My forever fav is Jackie Liu!! He’s the best cute and both him n Fiona made a good couple in the drama!! Love it! Kudos to the director and producer!!🌺
Jackie Lui Chung-yin was a very good Linghu Chong. In the novel, Linghu Chong is constantly tormented by inner conflict between being honorable to his unorthodox friends and being loyal to his master, his love for Ren Yingying and his nostalgic feelings for Yue Lingshan. Jackie portrayed that well in the series. Leung Kar-yan version looks scary though lol
I didn't watch all of them but I think Jackie Lui did a great job and his TVB 90's version is rare case where it is far better than the TVB 80's. As amazing as Chow Yun Fat is he wasn't so great in Smiling Proud Wanderer. He is too angry and bitter for most of second half. There were other amazing actors in the 80's where their performances just didn't work story wise for me. Yes their series was much shorter so they didn't have the same length to tell the story as 90's but this is where creativity steps in to manage limitation with effective story telling. I can go on and on but this is my general opinion
Good video. I think I might be in the minority here, but my favourite was Jet Li. One I am a huge fan. Two that scene where he jumps of the cliff and holds DFBB begging her to tell him she is CiCi. To me this captures the essence of unconditional love. It did not matter that she was a transsexual or the fact she had murdered so many people, he loved her and that was all that mattered. PS heard a rumour Jet Li is ill, is that true?
I don't know it's true or not, haha. I think the Jet Li version was great mostly because of Lin's DFBB. If DFBB was 魯振順, this "unconditional love" would be totally different.
Can't argue with that, I would probably turn gay for Lin (heehee). Yes Jet really can't compare to Lin when it comes to acting, but you can't tell me when the camera gave him that close up as he watched her falling to her supposedly death you did not feel something.
![Chino Pacas - Modo Capone (with Drake & Fuerza Regida) [Video Oficial]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zjv8TQ0gBkg/mqdefault.jpg)
My forever fav is Jackie Liu!! He’s the best cute and both him n Fiona made a good couple in the drama!! Love it! Kudos to the director and producer!!🌺
金庸小說笑傲江湖中令狐沖的角色，以呂頌賢最為經典，雖說有好多位演出這個角色，還是以呂頌賢最好。
他很有那種氣質
最好丁嘅令狐沖
呂頌賢版本最貼近原著, 選角最好. 令狐沖/小師妹/儀琳/岳不群/左冷禪/任我行/林平之, 印象都深刻.
一好就全部好
吕颂贤是最好的冲哥侧颜也帅，96版是刷了一遍不够还想刷n遍的魅力
喜歡呂頌賢版令狐沖
呂頌賢很靚仔呀!怎麽不靓，咁多個最靚仔係佢。 最好版本的令狐沖
最有令狐沖的瀟灑
呂頌賢最好。
經典版
Jackie Lui Chung-yin was a very good Linghu Chong. In the novel, Linghu Chong is constantly tormented by inner conflict between being honorable to his unorthodox friends and being loyal to his master, his love for Ren Yingying and his nostalgic feelings for Yue Lingshan. Jackie portrayed that well in the series.
Leung Kar-yan version looks scary though lol
Lui Chung--yin was really good. Leung Kar-yan was brave and strong, good actor but not Linghu Chong, haha.
呂松贤版本就是经典！
呂頌賢版無可取代
他有那種氣質
@@tomato89 因為你的講解，所以我重新睇多一次。我好鐘意你講解，加油
多謝︿＿︿我是繼續努力的
我認為就他最像令狐沖
呂頌賢
曾经有报道说，金庸本人评价吕颂贤是最帅版的令狐冲。
我也覺得是，哈哈
呂頌賢!
