Iran vs Israel vs Hezbollah: Who makes the first move to war? | Trita Parsi | The Big Picture S5E2

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
  • What is the price tag for convincing Iran to back down?
    The US is desperately trying to keep a lid on the heightened tensions in the Middle East, following Israel’s assassination of Hamas chief Ismail Hanieyeh in Iran’s capital, and the airstrike on a Beirut suburb that killed senior Hezbollah commander Fuad Shukr.
    Benjamin Netanyahu seems determined to escalate tensions with Iran to the brink of war, largely to keep himself in power.
    Iran, meanwhile, has made it very clear that war is the last thing it wants. But after Israel’s attack on its embassy in April that pushed it to launch hundreds of retaliatory drones as a deterrent against further attacks, Iran finds itself again in the spotlight.
    What will it decide to do?
    This week on The Big Picture Podcast, we sit down with political analyst Trita Parsi to talk about what each party really wants to achieve from a confrontation, and what it would take for Iran to save face without escalating into all out war.
    Paris was the founder and former president of the Iranian-American National Council and is currently the executive vice president of the Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft.
    The frightening reality is - even if no one really wants a war - we may be just one tiny miscalculation away from a point of no return.
    Subscribe and listen on all podcast platforms: thebigpicture....
    Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
    Follow us on TikTok: / middleeasteye
    Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
    Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
    Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye

Комментарии • 734

  • @Madadaal
    @Madadaal Месяц назад +215

    Wake up, free Americans from AIPAC!

    • @y.m.505
      @y.m.505 Месяц назад

      Wake up, free America and the West from I$lam!

    • @SBana-xq2jl
      @SBana-xq2jl Месяц назад

      This guy Trita Parsy is a NIAC member mouth piece for the oppresive terrorist theocratic regime of Iran and everybody knows that.

    • @TheShocobo
      @TheShocobo 28 дней назад

      What is the relation here?
      The IRGC that controls Iran is a dictatorship, it is only supported by 20% of the people.
      By the way, Parsi, gets paid by the Quincy Institute with major donations from prominent philanthropists such as George Soros and Charles Koch.
      Parsi is very biased, and probably supported by the IRGC as well

    • @sambomambojambotango3961
      @sambomambojambotango3961 28 дней назад +8

      and the FED!

    • @shahakeitan
      @shahakeitan 27 дней назад

      Only a haunted person can think that 0.2% of the earth's inhabitants control 99.8%!!!!!

  • @StateOfPurgatory
    @StateOfPurgatory Месяц назад +142

    If. Netanyahu was not absolutely supported by AIPAC he wouldn’t go far

    • @tyfromuzi5871
      @tyfromuzi5871 28 дней назад

      They went so far as to have his balls Incase he didn't march

    • @shahakeitan
      @shahakeitan 27 дней назад

      Only a haunted person can think that 0.2% of the earth's inhabitants control 99.8%!!!!!

    • @rsb0000
      @rsb0000 26 дней назад

      Simikar for Hamas

  • @lydiavui1029
    @lydiavui1029 Месяц назад +93

    Psychologically Netanyahu is a ''game player''. ''Game players'' are not interested in truth, integrity, morals, ethics or humanity - they are only interested in their ''own will' - getting whatever is beneficial for himself only - he has no interest in the well being of anyone else. Those who follow him are the same.

    • @rebeccacrossley8733
      @rebeccacrossley8733 Месяц назад +4

      Amen

    • @oanna1221
      @oanna1221 29 дней назад

      We in usa have a head of defense that is a calamity. Need to cut off purse strings. Yahuu is hitler of 2000. Has had many chance to stop war. Rejected deal. Our goverment is a mess. Harris and that guy. Will have the entire usa in flames. That fiasco with riots and their approvals. Yet Jan 6st labled those people terrorist. Honestly. This needs to end with trump/ vance. With Harris and that guy. America is fkd.

    • @sambomambojambotango3961
      @sambomambojambotango3961 28 дней назад +6

      You mean he is a Pscycopath?

    • @arturallay8116
      @arturallay8116 28 дней назад +3

      @@lydiavui1029 oh you mean like Hifler

    • @shahakeitan
      @shahakeitan 27 дней назад +1

      Shere with us your truth

  • @Vict-nu4id
    @Vict-nu4id Месяц назад +149

    Israel has already started the war. Iran has full right to defend themselves

    • @Amira_Jessa
      @Amira_Jessa Месяц назад +4

      True. But i don't think iran wants to

    • @ShaistaAziz-mu9kb
      @ShaistaAziz-mu9kb Месяц назад

      Israel wants Iran to. It’s what Netanyahu has wanted for a long time! He keeps goading the Iranians. Satanyahu knows he has America by the balls!

    • @NomadicSlr
      @NomadicSlr Месяц назад +16

      Israel is notorious for throwing the first punch then running back to the US to get assistance for "self defense" - like brothers in the playground where the little one is actually the bully despite that the big one is doing most of the fighting.

    • @sergeylibster9654
      @sergeylibster9654 Месяц назад +12

      Lmao... Iranian proxies attacking Israel for decades....

