Carmelita Cruz Except no. Isildur was no pushover. He had literally just defeated Sauron. What makes you think Elrond is just going to be able to throw him over the edge? Not to mention Isildur had the Ring with him, which would’ve made him even stronger. And remember, the Ring had a will of its own, and would’ve helped Isildur kill Elrond, since, you know, it obviously doesn’t want to be destroyed. The reason we don’t see the Ring make anyone super powerful in the trilogy is because hobbits themselves aren’t powerful creatures, which is why it is a hobbit that is chosen to take the Ring to Mordor.
@@karlfranzemperorofmandefil5547 I don't know much about Lord of the Rings other than what I saw in the movies but isn't the One Ring suppose to be more powerful than any other? I don't think it matters he's a Ring Bearer compared to anyone using the One Ring.
Legend101 In the name of Robert of the House Baratheon, the First of his Name, King of the Andals and the First Men, Lord of the Seven Kingdoms and Protector of the Realm, I Eddard of the House Stark, Lord of Winterfell, and warden of the North, name you the Master of Wisdom
+TakeshiMagdonish ummmm....Gandolf did at the end of Return of the King....flew right in....I'll bet Mordor doesn't even have radar....could have flown in day one...would have made for a horrible movie but...just sayin...lol
It's amazing to see how far the channel has come over the years. I didn't realize just how old this video actually is rewatching it all this time later.
ALL of them would have died if they flew conspicuously so that Sauron saw them. Then a Nazgul would have went over there and ended the sightless eagle.
The Real HIshe: Elrond: Cast the ring into the fire! Isildur: No. Elrond: [When Isildur tries to leave] YOU! Isildur: You wouldn't dare... Elrond: SHALL!!! Isildur: Don't do it Elrond: NOT!!! Isildur: STOP! Elrond: PASS!!!! Isildur: Fine, I'll do it!
lynx He can't. Isildur would have put the ring and go away. And even if Elrond took the Ring, he would'nt be able to throw it in the volcano, because corrupting power of the Ring is irresistible.
Dia celium about isildur is true but corrupting a elf is harder than corruptig a human and it would just take seconds no way he will be corrupted that fast
Gandalf actually you of all people should know that you can’t do that. 1st of, Nazgul (I just destroyed the entire theory) 2nd of, the eagles don’t help anyone. The only reason you eventually got them to help was because the eagles owed you. Case closed
@@armon9555 Also you forgot to mention that the Eagles hate flying over the lands of men because the men will shoot at them out of fear. And when the Eagles rescued Gandalf off of Orthanc, they not only got shot at but nearly died.
What's especially funny is that someone actually asked Tolkien about using the eagles, and he pointed out that he should have given more thought to explaining why this wasn't a viable option.
It’s cause the eagles are kind of like Gandalf but instead of choosing human form they chose eagle form, so it would be like forcing you to go and stand above a volcano
@@musicislobb I think you might be confusing the Ringwraiths with their flying mounts. The flying mounts might be used to intercept the Eagles, but the Nazgûl were recently unhorsed at the Ford of Bruinen and it is highly unlikely that they could intervene.
1. The Fellowship's only, only, advantage over Sauron is stealth and riding an Eagle into Mordor would waste it. 2. Sauron has like four hundred ways of dealing with airborne enemies. He doesn't even need to use Nazguls or magic, just Orc archers would do. 3. Eagles are Maiar and thus the odds of them just splatting Frodo somewhere on the way and taking the Ring is 99%. 4. The War of the Ring is Eru's test for humanity to unite and stand on their own against Sauron. If the wizards are forbidden to use their full power, then so are the Eagles, who are also Maiar.
Well actually, if you had read the books, you would have known that they thought this was a good idea, but the eagles were proud creatures and would not do the mission for them. Plus, Sauron would have seen them approach and sent his Nasgul after them.
Nazgul at the time were nowhere near their fell beasts. They were still jogging back to Mordor after all their horses for murdered by a river. Mordor was unguarded.
@@QualityPen Arrows? Even without the nazgul sauron was mustering his forces inside mordor if they eye didn't see the birds atleast some orcs would, not farfetched for eagles to be shot out of the sky by ballistas or bow. Sarumon could also intervene. Nazgul are also not ordinary beings. Still plausible for sure.
Isildur: The ring is mine! Elrond: What the fuck?! We just fought this whole battle to destroy the ring! Your dad DIED! Do you have any idea what could happen if you don't destroy it now?! Isildur: THE RING IS MINE! Elrond: *shoots him* *Isildur and ring fall into fire* -later Elrond: Yeah, guys, Isildur tripped.
+teenwilliam1000 Let's use the story of the books here. Elrond is an elf. Not just any elf, but one of the elf LORDS who fought MORGOTH'S ARMIES and survived to tell the tale. He has lived for HUNDREDS, if not thousands of years by that point. Now we have Isildur. Guy wielding a broken sword and yes, one of the Numenorans. He has none of the skill and talent accrued over time as Elrond. Now Elrond has an elven bow. And elven arrows. Guess what elves masters at. Making weapons and such. Now picture Elrond firing his bow into Isildur's chest and Isildur crumpling into a heap and the Ring falling into Mt. Doom.
+The One Banana then civil war all over again :S , if you come to think about it shauron actually united all the tribes to fight him , a necessary evil one might say
Murder only applies if his intent is to kill Isildur. Not, you know, destroy the ring that ends up almost destroying the world because Isildur lost his damn mind. Although the ring can corrupt someone without them ever even touching it (Boromir case in point) but that was over months of traveling with Frodo. Isildur had only had the ring for a few minutes. I very much doubt Elrond would've been so corrupted in a few minutes he would've killed Isildur only to steal the ring for himself.
So... Aragorn isn't king Saruman still lives (he's a terrible man) Gandalf remains as Gandalf the Grey Frodo lives a happier life Aragorn doesn't get married Boromir is still alive Frodo and Sam aren't as close Frodo has TEN FINGERS (O.o) Gollum is alive Theoden still looks ugly Sam and Rosie don't get married Merry and Pip don't become the tallest hobbits Frodo actually will smile more Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli don't get to kick Orc butt Aragorn doesn't get to lead a bunch of ghosts I am running out of things to say Are you still reading this? If you are here's a cookie.
Kaitlin Buehl I think theyre talking about HISHE. If they took the Eagles (Which they couldn't have, the Eagles actually don't like helping people and they only help Gandalf because they owe him) and dropped the ring into the fire, Aragorn would never become king, Saruman would have still corrupted Theoden, etc. It would still be very disastrous.
