engineers have very good ideas, let's check them
Islam is compatible with Secularism
Pakistani Muslims have no chance of winning over Israel
Boycott of Israeli product is Against Islam
Still if you are going to defend him then frankly speaking, Mirza Ali is a New Baba of his sect
🤣🤣🤣🤣
مرزا غلام انگریز قادیانی جہنمی کا فرنٹ مین مرزا جونیئر جہنمی اپنے سٹوڈنٹ کو بھی ساتھ لے کر جائے گا جہنم میں
😂😂😂😂
Welldone Sir Qaiser you really showed your intelligence by asking such questions which others couldn’t have asked or have lacked in knowledge regarding those matters.. Great work to have strong minds together to evaluate the facts about the critical topics of era..
no doubt,. MashAllah both are doing excellent work ,
After so many 'unimpressive' podcasts in which repetitive questions were being asked,.... here is the genuine interview with attacking questions pushing Engineer sahb really hard,... i hv listened this man, the host, fr the first time and i am impressed by the depth of his knowledge and the approach he applies to understand an issue,... it was a commendable podcast
I was hoping (but did not expect) to hear some more intellectual and objective response from Mirza Saheb.
Just Amazing ... Valuable Discussion from both Sides.
Huge Respect for Both 👍
Eng Ali mirza know art of Facing and Answering Questions ❤
The Questions are splendid as well
engineer saab ki sab sa badi quality ha ky even if he dnt know the answer but still he knows how to fill the answersheet
Mujhe laga Karl Marx or Lenin wali baat withdraw krenge.... Lekin afsos dis chhota h Engineer sahab ka
@@deenkihaqeeqat2259 hum yeh nhi kehtay ky engineer saab ki sare baatai galat ha hum unko bi suntay ha aur iktelaafi raai rakhtay ha unse andi taqleed kay hum kayel nhi hum sab sa ilmi iktelaaf rakhtay ha .inko yeh problem ha ky yeh baataou ko gumatay ha bht zaada yeh baat ka seeda jawaab nhi detay ha
@zeeshan-pk9qxatheist v Qaiser vai accha Jalebi master kehte hai?? Qaiser vai v kam jalebi nehi ghumate baquol atheist.
A man and his love can change the world🌍🌏. Thanks for your contributions.
ruclips.net/video/Q19AdaFtGVg/видео.htmlsi=XVtBMEBhlQNYIGTm
Engineer = Andho me kana raja
Murtado ko Jine Do
Exmuslim Sahil, Sameer, Adam Seeker Urdu, Zafar Heretic and YASMIN KHAN and Harris Sultan
@@Sushil1974 murtadd ka ilaj qiyamat tak nhi ho sakta.
Khuda ki zamin par Khuda ki nafarmani.
Jo 1 Khuda ko nhi maanta vo majbur me har chiz ko Khuda bana leta he.
Majburi n ho to khud hi Khuda ban jata he.
Is liye murtadd logo ko pagal khane bhej dena chahiye.
Movt tak maanne wale nhi
Ma Shaa Allah Qaiser sahib very nicely amd honest session. As usual Engineer Sahib best introduction is always negative and he Ma Shaa Allah proof everyone wrong. May Allah Subhan o Talaa protect from any type of sharr and keep him strong and full of emaan Ameen
Much awaited podcast. Respect for both Ali and Qaiser bhai. ❤
1:05:14 exactly. I am an Indian and this is a fact.. Yahan k musalmano k dilo me ulamao k lie nafrat pida ki jaa rhi.. madaris k lie nafrat paida ki jaa rhi jis wajah se kuch hadd taq musalmandeen ulama aur madaris se door ja rhe. Bahot hi sahi sawal kia aapne..❤ thanks for pointing this out . 1:07:06 kind of this is true in northern India
Bhai agr RSS apko Quran ki aik ayat out of context la kr dkhaye to ap agr usko maan lo ge to ye apki bewakofi ho ge na k Quran main khuc galat hai bhai agr jin ko bi engr ki video bech main se dkhaye ho ge aur woh banda mutmain bi ho jaye to us bande ka farz hai is pe research kre aur agr ap ye bole k akshar log research nai krte to zarori nai woh engr ki short video dkhne se gumra ho jaye woh to Quran ki ayat out of context dkhane se hi gumrah ho jayen ge
But problem unki ha jo out of context clip kaatata hain otherwise Nabi A.s ki kitni ahadith hain k qurb e qayamat musalmaaanon ka ya haal ho jaye ga ya ho ga wo ho ga to iska matkab doosron ko ibraat dilana or mahfooz karna tha k musalmaanon ko mutanafar karna to musalmaan ho jayee madaris or ulama sa mutanafar farq nahiinoarhta baat ya ha Quran o Sunnat sa jura Engineer sahaba ya kah raha hain
But muje Qasir sahab ki muje baat ajeeb lagye k engr shahab ap aik baar condemn kr de bhai agr engr ye bole k RSS wale jo ye video apko dkha rhe hain galat to kia phr RSS wale ja k ye bi show kren ge nai bhai sahi baat ya rah usko hi milti jo dondna chahate hain na k koi khud ba khud milti hai.
I am an atheist and a secular but I appreciate Mirza in this video. Well done!
That's why he is an enemy of Islam
Even who can neither define nor understand the term secularism and just beating about the bush.
@@jadoonhamid5578he completely denied the liberal secularism and defined his own portraying of religious secularism ,what else you would like?
@@shamiawan5500lol atheists aur islamophobes k liye engineer sahab ek ni'mat hai jo ye sabit kar rha hai ki islam k followers dunya me boj hai
@@shamiawan5500 no dear it’s not the matter of like and dislike but fruitful debate progresses intellectually in realm of mutual understanding of standardised terms and it’s paradigms not just to coin self-style definition in way to defend previous bragging.
آسان الفاظ میں راجا صاحب نے انجینئیر کو بہت پیار سے دھویا😂😂😂
L
Aapki naqli muskurahat bata rahi he k The damage has been done
😁😁😁
1 ghnta 35 min podcast main ye kb ho gya .....? 🤨🧐
Bilkul sahi😂😂
بالکل صحیح فرمایا ایک سو دس پرسنٹ میں آپ کی بات سے متفق ہوں اس میں کوئی شک نہیں 👍👍👍❤🌹❤ جس انداز سے جواب دیے ہیں جونیئر نے گلی محلوں کا ایک لچا لفنگا بھی اس سے بہتر انداز میں گفتگو کر سکتا ہے
I am from India and I agree with Ali Mirza Saheb, none of his clips are shown in India, he is talking nonsense and blaming Engineer Saheb, keep it up Engineer Saheb.