My buddy died the summer after our senior year…was pretty tragic and shitty, but I put mvp 2005 in his casket….that’s how important it was to my friends in high school…love ya E$
WSD not understanding Brandon during the Golden Eye discussion is legitimately one of the funniest things that’s happened in a long time on this show. WSD forever.
Thank god he was here thank GOD. All these sports games or nostalgia picks are so boring. Seems like they shoulda just called it favorite games instead of games for a desert island.
An insane lean into older games. Gaming has never been better than it has been for the past 10-12 years, especially for one player story driven games that are perfect for the prompt
lot of multiplayer games here. may be recency bias, but ive been playing bg3 (never played this kind of game before either, not sure what its considered), and with the virtually infinite choices and storylines, seems like you can play something like this for ages and keep it fresh.
WSD has a raccoon brain but Roller coaster tycoon was an incredible 5th rounder, especially with the “desert island” parameter. I’d play that for 8 hours straight as a kid like nothing. Great pick
@@Fent- Thank you for agreeing with me that it does not take months for an adult to beat and probably isn’t a great 1-1 pick for games you want on a desert island
@@Millenium2927it´s the same with Golden Eye, I was playing on PC at the same time, so when I saw it for the first time I thought it´s complete crap compared to Quake 2, Unreal and Half Life on PC.
Dave arguing with Brandon about Golden Eye had me dying laughing. Brandon so clearly stated that he thought it was a good game but wasn’t good at it. Somehow Dave doesn’t understand Brandon’s simple explanation.
Chiefs NHL 96 pick brought me back so much. I lived on my computer back in the day playing NHL 2000 PC version. The nostalgia right now is real. This draft is the best for a video game lover.
Glad Rudeboy mentioned Skyrim because that was my 1-1. No game in history has more replay value which is clutch on a deserted island. I've had at least 50 playthroughs and still play it to this day
Pokémon not even being mentioned is so bad. Nick should have been on this draft over Brandon. Actually, he should have been in over Chief. Let Chief take the week off.
I think there’s definitely a difference between favorite video games and games for a deserted island. One that would correlate is RuneScape. Put way too much time into that.
For the first time in a while I’m on WSDs side. They absolutely fucked him because they’re idiots. I love chief but he picked TWO CFB games!?! You only get to bring 5 games to an island and you’re picking TWO of the same exact game!?
Rudy hit a HR with Red Dead Redemption 2 game. That game is legendary and the detail is amazing. So many amazing things u can do in that game. U can posse up with people and play that story mode etc it’s great game . Rockstar needs to hurry up and make RDR 3
Gta san andreas was legit the best gta.. then vice city then gta 3 they dont even know that gta 3 is quest locked in some areas and they fixed that in vice city
Haven’t watch yet. But I have a feeling WSD picks a video game out of South Park or The Simpsons. Bob’s Burgers as a sleeper for him. Or at least ties it in somehow That’s how WSD’s brain works.
Red dead 2, and fallout 3 gotta make the list. People easily sink over 100+ hrs in a single play through. I don’t think multiplayer games would be a good choice for being stranded on an island lol
What’s great about madden now days is if player is hurt then he don’t play, that’s what makes sports game the best when thy are realistic up to date with players health etc .
Rudy getting RDR2 in round 3 is great value. Might be the best game I've ever played. Everytime i start a new save I try and go the evil route but I just can't. Arthur Morgan deserves better
think the main issue is that 3 basically knew nothing about video games besides what they played as children. Contra? Never heard of it. Red Dead Redemption, is it a horror game? Is Halo only on Xbox? What´s the difference between the Smash Brothers games? It´s like letting people pick their basketball starting five and they followed Basketball for like 5 years as children and know who Michael Jordan and LeBron James is besides that.
Its definitely nostalgia cause if youve played goldeneye recently. You know how bad it is compared to quality FPS games now. Even though i also have many great memories of goldeneye from my childhood
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
WSD has never been wrong about anything ever. He and cheah could go back and forth for months and never get anywhere in a conversation
This should be the next jerry after dark challenge to moderate a debate between cheah and wsd
Make it a 4 hour long debate with 4 topics that cheah and wsd both have conflicting views on
It’s truly exhausting.
Two of the worst Barstool employees ever
Except Dave’s funny and Cheah sucks
Dave is such a "im taking my ball and going home" type guy
Ask Carl 😂
Eddie taking Mario Party when you're alone on a deserted island might be the worst pick in Snake Draft history.
Eddie tries to have the most cultured list while being the most uncultured
That MX/ATV unleashed pick by Rudy was amazing
BFW one of the best guests. Pumped for this
My buddy died the summer after our senior year…was pretty tragic and shitty, but I put mvp 2005 in his casket….that’s how important it was to my friends in high school…love ya E$
As a gamer, watching the Chicago guys draft anything video game related is disappointing. Props to B-Walk and Rudy for making this watchable.
Brandon needs to watch his tone regarding Roller Coaster Tycoon, amazing pick by WSD in round 5. Perfect for a desert island!
Dave: i'm trying not to argue.
And that was a lie.