Well... they actually had only one of those flying beast in the book, so there it would have been possible. AND if Sauron doesn’t know about the eagles to fly into Mordor, why should he have the Nazgul kill them? (In the Book there are like lots of other reasons, why it might not work)
Isn't there Nazgul, archers and other deadly flying creatures surrounding Mordor? The eagles would never go there while it's infested with thousands of deadly creatures.
Well then take them 2 miles outside of Mordor. Hell take them 10 miles away. It sure beats doing what they did, especially thinking back to the Snowy Pass to the Mines of Moria in the Fellowship. Why subject yourself to that?
superweirdguy123 Well then why the fuck did they show up at the Black Gate to save Aragorn and the company from the Nazgul? I am well aware that I may have completely overstepped my bounds with this statement because I haven't read the books in ages and the eagles probably only show up to save them in the movie. haha. Whatever. Its a funny video. Laugh and move on
Actually, take it from a person who has actually read Silmarillion and the LotR books, the eagles and their lord Gwaihir are actually not on the Free People of Middle Earth's side, just like the maiar ( beings of light or Wizards basically - Gandalf/Saruman). They are not neutral, but they are not siding with middle earth's inhabitants unless they feel honor-bound (as seen in War in the North with Beleram) or if they are connected/allies (Gwaihir and Gandalf especially). Thus, The eagles were only in middle earth to spy on Elrond's elves who were deemed the most knowledgeable of elves and on their enemy Morgoth, A.K.A Sauron's master before he was cast down. They didn't have any responsibility in ensuring the ring's destruction and so, Gandalf and Elrond knew that they could not ask Gwaihir and his Great eagles for help in their quest. So, they sent the Fellowship to do so, with Gandalf guiding them. The only reason Gandalf is helping the free people of middle earth is because he has grown attached to them (Especially the Hobbits) while Radagast has grown fond of the nature, the Red and blue wizard are off to god knows where (The valar sent five Maiar to Middle earth) and Saruman usually kept to himself and spoke sometimes with leaders of other races such as the ents and the elves.
***** Check your facts better mate; It's a blue and a red wizard, not two blue wizards. They were always of different colours, remember? Gandalf the Grey, Saruman the white (Later "Of many colours" when serving Sauron), radagast the brown and the two mentioned as Blue and Red. Points on remembering their names though. Like I said, they were sent to spy on Morgoth and the exiled Noldors (The clan of elves Elrond belongs to), but of course they helped in the war against Morgoth. However, they are not on anyone's side but the Valars and some of the Maiar (Gandalf and Radagast), but they are not so willing to help the free people of middle earth since that is/was not their main "objective/quest", if you will, in middle earth. Correct, the fumes posed a problem, but even so, Gwaihir and his great eagles would still not have helped them since it wasn't their quest to complete for them. No idea why they joined in the last battle at the Gates of Mordor, but I would assume that they saw that there was a great opportunity for Sauron to be vanquished and thus, they helped for once.
Why Eagles weren't used: Sauron is a Great, lidless eye, weathered in flame that could see the eagles coming for miles. He would have planned a trap for them long before they got there. Now what could have been done to prevent any of this, Elrond slaps Isildur, take the ring, and throw it in himself.
Except its super silly. Obviously everyone would see a giant eagle flying around. Even orcs would see it. So a Nazgul would go and kill that eagle and everyone on it promptly and Sauron wins.
LOTR does not have plot holes. Eagles were race not just like birds, they could only be summoned by Gendalf because he did a favor for them in the past and they would help just for the save, but not like a transport. besides the ring would effect eagle (because its not animal, like a pony who does not understand good and evil). Eagles had intelligence and they could even talk. Riding eagle with the ring would turn into disaster, because he could get corrupted by Sauron
Irakli Meparishvili actually the favour for Gandalf was the eagle would do anything for Gandalf, you should really start reading the books (its in the hobbit book, not the lord of the rings)
read the books, Mordor was constantly overhung with a pyroclastic cloud of volcanic ash ,gas and smoke, and storms. Sauron controlled the weather and Volcanoes in Mordor. He kept in that way so it would always be dark (in the shadow) there , so his orcs could travel during the day. The eagles could not fly though the volcanic cloud and storms. Only after he died were the eagles able to fly to Mt Doom and save the hobbits.
it might have served everyone better if the eagles where never shown in the movies. In Hobbit they rescued the team once, in LOTR they didn't do very much. They were a race of Maiah and were not placed in Middle Earth to take sides. Manweh (the main Valar) put them in Middle Earth as overseers, mostly because the Valar (aside from Ulmo and Melkor aka Morgoth or Sauron's original master - the Valar didn't really care about Middle Earth).
We bought our first HD TV in 2004 - it was a 40" Samsung LCD (which was HUGE at the time) for, wait for it... $1,600.00!!!! In 2010 we bought a 55" Toshiba for $850 - we still have that one. My father-in law just bought a brand new 50" for $275 last month.
Yeah, they actually changed it.. I noticed at the end, The Hobbit Hishe, and other videos made YEARS after this video appeared, probably done with the RUclips editing software..
Can anyone not realise that Mordor at the time of the fellowship was swarming with orcs had a gigantic eye atop of a tower constantly searching for the ring or even waiting to feel its presence, and people think a giant eagle wouldn't go unnoticed if it were to just fly on in. The orcs would know of the eagles approach several miles before even reaching the black gates and would be trying to take it down. The only reason the eagles rescued Frodo in Mordor at the end of the third movie was because there was no longer an Immanent treat of being there once Sauron was destroyed. I mean yes there was a possibility of success getting a lift from the eagles but they would not risk it as it was basically a suicide mission. This is the reason Frodo needed to approach by foot as they suspected Sauron would never expect an attack from there, and they were right.
Theres also the nine immortal ghost sorcerers on fell beasts and (if you go by the books) Saruon himself at the heart of his power where even Gandalf would have been defeated if they'd tried to just brute force there way in, But man fuck that they could just use the Eagles right?
I just realised that Sam and Frodo wouldn't be best friends, Aragon wouldn't become King or meet Erowyn (can't spell her name), Saruman would have still looked for a way to be an evil leader and Gandalf wouldn't get to be a White Wizard!
Jacob Lunt No, the suicidal thing would be to use the Eagles. Sauron would see them coming a mile away and Mordor arrows and ballistas and god knows what else would shoot them down before you could say "You shall not pass".