    • @flamboyentpromotions3471
      @flamboyentpromotions3471 Месяц назад +13

      @@sergeylibster9654which ones? Hamas has a legitimate beef with Israel that does not involve Iran, so does/ did Hezbollah an the Houthi have not been attacking Israel for years.

  • @chrismalcomson7640
    @chrismalcomson7640 Месяц назад +60

    The view of Iran throughout this conflict has changed radically. Its pragmatic, thoughtful and measured in its approach and occupies the moral highground. The image Israel likes to push, of this insane terror supporting regime that sponsors terrorism doesn't seem to fit anymore. Many people who support a ceasefire and and end to the occupation now view Iran as one of the good guys..

    • @jazzman1904
      @jazzman1904 29 дней назад +7

      These two have spoken about how Iran has supplied Hesbolla with over 100,000 rockets and you claim Iran is an honest broker?

    • @sanammahootchi4194
      @sanammahootchi4194 28 дней назад

      Trita Parsi and Vali Nasr are sons of two extreme Islamic terrorists who brought Shia extremism to Iran by terror and their role is to strengthen Islamic hegemony in the West by demonizing Israel and running West from within.. do not trust a word they say.. by the way Trita Parsi is a false name, his name is not Parsi, he’s an Islamist who has changed his name

    • @sallyrussell397
      @sallyrussell397 28 дней назад

      BOYCOTT AND SANCTION AGAINST ISRAEL GOVERNMENT

    • @valerietweedie4376
      @valerietweedie4376 27 дней назад

      Chrismalcomson - Outstanding comment!

    • @robertmmuhavi3358
      @robertmmuhavi3358 27 дней назад

      I am surprised at that

  • @Bavafa1
    @Bavafa1 Месяц назад +86

    What’s the difference between Isrealis and NOT-Zs? NOT-Zs fought and paid for their own battles.

    • @averayugen7802
      @averayugen7802 Месяц назад +18

      Both are NOT-SEE's. Selfish predatory and abusive!!!

    • @tao4124
      @tao4124 Месяц назад

      The difference is israelis won vvvv2. Since then, they control US and western nations. We were warned.

    • @tao4124
      @tao4124 Месяц назад +12

      BS. They deleted my commentary. The real difference is not allowed to say in RUclips.

    • @Bavafa1
      @Bavafa1 Месяц назад +6

      @@tao4124 Welcome to my world at UT

    • @knockknock1246
      @knockknock1246 Месяц назад

      Do non zionists spit on Christian clergy and pilgrims in faux Israel too. Yes. Do non zionists want talmudic and noahide laws systems to govern the world too? Yes. Do non zionists want Christianity and Islam illegal in faux Israel too? Go read the Talmud, it's in all their synagogues. Don't try and help them create a new ptiy me narrative. They're ALL done.

  • @4376mb
    @4376mb 27 дней назад +5

    Ridiculous to think Kamala Harris will change policy. Policy will change her.

  • @kewsr6972
    @kewsr6972 29 дней назад +22

    No sure about Mr. Paesi's analysis about Harris taking a different stance from Biden. How did he see this? Nothing that's come out of her mouth has shown thus. She did say Israel has a right to defend itself. We're way beyond that now so enough said. In fact, she's already proven to be quite a disappointment for those wanting peace and believing in human rights and having even a tiny bit of morality. Not there with her unfortunately.

    • @EmmaKing30
      @EmmaKing30 29 дней назад +3

      It’s because of the implications of taking a stance on the matter in the election . Mr. Parsi’s analysis is right in the sense that Harris is quiet because on one hand if you take a hardline on Israel, it will please a lot of minority base that’s in swing states which may win her the election but it will upset AIPAC who will counter by supporting pro-Israel candidates for Congress & if she won the election, she’d have to deal with majority Republican HOC

    • @miacat1727
      @miacat1727 26 дней назад +2

      She did say (after the Palestine school was bombed by IDF) Quote: "These killings are enough". How far this will go depends on allot.

    • @miacat1727
      @miacat1727 26 дней назад +1

      She did say Quote; "these deaths are enough". How far this will go remains to be seen.

    • @gokeoluyemo
      @gokeoluyemo 25 дней назад +1

      However even if you have a different perspective or stance. In the USA Today there is a limit to what you can say or do if you have any interest in actually winning the election. And that’s the truth. If you don’t know you need to learn more

  • @360tailslidfaceplant
    @360tailslidfaceplant 28 дней назад +5

    I'm screaming into the wind here, but I have a serious question for Mr. Parsi. Energy independence actually isn't the only US interest in the middle east. It's the fact that without US support to gulf monarchies they might think about not trading oil in dollars anymore? And THAT would actually be devastating for the US economy. Now that's an imperial reason still, and I don't support it. But until that fact changes the US investor class will have an interest in making sure the Middle east oil is traded in dollars. Unless the whole world switches to an alternative tomorrow, which doesn't needed to be traded in a reserve currency, then I think the US (investor class) has an interest in the middle east unfortunately.

  • @BNFaraj-vy9zh
    @BNFaraj-vy9zh 28 дней назад +5

    But how does any of that preserve the interests of the military-industrial complex? If peace broke out tomorrow, do you think these military factories would retool overnight to start making refrigerators?!