經典版
是許冠傑演的那個豁達不覊，逍遙四方的形象，令我迷上令狐冲這角色。
許冠傑本人也很有那種氣質
好彩冇包括最近大陸版的令狐沖，造型簡直識豬頭丙，睇到都暈
吕颂贤的表现最贴近小说角色
很有那種感覺
没有一位合我意。
各版林平之，有没有片？
呂
陳美濤小姐，令狐沖2019年年頭再有update板，用一個好後生小子做，請你拍更新板及作評論，你評論好中肯及好看
之前有做過2019的笑傲江湖，等我看看這個角色可不可以講到一集，多謝你！
好似頭上倒瀉杯麪，哈哈哈。
令狐沖嘅髮型真係唔容易
除了汪、梁、馬，其他版本都睇過，最喜歡都係呂頌賢版，成個令狐冲比佢演譯哂，再加上電視配樂也是一絕，正如梁家仁係喬峰，呂頌賢一定係令狐冲。
哈哈，佢地本身好符合嗰種氣質
@@tomato89 發哥欠缺一分瀟灑不羈。不太像小說的令狐冲。
@@tomato89 記憶中好像計漏了一個馮寶寶版，70年代有一套電視劇叫一劍震神洲，成個故事都係笑傲江湖做藍本，馮寶寶做主角叫南宮逸。
發哥戴番頂帽會似華山弟子
唔駛講，只鍾情呂頌賢同李連杰(僅代表本人立場)
哈哈，都係經典黎。
同感，李连杰是电影版，吕颂贤是电视剧版。吕颂贤版唯一遗憾的是任盈盈颜值不够其他都好。最烦李亚鹏版，里面把任盈盈演成一个妓女。是在让人气愤。其他版没看过，看过吕颂贤的其他都不想看了。
喜歡呂頌賢和任賢齊😊😊
瀟灑快樂
可能是先入為主的關係，加上葉麗儀和葉振棠主唱的笑傲江湖悅耳動聽，個人比較喜歡周潤發的令狐沖，各版令狐沖各有特色，最瀟灑的令狐沖是許冠傑，也是較老成，最打得的令狐沖是李連杰，最接近原著的令狐沖是相貌平凡的呂頌賢。梁家仁怎樣演都是丐幫幫主而不像華山派大弟子，可能是受了港劇天龍八部的影響。至於任賢齊，感覺上演林平之更適合。其他的版本都沒印象。
說得很對！呂頌賢的版本真的很經典，可能是氣質問題
呂也叫相貌平凡？，，論樣貌信相你連他十分一的平凡也沒有
因为吕颂贤版是TVB制作。李亚鹏版是央视制作的。这两个版本自然比其他版本好。
是大製作
靚女,下次講林平之咁多個邊個做得好?
好啊，等我做做功課
發哥雖然又靚仔又好戲，但我揀呂頌賢😁
I didn't watch all of them but I think Jackie Lui did a great job and his TVB 90's version is rare case where it is far better than the TVB 80's.
As amazing as Chow Yun Fat is he wasn't so great in Smiling Proud Wanderer. He is too angry and bitter for most of second half. There were other amazing actors in the 80's where their performances just didn't work story wise for me. Yes their series was much shorter so they didn't have the same length to tell the story as 90's but this is where creativity steps in to manage limitation with effective story telling.
I can go on and on but this is my general opinion
Yes, people did not like Jackie Lui to be this character before broadcast. But what he did was really great that impressed the audience
呂頌賢最成功
夠瀟灑
吕賢賢都靓仔過后生發哥啦下話
發哥之前馮寶寶都反串演過令狐沖套戲叫”一劍鎮神州”
記低先，謝謝你！
TVB 《一劍鎮神州》
改編自金庸《笑傲江湖》 和古龍《浣花洗劍錄》
-演員表
南宮逸--馮寶寶飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》方寶玉。金庸《笑傲江湖》令狐沖合併]
離垢居士--鄭少秋飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》紫衣侯]
無名客--陳鴻烈飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》白衣人]
余翠翠----黃杏秀飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》水天姬/小公主。金庸《笑傲江湖》任盈盈合併]
伊蘭----歐陽佩珊飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》小公主。王大娘吳蘇合併]
白如霜----王愛明飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》牛鐵蘭。金庸《笑傲江湖》岳靈珊合併]
