Thanks for that, Aaron. I really liked "Black Rose". The combination of Taemin's voice and the instrumental was very well done. I found that Kid Milli gave something more in this song. If you like this kind of music, I recommend you "Stranger" and "Impressionable" from the same album as Criminal, 2kids, Just Me And You and Black Rose. They have something quite similar.
Here's the official audio: ruclips.net/video/SzgkD7NObc8/видео.html If you want more of his dark songs like this with a nice instrumental - Strangers, Impressionable, Waiting For (these 3 are from the same album with Black Rose and I'm sure you're gonna love them as well, people were recommending mostly just Black Rose because it has an iconic performance that everyone loves), Mystery Lover (similar atmosphere to Black Rose and it's also one of his best songs vocal wise)
The live stage is mesmerizing 🔥 Idk the scale, but I recently heard an interview with Adrian Mckinnon (the composer of this song. He's a genius, btw) He said he composed it with a friend who is an urban musician and they took a different approach to create it. Instead of writing the lyrics or making a cool melody, they first imagined the atmosphere of the song. Adrian said that "Black Rose" is a combination of the Tim Burton movie "Corpse Bride" and Beetlejuice. I think that's why you feel like the scale is dark and wacky. It's an amazing song!
aww man, you really should react to the live stage. The stage is beautiful and the choreo is amazing! I even think you'll maybe like to cover it in the future haha Adrian McKinnon the songwritter talked about the writing process and inspirations for Black Rose, and the inspirations were Tim Burton, Graveyards, roses and thorns, creepy stuff and yeah, the choreo stage really accompanies the song. Thanks for the reaction!
Black Rose is one of the most iconic and mesmerizing songs that I have listen to in my entire life, and the live stage is a masterpiece 🌟 If you liked Black Rose I think you will like "Pinocchio" as well it's ft. BewhY he's also a rapper. Other recommendations: Waiting for, Stone Heart, Be your enemy, Strangers, Never forever, Shadow, Play me, Pansy... and so many others, agh I just love Taemin ㅠㅠ
I really hope one day you’ll react to Clockwork - it’s probably the most unique song in Taemin’s discography, so beautiful and poetic. Thanks Aaron and please check out the performance of Black Rose!
Thank for reaction! Really waiting black rose reaction. Absolutely love this song. But in my opinion stage performance in even better! Absolutely amazing 💔 Hope to see your reaction on it
If you liked this, you will also really like "Impressionable". It's on Act 2 and he really plays with the melody using his voice. Then there's "Mystery Lover" with the music box melody, lots of harmonizing with himself and lots of belting! Both are haunting and dark.
Regarding the meaning of the lyrics, I believe it fits in perfectly with the overall theme of the entire NGDA album. The "Black Rose" is Taemin's ideal self -- his perfect "IDEA" of himself that he knows is hidden within and has been chasing since debut. The big clue to this is in the line, "I can face you hidden inside me." However, it is just a flicker that he can grasp only at brief sporadic or sub-conscious moments, like in his dreams, before his "black pupil swallows the foreign golden sun..." This causes him pain because roses have thorns that "keep scratch at my heart painfully" because he can't grasp that which he wants so desperately but also joy at the moments when they "can face each other". So, just like with "Criminal", it's a love/hate relationship.
The whole Never Gonna Dance sequence is a masterpiece. I was shook when I discovered those albums, the universe gave me no other chance but stanning Taemin instantly.
this song is amazingg! You should definitely react to the live stage. I also recommend checking out Taemin's "Impressionable" and "Mystery Lover" next, I think you would like them.
