What people don’t know is that the voice has been there from the very start. She had to suppress it for industry’s standards. She had to “die to be born.”
This is like 2007 or 2008.. mad nostalgia vibes and yes I know this is a cover but look at Gaga lol she's sooo young sheesh lol I'm getting old and fat send help
@@Marrythenightgaga101this was recorded in 2008 before Gaga blew up. This is actually the leaked demo version and the final version was never released.
Hope you’re doing well now! Just seen your comment and thought I would say.. I am a HUGE Gaga fan and actually came out to my parents the day born this way dropped. I remember being bullied at school when this song hit the internet back when just dance was blowing up. It helped me so much when I felt so along and misunderstood. It brought a tear to my eye knowing it’s still helping people all these years later
La versión original o famosa es poderosa por llegar primero. Pero esta trae un ambiente pop super nostálgico al reducir el tiempo de la canción, la canción es mas breve, y claro la música instrumental y las nuevas voces de gaga y the midway state son excelentes, son tan emocionales. Es una versión poderosa también inyecta todo lo que la original logró en su tiempo.
LYRICS: In this proud land we grew up strong We were wanted all along I was taught to fight, taught to win I never thought I could fail No fight left or so it seems I am a man whose dreams have all deserted I've changed my face, I've changed my name But no one wants you when you lose Don't give up 'cause you have friends Don't give up You're not beaten yet Don't give up I know you can make it good Though I saw it all around Never thought I could be affected Thought that we'd be the last to go It is so strange the way things turn Drove the night toward my home The place that I was born, on the lakeside As daylight broke, I saw the earth The trees had burned down to the ground Don't give up You still have us Don't give up We don't need much of anything Don't give up 'cause somewhere there's a place Where we belong Rest your head You worry too much It's going to be alright When times get rough You can fall back on us Don't give up Please don't give up 'got to walk out of here I can't take anymore Going to stand on that bridge Keep my eyes down below Whatever may come And whatever may go That river's flowing That river's flowing Moved on to another town Tried hard to settle down For every job, so many men So many men no-one needs Don't give up 'cause you have friends Don't give up You're not the only one Don't give up No reason to be ashamed Don't give up You still have us Don't give up now We're proud of who you are Don't give up You know it's never been easy Don't give up 'cause I believe there's the a place There's a place where we belong
I’ve heard the original version by Peter Gabriel and Kate Bush after this version and I was trying so hard to feel the emotions like in this version.. They are legends but for me the original version is type of music that I’m going to skip.. And I have same feelings about the music video.. And I’d like to say that The Midway State are so underrated.. I’ve heard couple songs and I love it.. It could be best to see or hear Gaga with Nate (The Midway State) together again..
Well, I understand your opinion, but you should be aware that Lady Gaga wanted to do this version so that new generations would know the work of Kate Bush. That is called respect.
Me encanta esta música de Lady Gaga. Si alguien tiene el video en HD o DVD (VIDEOS VOB) etc, que lo comparta. me gustaría descargar esta video musical en su máxima calidad. :)
I agree.. I think that Nate (The Midway State) and Gaga put more emotions than Peter Gabriel with Kate Bush in to this song.. They are legends but I don’t like the original version
Do you really think that this cover conveys the same feeling and is musically better than the original? Or that these voices are superior to those of Peter Gabriel and Kate Bush? Well, I'll do as Kate: wow. I say no.
It’s a decent version but not even close to the original. This guy’s voice is really weak compared to Gabriel. Lady Gaga gives a good account of herself but not in the same league as Kate Bush - noticeable that she can’t get anywhere near the high register so drops an octave
It's definitely close to the original, not to say better. I agree on the guy's part, but Gaga is actually singing and belting. Kate can barely compete with Gaga's vocal projection
Why did someone do something like this with the amazing song of Kate Bush and Peter Gabriel? There were emotions, sadness, passion - you felt the connection between two people. This is just a poor cover that hurst ears. Profanation...
