OMG!!! I'M SO HAPPY TO SEE THEM TOGETHER!! When Tia showed up last week, my first thought was "unfortunately we won't be able to see her singing with Chanté because of the competition" and here we are!!
You can tell by the looks on their faces that this performance was not rehearsed and was a very last-minute add-in to the show. Cause Chante started the song but quickly stopped so Tia could sing the beginning. This show is so damn messy for not letting them rehearse somewhere before sending them on stage. But thankfully both ladies did great but you can tell they were both caught off guard by the performance. It's cute they got to sing together but I would have preferred if Chante sang the song solo.
THE SHADE: Chante was there to be a coach and judge. AT THE LAST MINUTE after coaching the contestantS, The show requested her to be a contestant. DIMASH AND CHANTE was lured to help the show ratings. ALSO, Adam Lambert was thrown in this competition.But he only did one round.He won that round and left. THE SHOW did a Bait and Switch on her... THE SHADE OF IT ALL
That is not the case. It was not prepared at all and Tia was giving Chante the lead as Tia was trying to find harmony as a duet. You could see none of it was prepared, It seemed to be just an opportunity JD's production/planning team for the festival 618 (date 6/18) while all singers are the same City & broadcasting building. This opportunity turned out be not working while unrehearsed. You can see the body language.
U are so spot on!!! see how Tia kept looking at n clappin n cheering her on.... its obvious this song is for Mo Mo.... so dont judge Tia for being 'unselfish'...
For sure this seemed to be a last minute thing, making use of the opportunity of the singers while active or participating for the show The Singer 歌手 and being in the same broadcasting building & city 长沙, to fill up the entertainment and JD's promotional festival 618. This is what you get, improvised. If both had solo's it would be much easier as you don't have find harmonies.
In my opinion listening to this, it sounds like they learned this song at the last minute. They may have been singing a lot within a days period, because Shantae's voice sounds fatigued, though it sounds very good. Because she seasoned , but it still sounds fatigue for her.
Chante is a contestant on *Singer 2024*, a famous high-production singing competition featuring famous singer superstars from Asia and occasionally, global artists. This year, Chante joined the show from the very start and Adam Lambert also appeared as a guest for only one episode. Chinese singer Tia recently landed a place in the show after defeating Chante in a one-on-one battle. A few days after the show, they performed at a gala hosted by a prominent e-commerce group for commercial purposes
Chante 把key降得太低了,比原唱的 alicia keys低多了。低真声 + 海豚音在一起有点奇怪. I felt that Chante lowered the key of the song too much, much lower than the original singer Alicia Keys. The combination of whistle note + lowered chest voice is a bit strange
袁娅维很棒啊 感觉很尊重前辈和外国友人 没在竞技 是合作和欣赏 一直在留白捧对方发挥 另外Chanté的演绎已经非常的满了 甚至过于满溢了 嗓音疲惫缺少适当的收敛 海豚音那段也过多了没了首演时的恰到好处游刃有余 这首歌的编排也没什么新意了 不像是专门给两个人合唱的样子
看感动了怎么回事 就觉得tia真的很欣赏momo 两个互相欣赏的人一起合作 感觉超幸福超感动 而且唱的很好呀❤
本季歌手最愛的兩名R&B/ Soul唱將們 看他們互相競爭、相惜 真的很感動和開心
Chante is pitch perfect ! 立马把音给抓回来。这真的是天赋中的天赋❤
Tia太棒了！
真正厲害的人就是合唱的時候懂得什麼時候讓對方表現的那種，
像某位跟她齊名的鐵肺歌后跟其他女歌手合唱的時候都是一副想用高音把人比下去的感覺，就讓人無法好好欣賞歌曲。
你是說譚維維嗎lol
OMG!!! I'M SO HAPPY TO SEE THEM TOGETHER!! When Tia showed up last week, my first thought was "unfortunately we won't be able to see her singing with Chanté because of the competition" and here we are!!
