Bartok - Out of Doors

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 апр 2012
  • Out of Doors (Szabadban), composed by Béla Bartók in his 'piano year' of 1926.
    1. With Drums and Pipes - bang bang bang WHAM bang WHAM bang WHAM. Oh yeah...
    2. Barcarolla (1:51) - you can almost see the girls bumping their hips.
    3. Musettes (3:50) - as in bagpipes
    4. Musiques Nocturnes (6:40) - Night Musics, not Night's Music. Not sleepy or dreamy, but with senses and awareness heightened.
    5. The Chase (12:01) - are those arpeggiated clusters at the opening, or screams of terror? Curiously, rather than press on towards the end, Bartok backs off as in exhaustion, with a final Chomp!
    Created, edited and mastered in Digital Performer 5.13 (MOTU), using Ivory (Synthogy) sound banks. Video created in iMovie.
    Disclaimer! The music score is from a Russian edition downloaded from classicscore.hut2.ru. In the US the score is administered by the Harry Fox agency. The audio is my own.
  • ВидеоклипыВидеоклипы

Комментарии • 245

  • @jerryengelbach
    @jerryengelbach 6 лет назад +232

    This piece dispels any possible doubt that Bartok considered the piano to be a percussion instrument.

    • @palmaiattila3288
      @palmaiattila3288 3 года назад +11

      Yes, but not only in this ingrained interpretation. In my opinion, the treatment of the piano as a percussion instrument in his interpretation was mainly due to attempts to better emphasize syncopations and other nuances in the paraphrases of rhythmic male dances. I recommend watching this short video first ruclips.net/video/VHn_NBBIKeM/видео.html
      - then coming back to "With Drums and Pipes", or choosing the "Allegro barbaro"

    • @translucent.
      @translucent. 2 года назад +3

      you mean, surely, that "... bartok did not consider the piano to be a percussion instrument" ...

    • @jerryengelbach
      @jerryengelbach 2 года назад +3

      @@translucent. No, I mean just what I said. Any doubt that Bartok considered piano a percussion instrument would be dispelled by his pieces that used it like one.

    • @jarokadezso
      @jarokadezso Год назад

      I guess he thought the boys were girls

    • @jeanlobrot
      @jeanlobrot Год назад

      @@jerryengelbach this was made by a midi

  • @cobblestonegenerator
    @cobblestonegenerator 5 лет назад +10

    The nocturnes is absolutely bueatiful. Especially when those little folk melodies weave in. Bartok is a genius and master of anxiety and mystery in music.

  • @sevenlayer8780
    @sevenlayer8780 4 года назад +80

    The reason why we love Bartok so much is because he is, foremost, a composer of melody. The more you familiarize yourself with his music, the more obvious it becomes. He constructed the perfected harmonic language and aural landscapes on which to place those melodies, cocoons where they could grow and thrive.

    • @AndreyRubtsovRU
      @AndreyRubtsovRU Месяц назад +1

      This comment is bullshit much as i like bartok 😂😂

    • @sevenlayer8780
      @sevenlayer8780 27 дней назад

      @@AndreyRubtsovRU right, well, you’re obviously not a musician, so why the f*ck would anyone bother with what you think? Shouldn’t you be playing Xbox right now?

  • @brianlam6617
    @brianlam6617 8 лет назад +161

    Teacher: From 1 to 10, how crazy are you about music? Me: Bartok

    • @Soytu19
      @Soytu19 7 лет назад +12

      I remember my first class with a teacher. The first day she asked me who was my favourite composer, to start knowing eachother at least musically, being the first day... And I said: Bartók of course. And she not only knew me musically.

    • @sebastianzaczek
      @sebastianzaczek 6 лет назад +7

      Me: Level Ferneyhough/Xenakis
      ok not really, i don't really enjoy ferneyhoughs music, but i often listen to music a Little more "out-there"

    • @sergiohman
      @sergiohman 2 года назад +1

      Hahaha

    • @klop4228
      @klop4228 2 года назад +2

      So like a 7.5?