How come I am barely hearing this on 2024?? Wtf lol
Exactly! omg
Here in 2021 for this song and video that deserved so much!!
Absolutely. I love this song so much! And the original, of course.
YES!
The way baby gagas voice was so powerful in 2007 and now even in 2022 over a decade later her voice is still if not more powerful
Gag died after 2011
Fame Era - most powerfull in music that world has.
Very close to Madonna.
Bit not)
@@dexterstockman2640oh plz
Happy Mistake, from “HARLEQUIN” (2024) reminds me this song! ❤️🔥
I can actually imagine her singing this in 2022 I feel like this could of been on the A Star Is Born soundtrack seamlessly
I just seen this on fb! How was this not released as a single??? We need this to be on the charts!!!!!!!!!!
A 22 yr old Stefani 🥰❣️🌷
just discovered the song today! WTF! I am blown.
Te amo canción presiosa... 😢 Perdón por olvidarte... 2023 aquí
I just discovered this song. And I am a big fan!!!
Sounds like an updated version of the original, it's beautiful. As much as I love those 80s synths, this is also pretty
WTF this is my first time listening to this. It's so beautiful ❤️
Joker 2 is gonna rock
It didn't...
@@lipefwsIt was a decent misunderstood film who flopped. That's it. All the actors were fine.
@@MadininaCarribean Joaquin and Gaga were great. But the the movie itself was definitely a huge flop
*THIS SONG IS TIMELESSLY LIT!* 🔥
What people don’t know is that the voice has been there from the very start. She had to suppress it for industry’s standards. She had to “die to be born.”
i know for a fact she can still sound like this. I miss immature gaga so much
I would love to hear her sing like this again
What a throwback!
Here its 2022 and i got some sort of brain and muscle damages so Gaga keeps me alive! 🙏🏼💜🤘🏻
This is like 2007 or 2008.. mad nostalgia vibes and yes I know this is a cover but look at Gaga lol she's sooo young sheesh lol I'm getting old and fat send help
Yep you’re almost on the date this was very early 2009 (January or February)
@@Marrythenightgaga101this was recorded in 2008 before Gaga blew up. This is actually the leaked demo version and the final version was never released.
Cómo es que está canción nunca salió a la luz oficialmente 💔😭
¿De qué hablas? Peter Gabriel y Kate Bush ya la hicieron brillar cuando Lady Gaga era apenas una niña.
I mentally was in a bad place and this song all I needed to feel better 💪❤️🙏
Hope you’re doing well now! Just seen your comment and thought I would say.. I am a HUGE Gaga fan and actually came out to my parents the day born this way dropped. I remember being bullied at school when this song hit the internet back when just dance was blowing up. It helped me so much when I felt so along and misunderstood. It brought a tear to my eye knowing it’s still helping people all these years later
Wow este es el video que buscaba durante años.
Al fin lo encontré.
¡¡¡Muchas gracias!!!
2022 and listening!
So beautiful.
La versión original o famosa es poderosa por llegar primero. Pero esta trae un ambiente pop super nostálgico al reducir el tiempo de la canción, la canción es mas breve, y claro la música instrumental y las nuevas voces de gaga y the midway state son excelentes, son tan emocionales. Es una versión poderosa también inyecta todo lo que la original logró en su tiempo.
esta version es fabulosa
I never knew the covered this song. The original Peter Gabriel and Kate Bush version is one of my all time favourite songs.
2024?
