Alhambra 7P vs Yamaha C40 Classical Guitars

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 дек 2024

Комментарии • 109

  • @amirsadrpour3456
    @amirsadrpour3456 6 лет назад +21

    the quality of your mic makes it hard to render an accurate judgement

  • @joshuabell8000
    @joshuabell8000 7 лет назад +2

    Im14 years old and my guitar teacher had me working on this song! I immidiatly recognized it as Waltz. Its really cool to recognize classical songs ive played

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  7 лет назад +1

      JB999 Mobile Gamplays That's right. Good luck in your classical guitar learning and thanks for the comment. :))

  • @1guy1wisdom
    @1guy1wisdom 2 года назад +3

    Definitivamente hay gente con la asombrosa capacidad de hacer sonar mal cualquier guitarra.

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  2 года назад

      He visto tus videos y eres un jugador muy talentoso. Gracias por el comentario. Que tenga un buen día, señor :)

    • @1guy1wisdom
      @1guy1wisdom 2 года назад +3

      @@ILoveMYOOZIK hola, es sólo un chiste, no te lo tomes a mal, tengo una alhambra 3c y quisiera una 7p o superior pero no puedo permitirmelo, hay que tratar de hacer lo mejor que se pueda con lo que se tenga.

  • @bonoandlavin
    @bonoandlavin 4 года назад +2

    I had a C40. Open strings and up up the 7 fret seem ok-ish but anything closer to the 8th to 12th frets especially on G string can totally expose how bad the C40 sounds when you pair it with a better guitar

  • @daidi9025
    @daidi9025 Год назад +1

    Hi ty for this comparison but i have a question, what do you think about playibility ? Is alhambra much more better in terms of playability or is it more difficult to play on it ?

  • @albee3610
    @albee3610 8 лет назад +5

    I think if you try playing beyond fifth fret flaws become more noticeable. C40 is a brilliant starter guitar though.

  • @mattbod
    @mattbod 4 года назад +1

    Comparison also against a spruce top and a cedar top so kinda hard to judge. I would recommend an Alhambra 3C as a very good first guitar that will take you well into intermediate level before you will yearn for anything better. It’s about €400.

  • @josejcastaneda5826
    @josejcastaneda5826 7 лет назад +3

    Yamaha makes wonderful products I have owned at leas 6 of the mid expensive line.

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  7 лет назад

      Jose J Castaneda They sure do. Thanks for the comment.

  • @johnbisp
    @johnbisp 8 лет назад +11

    Dear Sir
    The poor attack makes it difficult to hear. When you get better playing the different will be clear. Try practicing tirando and apoyando - good luck :-)

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  7 лет назад +1

      J thanks for the advice sir. I guess using the laptop's mic at that time didn't help much too :)

  • @dirkjanklijn9949
    @dirkjanklijn9949 3 года назад

    Played both and I wonder what made you choose a comparison of thes two totaly different guitars, Alhambra has teh best sound hands down but it's a concert guitar and the Yamaha is a starter learning guitar.

  • @777Wilderness
    @777Wilderness 7 лет назад +4

    The deeper,
    bolder sound of the lower strings seem clearly evident, which has always been the signature of a true Spanish guitars for me.. Alhambra!

  • @soulvaccination8679
    @soulvaccination8679 6 лет назад +1

    I understand fully what you are doing here.A lot of these comments are rude and immature.To me the Yamaha sounds just about as good as the more expensive guitar.

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  6 лет назад

      Donny brown I’m happy to see that some people do see the point. Some other people are somewhat blinded with their love of big names super expensive guitars that surely sound good but not as good for the price IMHO. In my opinion you can go a long way with this laminated top 100$ Yamaha guitar and it’s 10 times worth every penny you pay for it. Thanks for the comment. Much appreciated.