兩位合作舞台 真的是太棒了
完全不同的風格 兩位都很棒
居然在618晚會唱這首歌嗎😂勸大家不要購物了哈哈哈
謝謝你 我的省錢超人
😂我真的敗了兄弟
Tia其实已经唱得好好！👏🏻👏🏻
奈何Chante实在太厉害👍🏻👍🏻
chante is amazing
我看Tia一直讓Chante發揮啊，這個編曲是順著Chante做的，不一定適合Tia唱，Tia唱歌比較自由，Chante比較地道，兩個風格不同，應該多給點鼓勵少批評～畢竟R&B是活在外國人骨子裡血液的靈魂，能站在一起唱已經都實屬不易了
一堆人都忽視掉
1.這首編曲是為香緹莫打造，看得出袁並不熟悉
2.練習時間有限。可以聽出來他們的嗓音都很疲憊，這點看凡希亞的也聽得出來
3.聽說沒彩排。合唱歌曲本來就需要大量的磨合，不然很容易車禍，加上這首難度很高。
總之，我覺得袁很衰，莫名被質疑唱功😢 顯然這首和這組合是製作單位安排的，有人說袁可以不要和音嗎？但都上台了，在旁邊什麼都不做也很乾吧～
事实上也不是tia的调， tia舒适音域应该是原曲再升， 而这个比原曲还低，最后一段升调虽然因为不熟悉唱烂了 ，但那个tia明显更舒适了。
你們還真會編故事
唱的爛 問題還一堆
@@Leeogh 好直线条的理解力 👏生活里肯定常因为连一点复杂问题都解决不了而辛苦吧。
You can tell by the looks on their faces that this performance was not rehearsed and was a very last-minute add-in to the show. Cause Chante started the song but quickly stopped so Tia could sing the beginning. This show is so damn messy for not letting them rehearse somewhere before sending them on stage. But thankfully both ladies did great but you can tell they were both caught off guard by the performance. It's cute they got to sing together but I would have preferred if Chante sang the song solo.
I would have preferred if they didn't knock Chante down by making her do the song twice where the second version/duet wasn't good.
THE SHADE: Chante was there to be a coach and judge. AT THE LAST MINUTE after coaching the contestantS, The show requested her to be a contestant. DIMASH AND CHANTE was lured to help the show ratings. ALSO, Adam Lambert was thrown in this competition.But he only did one round.He won that round and left. THE SHOW did a Bait and Switch on her... THE SHADE OF IT ALL
莫莫还是很厉害的🥺 就感觉最近应该消耗嗓音太多 可能岁数也大了
這一對唱袁婭維直接被比下去~香緹莫真的無懈可擊
評論區其實把香提美說的太好了，這場來說香提莫比較大的優勢只有音色，到了高音其實是比較擠的，聽起來跟歌手比賽已經有差了
哨音也是一樣，後面升key明顯是兩個人沒對好，真的是車禍
不過說香提莫歌手2024版的到了後面升key也是音準有問題而且大力扯上去的感覺，因為高音到了E5 但是她沒有上去大概才Eb5
但是前面確實很完美
後面升key, Tia沒唱對key Chante聽到不對直接停止 XD
Chante Moore outshined Tia in this song - Without a doubt with all those over-the-top whistles and register changes.
That is not the case. It was not prepared at all and Tia was giving Chante the lead as Tia was trying to find harmony as a duet. You could see none of it was prepared, It seemed to be just an opportunity JD's production/planning team for the festival 618 (date 6/18) while all singers are the same City & broadcasting building. This opportunity turned out be not working while unrehearsed. You can see the body language.
Over-the-top whistles? The whistle notes were poorly executed
2:50 我和我ADC队友的走位
笑死
笑死
人才
哈哈哈哈哈
尷尬癌發作
超級即興的感覺
分论区过分了…袁娅维根本就没想和她竞争PK这个歌好吗。这首歌提莫唱了多少遍了，初舞台就这首，算是她最喜欢的一首吧，可能也是最适合她的音色一首之一，早就练的熟透透的那种了，袁娅维本意就是以友人的姿态和音帮她完成这首歌，根本就没想宣兵夺主，而且袁娅维无论是音色或音域都不输，声音可有力量和爆发力了，再说最近的浪姐已经让她忙得不暇了，哪还有这么多时间练这个，人家没想竞争而已，之前Bored那首歌就证明她的实力和别出心裁的创造力。
bored也一般😢
U are so spot on!!! see how Tia kept looking at n clappin n cheering her on.... its obvious this song is for Mo Mo.... so dont judge Tia for being 'unselfish'...
