Girl Defined Updates #3 | Rampant transphobia & Bethy's Courses

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 1 янв 2025

Комментарии • 2,4 тыс.

  • @FundieFridays
    @FundieFridays  2 года назад +119

    CASETiFY's Bounce Cases and Clear Cases are available at casetify.com! Go to www.casetify.com/fundiefridays today to get 15% off your order!

    • @shannsimms9072
      @shannsimms9072 2 года назад +8

      I want to buy a casetify case so bad cause they have so many beautiful ones. But it’s all too overwhelming for me because they have sooo many I literally can’t choose.

    • @beccafichtner5305
      @beccafichtner5305 2 года назад +14

      You two make me actually want to watch the adverts.

    • @ImperialMaiden
      @ImperialMaiden 2 года назад +13

      i normally skip the ads in vids, but you guys were just too much fun to watch, got a good laugh from the segment

    • @themidcenturyzillennial
      @themidcenturyzillennial 2 года назад

      @@shannsimms9072mine snapped in half within a couple months and they kindly replaced it...unfortunately that one broke too. Not from dropping my phone either, the case itself just split apart. Not worth it at all

    • @alexnorthover4894
      @alexnorthover4894 2 года назад

      @@themidcenturyzillennialthat’s a shame. I ordered one and the utility strap, I’ve been really happy with mine. Mine is the heavy duty bounce case type and seems very sturdy. I wonder if the type makes a difference?

  • @SilvanaLTD
    @SilvanaLTD 2 года назад +7814

    "Marilyn Monroe had everything a woman could dream of," yes like debilitating endometriosis pain and a lifelong struggle with infertility and miscarriage. Like jeez can everyone just leave Marilyn alone let the woman rest in peace rather than use her legacy for their own agenda?

    • @SteffyP623
      @SteffyP623 2 года назад +1077

      Not to mention a really traumatic childhood filled with physical and sexual abuse, abandonment, mentally ill parent, etc. The woman just needs to be a peace period

    • @null5180
      @null5180 2 года назад +447

      I legit gasped when they used her story so blatantly like,.,,, wtaf ppl need to leave Marilyn alone already

    • @finevindicatedmess
      @finevindicatedmess 2 года назад +372

      The irony of them only seeing Marilyn as a Hollywood starlet isn't lost on me. They would do well to listen to "Candle in the Wind" by Elton John, but something tells me they would be too busy bashing Elton for being gay to bother listening to the track at all. I love and respect Marilyn not for her beauty and her acting talents -- although she obviously has those in spades -- but because she was human. She had to work so hard to be Marilyn, and that's the story that gets wafted aside in favor of telling a story of Marilyn that's all about sex, beauty, and fame.
      Anyway, my point is that Girl Defined can only see the surface meaning of all the subjects they talk about. And that's what pisses me off about Girl Defined -- and Evangelicals as a whole. If you can only understand things at a surface level, how the Hell am I supposed to take you seriously when you preach your Bible at me while completely missing the core message of your holy book?

    • @benniepieters
      @benniepieters 2 года назад +192

      She's not resting in peace: Hugh Hefner is buried beside her

    • @peach9789
      @peach9789 2 года назад +197

      @@benniepieters how anyone allowed that to happen is beyond me.
      however, it’s only her body and i can only hope that there’s peace for her in another place.

  • @ronnoid
    @ronnoid Год назад +405

    the fact that they tell marilyn's story as just "she had a perfect glamorous life and was just never happy :(" ENRAGES me, she was a fucking victim!!! let her rest!!!

  • @annjay2581
    @annjay2581 2 года назад +2242

    Bethy really said women wanting a carreer outside home is sinful but running a scam from home isnt 🤦‍♀️
    The original gaslight gatekeep girlboss 💅

    • @NennaJuj
      @NennaJuj 2 года назад +75

      Rules for thee, not for me!

    • @maggiekarabel123
      @maggiekarabel123 2 года назад +1

      Yeah just go in debt and join a cult, that’s not sinful. 😂

    • @infinitelives1119
      @infinitelives1119 2 года назад +28

      So if I'm a technical project manager but I work from home that's totes fine? Or is it only okay if they think it's a "girly" job?