  • @johnrenshaw7684
    @johnrenshaw7684 8 лет назад

    All solid wood guitars will improve with age.An Alhambra 7C from the 1980's just sold on Ebay for £240(less than $300!) Solid Cedar Top,Solid Mahogany Back and Sides,in mint condition.If your a beginner buy a quality second hand all solid wood classical guitar,for some reason in the UK second hand they are fetching a fraction of the original retail prices,especially now the £ has collapsed in value.It will be a good investment at current UK prices!

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  8 лет назад

      John Renshaw You're absolutely right here. If you can get an all solid for a fraction of the price I see no reason why to not go for it. It's surely a good investment that will improve with time if properly taken care of.

  • @VILCAPAMPA
    @VILCAPAMPA 3 года назад +5

    Ni siquiera la guitarra CG192S de Yamaha se puede comparar con una guitarra Alhambra 7P. Alhambra es muy superior.

    • @Voxaac
      @Voxaac 2 года назад

      Ni siquiera es por ser "Alhambra", es que no hay manera de comparar un modelo gama baja con uno gama alta.

  • @SoumyadiptaRay
    @SoumyadiptaRay 6 лет назад

    i have a question...according all experts opinion.. which is/are best guitar/s within the budget of $1500-2000???

    • @plunderclat221
      @plunderclat221 6 лет назад +1

      Don't take advice from other people. Only trust your own ear. Don't know why you'd need a price range either... just play go some. Go for what makes you feel good.

  • @Ken_Fleming
    @Ken_Fleming 7 лет назад +1

    I got quiet a few top end guitars the guild I'm holding was one of the first of that model well over 40 years old when guild was guild which I got in the 70s second hand, there is no reason why this guitar could not be improved better strings for a start replace the nut and saddle may even improve the intonation, if you know what your doing, put a pick up on it and off you go still cheep but will sound a lot better at the moment It's not really a comparison with the Alhambra is it, but with a few tweaks who knows

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  7 лет назад

      Thanks for the comment. No it's not actually a comparison. It's just to show that, IMHO, in the classical guitar world you pay so much more to get a little better sound. I mean as you mentioned, with some little tweaks the C40 could sound a lot better than it does now. It costs at least 10 times less than the Alhambra.

  • @notmyname8527
    @notmyname8527 3 года назад

    The law of diminishing returns will always apply. So something 10 times more expensive wont be 10 times better.

  • @shailendranathgospelguitar
    @shailendranathgospelguitar 4 года назад +1

    Both are good

  • @klasikindo
    @klasikindo 7 лет назад +4

    If your playing technique is still low cheaper guitar will do the trick. Your opinion will sure change once you advance further. No one is stupid enough to pay a lot of money for nothing. There are more quality tones or colors you can bring out in more expensive guitars but you need to know how to.

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  7 лет назад

      klasikindoo You have a point sir. Thanks for commenting.

  • @vincentmaloney5835
    @vincentmaloney5835 5 лет назад +1

    It's like comparing apple and banana. Yamaha C40 is good in the beginnng, but then you want something better. Is Alhambra 7P worth the money? Yes, it is. It's even pleasant to hold in your hands. You cannot put it down. You want to play it all the time. It sounds much better than Yamaha C40. It will sound even more beautiful in 10 or 20 years. Yamaha C40 will always sound the same. Spruce top doesn't change the quality of sound with aging.

  • @swaroopsinha1738
    @swaroopsinha1738 6 лет назад +3

    those who say this comparation isnot good,did not have any idea about thevideo

  • @chunyaw
    @chunyaw 3 года назад

    In the past many guitarist prefer Jose Ramirez compare to Alhambra for the higher level.
    Beginner C40 Yamaha is enough. The older Yamaha guitar for the year 80th even better.

  • @ILoveMYOOZIK
    @ILoveMYOOZIK  6 лет назад

    Hi, I'm not that of an expert but I heard that Almansa and Alhambra make excellent guitars at this price point. Yamaha GC series (not CG) seem to be great too. But around 2000$ you should be able to get a fine luthier custom built guitar which might be the best choice for you. I'm sure there are real experts out there that might give you a piece of advice. Thanks for asking. It's actually a great question.