@@SunriseAZ9 lmaooo I am the oppositive those are my top favorites from their respective albums sksks. But yes, from what I have seen in terms of Aaron's taste he would definitely enjoy those two songs. I also see you mentioned Stranger, I love that song. Honestly in my opinion all the songs from the NWDA series and Advice are incredible.
thank you aaron for reacting to black rose, i love the song and the combination of instruments with taemin's voice, you should see the choreography too, it's awesome ♥️
Glad people have mentioned the stage performance- beautiful choreography from Taemin and the other dancers and gorgeous vocals as per usual from our baby cheese. 🥰
Aww I’m so sad there’s no live stage reaction on this vid. If It had, I would have seen your more more intense reaction! lolol I hope I can see it on here, YT, as soon as possible Aaron 😭
Aaron, thank you very much for your reaction to Taemin. I always look forward to it. I recommend you can listen to Taemin's song named itsuka kokode. It is a Japanese song. Taemin had ever sung it and played piano at the same time at the ending of his concert at Nippon Budokan in Japan. It is really a beautiful song.😊
I came faster than I thought. but because it's just the song. where is the live video? (I'm going to cry) I feel betrayed and I thought you would react to the live video. The one we all wanted you to see. 😞😞😞😞😞😞
Finally u reacted to 'black rose' I really enjoy it thanks Aaron for your honest reaction and about the black rose stage performance don't miss it because you will never regret...amazing performance from taemin.
Hi Aaron! I've been watching all your Taemin videos lately and I loved that you picked up on the bridge part being weird! From what I know and what I've heard the bridge is actually modulating between keys in a jazz fashion. Some of the chords are just interjected to make the bridge sound as if we are floating in space (or in between musical modes) which is why the notes sound as if they don't fit perfectly with the already established key (or like you said they sound unsettling). Then the notes taem sings when the chorus comes back in are also jazz chords, continuing this jazzy element from the bridge. It's honestly my fav part of this song and i'm glad you enjoyed it!
If you get a chance, definitely check out his live performances for this track. Thanks for the react and I’m glad you liked the song! I would recommend Strangers from the same album. Another dark haunting track. I was rewatching the TV show Hannibal when this album came out so now the music is always linked in my head to the dark themes and visuals from Hannibal.
Great reaction as always! You should watch the stage performance of this song, it’s so much better. And if you’re gonna do another SHINee reaction, I highly suggest the From Now On performance from 2018. It’s very emotional and I think you’ll like it.
I LOVE THIS SONG SO MUCH!! Also his "The stage" performance is one of my all time favourite Taemin performances!! How sad you didn´t react to the performance, I hope you will! It´s mesmerizing ♥
Aaron eres genial encantador. Me encanta todas tus reacciones. La de TAEMIN me facina .pliss reacciona RISE ,SOLDIER, IDENTIDAD .Live SIRIOS arena tour . WUESS WHO LIVE NIPPON BUDOKAN .💎❤️
you should definitely see him perform this at “the stage” !!
ruclips.net/video/JIuquo8i7oM/видео.html
블랙핑크 무대
The live stage of black rose is damn mesmerizing...taemin and his backup dancers did Amazingly well!.....
You have to see TAEMIN Black Rose on stage by SM. It's just incredible🙌. Please check it out🙏
Thanks for that, Aaron. I really liked "Black Rose". The combination of Taemin's voice and the instrumental was very well done. I found that Kid Milli gave something more in this song. If you like this kind of music, I recommend you "Stranger" and "Impressionable" from the same album as Criminal, 2kids, Just Me And You and Black Rose. They have something quite similar.
I think you’re gonna love the choreo! If u like this type of music u will also really like mystery lover by Taemin!
please.... his voice is so.. so... good....!!! is.. TAEMIN... ..
he is ART....
his voice is AMAZING.....!!!!!!!!! The song is perfect.
Thank you...!
Here's the official audio: ruclips.net/video/SzgkD7NObc8/видео.html
If you want more of his dark songs like this with a nice instrumental - Strangers, Impressionable, Waiting For (these 3 are from the same album with Black Rose and I'm sure you're gonna love them as well, people were recommending mostly just Black Rose because it has an iconic performance that everyone loves), Mystery Lover (similar atmosphere to Black Rose and it's also one of his best songs vocal wise)
Up
Most of my favourite songs.
