The author brings his own style to the writing, but is true to the characters of Goodwin and Wolf. The music was a bit loud, but the narrator was excellent; his characterizations were very well done. Thank you for this.
Excellent reading! The different voices brings each character to life. I love the music, but I have to agree with a previous comment that it is a little too loud and makes listening to the narrative slightly challenging. Even still, it was very enjoyable overall! I'll share this one with friends!! And, I'm looking forward to exploring your channel for more wonderful stories. Thanks for publishing this one!😍
I've read every single book and short story Stout ever published and some of his unpublished bits. I must say Goldsborough does an excellent job! He's one of the best I've read at getting the rhythm, timing of the Stout stories/characters. It's nearly impossible for an author to pick up a character series (i.e. Philip Marlowe, Sherlock Holmes,...etc...) after the originator has passed, yet it's nice to have some new stories.
As a former “executive pastor” of a large, ambitious independent church on Staten Island (1980s), this was a fun surprise. It was fascinating to see what the author nailed and what he got wrong about the setting (most egregiously, protestant pastors are never addressed as “Father”). A fun story and expertly read. Yes the music is too loud but otherwise very appropriate and not terribly long
In the last 24 hours I have listened to 4 of Robert Goldsburough’s Nero Wolf novels. That in itself should be evidence enough of what I think of this author’s attempt to recreate the indomitable Nero Wolf of Rex Stout. No one can replace Mr. Stout’s original characters & plots but after reading & rereading his beloved stories, Mr. Goldsburough has created an excellent facsimile in his Nero Wolf. Many Thanks to him for doing so. All I ask is that he take good care of himself so he can keep writing more stories for a long time.
Having read most of the books and watched the tv adaptations over the years, I think the script was about as good as anyone, barring Rex, could have done. Congratulations! The narration was also very good, bearing in mind all the voices were done by one actor. The music, as is often the case on these productions, was somewhat obtrusive but I've heard worse. I guess some folk object to efforts like this on principle.
I am only at 2:41 and consider the opening paragraphs lost to mankind. There is no music but plenty of suspense and trepidation that it may, without rhyme or reason, insert itself again. My opinion: this is not an artful way to add suspense to a text--surely that is the responsibility of the author. 🤨🥸🥸
I like this yarn, quite a bit. I, however, question the means and ease with which the characters traveled to and from Staten Island and Manhattan and especially the use of cars so to do. I grew up on the Island and know how long these jaunts take. Though, a trip to Saint George is, I admit, less onerous than one to Tottenville, where my people lived for about two hundred years.
Good music but Nero's voice has to grab everyone's attention always. It must be unique along side his mythological like reputation. I love the old time radio shows. I do feel this version has music I really like along with its placement. Archie's voice actor fits just not as Nero.
As much as I enjoyed this it just occurred to me How come a paraffin test was not done ? Guess that would have scotched about 4 hrs of audio. Still thanks muchly ❤
Why do people think they can enhance a clear good voice. Audio means not seeing anything. We only have the audio so when additional noise alongside it makes a situation arise where we are listening to the pointless music not the voice. Fluff freeman used to turn down rather skilfully,the pop tune as he spoke then back up.sadly that skill seems lost.
20 minutes in and not continuing. Author has caught the personalities but bring Nero Wolfe ahead to the present ruins it for me. Additionally the bad music over the narration makes listening too hard. Maybe I'll check to see jf original books are on audio. Read them years ago. Also thoroughly enjoyed Timothy Hutton's productioon for tv.
@@mwatts-riley2688Thank you for your critique, perhaps you should have read my comment more carefully. My comment clearly stated that I appreciate the author did a good job writing and they clearly studied the characters. I have a real love for the time period that Rex Stout wrote about, perhaps because my parents lived at that time. If others enjoy the new setting in a more modern time, that's wonderful and a whole new group getting to meet the fascinating people portrayed therein. To address your question of my writing a follow up book, I wouldn't even try! My talents lie in other areas, where they bring joy to me and others.😊
How did YOUR writing and reading, go? When you wrote further Nero books, as per permission of Marsh 's wife, how did YOUR BOOKS take on? When you hired a narrator, did you pay in cash or credit? Hmmm. Oh wait...
