To be honest, from the last chorus until the end, it sounds like Hikaru. But after watching the live performance, I heard the voices of Chaehyun, Youngeun, and Yeseo, so I added them like this.
nope the actual line distribution is: 1. hikaru 43.7s (-4.2s) 2. chaehyun 35s (-3.9s) 3. youngeun 25.3s (-3.8s) 4. yeseo 17.4s (-9.4s) 5. yujin 16.7s 6. dayeon 12.5s (-13.5s) 7. bahiyyih/xiaoting 11.5s 8. mashiro 8.5s (-7s) all of the “l o v e l y la la la lovely l o v e l y la la la lovely” is sang by hikaru and they were sang by just her in the last chorus the voice tone in the 1st 2nd and last chorus sounds the same and it’s hikaru and being in the center ≠ it’s ur line all of the “l o v e l y no no more lonely l o v e l” is sang by just chaehyun like I said before being in the center ≠ it’s ur line the “l to the o to the v to the e to the l to the y to the la la lovely” adlibs in the last chorus were background vocalists and no one is singing those adlibs in the live performance
i still think the choruses are all sung by hikaru and chaehyun cause i can’t hear any difference between them 😂 also i think the last lvly is hikaru too but performance wise they changed the members for the center distribution ps: i had no idea the few lines shiro actually had (😭)
I think the choruses are Hikaru/ALL only, I don't hear any difference in vocals even in the live performance and I don't think chaehyun is singing the 2nd part of the chorus, it sounds more like everyone singing instead
I also think about it. The original audio version is Hikaru and Chaehyun who sing the choruses but it will not fair if they perform it only Hikaru/Chaehyun who centered the most
i can actually hear the difference it’s minimal but if you listen closely you can hear it i’m guessing they told them to sing in similar styles to not break the vibe of the song
Fr I was a bit worried since YG hit your BAEMON Dream video twice. Second part of each chorus should be no one though since they only use Hikaru and Chaehyun's vocals as the front for background.
all of the “l o v e l y la la la lovely l o v e l y la la la lovely” is sang by hikaru and they were sang by just her in the last chorus the voice tone in the 1st 2nd and last chorus sounds the same and it’s hikaru and being in the center ≠ it’s ur line all of the “l o v e l y no no more lonely l o v e l” is sang by just chaehyun like I said before being in the center ≠ it’s ur line the “l to the o to the v to the e to the l to the y to the la la lovely” adlibs in the last chorus were background vocalists and no one is singing those adlibs in the live performance so the actual line distribution is: 1. hikaru 43.7s (-4.2s) 2. chaehyun 35s (-3.9s) 3. youngeun 25.3s (-3.8s) 4. yeseo 17.4s (-9.4s) 5. yujin 16.7s 6. dayeon 12.5s (-13.5s) 7. bahiyyih/xiaoting 11.5s 8. mashiro 8.5s (-7s)
I don't really think Dayeon really sung the second chorus. She's just in the center because..... idk actually but I like how you count some of the hidden vocals Edit:I watched the live and then it sounded like Dayeon.... maybe Hikaru sang the second chorus in studio but Dayeon sang it in live
@@DJ-tx3ux There's no way all NINE of them would record the chorus together in studio lol, usually only 2-4 members would be used to record the chorus for a group with this much members, maybe only one like Hikaru in this song, or maybe it's just background vocalist who record it
sorry for being offtopic but can I ask a question abt your line distribution ver. 2 tutorial?? so you know how you made the bars move up and down in the tutorial-how would I make them move left and right like in this vid instead?
ty! they move the right way now, but my 2nd timebar is below the rest and i can only move it diagonally, do you know why? ruclips.net/video/GbyeMCSGIws/видео.html
@hey hall OMG WAIT when i did that but also put the same code in the y position of the 2nd one it moves into place, but idk why it starts out below the rest still ruclips.net/video/F6tm8gjc4Vw/видео.html
Bruh, I know in the live it was divided like that but how come that I hear the chorus like Dayeon(1st half of 1st half)->Hikaru(2nd half of 1st half)->Hikaru and Chaehyun(The second half of the chorus)
@@heyhall "It sounds like Hikaru in the studio version" It's literally the same voice as the other chorus. For some reason, they give it to Dayeon but if you compare both studio and live, it's completely different
It's like We Fresh "Move your body fresh", it sounds exactly the same but it's Bahiyyih & Dayeon, also Up! "Na-na-na-na", it sounds almost the same but it's Yeseo & Youngeun
chaehyun is 1st in why not youngeun youngeun is 2nd the line distribution ranking of why by kep1er is: 1. chaehyun 2. youngeun 3. dayeon 4. yujin 5. bahiyyih 6. hikaru 7. yeseo 8. mashiro 9. xiaoting
I like the Choreography and the Base even the Ad libs but i don’t like the Line Distribution its not fair and the MV but Hikaru is Perfect on this song She is the FOTG I like it the Chorus is my FAVORITE.
