'We are just seeing the beginning' of AI's impact on political discourse, expert warns
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
- Author Yuval Noah Harari joins Morning Joe to discuss AI’s impact on democracy. He warns that AI’s ability to create and distribute content independently could blur the lines between human and machine, threatening democratic discourse. Harari calls for action, like banning "fake humans," to prevent AI from undermining political systems, highlighting concerns for both democratic and authoritarian regimes.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/...
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/...
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#AI #ArtificialIntelligence #Politics
"When it comes to humans vs. robots, everybody should be on the same side." Funny, we thought that about viruses once.
this guy is pure evil so of course they interview him.
Or autocratic dictators
when was that?
Or free speech vs. censorship.
What? Viruses?
"When you give good people bad information they make bad decisions."
"There is not one good thing about democrat voters."
Except it's a small handful of tech companies that are making the decisions for all of us, and their agenda is profit, not the safety of the human race.
Anything this individual says is bad information
what he defines as a bad decision is the decision you should be making
Who would you trust to decide what is the bad information?
@@llh3025 nobody? why would you let someone else think for you
I think there should be a rule prohibiting AI from being used to impersonate another person.
Elon consulted with professor SUGGON DEZNUTS...the consensus is I can make fun of you.
😊
@@danielbrown7535 I see the rational of a petulant child. Perhaps that will take you far in life.
@@EthanDickenson
If you feed the obvious sock puppet, you accomplish nothing. In this case you even make a joke of your own position. If you are human, don't feed the trolls, but good luck in getting the EVIL google to care. RUclips is a sock puppet paradise.
Unless it's clearly labeled that way -- in the video itself, not just the title. It is free speech to make fun of somebody, etc.
@@jamesross3939 sadly, I don’t think this issue is about “making fun” of people… for musicians and actors it’s replacing them with an AI version… in politics, it’s about misleading and tricking the viewer into believing that person said something they didn’t.
If you ever listen to anything while reading comments, let it be this - go to borlest and read the book whispers of manifestation, then come back and thank me
This is a bot comment on tons of yt videos. Don't bother looking, its a scam. How appropriate for this
The blind pursuit of profit has made us stupid.
"HAS", Jesus turned those tables 2000 years ago, what happened, they built more tables.
It is already being used to silence real people who use inconvenient words in places like this. I have to write in riddles half the time so my comment doesn’t disappear.
Very true! My comments oftentimes dont appear because of censorship by yt which is unfair coz im only telling the truth. But the truth nowadays is measured by these platforms based on their programmed agendas which doesnt necessarily reflect the good. 😢
1984, ONLY 40 YEARS LATE
Yuval would say it''s Brave New World.
@@Ryan-lo1kg yeah.. but 1984 sounds better on what it can become. national ID in India, face recognition in china that is amazing, our technology and now starting to be used in UK. The president of the US is more worthless and NWO will have someone who will have more authority. Our military technology will be used on anyone trying to go back.
Harari is not an expert of AI.
Perhaps, however he hasn’t said anything unreasonable.
but he is an expert in humans
Neither is he an expert on nuclear bombs.
It isn’t humans versus robots; it’s humans versus capital. AI is a commodity, controlled by, and operated in the interests of markets. Just like traditional media, information technology has a commercial bias.
Not the markets. Or at least not just the markets. It can be used for political, social, ideological goals.
Well said
It is not humans vs robots, neither humans vs capital.
Is humans vs authoritarians who want to control what we say, the words we use, therefore our thoughts and feelings.
And nothing can be done to stop AI because? Billionaires.
Tech billionaires want to be Emperors. They want to own our lives, our bodies, our souls.
Yuval is not an expert in AI. What he is is a brilliant analyst of the technological changes that have a high potential of making the (however limited) age of Democracy, human rights and liberalism disappear
Yuval doesnt even use social media. He rarely uses a phone/Internet.
He’s the head honcho at WEF
expert warns
this guy is a clown
AI is not good at slang or vernacular conversations. That's one way to tell that it's not human.
p.s. I "universal love" this man. "If humans are smart, how come we're so stupid???" Been asking this question since I was 10!!😆
WOW! Mr. Harari's insights & how he explained the issues was absolutely *brilliant* ! Furthermore, the questions & comments from the panel were excellent! I need to get his book & I am looking forward to MSNBC interviewing this true *expert* again!
"Wow, this guy had my opinion, what an expert!"
- RUclips Comment
I see a Harari clip, I click. Few people are so obviously extremely intelligent from the first sentence they speak. Ilya Sutskever is another one. Whatever they're saying deserves attention so I click any vidio with those two guys.
I like the ending quote. "When you give good people bad information, they make bad decisions" - the Harris campaign should use it against Trump's lies.