They found Fred's .38 and 2 shell casings on the floor. THAT'S IT. STUPID-STUPID. Why write about something you obviously don't know the first thing about
Good point! Can’t recall if it is described as a .38 pistol or automatic - you might possibly find shell casings discharged from an automatic but not otherwise. In the end it didn’t matter b’cos the murderer made sure not to leave prints and the shells were immaterial.
![[#2024MAMA] ROSÉ (로제), Bruno Mars - APT. | Mnet 241122 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dgGqD28J6aQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Well done!! Grateful for the respectful handling of the religious aspect of the story.
I've read a ton of Nero Wolfe novels , a few Goldsbrough. All is good ,,,except the ill executed music over
What a treat this was!!! It was a Nero Wolfe new to me. Thank you SO very much!
This is a fake imitation. Not written by Rex Stout.
@@heenanyou thank you for the information. Have a great day!
The author brings his own style to the writing, but is true to the characters of Goodwin and Wolf. The music was a bit loud, but the narrator was excellent; his characterizations were very well done. Thank you for this.
I really enjoyed this mystery. I love the readers voice and reading style. Excellent styling Thank you
Brilliant,so well read by Michael Murphy.
Thank you, I enjoyed listening.
Excellent reading! The different voices brings each character to life. I love the music, but I have to agree with a previous comment that it is a little too loud and makes listening to the narrative slightly challenging. Even still, it was very enjoyable overall! I'll share this one with friends!! And, I'm looking forward to exploring your channel for more wonderful stories. Thanks for publishing this one!😍
I've read every single book and short story Stout ever published and some of his unpublished bits. I must say Goldsborough does an excellent job! He's one of the best I've read at getting the rhythm, timing of the Stout stories/characters. It's nearly impossible for an author to pick up a character series (i.e. Philip Marlowe, Sherlock Holmes,...etc...) after the originator has passed, yet it's nice to have some new stories.
As a former “executive pastor” of a large, ambitious independent church on Staten Island (1980s), this was a fun surprise. It was fascinating to see what the author nailed and what he got wrong about the setting (most egregiously, protestant pastors are never addressed as “Father”). A fun story and expertly read. Yes the music is too loud but otherwise very appropriate and not terribly long
In the last 24 hours I have listened to 4 of Robert Goldsburough’s Nero Wolf novels. That in itself should be evidence enough of what I think of this author’s attempt to recreate the indomitable Nero Wolf of Rex Stout. No one can replace Mr. Stout’s original characters & plots but after reading & rereading his beloved stories, Mr. Goldsburough has created an excellent facsimile in his Nero Wolf. Many Thanks to him for doing so. All I ask is that he take good care of himself so he can keep writing more stories for a long time.
Wow! What an unexpected treat❤❤ty
Having read most of the books and watched the tv adaptations over the years, I think the script was about as good as anyone, barring Rex, could have done. Congratulations!
The narration was also very good, bearing in mind all the voices were done by one actor.
The music, as is often the case on these productions, was somewhat obtrusive but I've heard worse.
I guess some folk object to efforts like this on principle.
I enjoyed by this reading very much❣️
👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽What a treat ❤ thank you 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏💕
Not Rex Stout, but a good story nonetheless! Well read as well! Thanks!
I also had a bit of a problem adjusting to a more current day Nero Wolf but I’m glad I hung in because I found this to be an enjoyable read
Thanks so much for this! Saul Rubinek recorded a number of abridged Nero Wolfes. If you have any of them, I'd love to hear them.
Wonderful book. I very much enjoyed spending an evening with Mr. Wolf and Archie.
I am thrilled to find this! Ty🎉🎉🎉
Can't hear the reading thru the music at beginning
Thank you very enjoyable ❤
Can the music be removed??
I am only at 2:41 and consider the opening paragraphs lost to mankind. There is no music but plenty of suspense and trepidation that it may, without rhyme or reason, insert itself again. My opinion: this is not an artful way to add suspense to a text--surely that is the responsibility of the author. 🤨🥸🥸
Funny how long bad music seems to last when you don't want to listen.
