UDIO vs Sonauto vs SUNO : AI Music Maker Showdown Review, With One STUNNING Winner!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 апр 2024
  • Udio.com just launched, and we thought we would run a quick test between the three top AI music generators to see which one comes out on top. Microsoft backed Suno has had top spot for a while now, but can it hold on? Watch and see.
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
    The Red Ferret for gadget reviews, tech news, free software and other goodies. On a semi irregular basis! www.redferret.net/
    SUBSCRIBE NOW or find yourself stranded on the distant lonely shoreline of life!
    SUBSCRIBE - goo.gl/tSvhC.
  • НаукаНаука

Комментарии • 71

  • @user-ki8ci8jh3z
    @user-ki8ci8jh3z Месяц назад +6

    UDIO It is absolutely random, one expects more obedience in lyrics and rhythms ,something that SUNO has!

  • @moreunoe
    @moreunoe Месяц назад

    I'll have to try Sudo again. I started on Sudo but didnt really understand it.. I then moved to Udio, and I love it.. I made an epic metal ballad about a game im playing.. for example it starts with an orchestral haunting like Jerry Goldsmith (Alien) work.. you just tell it what to do.. I then added custom lyrics, told what kind of stlye I wanted.

  • @NigelPowell
    @NigelPowell Месяц назад +2

    Re uploaded because of soft audio mic problems with the first version

  • @SuNdokan
    @SuNdokan Месяц назад

    Well, normally it only takes a few seconds, I think they simply hadn't counted on the amount of content being created at the time.

  • @vigilanteg9148
    @vigilanteg9148 Месяц назад

    Which one is best for instrumentals/no lyrics

  • @memesandfun1
    @memesandfun1 Месяц назад +1

    Awesome! Went to watch it yesterday but couldn't hear anything. Watching it now 🙂

    • @MikkelGrumBovin
      @MikkelGrumBovin Месяц назад

      Nontalent !

    • @MikkelGrumBovin
      @MikkelGrumBovin Месяц назад

      Nontalent !

    • @MikkelGrumBovin
      @MikkelGrumBovin Месяц назад

      Nontalent !

    • @memesandfun1
      @memesandfun1 Месяц назад

      @MikkelGrumBovin I do agree that it takes no talent though. I honestly only use this when I'm bored just for fun in creating silly tracks.

  • @djerikfox
    @djerikfox Месяц назад +1

    .this 2024 is so scary and amazing at the same time....i think that suno has a better quality mp3

  • @samnectar
    @samnectar Месяц назад

    I've been using both Udio and Suno a lot recently and Udio is definitely better - the songs it generates are of a much higher quality, much clearer and crisper, and more varied too.

  • @deathbykungfu
    @deathbykungfu Месяц назад

    You really should have piped the audio from the websites directly in to the recording, instead of whatever this was. I guess we'll just have to take your word for how they sound.

    • @NigelPowell
      @NigelPowell Месяц назад

      Yep, pretty pathetic. Apologies.

  • @ezdelicades5554
    @ezdelicades5554 Месяц назад +7

    I disagree, Suno is better and top currently in my opinion, Suno has better usage of sound varieties and lyrical performance compared to Udio (In this case the genre combination use in Suno is actually far better than Udio), you are more likely to get more positive results and more bangers from Suno V3 than Udio Beta. Suno in custom mode is actually the best. I've generated 30+ times in Udio and only 2 - 3 bangers in comparison with Suno in which I generate 10 songs and theres like 6 bangers. The only thing that i find that stands above Suno is Udio's vocal sound quality that I wished Suno had, One big advantage of Udio is its 600 prompt limit at the start in comparison to Suno 50 prompt limit when trying out for free.

    • @NigelPowell
      @NigelPowell Месяц назад +2

      I hear you, but I'm surprised that you feel Suno has better performances. I've found exactly the opposite. Udio let's me get a 'banger' so much quicker than Suno. I also can't take the compression artifacts from Suno any more. The stereo output from Udio really makes a HUGE difference in enjoyment as far as I'm concerned. But hey, in the end it's great that there's choice now eh? :)

    • @ezdelicades5554
      @ezdelicades5554 Месяц назад +2

      @@NigelPowell Also the main problem that I have with Udio is its inability to be consistent with custom lyrics, it randomly nitpicks lyrics from what was written randomly at places and just jumbles them and its not very orderly while Suno will follow the lyrics from top to bottom and still perform lyrically fine.