they suddenly remembered she existed in the group and threw her some random lines towards the end and called it a day 💀 also i thought 0:21 was mashiro 's part youngeun really sounded like mashiro here 😮 youngeun 's voice is quite versatile and sometimes matches with certain members of the group her voice is harder to identify than i thought
1. HIKARU: 47.9s
2. CHAEHYUN: 38.9s
3. YOUNGEUN: 29.1s
4. YESEO: 26.8s (12.6s)
5. DAYEON: 26.0s
6. YUJIN: 16.7s
7. MASHIRO: 15.5s (7.0s)
8. XIAOTING: 11.5s
9. BAHIYYIH: 11.5s
Evenness: 83.2%
To be honest, from the last chorus until the end, it sounds like Hikaru. But after watching the live performance, I heard the voices of Chaehyun, Youngeun, and Yeseo, so I added them like this.
Don't you mean (8.5s) for Mashiro?
nope the actual line distribution is:
1. hikaru 43.7s (-4.2s)
2. chaehyun 35s (-3.9s)
3. youngeun 25.3s (-3.8s)
4. yeseo 17.4s (-9.4s)
5. yujin 16.7s
6. dayeon 12.5s (-13.5s)
7. bahiyyih/xiaoting 11.5s
8. mashiro 8.5s (-7s)
all of the “l o v e l y la la la lovely l o v e l y la la la lovely” is sang by hikaru and they were sang by just her in the last chorus the voice tone in the 1st 2nd and last chorus sounds the same and it’s hikaru and being in the center ≠ it’s ur line all of the “l o v e l y no no more lonely l o v e l” is sang by just chaehyun like I said before being in the center ≠ it’s ur line the “l to the o to the v to the e to the l to the y to the la la lovely” adlibs in the last chorus were background vocalists and no one is singing those adlibs in the live performance
i still think the choruses are all sung by hikaru and chaehyun cause i can’t hear any difference between them 😂 also i think the last lvly is hikaru too but performance wise they changed the members for the center distribution
ps: i had no idea the few lines shiro actually had (😭)
I think the choruses are Hikaru/ALL only, I don't hear any difference in vocals even in the live performance and I don't think chaehyun is singing the 2nd part of the chorus, it sounds more like everyone singing instead
I also think about it. The original audio version is Hikaru and Chaehyun who sing the choruses but it will not fair if they perform it only Hikaru/Chaehyun who centered the most
i can actually hear the difference
it’s minimal but if you listen closely you can hear it
i’m guessing they told them to sing in similar styles to not break the vibe of the song
Youngeun vocals /melt
Wow Hikaru is first
Girl am so proud of you ❤️
Mashiro I am so proud of you! You are now a "queen of adlib"
YO IM SHOCK BECAUSE I CAN HEAR EVERYONE VOICE ESPECIALLY THE TRANSITIONS FROM CHAEHYUN TO YOUNGEUN
Finally thank you so much
0:49
2:04 i actually hear some differences
please make one for Kep1er together forever @heyhall 🙏
Fr I was a bit worried since YG hit your BAEMON Dream video twice.
Second part of each chorus should be no one though since they only use Hikaru and Chaehyun's vocals as the front for background.
Fortunately, it doesn't affect my channel. I'm confused about whether to use the live version or the studio version, so it ended up like this.
this song is a fucking masterpieceeeeeeeeeee
Finally you comeback!
Is much fairer than I though, 2nd chorus does sound different than tge first but I was surprised to see Dayeon there, good job ❤
For the chorus part hihi it's better to ask the member who sang the chorus parts hihi
this deserved to be the title track. giddy was good but this is like the best kep1er song
doublast and lovestruck eras are my favs
all of the “l o v e l y la la la lovely l o v e l y la la la lovely” is sang by hikaru and they were sang by just her in the last chorus the voice tone in the 1st 2nd and last chorus sounds the same and it’s hikaru and being in the center ≠ it’s ur line all of the “l o v e l y no no more lonely l o v e l” is sang by just chaehyun like I said before being in the center ≠ it’s ur line the “l to the o to the v to the e to the l to the y to the la la lovely” adlibs in the last chorus were background vocalists and no one is singing those adlibs in the live performance so the actual line distribution is:
1. hikaru 43.7s (-4.2s)
2. chaehyun 35s (-3.9s)
3. youngeun 25.3s (-3.8s)
4. yeseo 17.4s (-9.4s)
5. yujin 16.7s
6. dayeon 12.5s (-13.5s)
7. bahiyyih/xiaoting 11.5s
8. mashiro 8.5s (-7s)
ot7 version:
1. hikaru 45.2 (+1.5s)
2. chaehyun 38.1s (+3.1s)
3. youngeun 26.7s (+1.4s)
4. yujin 20.4s (+3.7s)
5. dayeon 19.2s (+6.7s)
6. xiaoting 16.3s (+4.8s)
7. bahiyyih 16.2s (+4.7s)
0:10 hikaru
1:24 yujin
adlibs at 1:29 and at 1:32 were chaehyun
1:45 dayeon
2:02 yujin
2:42 bahiyyih
2:47 xiaoting
2Kim part is so good!