WSD not understanding Brandon during the Golden Eye discussion is legitimately one of the funniest things that’s happened in a long time on this show. WSD forever.
Holy shit Rudy is gonna win this by a landslide
Thank god he was here thank GOD. All these sports games or nostalgia picks are so boring.
Seems like they shoulda just called it favorite games instead of games for a desert island.
draft winner.
Roller Coaster Tycoon is a GREAT pick especially if we're actually following the draft prompt
WSD lives in his own world. Zero awareness of the world around him. Never change, David.
An insane lean into older games. Gaming has never been better than it has been for the past 10-12 years, especially for one player story driven games that are perfect for the prompt
Exactly. I get the nostalgia factor, but it wears off.
lot of multiplayer games here. may be recency bias, but ive been playing bg3 (never played this kind of game before either, not sure what its considered), and with the virtually infinite choices and storylines, seems like you can play something like this for ages and keep it fresh.
You know all these guys are in their mid to late 30s cept Rudy right?
Rollercoaster Tycoon was a good pick
That or Age of Empires is a phenomenal time killer
WSD has a raccoon brain but Roller coaster tycoon was an incredible 5th rounder, especially with the “desert island” parameter. I’d play that for 8 hours straight as a kid like nothing. Great pick
WSD kills me his brain needs to be studied 😂
Rudy made the right choice picking the Game Cube version of Smash. Melee is definitely the best version in terms of gameplay
You can tell these guys havent played video games since 90's
Ocarina of time might take “months” to beat when you’re 12, but as an adult it’s a 20 hour game tops
Hardooooooooo
@@nathanak1 played it recently, took me about 2 weeks playing a couple hours a night. It’s a great game, just not a particularly long game.
Congrats on beating a game made for children fast
@@Fent- Thank you for agreeing with me that it does not take months for an adult to beat and probably isn’t a great 1-1 pick for games you want on a desert island
Plus you can go on youtube if you're in a jam.
WSD going from ocarina of time to attacking melee is a wild turn. Melee is the best smash by far
MX vs ATV Unleashed is a phenomenal….albeit unexpected but an OUTSTANDING pick. For the culture.
gamecube double dash is the elite Mario Kart
Anyone that argues 64 is the best Mariokart is exclusively basing it off nostalgia and nothing else.
@@Millenium2927it´s the same with Golden Eye, I was playing on PC at the same time, so when I saw it for the first time I thought it´s complete crap compared to Quake 2, Unreal and Half Life on PC.
If this draft doesn’t have Skyrim on it then it is invalid
Dave arguing with Brandon about Golden Eye had me dying laughing. Brandon so clearly stated that he thought it was a good game but wasn’t good at it. Somehow Dave doesn’t understand Brandon’s simple explanation.
Halo 3 and mvp baseball 2005. What back to back picks by Rudy and BFW
Love hearing people talk about stuff they’re most passionate about. Inspiring.
We need a draft with tommy walker.... best weapons maybe?
This would be awesome, but CPS might be called on bwalk for putting his son in the same room as WSD.
Rudy with the best picks by far. The other guys might be the worst people to have for this topic
Depends on your age. I'm 41 and these guys are batting 1.000 with my picks.
Amazing topic and draft!
Chiefs NHL 96 pick brought me back so much. I lived on my computer back in the day playing NHL 2000 PC version. The nostalgia right now is real. This draft is the best for a video game lover.
Glad Rudeboy mentioned Skyrim because that was my 1-1. No game in history has more replay value which is clutch on a deserted island. I've had at least 50 playthroughs and still play it to this day
It’s hilarious how little they know about the video game world
Rudy looks like Chief's mom made him take his little brother with him to work
Backyard baseball and Pokémon red or blue not getting picked was criminal
Backyard sports were more PC games, no?
Pokémon not even being mentioned is so bad. Nick should have been on this draft over Brandon. Actually, he should have been in over Chief. Let Chief take the week off.
I didn't play Pokemon but definitely should have been drafted in the first 2 rounds
Roller Coaster tycoon is an awesome game
Couldn’t keep listening earlier. Brandon is spot on. That was the best baseball video game ever made. It was perfect.
I think there’s definitely a difference between favorite video games and games for a deserted island. One that would correlate is RuneScape. Put way too much time into that.
WSD would argue with a brick wall.
And lose.
Dave had a great draft. Everyone else had just sports games or gta
For the first time in a while I’m on WSDs side. They absolutely fucked him because they’re idiots. I love chief but he picked TWO CFB games!?! You only get to bring 5 games to an island and you’re picking TWO of the same exact game!?
BFW with the contra pick to close was top notch
Rudy hit a HR with Red Dead Redemption 2 game. That game is legendary and the detail is amazing. So many amazing things u can do in that game. U can posse up with people and play that story mode etc it’s great game . Rockstar needs to hurry up and make RDR 3
Rdr2 sucked
mx vs atv is pick of the decade
BFW is right about Mike Tyson’s punch out. Best game ever.
Wow.... White Sox Dave doesn't get generations... unbelievable yet totally expected
Mario 64, Super Mario brothers 3, Tony Hawk pro Skater 2, Modern warfare 2, WWF No Mercy, Uncharted 4. Some bangers left off.