I think the level should be the same but wow No comparison No hurt 😢
Chante is another level for truth
很像實力堅強的姪女
帶著一個實力超群的阿姨唱KTV
現場都是姪女的朋友
姪女超崇拜阿姨
所以一直做球給阿姨發揮
讓現場的朋友能看看阿姨的厲害
袁唱得挺好的啊
跑跑更健康😂现场这样已经很优秀了❤
莫莫哨音功力依舊厲害，兩人音樂交流互動好棒，說不定袁娅维也有機會學到哨音技巧~~~
袁也會海豚，他有唱莫文蔚的 愛
Tia自從唱完開往春天的地鐵以後就比較強調強混了，這兩者比較難兼得😢
建議大家去聽現場飯拍版喔，直播的收音不好，哨音無法完全呈現在這裡
很喜欢❤
這兩個人真的好搭配喔 好像媽媽帶女兒
這首莫音色厚實溫潤，較適合她，袁可能低音較不穩，但海豚音有點太頻頻了
不懂为什么有人说Tia没在调上。除了开场和升调，Tia的和声蛮不错的，音准也没有大问题，国外歌手很多live也是这个水平，完全没有喷tia的必要
為了酸而酸而已
可能freestyle的轉音就被他們歸類成走音吧…
沒有噴的意思 最後高潮那一整個糟到不行 另外回應某樓 轉音也都應該轉在調內喔😅😅
請有一些正確的知識再出來講話😅
其他部份都唱得不錯
就唱的爛啊 實話實說不行嗎？
袁娅维终于来了，虽然不是歌手。
1：47袁的藍調即興太漂亮囉！👍👍👍
The duet i never know i needed
The duet that should never have been. There is no blend. And Chante shouldn't have sang her winning song twice.
i can tell none of the performances were rehearsed. wtf is this network scheduling. give your artist enough time to plane shit out
For sure this seemed to be a last minute thing, making use of the opportunity of the singers while active or participating for the show The Singer 歌手 and being in the same broadcasting building & city 长沙, to fill up the entertainment and JD's promotional festival 618. This is what you get, improvised. If both had solo's it would be much easier as you don't have find harmonies.
莫莫受委屈了 感觉
Chante is AMAZING. The other singer is not even close. She’s off key, and doesn’t know how to harmonize at all.
In my opinion listening to this, it sounds like they learned this song at the last minute. They may have been singing a lot within a days period, because Shantae's voice sounds fatigued, though it sounds very good. Because she seasoned , but it still sounds fatigue for her.
原以為TIA唱起來不會輸... 一比下來果然有點差距
亞洲人聲線比較薄
tia的确嗓号小很多但唱功是各有千秋。这是香姨版的编曲，事实上除了没时间排练不熟悉编曲分配外，这也不是tia的调， tia舒适音域应该是原曲再升， 而这个比原曲还低，最后一段升调虽然因为不熟悉唱烂了 ，但那个tia明显更舒适了。如果给他们多点时间排练应该会是一场很和谐的演出。
這首歌我還是比較喜歡相對厚實的聲音詮釋
@@nicky911336 的确是的这首歌被设计成表现女声中低音中高音部分的音域，像香姨这种音色厚黑有90年代唱腔的R&B女中音更有味道。
誰設計誰啊！
想聽Tia solo version😊
沒看完整版 真心想問歌怎麼選的🥺如果不是這首歌袁可以發揮的更好吧 她不適合這首吧 而且莫之前就唱過 這樣不是很容易被比較嗎😑？
袁娅维在国内唱r n b已经是顶级的一批了，跟黑人高手相比差的不是一星半点。
內娛自嗨，看不到世界🤧
不虧，內娛RNB 本身就非主流，Moore算是歐美頂級了，和席琳迪翁，全盛期瑪利亞凱瑞一等級的。
@@weiii933你们是真神奇
@weiii933 你看见世界了说说你有什么出圈的节目让我们开开眼。
