Hindi Language Controversy: What did R Ashwin say and what did he mean? • Sree Iyer

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 янв 2025

Комментарии • 392

  • @rajaramakutty9088
    @rajaramakutty9088 15 дней назад +147

    These Dengue Malaria Kazhagam (DMK) don't have a problem with Urdu or Arabic. Their problem is only with bona-fide Indian languages like Hindi and Sanskrit.

    • @praks007
      @praks007 15 дней назад +13

      Languages are not popular or unpopular based on what you like or dislike. It is based on what is most spoken. In this context the children were not insulting Hindi. They cheered for Tamil because obviously they are in Tamil Nadu and majority speak Tamil.
      If a minister from TN goes to a UP school and say, English, Hindi or Tamil, then obviously the children will cheer for Hindi and be silent for Tamil. Does that mean the UP children hate Tamil? Of course not.

    • @sreerajsukumarannair2772
      @sreerajsukumarannair2772 15 дней назад +2

      @@rajaramakutty9088 spot on.wellsaid 🙏🏻🇮🇳

    • @sreerajsukumarannair2772
      @sreerajsukumarannair2772 15 дней назад +9

      @@praks007 the question here is not what ashwin is saying. The discussion is on the mind set of the Regional parties especially DMK wherein they create an anti-hindi narrative. Now that has gone to the extent of being anti - hindu narrative and anti - sanatani narrative. That is what is being discussed here. At this point i dont think ashwin is trying to degrade hindi and support DMK narrative. His future actions will prove his stance.🙏🏻🇮🇳

    • @taneemtaha4230
      @taneemtaha4230 15 дней назад +7

      @@praks007 he commented on urdu Arabic.. u r explaining in Tamil Nadu what is majority .. r u alright sir

    • @praks007
      @praks007 15 дней назад +7

      @@sreerajsukumarannair2772 What anti hindi narrative? If the center is trying to impose hindi in a Tamil state then obviously the state will speak up right? Why should you call it anti hindi narrative?

  • @sudhakashyap9697
    @sudhakashyap9697 15 дней назад +64

    Yes Hindi is not our national language it’s a official he is correct.

    • @rajivsharma999
      @rajivsharma999 14 дней назад +2

      U seem to sound very opinionated… Madam try to understand I am from Andhrapradesh .. can I ask for making Telugu as our National language? The Answer is a simple NO. Majority in India speak Hindi.. What’s wrong ? If u are positive minded u will learn Hindi as well as teach our mother tongue to our children … I hope u will understand

    • @Koinae
      @Koinae 14 дней назад +5

      ​@@rajivsharma999 In North, west, central, east and even in parts of north east India no one have problem with hindi. We all use hindi as connecting language. We have our different mother tongue depending on our states. But we use hindi and don't hate it. But when i see south they thinks rest of India have hindi as their mother tongue and want to impose hindi as national language. But it is false propaganda of Dravidian propaganda based party. 🙏🙏🙏

    • @rajivsharma999
      @rajivsharma999 14 дней назад

      @@Koinae exactly that’s a false propaganda created by DMK. Why ? Vote bank politics. Guys let’s all understand one thing , any politician who speaks against our country or something which hurts our country is a THEIF. We should not be siding with those politicians who ever it may be.

    • @shaktimangangadhar3638
      @shaktimangangadhar3638 14 дней назад +2

      There is no comparison of Hindi and Tamil. Hindi is not a regional language, there is no village which can claim that hindi is their language.
      Every region has their separate language and their separate mother tongue, and all learn Hindi to communicate to each other.
      And Sanskrit is the common thread in most Indian language.
      Its not a national language yes but it should be, and Hindi does not stop someone to create poems in their mother tongue, to converse in their mother tongue, to read write books in their mother tongue.
      English by the way does that, because of the coloniality.

    • @PremJay
      @PremJay 14 дней назад +4

      @@rajivsharma999 go and live in andra nobody is preventing you. but if you come to tn, learn to respect tamil culture and speak tamil. dont come here and tell us what to do

  •  15 дней назад +37

    Ashwin is absolutely correct, As per Indian constitution article 343,Hindi is an official language. There is no National language in India

  • @jaihind3595
    @jaihind3595 15 дней назад +26

    Ashwin has been spot on in opining so! Bravo!!!❤ . Refer Article 343 of the constitution of India you will know Ashwin has spoken the fact!!!🎉

  • @Shoonya_India
    @Shoonya_India 15 дней назад +25

    Ashwin has very clearly communicated in tamil interviews about the unnecessary language barrier which is an obstacle for TN youth. He's a smart guy won't fall for cheap politics around him.

  • @bvireannah1806
    @bvireannah1806 15 дней назад +46

    My respected late dad was of the opinion every one should learn atleast 1 southern language, he starting learning Tamil besides marathi in 1970s in Tamil Samajam classes (my mom learnt marathi , even though they knew spoken language wanted to learn correct grammer etc)in kings circle,sion area- mumbai as he originally was from north (delhi local ancestral place now is more than 150 years old ) 🤔🤨🧐now more than 55 years in mumbai, i myself could understand , speak 3 southern languages learnt in hostel

  • @madhusudhanavedantam726
    @madhusudhanavedantam726 15 дней назад +39

    Ashwin is a thorough gentleman, never say petty things, an Indian to the core!! ❤❤❤Ashwin for what he achieved in cricket for India!!!