I really enjoyed 😅.
Music. Too. Loud. Too. Long. Book. Is. Pretty. Good. Thanks.
music is horrible but loved the story
I like this yarn, quite a bit. I, however, question the means and ease with which the characters traveled to and from Staten Island and Manhattan and especially the use of cars so to do. I grew up on the Island and know how long these jaunts take. Though, a trip to Saint George is, I admit, less onerous than one to Tottenville, where my people lived for about two hundred years.
Music masks narration. Glad it ended.
Good music but Nero's voice has to grab everyone's attention always. It must be unique along side his mythological like reputation. I love the old time radio shows. I do feel this version has music I really like along with its placement. Archie's voice actor fits just not as Nero.
Uncalled for overly loud music.
The reader competes with the loud music
What loud music?
You guys put down the crack pipe😮
A narration with blaring music behind is brilliant. D I S L I K E.
Music so lou.d I am struggling to make out the narrator.
Can't hear the story over the music!!!!!!
Abridged or unabridged? Thank you for making Rex Stout's Nero Wolfe available.
Ain't Red Stout, just a wannabe.
As much as I enjoyed this it just occurred to me How come a paraffin test was not done ? Guess that would have scotched about 4 hrs of audio. Still thanks muchly ❤
Why do people think they can enhance a clear good voice. Audio means not seeing anything. We only have the audio so when additional noise alongside it makes a situation arise where we are listening to the pointless music not the voice. Fluff freeman used to turn down rather skilfully,the pop tune as he spoke then back up.sadly that skill seems lost.
Music kills it
1/7 of a ton is no longer impressive, now commonplace, sadly.
oh. 2 hours 52 minutes. must be abridged.
Make a new hero. Updating Nero Wolf is shocking.
Music too loud!
Good story. BAD MUSIC!
20 minutes in and not continuing. Author has caught the personalities but bring Nero Wolfe ahead to the present ruins it for me. Additionally the bad music over the narration makes listening too hard. Maybe I'll check to see jf original books are on audio. Read them years ago. Also thoroughly enjoyed Timothy Hutton's productioon for tv.
How did YOUR writing a new Nero book end up? When YOU WROTE a follow up to a known figure, how did YOU venture that task?
Hmmm. ?? M
@@mwatts-riley2688Thank you for your critique, perhaps you should have read my comment more carefully. My comment clearly stated that I appreciate the author did a good job writing and they clearly studied the characters. I have a real love for the time period that Rex Stout wrote about, perhaps because my parents lived at that time.
If others enjoy the new setting in a more modern time, that's wonderful and a whole new group getting to meet the fascinating people portrayed therein.
To address your question of my writing a follow up book, I wouldn't even try! My talents lie in other areas, where they bring joy to me and others.😊
@adelechicken6356 excellent reply, and I agree with your original criticism, especially the music
Fake is fake. The quality of a fake is irrelevant. This does not have essence of the creator.
@@mwatts-riley2688Oh dear, Pepto Bismol might help. Or Tums. A good night's sleep does wonders for the disposition.
HAZELNUT‽‽
Too long, gets boring after a while.
I have so many issues with this. The writing was awful. The voices were second rate. The music was distraught. Don’t waste your time
How did YOUR writing and reading, go? When you wrote further Nero books, as per permission of Marsh 's wife, how did YOUR BOOKS take on? When you hired a narrator, did you pay in cash or credit?
Hmmm. Oh wait...
NOT written by Rex Stout. Fake and boring.
They found Fred's .38 and 2 shell casings on the floor. THAT'S IT.
STUPID-STUPID.
Why write about something you obviously don't know the first thing about
Presumably you never watch movies or TV. Both replete with inaccuracies and impossible events. A little suspension of credulity does no harm.
Good point! Can’t recall if it is described as a .38 pistol or automatic - you might possibly find shell casings discharged from an automatic but not otherwise. In the end it didn’t matter b’cos the murderer made sure not to leave prints and the shells were immaterial.