    • @miguelangelcolon1345
      @miguelangelcolon1345 Год назад

      @David Chatterton i have an Alhambra 1 cp $400 guitar and it says Made in Spain.

  • @alexwong9646
    @alexwong9646 4 года назад +1

    SOUND : Yamaha better softer
    Volume : The expensive one louder than C40

  • @MRbeqa100
    @MRbeqa100 6 лет назад +6

    Come on, even Alhambra 2C blows C40 away

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  6 лет назад +1

      b E q A Maybe you’re right but the question here is : does the difference in tone justify the difference in price? Is it 10 times better?

    • @mohamedchouiter1768
      @mohamedchouiter1768 4 года назад

      Bro Alhambra College, 1C, Z Nature, all sound better than Yamaha C40.

  • @azimahmed6764
    @azimahmed6764 8 лет назад

    bought one C40 today!! It's Indonesia made!

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  8 лет назад +1

      Azim Ahmed congratulations! Enjoy it!

    • @Genz95
      @Genz95 8 лет назад

      i just bought one too this week and i really like it :D

  • @OliverRoland1964
    @OliverRoland1964 7 лет назад +12

    You can't really compare two guitars of different classes. Take a Yamaha guitar of the same price class and then compare it.

  • @JAVIERGARCIA-wc2wl
    @JAVIERGARCIA-wc2wl 7 лет назад +6

    sin duda Alhambra suena mejor, pero no 10 veces mejor... NO entiendo mucho inglés, así que las cuerdas no se si son las mismas, parece que la diferencia está más en los bajos. Pero la Yamaha es muy buena, buenas maderas, buena construcción, excelente para empezar, es un instrumento galardonado en muchas partes y con el tiempo, haciendo uso de los métodos modernos y automatizados y rutinas de testeo numérico, yamaha está construyendo instrumentos tan buenos como aquellos que cuestan miles de dólares a un precio que podemos pagar los que no vivimos de la música pero si dedicamos tiempo al arte musical. Muchas gracias.

    • @miguelbarahona6636
      @miguelbarahona6636 7 лет назад

      Gracias, voy a comprar una Yamaha C70, me gusto mucho.

    • @andrespascual1164
      @andrespascual1164 5 лет назад

      Cierto. Practico guitarra clásica y comencé con Yamaha C 40, no me decepcionó y el precio muy asequible para cualquiera.

  • @heldersanches
    @heldersanches 4 года назад +1

    Buy the Yamaha and install a decent nut and saddle. 90% of the difference vanishes.

  • @juanmayotube
    @juanmayotube 4 года назад +3

    The sound difference is total.
    The Alhambra sounds like a guitar has to sound. The Yamaha in the video sounds like a toy guitar.

  • @rickescamilla5446
    @rickescamilla5446 6 лет назад +2

    Very little comparison. :-/

  • @miguelbalan348
    @miguelbalan348 7 лет назад

    I hear better base and deeper trebles in Alhambra I like how loud it is compare to Yamaha

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  7 лет назад +1

      It's at least 10 times the price of the C40. But is it 10 times better? This is the question... ;)

  • @christianmarloncortazar8213
    @christianmarloncortazar8213 6 лет назад

    What a comparison is this ???