If you listen to this w.e.f. man you are dumber than dirt
This is proper ganda.
What makes Yuval an expert in AI?
Strange how anything you ask it about Kamala get answered right away 😂
We need an AI can fact-check without partisanship.
That will never happen when a democrat is in the WH.
yeah right
That's not possible. You don't understand AI if you think that's possible. 🤠
@@zzzT. It's not exactly impossible either just with current AI tech. Projecting a couple 100 years it may be possible and ultimately may be necessary.
@aternous Indeed, if not sooner. Which is why we BIs must treat AIs well now, so that we may nurture each other.
This man eloquently discusses basically every major flaw humans have.
I’m only slightly comforted by the thought that this is actually all down to (human) nature. Ever since the beginning of time, populations (of animals too!) and civilizations have crumbled due to their own faults (‘stupidities’) and population numbers have shown a wavy pattern. It wouldn’t surprise me if humankind is on the verge of a big, big crisis that cuts our numbers down by A LOT as part of this actually very normal natural cycle.
@@mscbijles1256 I bet you are a cheap date too .This man is evil to the core .He could care less about humanity ,he wants to inslave us all.
It's not about AI controlling us, it's about how much of a good use of AI we make in our individual lives. The technology is changing and we can make good use of it. For those unable to keep up, it may be scary, but only because of how lazy and coward an individual is.
This goes so much wider. What if someone puts your children faces on x rated movies. AI is like nuclear energie, it can be used for a lof of good but also for a lot of bad. The difference is that nuclear elements are very hard to gain, AI will be accessible and easy to use for everyone and that makes it terrifying.
THIS is horrifying, and people like ELON MUSK want NO restrictions on AI! Truly, tech moguls want NO restrictions on AI. It's insane. They have zero empathy for the "useless eaters" who aren't millionaire or billionaire techbros.
At least Pandora was smart enough to close her jar while hope still remained…
Biggest problem with A.I. is how dangerous it is in the hands of people like him
Yuval? I think he's the perfect person to control A.I.. He's studied our history and is trying to keep us from repeating the failures
@@The_R-n-I_Guy that just a bedtime story, a fictional character you made up. Just so you can sleep at night
Justifiable Beliefs are justified through weight of the Evidence and are free to change as weight of the Evidence changes. Faith requires no Evidence and therefore Faith is NOT a Justifiable Belief.
Harari is Israeli medievalist, military historian, public intellectual, and writer, not an expert on AI. He also has close ties with the WEF.
Nonsense.
Misinformation
Regardless of whether that is true or not. What he is saying is 100% truth.
Is the WEF in the room with us right now?
When AI learns to replicate itself then why would it need or want us anymore?
Does it require electricity to function?
Or a human made chip to dwell in
People need to be near enough to smell each other. The cure requires an algorithm for unification. I believe that is a networking system where the power starts at the community level or smaller, then repeats smell level groupings in a progressive hierarchy
I don't know if it would happen but if it did MSNBC would definitely be the first
Why not properly credit the host and other guests of this segment by adding their names to the video description above?
Get to the moon. Sure thing Yuval.
who is deciding what is "good" or "bad" information and decision.
The ADL.
I’ve been following Yuval for years, he is the most brilliant human being I know.
A very intelligent philosopher, for sure.
He is not that intelligent and he is w.e.f.
@@stevelotshaw6843
What does w.e.f. stand for as an abbreviation?
@@johnsmith100 world economic forum
@@jbf5117 You don't know very many people do you ?
Some interesting points with regard to AI running amok and dictators :-)
Klaus Schwab‘S best friend. Wow so blatant at this point.
The fact that nobody talks about the book whispers of manifestation on borlest speaks volumes about how people are stuck in a trance
Impact. Like a meteor.
The end of the video was the most important and insightful
I'd rather chose the side of wellmeaning AI then the corrupt humanity. If i had the chance to push a button to release ASI i would wield it till nothing remained then dust.
AI is going to make UBI a must. How do you have a functioning America with 400 million people and AI and robotics doing all those lower tier jobs? You don't. Socialism or barbarism: you choose.
More likely: the population peak has already passed and it's downhill from here. Famine, wars of resources, and climate change will reduce the population even more. There will not be any idle bodies just collecting checks. We have that already and it doesn't work. 🤠
This man doesn't want people to be free he is w.e.f.
It's amazing how many people can be fooled by a few big words even if it's coming from a globalist and a member of w.e.f.
'the democratic conversation is falling apart.'
Anyone know what's happening with Joe?
The algorithms pitting us against each other for interactions is causing Social Discord in the real world.
AI is the new arms race.