  • @wokenessendedintheyear2025
    @wokenessendedintheyear2025 15 дней назад +24

    Sanskrit is spoken by more than a Million People in Bharat. Instead of letting our Sacred Language die, We should be preserving it by making it atleast the 3rd Language in Schools and Universities. Sanskrit teachers should be encouraged to teach Sanskrit. It’s thousands of years older than English, French, Spanish, Germanic as well as Greek and Roman.

    • @vickyrawat6113
      @vickyrawat6113 14 дней назад +1

      Yes you are right.👍

    • @vickyrawat6113
      @vickyrawat6113 14 дней назад +1

      Can you help me by providing some authentic books , sites names to learn and understand Sanskrit language . When I was in 8 th standard I got very humble teacher of Sanskrit he did teach us in a very good way that it remains still in my heart in a way like I will learn Sanskrit no matter what will be my profession. Now I am gonna persue my under graduation along with it I want learn Sanskrit .
      U r small efforts will encourage me .

    • @NAYouTuCA
      @NAYouTuCA 14 дней назад

      It should only be optional people have the freedom to choose

    • @jothimsw
      @jothimsw 13 дней назад +1

      It useless in day to day life other than using it for mantras…

    • @blackbull2550
      @blackbull2550 13 дней назад +4

      Sanskrit is not "our" language. You can say that it is your language. Why should we learn your language? Sanskrit is a "Indo-European" language, which doesn't have its own script. You learn, speak, worship Sanskrit ... its your right. Don't bring it to us. If Sanskrit is thousands of years older than English, French, Spanish, Germanic as well as Greek and Roman, then you all go to those countries and try to teach them your language, if they allow you to do so. YOU MAY INCLUDE HEBREW as well. I hope you understand everything very well.

  • @sathyanarayanan3998
    @sathyanarayanan3998 15 дней назад +25

    Ashwin is right. Hindi is only an official language as per our Constitution.

  • @sivasankarannair833
    @sivasankarannair833 15 дней назад +26

    Hindi is the official language and not national language though it is spoken or understood by a large number of people. I have been living in north India since more than 5 decades and I can handle Hindi very well. I used to enjoy the speeches of Vajpayee ji and now I enjoy speeches of Mody ji and Yogi ji, but still Hindi is not our national language.

  • @gubbinarayanswamy2855
    @gubbinarayanswamy2855 15 дней назад +35

    It's very Peculiar we, Indians Honor Indians respect Foreigners and their Language Britishers Helped to Fulfill Their "AGENDAS "

  • @free_thinker_rationalist_tamil
    @free_thinker_rationalist_tamil 14 дней назад +14

    Instead of asking Tamils / Kannadigas / Malayalis to learn Hindi, it is better for the people from UP / Bihar to learn the language of the states they migrate to for doing menial labor.
    It is the norm the world over for the economic migrants to learn the language of the land they migrate to.
    It is funny that the guys like this speaker want locals to learn the language of the migrants. Does not make any sense at all. 🙂🙂

    • @vrg1966
      @vrg1966 13 дней назад +3

      You are right. He is just giving useless half-baked ideas and conducting propaganda for Hindi which is totally nonsense.

  • @Bhadrudu
    @Bhadrudu 14 дней назад +7

    Hindi is not related to nationalism, to identifying one language with nationalism is suppression of other Indian languages.

    • @practicingminimalism4710
      @practicingminimalism4710 14 дней назад +1

      Hindi is not a National Language daa! But I love the Hindi language machaan as much as I love Tamil.

    • @blackbull2550
      @blackbull2550 13 дней назад +1

      @@practicingminimalism4710 Good to know that you love 250 yrs old "Indo-European" language Hindi .

  • @shanthalakshmi2082
    @shanthalakshmi2082 14 дней назад +3

    No controversy. He spoke the truth and reality

  • @jyothysri
    @jyothysri 14 дней назад +3

    Was very fortunate to have leaned hindi way back, this helped me immensely during my sales career, working in UP, Maharashtra, where i had an opportunity to learn marathi . people need a smoke screen to cover up, as one my exboss used to say you cannot cover the Sh....t with a blanket ultimately it will stink.

  • @Chander53
    @Chander53 14 дней назад +2

    Ash , no harm , you just explained the fact , we are with you

  • @pradeepkonnanath
    @pradeepkonnanath 15 дней назад +7

    He just asked what language you all prefer...Thats all...

  • @MN1961M
    @MN1961M 14 дней назад +2

    Ashwin demonstrated his knowledge when he says that Hindi is not the National Language. Those who are making an issue out of it are exposing their ignorance.

  • @srv232
    @srv232 14 дней назад +5

    Northies have an inherent bias against the South and that cannot be denied. So even if he said it, it is his right to say it. Go find your own brain and stand up and say what you have to say.

  • @EriOliyanVaenthi
    @EriOliyanVaenthi 13 дней назад +2

    We tamils back our greatest tamil cricketer Ashwin 1000000%. He just stated the fact. Almost all north indian media is furious for no reason.