  • @iggyosborn
    @iggyosborn 4 года назад

    With no offense meant to the performer, he does not demonstrate the difference between the two guitars; rather he shows that it is a waste for a person with person with little technique in classical guitar, to purchase an expensive instrument. Listen to Ana Vidovic's remarkable performance of Recuerdas de Alhambra, the most exquisite performance of it that I know.
    ruclips.net/video/fwjX-m4LkYk/видео.html
    You can be sure that she has the most remarkable guitar. But now think about her putting on a pair of leather workman's gloves and imagine her playing the same piece. Even on this guitar it would sound dull, almost mute. And this would be a problem with her hands, not with the guitar.
    The classical guitar is not mastered when a performer can make a C F and G. There are countless subtleties that must be mastered. In the example for this video here, the sound he is creating is largely made, whether intended or not, by the balls of his fingertips and not by his nails, and in this sense the potential of the guitar is almost totally inactivated: he might as well be playing a 60 dollar children's toy. I've played my entire life and during most of that time I have used second hand guitars I bought between 30 and 100 dollars because i could never bring out the quality of a better instrument. At this point, I could (marginally) if I worked studiously on the piece. Los Indios Caballeros found an abandoned guitar in the woods and started out with that -- only a culture of people of luxury are silly enough to think that the worth is in the price. It's the same thing when people buy exercise machines they use for a month or when they spend large amounts of money for a bottle of wine. In most cases the Yamaha is still too much for a starting guitarist, it's only real advantage is that it is a reliable purchase for someone who does not know what to look for in an instrument.
    Again, this is not to criticize the player. Much practice will make him much better.
    Here's another example of her performing. My gosh what remarkable intonation. NOw the Yamaha could never achieve this level of sonorous but the 7p could do something in that range and that is what you are paying for. But why pay for it if you are far from being able to do it.
    ruclips.net/video/8IEezGQwgZk/видео.html
    That woman is a genius.

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  4 года назад

      Hi there, you're absolutely right. No offense taken and Ana Vidovic is a wonderful player I enjoy listening and watching her performances. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year. Cheers !

    • @iggyosborn
      @iggyosborn 4 года назад

      @@ILoveMYOOZIK I do think that you are doing very well, but like me we only have so much time and also there are talent limits that we all have to acknowledge. I used to teach classes of bginning guitar and students would come in with 1000 dollar guitars. I started bringing in two guitars, one that cost 50 dollars (used) and one that cost a grand. I played them both but switched the identities of the guitars. They all preferred the sound of the fifty dollar guitar!! From that point on I tested my guitars blindfolded when purchasing. Was always surprised. I hope you have a wonderful holiday and a merry Christmas too.

    • @iggyosborn
      @iggyosborn 4 года назад

      @@ILoveMYOOZIK Here's a great example. It's a 275 thousand guitar. You can hear the richness when he gets something write because the guitar is always waiting to maych his level. But the moment he stops being a 275 thou player, you can hear that too and it isn't the guitar's fault :) I think it's a good lesson for alll of us. ruclips.net/video/E442Dzg8BcE/видео.html

  • @sale83
    @sale83 6 лет назад

    Yamaha sounds a bit dull and since it doesn' have a solid top, it will sound the same in 10-20 years. But the main difference is in the bigger room or venue.....then Alhambra has much more powerful sound than yamaha c40.
    In small room, recording like this, difference is not that big, they both play, they both give you the sound.If you don't play concerts, you don't need a concert guitar unless you really want it.Student guitars with solid top are just fine.
    And c40 is a great beginners classical guitar.

    • @sgnt9337
      @sgnt9337 6 лет назад

      I agree totally. For a student playing primarily the first 5 frets or so, the C-40 or something similar in the Yamaha line is an excellent guitar (I have a old CG-100A).

  • @omaregb
    @omaregb 7 лет назад +3

    there isn't really a lot of difference in the hands of a beginner, which is why budget guitars exist

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  7 лет назад

      You're right about that but some very cheap budget guitars sound like a cardboard box even in the hands of a beginner. The C40 is something else ;)

  • @NoahPARK82
    @NoahPARK82 8 лет назад +12

    the 7p has richer sound

  • @sumitsagaonkar
    @sumitsagaonkar 8 лет назад +3

    Anytime the Alhambra sounds at least better to the yamaha....in this video.