I think HISHE should also do How The Two Towers (LoTR) Should Have Ended and How The Return of the King Should Have Ended. Heck they did all the Hobbit movies separately, so I think should also parody the other 2 LoTR films as HISHE parodies.
No because each video would end the same. With the ring being thrown into the fire. Gollum falling after it. Sauron defeated. They make a joke about how easy it was and how they would have had to WALK. And it wouldn't be funny being said 2 more times.
Gandalf said he had a plan right from the start, and kept it from everyone else to stop the plan being known by Sauron if one of the fellowship was captured and interrogated. If you look on the map of Middle Earth, Gandalf was actually taking the fellowship to the mountains where the eagles lived - he planned on doing exactly what this video shows. Here's where it gets crazy: Gandalf had to take refuge in the underground caves in order to escape the snow storm the evil fella (whose name I don't remember), whilst down there he had to fight the big fiery thing, and when he was losing, he realised he was the only one to know the plan involving the eagles. When he fell and grasped onto the last piece of bridge, before falling he looks intensely at the fellowship and says "FLY YOU FOOLS", in an effort to let the fellowship know the plan of taking the eagles to Mordor... only the fellowship never caught on, and so they continued with the only plan they'd ever known; to take the ring to Mordor.
I taught his plan was to send a ring bearer, (which just so happened to be a hobbit....again) secretly into Mordor along with the fellowship as protection, but this plan got ruined with the devision of the fellowship and his death. You have to remember Sauron did know of a fellowship on a quest but as to what the quest was he was unaware. Fly is just another acronym for flee, run, get away.
The behaviour of the eagles reminded me of a harry potter quote: "Help will always be given at hogwarts to those who deserve it." That's how the eagles always behaved. I never saw them take commands. They provided help to those that deserved it the most. That's why they saved Frodo at the end and why they saved Gandalf and Thorin. They kind of appear just in time to tip the balance. They're not there to fight someone else's battles. They only get involved in the desperation of the deserving...not as a means of transportation.
@@happyscooter228 Funnily enough that's exactly what they are meant to be in the books. A group of immortal beings so scared of death that they would only come when it was absolutely necessary.
Awesome. But really, LOTR should have ended when, instead of yelling at him and doing nothing, Elrond pigsticked Isilidur and pushed the corpse and ring into the fire after Isildur decides to keep it for himself, amirite?
+spwb2k well then, how will there be a story? there are many books like this. why didn't superman ask batman for a kryptonite gun in man of steel, so he can kill zod?
+spwb2k A better writer would have compensated for such plotholes. Lord of the Rings however gets a free pass because it was written a long, long time ago. When people were far more forgiving of such dumb plot points, which also, at the time, were not necessarily considered dumb.
Came back to remember the start of a great Chanel the first episode I love you guys so much your animation has improved a lot but still full of great jokes
Well in the movies at least they had Fell Beasts patrolling Mount Doom at the end of Two Towers. But then again Gandalf shines some light beams and game over.
I don't think people realize that Gandalf and the eagles aren't actually supposed to be able to help the fellowship. That's the whole reason why Gandalf doesn't just do everything himself. He helps them only when they are in grave danger and there is no other way. Inform yourselves on the lore. I understand this video was purely made as a joke, but people truly dislike the movie because they always say "why didnt they just ride the eagle the entire way, stupid movie!"
dawgyv72 That was uncalled for. Really. I'm not lazy to Google it, I'm just not that interested in learning more of LoTR but since this eagle loophole thing and Gandalf always missing when the party needs him bugs me, I thought someone that understands LoTR like you could summarize it for me. But no. Looks like you don't understand it yourself.
Average Movie-Watcher: Oh yeah, they could have just used the eagles! Wow Gandalf, good job. Average Ringer: NONONONONONO!!! WHAT THE LEMBAS NO JUST NO! Like, Gwaihir was *not* Gandalf's pet! That's just like a Dwarf asking a Man if they could ride on their back or something!!! The eagles only let them ride on them since they owed Gandalf a debt! They wouldn't just... And have you ever even heard of the Nazgúl?! Duh?! And the orcs have longbows and cannons and... ARRGHHH.OH MY ELBERETH. _Pe channas..._
There is a good explanation as to why they DIDN'T use the eagles. I am pretty sure it was something like if they got the ring they might go bad, kind of like how Gandalf will not touch the ring. The eagles are already super powerful in the books and are on the level as Gandalf in the whole god scale thingy.
How it should have ended: Sauron: Yo! Celembrimbor, can I show you how to make cool magic rings? Celembrimbor: No Sauron: Shit They lived happily ever after.
Well... I know this is all for comedic purposes but for those that didn't know... Sauron was a Maia, he knew about the existence of the Giant Eagles same as Gandalf... You only need to look at the Nazgúl and their Felbeasts to know that flying over a land filled with toxic smoke, orcs shooting from below AND Felbeasts harassing the eagles that it would just be impossible.
What did the first line of my statement say? "I know this is for comedic purposes." I was simply saying that the Eagles dropping the ring into Mt. Mordor would be impossible, which people without any knowledge of the LOTR universe seem to think otherwise. And yes, I am a nerd. I take pride in that I know more about things than others. Don't even get me started on Star Wars. So, your comment has just be countered twice... What you going to do now, troll?
RonanRaff Because really, they're not two of the same thing? ._. People like this, dear youtubers... Make me question the survival of Humanity in a decade or so.
Yeah, they're the same thing that's just what i used to say as a kid (Don't know why) You are right humanity is quite dumb, we'll probably nuke ourselves in the years to come or start a WW3.
Uuuuuh, really? R u serious??? Would it be fun to read the books then? Would it be a good movie? In middle-earth there wasn't POSSIBLE to just "take an eagle" and go to mount doom! They lived their own lives in the misty mountains, there would've been NO CHANCE for the fellowship to travel by eagles, believe me... But I know, it's confusing...
Do you think when Samwise got married he asked Frodo to be the ringbearer?
You did not just say that...
Oh my god, that's hilarious. brilliant
Oh my god, that's hilarious. brilliant
+Dante Bonaccorso thanks! Haha
Not funny
Elrond takes Isildur to the mount doom, he tells him to throw the ring, isildur refuses so he throws isildur with the ring. THE END
Then Aragorn doesn't exist
point said. How LOTR should've ended
True, but who cares, there will be a faramir anyway, it will be just fine.
That would cause all out war between elves and men...
Elves would win. gg
This is older than some kids on RUclips let that sink in
Yea 12 years.... its as old as RUclips itself!