  • @chandrasekaranhemakumar3254
    @chandrasekaranhemakumar3254 14 дней назад +3

    Wgat Ashwin said is correct. Hindi is not a national language. Our Constitution does not recognize any language as a national language.

  • @venkatramananradhakrishnan4524
    @venkatramananradhakrishnan4524 15 дней назад +7

    Yes Sun News got a doctored video..circulation

  • @amarnathnagabushan7425
    @amarnathnagabushan7425 14 дней назад +1

    Media is blowing it out of proportion. He spoke in a language every one understood. You know very well who will reap the benefits of this controversy. Media has to be responsible.

    • @Sivajay10
      @Sivajay10 14 дней назад

      This is stupid play by Ashwin & This is unnecessary Comment Unless someone said Hindi is our national language and Asked Ashwin to speak in hindi instead of English or Tamil. What he said is right but Why he said it there is unnecessary.

    • @rrao7963
      @rrao7963 14 дней назад

      ​@@Sivajay10I agree with you because of virat kohli didn't support him he is disturbed

  • @drsubashn4025
    @drsubashn4025 9 дней назад +1

    When south indians go to northern parts they are expected to learn and speak Hindi. But when north indians go to southen parts , south indians are expected to speak to them in hindi. . !!

  • @vinayakdasaka4605
    @vinayakdasaka4605 15 дней назад +1

    Never say anything that will give chance to some people to take it up and create controversies. Now, this individual is pulled into controversies.

  • @viswanathanseshadri1047
    @viswanathanseshadri1047 14 дней назад +1

    I have been thinking about this issue over the years. My stance has undergone a change. I now am beginning to think that having the concept of an "official" language abe was probably a mistake, as was granting recognition to 10 or 22'or 15:other languages with that status of being "official". I am now really beginning to think if language of convenience would not have been a better concept, and leave the languages to the people and society at large.

  • @GunaSekaran-zj2nl
    @GunaSekaran-zj2nl 11 дней назад +1

    Hindi is not our national language.
    All the languages have equal rights in India.
    This is called united india.

  • @1960subbu
    @1960subbu 15 дней назад +2

    All indian languages are given the status of national languages, including Hindi. But Hindi is also official language. So, lets get it clear, HIndi is not the only national language, but other languages also are national languages.

  • @GunaSekaran-zj2nl
    @GunaSekaran-zj2nl 11 дней назад

    Anyone is having doubt, please refer the Supreme court judgement on the national language issues

  • @srinivasagopalanramanujam1179
    @srinivasagopalanramanujam1179 14 дней назад +1

    Why did Ashwin bring up the topic of Hindi? Did someone ask him to speak in Hindi? Then, why bring it up?

  • @abhayagarwal2589
    @abhayagarwal2589 15 дней назад +4

    Generally speaking, languages are for communication. People learn it based on the utility and the vastness of it. If a language connects you with either huge number of people or influential people, it is good to learn it. If you make it an issue of prestige, then you will be the one suffering because you would not be able to expand your network. People should be willing to learn as many languages as possible, specially the ones which are highly influential or spoken among large masses.

    • @peachNpink
      @peachNpink 15 дней назад

      Because original Hindi is since Satyayuga more than 1000years old. It is spoken by maximum people in maximum states of India. Tell me one Southern language spoken outside the state. ​@@santoshbannur

    • @abhayagarwal2589
      @abhayagarwal2589 15 дней назад +1

      @@santoshbannur Because the language of national politics is Hindi, like the language of economy and formal communication is English. Hindi is spoken among the largest number of people in India, who play a major role in deciding the political fate of the nation. I agree with your point that Hindi currently seems away from culture, which is why Hindi needs Sanskritization.
      Hindi is not spoken only in "Hindi belt" but also heavily used in Non-Hindi states like Gujarat and Maharashtra. Even in parts of Karnataka, Telangana, West Bengal, Odisha, etc., people can communicate in Hindi. Almost, 60% of the Bharatiya population can speak or/and understand Hindi as, at least, their 3rd language.
      P.S.- When I am talking about the importance of Hindi, it does not, at all, mean that we should should not be proud of other Indian languages, and ignore them. We should celebrate the glory of all Bharatiya languages as a part our shared heritage as Bharatiyas.

    • @abhayagarwal2589
      @abhayagarwal2589 15 дней назад +1

      @@santoshbannur Then, good luck understanding and making a mark on national political scene, and expanding your horizons beyond your respective states. National politics will NOT be Non-Hindi languages based no matter what you do, because none of those languages provide 60% population coverage, overall, across India. Anyway, no one is forcing you to learn anything. I have just pointed out the signficance of Hindi because you asked the question. Northeners do not speak in Hindi with southerners anyway, they use English for striking neutrality.
      Having said it, I do agree with you on respecting local languages and eventually Sanskrit being the national language. My suggestion is only for the time being.
      Jai Hind! Jai Bharatam!