According to their performance last l o v e l y la la la lovly is chaehyun
It's all sounds the same, probably Hikaru in studio version
is it bad that i cant tell their voices apart except for chaehyun 😭
I think in the studio version Hikaru's have 62 seconds
I don't really think Dayeon really sung the second chorus. She's just in the center because..... idk actually but I like how you count some of the hidden vocals
Edit:I watched the live and then it sounded like Dayeon.... maybe Hikaru sang the second chorus in studio but Dayeon sang it in live
In the studio the chorus is all but Hikaru and Chaehyun are put in the front. The live version is Hikaru-Dayeon-Chaehyun.
@@DJ-tx3ux There's no way all NINE of them would record the chorus together in studio lol, usually only 2-4 members would be used to record the chorus for a group with this much members, maybe only one like Hikaru in this song, or maybe it's just background vocalist who record it
Can you do Why? Some people forgot to count Dayeon's adlibs
Yes I need why, everyone did it wrong for some reason when it isn't even that hard 😭
@@hueningbahibitch yes, only LVLY distribution is confusing
I wish they did one. No one did it correct
@@hueningbahibitchhe uploaded Why yesterday
@@illegaluser69he uploaded it yesterday
sorry for being offtopic but can I ask a question abt your line distribution ver. 2 tutorial?? so you know how you made the bars move up and down in the tutorial-how would I make them move left and right like in this vid instead?
instead of y Position move the code to x position.
ty! they move the right way now, but my 2nd timebar is below the rest and i can only move it diagonally, do you know why? ruclips.net/video/GbyeMCSGIws/видео.html
@hey hall OMG WAIT when i did that but also put the same code in the y position of the 2nd one it moves into place, but idk why it starts out below the rest still ruclips.net/video/F6tm8gjc4Vw/видео.html
Bruh, I know in the live it was divided like that but how come that I hear the chorus like
Dayeon(1st half of 1st half)->Hikaru(2nd half of 1st half)->Hikaru and Chaehyun(The second half of the chorus)
2:06 I don't think it sounds like Dayeon at all
Yeah, it sounds like Hikaru in the studio version, but in the two live performances, it sounds like Dayeon.
@@heyhall "It sounds like Hikaru in the studio version"
It's literally the same voice as the other chorus. For some reason, they give it to Dayeon but if you compare both studio and live, it's completely different
@@heyhall yeah, I just heard the live version & the 2nd chorus does sounds like Dayeon. But in the Studio version sounds like Hikaru.
It's like We Fresh "Move your body fresh", it sounds exactly the same but it's Bahiyyih & Dayeon, also Up! "Na-na-na-na", it sounds almost the same but it's Yeseo & Youngeun
I agree I listened to the live performance and I couldn't hear dayeons voice in the 2nd chorus at all
oh... I had only heard bahiyyih's part so I thought it was a good song... damn...
And it is!
Pls Why Distribution I think Youngeun it's First 🤞
chaehyun is 1st in why not youngeun youngeun is 2nd the line distribution ranking of why by kep1er is:
1. chaehyun
2. youngeun
3. dayeon
4. yujin
5. bahiyyih
6. hikaru
7. yeseo
8. mashiro
9. xiaoting
I like the Choreography and the Base even the Ad libs but i don’t like the Line Distribution its not fair and the MV but Hikaru is Perfect on this song She is the FOTG I like it the Chorus is my FAVORITE.
I don’t agree with the choruses but wow they really forgot mashiro was in the group for this song
they suddenly remembered she existed in the group and threw her some random lines towards the end and called it a day 💀 also i thought 0:21 was mashiro 's part youngeun really sounded like mashiro here 😮 youngeun 's voice is quite versatile and sometimes matches with certain members of the group her voice is harder to identify than i thought
why call a song LVLY if you literally spell the whole word out in the song
either way its a bop so