Is Archbishop Vigano a Sedevacantist?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 окт 2024
  • From our full Weekly News Roundup: ruclips.net/user/li...
    Brian McCall and Murray Rundus discuss Archbishop Vigano's statement, analyzing some of the arguments involved.
    Full statement: catholicfamily...
    Subscribe to our paper! catholicfamily...
    Remember to support CFN by purchasing books from:
    • Angelico Press: angelicopress....
    • Sophia Institute Press: sophiainstitut...
    • TAN Books: tanbooks.com/?...
    Follow us on Rumble! rumble.com/c/c...
    #catholic #traditionalcatholic #vigano

Комментарии • 38

  • @CFN_Official
    @CFN_Official  3 месяца назад +4

    Do you think Archbishop Vigano might have gone too far? Do you think he went far enough?

    • @carolynkimberly4021
      @carolynkimberly4021 3 месяца назад +16

      Vigano is just right

    • @ciaran6171
      @ciaran6171 3 месяца назад +6

      The Archbishop has stepped forward to take on the champion of the Philistines. Why ask has he gone too far?

    • @johnchristiancanda3320
      @johnchristiancanda3320 3 месяца назад +4

      No, he didn't. Archbishop Viganò is just telling the plain truth that Jorge Mario Bergoglio was not, is not and will never be a valid pope. For the Archbishop to be a sedevacantist, he must consider John XXIII, Paul VI, John Paul I, John Paul II and Benedict XVI to be invalid popes.

    • @Mutasis_Mutandis
      @Mutasis_Mutandis 3 месяца назад +1

      Thank the Lord for Abp Vigano. ❤. We need more strong faithful men to step up as he has.

    • @crusader333ad
      @crusader333ad 3 месяца назад +1

      If vigano can corroborate the seminarian’s accusation that bergoglio abused him, game over.

  • @CatsHeartbeat
    @CatsHeartbeat 3 месяца назад +15

    "I am happy to repeat to you the same thing: if one day I taught you something contrary to what all the Tradition of the Church has taught us, do not listen to me. At that moment, you will have the right and even the duty not to obey me because at that point I am not being faithful to the mission God gave me." ~ Archbishop Lefebvre

  • @anng.4542
    @anng.4542 3 месяца назад +8

    Pray for our dear Archbishop!

  • @misss.o.j.
    @misss.o.j. 3 месяца назад +7

    Fence-sitting is lukewarmness. Sedevacantists and Sedeprivationists are not in schism but they do force the question which rocks the boat and makes life difficult.

  • @DrJonathanGemmill
    @DrJonathanGemmill 3 месяца назад +8

    Vigano may have gone too far, but I completely sympathise with his words and position - God bless him 🙏.
    Great show gentlemen - thank you 🔥👏 😎.
    God bless, Ave Maria 🙏⛪⚓👑.

  • @ccl754
    @ccl754 3 месяца назад +1

    I think you both very fair to ABP Vigano. You're right, we need to be patient to find out how this pans out. We are living in a time of extreme contradiction and confusion. Give it up to God. Meanwhile, do not judge ABP Vigano. 🙏

  • @mylipsread
    @mylipsread 3 месяца назад +3

    Pope had abandoned the papacy with proof of him redefining the papal office to be the president presider of world council of churches.

  • @sueadauctus3306
    @sueadauctus3306 3 месяца назад +2

    More men need to go too far, as you put it. How would Jesus regard pachamama episode? He forbid even any vessel to be carried through His Father's house. Mark 11:16, and that pagan thing was permitted during Mass. Vigano! Sede ok for me.

  • @silentium9639
    @silentium9639 3 месяца назад

    But the validity of a papal conclave is an act of administration. So cum ex apostolatum officio can’t be infallible on that point. The rules of the conclave have been changed by several subsequent popes.

  • @rosemarieloncaric-spataro2861
    @rosemarieloncaric-spataro2861 3 месяца назад

    Could this declaration be what was deposited at the tribunal in his defence and response? How does St John Paul 2 rules tabled for future conclaves align?

  • @Mokinono45
    @Mokinono45 3 месяца назад

    Yay Sedevacantism! Better than sifting the pope!

  • @lauraanderson7358
    @lauraanderson7358 3 месяца назад +3

    vigano is protest ant

    • @KGraceSpeaksKea1335
      @KGraceSpeaksKea1335 3 месяца назад +4

      Why?

    • @edukaeshn
      @edukaeshn 3 месяца назад

      You realize protestants don't recognize the papacy at all? Viganò acknowledges papal supremacy but thinks the election could not have been valid: similar to annulment concerning marriage.

    • @lauraanderson7358
      @lauraanderson7358 3 месяца назад

      @@KGraceSpeaksKea1335 rejects the pope

    • @brianbacon5149
      @brianbacon5149 3 месяца назад

      12:34 ​​@@lauraanderson7358+JMJ Vigano is a Successor to the Apostles who deserves respect. He loves the Chair of Peter which he has served his whole life. Don't confuse that with the matter of Bergoglio's highly questionable actions. I would like disinterested bishops to examine the record to resolve the question whether Bergoglio has the requisite Catholic faith and consented to assumption to the papacy. There is plenty of probable cause for the bishops to take action. This is what Vigano is asking for.

    • @brianbacon5149
      @brianbacon5149 3 месяца назад

      ​@@lauraanderson735812:34 ​​@lauraanderson7358 +JMJ Vigano is a Successor to the Apostles who deserves respect. He loves the Chair of Peter which he has served his whole life. Don't confuse that with the matter of Bergoglio's highly questionable actions. I would like disinterested bishops to examine the record to resolve the question whether Bergoglio has the requisite Catholic faith and consented to assumption to the papacy. There is plenty of probable cause for the bishops to take action. This is what Vigano is asking for.