Peter Griffin RUclips is 14 years old....
I was 2 🤣😂
FaZe XoTic This is older than me by 5 days
It came out 5 months before I was born my mom was pregnant with me at the time this came out.
Elrond: Hurry cast it into the fire
Isildur: No
*pushes*
THE END
Carmelita Cruz Except no. Isildur was no pushover. He had literally just defeated Sauron. What makes you think Elrond is just going to be able to throw him over the edge? Not to mention Isildur had the Ring with him, which would’ve made him even stronger. And remember, the Ring had a will of its own, and would’ve helped Isildur kill Elrond, since, you know, it obviously doesn’t want to be destroyed. The reason we don’t see the Ring make anyone super powerful in the trilogy is because hobbits themselves aren’t powerful creatures, which is why it is a hobbit that is chosen to take the Ring to Mordor.
@@RR-ir6ss yes Elrond could he's a Ring bearer
Your concept is uses on my video you will watch this I'd
Thankyou
@@RR-ir6ss
One word: *Arrows...*
@@karlfranzemperorofmandefil5547 I don't know much about Lord of the Rings other than what I saw in the movies but isn't the One Ring suppose to be more powerful than any other? I don't think it matters he's a Ring Bearer compared to anyone using the One Ring.
Is that what he meant when he said "Fly you fools!" ?
Could be...
Vincent Poirier flee*
There's actually a theory about that.
lol there is no theory about that. He simple said they needed to flee.
lordSeaworth It is still a theory! J. J. R. Tolkien or his son never confirmed this.
one does not simply fly into mordor
exactly
Legend101 In the name of Robert of the House Baratheon, the First of his Name, King of the Andals and the First Men, Lord of the Seven Kingdoms and Protector of the Realm, I Eddard of the House Stark, Lord of Winterfell, and warden of the North, name you the Master of Wisdom
+TakeshiMagdonish ummmm....Gandolf did at the end of Return of the King....flew right in....I'll bet Mordor doesn't even have radar....could have flown in day one...would have made for a horrible movie but...just sayin...lol
TakeshiMagdonish LOL...oh man...when I started reading this I'm thinkin "WTF?....ohhhh...lol"
+Yars McKartane but you should understand that Gandalf the grey is not the same as Gandalf the white.
Wow this is 13 years old, amazing how much your animation changed over the years
The sound too. It almost sounds like there is just one guy doing all the voices.
14 now just like me
It’s been ten years since I watched this. Crazy how much people change!
Yeah, nowadays they pay more focus on the detail and graphics instead of a good story
16 now
It's amazing to see how far the channel has come over the years. I didn't realize just how old this video actually is rewatching it all this time later.
Well that saved us 9 hours of screen time....
Lol
60 hours of book time
12 hours if you count the extended versions cut from theatres
Oh plot holes
+Ben Wasserman yeah!
"Imagine if we had walked the whole way."
(Laughing) "That would have been ridiculous!"
"Yeah, one of us might have died."
Or two of them actually but Gandalf got a revive. lol
ALL of them would have died if they flew conspicuously so that Sauron saw them. Then a Nazgul would have went over there and ended the sightless eagle.
@@marissashantez6051 Nazgul were on horses at that time
Anyone else catch that last, little jab by Aragon: Your mother had cataracts! 🤣
( I ) : _"I don't like you"_
Everybody did. We're not deaf. :)
@@LeKain08 yeah, and you're just rude.
I totally missed that one and I watched this years ago..
Haha, no. Thanks for pointing that out 😄
The Real HIshe:
Elrond: Cast the ring into the fire!
Isildur: No.
Elrond: [When Isildur tries to leave] YOU!
Isildur: You wouldn't dare...
Elrond: SHALL!!!
Isildur: Don't do it
Elrond: NOT!!!
Isildur: STOP!
Elrond: PASS!!!!
Isildur: Fine, I'll do it!
tbf at least that was only a movie thing
how it actualy should have ended: elron kicks isildur's ass and throws the ringin the volcano
lynx He can't. Isildur would have put the ring and go away. And even if Elrond took the Ring, he would'nt be able to throw it in the volcano, because corrupting power of the Ring is irresistible.
Dia celium about isildur is true but corrupting a elf is harder than corruptig a human and it would just take seconds no way he will be corrupted that fast
Lizard-Motion Films Elves have morality..
Lizard-Motion Films you sir, are a fucking genius
Lizard-Motion Films but i realised that aragorn wouldn't exist
Ugh. I told them to do this. I said "FLY, YOU FOOLS!" But no. They thought I meant something else...
Gandalf actually you of all people should know that you can’t do that. 1st of, Nazgul (I just destroyed the entire theory) 2nd of, the eagles don’t help anyone. The only reason you eventually got them to help was because the eagles owed you. Case closed
@@armon9555
Worth pointing out they didn't help until the fall of Barad-dûr.
Ew that's not how Gandalf talks like he has much better grammar and vocabulary
@@armon9555 Also you forgot to mention that the Eagles hate flying over the lands of men because the men will shoot at them out of fear. And when the Eagles rescued Gandalf off of Orthanc, they not only got shot at but nearly died.
Walter Fielding yeah that’s a major point as well. Another is that since the eagles are Maiar carrying the ring on their backs could corrupt them.
It’s crazy how much the animation has changed in 13 years
Now that's how you keep Boromir alive 😁
2007, holy crap. Feels like ages ago.
yeah
almost 10 years...
CidGuerreiro1234 yes it does
almost a decade
CidGuerreiro1234
made the year I was born
What's especially funny is that someone actually asked Tolkien about using the eagles, and he pointed out that he should have given more thought to explaining why this wasn't a viable option.
Nazguls
bro that eye was searching for ring all the time , so it would clearly notice the ring but even before nazguls would notice it
It’s cause the eagles are kind of like Gandalf but instead of choosing human form they chose eagle form, so it would be like forcing you to go and stand above a volcano
@@musicislobb I think you might be confusing the Ringwraiths with their flying mounts. The flying mounts might be used to intercept the Eagles, but the Nazgûl were recently unhorsed at the Ford of Bruinen and it is highly unlikely that they could intervene.
1. The Fellowship's only, only, advantage over Sauron is stealth and riding an Eagle into Mordor would waste it.
2. Sauron has like four hundred ways of dealing with airborne enemies. He doesn't even need to use Nazguls or magic, just Orc archers would do.