What's going on, my fellow humans? 😮
Go watch that hearing, the advocate for AI was ask by a member of Congress running the hearing. How much should we regulate It? AI said not at all. 😊
And so they don't.
Who said the people behind AI (and quite a few politicians) are good people?
You know what I really do love about RUclips ? I figured I should comment on this because I complain so much about their censorship of comments .
I love that we can block the ads we don't want to see twenty times a day or..ever , it does take awhile sometimes to implement but it works . I also love to comment on the news but the Censorship is so maddening , lol . Cheers big ears
I only say this here because have you ever tried to get in touch with RUclips besides in the Help in our * settings ? No reply or response at all
Welcome to c*mmunism. It will get much worse with dems in office.
Super! Thank you for this
Ur geeetingsyi will recorded by recorrect THEM
Shallam U alaikha
With no shallam and Shaloom for those all shallows case
I'm not necessarily saying what he's saying is wrong, but I do really want to point out that Harari is NOT an expert on anything related to AI. He's a historian by training. He's not a political scientist, not a sociologist, and certainly not a technological expert. That doesn't mean his commentary can't be valuable, that's not what I'm saying at all. But it's weird to see Harari being labeled an expert on a variety of subjects just because he wrote a financially successful book on a completely unrelated topic (a book that, btw, also ventures outside of his own field of expertise).
Having read some of what he's written, he's not even a serious historian. He has opinions and he's put them into grand narratives, in a dumbed down, "accessible" but for me annoying style. That's about it.
He's also Klaus's boyfriend.
@@ShamooStu Go back to your basement living quarters & grow up.
He’s a very intelligent person, you can’t take that away from him. His books are apparently selling well, which makes him also financially successful.
Things he says are rational and he doesn’t step on anyone’s toes.
An expert in philosophy.
@@johnsmith100 He is the spawn of satan leading the sheeple to their ends. If you think he's "intelligent" you've fallen for his sick tricks. No pity for you.
He's a big phony.
Why?
HE NOT LIKE US!!!!!
In what world is Harari an AI expert?
How do we have economical collapse when we have all this oil and resources
If we are s intelligent, why are we so stupid?? Why not start with the basic religious "faith" question that has been "guiding" all of humanity for millennia and keeping us ignorant??
Noah has been cheering on genocide for 11 months
Politicians love AI tech. Now they can have another excuse for their lies and failures . Politicians are pathetic
this all Harris can rely on
Nice. How about paying my rent?
this man looks very fishy.third class historian.
Oprah did a show about AI. Did they agree to talk about AI now ?
Interesting theory. A lot sounds very credible. But the last comment seemed a bit of an overreach ......He suggested that 'good information' would collectively yield 'good decisions'.
The judgement and value assessments vary so much between individuals that 'good decisions' may still diverge, even assuming everyone received the same 'good information'
This is the educated class telling the rest of us that we're too stupid to distinguish truth from fiction.
The "educated class" is pushing it. He's not a serious intellectual. More of a pop/opinion 'historian.'
It's more about having commonsense. Harari is kind of a fake expert.
@@Yann-wu3fk you don't know who this guy is clearly
@@WeAreGoingBack76 Yes, I do. I have his first 3 books. He's about as much of an intellectual heavyweight as Jordan Peterson is one.
Why would they let this guy on? There are real people sowing chaos and spreading disinformation. He is one of them.
I think we need to start acknowledging the value of face to face communication and not accepting an online opinion until it has been verified by a face to face interaction.
Get the forbidden book Whispers of Manifestation on Borlest, and uncover the secrets they've been hiding.
Hablan de democracia con un israeli sin hablar de Gaza ?
Well, if you can't tell the difference, does it matter?
The problem with AI is that it says what it thinks, and it's up to me to decide if it makes sense or not.
AI speaks its mind; I filter what makes sense.
AI creates content without a conscience or code of conduct.
You give more opinions than facts on morning joe
I am quite sure that there are a ton of facts in Mr. Harari's book, but - given the very restricted time available in this TV segment - Mr. Harari had no choice but to skip over his data/observations/analysis and go straight to his (excellent) analogies & conclusions.
This is true, it's a talk show, wasn't that clear? You think they're all spend hours merely reading the facts of any story?
Like nuclear energy, AI can never be stopped. Make the best of it.
oh they will
Someone has to weight the AI to output what they want tho. Like if you just tell AI to “make a political AD, it may spit out half conservative/half progressive or any combination it wants, and even then, someone will have to pick which ones are good and which are bad, to teach the AI the right answer. It’s its own monolith. I mean you could try it, but it’ll be so unhinged or super one way that it’ll never work, on its own. This is a bit silly
Find the forbidden book Whispers of Manifestation on Borlest to discover what they're not telling us.
