Season 2 for me. But the sentiment is still as strong. Perhaps stronger with this piece, for as i got into the show half my family disowned and ostracized me... also graduating separation from friends. Rough spot in my life and these type of songs from 4everfreebroney, aviators, princewhateverer, and others truly saved my sanity as well as my relationship with the godhead. So thanks
I always cried from the realization of how bad it was for Celestia without her sister, especially when you remember that it was her fault that the Luna turned into a Nightmare Moon
Yeah but she no choice so she felt bad what she did but when she came back they were happy see each other again and apologized I think I know why she did because Luna felt left out and her Tia got more attention than she did but now Luna got used to and fine with it
@@rb1633 Anyone can understand Luna's predicament. Imagine working hard to appease the masses, but all your efforts are always being overshadowed by your counterpart and people, ponies, in this case, seemingly can't even take the time to say, "Thank you." It also doesn't help when said counterpart dismisses your thoughts. Celestia even admits it herself, in season 2, that she ignored her sister. Point is: both sisters are guilty in their own right, but the fact is hammered home that none of it would've happened had Celestia just lent an ear to Luna's pleas.
Just when I þought þis was going to be a bad day, 4everfreebrony drops a new song into my pings. what I needed to end my day on a high note. Þank you for þis wonderful, song! Þis was just what I needed to end my day on a high note… as strange as þæt sounds for such melancholic music. Your music always manages to lift my spirits, even when þings have seemed þeir worst. To me, þe music has been a big part of why þe brony community has felt so welcome and inviting to me, and you’ve been at þe forefront from þe start! Þank you for all you’ve done, lad! I’m so glad I got to see you live last August!
Wow! Another song that I have never heard and is masterfully covered by you, thank you for keeping old songs alive for the new generation of bronys that missed everything.
i am one of those. Years ago, I was looking for somethong on TV... when the episode finished i was like: she said sister? but didnt she was banished 1000 years? it was a translation mistake? the time is diferent there or does that mean that the white mare is so freaking old? Well, i didnt get answers until years later, now when the show already ended
@@josuealexisramirezmares the term used was 1000 moons, which is real time is about 83 years (more than 83 years, but less than 84). But there is also lore that suggests it was actually 1000 years
I'm in this group! I kinda chose not to get super duper into ponies until the sunset of the brony craze, but the pitfall is missing out on some sweet fandom stuff...
@@memyselfandi2568 That's a reference to something else, for Luna it was explicitly mentioned to be a thousand years before: "Legend has it that on the longest day of the thousandth year, the stars will aid in her escape, and she will bring about nighttime eternal!"
@@josuealexisramirezmares what you can expect from magical beings able to move celestial bodies? ANd the plot itself is deeply rooted in themes present in pagan beliefs across central and eastern Europe. Mind you, the word "nightmare" in English itself is a reference to ancient spirit of winter and dream horrors, who battles its antagonist of summer.
4ever free, you have no idea how greatful I am to you & your music. Way back in season one of G4, I was in a vey dark spot in my life when I was introduced to the fandom. When I heard your music, i got hooked on it and the more of it I listened to the better I started feeling. Your music gave me the strength to pull myself out that dark place I was in & it still gives me strength & enjoyment today as well. I introduced your music to my nieces & they love it as well, they really enjoy your songs like the highest tower & who knows. Thank you so much , you are wonderful
I'll begin saying that the change at 3 m is spetacular, because that's the easiest part to express. The emotions between these sisters story and the songs you post here, I actually can't express much of that. I don't think non-pony fans will ever understand how those stories can actually touch our lives. I'm so grateful to my kids who grew up to be bronies and got me into this channel. The memories are and will always be precious, even though I feel it will be a millennium before we can be together again.
It's so cool how creativity within a fandom can become circular, with fans inspiring one another to keep producing content for a now ended series. A month ago I had a mental breakdown and lost all interest in creativity, and I'm still not back to being able to face it (or my life), but this makes me feel better about returning to my fanfiction about Luna and Celestia's past... It might be a pointless waste of time in the scope of the world, but perhaps if I can finish one thing that I feel proud of... maybe I won't feel like such a worthless failure. I hope I feel able to return to it one day, because I do still love the pony universe and the story I was telling inside it... Anyway, beautiful cover, and thank you for continuing to create for the brony community. You are a beacon of light and hope for the rest of us.
There is something about artwork, stories and songs that deal with Celestia being sad or crying, that just hits different for me. Great song Thank you.