    • @anahita1984
      @anahita1984 13 дней назад +1

      Very well said! 👏👏👏👏

  • @user-js4sb4qq2h
    @user-js4sb4qq2h 27 дней назад +4

    Such an eloquent, insightful, precise, strategic conversation!

  • @TripDarlin
    @TripDarlin Месяц назад +34

    kamala will do nothing

    • @uchangeng8954
      @uchangeng8954 Месяц назад +8

      Except giggling 😂

    • @thinkingtoomuch7974
      @thinkingtoomuch7974 Месяц назад +5

      Why would she?

    • @gnostic268
      @gnostic268 Месяц назад

      She only does and says what her husband Doug Emhoff tells her behind the scenes. That's why she sounds so stupid in public.

    • @Investormillard
      @Investormillard 28 дней назад

      Wrong she openly supports hamas and will get much worse!😅

  • @catherineali7790
    @catherineali7790 Месяц назад +45

    Thankyou for that talk. Very interesting. Clarified many things for me 👌👏
    I stand with Palestine
    🇵🇸 💯 ❤️

    • @shahakeitan
      @shahakeitan 27 дней назад

      ruclips.net/video/EWPFmdAWRZ0/видео.htmlsi=4oO-ASj8e41vE0Ah

    • @KiX-lr9fo
      @KiX-lr9fo 25 дней назад

      😂 😂 😂 You're lost bro!

    • @Ir-of4zn
      @Ir-of4zn 11 дней назад +1

      Thank you for that talk. Very interesting. Clarified many things for me: I STAND WITH ISRAEL.. 🇮🇱

  • @user-eo3gb1cq9d
    @user-eo3gb1cq9d Месяц назад +171

    The 7th October would never have happened if the European zoinest had to stay in Britain where they came from 😳 what is the European zoinest doing in the middle east 😳 Netanyahu was from Poland

    • @tamiiymchristine
      @tamiiymchristine Месяц назад +14

      Israel was given to the Israelites by the hand of God. Silence with your falsehoods. Israel is the apple of God's eye whether you believe it or not. God bless you.

    • @UsualYaddaYadda
      @UsualYaddaYadda Месяц назад +8

      Both of you sre repeating fictional tropes

    • @stevehughes2731
      @stevehughes2731 Месяц назад

      ​@@tamiiymchristinenice fairytale, now let's get to talking facts. Since becoming an illegal colonialist country (1948) until now, you have been commiting ethnic cleansing, to rid a people, whom belonged to the land (for millennia) to forward Zionism, a movement of European Ashkenazi Jews. Left thousands of years ago, brown, came back white 😮

    • @rayahassan8033
      @rayahassan8033 Месяц назад +24

      ​​@@tamiiymchristine u're wrong. Their bibles are changed and u still believe that?. Israel was never a country but another name of prophet Yaqoob AS. U're talking about the bani Israel. Bani means children so they were the children of israel. And they were muslims at that time following prophet Musa AS. Go educate yourself

    • @rayahassan8033
      @rayahassan8033 Месяц назад

      ​@@tamiiymchristine so u think ur god allows genocide and killing of babies?. U think ur god would allow bombing of houses, hospitals and mosques?. Allah would never allow that.

  • @user-fn7ev7nx4c
    @user-fn7ev7nx4c Месяц назад +61

    The degree of dishonesty is so far over the top that no one can see the top anymore.

    • @tyfromuzi5871
      @tyfromuzi5871 28 дней назад +1

      Least no one doubts we are being lied to en mass

  • @GeorgeBrownIII
    @GeorgeBrownIII 29 дней назад +5

    This conversation assumes that Ismail Haniyeh is a neutral non-combatant. I would strongly disagree with this assumption.
    The policy of vaporising your enemy whenever the opportunity presents itself is a winning strategy.

    • @user-kh5qi1rm7h
      @user-kh5qi1rm7h 27 дней назад

      Yes true in the short term. In the long term Israel is doomed.

  • @user-zi9rr6ih2b
    @user-zi9rr6ih2b Месяц назад +63

    Great interview. really insightful

    • @johnkesich8696
      @johnkesich8696 29 дней назад

      Really? Hasbara much?
      What has Harris ever done to show actual support for Palestine? You do know she’s accepted over $5 M from AIPAC, right?
      That and her rude and dismissive response to pro Palestinian protestors in Detroit shows just what gaslighting this “analysis” is.
      No one who has yet to call what Israel is doing genocide should be trusted - they should probably be in the dock with Bibi.

  • @johnbondegaardmadsen6019
    @johnbondegaardmadsen6019 29 дней назад +3

    DR Parsi, who says this greater conflict can't be in the USA..?
    Americans Americans always talk nonsens and say conflicts take place far away...far away from the middle East could be the USA, right...
    You completely forget how many hundreds of Countries and billions of innocent civilians You killed or put in misery with USA sanctions...
    What if every Country in the rewarded USA as USA has rewarded those Countries...?
    How will 330 million Americans fight Nearly 7 billion people from around the World, if they passed by USA...?
    You Would be very busy and very scared, right....?
    It's not about what USA want anymore, it's about what the whole World wants...
    USA failed completely, so people don't care about you guys anymore

  • @chipparker3950
    @chipparker3950 26 дней назад +2

    All of American leadership needs to listen to this guy. Compliments to the interviewer for on point questions and remarks and letting the person interviewed fully develop his points and thoughts without interruption. Rare these days.