    • @fryderyckchopin484
      @fryderyckchopin484 Год назад

      Level: Ligeti

  • @Yellow_Magpie
    @Yellow_Magpie 9 лет назад +19

    I feel so cheated realising this is a midi track xD The piece is so hard that any mechanical elements I would have put down to the performer, crazy what technology can do.

  • @andragg
    @andragg Год назад +4

    Bartok's piano music really shows his brilliance. In 1972 I bought an old used record with Bartok's piano music which included Out of Doors, Sonatine, Allegro Barbaro, A Bit Drunk and some others. I played the hell out of that record. Then I heard his String Quartet No. 4 last movement, Allegro Molto on the local college radio station and it changed my life. Bartok is one of the greatest composers ever. Sadly, Bartok died in poverty which prompted Stravinsky to change the way he went about collecting wages from his own music.

  • @E_FoxSnowspirit
    @E_FoxSnowspirit 23 дня назад

    Every time I listen to Bartók, my reaction is always a mix of "oooh I like this" and "who could like this?!"... hope to learn the theory behind it someday

  • @steverodak2230
    @steverodak2230 2 года назад +21

    The melody is breathtakingly beautiful. I'm sure Mozart would have loved to have taken lessons from him.

    • @jarokadezso
      @jarokadezso Год назад +2

      melody???

    • @MrPhil480
      @MrPhil480 Год назад +1

      D ailleurs au début je croyais que c' était Mozart j' avais confondu 😏

    • @klop4228
      @klop4228 7 месяцев назад

      @@jarokadezso 0:11 is the first one

  • @jonaskatona7136
    @jonaskatona7136 10 лет назад +222

    Bartók has made me completely impervious to any sense of dissonance.

    • @JohnDoe-dh8xc
      @JohnDoe-dh8xc 7 лет назад +13

      Jonas Katona I went through the very same thing listening to Miles Davis's electric period, specifically the album Bitches Brew (though other music may have primed me as well). In fact it lead me to seek out dissonance in music.

    • @davidquakkelaar341
      @davidquakkelaar341 7 лет назад +7

      For me Meshuggah did the job... :p

    • @johnappleseed8369
      @johnappleseed8369 6 лет назад +12

      People who complain about Schoenberg should just listen to lots of Bartok (and perhaps Liszt too) and then come back to it

    • @matheusturing2555
      @matheusturing2555 6 лет назад +21

      I still Can't enjoy Schoenberg pieces.

    • @andreapagella5347
      @andreapagella5347 5 лет назад

      ! #? 4%[]

  • @TomasikEnjoyer42
    @TomasikEnjoyer42 5 лет назад +7

    Musiques Nocturnes is breathtaking

    • @stevefrenca4825
      @stevefrenca4825 Год назад +1

      It sounds like something from a horror movie! The fact that no-one's used it in a film before is INSANE!

  • @ironmaz1
    @ironmaz1 5 лет назад +5

    this is the best description ive seen in any video :'D

  • @gborden1
    @gborden1 8 лет назад +1

    Great job! Thank you for doing this (and your many others, but this is my favorite).

  • @lionelcristino
    @lionelcristino 8 лет назад +130

    Argh, who has switched the midi drum part to Piano sound ?

    • @petervogt8309
      @petervogt8309 8 лет назад +4

      +Lionel CRISTINO that's actually an interesting comment

    • @lionelcristino
      @lionelcristino 8 лет назад +5

      +Peter Vogt lol it was a joke... i did play Bartok when i was young...

    • @petervogt8309
      @petervogt8309 8 лет назад +3

      :) a passing glimpse at the score may lead one to suspect a percussion part... Respect! I am just learning to listen to Bartok. Playing is in another dimension....

    • @DaveInirts
      @DaveInirts 8 лет назад

      +Peter Vogt I agree . Cristino comment is something one can reflect on

    • @luableah7615
      @luableah7615 6 лет назад

      XD

  • @fryingwiththeantidote2486
    @fryingwiththeantidote2486 8 лет назад +96

    Bartok invented djent.

