Sheikh Uthman did a refutation on Zakir Naik's video (twice) about how the hadith he uses are fabricated or weak in other ways and how using Ibn Taymiyyah's opinion on this is incorrect because even he has said separately that masturbation is haraam and does not endorse the view Zakir Naik says he does.
Assalaamu alaykum. Please brother change your comment about Shaykh Uthman's video being a "refutation" because this can be a cause for unnecessary fitnah . Shaykh Uthman made it clear that his video was naseeha (advice) to his brother in Islam and "not a refutation"
@@deultimatum8937 every imam have made mistakes. We can't follow any imam if it goes against the teaching of islam. We see clear proof from Qur'an and sunnah in this matter. Even Zakir naik makes mistakes. And this is one of the mistake. But this doesn't mean we have to stop listening him altogether. He is very beneficial to the ummah. Done a great job in debating other religions.
Thanks Wael Ibrahim :D, you have more experience in this field. You continue to help us with this kind of problem. and you have more experience in this field. May Allah help you to spread this message to more people.
Masturbation is totally haram. Its totally forbidden in islam. Watch out the video of mufti uthman. He has explained it very well. Go to masjid ribat youtube channel
On an unrelated topic, really hope people respect each other's opinions. In my experience, I see people replying "Be my guest to walk on the path to hell". Wtf? Sounding right doesn't make it okay to sound rude. (Not referring to this video, this video nice 👍)
Salaam Sheikh Wael Ibrahim, I really appreciate your facts to clear the short-term and long-term adverse effects of that activity on the generation. MashAllah! I am hundred percentage agreed with you not only as a health professional working in Australia but also being a parent of 4 children. Alhamdulillah! It’s a very effective message given by you. May Allah make you successful here and hereafter. Jazakallah Khair
@@fayahunter4273 exactly bro the hadith is weak. Masturbation is totally haram. Its totally forbidden in islam. Watch out the video of mufti uthman. He has explained it very well. Go to masjid ribat youtube channel
Masturbation is totally haram. Its totally forbidden in islam. Watch out the video of mufti uthman. He has explained it very well. Go to masjid ribat youtube channel
Thank you so much brother !! While I completely agree on your views..... Can you please help with some practical tips as you suggested in one of your videos to help people understand better on this subject
Working on a series titled: PornDemic - with a solution in mind - where I'll be talking about practical tips to help people control and break the cycle of their addiction.
Bro Wael, to be fair, Dr Yasir Qadhi did qualify strongly @13:30 of his video that it should not be said that masturbation is halal. It is about understanding all the hukums at different contexts and applying it appropriately. In fact at @11:47 he made a strong dissociation betwen these hukums and the question of pornography. On the whole, Bro, I agree with your position. Namely, you have suggested a different angle to look at this issue. Indeed, I think as a community, we are too dependent on fiqihi rulings to guide our actions. You have essentially presented an akhlaqi angle, i.e. looking at it from the effect of masturbation on our nafs. There should be more of such thinking. My only regret is that you have projected a sense of disquiet towards Dr Yasir's video. He is a faqih. We are counselors. He cannot handle sexual issues like the way we do. However, I thought his fiqihi-centric angle supports rather than contradicts our effort at discouraging masturbation. I don't mean to discredit your video. Just hoping that you had presented a more unified view between the fiqihi and akhlaqi angles.
Its completely haram, marry if you can, if you cant fast. But its very tough to fast every day poor Men also have need desires its very tough to fast every day and stay away from women what to do there must be more to it
You mentioned four generation but there are only three generation of Sahaba, one those lived are companion (1st gen), Tabien (2nd gen), Tatabien (3rd gen), where is 4th gen?
Masturbation is totally haram. Its totally forbidden in islam. Watch out the video of mufti uthman. He has explained it very well. Go to masjid ribat youtube channel
If we know any act Haram that doesn't mean we quit that act. If Dr. Zakir Naik say (Knowledgeable and authentic Islamic scholars view) Mukrooh what's the problem? Whose scholars say Masturbation mukrooh they are knowledgeable and authentic great Islamic scholars.