LYRICS:
In this proud land we grew up strong
We were wanted all along
I was taught to fight, taught to win
I never thought I could fail
No fight left or so it seems
I am a man whose dreams have all deserted
I've changed my face, I've changed my name
But no one wants you when you lose
Don't give up
'cause you have friends
Don't give up
You're not beaten yet
Don't give up
I know you can make it good
Though I saw it all around
Never thought I could be affected
Thought that we'd be the last to go
It is so strange the way things turn
Drove the night toward my home
The place that I was born, on the lakeside
As daylight broke, I saw the earth
The trees had burned down to the ground
Don't give up
You still have us
Don't give up
We don't need much of anything
Don't give up
'cause somewhere there's a place
Where we belong
Rest your head
You worry too much
It's going to be alright
When times get rough
You can fall back on us
Don't give up
Please don't give up
'got to walk out of here
I can't take anymore
Going to stand on that bridge
Keep my eyes down below
Whatever may come
And whatever may go
That river's flowing
That river's flowing
Moved on to another town
Tried hard to settle down
For every job, so many men
So many men no-one needs
Don't give up
'cause you have friends
Don't give up
You're not the only one
Don't give up
No reason to be ashamed
Don't give up
You still have us
Don't give up now
We're proud of who you are
Don't give up
You know it's never been easy
Don't give up
'cause I believe there's the a place
There's a place where we belong
2024 ❤
Kate Bush must be proud of her
I’m here because the vocals or melody or something in one of her new Joker songs reminded me of this
lady gagaaaaa
Best song lady Gaga has ever done
Yes, I'm a little monster and I knew about this song since 2013 or maybe before and I hate the fact this song has not been released
I’ve heard the original version by Peter Gabriel and Kate Bush after this version and I was trying so hard to feel the emotions like in this version.. They are legends but for me the original version is type of music that I’m going to skip.. And I have same feelings about the music video.. And I’d like to say that The Midway State are so underrated.. I’ve heard couple songs and I love it.. It could be best to see or hear Gaga with Nate (The Midway State) together again..
Well, I understand your opinion, but you should be aware that Lady Gaga wanted to do this version so that new generations would know the work of Kate Bush. That is called respect.
@@jenglishg I know.. I love Kate Bush and I’m happy that The Midway State with Gaga made this cover.. 🙏🏻🙏🏻 but still this version is better.
Gracias!
Old GAGA - is BEST OF GAGA
FINALLY
I love this, but is this Lord Gaga
yeshahaha
?
2023 still watching thisss
Me encanta esta música de Lady Gaga. Si alguien tiene el video en HD o DVD (VIDEOS VOB) etc, que lo comparta. me gustaría descargar esta video musical en su máxima calidad. :)
Eu em 2023 descobrindo isso 😅
I love is video
💔
1:01
As much as I love Peter Gabriel + Kate Bush, this is so much better!
I only gave it an 'equal to' but ...
better? that's a stretch. It is good tho...
I agree.. I think that Nate (The Midway State) and Gaga put more emotions than Peter Gabriel with Kate Bush in to this song.. They are legends but I don’t like the original version
Idk, this feels less intimate, like kate bush sings like a lullaby and gaga has this powerfull pop belt which while beautiful isn't as emotive to me.
Do you really think that this cover conveys the same feeling and is musically better than the original? Or that these voices are superior to those of Peter Gabriel and Kate Bush? Well, I'll do as Kate: wow. I say no.
like people commenting here don't realise its a cover lmao
If you're going to cover a music, you should make it better. Otherwise, is better just let the song stay as it was. The original song is perfect.
And it is better ! A lot of emotion, passion and intensity in this version as well. No need to hate. There's quality to this one too !
It’s a decent version but not even close to the original.
This guy’s voice is really weak compared to Gabriel. Lady Gaga gives a good account of herself but not in the same league as Kate Bush - noticeable that she can’t get anywhere near the high register so drops an octave
It's definitely close to the original, not to say better. I agree on the guy's part, but Gaga is actually singing and belting. Kate can barely compete with Gaga's vocal projection
U know this is unfinished and there's a reason they didn't release it officially, though this still slaps
Why did someone do something like this with the amazing song of Kate Bush and Peter Gabriel? There were emotions, sadness, passion - you felt the connection between two people. This is just a poor cover that hurst ears. Profanation...
This is powerful cover after it's a question of taste...