The live stage is mesmerizing 🔥
Idk the scale, but I recently heard an interview with Adrian Mckinnon (the composer of this song. He's a genius, btw) He said he composed it with a friend who is an urban musician and they took a different approach to create it. Instead of writing the lyrics or making a cool melody, they first imagined the atmosphere of the song.
Adrian said that "Black Rose" is a combination of the Tim Burton movie "Corpse Bride" and Beetlejuice. I think that's why you feel like the scale is dark and wacky. It's an amazing song!
Wow Love " BeetleJuice" )))
aww man, you really should react to the live stage. The stage is beautiful and the choreo is amazing! I even think you'll maybe like to cover it in the future haha Adrian McKinnon the songwritter talked about the writing process and inspirations for Black Rose, and the inspirations were Tim Burton, Graveyards, roses and thorns, creepy stuff and yeah, the choreo stage really accompanies the song. Thanks for the reaction!
Black Rose is one of the most iconic and mesmerizing songs that I have listen to in my entire life, and the live stage is a masterpiece 🌟
If you liked Black Rose I think you will like "Pinocchio" as well it's ft. BewhY he's also a rapper.
Other recommendations:
Waiting for, Stone Heart, Be your enemy, Strangers, Never forever, Shadow, Play me, Pansy... and so many others, agh I just love Taemin ㅠㅠ
I really hope one day you’ll react to Clockwork - it’s probably the most unique song in Taemin’s discography, so beautiful and poetic. Thanks Aaron and please check out the performance of Black Rose!
I considered myself a Taemin fan after this song, it's so nice and give you chills
개인적으로 일식 꼭 들어줬어면 했는데 정말 태민이의 목소리는 그누구도 흉내를 못낸다는 사실에 감탄 또 감탄 일식 들어주셔서 고맙습니다 ~^^ 녹아드는 태민이의 목소리가 잘나타나있는 노래중 하나입니다~늘 고맙습니다
Definitely
Taemin on live Stage he is Amazing 🖤✨👌
Yesss!!! I love Taemin reactionss
Black Rose is one of my top 5 Taemin songs
My favorite song of Taemin. So sacred but sexy😌
Thank for reaction! Really waiting black rose reaction. Absolutely love this song. But in my opinion stage performance in even better! Absolutely amazing 💔
Hope to see your reaction on it
Finally black rose... Even though you not go with live performance, I still enjoy it...
Thank you Aaron.... Let's keep continue with taemin, .....
Thank you for your reaction! Please react to the live stage Taemin - Black Rose The Stage you won't regret 🥺💙💎
If you liked this, you will also really like "Impressionable". It's on Act 2 and he really plays with the melody using his voice. Then there's "Mystery Lover" with the music box melody, lots of harmonizing with himself and lots of belting! Both are haunting and dark.
Thank you Aaron! Can wait for the live stage and hope you get to learn the coreography.
Please check identity, Soldier or rise.
Regarding the meaning of the lyrics, I believe it fits in perfectly with the overall theme of the entire NGDA album. The "Black Rose" is Taemin's ideal self -- his perfect "IDEA" of himself that he knows is hidden within and has been chasing since debut. The big clue to this is in the line, "I can face you hidden inside me." However, it is just a flicker that he can grasp only at brief sporadic or sub-conscious moments, like in his dreams, before his "black pupil swallows the foreign golden sun..." This causes him pain because roses have thorns that "keep scratch at my heart painfully" because he can't grasp that which he wants so desperately but also joy at the moments when they "can face each other". So, just like with "Criminal", it's a love/hate relationship.
black rose performance the stageeee
The whole Never Gonna Dance sequence is a masterpiece. I was shook when I discovered those albums, the universe gave me no other chance but stanning Taemin instantly.
Black Rose live stage is a must watch ❤️🔥 the choreo is amazing, one of my fav performances
this song is amazingg! You should definitely react to the live stage. I also recommend checking out Taemin's "Impressionable" and "Mystery Lover" next, I think you would like them.