  • @starrbowie8649
    @starrbowie8649 Месяц назад +10

    The comment at about 55 min in about the Israelis not knowing there would be Palestinian resistance seems questionable. Early Zionist leaders Jabotinsky and Ben Gurion wrote that Palestine, the land proposed for tge establishment of Israel, was not only fully occupied but that its inhabitants would not relinquish any of it willingly. Invaders who have had to fight to gain the land know they have to maintain forces to keep the conquered from rebelling against their oppression. Once in power the oppressor prefers to rely on indoctrination to impose its supremacist lies on the conquered, and it may overestimate its success at times, but it is ever-vigilant and ever-ready to use arms. The Israelis consciously drove the Palestinians to resist by ever-increasing aggression -- they just underestimated the response.

  • @amdesidik305
    @amdesidik305 Месяц назад +47

    This is among the best analysis with regards the USA Israel & wars in the Middle East..

    • @sanammahootchi4194
      @sanammahootchi4194 28 дней назад

      Trita Parsi and Vali Nasr are sons of two extreme Islamic terrorists who brought Shia extremism to Iran by terror and their role is to strengthen Islamic hegemony in the West by demonizing Israel and running West from within.. do not trust a word they say.. by the way Trita Parsi is a false name, his name is not Parsi, he’s an Islamist who has changed his name

  • @gwenrobinson7433
    @gwenrobinson7433 Месяц назад +30

    Excellent conversation.

  • @AlDiallo
    @AlDiallo Месяц назад +19

    One of the best impartial analysis of the current situation in the middle that I heard recently.

  • @zulphysenior
    @zulphysenior Месяц назад +41

    Honestly many Ethiopian Jews especially those working in the IDF are planning to go back home since many of us in our homes we do talk about ho unfair the Ashkenazi Jews has been to other people. For me I'm literally hoping I can go back to Ethiopia to cultivate my ancestral land my father was giveb years ago. Ashkenazi Jews are in the wrong in many ways even they know it themselves.

    • @maryannechilds6459
      @maryannechilds6459 Месяц назад +1

      There r ethopians fighting in idf ? 😮

    • @MuhammadAttahiru-hg7rq
      @MuhammadAttahiru-hg7rq Месяц назад +18

      ​@@maryannechilds6459Yes, many. The unfortunate situation is that the 'white' European Jews treat them with disdain. They are not fully integrated because of the colour of their skin, very shameful situation.

    • @djangofett4879
      @djangofett4879 Месяц назад +8

      ​@@maryannechilds6459if they don't serve then the Israeli government will put them in prison. some people actually choose going to prison over having to join the IDF

    • @boforce9096
      @boforce9096 Месяц назад

      How can you have stepped into idf on the first place? Don't you know how izr:helli are dis:gusted by your race? Don't you have any self-respect?

    • @carolwatanabe7576
      @carolwatanabe7576 Месяц назад +6

      Why do they join and support the IDF if they resent the ashkenazi rule?

  • @SDR0505
    @SDR0505 Месяц назад +47

    Its almost 45 thousand deaths and thousands more injured too late for diplomacy. Time for talking should be over.

    • @ckidd2436
      @ckidd2436 Месяц назад +5

      Talking is the only way to peace.

    • @uchangeng8954
      @uchangeng8954 Месяц назад +4

      130+ hostages still in the tunnels somewhere.

    • @djangofett4879
      @djangofett4879 Месяц назад +16

      ​​@@uchangeng8954those hostages are safer with Hamas than they are with IDF. if IDF finds them, IDF is probably going to unalive them. that's what IDF tends to do to Israeli hostages.

    • @liuj88
      @liuj88 Месяц назад +5

      "Time for talking should be over."
      Say that to the survivors whose lives your position doesn't recognize.

    • @gabbycarter965
      @gabbycarter965 Месяц назад +1

      Should've been over 9 months ago. The Israeli government is very evil.

  • @asifalimirza
    @asifalimirza Месяц назад +4

    I actually think Mr. Parsi, just like Israel, has very little understanding of the resistance. The US government fully understands Iran and it's proxies, which is why their dream of toppling the regime for over 40 years has never been fulfilled

    • @anahita1984
      @anahita1984 13 дней назад

      Please elaborate

    • @asifalimirza
      @asifalimirza 13 дней назад

      @@anahita1984 ok. He doesn't know what he's talking about

    • @anahita1984
      @anahita1984 12 дней назад

      @@asifalimirza please will you elaborate on what you wrote above. Thank you.

    • @asifalimirza
      @asifalimirza 12 дней назад +1

      @@anahita1984 It's better I don't. Plus it would end up being a 10 page essay

    • @anahita1984
      @anahita1984 12 дней назад

      @@asifalimirza okay.

  • @colettescobie1878
    @colettescobie1878 Месяц назад +16

    I dont know about the views of Irish American community from whom Biden claims his roots, but Irish people and the Irish government are very supportive of the Palestinians and have called for a ceasefire and are committed to recognizing the Palestinian state

  • @snnetwork8420
    @snnetwork8420 Месяц назад +18

    Excellent analysis by Mr Parsi. Hope you have him back for round 2!

