Thanks for the video. I've done many of these and found that using just high temp silicone caulk is better than using both just the gasket or the gasket and the caulk. Also, removing the old gasket and dried out glue is critical. I use a putty knife to remove the old gasket material and I use PVC cleaner and a scratch pad taped to my small wire brush handle to remove the old glue; nice and clean. I always replace the cover as well since the old one is usually warped and prone to breakage if you have to pry it off. If the old one breaks when you take it off and you don't have a replacement and the parts house is closed then you're SOL until you can get a replacement. Not good on a cold day. You were lucky you were able to remove it just by pulling on it. Also, I've found that the screws like to strip when you try to tighten at all, even with light torque, probably because they are sheet metal screws. Did any of you have this problem and, if so, what did you do to fix it? Goodman tech support says you need to replace the heat exchanger; WHAT!!! Just imagine what the customer would say if you told them you need to replace the heat exchanger because the screws stripped out. I now use 10-24 machine screws and tap out the holes with a 10-24 tap. Seems to work pretty good, but not sure fire. Goodman should have used machine screws and/or used a neoprene or rubber gasket. Poor gasket design and cover design. It usually takes me about 2 1/2 hours to complete.
I used 10 - 5/8 sheet metal screws. I had a leak right where the old screws were stripped. (see my post). Its been over 24 hours and the furnace is dry inside without any leaks so I think the screws worked and I am good to go. Thank you for your post. It helped me. When I realized the screws were stripped, I remembered your post and got the 10 - 5/8 sheet metal screws. Thanks again.
This happened to me after 3 years. The simple fact is that the material design is poor at best. The screws are bad, too. You guys are on the right track. I bet this happens more than we all know.
i know this post is 2 years old but I am having this problem and a new gasket is only available online and will take at least 3 days. So you are suggesting using high temp silicone caulk instead? can you recommend specifically? Also, what about the little round donut gasket in the middle is that a big deal if I don't replace that?
I just replaced my gasket. It took me about 5 hours. I would have been done much sooner but two screws (where the leak was) were stripped when I took them out. Maybe that is why the leak started. The gasket looked fine. Now what?? I remember Rick L's post below about replacing the stripped sheet metal screws with 10-24 machine screws. I found that 10 - 5/8 sheet metal screws worked very well. That Goodman wants to replace the whole exchanger is ridiculous. I didnt replace the collector box (mine was not warped or cracked) but If I have to do this again I will replace it also. On a side note it doesnt surprise me Goodman would want to replace the exchanger for a stripped screw instead of telling the service tech to just get a bigger screw. A few years back my heat exchanger cracked and had to be replaced. I found my purchase receipt and warranty which was not expired. I called a local Goodman dealer and Goodman at first refused to honor the warranty which was parts and labor. They said my unit had never been registered therefore I never had a warranty. I remembered that when I had the unit installed the installer said he would register it. I didnt have to. Goodman wanted him to contact them but unfortunately he had died a few years before. Now what?? I had to do some online research to find out you dont have to register a product to have a warranty. You only need your proof of purchase which I had. The local goodman dealer was very nice and spoke to Goodman. Goodman finally offered me a free heat exchanger but would not cover the labor. The local goodman dealer replaced my heat exchanger in about 2 hours and charged me $200 dollars. I thought that was a good deal since other furnace companies wanted more than 5 times as much and werent going to help me with my warranty. As far as Goodman is concerned, this is my first and last Goodman furnace. Telling a service tech the whole exchanger has to be replaced for some stripped screws sounds just like something they would say.
Thanks for sharing the video! Except for the pain in taking out the two screws on the right top (behind the connector PVC pipe) and pulling out the box (had to scrape the gasket around the borders using a thin knife), it took about 1.5 hours to replace the gasket and fix the problem. Got the gasket from Walmart for about $6. I believe it is a bad design - Goodman should have added water vents coming down, not out, from the box.
Great job, I split one of those white inducer ell’s o couple years ago. Prying it off, I also thought it was cemented on. What a project to get that fitting, why? Lmao at that filter . Thanks and don’t bleed out😜
When I do gaskets like that, I always use my Milwaukee heat gun, and they come off easy-peas. Then I prep the surface with alcohol on both sides, to ensure good adhesion.
You add sealant, you have now just altered the furnace, that’s a no no, you could spend years of your life in prison for that, should the furnace be the cause of a CO poisoning, or fire, and someone dies.
Quick update ... apparently i celebrated it prematurely. The gasket alone did not fix the problem. Since the plastic box was not perfectly flat and smooth around the gasket area, i had to apply silicone adhesive, which finally fixed the problem!! I wonder why the manufacturer did not use rubber based basket. Anyhow, the adhesive did the wonder.
@@MiHeatingGuy I guess that's what it would be, I see a couple screws on each side and looks like a gasket showing under each bottom two corners, this is what the collector box covers, my apology I am not versed in this very well.
What kind of Rubber seal only last Two years are furnace is not old unless they put in used furnace for 4000$ because motherboard was Replaced this year.