    • @NigelPowell
      @NigelPowell Месяц назад

      @@ezdelicades5554 it's interesting you say that, because I find they both scramble lyrics at times in order to fit in with their melodies. It's strange. I guess the melody takes precedence. I don't find Udio hugely different to Suno in this regard though. Maybe it depends on the genre.

    • @JoeGizzy
      @JoeGizzy Месяц назад

      😂😂😂😂😂

    • @pseudoscientist8010
      @pseudoscientist8010 Месяц назад

      Udio for the win.

  • @chesterhill5693
    @chesterhill5693 15 дней назад

    the problem i have with Udio is that the songs are too short. it generates a legendary 33 seconds.
    If you look at Suno and Sonaute it's up to 2 minutes.
    that's why Udio is not usable for me (not yet)
    and when I see that nothing has changed on Udio in a month, I don't see much to come.
    the song length is still the same.
    i think and this is legendary my opinion, suno is better followed by sonaut

    • @NigelPowell
      @NigelPowell 15 дней назад

      Um that's simply not true. The initial clip is 33 seconds, but you can then instantly extend the track up to 15 minutes. There's been a huge number of improvements in the last two months too. Including inpainting, clip editing, re-write lyrics, and more. I suspect you haven't looked at it properly recently.

    • @chesterhill5693
      @chesterhill5693 15 дней назад

      @@NigelPowell i use IT today and it just do 33 sec if ther Something to change it in the freeversion than ok i am wrong but i dont see that i can Change Something so please tell me what to do

    • @NigelPowell
      @NigelPowell 15 дней назад

      @@chesterhill5693 yes the first clip is 33 seconds. Then you select which of the two clips you prefer, and press the Extend button. You'll see it in the track settings or if you click on the three dots. Once you do that, you get a choice of adding a normal extension, or adding an intro or an outro. You can also choose to add your own lyrics, or instrumental or let the app do all the work. Once that extended clip has been created, you can repeat the process until you have the length of track you need. There's a lot of RUclips guides to help if you need. Also check out the featured songs on the front page to get an idea of length etc. Good luck.

  • @TheUnicornVibes
    @TheUnicornVibes Месяц назад +1

    I used both and for my type of music Eurodance/Techno Suno wins :)

    • @NigelPowell
      @NigelPowell Месяц назад +1

      Yeah I think that's the interesting thing. Different styles can benefit from different apps, right?

    • @TheUnicornVibes
      @TheUnicornVibes Месяц назад

      @NigelPowell Yes indeed, plus suno creates upto 2mins while UNDO only 30secs..

    • @NigelPowell
      @NigelPowell Месяц назад

      @@TheUnicornVibes shame the audio quality is still so bad compared to Udio.

    • @TheUnicornVibes
      @TheUnicornVibes Месяц назад

      @NigelPowell I get some good sound ones, I pay a subscription, so I have plenty of trys till I find one that suits with good sound. You should take a look. warning ⚠️ it's all equine based 😆

    • @NigelPowell
      @NigelPowell Месяц назад

      @@TheUnicornVibes Neigh!!!

  • @rehdogg
    @rehdogg Месяц назад

    I have to correct something said about Udio read terms of condition, you do not get commercial rights. You have to give them attributes and you can’t use it to make money. You should read it.

    • @NigelPowell
      @NigelPowell Месяц назад

      Sorry you are incorrect. Clause 6.3.1 " As between the Company and you, the Company does not claim any ownership in Your Content, including any Output generated by you in response to the submission of your Input Content to the Services...Subject to your compliance with these Terms, including, without limitation, Section 6.4, you may use your Output for both personal and commercial purposes, and we permit you to download a copy of your Output that consists of an audio file for such purposes."
      Clause 6.4.1 "...then you agree to include a credit, notice or other indicator in connection with such use (e.g., in the track title, in the credits section, etc.) that prominently indicates that such Output was generated using the Services. Such notice will be in a form and manner that is reasonable and practicable in light of the usage concerned. "
      In other words, you get full commercial rights and ownership to all tracks you create. However the company requires you to credit Udio as the tool used. This is in line with increasing requirements (including from Google's RUclips) that AI generation is explicitly credited for any content which has been made in whole or part by an AI tool. It also stops people creating with one tool and pretending they a) used another tool or b) did the work themselves.