Hmm,I wonder dr.naik said so..long time researched about that topic..I will not say that aya bcs don't know how exactly to translate but what I understood maturation is haram.( they refer to this aya) also, once i heard if u don't know if sth is haram or halal,imagine prophet a.s. doing this...subhanallah.just cannot. So.. my thoughts are..what would he do in this case...have sabr, and pray to Allah to give him a good spouse.. And He knows best! Also if u feel in your heart something is wrong,it is subhanallah! May Allah bless us all
Assalamu-alykoom I also believe no one is perfect and everyone makes mistakes (even you and me = we are not perfect)... Before jumping to conclusion and labeling any Muslim as Murtad or Kafir or questioning their Aqeedah etc... we must grant them a Q&A opportunity to correct their mistakes, absolve themselves of any wrong doing... so they can clarify their position in accordance with the Qur'an and authentic Sunnah of Rasulullah saws... it's only when this process has been properly exhausted and evaluated that judgment can then be passed on their status... this is my humble view... yes I am just a very simple student on the path of learning our beautiful and magnificent Islam, Alhamdulillah. In my humble view, we need to keep the Ummah and our Ulama united and stop fragmentation of the Ummah because of some human errors or unintended mistakes etc because we all make mistakes and Allah Ta'ala knows best and HE alone is the ultimate Judge of our intentions and actions, Alhamdulillah. Wallahi unity is our absolute key to success and prosperity, thus, if this Ummah needs and wants to succeed = we must remain united on all fronts, In'Sha'Allah. I recall you were very compassionate and lenient with several scholars who made grave mistakes in their utterances and/or publications etc... you gave them the opportunity of Q&A and followed the above referred processes in an amicable manner... has your office or any renowned Muslim scholars organization accorded the highly demanded and required Q&A opportunity to Yasir Qadhi, Omar Suleiman, Mufti Menk, Nouman Ali Khan and other Western based students or scholars with whom you seem to have fundamental differences in Qur'an and/or authentic Sunnah? In my humble view, it's only when the fore-indicated process has been done compassionately, with leniency and degree of tolerance that conclusions can be drawn... I hope you and the respected all our respected and highly regarded Muslim scholars will do the right thing and keep the Ulama & the Ummah united, In'Sha'Allah. For starters I strongly recommend and urge you to carefully listen to this one hour long Q&A about Yasir Qadhi on RUclips per the link shared below. ruclips.net/video/ToYSR6FA4fc/видео.html JazaqAllahu Khayran
By the way no one called anyone a kafir here of by any other name he is only giving the general adversities In this whole thing not only considering the fiqh point of view but also from the medical and empirical point of view
Shaikh I am neither sheikh nor aalim but in my humble opinion masturbation or any other sexualized misconduct is forbidden. Many aalim think by fasting is meant literally to fast but that is incorrect.By fasting is meant sexual fasting until god opens a way. Means to refrain from all sexual misconduct and that includes masturbation, prostitutes and zana and sodomy.
How did you know it haram till did not write in hadith or Qur'an ??that period people are did not had awareness for porography who could it bcame sin ?? Not only masturbation became adaction also married man became addacted ( maniac)with his wife ,than what is your answer ? spiritual did not solve this kind problems ,how can science solve it?
Masturbation is totally haram. Its totally forbidden in islam. Watch out the video of mufti uthman. He has explained it very well. Go to masjid ribat youtube channel
This one diskas hindi so andrea diat from mamuke connecting pram di swine open money from mama muhammad muhammad meaning rehat this one in destination juice kurang doktor sagri riyadhin juice
Masturbation is totally haram. Its totally forbidden in islam. Watch out the video of mufti uthman. He has explained it very well. Go to masjid ribat youtube channel
Dr. Zakir Naik and Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem are knowledgeable and authentic Islamic Dayee. And Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem not make video to reply Dr Zakir Naik's video because He (Assim Al Hakeem) are knowledgeable and authentic Dayee. Dr Zakir Naik and Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem are my ideal Islamic Dayee. May Allah bless and protect both
This one i finish question doctor saksi when you going to masjid youtuber from allah subhanahu wa ta'ala 2 aprom allah subhanahu wa ta'ala fokus river connecting seks something connecting all islam business money haram okey kanada movie rishon diaan senimani diswano a8 haram memang ni okey from alkohol this makro this one understand this one to obat from allah subhanahu wa ta'ala itu masjid insya-allah. Something no going to pc sex
I finished by special to ulama di swamping perobuktor saksi edision doktor sakrino fokus ini islam poket malaysia because something beautiful my husband because understand dosa dosa from allah subhanahu wa taala nuh diampun allah subhanahu wa beautiful this one is 10 khutbah nikah khutbah nikah vokasion islam
Di suara understand airgun ke hairan di suara distance of sapio chai from a ran this one i in side seminar from president understanding untuk haram peram i haram no a timbul benggo dicaprio eat haram number one disuwananda islam
Salam brother Please this a very simple thing The views of those scholars before do not apply to some people 1/ watching pornography we all know isn’t allowed in Islam so those people watching pornography and masturbating along that totally haram Please do not mix those one with brothers and sisters that really in serious condition and that to save their family or many other things 2/ masturbation is only allowed for people in a condition that if they don’t it may be dragged them to sina or something else Exemple there are many husbands working or doing things very important very fare away form their wives and family and some how they have to satisfy them self or their wives to Masturbation may be a possibility for them for protection please. So all those youngsters doing it for their fantasy are not people those schoolers talking about. Better put everything in the correct context please Thanks
Well said. "Guilt is a driving force that pushes sinful people into repentance"
your clarification is really clear. i was thinking the same thing. zazakallhu khairan brother
If Jeff Bezos ever converts to Islam and joins the Tablighi Jamaat, this is exactly what he would look like.