    • @radhikaraja8875
      @radhikaraja8875 15 дней назад

      ​@@santoshbannur..iam from Kerala and my opinion is that by learning to.speak Hindi...it works out to my efficiency in all parts of Bharat.. whether in Bengal, Telangana, Karnataka , TN , Orissa, Gujarat , Punjab, Rajasthan, Maharashtra, MP and almost any part of Bharat .I can manage to communicate compared to not knowing/ speaking Hindi but only English(apart from my mother tongue).I wonder how will I be able to manage in different parts of North, south, east and west Bharat....my knowledge of spoken English will be of no use other than in metropolitan cities .
      I feel it is just a feeling of self inflicted complex regarding Hindi ..and the hatred for North Indians that is coming out as hatred for Hindi..and believe me it is being politicised by the politicians by fooling the citizens of TN..
      Again ultimately we should all strive to bring back the lost glory of Sanskrit because our civilization is based on Sanskrit and which will unite this nation as a Sanatan Bharat...

    • @manjunathmnm
      @manjunathmnm 15 дней назад

      ​@@santoshbannurAgree with you 💯👍

  • @raghavansubramanian178
    @raghavansubramanian178 15 дней назад +5

    He can't stand up against Dravidian stocks and hope he wakes and proves it wrong😊😊

  • @dilleynasar297
    @dilleynasar297 15 дней назад +2

    Without Hindi Thamizh Nadu fares much better than Hindi belt, can you contest this

  • @narasimhannarayanarao775
    @narasimhannarayanarao775 14 дней назад +1

    Aswin dishonest? Drop out from cricket? Vengence? Any how it is unwanted. Totally fishy oh selfish. Lost his credibility.

  • @VenugopalanV-v5x
    @VenugopalanV-v5x 15 дней назад +1

    Dear Shri Iyer,
    You should tell the viewers that who we should follow in the X platform to know the ‘Sir’

  • @prafullabehera2178
    @prafullabehera2178 15 дней назад +1

    Excellent revelation.

  • @sankar42ify
    @sankar42ify 14 дней назад

    I had great respect for him. Since he spoke about Hindi and Tamil, that too, in an educational institution ceremony ... Just because he retired.

  • @sreenivasamurthy4163
    @sreenivasamurthy4163 14 дней назад +1

    If, after getting ayes for English, Tamil and Hindi, Ashwin had proceeded directly to his speech in Tamil, it wouldn't have made any news. It wouldn't have provided
    any fodder to controversisl-news hungry TV channels.
    But this newsbyte would be used by all channels if Ashwin enters politics in Tamil Nadu in the future. That's when people will start connecting dots and putting two and two together. If that doesn't happen, this will just blow over in a few days.

  • @rajivsharma999
    @rajivsharma999 14 дней назад +2

    We are Indians …and we should always be identified such… not on the basis of such silly differences in terms of language, caste , religion etc

    • @jothimsw
      @jothimsw 13 дней назад

      If you don’t identify yourself by language,caste and religion then you are not an Indian.. how about identifying with iyer???😅😅😅😅

  • @kumarmanish1409
    @kumarmanish1409 14 дней назад

    Thanks for clarifying, Sir. I also tweeted on the same lines. I coundn’t understand what Ashwin said but I knew he wouldn’t insult Hindi. He in fact encouraged people to learn Hindi from other forums. He runs a Hindi you tube channel himself. Sadly, there are some political vultures always ready to feed on inncoents like Ashwin in this case.

  • @jayanthikeshav8224
    @jayanthikeshav8224 15 дней назад +2

    But all Labour who are in the construction area are only Hindi speaking...this is double standards

  • @ramachandrananduri5657
    @ramachandrananduri5657 14 дней назад

    I fully agree with you.

  • @sudarshanr7040
    @sudarshanr7040 13 дней назад

    Whatever action has to be taken by the police have been complied and further investigations are also in progress. Annamalai is an ex IPS officer, now he has become an politician. Just because he has joined politics , has he forgotten the normal procedure of conducting an investigation and the process it requires. Honourable judges of high court have condemned the issue being politicized. Still Annamalai/ BJP are continuing thier protest . Do they think thier disgraceful attitude will be appreciated by general public.

  • @venkateshvs4330
    @venkateshvs4330 15 дней назад +8

    Just allowing Hindi to be taught, does not replace your regional language. It is ultra foolishness of politicians to oppose it and nothing else. Martin, Punjabi, assame, gujarati, bengali etc languages did not disappear because they speak hindi.

    • @jothimsw
      @jothimsw 13 дней назад +1

      Exactly. North Indians should learn Tamil and other South Indian languages….

    • @ArnabBiswas-l6x
      @ArnabBiswas-l6x 10 дней назад

      Then you learn Bengali.

  • @praks007
    @praks007 15 дней назад +2

    There is no controversy. He was only asking the students which language he should speak. And he was quite taken back that there was complete silence on Hindi. So he repeated it only to verify it once again. And he justified the silence by saying....yeah of course because hindi is not our national language.

    • @wokenessendedintheyear2025
      @wokenessendedintheyear2025 15 дней назад

      Why do you want to impose English as the National Language of Bharat?

    • @talesara74
      @talesara74 15 дней назад

      I think he intentionaly acted very ignorant and expected some Hindi speaking in the crowd.