  • @TheShocobo
    @TheShocobo 28 дней назад +4

    Trita Parsi supports the IRGC, this is NOT impartial analysis!

  • @remisofola5703
    @remisofola5703 Месяц назад +4

    The cease fire proposal is not viable, this is not in the interest of Israel that will not accept it. Iran has to respond militarily, but Israel will take advantage of this by luring US into a wider conflict with Iran. The cost has to be great for the US to stop this from happening, I doubt this will hinder it from the folly of the US.

  • @soleboxy
    @soleboxy 29 дней назад +3

    This is so odd they are analyzing the middle east like it's a football game

    • @soleboxy
      @soleboxy 29 дней назад

      Iran has made a dramatic step of firing 350 missiles and drones at israel and somehow it's a Benjamin netanyahu powerplay? So weird

    • @phasematerialsresearch9319
      @phasematerialsresearch9319 27 дней назад +1

      @@soleboxy And how many people did those missiles kill? 0

  • @airdee
    @airdee Месяц назад +20

    Thank you for having Trita on. he is always clear and on point

  • @annamaedevlin1713
    @annamaedevlin1713 Месяц назад +21

    GREAT VIDEO!

  • @user-qc2gy2lt3m
    @user-qc2gy2lt3m Месяц назад +7

    It's Netanyahu who does want the USA has improved relationship with Iran.Newly elected president of Iran has thrown his olive branch to the USA.The USA is trying to have good relationship with Iran but everytime Netanyahu rocks the boat.

    • @twatts1523
      @twatts1523 29 дней назад

      Hillary Clinton will have some influence, too.

    • @hunger4jsutice
      @hunger4jsutice 29 дней назад

      You are delusional

    • @JigilJigil
      @JigilJigil 20 дней назад

      Iran supreme leader has been always against it and actually he has said multiple times that he won't allow it happen ever.

  • @noahsark2009
    @noahsark2009 29 дней назад +5

    Have Haviv Rettig Gur on your podcast. It's interesting how Iran's support of Hamas, Hezbollah, the Houthis and Shia militias in Syrian and Iraq is not seen as destabilizing. Please explain.

    • @mohammadjavad.iranian1992
      @mohammadjavad.iranian1992 25 дней назад +2

      For the same reason as during apartheid in South Africa, Iran was called a supporter of terrorism(They meant Nelson Mandela). I hope you never become a school teacher because I am sure that instead of dealing with the spoiled school bully, you will punish the students who are not willing to listen to him.

  • @frankvanderpoll432
    @frankvanderpoll432 Месяц назад +2

    I very much enjoyed the interview. Professor Parsi offers a thoughtful analysis of the shifting balance of power in the region and beyond. What I've been missing in the conversation though, may be something of an elephant in the room, which is the Iranian regime's publically declared intention to destroy the state of Israel, together with the official denial of its intention to develop a nuclear arsenal. However one might be able to gauge these intentions, they are perceived as an existential threat in Israel, so much so that even the fiercest critics of the current goverment seem to agree on that perception.
    To underestimate the consequences of this might be a fatal mistake. The Israeli leadership seems to be intent on stepping up the escalation ladder in order to drag the US and its allies into a war with Iran. First to be hit, should this occur, could very well be Iran's nuclear installations, because to Israel, they have become the symbol of the regime's intentions and as such, a manifestation of the desire of many living in the region to correct the "historical injustice" and wipe Israel of the map. No matter where you stand on this idea, I think that anyone rejoicing in the idea of seeing the "Zionist State" defeated and destroyed, should consider that the price in order for this to happen is beyond anyone's ability to foresee, but might be far too high for all of us. I would welcome any guest on your show that could offer more insight and understanding, as a way to create common ground and against false beliefs and ignorance, which are the true enemies to each of us.
    It's my hope is that we, as human beings, are capable of transcending our self-righteousness and will be willing to end the "holy wars" we are waging upon one another. So much is to be lost if we don't.

  • @peterkerruish8136
    @peterkerruish8136 28 дней назад +1

    I appreciate your channel, your thoughts but i cannot handle your adverts that go on forever,or until i press "skip"- Unacceptable!!

  • @moeduroodchi2161
    @moeduroodchi2161 26 дней назад +2

    #Zionism another American and British made, ... monster.

  • @mohammadmalekniaz6670
    @mohammadmalekniaz6670 27 дней назад +1

    Obviously Iran is not paying Trista’s wages . He doesn’t have any other job except talking about Iran . That leaves US as his employer!