  • @AydarAkhmady
    @AydarAkhmady 8 лет назад +15

    Musiques nocturnes sounds so haunting!

  • @paulbetjeman9933
    @paulbetjeman9933 8 месяцев назад

    thank you thank you for posting this

  • @pianoman722
    @pianoman722 8 лет назад +41

    Rock and Roll Bartok

  • @zachcloyd9589
    @zachcloyd9589 8 лет назад +17

    Organized Chaos at its finest! Difficult to listen to, yes! Emotional, very! Also your descriptions of the pieces are fitting.

  •  4 года назад +25

    Bartok, what scene’s audio did you converted to midi?

    • @andrelaplante3734
      @andrelaplante3734 3 года назад +2

      A

    • @gagemorgan8139
      @gagemorgan8139 2 года назад

      i guess Im randomly asking but does anybody know of a tool to get back into an Instagram account??
      I was dumb lost the login password. I love any help you can give me!

    • @paxtonorlando8003
      @paxtonorlando8003 2 года назад

      @Gage Morgan Instablaster :)

    • @gagemorgan8139
      @gagemorgan8139 2 года назад

      @Paxton Orlando I really appreciate your reply. I got to the site through google and I'm trying it out now.
      I see it takes a while so I will reply here later with my results.

    • @gagemorgan8139
      @gagemorgan8139 2 года назад

      @Paxton Orlando it worked and I actually got access to my account again. I am so happy:D
      Thank you so much, you saved my account !

  • @natafineart2114
    @natafineart2114 11 лет назад +6

    Was lucky to witness a live performance of this and was inspired to create a musical portrait to this.

  • @jaketrask3053
    @jaketrask3053 7 лет назад +3

    this is like Dillinger Escape Plan, but from the 20's. I dig it.

  • @ghouston69
    @ghouston69 6 лет назад +4

    For someone who used Digital Performer, you did one hell of a good job.

  • @xdissonance8
    @xdissonance8 3 года назад

    Bang bang WHAM indeed, I love this piece so much

  • @Michael_Arnold
    @Michael_Arnold 9 лет назад +7

    Hard to believe this is midi. Well done! An interesting 'take' on the piece

  • @grantveebeejay535
    @grantveebeejay535 3 года назад +5

    A truly magnificent work. Thanks for creating this version and sharing. Bartok the Great!!!!

  •  8 лет назад +1

    Excellent audio editing!

  • @juanpabloposadagar
    @juanpabloposadagar 7 лет назад +4

    I love Bartok.

  • @jorguegonzalez3595
    @jorguegonzalez3595 4 года назад

    Bravo como siempre Bartok es encantador y poderoso

  • @Soytu19
    @Soytu19 7 лет назад +7

    I'm sure this is how Bartok concieved the nocturne. Here you can hear the progression better than how most pianist play it.

  • @robertkimmel12
    @robertkimmel12 5 месяцев назад

    Clearly, one of his greatest works for piano!

  • @sethebrown
    @sethebrown 4 года назад +3

    This is one of those pieces I always come back to for another listen. So relentlessly enjoyable!

  • @keybawd4023
    @keybawd4023 2 года назад

    A wonderful performance.

  • @robvonk9131
    @robvonk9131 5 лет назад +3

    The cluster chords in Musiques Nocturnes give me the heebie jeebies.

  • @nathanielwilson183
    @nathanielwilson183 6 лет назад

    Well you win the award for the best liner notes.

  • @Soytu19
    @Soytu19 7 лет назад

    I give like to this only for the nocturne, because it makes a lot of sense played like this and it's amazing

  • @charlottewhyte9804
    @charlottewhyte9804 7 лет назад +5

    luv to learn this 1st one especially

    • @sebastianzaczek
      @sebastianzaczek 6 лет назад

      I managed to learn the 1st mvt in only 4 days... but i certainly love all of them

  • @timward276
    @timward276 5 лет назад +5

    supposedly Musiques Nocturnes was inspired by a night in a Hungarian forest, complete with the chirping of frogs and crickets, and a shepherd boy playing the flute in the distance.