3. Eagles are Maiar and thus the odds of them just splatting Frodo somewhere on the way and taking the Ring is 99%.
4. The War of the Ring is Eru's test for humanity to unite and stand on their own against Sauron. If the wizards are forbidden to use their full power, then so are the Eagles, who are also Maiar.
Well actually, if you had read the books, you would have known that they thought this was a good idea, but the eagles were proud creatures and would not do the mission for them. Plus, Sauron would have seen them approach and sent his Nasgul after them.
It's something they should have mentioned in the movie
Nazgul at the time were nowhere near their fell beasts. They were still jogging back to Mordor after all their horses for murdered by a river. Mordor was unguarded.
@@QualityPen Arrows? Even without the nazgul sauron was mustering his forces inside mordor if they eye didn't see the birds atleast some orcs would, not farfetched for eagles to be shot out of the sky by ballistas or bow. Sarumon could also intervene. Nazgul are also not ordinary beings. Still plausible for sure.
Eagles are proud creatures, but they help when story needs them. Gandalf could have force them to do so.
@@faultytitties The movies assumed you were smart enough to realize why it's a bad idea.
Wow this is old
@TheMETROMOD wow i was 4 years when this 3 years when this came out
It's the first one
@TheMETROMOD I was -2months
Yeah my mom was pregnant with me at this time
OLD, I WAS BARELY 3
"Preciouuuuus! Uh oh" I loved how Golem just came flying in out of nowhere LOL
Gollum / Smeagol / One ring!
Gollum. Golem is a czech legend about giant made of earth
I knew it would happen 😂
It’s Gollum not golem
@@namarie0005
Thank you
It would've been more logical if Elron had just pushed Isildur into the fire right at the beginning.
Then you would have changed the whole story line based on a scene that was never in the original book.
Good call!
That there is the biggest plot hole ever
***** one murder vs saving the whole world a fuck ton of hassel? Eh is it that bad really?
***** someone would have to though.
10 years later and I haven't missed a single HISHE short. One of the first channels I ever subbed to. Great work guys!
It's the kind of idea that crosses everyone's mind but who no one is brave enough to say out loud.
Isildur: The ring is mine!
Elrond: What the fuck?! We just fought this whole battle to destroy the ring! Your dad DIED! Do you have any idea what could happen if you don't destroy it now?!
Isildur: THE RING IS MINE!
Elrond: *shoots him* *Isildur and ring fall into fire*
-later
Elrond: Yeah, guys, Isildur tripped.
+The One Banana Elrond wouldn't have a chance of killing Isildur
+teenwilliam1000 Let's use the story of the books here. Elrond is an elf. Not just any elf, but one of the elf LORDS who fought MORGOTH'S ARMIES and survived to tell the tale. He has lived for HUNDREDS, if not thousands of years by that point. Now we have Isildur. Guy wielding a broken sword and yes, one of the Numenorans. He has none of the skill and talent accrued over time as Elrond. Now Elrond has an elven bow. And elven arrows. Guess what elves masters at. Making weapons and such. Now picture Elrond firing his bow into Isildur's chest and Isildur crumpling into a heap and the Ring falling into Mt. Doom.
+The One Banana then civil war all over again :S , if you come to think about it shauron actually united all the tribes to fight him , a necessary evil one might say
+sakor88 Well said... People who don't understand that idea haven't grasped onto what the ring actually is on a psychological/spiritual level.
Murder only applies if his intent is to kill Isildur. Not, you know, destroy the ring that ends up almost destroying the world because Isildur lost his damn mind. Although the ring can corrupt someone without them ever even touching it (Boromir case in point) but that was over months of traveling with Frodo. Isildur had only had the ring for a few minutes. I very much doubt Elrond would've been so corrupted in a few minutes he would've killed Isildur only to steal the ring for himself.
-Can you imagine what it would be like if we walked the entire way?
-Don't be silly
-One of us might have died
HAHAHAHAHA
"Huh?" - Last words of Sauron, the dreaded Lord of The Rings.
And yet the best trilogy ever created.
These are some of my favorite movies ever
So...
Aragorn isn't king
Saruman still lives (he's a terrible man)
Gandalf remains as Gandalf the Grey
Frodo lives a happier life
Aragorn doesn't get married
Boromir is still alive
Frodo and Sam aren't as close
Frodo has TEN FINGERS (O.o)
Gollum is alive
Theoden still looks ugly
Sam and Rosie don't get married
Merry and Pip don't become the tallest hobbits
Frodo actually will smile more
Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli don't get to kick Orc butt
Aragorn doesn't get to lead a bunch of ghosts
I am running out of things to say
Are you still reading this? If you are here's a cookie.
but i have no mouth to eat the cookie!
Gollum dies! He dives into the fire with the ring Frodo drops. Can I still have a cookie?
Kaitlin Buehl I think theyre talking about HISHE. If they took the Eagles (Which they couldn't have, the Eagles actually don't like helping people and they only help Gandalf because they owe him) and dropped the ring into the fire, Aragorn would never become king, Saruman would have still corrupted Theoden, etc. It would still be very disastrous.
10 fingers XD
Yeah, I won a cookie :-D
so the only problem I see is the lack of orc army and nazgul patrolling near the eye of sauron.
well they wouldn't have the orcs cause saroun didn't make them
Early HISHE animation.
9 years ago fucccckkk I didn't even know what RUclips was
To be fair, it would take more than fifteen minutes to get to Mordor, but the eagle would be logical
nazgul are weak and at the end of the third moovie they get raped by the eagles...
"Your mother had cateracs! Oh snap! " lol XD
“Can you imagine what it would be like if we had walked the entire way?” 😂😂😂
Don't be silly one of us might have died
One small problem. To quote Faramir:
NAZGUUUUUUULLLLLL!!!!!!!!
I also thought that
Ditto
Well... they actually had only one of those flying beast in the book, so there it would have been possible. AND if Sauron doesn’t know about the eagles to fly into Mordor, why should he have the Nazgul kill them? (In the Book there are like lots of other reasons, why it might not work)
Isn't there Nazgul, archers and other deadly flying creatures surrounding Mordor? The eagles would never go there while it's infested with thousands of deadly creatures.