  • @ourcommonbeliefs
    @ourcommonbeliefs 28 дней назад +2

    Very important discussion and disturbing. Praying for miracles

  • @arturallay8116
    @arturallay8116 Месяц назад +2

    I can’t listen to any stupid who says Russia can’t even reach Kiev

  • @pavel0900
    @pavel0900 Месяц назад +1

    “Reckless and rogue Benjamin Netanyahu” really?! I mean really??? Reminder, you are speaking of the ONLY democracy in the region and its democratically elected leader. Israeli leader is doing a million times better, especially if compared to Iran or its proxies, where rogue and reckless government is the least of everyone’s concerns. You lost me at 2:00

  • @jeps.e4305
    @jeps.e4305 29 дней назад +2

    Why is no one talking about the October 7th

  • @Fatimaal.i
    @Fatimaal.i Месяц назад +43

    Oh God, protect our Muslim brothers, male and female, in the land of Palestine and in every place and time

    • @tamiiymchristine
      @tamiiymchristine Месяц назад

      Call on the name of Jesus Christ the Risen Savior for protection. There is no other name by which salvation comes. God bless you.

    • @ChannelMath
      @ChannelMath Месяц назад

      lol you guys

    • @viktoriyaserebryakov2755
      @viktoriyaserebryakov2755 Месяц назад +1

      Protect them from hamas.

    • @SilasGreenback
      @SilasGreenback Месяц назад

      ​@tamiiymchristineragercollins
      When you say God bless you, do you mean God or the prophet Jesus (as).

    • @chanking7520
      @chanking7520 29 дней назад +1

      Alhamdulilah

  • @1979risky
    @1979risky 28 дней назад +1

    If you are watching this, you are watching terribly bad analysis. If Netanyahu leaves, someone worse could take his place? Nobody in the current coalition can hold a coalition. Even another politician from Likud wouldnt be able to keep the right wing coalition together. That is very common knowledge.
    Assassination of Hezbollah and Hamas leaders is considered escalation? So the bombing of Majd Al Shahms football ground was what? It was a retaliation for the deliberate targeting and murder of many children. That is also common knowledge.
    These two are frankly lacking the most basic knowledge of the conflict. Utterly useless, propaganda rubbish.

  • @ICHope1
    @ICHope1 Месяц назад +3

    Vote Green!

  • @philipzaccheus8398
    @philipzaccheus8398 Месяц назад +4

    RIGHT IS MIGHTY MIGHT WITHOUT REMORSE FOR ALL FORMER COLONIALISMIC CAPITALISM SUBJECTS

  • @Ir-of4zn
    @Ir-of4zn 11 дней назад +1

    Israel is fighting for its life....prayers for Israel...

  • @4376mb
    @4376mb 27 дней назад +1

    The bipartisan uniparty will fully support military and financial support for Israel.

  • @Vista-gn1pb
    @Vista-gn1pb Месяц назад +3

    If you are not paying any attention in middle east politics, first move has already been made and tested..

  • @SlashB100
    @SlashB100 Месяц назад +4

    If the Iranians are sensible and rational, why don't they put the interest of their people before terrorists proxies and make peace with Israel? There is no reason iran must destroy their beautiful country religiously driven hatred to wards Israel.

    • @hunger4jsutice
      @hunger4jsutice 29 дней назад

      😂 make peace with the devil and wonder why you find yourself in hell?

  • @dromgarvan
    @dromgarvan 26 дней назад +2

    No,mention of the barbaric attack on the 7th!

  • @edprotas4148
    @edprotas4148 Месяц назад +9

    I compare this point in time to the Cuban Missile Crisis. Clearly there was an extreem effort to solve a complex issue while avoiding an escallation. That seems missing now.

    • @pennylaprebendere7804
      @pennylaprebendere7804 Месяц назад +2

      I compare it to Nazi Germany, except for this time the United States is not fighting the Nazis.

    • @bapbap22
      @bapbap22 Месяц назад

      There is no leadership to put in that effort. Everyone is acting on out of sight, out of mind. They don’t want to dirty their hands in case they get it wrong.

  • @molliestanton2869
    @molliestanton2869 26 дней назад

    Mr. Parsi gave a brilliant, nuanced analysis in this interview!!

  • @clawmarx5393
    @clawmarx5393 Месяц назад +2

    ~ 50 min Interviewer expands on Biden's view that Israel serves as USA's "power projector." If granted, question I have is, To what purpose? What is the use or need to project power in that region? Is it just power for Chest Thumping creds, or is there something being gained from that "power." If it's about oil -- then why sanction ie. Iraq & Iran ability to market oil? Isn't it easier & cheaper to just compete and trade?

  • @moniquethiebaut2690
    @moniquethiebaut2690 27 дней назад +1

    From France 🌏🌍🌎👂🏽🧐, Israël is training all the World in the 3 World War.

  • @fredm.7145
    @fredm.7145 27 дней назад +2

    This is hilarious. Either Kamala means a new approach or doesn't. You can't have both ways. How is Kamala a new direction but she is prone to be manipulated by Netanyahu. So i't business as usual. He acts as if U.S., politicians have no choice but to defend Israel. We do have choice. Politicians if they cared about the U.S. would be working to protect us instead of Israel.

    • @explorer0213
      @explorer0213 27 дней назад

      Only bank accounts count.!!!

  • @deedrake4846
    @deedrake4846 Месяц назад +2

    Iranian "regime"? Get lost

  • @user-rh9gl3ig1q
    @user-rh9gl3ig1q Месяц назад +6

    Where are the champions of so called human rights freedom equality 50000 children women and infrastructure gone common now please people can see what u people are really about selective condemnation

    • @brianmartin5085
      @brianmartin5085 Месяц назад

      50,000??? And not a single one was a Hamas soldier? In what world do you think that's real?