Bro is associated with tabhleeg jamaat really ?
What did you mean by this
😂
Sheikh Uthman did a refutation on Zakir Naik's video (twice) about how the hadith he uses are fabricated or weak in other ways and how using Ibn Taymiyyah's opinion on this is incorrect because even he has said separately that masturbation is haraam and does not endorse the view Zakir Naik says he does.
Assalaamu alaykum. Please brother change your comment about Shaykh Uthman's video being a "refutation" because this can be a cause for unnecessary fitnah . Shaykh Uthman made it clear that his video was naseeha (advice) to his brother in Islam and "not a refutation"
to add to dr zakir naik, according to imam hanbal teaching masturbation is makrooh
@@deultimatum8937 every imam have made mistakes. We can't follow any imam if it goes against the teaching of islam. We see clear proof from Qur'an and sunnah in this matter. Even Zakir naik makes mistakes. And this is one of the mistake. But this doesn't mean we have to stop listening him altogether. He is very beneficial to the ummah. Done a great job in debating other religions.
May Allah Azza wajal reward you sheikh wael for your clarification.
Thanks Wael Ibrahim :D, you have more experience in this field. You continue to help us with this kind of problem. and you have more experience in this field. May Allah help you to spread this message to more people.
Well done,well said. brother may allah reward you.ameen
They've said weak hadith about masterbation . Plx watch this video.ruclips.net/video/BQQR-GkqECo/видео.html
My THOUGHTS if it effects your life in a negative way its not good.
Islam is not about "My Thoughts", it's about what is from Allah and Sunnah of prophet S. A. W, May Allah always be with you.
Masturbation is totally haram. Its totally forbidden in islam. Watch out the video of mufti uthman. He has explained it very well. Go to masjid ribat youtube channel
Great way of thinking ❤
Very beautifully explained.
On an unrelated topic, really hope people respect each other's opinions. In my experience, I see people replying "Be my guest to walk on the path to hell". Wtf? Sounding right doesn't make it okay to sound rude. (Not referring to this video, this video nice 👍)
Salaam Sheikh Wael Ibrahim, I really appreciate your facts to clear the short-term and long-term adverse effects of that activity on the generation. MashAllah! I am hundred percentage agreed with you not only as a health professional working in Australia but also being a parent of 4 children. Alhamdulillah! It’s a very effective message given by you. May Allah make you successful here and hereafter. Jazakallah Khair
Great explanation ever!
Assalamualaikum. They have taken weak hadith about masterbation. Plx watch this video. ruclips.net/video/BQQR-GkqECo/видео.html
@@fayahunter4273 exactly bro the hadith is weak. Masturbation is totally haram. Its totally forbidden in islam. Watch out the video of mufti uthman. He has explained it very well. Go to masjid ribat youtube channel
They made it clear looking at porno and masturbation is wrong
i do agree with you sheikh may allah protect you
Jazakallah khairon.
Masha Allah good information
JazakAllah very informative ,
God bless you man
sheikh you always tell us to seek professional help but how i dont know any counsellors please guide me.
Jazakum Allah khayran
Masturbation is totally haram. Its totally forbidden in islam. Watch out the video of mufti uthman. He has explained it very well. Go to masjid ribat youtube channel
Can you separate between women and men please?
Women were not mentioned in the ayah…
Thank you so much brother !! While I completely agree on your views..... Can you please help with some practical tips as you suggested in one of your videos to help people understand better on this subject
Working on a series titled: PornDemic - with a solution in mind - where I'll be talking about practical tips to help people control and break the cycle of their addiction.
Bro Wael, to be fair, Dr Yasir Qadhi did qualify strongly @13:30 of his video that it should not be said that masturbation is halal. It is about understanding all the hukums at different contexts and applying it appropriately. In fact at @11:47 he made a strong dissociation betwen these hukums and the question of pornography.