  • @pedroa.cantero9449
    @pedroa.cantero9449 10 лет назад +41

    En mis viajes nostálgicos a través de la música, Bartok representa un alto en el camino de esa juventud violenta y rompedora por la que solo quienes se atrevieron a volar tan alto como las águilas nos interesaban. Él fue sin duda alguna quien encarnaba el vigor insurrecto y la esperanza de un mundo donde solo la verdad triunfara, como sí la verdad tuviera una sola cara y esta no fuese su peor máscara. Pero en fin, lo propio de la juventud es barrer hacia afuera para dejar entrar aire fresco. Puertas abiertas. Y Dios sabe que Out of Doors las abre por completo hasta no dejar más que el viento nuevo y la sazón de una vida sin barreras. En Plein Air. Años aquellos de ilusión en los que creíamos que una vez cruzado el Cabo de Buena Esperanza todo era bonanza.

    • @alexisdanielvaneskeheian2127
      @alexisdanielvaneskeheian2127 6 лет назад

      Excelente y sentido comentario.

    • @Michael-cl9mb
      @Michael-cl9mb 6 лет назад

      pedro a. cantero me hubiera encantado ser un amigo tuyo.

    • @Tanke478
      @Tanke478 3 года назад +1

      También he visto sus comentarios en la Fantasía en Fa menor de Schubert, y sin conocerlo se comprende su genio.

    • @davisatdavis1
      @davisatdavis1 2 года назад

      That was beautiful

    • @robotkarel
      @robotkarel 2 года назад

      En algún momento de mi vida quise redactar así. Pero se me pasó.

  • @blackbrownbeige55
    @blackbrownbeige55 Год назад

    This is a FABULOUS performance and recording. I believe THE best I have heard. Up front sound engineering makes all the difference

    • @vartonise
      @vartonise Год назад

      John Milbauer is my piano professor, and he recorded this in his Images album. I just stumbled to this recording as I’m looking for my next repertoire!

    • @blackbrownbeige55
      @blackbrownbeige55 Год назад

      THIS IS BARTOK at his Finest. This performance is MAGIC and UNBELIEVABLE

  • @erliLila
    @erliLila Год назад +3

    Usually people throw the metal comparison randomly on classical music. But THIS is actually metal as fuck

  • @chadevans3299
    @chadevans3299 3 года назад +1

    I consider this the best of his compositions.

    • @Dylonely42
      @Dylonely42 2 года назад

      Even better than his piano concertos ?

    • @PaulVinonaama
      @PaulVinonaama 2 года назад

      @@Dylonely42 or string quartets etc.

  • @chipstern1
    @chipstern1 6 лет назад +3

    Bartok a hero of mine, though oddly enough, outside of [Mainly, since I was a little boy]CONCERTO FOR ORCHESTRA and MIKROKOSOMOS...as well as THE MIRACULOUS MANDARIN, MUSIC FOR STRINGS PERCUSSION AND CELESTE and of late, THE PIANO CONCERTOS and the SIX STRING QUARTETS, I am clearly not as conversant as I might. One lifetime, SO MUCH MUSIC. This was a pleasant surprise. Bartok really speaks to my sense of rhythm and harmonic tension. Oddly enough, THE CHASE made me think of Sun Ra.

    • @palmaiattila3288
      @palmaiattila3288 4 года назад

      If you haven't heard "Sonata for two pianos and percussion" yet, don't miss it!

    • @chipstern1
      @chipstern1 7 месяцев назад

      My Bartok journey as well. CONCERTO as a little boy. Still so much to learn

  • @alexisdanielvaneskeheian2127
    @alexisdanielvaneskeheian2127 Год назад

    Hermosa!!! 🎼🎹💐👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

  • @MrZappianoify
    @MrZappianoify Месяц назад

    Inmensa, impresionante conjugación de piano y percusión tan percutiva como una flecha entre los ojos!!!!!!