  • @gangatharanchinnan7257
    @gangatharanchinnan7257 10 дней назад +1

    Weather it is a national language or official language it is the sane.

  • @subramanianmahadevan1250
    @subramanianmahadevan1250 13 дней назад

    When a person from TN wants to move away from the State, it's a must that he is adept at the Hindi language, in addition to English. People like Ashwin have encountered problems due to lack of proficiency in Hindi. What he says is correct .

  • @ajaykumarjha1608
    @ajaykumarjha1608 15 дней назад +1

    Sriji, you correctly said that this perriayr ecosystem has ensured that the common people in the TN are not not taught Hindi. Since you talked about Navodaya Vidyalay and KVs, I know a person named N Gineesh K from TN, who was posted in jharkhand, during a discussion on Hindi Diwas, when someone told that since Hindi as a language is spoken by more number of people, should be the national language, so the fellow named Giineesh, suddenly says that since crows as a bird are found everywhere, so it should be the national Bird of India. What I want to say is that it's also some people in TN hate Hindi to the extent that even if they know the language, they would not speak it. I have come across people from Kerala, AP, Karnataka but no one from there would say it openly that they hate Hindi. And surprisingly that fellow Gineesh k for at least 12 to 13 yrs, had served in the NE region and than in the place where i met him, during his service period.

  • @DeedarGhatehorde
    @DeedarGhatehorde 15 дней назад +1

    Excellent 👍👍👍

  • @ashuexcel
    @ashuexcel 15 дней назад +11

    How can one hate hindi and sanskrit? Can one hate the language which has given your name...

    • @cosmicallyspeaking871
      @cosmicallyspeaking871 15 дней назад +1

      The name stalin is as Adharmic as one can get.

    • @NAYouTuCA
      @NAYouTuCA 14 дней назад

      No one is hating the language it's only the people who are imposing one language on others causing the trouble

    • @ashuexcel
      @ashuexcel 14 дней назад

      @@NAYouTuCA who is forcing it btw? In fact hindi/urdu has a overwhelming presence in the subcontinent and is well understood across afganistan, pakistan, india, nepal, bhutan and even bangladesh.
      Actually its not a forced thing but a necessity at times as so many are speaking it and we cant somehow ignore it..same like english.
      But opposing hindi just beacause central govt wants to teach it as a language in JNV, KV, sainik schools etc is foolish.
      Why on earth we learn english,? Its for communicating with the world as its the most used language now.

    • @NAYouTuCA
      @NAYouTuCA 14 дней назад

      ​@@ashuexcel Then why can't we everyone learn and communicate in English it's the most convenient ? One language for local and common language should be English that solves everything

    • @ashuexcel
      @ashuexcel 14 дней назад

      @NAYouTuCA why not my language which is spoken by just 2 lakh people...
      And does everyone know english? Thw whole world jokes about "indian accent" and why should i converse in a language if i have other option?
      I can converse with 85% indians with ease with hindi/urdu sp have no issue.
      But if you cant converse with an average indian who hardly speaks english, its your loss.
      Your hate for hindi is the real issue my dear and you are unable to digest the fact that its widely accepted as a medium even in deep south..
      I with a language with 2 lakh speakers am not paranoid buy someone with 100 million speakers is worried...come on your language wont vanish untill you starr conversong with your kids in some other language..btw most are now speaking in english nowadays and that generation may not communicate in local languages in future..

  • @EriOliyanVaenthi
    @EriOliyanVaenthi 13 дней назад

    Bangladesh got separated when native Bengali langauge was sidelined and Urdu imposed.

  • @swathiprasaddora9627
    @swathiprasaddora9627 14 дней назад

    Unnecessary controversy by dragging our 'National Language Hindi' in his speech sad indeed 😞
    We all missed lack of Hindi knowledge due to 'DRAVIDIAN' politics ...... hope & wish our youngsters take initiative to learn Hindi.

  • @shanmugamisha
    @shanmugamisha 15 дней назад +1

    Namaskaram Sri Iyar ji.

  • @shakthidharanp.v8030
    @shakthidharanp.v8030 14 дней назад +1

    Ashwin should punished legally if really said what ever record he made it india gave him the stage for do it

    • @feelthirsty5111
      @feelthirsty5111 14 дней назад +1

      Yes india gave him stage so what....is he indian or what?...do you think only hindi speakers are india??...immature grow up...

  • @sadasivank6082
    @sadasivank6082 13 дней назад

    Nobody has the right to stop a person from learning a new language of his/her choice. Opportunities should be given for learning new languages. Also, nobody should be forced to learn a language which he/she does not want to.
    A language will survive only if its spoken and written by people. A language should be in daily use for its existence. We should take steps so that none of our Indian languages become extinct.

  • @GOODMEALTASTESGOOD
    @GOODMEALTASTESGOOD 14 дней назад +1

    If at all there is one language that can integrate the whole nation and even the entire Indian subcontinent, that is Sanskrit. Sanskrit can even integrate Germans, Arminian, Latvian, Azerbaijani, English, Spanish, Italian, Australian tribal languages, Newziland tribal languages, African tribal languages, Argentinian tribal languages, French, Malai, Nepali, Myanmar, Korea, Cambodia, Nepal, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Iran… you name a language, there is Sanskrit in it.