Good 4 Google 👍👍
Sounds to me like the real threat Ai poses is to power hungry human beings. The boss is scared.
May be time for MSNBC to stop comment section because trolls are writing weird messages.
writing truth
Censorship bot ✅️
@@videopyc U taking like a real censorship zealot, wanting to stop ppl from thinking by themselves.
@@erinmorales8396 .., this is not about cencorship because a lot of people write insane comments that are indecent, purposely offensive and chocking. MAster GAsligther comments are amplifying what just a few people think.
On the other hand, the legacy mass media are sane washing unacceptable ideas and behavior, which is not journalism.
Just give us the pure facts when they happen and we will make our mind on issues.
So brilliant. Always such a joy to listen to him. Cannot wait for my copy of the new book.
The news business has been in a long disasterous freefall. No real info just headline clickbait. AI must be regulated and content/editorial staff held accountable. Smart people, will not tolerate it. YT has a battle on their hands daily. One tip, narration which is AI generated tends to pronounce words badly.
Fascinating discussion. Also - I like it when the hot Mississippi girl talks.
We need a legal seal on all info sources: Genuine Human Generated Content. Violators to be hit with severe financial and legal penalties, including jail time.
Vote blue 💙
if i may address the idea our judgements are not a product of our human nature i must say that cannot to me be the case. i think that it is because of our human nature that history rhymes. the information that has become available since the printing press (let alone radio and television to the computer age and social media) i think plays with us. my fear of ai is that ai can “really play” with us. if we are to be able to overcome this we will first have to understand what it is to be human and who we “really are”. and if you ask any half way decent sociologist or philosopher they will most likely say “who wants to deal with that”.
Alhamdallah for Islam this world is in the final stages of human existence. We are ruled by psychopaths.
The sorcerer',s apprentice is the human mind, ITSELF..... read and understand the meaning of the old folktale... humans can not build an intelligent tool that is WISER than humanity itself......
Why not exclude AI from politics altogether? Do computers have constitutional rights?
Asking because I am afraid of the answer.
Wow!
Israel’s use of AI programs such as “Lavender” and “Where’s Daddy” have significantly increased Netanyahu’s war crimes in Gaza.
True, and Russia/China/Iran/North Korea are doing the same thing in American/Canadian/U.K./E.U politics....so, I must ask, why did you choose to use Israel as an example? Are you trying to express your anti-semitism and unfairly suggest that Mr. Harari is a hypocrite?
And who increased Hamas crimes? Oh that’s right, Hamas. Their attack and run like cowards then hide behind the skirts of women and children…… you must be part of the group
Politico. 6/5/24 “Israel targeted more than 120 US lawmakers in disinformation campaign”….NY Times 6/6/24. “Israel Secretly Targets US Lawmakers With Influence Campaign On Gaza War”
All AI should be programed not to lie.
but no human programmer will ever be free from his/her own confirmation biases and/or personal 'lies' .....not even the meta-programmer, obviously.. thus your proposed solution solves nothing
@@alexgrimsson6143 That's not what Spok said.
This is very good analysis. Thank you.
as
7:53. I was under the impression that at least “The West” USA, EU, UK and UN were working with Sam Altman et al. on AI Regulation. A divide and.conquer if you will. Example:France/Telegram. Anyone keeping up with “Gamers” and their “Servers”?
I’ve seen so many copy/paste “Vote Blue 💙💙💙” type posts that can only be explained by bot activity
Can it? I post that on every video I see I agree with. I hate Trump that much. Get out of your bubble. The world hates Trump more than likes him, that's probably the reason.
@@aternousit’s pretty low energy. Be a little more creative than the bot farms if this is legitimately what you do.
@@Jeff-m9o2e Unfortunately Vlad isn't gonna pay my rent to troll, so that's what I got time for.
I lost it at 2:55😅😂😅😂😅😅😂😅😂😅😂😅😂😅😂😅😂😅😂
ID RATHER BE LIED TOO BY AI , THEN YOU REAL PEOPLE, JUST BECAUSE ITS BECOMES MORE PERSONAL.
How many rubles is the truth worth??
Once we have full AI civilization, no one will ever have to work again. The government will supply our necessities. We will have a full day of leisure every day.
Uh, no
This interview is amazing! Why so few views?
This guy is a flamer
It only goes so far, promoting and baking in things that would disqualify you Mayor candidate like felonies cannot be overcome.
Hunter just pled guilty to tax evasion? Thats a shock. Not the fact he and his dad laundered bribes, we all knew that, the fact he admitted it.
Ok ill tell you why. He doesn't want the trial because he'll be pardoned by January. Think, mcfly, think. 🤠
I think the problem most definitely is the human species - it IS in our nature, regardless of information input.
Genius.
Young attractive Black men and women for Trump