  • @JigilJigil
    @JigilJigil 20 дней назад

    For those who are not aware, Trita Parsi works for Iranian regime.

  • @vernatheodore6296
    @vernatheodore6296 Месяц назад +10

    I am glad Iran did not go to war with Isreal. I was hoping Iran don't satisfy Natanyahu desire to distroy Iran. Natanyahu and his government has a plan, One of his leader, she is a woman actually said on a live video that isreal will take the whole of Palistan, and all the other Arab lands,she call the name of the other lands around Palistan and the last name she called was Iran. So i am glad Iran did not let Natanyahu get what he want, be patience.

    • @AbtinX
      @AbtinX Месяц назад

      Iran is at war with Israel. This is not true. There hasn't been an official declaration of war.

    • @user-xq3wh5ks8x
      @user-xq3wh5ks8x Месяц назад +1

      Israel never said that Iran is stupid maybe coward but not stupid

    • @o.z.p.
      @o.z.p. Месяц назад +1

      U.S. will not admit it to the public but isrl owns U.S. there will soon be civil unrest here. U.S. being a melting pot of ALL ethnicity who pay uncle sam, it will be horrendous. For a ppl without a land, they sure have their paws EVERYWHERE.

    • @safooranejrabi6613
      @safooranejrabi6613 Месяц назад

      Cc

    • @twatts1523
      @twatts1523 29 дней назад

      Yes, the want to expand into several other countries to create “Greater Israel”.

  • @sambomambojambotango3961
    @sambomambojambotango3961 28 дней назад +1

    The Rothchids own 60% of lands in Israel/Palestine.

    • @explorer0213
      @explorer0213 27 дней назад

      One of 5 richest in the world 550 trillion is that true or???

  • @boardoffisheries8640
    @boardoffisheries8640 Месяц назад +4

    Brilliant clear commentary

  • @mohammadmalekniaz6670
    @mohammadmalekniaz6670 27 дней назад

    Trita Parsi is an American national no different than other Americans who support the Us interest . He calls Iran a regime not elected government more valid than American regime.

  • @msbrisbane9370
    @msbrisbane9370 24 дня назад

    Iran's prestige is raised by its patience and non response...as contrast to Israel with no integrity.

  • @aromero385
    @aromero385 27 дней назад

    Good analisys and enlightenment of this near east situation.

  • @robertstar8240
    @robertstar8240 26 дней назад +1

    most likely Iran will move slow as always, they always try to deescalate all they can by waiting, only occident governments want them to attack nowwww, but don't think they'll take the bait

  • @karenramsburg8565
    @karenramsburg8565 28 дней назад +1

    Very interesting, insightful, and politically astute.

  • @user-eo3gb1cq9d
    @user-eo3gb1cq9d Месяц назад +13

    Thx having Trita always good listening to him

    • @tamiiymchristine
      @tamiiymchristine Месяц назад +1

      Jehovah Sabaoth, Jesus Christ, is Israel's great defender. He is the sky, the fog, the helicopter and the mountain. He says I will bless those who bless Israel and curse those who curse Israel. Hint ; Bless Israel. Or not. Your choice. God bless Israel

    • @annikamyren3026
      @annikamyren3026 Месяц назад +1

      ​@@tamiiymchristine😴😴😴😴

    • @kekennedy
      @kekennedy Месяц назад

      @@tamiiymchristine no wrong answer, what faith are you a part of? Christian, Judaism? I'm just trying to understand where you're finding your information.

  • @parwazekram7892
    @parwazekram7892 27 дней назад +1

    Excellent. Guest.

  • @kristianhermann5971
    @kristianhermann5971 Месяц назад +3

    Excellent interview! Thanks ❤

  • @rsb0000
    @rsb0000 26 дней назад

    Why is this war in Gaza an issue that muslims are concerned about.
    Sudanese muslims are killing each other, but muslims aren't to concerned.
    Isis salafists killed sufis and shia muslims but most muslims werent concerned.
    Turkey has occupied northern Syria - muslims are not bothered.
    Houthis vs Saudi - 1000s of muslims killed eac other, not a big concern for muslims.

  • @alinoberi2256
    @alinoberi2256 Месяц назад +2

    Interesting,you call Iran regime,but you don't call us regime or european regime,the same your I think so causing in Sweden
    Are you intelctuer or double face my friend?

  • @billyg54
    @billyg54 Месяц назад +8

    Trita is a very good analyst. Keep up the good work. Cheers

  • @omiid8393
    @omiid8393 Месяц назад +15

    As long as there are patriotic Iranians, regime change is impossible ❤️🇮🇷💪💪

    • @airdee
      @airdee Месяц назад +7

      unfortunately the regime does not represent majority of Iranians .

    • @kajsarezoo138
      @kajsarezoo138 Месяц назад

      @@airdeeit does the ones who supported the king who almost sold he’s country to the Zionists and the Iranians will never forget it was The us and rest of the west who supported Sadam Husain on the iraqi Iranian war and armed the Iraq with chemical weapons which were used against civilians.