    • @ultraboombean
      @ultraboombean 2 года назад +7

      @@infinitelives1119 i guess side gigs are okay. As long as you are not the main bread winner? Or as long as you answer to your husband and not another ( boss?)

    • @omnistpagan3282
      @omnistpagan3282 2 года назад +13

      I guess they think because they’re spreading the gospel it’s fine. Even though in their faith women can’t preach, ultimate hypocrisy.

  • @PamelaBowsArt
    @PamelaBowsArt 2 года назад +419

    “FEMINISM IS THE RADICAL IDEA THAT WOMEN ARE GOD, CAPABLE OF BEING THEIR OWN AUTHORITIES” please make that shirt I will purchase it

    • @goodguygeorge3355
      @goodguygeorge3355 Год назад +18

      Feminism sounds kinda based tbh

    • @hannahp730
      @hannahp730 Год назад +11

      Also so disturbing that they're bothered by feminism allowing women to be their own boss, yet men should be allowed to embrace their own divine leadership. And of course, make all the decisions for women. UGhhhh

    • @skylarsf4574
      @skylarsf4574 8 месяцев назад +1

      Amen ! I'll purchase it too 🥳

  • @oxford_trauma
    @oxford_trauma 2 года назад +1604

    Kristen really volunteered the information that her husband doesn't rock her holy boat.

    • @alexandraseabrook9242
      @alexandraseabrook9242 2 года назад +207

      I know!!! It has always astounded me that for people who adhere to purity culture and see sex as shameful, they literally talk about sex more than a locker room full of virgins!! 😂😂

    • @dominicfucinari1942
      @dominicfucinari1942 2 года назад

      @@alexandraseabrook9242 I keep forgetting why United Statish fundamentalists insist on policing everybody's sex lives. Is it lucrative? Do they think it's an easy way to grab political clout?

    • @ZZ-qw6el
      @ZZ-qw6el 2 года назад +79

      Not her holy boat 😩😂

    • @SpecialBlanket
      @SpecialBlanket Год назад +8

      eh. i'm not sexually attracted to my partner and i'm ok with that.

    • @emilyporter1186
      @emilyporter1186 Год назад +53

      And it's like... Just communicate what you like? Like the answer to that isn't not masturbating, it's just communication with someone who isn't so caught up in their own ego that they can accept that you know your body better and can learn from you lmao

  • @connorletkeman3539
    @connorletkeman3539 2 года назад +1160

    Girl defined gives big "mean girl in high school who became nurses" energy

    • @driley5004
      @driley5004 2 года назад +45

      the ACCURACY

    • @Swigi_E
      @Swigi_E Год назад +13

      This.
      My mom's a nurse.

    • @TaurusWitch29
      @TaurusWitch29 Год назад +36

      All the mean girls at my school did the same thing and I'm 35, so I thought I'd get away from them forever but if I show up at the hospital then it's a blast from the past and I want to stick myself in a coma.

    • @whitketchum
      @whitketchum Год назад +2

      Yes! Best take

    • @vans0nhead220
      @vans0nhead220 Год назад +1

      they’d never make it through all the schooling

  • @katiestein991
    @katiestein991 2 года назад +931

    Omfg them suggesting that Marilyn Monroe died because she didn’t have Jesus is so ignorant 😡 god they are pathetic

    • @cecizilla
      @cecizilla 2 года назад +16

      no seriously i was so angry

    • @shroomshroom5945
      @shroomshroom5945 2 года назад +25

      I know! She had soooo much more on her plate than they really mention.

    • @NoName-dx1no
      @NoName-dx1no 2 года назад

      Isn’t Marilyn Jewish? That makes their comment even more irrelevant 💀

    • @515aleon
      @515aleon 2 года назад

      Disgusting!! It's well known she suffered from rather severe mental illness, not to mention severe pain! Pathetic G.D. Sht.

    • @tbrad17
      @tbrad17 2 года назад +133

      Marilyn was also a Jew, and telling a Jew they need Christ is a telling choice.