  • @lindsaymonteer3862
    @lindsaymonteer3862 Год назад

    Very relaxing

  • @Soytu19
    @Soytu19 9 лет назад +3

    Hey man, i love how you change the music in some passages, you make them better. You have my admiration. But although I also love the sound effects you add to your piano, I would love to hear them without those effects the way you play them. But what amazes me is the reason of why you are not playing in big halls in front of a huge public and being famous all around the world as one of the best interpreters of Bela Bartok. This is amazing, seriosly.

    • @aidenpeleg7113
      @aidenpeleg7113 8 лет назад +3

      +soigon
      Read the description. "Created, edited and mastered in Digital Performer 5.13 (MOTU), using Ivory (Synthogy) sound banks.". The notes are being played by a computer with a collection of sounds, not a pianist. Pay attention and you'll see that unless indicated in the score, not once does the tempo or dynamic change. The score's written/edited very well though

  • @stankochman2558
    @stankochman2558 3 года назад +1

    I got turned on to Bartok via a Frank Zappa interview in the 80's, it made my list of 'what to listen to when you want to hear something different', along with Crack the Sky, Schoenberg and a few others. Perfect when I am in the mood for it, otherwise I give it 7 out of 10. My fiancé' hates it so let's bump it up to 8 out of 10. ;)

  • @stevehetzel1866
    @stevehetzel1866 7 лет назад

    Oh Yeah! Like that!!!

  • @random_user_hmm
    @random_user_hmm Год назад +2

    9:46 that is truly beautiful it suite the night

  • @MusicalMissCapri
    @MusicalMissCapri 6 лет назад +1

    Wow. I feel out of breath just listening to the last movement.

  • @user-sv8ku1sj9i
    @user-sv8ku1sj9i 6 лет назад +1

    Genius

  • @TheDissonantStates
    @TheDissonantStates 4 года назад

    sounds good!

  • @fraproxy
    @fraproxy 9 лет назад +7

    It's not all about the music only - meaning the notes itself. It gives a kind of feelings, momentum, it's a bit like a watiching Picasso paintings or might be like observing your own thoughts.

  • @2ndviolin
    @2ndviolin 8 лет назад

    you may or may not like his music, but it is never boring. I love his simple duets for violin.

    • @jarokadezso
      @jarokadezso Год назад

      Is there anyone who doesn't like it?

    • @2ndviolin
      @2ndviolin Год назад +1

      @@jarokadezso many people hate "strange" harmonies and disonance.

  • @CatkhosruShapurrjiFurabji
    @CatkhosruShapurrjiFurabji 2 года назад +1

    Nice

  • @FeonaLeeJones
    @FeonaLeeJones 5 лет назад +6

    definitely hear how Ligeti was inspired by him

  • @p51mustang_
    @p51mustang_ Год назад

    カッコよすぎて笑ったw
    バルトーク最高か!

  • @patrickbecker4473
    @patrickbecker4473 2 года назад

    Good to hear, where Tan Dun got the inspiration for his soundtrack to ‘The Banquet.’

  • @jaco04750638
    @jaco04750638 6 лет назад +1

    I Love Bortok

  • @jackneefus
    @jackneefus 5 лет назад +1

    Now this is the kind of Bartok piece that inspires all the heavy metal musicians.

  • @jsabuilds2404
    @jsabuilds2404 3 года назад +1

    Musiques Nocturnes is my favorite, with all those strange chromatic glissandos and grace notes. I would love to learn how to play it.

  • @mungiljeon7468
    @mungiljeon7468 10 лет назад

    Wow

  • @johnnynoirman
    @johnnynoirman 6 лет назад +2

    Bartok is my favorite!

  • @user-qy6un4vb5q
    @user-qy6un4vb5q 8 лет назад

    I was freaking out into the second measure jeez it really sounds like a murderer banging on my door

  • @nicholasboros6079
    @nicholasboros6079 Год назад +1

    Ah crap... I'm completely out of doors.