  • @mohamedchouiter1768
    @mohamedchouiter1768 4 года назад

    Even with the poor quality you can tell that Alhambra has a stronger and cleaner sound.

  • @plunderclat221
    @plunderclat221 6 лет назад

    I played a c40 only 2 weeks ago while my 4p was having the saddle checked in the back of the guitar shop. The guy came in with the c40 and said "try this, while I check yours out".
    All I can say is that I could live with a c40, but the poor intonation on the D wouldve bothered me in time, not to mention the fact that they sound utterly dull compared to the alhambra. Not really sure what this video is trying to achieve tbh. The playing isn't great but even then, the sound difference is huge, but even that can't be assessed in this video because the sound quality is so bad :S

    • @plunderclat221
      @plunderclat221 6 лет назад

      ...and the difference between the c40 and the 4p is that the 4p sounds more like a church bell in comparison :D

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  6 лет назад +1

      Thank you for for commenting and for your interesting point of view. It's not the only point of view in the comments section though :). It's always enriching to hear another take on the subject. Have a nice one.

    • @plunderclat221
      @plunderclat221 6 лет назад +1

      @@ILoveMYOOZIK i couldn't believe how coincidental it was that only two weeks ago i was handed the c40 to play with while a guy looked at my alhambra and then two weeks later youtube recommended your video to me. Thats what REALLY interests me :) same to you

    • @plunderclat221
      @plunderclat221 6 лет назад

      My first classical was a hohner h105 and I could say the same about that too. Very solid instruments just like the c40, and most certainly worth the money, but I can't play it now without feeling like someone has taken something away from it. Be interesting to hear the differences between the 4p and your Alhambra.... that would be interesting!

  • @joaoramalho7368
    @joaoramalho7368 3 года назад

    A great guitar player wil always make a piece of wood with strings sound great. That's why the greatest names of classical guitar play cheap guitars, 100 dolars guitars.
    High priced instruments are a swindle.
    .... Come on, don't be silly.

  • @tfla4062
    @tfla4062 3 года назад

    bro those guitars arent even comparable the Alhambra comes with all Solid woods and one big solid "Ebony" peace fretboard so its gonna sound better and louder of course..even the cheap 250$ alhambra 1C will blow C40 away

  • @carloscallejasrosales7478
    @carloscallejasrosales7478 6 лет назад

    La neta cada guitarra es unica aunque sea la misma marca jamas sonaran igual

  • @persiaguitar
    @persiaguitar 6 лет назад +2

    Yamaha is far much better.

  • @rickphilipsen9944
    @rickphilipsen9944 7 лет назад +2

    why would you compare a 1000 dollar and a 150 dollar guitar???

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  7 лет назад +6

      Rick Philipsen This is exactly the point of this video. To show that a 10 times more expensive guitar is surely better but is it really 10 times better? :))

    • @rickphilipsen9944
      @rickphilipsen9944 7 лет назад +1

      ahh i see, it sounds better for sure. but not 10 times tho!

  • @asherasator
    @asherasator 8 лет назад +4

    The Alhambra is brighter & louder. Both guitars are out of tune.

    • @Ken_Fleming
      @Ken_Fleming 7 лет назад +2

      All guitars sound out of tune on yt 😁

  • @eviesyd
    @eviesyd 6 лет назад +1

    yes 10 times better or maybe 12.

  • @barryroberts2093
    @barryroberts2093 6 лет назад +1

    For me the Yamaha got tone sustain quality gets a yes from me .

  • @uraimuhammadreza
    @uraimuhammadreza 6 лет назад +4

    Lol. Different class

  • @FreddyMorales
    @FreddyMorales 3 года назад

    Alhambra so far

  • @wongchinkong4505
    @wongchinkong4505 Год назад

    To truly test a classic guitar capabilities, please play pieces that got many notes beyond the 12 fret. No good cheap guitars just sound horrible after 12 fret positions: blunt, out of pitch, no sound at all on these high frets.