On the whole, Bro, I agree with your position. Namely, you have suggested a different angle to look at this issue. Indeed, I think as a community, we are too dependent on fiqihi rulings to guide our actions. You have essentially presented an akhlaqi angle, i.e. looking at it from the effect of masturbation on our nafs. There should be more of such thinking.
My only regret is that you have projected a sense of disquiet towards Dr Yasir's video. He is a faqih. We are counselors. He cannot handle sexual issues like the way we do. However, I thought his fiqihi-centric angle supports rather than contradicts our effort at discouraging masturbation. I don't mean to discredit your video. Just hoping that you had presented a more unified view between the fiqihi and akhlaqi angles.
I want to get treatment for genital warts but I am in Nigeria
Kalimat usaha dan connecting perang perubatan desember ke sini islam kalimah tu syahadata shadow lailahaillallah wasallam
Its completely haram, marry if you can, if you cant fast. But its very tough to fast every day poor Men also have need desires its very tough to fast every day and stay away from women what to do there must be more to it
Brother did the prophet saw give a thirth option? Who are you to give fatwa against the saying of the rassuk alayhi salam!
You mentioned four generation but there are only three generation of Sahaba, one those lived are companion (1st gen), Tabien (2nd gen), Tatabien (3rd gen), where is 4th gen?
Masturbation is totally haram. Its totally forbidden in islam. Watch out the video of mufti uthman. He has explained it very well. Go to masjid ribat youtube channel
Walaikum Assalam warohmantullahi wabarokatuhu
If we know any act Haram that doesn't mean we quit that act. If Dr. Zakir Naik say (Knowledgeable and authentic Islamic scholars view) Mukrooh what's the problem? Whose scholars say Masturbation mukrooh they are knowledgeable and authentic great Islamic scholars.
There is difference of opinion on this issue
Shaykh Uthman Ibn Farooq has a good video on this topic.
Shaikh tell people about nofap..it helps the young people alot.
Hmm,I wonder dr.naik said so..long time researched about that topic..I will not say that aya bcs don't know how exactly to translate but what I understood maturation is haram.( they refer to this aya)
also, once i heard if u don't know if sth is haram or halal,imagine prophet a.s. doing this...subhanallah.just cannot. So.. my thoughts are..what would he do in this case...have sabr, and pray to Allah to give him a good spouse..
And He knows best!
Also if u feel in your heart something is wrong,it is subhanallah! May Allah bless us all
Zakir naik wants to say that if you avoid from masterbation it is best please dont take of this negatively❤❤❤❤❤
Assalamu-alykoom
I also believe no one is perfect and everyone makes mistakes (even you and me = we are not perfect)...
Before jumping to conclusion and labeling any Muslim as Murtad or Kafir or questioning their Aqeedah etc... we must grant them a Q&A opportunity to correct their mistakes, absolve themselves of any wrong doing... so they can clarify their position in accordance with the Qur'an and authentic Sunnah of Rasulullah saws... it's only when this process has been properly exhausted and evaluated that judgment can then be passed on their status... this is my humble view... yes I am just a very simple student on the path of learning our beautiful and magnificent Islam, Alhamdulillah.
In my humble view, we need to keep the Ummah and our Ulama united and stop fragmentation of the Ummah because of some human errors or unintended mistakes etc because we all make mistakes and Allah Ta'ala knows best and HE alone is the ultimate Judge of our intentions and actions, Alhamdulillah.
Wallahi unity is our absolute key to success and prosperity, thus, if this Ummah needs and wants to succeed = we must remain united on all fronts, In'Sha'Allah.
I recall you were very compassionate and lenient with several scholars who made grave mistakes in their utterances and/or publications etc... you gave them the opportunity of Q&A and followed the above referred processes in an amicable manner... has your office or any renowned Muslim scholars organization accorded the highly demanded and required Q&A opportunity to Yasir Qadhi, Omar Suleiman, Mufti Menk, Nouman Ali Khan and other Western based students or scholars with whom you seem to have fundamental differences in Qur'an and/or authentic Sunnah? In my humble view, it's only when the fore-indicated process has been done compassionately, with leniency and degree of tolerance that conclusions can be drawn... I hope you and the respected all our respected and highly regarded Muslim scholars will do the right thing and keep the Ulama & the Ummah united, In'Sha'Allah.
For starters I strongly recommend and urge you to carefully listen to this one hour long Q&A about Yasir Qadhi on RUclips per the link shared below.
ruclips.net/video/ToYSR6FA4fc/видео.html
JazaqAllahu Khayran
Sure, but shouldn't we work hard to eliminate these errors from our lives and live up to the expectations revealed by Allah SWT?