Astonishing cover. And what a throwback! This takes me back to when I was just getting into the fandom. After stumbling across the brony music scene, I went in search of pony rock music and came across the likes of Bronified and Cyril. Makes me want to dig out some of the older pony music which I made my own little albums out of.
Honestly amazing cover and song. From the beautiful piano and melancholy melody and great vocals, and then that dive into full on Rock at 3:03, amazing dude. Fantastic work!
Strong and great and powerful. I very glad to see, how growing your skill. Several years ago, you wasn't use your voice a lot, you got more instrumental songs, I guess. But now, your songs take little other course. More rock, may be. And I like it. You musical way is beautiful!
@@4everfreebrony I mean, in your early songs, the emphasis was on the musical component, and with your voice you kind of accompanied the music. In the same emerald eyes, for example. it felt like you were afraid to reveal your voice to the fullest!
I decided to pop in to the comments just to see what people thought of the cover, this one caught my eye cuz yea - I had just heard Carnival of Rust for the first time when recording this song - though in all the years it's been out you're the second one to make the comparison - cheers 😊
I'm so glad we're getting amazing artist from the fandom that are still doing pony music to these days, your stuff never fails to make me feel a lot of stuff and emotions, I was having a hard day but this made my day better, what a beautiful piece you never disappoint ❤️
Omg coming back to listen later. I'm guessing what this song will be about, and if I'm right, I will probably cry. This will be an emotional battle for tomorrow lol
Everytime I listen to this song, it reminds me of big rock classics like from Pink Floyd or Dire Straits! 💜 Thank you for being awesome all this time! You're a big star for me 4efB /)☆(\
I love Cyril's original works but I always felt he was too attached to pushing the higher pitches. His songs started sounding all the same after a while (kind of like Aviators). His softer songs always hit better for me. Overall this is a great cover.
This version is pretty great man. It's an honor you put the time into this cover
As a Brony that was there from season one im glad we are still getting some pony music from another long time artist. Keep it up!
@@Lot742 same since season 1
Season 2 for me. But the sentiment is still as strong. Perhaps stronger with this piece, for as i got into the show half my family disowned and ostracized me... also graduating separation from friends. Rough spot in my life and these type of songs from 4everfreebroney, aviators, princewhateverer, and others truly saved my sanity as well as my relationship with the godhead. So thanks
Well spoken!
As a Brony that's only been a fan since around last October I'm glad I wasn't so late to the fandom that all the artists had moved on
@@Lot742and what does that tell us? F humans and go for ponies
I always cried from the realization of how bad it was for Celestia without her sister, especially when you remember that it was her fault that the Luna turned into a Nightmare Moon
Yeah but she no choice so she felt bad what she did but when she came back they were happy see each other again and apologized
I think I know why she did because Luna felt left out and her Tia got more attention than she did but now Luna got used to and fine with it
@@rb1633 Anyone can understand Luna's predicament. Imagine working hard to appease the masses, but all your efforts are always being overshadowed by your counterpart and people, ponies, in this case, seemingly can't even take the time to say, "Thank you."
It also doesn't help when said counterpart dismisses your thoughts. Celestia even admits it herself, in season 2, that she ignored her sister.
Point is: both sisters are guilty in their own right, but the fact is hammered home that none of it would've happened had Celestia just lent an ear to Luna's pleas.
@@pn5705 which episode when Celestia even admits it herself, in season 2
And then there's the holiday celebrating her victory over Nightmare Moon. To Celestia, it was a constant reminder of her failure.
@@pn5705Honestly, I think Celestia paying more attention to Luna would only have delayed it, not actually stopped it.
This is hauntingly beautiful, the Regret and misery of Celestia is brought out amazingly through this piece of music!
Just when I þought þis was going to be a bad day, 4everfreebrony drops a new song into my pings. what I needed to end my day on a high note. Þank you for þis wonderful, song! Þis was just what I needed to end my day on a high note… as strange as þæt sounds for such melancholic music.
Your music always manages to lift my spirits, even when þings have seemed þeir worst. To me, þe music has been a big part of why þe brony community has felt so welcome and inviting to me, and you’ve been at þe forefront from þe start! Þank you for all you’ve done, lad! I’m so glad I got to see you live last August!
Mad respect for trying to bring back the letter thorn! Best of luck!
þank you i forgot i could type like þat on my computer. now i will forever use þe letter þorn. lets do þis man, let's bring back þe letter þorn.
@@timsplosion *letter þorn
Thorn? What kind of letter is that? I’m not judging, I just never heard or seen it before.