I really didn't like "Impressionable" and "Mystery love", they are my least favorites in the two album. 😅
@@SunriseAZ9 I'm sure Aaron will love Impressionable and Mystery Lover 🙂 They're amazing songs with the unique atmosphere and really fit his taste
@@SunriseAZ9 Understandable, I can definitely see why these songs might be not for everyone
@@SunriseAZ9 Agree with you about Strangers, I also mentioned this song first in my comment
@@SunriseAZ9 lmaooo I am the oppositive those are my top favorites from their respective albums sksks. But yes, from what I have seen in terms of Aaron's taste he would definitely enjoy those two songs. I also see you mentioned Stranger, I love that song. Honestly in my opinion all the songs from the NWDA series and Advice are incredible.
thank you aaron for reacting to black rose, i love the song and the combination of instruments with taemin's voice, you should see the choreography too, it's awesome ♥️
Glad people have mentioned the stage performance- beautiful choreography from Taemin and the other dancers and gorgeous vocals as per usual from our baby cheese. 🥰
The live stage is insane
yeah
울 태미니~~매력에 빠지면. 멈출수없지!!♡♡♡♡
The perform at the stage is just amazing
FINALLY THE QUEEN IS HERE🙌
I think one of taemin’s most unsettling songs is impressionable you shroud def listen to it
Where is the stage performance!?!? Little bit sad about that, but glad you reacted to this song, it's great!
Aww I’m so sad there’s no live stage reaction on this vid. If It had, I would have seen your more more intense reaction! lolol I hope I can see it on here, YT, as soon as possible Aaron 😭
Aaron, thank you very much for your reaction to Taemin. I always look forward to it. I recommend you can listen to Taemin's song named itsuka kokode. It is a Japanese song. Taemin had ever sung it and played piano at the same time at the ending of his concert at Nippon Budokan in Japan. It is really a beautiful song.😊
I came faster than I thought. but because it's just the song. where is the live video? (I'm going to cry) I feel betrayed and I thought you would react to the live video. The one we all wanted you to see. 😞😞😞😞😞😞
Finally u reacted to 'black rose' I really enjoy it thanks Aaron for your honest reaction and about the black rose stage performance don't miss it because you will never regret...amazing performance from taemin.
The whole time Aaron is analyzing the vocals, I'm waiting for him to discover the mv and live stages... next level beautiful. I do love the song 🎵
Taemin is art.
Thank you for this and also this with the performance is just!!!! He nails it you gotta watch that cuz his choreo is so majestical there!
Please check out the live stage for this song! It won't get blocked :)
Pls see black rose live stage ~~so beautiful!
I love this song💖
Shinee 🥰🥰🥰
Hi Aaron! I've been watching all your Taemin videos lately and I loved that you picked up on the bridge part being weird! From what I know and what I've heard the bridge is actually modulating between keys in a jazz fashion. Some of the chords are just interjected to make the bridge sound as if we are floating in space (or in between musical modes) which is why the notes sound as if they don't fit perfectly with the already established key (or like you said they sound unsettling). Then the notes taem sings when the chorus comes back in are also jazz chords, continuing this jazzy element from the bridge. It's honestly my fav part of this song and i'm glad you enjoyed it!
This is probably one of my favorites from Taemin as a whole. It just hits so much
Yes the korean version of Famous is in this album but it is originally a Japanese release.
I love this song!! Thank you, Aaron.
Please react on black stage performance as well he is amazing
Por fin estás haciendo la reacción a Black Rose, gracias Aaron, es una gran interpretación de Taemin!!!
If you get a chance, definitely check out his live performances for this track. Thanks for the react and I’m glad you liked the song! I would recommend Strangers from the same album. Another dark haunting track. I was rewatching the TV show Hannibal when this album came out so now the music is always linked in my head to the dark themes and visuals from Hannibal.
But when the song and the choreography was combined, BOOMM! SO DAMN FASCINATING!