Well then take them 2 miles outside of Mordor. Hell take them 10 miles away. It sure beats doing what they did, especially thinking back to the Snowy Pass to the Mines of Moria in the Fellowship. Why subject yourself to that?
you're right, the eagles would never go there.. by choice. If they were ambushed and blindfolded, maybe..
superweirdguy123 Well then why the fuck did they show up at the Black Gate to save Aragorn and the company from the Nazgul? I am well aware that I may have completely overstepped my bounds with this statement because I haven't read the books in ages and the eagles probably only show up to save them in the movie. haha. Whatever. Its a funny video. Laugh and move on
Actually, take it from a person who has actually read Silmarillion and the LotR books, the eagles and their lord Gwaihir are actually not on the Free People of Middle Earth's side, just like the maiar ( beings of light or Wizards basically - Gandalf/Saruman). They are not neutral, but they are not siding with middle earth's inhabitants unless they feel honor-bound (as seen in War in the North with Beleram) or if they are connected/allies (Gwaihir and Gandalf especially). Thus, The eagles were only in middle earth to spy on Elrond's elves who were deemed the most knowledgeable of elves and on their enemy Morgoth, A.K.A Sauron's master before he was cast down. They didn't have any responsibility in ensuring the ring's destruction and so, Gandalf and Elrond knew that they could not ask Gwaihir and his Great eagles for help in their quest. So, they sent the Fellowship to do so, with Gandalf guiding them. The only reason Gandalf is helping the free people of middle earth is because he has grown attached to them (Especially the Hobbits) while Radagast has grown fond of the nature, the Red and blue wizard are off to god knows where (The valar sent five Maiar to Middle earth) and Saruman usually kept to himself and spoke sometimes with leaders of other races such as the ents and the elves.
*****
Check your facts better mate; It's a blue and a red wizard, not two blue wizards. They were always of different colours, remember? Gandalf the Grey, Saruman the white (Later "Of many colours" when serving Sauron), radagast the brown and the two mentioned as Blue and Red. Points on remembering their names though. Like I said, they were sent to spy on Morgoth and the exiled Noldors (The clan of elves Elrond belongs to), but of course they helped in the war against Morgoth. However, they are not on anyone's side but the Valars and some of the Maiar (Gandalf and Radagast), but they are not so willing to help the free people of middle earth since that is/was not their main "objective/quest", if you will, in middle earth. Correct, the fumes posed a problem, but even so, Gwaihir and his great eagles would still not have helped them since it wasn't their quest to complete for them. No idea why they joined in the last battle at the Gates of Mordor, but I would assume that they saw that there was a great opportunity for Sauron to be vanquished and thus, they helped for once.
0:26 this voice comes to mind every time I hit a lightbulb in my brain.
SIXTEEN YEARS AGO????????
I didn't even know what RUclips was when this came out.. THIS CHANNEL IS FREAKING OLD
yrcyrgedtreerte4ed5gfdsfcdrgvx
Well so is SMØSH...
Yeah and how did u not know RUclips
+JasonBeckham13 Jj He Or She Is New In RUclips
+JasonBeckham13 Jj maybe because I was 5
"One of us might have died" bahahahaha lost it xD
Favorite scene: Eagle: what the heck is going on?! Gandalf: I’ll tell you when it’s over, keep flying you blasted bird!
Always find myself here again after watching a lotr marathon. Starting March 2020 the right way
Goddamn has it really been 8 years since this came out?
+Brian L Talking about the video
ikr
Aomine? Dafuq are you doing here? Go back to practice!
Nutelko8 There's no point in practicing
+The Nerd That Lifts 9 years now... its 2016
Why Eagles weren't used: Sauron is a Great, lidless eye, weathered in flame that could see the eagles coming for miles. He would have planned a trap for them long before they got there.
Now what could have been done to prevent any of this, Elrond slaps Isildur, take the ring, and throw it in himself.
Elrond should have pushed Isildur into the mountain, because he would have gotten corrupted by the ring
Elves (especially Elrond) wouldn't get corrupted as easily and fast as Isildur and other men.
Huh i thought i read somewhere that Elrond would have gotten corrupted as soon as he touched it
Elves aren't are easy to corrupt as men are since their more powerful. And Elves aren't as needy as men are.
Commie Brony Feanor though... just saying.
I’ve been following you guys from the beginning. This is a classic, yet it remains my favorite. Keep up the fabulous job!
Except its super silly. Obviously everyone would see a giant eagle flying around. Even orcs would see it. So a Nazgul would go and kill that eagle and everyone on it promptly and Sauron wins.
"Eagles really do solve every problem we have!"
LOTR does not have plot holes. Eagles were race not just like birds, they could only be summoned by Gendalf because he did a favor for them in the past and they would help just for the save, but not like a transport. besides the ring would effect eagle (because its not animal, like a pony who does not understand good and evil). Eagles had intelligence and they could even talk. Riding eagle with the ring would turn into disaster, because he could get corrupted by Sauron
Wouldn't the eagles SAVE Gandalf a lot of trouble by bringing Frodo up the mountain. What if the favor he owed Gandalf was anything he asked?
don't speak nonsense
WTF are u talking?! Just imagine Gandalf asking to eagles "Guys take us to Mordor because I may die there..." and u think it would have more sense?!
U suck!, don't take everything so seriously!
Irakli Meparishvili actually the favour for Gandalf was the eagle would do anything for Gandalf, you should really start reading the books (its in the hobbit book, not the lord of the rings)
*_"not the blasted eagles again!!!"_*
*"But they solve all of our problems..."*
read the books, Mordor was constantly overhung with a pyroclastic cloud of volcanic ash ,gas and smoke, and storms. Sauron controlled the weather and Volcanoes in Mordor. He kept in that way so it would always be dark (in the shadow) there , so his orcs could travel during the day. The eagles could not fly though the volcanic cloud and storms.
Only after he died were the eagles able to fly to Mt Doom and save the hobbits.
They could have been taken Mordor adjacent. 😔
"Your mother has cataracts"
Solid burn
😂😂😂
So glad it didn't end this way, otherwise we wouldn't have three beautiful movies
it might have served everyone better if the eagles where never shown in the movies. In Hobbit they rescued the team once, in LOTR they didn't do very much. They were a race of Maiah and were not placed in Middle Earth to take sides. Manweh (the main Valar) put them in Middle Earth as overseers, mostly because the Valar (aside from Ulmo and Melkor aka Morgoth or Sauron's original master - the Valar didn't really care about Middle Earth).
Kogeta Sarada Will you subscribe to my channel
There was HD quality back in 2007?
+Wiz Technikik HD was in the stage as 4K is now
Wiz Technikik i guess so
BIG-E 23 2007 is my birth date and Cool Yo
We bought our first HD TV in 2004 - it was a 40" Samsung LCD (which was HUGE at the time) for, wait for it... $1,600.00!!!! In 2010 we bought a 55" Toshiba for $850 - we still have that one. My father-in law just bought a brand new 50" for $275 last month.