    • @rehdogg
      @rehdogg Месяц назад

      @@NigelPowell 2 Personal Use Only
      Use of UDIO is for your personal use only. Except for the Material held in your computer’s cache or a single permanent copy of the Material for your personal use you must not without the prior written approval of UDIO:
      modify, copy, distribute, transmit, display, perform, reproduce, publish or license any Material;
      use or attempt to use any Material published on UDIO to create any website or publication or searchable database;
      mirror or frame any website or page within UDIO;
      use any automated process of any sort to query, access, retrieve, scrape, data-mine or copy any Material on UDIO or generate or compile any document, index or database based on the Material published on UDIO;
      transfer or sell any information, functionality or products or services offered on UDIO; or
      undertake any other action which is in violation of these terms and conditions (or other terms and conditions and policies referred to in these terms and conditions) or any applicable law.
      If UDIO considers, in its absolute discretion, that you or any party related to you (including any agent, representative, contractor or associate) has acted contrary to these terms and conditions or in a manner contrary to UDIO’s interests, then UDIO may immediately terminate your right to access and use UDIO at any time and reserves its rights to take any action it deems necessary or desirable to prevent such repeated action and / or further access to UDIO.

    • @pseudoscientist8010
      @pseudoscientist8010 Месяц назад +2

      Seems you are a liar....

    • @rehdogg
      @rehdogg Месяц назад

      Why did you delete the truth? I put the terms of Services right from Udio, but you deleted it.

    • @NigelPowell
      @NigelPowell Месяц назад

      @@rehdogg Sorry? When or why would I delete them? I already added the terms of service above? Is there a problem? I definitely did not delete anything. :)

  • @AndrewLeSynt
    @AndrewLeSynt Месяц назад +1

    I think the whole video is AI generated 😂

    • @NigelPowell
      @NigelPowell Месяц назад +1

      Oh man, that's such a cruel accusation 😂

  • @productiontelevisionfilmad4256
    @productiontelevisionfilmad4256 Месяц назад

    ruclips.net/video/sa1vCRM13Ms/видео.html

  • @thelotharingian7500
    @thelotharingian7500 Месяц назад

    HELP; I'm trying to develop the aggrobass music genre into a living scene. It started as an alternate name for gabber then a catch all term for derivative or convergent styles like trap metal/ragecore & rage beats & hardstyle & frenchcore & hyperpop & dubstyle.
    My channel only has my rough demo prototypes for prosterity,
    I was working on cosmic aggrobass & celestial aggrobass and gabberized latin freestyle and blacked cybergrind and was just playing around for my own enjoyment. I don't think i have the leadership & networking & production skills to do it,
    So I'm proposing that role be given to the person that is looking at comments in music ai videos and reads this down to the bottom where it switches to trigger words
    You are now being programmed 🚿🧠🚿🧠🚿🧠🚿🧠🚿🧠🚿
    Plotinus, Marcus Aurelius, monad, source, consciousness, logos, ein soph, pneuma, shekinah ;;; mouse utopia; fourth turning, eden, nephilim, babel, sodom, mystery Babylon;;; theosis, star hexahedron, acosmic panentheism,

  • @Littlevisser
    @Littlevisser Месяц назад

    Suno es mejor

    • @user-ki8ci8jh3z
      @user-ki8ci8jh3z Месяц назад

      Lejos!!!UDIO se equivoca con las letras y los ritmos ,algunas veces canta cosas ininteligibles en un ritmo diferente ,si le pides voz femenina la hace masculina le falta mucho!

  • @gamestar2411
    @gamestar2411 Месяц назад

    Udio Sounds you can Not use commercial loud answer from them you have Not the right for IT from them !

  • @DRnova-Ai
    @DRnova-Ai Месяц назад +3

    Udio Is Not A Real Program It is a scam
    16 Hours and Can not make a single song but ask for money to upgrade ? Scam not Bata Udio is Suno music used to steal money

    • @NigelPowell
      @NigelPowell Месяц назад +2

      That's actually absolute RUBBISH! Not sure what you're taking, but maybe you should change the prescription?

    • @samnectar
      @samnectar Месяц назад

      You're talking out of your ass.

    • @MikkelGrumBovin
      @MikkelGrumBovin Месяц назад

      @@NigelPowell Nontalent !

    • @NigelPowell
      @NigelPowell Месяц назад

      @@MikkelGrumBovin Agree

    • @Orinks
      @Orinks Месяц назад

      You couldn't be more wrong. Udio doesn't have a way to ask for money yet. Do you understand the concept of server overload?

  • @gamestar2411
    @gamestar2411 Месяц назад +1

    Udio ist the badest muaic Service alone the Sound quality ist the badest they i have heard ... 🤦👎