Some time the leak water drains into the lower blower chamber and there they have control board mounted. The leak water may find way on the Control board or the transformer!!!
Thank you for this video. Question - why do you need to replace the collector box I have found some videos where people just would seal the gasket in it with the silicon? My Goodman furnace model # GM9S960603BN and as per the description it has a faster condensate water drainage and no unit water leakage! How old was that furnace when it is started to leak? Here is the video: ruclips.net/video/nfZidEFURj8/видео.html
@@craighvac1808 dirty combustion air is bad, say it's loaded with indoor contaminates, like bleach/other cleaner, litter dust, dryer lint, other chemicals and even gases leaking through the foundation/walls. but outdoor air can be bad also, near swimming pool/chlorination/filtration, patios, driveways and sidewalks that get bleached/cleaned often. also lets not forget heavy air day/night polluted from nearby factories and even highways(salt spray!) you really have to weight in all the factors
Thanks for the video.
I've done many of these and found that using just high temp silicone caulk is better than using both just the gasket or the gasket and the caulk. Also, removing the old gasket and dried out glue is critical. I use a putty knife to remove the old gasket material and I use PVC cleaner and a scratch pad taped to my small wire brush handle to remove the old glue; nice and clean. I always replace the cover as well since the old one is usually warped and prone to breakage if you have to pry it off. If the old one breaks when you take it off and you don't have a replacement and the parts house is closed then you're SOL until you can get a replacement. Not good on a cold day. You were lucky you were able to remove it just by pulling on it.
Also, I've found that the screws like to strip when you try to tighten at all, even with light torque, probably because they are sheet metal screws. Did any of you have this problem and, if so, what did you do to fix it? Goodman tech support says you need to replace the heat exchanger; WHAT!!! Just imagine what the customer would say if you told them you need to replace the heat exchanger because the screws stripped out. I now use 10-24 machine screws and tap out the holes with a 10-24 tap. Seems to work pretty good, but not sure fire. Goodman should have used machine screws and/or used a neoprene or rubber gasket. Poor gasket design and cover design. It usually takes me about 2 1/2 hours to complete.
I used 10 - 5/8 sheet metal screws. I had a leak right where the old screws were stripped. (see my post). Its been over 24 hours and the furnace is dry inside without any leaks so I think the screws worked and I am good to go. Thank you for your post. It helped me. When I realized the screws were stripped, I remembered your post and got the 10 - 5/8 sheet metal screws. Thanks again.
This happened to me after 3 years. The simple fact is that the material design is poor at best. The screws are bad, too. You guys are on the right track. I bet this happens more than we all know.
I would use a riv-nut. They work awesome.
i know this post is 2 years old but I am having this problem and a new gasket is only available online and will take at least 3 days. So you are suggesting using high temp silicone caulk instead? can you recommend specifically? Also, what about the little round donut gasket in the middle is that a big deal if I don't replace that?
Thank you sir. Did this myself, saved about $350.
I just replaced my gasket. It took me about 5 hours. I would have been done much sooner but two screws (where the leak was) were stripped when I took them out. Maybe that is why the leak started. The gasket looked fine. Now what?? I remember Rick L's post below about replacing the stripped sheet metal screws with 10-24 machine screws. I found that 10 - 5/8 sheet metal screws worked very well. That Goodman wants to replace the whole exchanger is ridiculous. I didnt replace the collector box (mine was not warped or cracked) but If I have to do this again I will replace it also.
On a side note it doesnt surprise me Goodman would want to replace the exchanger for a stripped screw instead of telling the service tech to just get a bigger screw. A few years back my heat exchanger cracked and had to be replaced. I found my purchase receipt and warranty which was not expired. I called a local Goodman dealer and Goodman at first refused to honor the warranty which was parts and labor. They said my unit had never been registered therefore I never had a warranty. I remembered that when I had the unit installed the installer said he would register it. I didnt have to. Goodman wanted him to contact them but unfortunately he had died a few years before. Now what?? I had to do some online research to find out you dont have to register a product to have a warranty. You only need your proof of purchase which I had. The local goodman dealer was very nice and spoke to Goodman. Goodman finally offered me a free heat exchanger but would not cover the labor. The local goodman dealer replaced my heat exchanger in about 2 hours and charged me $200 dollars. I thought that was a good deal since other furnace companies wanted more than 5 times as much and werent going to help me with my warranty. As far as Goodman is concerned, this is my first and last Goodman furnace. Telling a service tech the whole exchanger has to be replaced for some stripped screws sounds just like something they would say.
You saved me 585$ found the box and gasket for 32$ watched ur vid for guidance ! Thank you !
Thank you for making this video it helped this senior save some dollars.
Thanks for sharing the video! Except for the pain in taking out the two screws on the right top (behind the connector PVC pipe) and pulling out the box (had to scrape the gasket around the borders using a thin knife), it took about 1.5 hours to replace the gasket and fix the problem. Got the gasket from Walmart for about $6. I believe it is a bad design - Goodman should have added water vents coming down, not out, from the box.