By the way no one called anyone a kafir here of by any other name he is only giving the general adversities In this whole thing not only considering the fiqh point of view but also from the medical and empirical point of view
Shud hilite wife cannot entertaining husband due to health reason and husband financially not afford to have second wife...
Shaikh I am neither sheikh nor aalim but in my humble opinion masturbation or any other sexualized misconduct is forbidden. Many aalim think by fasting is meant literally to fast but that is incorrect.By fasting is meant sexual fasting until god opens a way. Means to refrain from all sexual misconduct and that includes masturbation, prostitutes and zana and sodomy.
How did you know it haram till did not write in hadith or Qur'an ??that period people are did not had awareness for porography who could it bcame sin ?? Not only masturbation became adaction also married man became addacted ( maniac)with his wife ,than what is your answer ? spiritual did not solve this kind problems ,how can science solve it?
Sir even in person in fast sexualities thought come....what is ur opinion on that
Make new habits. Read quran translation, Watch motivational videos etc. Make new habits to make your old habits become weak.
If you are using instagram check my page tutor_nabeel. I expose harms of porn content.
I respect sheikh wael ibrahim 😊 he is also good in this field
@@Sir_Nabeel_Abdul_Raheem still it may come.. very less but comes ...tat urges will burst after sometime
@@Sir_Nabeel_Abdul_Raheem even though I too have huge respect for him ...being at tat level is Not easy
Masturbation is totally haram. Its totally forbidden in islam. Watch out the video of mufti uthman. He has explained it very well. Go to masjid ribat youtube channel
This one diskas hindi so andrea diat from mamuke connecting pram di swine open money from mama muhammad muhammad meaning rehat this one in destination juice kurang doktor sagri riyadhin juice
Haram or not? I need yes or no answer only ✌️👍
Please 🥺🥺🥺🥺🙏🤣
Haraam
No if your wife is around, Yes if you are far away from your wife
@@muhammadaidid9771 my wife is far away, and I have a high sexual desires?
Bro semen is meant to be released holding it inside for a longtime what it will do just try it very painful
we should stay away from fornication and masturbating is getting close to fornication.
Masturbation is totally haram. Its totally forbidden in islam. Watch out the video of mufti uthman. He has explained it very well. Go to masjid ribat youtube channel
Dr. Zakir Naik and Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem are knowledgeable and authentic Islamic Dayee. And Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem not make video to reply Dr Zakir Naik's video because He (Assim Al Hakeem) are knowledgeable and authentic Dayee. Dr Zakir Naik and Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem are my ideal Islamic Dayee. May Allah bless and protect both
He did respond to Dr Zakir Naik fatwa
The title of this video is textbait
This one i finish question doctor saksi when you going to masjid youtuber from allah subhanahu wa ta'ala 2 aprom allah subhanahu wa ta'ala fokus river connecting seks something connecting all islam business money haram okey kanada movie rishon diaan senimani diswano a8 haram memang ni okey from alkohol this makro this one understand this one to obat from allah subhanahu wa ta'ala itu masjid insya-allah. Something no going to pc sex
why i stop ? till i love it and you said before it is not sin.
I finished by special to ulama di swamping perobuktor saksi edision doktor sakrino fokus ini islam poket malaysia because something beautiful my husband because understand dosa dosa from allah subhanahu wa taala nuh diampun allah subhanahu wa beautiful this one is 10 khutbah nikah khutbah nikah vokasion islam
Di suara understand airgun ke hairan di suara distance of sapio chai from a ran this one i in side seminar from president understanding untuk haram peram i haram no a timbul benggo dicaprio eat haram number one disuwananda islam
Am sure you got a wife? So don,t play the holy guy😂 relax eveybody got some love❤ to get inshallah we will taste😊
i am from kashmir
always related to sex...no wonder...
😢😢👍❤
Salam brother
Please this a very simple thing
The views of those scholars before do not apply to some people
1/ watching pornography we all know isn’t allowed in Islam so those people watching pornography and masturbating along that totally haram
Please do not mix those one with brothers and sisters that really in serious condition and that to save their family or many other things
2/ masturbation is only allowed for people in a condition that if they don’t it may be dragged them to sina or something else
Exemple there are many husbands working or doing things very important very fare away form their wives and family and some how they have to satisfy them self or their wives to
Masturbation may be a possibility for them for protection please.
So all those youngsters doing it for their fantasy are not people those schoolers talking about.
Better put everything in the correct context please
Thanks
Sorry you make no sense please revisit your analysis
Is it allowed if one's wife give hand job to the husband and vice versa
Yes