Poor Luna... Poor Celestia...
They both have suffered enough and it's a good thing that the animated series begins with them finally reuniting.
Yeah...
Wow! Another song that I have never heard and is masterfully covered by you, thank you for keeping old songs alive for the new generation of bronys that missed everything.
i am one of those. Years ago, I was looking for somethong on TV... when the episode finished i was like: she said sister? but didnt she was banished 1000 years? it was a translation mistake? the time is diferent there or does that mean that the white mare is so freaking old?
Well, i didnt get answers until years later, now when the show already ended
@@josuealexisramirezmares the term used was 1000 moons, which is real time is about 83 years (more than 83 years, but less than 84). But there is also lore that suggests it was actually 1000 years
I'm in this group! I kinda chose not to get super duper into ponies until the sunset of the brony craze, but the pitfall is missing out on some sweet fandom stuff...
@@memyselfandi2568 That's a reference to something else, for Luna it was explicitly mentioned to be a thousand years before: "Legend has it that on the longest day of the thousandth year, the stars will aid in her escape, and she will bring about nighttime eternal!"
@@josuealexisramirezmares what you can expect from magical beings able to move celestial bodies?
ANd the plot itself is deeply rooted in themes present in pagan beliefs across central and eastern Europe. Mind you, the word "nightmare" in English itself is a reference to ancient spirit of winter and dream horrors, who battles its antagonist of summer.
I'm quite happy by the fact that people are still here and still pouring their creativity into this fandom.
Thank you
4ever free, you have no idea how greatful I am to you & your music. Way back in season one of G4, I was in a vey dark spot in my life when I was introduced to the fandom. When I heard your music, i got hooked on it and the more of it I listened to the better I started feeling. Your music gave me the strength to pull myself out that dark place I was in & it still gives me strength & enjoyment today as well. I introduced your music to my nieces & they love it as well, they really enjoy your songs like the highest tower & who knows. Thank you so much , you are wonderful
I'll begin saying that the change at 3 m is spetacular, because that's the easiest part to express. The emotions between these sisters story and the songs you post here, I actually can't express much of that. I don't think non-pony fans will ever understand how those stories can actually touch our lives. I'm so grateful to my kids who grew up to be bronies and got me into this channel. The memories are and will always be precious, even though I feel it will be a millennium before we can be together again.
Luna warrants her own series or her own special, I mean she had the darkest backstory of any character on the show.
"Oh Boy! Time for more deceptively happy music with depressing lyrics!"
"..."
"o h"
It's so cool how creativity within a fandom can become circular, with fans inspiring one another to keep producing content for a now ended series.
A month ago I had a mental breakdown and lost all interest in creativity, and I'm still not back to being able to face it (or my life), but this makes me feel better about returning to my fanfiction about Luna and Celestia's past... It might be a pointless waste of time in the scope of the world, but perhaps if I can finish one thing that I feel proud of... maybe I won't feel like such a worthless failure. I hope I feel able to return to it one day, because I do still love the pony universe and the story I was telling inside it...
Anyway, beautiful cover, and thank you for continuing to create for the brony community. You are a beacon of light and hope for the rest of us.
A song much needed of attention. Finally, it’s good to see.
There is something about artwork, stories and songs that deal with Celestia being sad or crying, that just hits different for me.
Great song
Thank you.
Astonishing cover. And what a throwback! This takes me back to when I was just getting into the fandom. After stumbling across the brony music scene, I went in search of pony rock music and came across the likes of Bronified and Cyril. Makes me want to dig out some of the older pony music which I made my own little albums out of.
This song has every chance of getting into my playlist. Let it brew in the RUclips library like a good whiskey.
I used to listen to the original so long ago. Definitely nice to hear your version as well!
I'm really disappointed G4 never explored this subject more
that's what the fandom is for.
🤝
Absolutely love this song both the original and this cover fantastic work as always.
Thanks for this. Its always a treat to listen to. I dont think ive ever disliked any music you've put out.
0ih goodness. This song is my favorite. This song is so powerful in this fandom.
The piano chords at the beginning is what sold it for me...
I’ve always loved this song and you have done it justice!
Man, I had missed this one, and that's an absolute shame because this cover is just incredible. You've been doing great at keeping the flame alive.
Honestly amazing cover and song. From the beautiful piano and melancholy melody and great vocals, and then that dive into full on Rock at 3:03, amazing dude. Fantastic work!
Amazing work! Deep inside the heart. Thank you so much for your wonderful pony songs!
Your vocals and emotions in this song are astounding.