遠塵居士----劉丹飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》紫衣侯師兄周方]
淩繼祖----黃允財飾[金庸《笑傲江湖》林平之]
莫若缺----徐廣林飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》胡不愁]
瘦柴----龍天生飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》牛鐵娃]
白樂天----關海山飾[金庸《笑傲江湖》岳不群]
白夫人----陳嘉儀飾[金庸《笑傲江湖》寧中則[
南宮凈----馮淬帆飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》白三空]
鐵箏客姚叔岩----高崗飾
方圓大師----黃新飾
沖靈道長----張活游飾
馬如虎----梁少狄飾
辛若虛--黃恩思飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》莫不屈]
徐若怯--鍾俊偉飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》魏不貪]
郭若愚--林家宜飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》公孫不智]
楚天魁--鍾志強飾
村童--林世傑飾
青龍堂主--馬慶生飾
樓蘭使者樂以斯--佐治飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》金河王]
樓蘭美女--張夢真飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》黃金魔女]
清風--黃楚英飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》珠兒]
明月--方潔玲飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》玲兒]
布拉法王--林文偉飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》伽星法王]
鍾真--焦雄飾
楊鋒向問天--飾
皇甫極--甘國衛飾[金庸《笑傲江湖》東方不敗]
凌宵--何璧堅飾
凌夫人--上官玉飾
花姬娘--程可為飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》水仙花方靈玉,金庸《笑傲江湖》藍鳳凰合併)
老趙--談泉慶飾
周師爺--梁鴻華飾
木駝子--何禮男飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》木郎君。金庸《笑傲江湖》，木高峰合併]
彭沖--廖偉雄飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》彭清]
任伯光--李國麟飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》王半俠。金庸《笑傲江湖》，田伯光合併]
慧琳--林欣欣飾[金庸《笑傲江湖》儀琳]
清寧師太--梅蘭飾[金庸《笑傲江湖》定逸師太]
馮瀾--曾偉明飾
司徒震宇--石堅飾[金庸《笑傲江湖》左冷禪]
沖虛道長--黎永強飾
龐飛--朱剛飾
大莊主--吳孟達飾
黑白子--飾
余獨行--白文彪飾[金庸《笑傲江湖》任我行]
清照師太--羅麗娟飾
韓晶--鄧英敏飾
阮彪--黃偉光飾
柳青--吳子山飾
錢強--鄭厚華飾
方俊--黃奕華飾
司空樓主--許紹雄飾[古龍《浣花洗劍錄》]
方正大師--郭鋒飾
呂頌賢!! 其他的都是服裝造型比较好。。。
佢實在做得好似
其實李亞鵬版係最好一套『笑傲』。CCTV真係下左功夫，只不過劇情改左而且小小拖沓。對中國傳統文化既解讀真係無得輸，呂頌賢果套有D趕工製作，而且似拍『令狐沖歷險記』而唔係『笑傲』
係，不過「令狐沖歷險記」更吸引觀眾，大家鍾意睇成長
令狐沖殺左師傅喎，哪有正派人物殺師的？
@@iloverichardhk
令狐冲毫無人品,
沒有男主角風範,
同淫賊稱兄道弟,
同魔教結交,
在思過涯發現袐洞又不同岳不群講,
在思過涯同田伯光交手,
輸完又輸都不認數就係失信 (反而田伯光在酒館輸了一次都認數),
响思過涯令狐冲應承過風清揚唔會透露劍法來源,
結果周圍唱,
令狐冲失信於風清揚,
最大失信就是將林家祖訓,
等到後期才說給俾林平之知,
反而第一時間說給與林家無關的岳不群知,
在五霸崗,
少林崑崙三位前輩對令狐冲手下留情,
“又與魔教的任小姐聯手，殺害了好幾個少林派和崑崙派弟子” (原著句語),
初遇向問天,
“涼亭之中，深谷之前，和向問天並肩迎敵，確有不少正教中人因自己而死” (原著句語),
“向大哥明明不是正人君子，我怎地不問情由，上前便幫他打架？” (原著句語),
响福州一次過犯下3宗罪:
1. 夜媽媽跟蹤女仔 (岳靈珊),
2. 暗中監視人 (林平之岳靈珊),
3. 所謂名不正則言不順,
佢响林家老宅,
係冇身份 (佢已經俾岳不群逐出師門),
佢同袈裟既關係等於左冷禪同袈裟既關係,
佢同袈裟係冇關係,
佢以冇身份去搶奪袈裟,
其實係搶嘢.