Yeah, they actually changed it.. I noticed at the end, The Hobbit Hishe, and other videos made YEARS after this video appeared, probably done with the RUclips editing software..
Y’all should remaster this classic! It would be totally awesome.
0:01 And so on that day, HISHE was born
0:00
I will always love the lines "Gandalf, there's fire below us!" and "Whee!"
One does not simply fly into Mordor is all I can say to this.
:D :D :D
This is one of the most OG youtube videos
I randomly remembered this existed, but boy am I glad I looked up the video again. 2007, brilliant
Can anyone not realise that Mordor at the time of the fellowship was swarming with orcs had a gigantic eye atop of a tower constantly searching for the ring or even waiting to feel its presence, and people think a giant eagle wouldn't go unnoticed if it were to just fly on in. The orcs would know of the eagles approach several miles before even reaching the black gates and would be trying to take it down. The only reason the eagles rescued Frodo in Mordor at the end of the third movie was because there was no longer an Immanent treat of being there once Sauron was destroyed. I mean yes there was a possibility of success getting a lift from the eagles but they would not risk it as it was basically a suicide mission. This is the reason Frodo needed to approach by foot as they suspected Sauron would never expect an attack from there, and they were right.
Theres also the nine immortal ghost sorcerers on fell beasts and (if you go by the books) Saruon himself at the heart of his power where even Gandalf would have been defeated if they'd tried to just brute force there way in, But man fuck that they could just use the Eagles right?
I just realised that Sam and Frodo wouldn't be best friends, Aragon wouldn't become King or meet Erowyn (can't spell her name), Saruman would have still looked for a way to be an evil leader and Gandalf wouldn't get to be a White Wizard!
Yeah, but they had no way of knowing that. The logical thing would be to use the eagles.
Jacob Lunt No, the suicidal thing would be to use the Eagles. Sauron would see them coming a mile away and Mordor arrows and ballistas and god knows what else would shoot them down before you could say "You shall not pass".
Jacob Lunt Always the Eagles :P
Don't forget, in The Hobbit, Tolkien explains the eagles would get shot down by men and orcs.
***** You should if you want to validate your argument. :P
Also, the air will be toxic, especially if you fly over a volcano -.-
Incredible that this vid is over 15 years old as I'm writing this. The video quality is great! ❤ My oldest niece and nephew turned 15 this year...
OH MY GOD, I JUST WATCHED THE MOVIE AND GANDALF LITERALLY TELLS THEM TO FLY AND THEN CALLS THEM "Fools"
IKR?! BIGGEST PLOT HOLE IN THE SERIES
I think HISHE should also do How The Two Towers (LoTR) Should Have Ended and How The Return of the King Should Have Ended. Heck they did all the Hobbit movies separately, so I think should also parody the other 2 LoTR films as HISHE parodies.
If the first one had ended like this there wouldn’t be a 2nd or 3rd film😂
If the heroes throws ring in first story, the sequels would be unnecessaries, no reason
it wouldnt fit with the plot becouse they destroyed the ring almost instantly so the events leading to frodo trying to destroy the ring never happened
LoTR is better
No because each video would end the same. With the ring being thrown into the fire. Gollum falling after it. Sauron defeated. They make a joke about how easy it was and how they would have had to WALK. And it wouldn't be funny being said 2 more times.
Gandalf said he had a plan right from the start, and kept it from everyone else to stop the plan being known by Sauron if one of the fellowship was captured and interrogated. If you look on the map of Middle Earth, Gandalf was actually taking the fellowship to the mountains where the eagles lived - he planned on doing exactly what this video shows.
Here's where it gets crazy: Gandalf had to take refuge in the underground caves in order to escape the snow storm the evil fella (whose name I don't remember), whilst down there he had to fight the big fiery thing, and when he was losing, he realised he was the only one to know the plan involving the eagles. When he fell and grasped onto the last piece of bridge, before falling he looks intensely at the fellowship and says "FLY YOU FOOLS", in an effort to let the fellowship know the plan of taking the eagles to Mordor... only the fellowship never caught on, and so they continued with the only plan they'd ever known; to take the ring to Mordor.
the evila fella sent*
***** wow I'm slow this morning, the evil fella is Sauron - my bad
***** FUCK, I mean Saruman
I taught his plan was to send a ring bearer, (which just so happened to be a hobbit....again) secretly into Mordor along with the fellowship as protection, but this plan got ruined with the devision of the fellowship and his death. You have to remember Sauron did know of a fellowship on a quest but as to what the quest was he was unaware. Fly is just another acronym for flee, run, get away.
Ha, that is a pretty clever interpretation :)
15 years ago... the improvement on animation style
Love how Sauron goes HUH ?!? And instantly falls. Like he feels someone made toast and then dropped the waffle down on the floor.
The behaviour of the eagles reminded me of a harry potter quote: "Help will always be given at hogwarts to those who deserve it." That's how the eagles always behaved. I never saw them take commands. They provided help to those that deserved it the most. That's why they saved Frodo at the end and why they saved Gandalf and Thorin. They kind of appear just in time to tip the balance. They're not there to fight someone else's battles. They only get involved in the desperation of the deserving...not as a means of transportation.
Help will always be given at Hogwarts to those who ask for it.
The Eagles are also from the ancient Deus Ex Machina clan who lives by the code of only taking action when all is lost for the protagonist.
@@happyscooter228 Funnily enough that's exactly what they are meant to be in the books. A group of immortal beings so scared of death that they would only come when it was absolutely necessary.
I think Elrond should have just "SPARTA" kicked Isildor into Mt. Doom.
you know that kind of bothers me. I mean Elrond just stood there let Isidor go with the ring.
Yeah, I like this idea better. I was thinking the same thing.
This must’ve been one of the very first videos from hishe
What a beautiful start to a great channel , in years to come many more great videos are coming our way :)
Awesome. But really, LOTR should have ended when, instead of yelling at him and doing nothing, Elrond pigsticked Isilidur and pushed the corpse and ring into the fire after Isildur decides to keep it for himself, amirite?
true
+spwb2k well then, how will there be a story? there are many books like this. why didn't superman ask batman for a kryptonite gun in man of steel, so he can kill zod?
+Anna Philips Understood. I was playing along with the "how it should have ended" meme.
+spwb2k A better writer would have compensated for such plotholes.
Lord of the Rings however gets a free pass because it was written a long, long time ago. When people were far more forgiving of such dumb plot points, which also, at the time, were not necessarily considered dumb.