  • @petjobedet4650
    @petjobedet4650 4 года назад

    Apples and oranges

  • @odyssey570
    @odyssey570 Год назад

    How can you compare the sound of two guitars using, as you say, a "laptop webcam microphone"?? It tells us nothing about the actual sounds of these two guitars. How about projection and dynamic range, loudness range, fullness and richness of tone, the intonation, how well it stays in tune down the neck, the ease and feel of play. This comparison is meaningless. The Yamaha C40 may be a decent beginner's guitar, especially for the price. But this video is not a valid comparison with the Alhambra 7P.

  • @davidteo03
    @davidteo03 2 года назад

    You cannot compare price with sound quality this way price and sound quality is a diminishing curve once more comments you don’t play very well

  • @tony33herreras21
    @tony33herreras21 Год назад

    La eterna pregunta, se habla de sonido, no de calidad de construccion y de dinero, que te crees que porque te gaste 3000 dolares vas a hacer mejor sonido? Estoy seguro que un buen guitarrista coge la Yamaha y deja a la gente boquiabierta y con la Alhambra iden de idem.

  • @swaroov9236
    @swaroov9236 6 лет назад

    poor people like me can expect yamaha c40

  • @mondariz6
    @mondariz6 6 лет назад

    Alhambra

  • @hasanozdemir1836
    @hasanozdemir1836 6 лет назад

    hüsegin

  • @AddeeK
    @AddeeK 7 лет назад +1

    yamaha c40 sounds good.

  • @edgard.t.7028
    @edgard.t.7028 4 года назад

    Jaja ALHAMBRA sounds better!! Is easy to identify!, this is for poor people that looks justify a cheap guitar sounds equal.

  • @juanpablonimuyao9186
    @juanpablonimuyao9186 2 года назад +1

    jajajaaajjajajajajaja

  • @davemp9008
    @davemp9008 6 лет назад

    Sound like Tin Cans

  • @mr.raxman
    @mr.raxman 5 лет назад

    Yamaha 👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻

  • @miguelangelcarballido8729
    @miguelangelcarballido8729 4 года назад

    Jajajajajajajajajaja yamaha por favor pesima guitarra

    • @christiandonado2630
      @christiandonado2630 3 года назад

      La Yamaha c40 no es una pésima guitarra, de hecho es una guitarra que ofrece buenas prestaciones en su rango de precio que es de unos $130 dólares. Es obvio que al hacer una comparación de sonido tan desigual frente a una Alhambra 7p que está más o menos en unos $1.800 dólares. La c40 se va a quedar corta. Es más, Ninguno de los modelos de guitarra clásica de Yamaha pueden compararse con una 7p de Alhambra, ni siquiera la serie Cg, que es de lo mejorcito de Yamaha en guitarra clásica.

  • @lawcch
    @lawcch 7 лет назад

    it is stupid comparison. it should be make comparison with Budget guitar Vs another brand of budget guitar. Furthermore , your playing of the pieces only utilize the first 4 frets. That points alone does not justify a guitar sound is good or otherwise.

    • @ILoveMYOOZIK
      @ILoveMYOOZIK  7 лет назад

      Lawrence Hiun Very smart point sir! Thank you!

    • @janko6458
      @janko6458 7 лет назад +2

      This is not a stupid comparison! This comparison reveals that 10 times more expensive guitar does not play better if the guitarist does not play perfectly. The beginner on a more expensive guitar will not play any better!

    • @mangore623
      @mangore623 6 лет назад

      Unless you are an idiot, the argument is sound: Is the expensive guitar so dramatically different that it warrants a very hefty price tag. Most luthiers will tell you that older, cheaper, guitars will sound better, than newer more professional guitars due to the dearth of quality material to build fine guitars. Sorry this fellow crushed your illusions and biases, of which the guitar world is overflowing.