  • @kommajosyullashyamprasad1451
    @kommajosyullashyamprasad1451 14 дней назад

    MY SIX YEAR OLD GRANDSON WHO RESIDES IN PICKERING CANADA GOES TO SPANISH AND FRENCH DURING SUMMER VACATION.

  • @ramyasrikanth8423
    @ramyasrikanth8423 15 дней назад

    Media is like playing Chinese whispers.. nobody will know the original form of anything said..

  • @Amod2050
    @Amod2050 14 дней назад +1

    The comments in most of the website are full of claims how Tamilnadu feeds North India. Truth is opposite and ugly: "Kerala, Tamil Nadu and Himachal Pradesh have the highest overall migration rate according to a recent ILO report". There is hardly any brotherhood between Tamils and Kannadigas.

    • @JordMax-s8t
      @JordMax-s8t 14 дней назад +1

      Hardly one goes to north for job

    • @Amod2050
      @Amod2050 13 дней назад +2

      Check the immigration data out of Tamilnadu both within India and outside India.

  • @raysun6617
    @raysun6617 14 дней назад +1

    Namaskaram(Sanskrit) = Vanakkam(Tamil)

    • @SJ-tm6iq
      @SJ-tm6iq 14 дней назад

      Sree Iyar doesn’t know that.

  • @SV-wu2my
    @SV-wu2my 15 дней назад +3

    But Stalin family run schools teach Hindi. English medium and Tamil is taught as just language

  • @lathas6302
    @lathas6302 14 дней назад

    During 70s , 80s , 90s and in the year 2000 to 2004 I have seen hindi was there in kendriya vidyalaya and in private schools in coimbatore, but I don't know the status now

  • @hariharankailasanathan7532
    @hariharankailasanathan7532 15 дней назад +1

    In any case tamil or Malayalam or Telugu is also not national language. But any Indian benefits by knowing any language spoken by any Indian. He never loses something by knowing some language spoken by anyother Indian.

  • @ramakalimireddi9083
    @ramakalimireddi9083 14 дней назад +1

    Tamils if they want to movie out of State they should learn Hindi language, they should buy "learn in 30 days language books" just like IAS officers there posting area local language they learn, actually North people they have lot of descrimation against South Indians.

  • @lakshminarasimhan3252
    @lakshminarasimhan3252 14 дней назад

    Excellent 👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👌👌👌👍👍👍👍👍👍👌

  • @umaamarnath4745
    @umaamarnath4745 14 дней назад +1

    Sir we dont want hindi to be an official one. What is wrong in making english as a communicative one.

  • @venkatesank4183
    @venkatesank4183 15 дней назад

    Good afternoon sir 🙏🙏🙏. Wonderful listening to you sir 🙏🙏🙏

  • @ldreams730
    @ldreams730 14 дней назад +2

    Make tamil as national language

  • @skumaryt
    @skumaryt 14 дней назад

    But why that statement was needed in first place !! and why did he not ask about other official languages :)

  • @lakshmanand5161
    @lakshmanand5161 14 дней назад

    I agee with you on Navodhya schools Sir and on learning Hindi but it should not be imposed

  • @gopalc3733
    @gopalc3733 13 дней назад

    What Ashwin deserved he could not get as he is from south. To note that both 1&2 wicket takers in India are from south. Today, non-playing captain is from a Hindi speaking state and an inefficient coach is from north.
    South or Tamil Nadu does not mean dmk or admk. Respect languages and tamilians respect their mother tongue in addition to other languages. A mother does not discriminate their children.

  • @Bslkuye-29q
    @Bslkuye-29q 14 дней назад +1

    Mandarin was not spoken by majority Chinese forget every individual but made china's official language and even now almost one third donot speak/know it. Similarly French was not spoken in France by all but made national language and people speak it. English is internationally spoken but eould you expect USA/UK etc people w🎉ho work anywhere in the world to learn language of that country? Btw I see Indians from South who donot speak English, talk to each other in Hindi very comfortably here in Mumbai.

  • @avi105
    @avi105 14 дней назад

    He is right, one is Hindi is not national language and should not be. Other is if he is south Indian, he can not be captain of Indian team . It is only maharastrians and north indians allowed now.

  • @PremJay
    @PremJay 14 дней назад +1

    Inventor saheb, FYI: In TN schools, students have an option to learn Hindi or Tamil as a second language. So, those who need to learn, they learn. No one is stopping that. Dont peddle non sense by saying otherwise and selectively leaving what the BJP is doing. What is the need to rename everything in Hindi? In the same video, you can see majority speak Tamil and English. Why they need to speak Hindi? Now, lets talk other things. Tamil culture goes back 3000 years. Tamil literature, Language goes back thousands of years. It is older than Sanskrit. In other words, we know roughly how old Sanskrit is. But no one can say how old Tamil is. It goes beyond Sanskrit. So, dont peddle non sense. Tamil people are smarter than what you think.. because of the history. They understood English is important to communicate with the world and they have Tamil in their heart and minds. There is no place for HINDI. But you will keep trying. We know that. Anyway, Ashwin is an outlier. He is speaking clearly using the right words keeping the context in mind.