Edit: I felt being hypnotized while watching the live stage
I love it❤ taemin🥰
Pleaaase react to the stage of this song the choreography the costumes everything is so beautiful
check the live stage.. It's mesmerising..
Arron thank you for the reaction, and please check out "Clockwork" too, it's in the same album, i really really like that song.
Thanks Aaron! Taemin's b sides are all real epic songs! pls also react to Taemin's Shadow, Strangers, Waiting For, Pansy, Be Your Enemy
Thank you again Aaron for taemin reaction. Hope you'll also check out Strangers, Waiting For, Clockwork, Mystery Lover
Thanks Aaron! I love his NGDA Album and really hope you check out the other B sides. Clockwork is one of my favourites that I think you will love too!
Great reaction as always! You should watch the stage performance of this song, it’s so much better. And if you’re gonna do another SHINee reaction, I highly suggest the From Now On performance from 2018. It’s very emotional and I think you’ll like it.
I LOVE THIS SONG SO MUCH!! Also his "The stage" performance is one of my all time favourite Taemin performances!!
How sad you didn´t react to the performance, I hope you will! It´s mesmerizing ♥
Thank you for your reaction!˶˙ᵕ˙˶)꜆
Aaron eres genial encantador. Me encanta todas tus reacciones. La de TAEMIN me facina .pliss reacciona RISE ,SOLDIER, IDENTIDAD .Live SIRIOS arena tour . WUESS WHO LIVE NIPPON BUDOKAN .💎❤️
Sm's The stage performance is the best, and I don't think it will get blocked, I've watched other youtubers react to it.
The prechorus and the bridge are SO GOOD
U have to watch his live stage so awesome
You will definitely also enjoy Clockwork and Impressionable by Taemin!
Strangers too
Finally... but I was really excited for the reaction to the performance.. please check "The stage" of Black rose.. that's just heavenly
I also love his song "back to you"
thank you for your reaction aaron. you absolutely have to watch the choreography of this music, it is exceptional. especially the version: the stage
Thank you so much for reacting to black rose the stage performance makes the song even better.
ruclips.net/video/JIuquo8i7oM/видео.html
블랙핑크 무대
You have to see the stage of black rose!
Aaron, hubiera sido lindo la reacción en video porque a Taemin no solo hay que escuchar, también hay que verlo para apreciar todo su arte.
Please react taemin~ black rose live stage... It's really amazing...🥺🥺
The performance for this song is just wonderful. Also I feel that this song is more about facing your inner darkness than about anything else.
I LOVE THIS SOOONG
The instrumental is *chefs kiss*👑
Oh shit. Yeah. My one of favorite song
Love ur reaction 💜💜💜💜
This song is SO AWESOME
This stage is necessary reaction
Just wait until you hear Clockwork.
My favorite song 💥💥💥
Oh I thought you were checking the live stage too.. it's amazing
this song hits seriously
you should’ve reacted to the live stage performance aswell it’s so good
This was from the Criminal NGDA album! You need to see the live stage because, if you're blown away from just the audio...!!!! :D
Taemin💯 💖black rose💯
I like this so much that im trying to find the instrumental version of this but $M won't share those with us. It's a shame
YOU SHOULD SAW HIS PERFORMANCE AT "THE STAGE" , ITS ART!!!!!
Wait for your reaction to next taemin song “stranger”
I wish u reacted to the live too, it hits different
The live stage pleaseee😭
act 1 is a masterpiece! i love every song. actually you have listened to a lot of songs on this album already. maybe react to the rest?
I like Black Rose in Inkigayo! The live is supreme Aaron! Check ✅
⚫🌹⚫
No pleeease do the live performance on here it won't get blocked 🙏🙏
PINCHES REACCIONES INCOMPLETAAAAS 👿👿👿👿 TE FALTO EL LIVE STAGE Encantadoooor 🤬🤬
Oh man I wish you had watched the stage performance cause it’s my faborite
You should check out his performance for this it’s amazing