呢一樣嘢唔係我屈令狐冲,
連金庸都係咁寫,
第三十五章原著句語:
"有甚麼錯怪？令狐冲又不是不想奪我的劍譜，實則他確已奪去了。只不過強盜遇著賊爺爺"
由福州到龍泉鑄劍谷途中,
打家劫舍.
原著還有搶馬一段:
“奔出十餘里，只見一片草地上有數十匹馬放牧，看守的是六七名兵卒，當是軍營中的官馬。令狐冲道：「去把馬搶過來！」于嫂忙道：「這是軍馬，只怕不妥。」令狐冲道：「救人要緊，皇帝的御馬也搶了，管他甚麼妥不妥。」儀清道：「得罪了官府，只怕……」令狐冲大聲道：「救師父要緊，還是守王法要緊？去他奶奶的官府不官府！我吳將軍就是官府。將軍要馬，小兵敢不奉號令嗎？」儀和道：「正是。」令狐冲叫道：「把這些兵卒點倒了，拉了馬走。」儀清道：「拉十二匹就夠了。」令狐冲叫道：「盡數拉了來！」”
身為恆山派掌門,
居然幫魔教做事.
令狐冲是一個頂着主角光環之敗類.
Good video. I think I might be in the minority here, but my favourite was Jet Li. One I am a huge fan. Two that scene where he jumps of the cliff and holds DFBB begging her to tell him she is CiCi. To me this captures the essence of unconditional love. It did not matter that she was a transsexual or the fact she had murdered so many people, he loved her and that was all that mattered.
PS heard a rumour Jet Li is ill, is that true?
I don't know it's true or not, haha. I think the Jet Li version was great mostly because of Lin's DFBB. If DFBB was 魯振順, this "unconditional love" would be totally different.
Can't argue with that, I would probably turn gay for Lin (heehee). Yes Jet really can't compare to Lin when it comes to acting, but you can't tell me when the camera gave him that close up as he watched her falling to her supposedly death you did not feel something.
Yes, and Lin may actually bring man into the character, haha
外表和個性就 任賢齊 最似
最鍾意吕颂贤版；最顶唔顺霍建華版
呂版是永遠的經典
首選許冠傑，江湖味、大師兄、大俠，第二集換角真可惜，在獨孤九劍招式上，原創讀出口也充滿劍氣，笑傲上最江湖係呢套啦。神作👍
林平之選角一流-年輕張學友 意想不到做奸角一絕
電影可能預算較多，請嘅角色夠勁，演出黎真係好有味道
令狐沖原著本身都唔係靚仔嘅，只係話佢劍眉薄唇，林平之先係真正靚仔。呂仲賢版最啱啦，btw幾時做任盈盈呀？
哈哈，任盈盈都值得做，研究吓先
吕颂贤版唯一遗憾的就是任盈盈颜值不够啊，李亚鹏版的就不说了，想起里面那个梅花红就恶心。
喜歡霍建華的,帥氣跟俊朗
真心靚仔
吕