    • @SJ-tm6iq
      @SJ-tm6iq 14 дней назад

      The BJP and their supporters including Thi channel and Sree Iyar only want to create controversy and instability in Tamil Nadu which is compariyively peaceful ashamed this block claims to be a tamilian.

  • @SBALAK9753
    @SBALAK9753 8 дней назад

    Mr Iyer seems to think that in schools the primary objective is to learn as many languages as possible and does not care about other subjects. Children has limited time in school and their time is precious. Learning a language that does not help them in mastering important subjects has no value especially if they can`not use it in any meaningful way. I have learnt many languages but could never master them when I am not in a place where that language is not spoken. It is more important that the children in school learn subjects like Mathematics, science, history, geography, literature etc in depth. What is the use of learning Hindi in any of these fields? Sure Mr Iyer has learnt Hindi since he lives in an area where Hindi or Urdu is spoken. For children in Tamil Nadu it is enough to learn Tamil and English along with subjects like science which will help them in their life. No sense in learning a language like Hindi which does not benefit them in improving their understanding of these subjects. With English they can acquire knowledge of subjects that they are not able to get in Tamil. So Mr Iyer should stop making pleas for people to learn Hindi in school. If the necessity arises people will learn any language that they need once they learn two languages well. Additional languages are only necessary if they have some usefulness for adults. Mr Iyer seems to advocate Hindi in TN while he never ever asks the people in the Hindi areas to learn additional Indian languages.

  • @ananthanarayanannv9589
    @ananthanarayanannv9589 14 дней назад

    Did anyone have guts to asks north indian to learn one of other indian language

  • @Nation_first1947
    @Nation_first1947 15 дней назад +5

    This guy Aswin is brand ambassador for many companies. Guy learn many many indian languages. English is going to collapse. All english countries are down financially. No more jobs will be in these countries.

    • @JordMax-s8t
      @JordMax-s8t 14 дней назад

      North India coming south 😮😢😢😢

    • @ArnabBiswas-l6x
      @ArnabBiswas-l6x 10 дней назад

      Hindi speaking people are down financially. They depend on non hindi people's money.

  • @johndavid3064
    @johndavid3064 14 дней назад

    If Iyer is so sure as to who SIR is.He should come out and say it.Not hide behind rhetorics

  • @ganapatibhat2161
    @ganapatibhat2161 13 дней назад

    Mr. Iyer, people outside Tamilnadu and they will not be knowing the fine aspects of TN. Please do not take your viewers for granted, put them in confusion about who that 'SIR' is! Or, perhaps your also afraid of that gang!

  • @sram3875
    @sram3875 15 дней назад

    Namaskaram Sree Ji. With all the enlightenment we have been receiving from PGurus conversations, something not good with that statement. Why from nowhere Ashwin has to mention it explicitly? I dont know!! On the other hand, great respects for him. I hope he is not getting succumbed to this sort of influence. But only worry is that his words will be used as distraction by these stocks!!

  • @dsconverse
    @dsconverse 14 дней назад

    No issues if Ashwin calls Hindi a link language. Tamil was there in past without controversy that political situation has made today. Best wishes for Tamil and Hindi🙏
    अगर अश्विन हिंदी को संपर्क भाषा कहें तो कोई दिक्कत नहीं। तमिल अतीत में बिना किसी विवाद के थी, जो आज राजनीतिक स्थिति ने बना दी है। तमिल और हिंदी के लिए शुभकामनाएं🙏

  • @sudarshanr7040
    @sudarshanr7040 13 дней назад

    A majority of brahmins atleast in tamilnadu are not wholeheartedly happy about the bjp rule . But the main reason for thier bjp support is , they are against DMK , " MY ENEMIES ENEMY IS MY FRIEND " is the reason.

  • @nagkanda
    @nagkanda 13 дней назад

    Everyone knows hindi is not a national language. What is the necessity to tell about this. Ashwin thinks that he is super in everything. Let him concentrate only on cricket activities only.

  • @geethanjalirajaram9288
    @geethanjalirajaram9288 15 дней назад

    Ashvin is the most courteous and positive cricketer one can ever come across and does not speak ill about anything or anyone

  • @ProudIndian2345
    @ProudIndian2345 15 дней назад +1

    Official or National.. who cares bro ? No. of students willing to learn hindi, german, French, Japanese is increasing year after year - mind you, kids of public with all party affiliations! Chill, guys.

    • @wokenessendedintheyear2025
      @wokenessendedintheyear2025 15 дней назад

      How is learning German or French going to help anyone in Bharat. Japanese I can understand cause of Buddhism.

    • @ProudIndian2345
      @ProudIndian2345 15 дней назад

      Contact students of mechanical engineering who want to study or work in Germany. Contact students of archaeology who want to work in France and other Europe museums.

    • @wokenessendedintheyear2025
      @wokenessendedintheyear2025 15 дней назад

      @@ProudIndian2345 But the topic is about Bharat. If they want to move to a foreign Country, they should learn the language of that Country. For example if Foreigners come to Bharat, they should learn the languages of Bharat.