Ivan Stewart’s Off Road arcade three player is the best game of all time.
I'd only buy Nitros, lol.
15:20 😂 start of a great argument
16:40
Dave thinking anyone would get mad over people liking vice city over GTA 3 is such a brain dead take. If anything it’s San Andreas over Vice City.
Roller coaster tycoon is a WILD pick hahaha
Gta san andreas was legit the best gta.. then vice city then gta 3 they dont even know that gta 3 is quest locked in some areas and they fixed that in vice city
CONTRA was a BANGER
USA needs to endorse a indoor soccer league aka Futsal. Its fast pace and physical.
Guys are out here picking Madden 04, NCAA Football 06, and then raggin on RCT? Get out of here.
This was dope
Born in 01, contra is one of my favorite arcade games
Haven’t watch yet.
But I have a feeling WSD picks a video game out of South Park or The Simpsons. Bob’s Burgers as a sleeper for him. Or at least ties it in somehow
That’s how WSD’s brain works.
Nah it’s definitely gonna be Zelda Ocarina of Time.
@@spryfilly8968 thats a legit answer tho you can play that game forever.
GTA
The Stick of Truth lol
I knew it 😎
Brandon had the perfect first 2 picks
MVP Baseball 05 and FIFA 14 Soundtrack 🔥
Roller Coaster Tycoon was THE pick of the draft.
Brandon trolling Chief on Hockey and him having no clue was gold.
Mario 64 is a magical game...crazy no one picked one Mario game
Rudy instant W with RDR2 and THEN getting THUG. My two favorite games of all time. Rudy is right that THUG1 is the apex.
I love the MVP 05 love. That game was the shit. My cousin and I spent so much time playing that game, drafting teams, etc.
NFL 2k5 had to pull out the Xbox to play this one again
Red dead 2, and fallout 3 gotta make the list. People easily sink over 100+ hrs in a single play through. I don’t think multiplayer games would be a good choice for being stranded on an island lol
This is quality content from WSD😂, honestly had some fair points too.
Lot of the others guys last picks were trash too.
Dave is truly from another planet
Rudy hit a homerun on MX vs ATV unleashedd. Sum 41 Fat Lip was goated during that era on that soundtrack
Now here is a draft topic!
Saying that melee was not different than the other smash games truly broke my heart, competitive melee is the best
RD2 going in the 3rd round is a steal
This is an all time wsd episode
Rudy absolutely murdered this draft
Amazing pick by Brandon. MVP Baseball 2005 is goat'd
Brandon prolly played Zelda once at a neighbors house and all of a sudden he’s a expert
Medal of Honor: Frontline GOATED
MX vs ATV Unleashed wins the draft for me
Roller Coaster tycoon slander will not be accepted
Ocarina slander is crazy. Brandon not getting voted off is insane, quite possibly the shittiest list in terms of best games on an island.
How do you vote !?
Before starting
1. Goldeneye N64
2. Mario Cart N64
3. Madden
4. Tiger Woods PS3
5. Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2
Halo 3 is the correct first round answer. Rudy won my vote with that pick.
Halo 2 online
What’s great about madden now days is if player is hurt then he don’t play, that’s what makes sports game the best when thy are realistic up to date with players health etc .
Chicago guys getting called out in the first round is perfect, rudy and brandon were so right
Twisted metal was classic game back in the day . Also Grantrismo was Badass game. But Brandon knows Madden is legendary as well
Whitesox Dave with the Mr. Bones Wild Ride pick. He conquered this draft.
N64 had perfect dark that had a local multiplayer mode with ai bots that you could adjust difficulty wise and personality it was way ahead of its time
That GoldenEye rant by WSD is an all time moment
Holy fuck the fact that no one corrected WSD instantly on not even knowing how to pronounce the 1.1 pick is abysmal
Detlef Schrempf and Shawn Kemp all time NBA Jam duo.
Agreed. My favorite team to play with
Rudy won the draft with RDR2. The other guys can't even comprehend what a pick that was.
Rudy getting RDR2 in round 3 is great value. Might be the best game I've ever played. Everytime i start a new save I try and go the evil route but I just can't. Arthur Morgan deserves better
This draft kinda sucks all nostalgia pick’s nobody plays games any more other than Rudy
think the main issue is that 3 basically knew nothing about video games besides what they played as children. Contra? Never heard of it. Red Dead Redemption, is it a horror game? Is Halo only on Xbox? What´s the difference between the Smash Brothers games? It´s like letting people pick their basketball starting five and they followed Basketball for like 5 years as children and know who Michael Jordan and LeBron James is besides that.
You guys gotta fix the vote out process. Go back to having to write it down
Normally I don’t agree with WSD, but Ocarina of Time is absolutely a top 3 game of all time. The amount of story in Zelda for a kid is a classic
Its definitely nostalgia cause if youve played goldeneye recently. You know how bad it is compared to quality FPS games now. Even though i also have many great memories of goldeneye from my childhood
Skyrim going undrafted is CRIMINAL
Chrono Trigger, great replay value for an RPG.
Is 05 baseball game with manny on the cover?