我比較喜歡李亞鵬版嘅令狐沖😄雖然佢唔太靚仔，但女主角許晴絕對為他加了分，實在太漂亮了
而且這個版本又比較貼近原著😆我呢種老鬼，思想就係守舊，要一板一眼跟原著小說會看得舒服，係自己問題，當然有些例外的，就如古龍的小說，要改編成電視劇，大多數都要改才可以，邪派一出場，轉過頭又魂歸天國，小說就可以啫，電視劇要點攪啫，呢頭化完妝，跟手化多個與世長辭妝喎，觀眾都唔多鍾意咁喇。。我估。。。
離咗題㖭😅橫豎都離咯，離埋佢喇，霍建華版的東方不敗，究竟佢練乜鬼武功呢？請問，應該唔會係葵花寶典卦，無得切JJ喎，唔通切個巢咩。。。哈哈…
哈哈，佢可能係練初版葵花寶典，第一版笑傲江湖中，葵花寶典係一對夫妻合著：
「這部『葵花寶典』，武林中向來都說，是一雙夫妻所合着。至於這一對前輩高人姓甚名誰，已是無可查考，有人說，男的名字中有一『葵』字，女的名字中有一『花』字，所以合稱『葵花寶典』，但把多半也只是猜測之詞。大家只知道，這對夫妻初時恩愛甚篤，後來卻因故反目。這對夫妻撰作『葵花寶典』之時，年方壯盛，武功如日中天，反目之後，從此避不見面，而一部武功祕笈，也就分為兩部，歷來將那男子所着的祕笈稱為乾經，女子所着的稱坤經。」後來先變成太監XD
陳美濤 Tomato
原來笑傲江湖都有初版㗎😅葵花寶典仲係一對夫妻合著，我真係唔知道㖭，妳對各本金庸武俠小說好清楚嘎，佩服佩服
妳都無睇過霍建華版笑傲江湖㗎？😄不過知道東方不敗係一個女子，無乜興趣睇㖭
好多金庸小說都改過幾次版，祕笈如《九陽神功》《葵花寶典》來曆都有改過。
霍建華版其實拍得幾靚，景色波瀾壯闊，不過主要係東方姑娘同令狐沖嘅愛情故事XD
陳美濤 Tomato
現在國內嘅劇集水準真係好高😃可能香港拍攝嘅人材北望神州，而且又肯用心製作，大花金錢等等，國內景色更不在話下了，我覺得已經超越港台兩地咯
睇霍建華版笑傲江湖劇照😅嗰位東方姑娘係幾靚嘅，但這套笑傲江湖裏面，佢真正變回女子，顛覆咗我固有嘅笑傲江湖世界。。哈哈…
陳小姐妳睇過好多金庸舊版小說😊知道新舊版之分別，市面上還有沒有舊版的銷售，好想買來看看
有錢就好有機會拍得大，東方姑娘演得唔錯架，不過原著讀者係有啲難接受，如果唔叫笑傲，改成《令狐公子與東方姑娘不得不說的故事》，可能會更好，哈哈。
舊版無得賣，不過上網可以搵下
可惜没看過周润发的版本
Marilyn Ong youtube上就有
当然是Tvb的啦
再拍笑傲江湖可以揾馬國明飾演令狐冲，簡直度身訂做，而家連任盈盈都有了 XD
自帶任盈盈XD
最新有第十一個令狐沖，紀對最係最醜最不符原著一個，大家有空可以search 吓，包嚇死你
好啊，搵次專門講呢套
個人喜歡同潤發 霍建華，演技取勝
有演技得黎，亦係靚仔
陳美濤 Tomato 好士似乎欣賞靚仔多啲
哈哈，外在美都好緊要架
哈哈哈哈哈 頭髮好似杯麵
男人捲髮真的不易Handle XD
吕颂賢最似
周潤發飾演令孤冲
以身形來說 許冠傑最像原著
他的氣質也很像
霍建华饰演的令狐冲则被东方不败占尽风头戏名应该改为笑傲江湖之东方不败传奇更贴切
或者笑傲江湖之東方姑娘傳奇
周润发诠释令狐冲扮哑婆婆那段惟妙惟肖最攒最有性格
果然係發哥
越拍越離譜，東方不敗是異性恋者，只是自官後才慢慢愛做女人，不是先天的gay.
改著改著，他依然是異性戀，不過變成異性戀的女人了．．．
不是這樣的，同性恋和異性恋的性取向心理是不同的，東方不敗是自官後才將那此小妾刹了，亦發覺只有楊蓮廷才值得他欣賞，以黑木崖上的鸟合之众，总會流傳他東方不敗喜歡小白臉，但值到他死後众人在聲討他時也沒人說他喜歡男人，而東方不敗看到令狐冲時也只是說他平平無奇，不外如是，而他對蓮弟的感覺是日久生成的。
明明東方不敗就是個閹人，即像大監般，他原本就是個男人，不過找女的演沒那么噁心⋯⋯其實應該找個泰國人妖/變性人來演會入戲些
呂頌賢
經典版