Great timing, going to do one as soon as I find the part. Are any of these under a recall? Mine is leaking and cracked.
The filter at the end epic 🤘⚡️🤘
Great job, I split one of those white inducer ell’s o couple years ago. Prying it off, I also thought it was cemented on. What a project to get that fitting, why? Lmao at that filter . Thanks and don’t bleed out😜
When I do gaskets like that, I always use my Milwaukee heat gun, and they come off easy-peas. Then I prep the surface with alcohol on both sides, to ensure good adhesion.
In addition to 22 chances to break the new part, Goodman also lines the cabinet with razor sharp edges. Ouch. Good work. 👍
sounds spot on ;O
John T that way it keeps the hair off my knuckles
Does the gasket go on like this video or like in your other video it was stuck onto the collector box first then attached?
Fellow hvac techs! This is not an everyday repair. It's a flaw of Goodman high efficiency furnaces. Changing collector boxes is not routine.
I’m trying just replacing the gasket. We’ll see how it goes.
I'll be an Pro furnace installer after dealing with this Goodman furnace I took plumbing year's ago but Painting is much simple.
Clear video on Goodman Collector Box replacement! So helpful! For quality Goodman Collector Box spare parts visit our site.
Awesome video! Thanks!
22 screws and it still leaks. I put high temp caulk on the bottom along with the seal.
You add sealant, you have now just altered the furnace, that’s a no no, you could spend years of your life in prison for that, should the furnace be the cause of a CO poisoning, or fire, and someone dies.
@@justinperry68 well there's the common sense I was waiting for.
@@colindavid5868 Hate for the family to sue itself for wrongful death. please...
My favorite diagnostic is “hmm”
Quick update ... apparently i celebrated it prematurely. The gasket alone did not fix the problem. Since the plastic box was not perfectly flat and smooth around the gasket area, i had to apply silicone adhesive, which finally fixed the problem!! I wonder why the manufacturer did not use rubber based basket. Anyhow, the adhesive did the wonder.
Curious why you opted to replace the whole collection box and not just the gasket. Was the box cracked or warped?
The usually are warped. For $30 it’s a good idea to replace the box also
@@joshsmith2982 I checked the prices for a collector box for my Goodman and it was $38.
Great job and video like always
Do you happen to have a part number for the collector box and gasket?
Use some good silicone caulk and you should be fine
It’s imprinted in a circular shape on the bottom corner of the old collector box (exterior). I had a hard time finding it as well but yeah.
Where can I order a collector box
lol lost one screw always happens to me I had a great laugh
Hey Rick could you please give me the part number of the collector box I have been looking for one exactly like that and cannot find one
not sure and who is rick
It’s imprinted in a circular shape on the bottom corner of the old collector box (exterior). I had a hard time finding it as well but yeah.
That gasket is just going to fail again. Use high temp silicone.
How many screws do you need in a collector box you ask? It’s a Goodman! 🤷♀️
Like a British car. And it still leaks.
Minus one...
Took me seven Videos to get to this Video. after diagnose Condensation pump works fine no clogs I'm thinking Goodman blowers leeks to.
I change a bunch of them.
I try but couldn’t remove the pvc pipe I have one top right and left another one , look like they are glue , any tips ? Can u help me ? Thanks
That goodman beat the crap out of you.
Hey do you know where the gasket is. And where to put the high temperature silicone on thr gasket. Please let me know.....Thanks
Hire a professional bud.
Where does the water come from if it involves the heater?
It's a condensing furnace creates condensate
Just a quick question, the plate behind the collector box that has a few screws and a gasket? mine is identical GMS9094
Are you talking about the secondary heat exchanger
@@MiHeatingGuy I guess that's what it would be, I see a couple screws on each side and looks like a gasket showing under each bottom two corners, this is what the collector box covers, my apology I am not versed in this very well.
Old collector box looked good, couldn't you just have put new casket and better screws
What kind of Rubber seal only last Two years are furnace is not old unless they put in used furnace for 4000$ because motherboard was Replaced this year.
Some time the leak water drains into the lower blower chamber and there they have control board mounted. The leak water may find way on the Control board or the transformer!!!
Thank you for this video. Question - why do you need to replace the collector box I have found some videos where people just would seal the gasket in it with the silicon? My Goodman furnace model # GM9S960603BN and as per the description it has a faster condensate water drainage and no unit water leakage! How old was that furnace when it is started to leak? Here is the video: ruclips.net/video/nfZidEFURj8/видео.html
Nice video. I hate single pipe 90% outside combustion air is important
What makes you think that? Just out of curiosity
@@craighvac1808 dirty combustion air is bad, say it's loaded with indoor contaminates, like bleach/other cleaner, litter dust, dryer lint, other chemicals and even gases leaking through the foundation/walls. but outdoor air can be bad also, near swimming pool/chlorination/filtration, patios, driveways and sidewalks that get bleached/cleaned often. also lets not forget heavy air day/night polluted from nearby factories and even highways(salt spray!) you really have to weight in all the factors
LOL, must have had a surplus on screws..jeesh