This song is amazing and I love the singing voice.
Thank you for this.
Beautiful.
Absolutely amazing song as always!
3:02
Yoooo I didn't expect that at all! Such a great cover well done!
Strong and great and powerful. I very glad to see, how growing your skill. Several years ago, you wasn't use your voice a lot, you got more instrumental songs, I guess. But now, your songs take little other course. More rock, may be. And I like it. You musical way is beautiful!
To be honest, I hardly ever used to make instrumental tracks.
@@4everfreebrony I mean, in your early songs, the emphasis was on the musical component, and with your voice you kind of accompanied the music. In the same emerald eyes, for example. it felt like you were afraid to reveal your voice to the fullest!
@@darkmaster6817 In truth, I just didn't have much practice or training, and I wasn't that good.
Already knew all of these Songs as I bought the album and from all of them thats my second favorite. Yet hits right into the feels on place one🔥
My goodness this song is absolutely amazing!
Just great
Ah the beginning quotes reminds me "it's easier to forgive an enemy than a brother!" - some warhammer 40k general
So beautiful. I got chills and tears down my cheeks listening the heartache.
This cover is an absolute banger, of an already absolute banger
Great song. For some reason, the tune reminds me of Carnival of Rust by Poets of the Fall.
I decided to pop in to the comments just to see what people thought of the cover, this one caught my eye cuz yea - I had just heard Carnival of Rust for the first time when recording this song - though in all the years it's been out you're the second one to make the comparison - cheers 😊
4ever, would this type of gorgeous song be considered a ballad? Just was curious abt it, because ballads are way more emotional, like this one right?
Yeah, this is a metal ballad.
Thanks ^^
Little sneaky lyrics trying to hide from me but i see yall when i pull the video down
I'm so glad we're getting amazing artist from the fandom that are still doing pony music to these days, your stuff never fails to make me feel a lot of stuff and emotions, I was having a hard day but this made my day better, what a beautiful piece you never disappoint ❤️
Thank you for this wonderful song! I've been watching your channel since 2014, and your skill never fades. Good luck in creating new songs!
Masterpiece this is trully masterpiece
I hope someone makes an animation for this song. Because I can see it turning down right beautiful just from the lyrics
Incredible cover and amazing song! No words to describe how good you guys are.
This one is quickly becoming my favorite
Love this song can't get enough of it
Hot DAMN 3:03, I was not expecting that but it's BEAUTIFUL
Omg coming back to listen later. I'm guessing what this song will be about, and if I'm right, I will probably cry. This will be an emotional battle for tomorrow lol
As always, just loving it
One of my fav brony ballads! Glad you made a cover
A very beautiful song, for one of the most beautiful back stories in equestrian lore.
That’s awesome song!
Beuatiful cover. And a good song in general.
Good times.
This is absolutely beautiful and sad..
These remake covers are amazing :D
Holy fuck, I am a massive fan of the first one, to see you cover this is a dream come true
Everytime I listen to this song, it reminds me of big rock classics like from Pink Floyd or Dire Straits! 💜
Thank you for being awesome all this time! You're a big star for me 4efB /)☆(\
I'm an ex brony but I still love listening to the mlp songs over the year's, glad your still making music bro hoof /)
Absolutely beautiful 😌
Beautifull work.
Phenomenal...
Excellent ❤
Wow ok I'm surprised when I saw that this is new. Epic. Also been here from season one.
Amazing
incredible
I love Cyril's original works but I always felt he was too attached to pushing the higher pitches. His songs started sounding all the same after a while (kind of like Aviators). His softer songs always hit better for me. Overall this is a great cover.
Nice!
Lovely!
that solo hits so fucking hard. holy Shit
im a brony, but this song tear me up as a men. And thats everything i wanna say.
Only thing missing is the super shrill scream at the end
Another upload so soon!
Wow cool Music
i'mm nooo crying
Powerful
Dang that was great.
Amazing job ❤
Amazing and terrifying.
Gives twice as bright some more perspective.
I miss you going live on RUclips. I hope you are doing well though ❤️
Happy 12th birthday MLP:FiM! Brohoof /)
Spotify soon? 👀👀
hmmmm
Comment for algorithm
Didn't even listen to it and I already liked it. I just know it'll be amazing and very moving!
Dont we all? :P
Мне или кажется или это песня заделана по мотивам песни "Это все мое родное"?
до середины было бомбически но электрогитара и барабаны все испортили
зачем их только добавили одной пианино было достаточно
5 из 10
Душевая композиция. Спасибо.