  • @jagannathm.t.9413
    @jagannathm.t.9413 13 дней назад

    All South Indian Students, learn anyone of the North Indian Languages. And All North Indian Students, learn anyone of the South Indian Languages.
    This is the panacea.

    • @Zak-qh5tb
      @Zak-qh5tb 13 дней назад

      You want to make India a giant language learning school😂 No need of such nonsense policy. Local state language+English/Hindi (as per individuals choice)

  • @angryoldman-r6g
    @angryoldman-r6g 15 дней назад

    No one is forcing anyone to speak only Hindi, whoever wants to speak can speak the language, you have to speak to the person in front of you in a language which he can understand, otherwise you should remain silent, but the truth is that people are using the language for their political interests. Maintain controversy, this is the beauty of democracy? Those who hate Hindi and Hindi-speaking people also argue that Hindi has swallowed the regional languages ​​and dialects of North India. Such so-called intellectuals are forced to move out of the metro-centric film world of Bollywood and into small towns and villages. One should go and see that people converse only in their regional languages ​​and dialects. As for Ashwin, factually he has not said anything wrong, it is a fact that he has said it.

  • @ratnamurlidharan9885
    @ratnamurlidharan9885 15 дней назад

    Maharashtra Disha’s death went unpunished because of someone powerful in politics,so the Anna University student will be pushed under the carpet….thanks to the links with top powerful people…..There is no naya in our country because justice isthe sport of the rich and powerful who can buy it across the counter….

  • @haran1959
    @haran1959 14 дней назад

    Well said Ashwin

  • @sreenivasanmahadevan1028
    @sreenivasanmahadevan1028 14 дней назад

    Ashwin has a Hindi RUclips channel on cricket and speaks Hindi fairly well. I can say he respects Hindi since it is the link language for almost all States. No state other than TN refutes this.

  • @SJ-tm6iq
    @SJ-tm6iq 14 дней назад +6

    Who made Hindi the language of cricket? Stop making up stories.

  • @sandeeprai1517
    @sandeeprai1517 15 дней назад +4

    Ashwin not new to controversies. Even in his retirement he created controversy. On ground controversies also we seen.
    I seen peoples argument learning other indian language will kill their own language. For this people English leaning gives great pride. I am Indian from South can speak all South Indian languages. I am very good in Hindi as well. I can go any part of India and dont need google translator. Those speaking against the hindi are still inside the shell and need to come out to explore the benifits of learning more and more languages. Anti Hindi speaking will not make us nationalist.

    • @SV-wu2my
      @SV-wu2my 15 дней назад +2

      What controversy he created while retiring from Cricket. When you don't know the truth, do not create your own version.

  • @ViswaMitrann
    @ViswaMitrann 12 дней назад

    The fact that this issue hasn’t gained much attention in Tamil media suggests that only those aligned with the RSS-BJP ideology are concerned about it. While learning multiple languages is valuable, how many languages are actually embraced in North India? If you are batting for learning multiple language, Is it acceptable to sideline Sanskrit or Hindi and instead learn global languages like Spanish or Chinese?
    All the additional justifications for promoting specific languages ultimately point to pushing a Vedic-Sanskrit ideology. This approach lacks honesty and genuine concern for the well-being of all. communities.

  • @Mukunda-b6x
    @Mukunda-b6x 15 дней назад

    Anything National like bird, animal,flower etc are supposed to be the Best in India. In that analogy a language that is called Nationa language should have rich literature and Grammer. The Majority does not decide this. The whole Hindi Grammer can be written in a post card. Being easy to learn it can only be official language. The National language should have deep history and rich literary values like Sanskrit Tamil etc.

  • @Vsraja-um1ri
    @Vsraja-um1ri 14 дней назад

    Except Hindi belt states, all other state people give preference to mother tongue first, then we choose English because it is advanced in technologically, medicinally and in other academic fields
    And is used in many countries and also gives elite jobs. Hindi is developed to complete with English.

    • @royalgamers4810
      @royalgamers4810 14 дней назад

      And which states comes under your so called hindi belt

  • @sudarshanr7040
    @sudarshanr7040 13 дней назад

    Two languages are more than enough for anybody. Better concentrate on science & mathematics and create scientists to make India a technologically advanced country.

  • @maheshramachandran792
    @maheshramachandran792 14 дней назад

    Ashwin deserves the treatment what he got from bcci it has became a habit that nonsense can be delivered irrespective of his subject sure ashwins kids will be versatile in hindi

  • @jagannathm.t.9413
    @jagannathm.t.9413 13 дней назад

    The problem is with DMK people only. NOT AT ALL with any one of the rest of regional political parties ol the South Indian States.

  • @parthppopat
    @parthppopat 15 дней назад +2

    Not only Gujrati, make Kutchi national language too 😮😂

    • @vpmanoharan2274
      @vpmanoharan2274 14 дней назад +1

      Parth poppat what katiyawadi and surti

  • @raju3g
    @raju3g 14 дней назад

    But his body language, smile and tone was like mocking hindi. He could have easily avoided this unwanted topic knowing very well how dravidiyas dmk are against hindi hatredness.