Are u so naive u think elrond would have had the power to push down a a man who has the INSANE POWER of the ring?
'its funny cause its extremely far' 😂😂😂
0:00 a lengend was born
Came back to remember the start of a great Chanel the first episode I love you guys so much your animation has improved a lot but still full of great jokes
Feeling nostalgia
sauron had antiaircraft batteries encircling the mountain..everybody KNOWS that! sheesh
his mother got cataracts :D
Well in the movies at least they had Fell Beasts patrolling Mount Doom at the end of Two Towers. But then again Gandalf shines some light beams and game over.
Can't believe it's been nine years!
Damn nearly 11 years... Feels like I was watching this when it was first released just yesterday
Did you know that according to Tolkien, it is impossible for anyone to willingly bring harm to the ring.
I don't think people realize that Gandalf and the eagles aren't actually supposed to be able to help the fellowship. That's the whole reason why Gandalf doesn't just do everything himself. He helps them only when they are in grave danger and there is no other way. Inform yourselves on the lore. I understand this video was purely made as a joke, but people truly dislike the movie because they always say "why didnt they just ride the eagle the entire way, stupid movie!"
So uh......basically deus ex machina?
Gandalf "only helps when they are in grave danger and there is no other way" wut!?
Read the lore....
dawgyv72 Explain the lore...
Here you go bit.ly/1eLGRrc
dawgyv72 That was uncalled for. Really. I'm not lazy to Google it, I'm just not that interested in learning more of LoTR but since this eagle loophole thing and Gandalf always missing when the party needs him bugs me, I thought someone that understands LoTR like you could summarize it for me. But no. Looks like you don't understand it yourself.
Average Movie-Watcher: Oh yeah, they could have just used the eagles! Wow Gandalf, good job.
Average Ringer: NONONONONONO!!! WHAT THE LEMBAS NO JUST NO! Like, Gwaihir was *not* Gandalf's pet! That's just like a Dwarf asking a Man if they could ride on their back or something!!! The eagles only let them ride on them since they owed Gandalf a debt! They wouldn't just... And have you ever even heard of the Nazgúl?! Duh?! And the orcs have longbows and cannons and... ARRGHHH.OH MY ELBERETH. _Pe channas..._
Eddie N True...
It still could have happened a much easier way. they just stretched it offcourse to be ablle to write more books/make more movies.
cannons?
The orcs would be distracted by Aragorn and co. The Nazgul, though, would attack any air support of the eneny.
😂😂😂
"WHAT THE LEMBAS NO"
🤣
17 years later, this animation holds up.
Wait... That video is 10 days older than me, yet it is still as great as the newer ones.
If they did this in the movie, I would laugh my ass off.
Yeah a 2 minute movie 11/10 IGN
Blaze Gaming XD, yeah.
Imagine if this was an alternate ending they put in the deleted scenes...
What if they just made Sauron have laser vision or anti bird vision or some shit so it would explain why they didn't use Eagles
You might enjoy "Gimli destroys the ring" by Bill Kramme.
This video was made more than half of my life ago
And mine.
Ryan Brewer same,
Its closer to the creation of the film than to today
Ryan Brewer lol same
I was born 2007
0:51 your mother had cataracts😂😂😂
They should make a special edition remake for this video as well.
Your mother had Cataracts XD I Died !
'Hey Sauron, you suck!' Hahaha The whole video was hularius.
Wahahahha
The first wide screen HISHE video.
There is a good explanation as to why they DIDN'T use the eagles. I am pretty sure it was something like if they got the ring they might go bad, kind of like how Gandalf will not touch the ring. The eagles are already super powerful in the books and are on the level as Gandalf in the whole god scale thingy.
not only that there r thousands of orc archers and 9 nazguls with fell beasts good luck passing through them
And Sean Bean who have lived...
***** That movie is already there even though its a crappy movie. Its called Percy Jackson and the Lightning Bolt.
How it should have ended:
Sauron: Yo! Celembrimbor, can I show you how to make cool magic rings?
Celembrimbor: No
Sauron: Shit
They lived happily ever after.
How is this video close to 20 years old?! 😭
Don’t put that video in 2007. Put it back in 2012 please.
one of us might of died #poorborimir
+Jacques Marais One of us might *have* died. #poorgrammar
+Jacques Marais #poornedstark he also didn't make it thought first book X(
+petr pinc Read that as Porned Stark
+Jacques Marais Can't even spell Boromir right.
Yes, he died on second page of second book(I read it week ago).
1:18 weeeeeeeee
I'm watching this in 2019 and I can't believe how much your videos have changed!
Always a joy to come back to this gem
Well... I know this is all for comedic purposes but for those that didn't know... Sauron was a Maia, he knew about the existence of the Giant Eagles same as Gandalf... You only need to look at the Nazgúl and their Felbeasts to know that flying over a land filled with toxic smoke, orcs shooting from below AND Felbeasts harassing the eagles that it would just be impossible.
the purpose of this video is for comedy. shoo nerd!
What did the first line of my statement say? "I know this is for comedic purposes." I was simply saying that the Eagles dropping the ring into Mt. Mordor would be impossible, which people without any knowledge of the LOTR universe seem to think otherwise.
And yes, I am a nerd. I take pride in that I know more about things than others. Don't even get me started on Star Wars.
So, your comment has just be countered twice... What you going to do now, troll?
Ryan McNeal He's not a nerd, he is a geek!
RonanRaff Because really, they're not two of the same thing? ._. People like this, dear youtubers... Make me question the survival of Humanity in a decade or so.
Yeah, they're the same thing that's just what i used to say as a kid (Don't know why) You are right humanity is quite dumb, we'll probably nuke ourselves in the years to come or start a WW3.
Wow, that actually makes WAY more scence then the actual movie. why didn't it end like that?
Because then there wouldn't have been a movie...
It would probably be better to skip out the eagles entirely. They pretty much makes the trilogy very dumb.
There is a logical reason: eldorion.com/lore/eagles/
Uuuuuh, really? R u serious??? Would it be fun to read the books then? Would it be a good movie? In middle-earth there wasn't POSSIBLE to just "take an eagle" and go to mount doom! They lived their own lives in the misty mountains, there would've been NO CHANCE for the fellowship to travel by eagles, believe me... But I know, it's confusing...
IronMaytons THANK u, FINALLY someone that gets it!!!!!
I've been watching the og video on all my subsrciptions. This is really the only one that is anything like the latest uploads
“Your mother had cataracts” to sauron 😂😂