會嗎？聽聽1：47袁的即興（有藍調半音階出現）香姨至今我還未聽過有此功力喔！
There is no harmony. And why they make Chante sing it again as a duet? I guess they loved it that much
Aww🥰 🫶🏻
還是一個人唱就好了 期待值過高
真的很難不拿看歌手的濾鏡看她們
0:41 把Physical things 唱成superficial 有什么含义吗
哦，可能是唱错词了
@@yuhengli1979 这一段袁娅维也傻了😆
Physical things are superficial所以说得过去😂
好幾個地方都是唱錯了，這曲有改編一些的，明顯tia按原曲唱了，不同調，升key也是錯過了，哨音那裡也不清楚😂
因為斷眉沒來，袁婭維他們是臨時救場的。這歌本來是MOMO獨唱，臨時加了她。排練都沒時間
在KTV 如果像袁娅维的朋友一直這樣幫我和音 我會生氣XD
很能理解
他怎麼了？
@@麥克緣我愛哼 她太忙了没时间排练 走位混乱，唱错好几段
@@麥克緣我愛哼 就是一個舉例拉 你在KTV唱歌 像袁娅维這樣的朋友一直幫你和音 會很煩 唱不下去
@@天使小鴨 喔喔對耶，我有被合過會被拉走，要很專心唱或著遮住一耳唱
台灣的黃小琥也很適合唱這樣的歌
很亂😊
黑人聲音有天聲優勢，高頻的中低音很多聽起來會很溫厚，很耐聽，但是缺點是高頻穿透力會不夠因為混了太多中音
這什麼舞台 感覺沒彩排過的 默契有點邊緣快出錯感
參與過歌手這檔節目的歌手是不是過後都會懷疑自己是不是位歌手了！完全偏離初衷。
袁娅维低音区不行，全让momo唱了
差距明顯
高手唱k現場😂
What is the context of this duet? I only watch the clips so I’m not sure where this competition is heading?
This is just a commercial show, the competition is only live on every Friday
Chante is a contestant on *Singer 2024*, a famous high-production singing competition featuring famous singer superstars from Asia and occasionally, global artists. This year, Chante joined the show from the very start and Adam Lambert also appeared as a guest for only one episode.
Chinese singer Tia recently landed a place in the show after defeating Chante in a one-on-one battle.
A few days after the show, they performed at a gala hosted by a prominent e-commerce group for commercial purposes
感觉她们歌词唱错很多 像即兴表演 还是字幕问题
哦莫哦莫点进来前以为是神级合唱，有点小小失望呜呜
Tia連音準都⋯😮
合音
感觉有点乱，上次莫莫独唱的时候比较惊讶比较好听，不过她们唱得挺开心的 开心就好❤
两位的表现有够大跌眼镜。Tia好像直接忘记了后面那段需要升key，导致音准事故，有些转音也生硬。Chante Moore的话，这次哨音毫无美感，很用力在吐出哨音了但还是挤卡严重，其实上台之前如果发现嗓音状态不佳，不如换掉哨音。
😂有点乱
一開頭末就搶進了，Tia有給她使眼色，後面tia都是和聲幫忙莫
什麼啊，這首歌本來就是Moo獨唱，袁婭維本來是另一個浪姐組合唱節目。
因為斷眉沒來，袁婭維臨時救場加入我是歌手，才非要塞進來湊成合唱的。
是真唱 3:10神救援😂
真的 笑死 但可能他們根本沒時間彩排
導致Tia根本不熟Chante的升調版本
兩位條件都是好的，但都不知道怎麼收，怎麼配合彼此，這其實就是Tia和A Lin的差距，後者在意的是把歌唱好，呈現更好的聽感給觀眾，前者常常是唱爽的
还是分开唱吧谢谢啦
我打不开此视频，什么原因
感覺Chante Moore要找話語女歌手是張碧晨，男歌手陳奕迅才能比較搭配得起來
合唱时声音有点打架了 不是很和谐😅
Chante嬴太多了
之前有些粉說Tia能PK掉Chante，真的嗎😅
Tia会唱r&b也就国内说说
Tia ❤❤❤
這什麼晚會😂
委屈Tia了。 這首歌和調都不適合她。 請她來陪襯？🙄很明顯 開頭是chante搶唱了。 maybe 耳mic有問題吧。 連Chante也flat了。 海豚音whistle 也低半音吧。 😮
因為這首本來就是chante獨唱，袁婭維是臨時加進來的。
剛剛有車禍嗎？
希望海豚不要使用過度 讓聲帶壞了
我目睹的是車禍現場吧。。。
猿牙圍這是上了多少個比賽
結果沒有尚雯婕...