    • @Imanoooob645
      @Imanoooob645 Год назад

      That's not the point....
      It means outside

  • @TimYocraft
    @TimYocraft 3 года назад +2

    Without Bartok there will be no Tigran Hamasyan

  • @Maximilian2808
    @Maximilian2808 3 года назад +2

    there is a part in sacre that sounds like the beginning here

  • @gcravista
    @gcravista 10 лет назад +1

    Played on MIDI Casio 1984 and viewed in Cubase 1500 :P

  • @pageljazz
    @pageljazz 12 лет назад

    Hey, you're right!

  • @E_FoxSnowspirit
    @E_FoxSnowspirit 23 дня назад

    I was wondering why this piece could've had more emotion in it... it's a freaking midi track

  • @mayokota_
    @mayokota_ 6 лет назад +2

    Your comments about the pieces, hahaha oh i can't

  • @Ansemesser
    @Ansemesser 5 лет назад +1

    There is an error according to the sheet in 'Musiques Nocturens' when the choral tune enters; on 8:34 the audio file is playing a d# and not a d as it says in the sheet

    • @NF30
      @NF30 4 года назад

      There's another one at 12:22. The sheet music says D# and the MIDI file plays D. This is the type of thing where I would make my own MIDI file of it and listen to it instead, just to fix the mistake.

  • @florianaltwegg1274
    @florianaltwegg1274 7 лет назад +8

    is this MIDI seriously? The chase is played so inhumane it is hard to believe its real but also hard to believe its MIDI.

  • @sergiohman
    @sergiohman 2 года назад

    Está loco

  • @Soytu19
    @Soytu19 9 лет назад +12

    6:40

  • @lynnes2947
    @lynnes2947 6 лет назад +1

    this is spooky cool/love it

  • @d34u8bdf2
    @d34u8bdf2 6 лет назад

    I wonder where did he get his folk song reference for this piece.
    If anyone can send me the source of the piece that he referenced to, I would be appreciated.

  • @vonMohl
    @vonMohl 9 лет назад +13

    I could not walk stright after listening to that "music"

    • @vonMohl
      @vonMohl 8 лет назад

      +Stuart Campbell good question ask Bela.

    • @sneddypie
      @sneddypie 4 года назад +1

      if you struggle to see music in this, learn some theory, maybe you will even be able to remotely understand this music

  • @palmaiattila3288
    @palmaiattila3288 4 года назад

    Excellent, it sounds unbelievable realistic and authentic. Please read the comments here, and try to correct the mentioned tonal errors.

  • @bvbwv3
    @bvbwv3 3 года назад

    allarmunumralla! What fun you are with your perfect movement descriptions. The mystery pianist is fabulous. May we know who, please??? - Oh - is it John Milbauer?

  • @TheMathDieu
    @TheMathDieu 6 лет назад +2

    how hard is this piece to play? (what grade is it)

    • @sebastianzaczek
      @sebastianzaczek 6 лет назад +2

      I play the piano for about 9 years now (i'm 16 now) and it took me about 4 or 5 days to learn "With drums and pipes", the second movement probably took one and a half weeks for me to learn, so the pieces aren't that hard...
      The difficult thing about the First movement is that you have to play many nineths in the left hand, but otherwise it's a relatively simple piece... also it is worth to mention that the piece sounds waaay better on a grand piano than on an upright...
      The second movement is a rhythmical challenge at first (form bars 9 to 45 it changes time signature every single bar) and memorizing all the notes and variations on the little structures will take some time, but it's certainly doable and you will find a lot of patterns in the piece...
      Side note: I said it only took me a little time to *learn* the pieces, not to *master* them...

  • @simonkawasaki4229
    @simonkawasaki4229 5 лет назад +3

    Interesting how the Night Music movement has the upper treble clef as a separate instrument!

  • @Prokofiev2023
    @Prokofiev2023 4 года назад

    4; the best.

  • @leomoore3597
    @leomoore3597 3 года назад

    It don't mean a thing, if it ain't got that swing !