    • @ArwinRahi
      @ArwinRahi Месяц назад

      ​@@airdeeNor does the US puppet Reza Pahlavi.

    • @amiralavy4431
      @amiralavy4431 Месяц назад

      As iranan i telling you 80% iranan supporting iranan government...don't believe everything you hear from Maine Media propaganda ..Fact ❤️🇮🇷​@airdee

    • @djangofett4879
      @djangofett4879 Месяц назад +6

      Iran isn't as cartoonishly evil as Israel but they're pretty bad. they don't actually care what Israel is doing to the Palestinians because Palestinians are the wrong sect. unfortunately there are no heroic governments in the region which are going to come to the Palestinians rescue. Iran cares about Iran and it's own sectarian interests, Palestinians arent included in that.
      the enemy of your enemy is not your friend. people need to learn that lesson.

  • @lizberezin2919
    @lizberezin2919 26 дней назад

    Where and when did Iran make the claim that war is the last thing it wanted? The last i heard, they declared many times that do want war. Hizbollha, which is their proxy, has also declared many times it will continue to make war, revenge for Shukr, etc.

  • @alhaah777
    @alhaah777 29 дней назад

    Very in-depth discussion and very insightful dialogue. Thank you both.

  • @tontontouzo
    @tontontouzo 29 дней назад

    This has been happening for 76 years…………………….. AMERICA wants this

  • @Adham4448
    @Adham4448 25 дней назад

    Parsi is not an objective analysis, he is working for the regime of Iran.

  • @nbach2202
    @nbach2202 Месяц назад +1

    You are talking about kamala as she matters. You're naive , gaulible, or demagogues.

  • @tomwyllie8027
    @tomwyllie8027 26 дней назад +1

    Nonsense . Kampala Harris has no say in anything . She will say and do what she is told.

  • @hoogiejackson4064
    @hoogiejackson4064 Месяц назад +1

    76 years ago these clowns from NY started ww3

  • @mouksb2000
    @mouksb2000 Месяц назад +1

    Fantastic interview....balanced, realistic and informative. Hats off to you both ! #Decolonise #Palestinian Revolution #PalestinianGenocide #Resist

  • @sarahfern7128
    @sarahfern7128 26 дней назад

    But Israel wants US to fight Iran.. If we do this, we will be very much weakened militarily and economically. Then doesn't Israel emerge as powerful politically, financially and militarily? Can 't it step in as military supplier to the world, both more than it is already, but also more than US?

  • @patrickgrove3469
    @patrickgrove3469 25 дней назад

    Excellent analysis.

  • @mehdifarid2864
    @mehdifarid2864 Месяц назад +3

    This guy is so smart. Nice to meet him.❤❤❤

  • @fitzroyarmour7391
    @fitzroyarmour7391 28 дней назад

    Official Islamic documents show that the Islamic Moon god Al 'lah' aka 'the greatest of deceivers' sent these two 'angels' ( demons) to teach black magic/obeah.

  • @rezashaygan6091
    @rezashaygan6091 27 дней назад

    Trita is a reformist who supports the government of the Islamic Republic of Iran. This person's opinions are not the opinions of the Iranian people. The people inside Iran know Trita and people like Trita are regime exports and hate them. They are Reza Pahlavi

  • @SusanKoech-ip1jk
    @SusanKoech-ip1jk 25 дней назад

    Maybe you two should also tell Iran to stop arming its proxies; hamas, Hesbolah, Houthies, Shia terrorists in Syria and Iraq etc

  • @masoodreyhani4769
    @masoodreyhani4769 28 дней назад

    Great interview

  • @GarySmithartist
    @GarySmithartist 29 дней назад +1

    But the USA survival requires the revenue from arms sales

  • @molliestanton2869
    @molliestanton2869 26 дней назад

    Brilliant, sensitive analysis!!!

  • @earthspirit516
    @earthspirit516 22 дня назад

    I think everyone just wants Israel to leave them alone.

  • @danbuda612
    @danbuda612 25 дней назад

    Which move are we talking about? Isreal and US have already made the war move.

  • @faridamazhar5114
    @faridamazhar5114 29 дней назад +1

    Doesn’t Biden see this! Why does he get fooled by Nathanyau!

    • @user-kh5qi1rm7h
      @user-kh5qi1rm7h 27 дней назад

      Because on the one hand he's a Zionist and on the other hand driven by Evangelicals.

  • @esmaanderson1802
    @esmaanderson1802 Месяц назад +2

    Trita Parsi always gives very good analyses of situations. Thanks for a very informative and insightful interview.

  • @scottweaverphotovideo
    @scottweaverphotovideo 29 дней назад +1

    Who is the show host?

  • @jacklaw3962
    @jacklaw3962 Месяц назад +12

    Calling Netanyahu 'rogue and reckless' for committing to the destruction of Hamas is the exact same as calling Churchill and FD Roosevelt rouge and reckless for NOT negotiating with the Nazis.

  • @johndewey6358
    @johndewey6358 Месяц назад +1

    Is it true that Mr. Parsi is the grandson of the famous Mr. Navab Safavi?

  • @mofrare
    @mofrare 28 дней назад

    BLM couldn't find Palestine on a map. Not sure where you got that.