Chante 把key降得太低了,比原唱的 alicia keys低多了。低真声 + 海豚音在一起有点奇怪. I felt that Chante lowered the key of the song too much, much lower than the original singer Alicia Keys. The combination of whistle note + lowered chest voice is a bit strange
Chante 降低音调并不是因为他唱不出原来的音调，而是为了让歌曲在即兴创作时有更大的发展空间。如果你仔细观察，在歌曲的中间部分，它又回到了艾丽西亚原来的音高，这正是因为它的结构让它听起来更像是一首在《歌手 2024》中演唱的歌曲。再说一遍，"吹口哨 "只有在不是为了给歌曲增色时才是糟糕的，而尚特却不是这样，她总是选择最合适的时机来吹口哨。
@@soprecious1241前面不降调，后面哨音就可能唱不上去了。她为了把哨音留在安全区要做调整
Key對袁婭維來說偏低，但唱的還可以，是不是沒有彩排啊，走位根本亂七八糟😂
走位感覺是袁突然變迷妹在台上捧momo的臨場反應，但這樣會影響觀看，其實有點不專業
她本來在浪姐組一個節目，斷眉沒來臨時救場加入歌手。
618莫名其妙被塞進ChanteMoore的獨唱節目裡。 都沒彩排過
r＆b合音沒經過設計及彩排，肯定是會亂七八糟的。
这是什么小品现场😂😂😂
Tia感覺在bored跟這首都給我一種聲音太「前面」跟口腔內聲音太多的感覺
我不是專業人士 希望有人可以給予專業指正
袁沒有秀她的海豚音 好可惜
歌词是不是一开始也错了
Moore 当年是怎么抢歌没抢过Whitney Houston的？？？这实力会抢不过？
她哪里唱得比Whitney Houston好了？
誰家的水滾了啦!!!
快把火關掉!!!!!!!!!!!
Tia 还得要更专业一些。
现在的听众不好忽悠了
同意
Tia音准更好一些
@@wuliwuli241 转调后都唱跑调了还音准好？
歌手開唱至今，香姨的音準才是讓人提心吊膽喔！（第三期大走音）🤣
袁娅维油腻到语无伦次的地步了，没有一句在调上的，大量尴尬即兴加每一句都饱含的偏音，纯纯折磨观众耳朵
差距
心心相惜，她們都遇到了r&b同好
一比下去Tia 差太遠了，真不知道怎麼可以衝榜贏了
同意！
是說，歌都唱了，可以搖槍姐來歌手嗎？
😂需要这么多哨音吗😅
原來根本就不是一個等級的。
同意
Tia 的音准 嗯，这天生的吧，也许练习下能行🤣
香姨跟人比音準？笑死！🤣
右邊來亂的
兩位我都很喜歡，但唱的完全就像是KTV硬要合音的感覺，完全沒對頻，完全大出戲不知道在幹嘛，硬要炫技
tia是吃到孫楠的口水？油成這樣
可以不要每首都叫海豚出來嗎🤣
真的
这首歌让《歌手 2024》的观众认识了她，其中的口哨声等都是她的风格，其他所有歌手都没有这样做，去看看他们吧，不要说多余的话。Chanté 和 Tia 合作得很开心，观众也很喜欢，这才是最重要的。
@@soprecious1241要不要唱哨音是她的选择，好听不好听观众有资格去评