  • @RichardASalisbury1
    @RichardASalisbury1 4 года назад +3

    I've loved Bartok's music for over 60 years, but find this piece terrifying. I wonder: maybe this is the out-of-doors that surrounded the peasant villages and farms of Hungary, Rumania, and Bulgaria where he searched out the music that became his music and made him as a composer. Maybe it is the out-of-doors beyond the cultivated land, before there were electric lights and maybe, where he traveled then, before there were even gas lamps--out where the night was truly dark and where there might still have been dangerous predators or at least, everywhere, strange, unknowable creatures.

  • @sneddypie
    @sneddypie 4 года назад

    i want to learn rhis

  • @none5020
    @none5020 3 года назад

    I see this guy REALLY loves major key, or really ANY key.

  • @jaspernatchez
    @jaspernatchez 12 лет назад

    I just noticed you're right! Shit, had me fooled.

  • @kaleidoscopio5
    @kaleidoscopio5 5 лет назад +1

    After listen this I am agorafobic now 😵

  • @ericrakestraw664
    @ericrakestraw664 5 лет назад +1

    What do all the mustaches in the score mean?

  • @andreassundstrom1297
    @andreassundstrom1297 9 месяцев назад

    Sounds like music from a haunted house in a video game..

  • @douwemusic
    @douwemusic 10 лет назад +1

    0:25 there's no limit

  • @davidbrookspiano
    @davidbrookspiano 10 лет назад

    Holy robotic playing, Batman!

  • @TheCitybike
    @TheCitybike 2 года назад

    Very good!! Who plays?

  • @jaspernatchez
    @jaspernatchez 12 лет назад

    I think he must have used a diff edition. I was too lazy last night to turn off the a/c so I could hear better, but this morning i checked, he plays, e.g. at 7:00, an F# octave, but top note is G.

  • @sir_john_mcgrand3534
    @sir_john_mcgrand3534 8 лет назад +9

    In the first part, at 0:41 there appears a very good melodic line, but to 0:59 it totally collapses. Do you think it would be great if Bartok saved and developed it? I do.

    • @EsPoReNg
      @EsPoReNg 7 лет назад +6

      I think stuff like this all the time. I think composers avoid fulfilling the listener's expectations like this because doing so might give a sense of "completeness" way too soon for their intentions.

    • @MusicalMissCapri
      @MusicalMissCapri 6 лет назад +1

      Or they just can't come up with any more to add to that melody.

    • @Myagooshki
      @Myagooshki 5 лет назад

      The melody comes in again at the end of the first movement and derivatives of the rhythm come before and after that part. Actually now that I'm in the second Movement I hear it in here too. But the part that really gets me is the lydian stuff around 0:28. I started learning this on the piano once and to play that part slowly while practicing it is beautiful.

    • @PaulVinonaama
      @PaulVinonaama 2 года назад

      But he already grinds it for quite a while. Incidentally, a real pianist might bring out the left hand part a little more at 0:50 or so.

  • @harryandruschak2843
    @harryandruschak2843 8 лет назад

    "Like" on 17 March 2016

  • @dingdingdone
    @dingdingdone 6 лет назад +1

    Who played these?

  • @yvesgerard1308
    @yvesgerard1308 9 лет назад

    J' ai dû rater un épisode là ... Il s' agit d' une création " midi " ? Pas de pianiste ? ... What the f... C' est encore plus fort !

    • @dominiquepautrel5992
      @dominiquepautrel5992 9 лет назад

      Plus fort non je dirais pas ça... Si c'est du boulot de retranscrire une partition en midi, c'en est bien plus encore soit d'apprendre la pièce à ses dix doigts, soit d'apprendre à jouer ce qu'on lit si parfaitement qu'on a besoin que d'un autre lecteur pour tourner les pages...
      Et je confirme c'est du midi... en écoutant les vélocités, la dynamique de chaque note... L'instrumentiste cherche bien sur à avoir un jeu égal dans toutes ses phrases, mais ici c'est si parfait que c'en est inhumain...
      Ou alors peut-être la pièce a réellement été jouée, mais ensuite corrigée, note à note ou par groupes de notes... En vélocité comme en quantisation (mise en place rythmique)... :)

  • @Imanoooob645
    @Imanoooob645 Год назад

    Nightmares in the outdoors....