  • @giddlefuitarist
    @giddlefuitarist 2 года назад +742

    I lost it at "like a homeschool curriculum, these two completely lack chemistry"

    • @AVspectre
      @AVspectre 2 года назад +6

      Right!?

    • @carencronin7730
      @carencronin7730 2 года назад +1

      Me too! A literal loud cackle from me.

    • @emiemiemi4769
      @emiemiemi4769 2 года назад

      WAIT I JUST GOT IT

    • @rohanmorningstar7795
      @rohanmorningstar7795 11 месяцев назад +2

      "Exploring Creation with Chemistry" would like to have a word 😤

    • @giddlefuitarist
      @giddlefuitarist 11 месяцев назад +1

      Oh my gooosh Jen please cover Exploring Creation with Chemistry 😮

  • @Amy-cv4fd
    @Amy-cv4fd 2 года назад +364

    "victim to the urge" is honestly a great band name or clothing brand name

  • @TripleGia
    @TripleGia 2 года назад +416

    All of this is insane, but Kristen talking about planning for getting the urge to masturbate like it's a panic attack that needs to be worked around made me wonder how these girls are real.

    • @abbywolffe4114
      @abbywolffe4114 2 года назад

      You mean _you_ don't have to resist your sinful womanly urges because only your husband may touch your holy bean?

    • @galaxyocicat5660
      @galaxyocicat5660 2 года назад +37

      They talk like literal children when they're adult mothers with kids

    • @lydiathornton1999
      @lydiathornton1999 Год назад +96

      honestly, if you're raised with this degree of shame around sex, the urge to masturbate probably *does* more or less feel like a panic attack...

    • @AirConditioner402
      @AirConditioner402 Год назад +19

      Imagine being a married woman and having this much fear around masturbation? GIRL--

    • @joelleash8873
      @joelleash8873 Год назад +16

      @@lydiathornton1999 I was raised like this and can confirm

  • @landofthebooks
    @landofthebooks 2 года назад +1363

    Michelle Duggar being mom of the year boils my blood. I can't imagine how much angrier her older daughters who raise her younger kids must feel

    • @missmelodies52
      @missmelodies52 2 года назад +167

      It’s about giving birth, not raising healthy happy kids

    • @emilybarclay8831
      @emilybarclay8831 2 года назад

      And the daughters who’s molestation she covered up, excused and minimised. She’s not mother of anything except an incestuous peedoughfile

    • @fixinfkinsandwiches6183
      @fixinfkinsandwiches6183 2 года назад

      Exactly! The older daughters should win mothers of the year. Michelle did the bare minimum and passed the torch to her daughters to raise her babies. Michelle still has to wear maternity clothing because her poor body is destroyed.

    • @florianopolis6299
      @florianopolis6299 2 года назад +22

      How about we do that with shit. It's similar.. Your squeeze out something. The difference being, that nobody gets hurt in the process. We just need a way to measure it!

    • @skylarjohnson7779
      @skylarjohnson7779 2 года назад +105

      and the ones who she let Josh abuse.

  • @FeministCatLadySpinster
    @FeministCatLadySpinster 2 года назад +1719

    I love how Bethany is often scrolling on her phone when Kristen speaks - it's painfully obvious she's just waiting for her turn to speak.

    • @Superwoodputtie
      @Superwoodputtie 2 года назад +23

      I wonder if she has ADHD?

    • @TheExFrenchie
      @TheExFrenchie 2 года назад +8

      Hello!! I love your channel glad to see you're a Jennonite too! ❤❤❤

    • @rayay248
      @rayay248 2 года назад +79

      @@Superwoodputtie I have pretty severe adhd and I always make a point to not look at my phone or interrupt people when they’re talking because it bothers me when people do that to me (not that I always do a great job of truly taking in what they say, but I want people to feel like it matters when they talk). I get that some people will struggle with things more than others and adhd doesn’t just present in one way, but it seems like that sort of thing can be overcome with intentionality and empathy. It doesn’t seem like either of those things are Bethy’s strengths, so it probably has more to do with the lack of those things than adhd related stuff.

    • @Superwoodputtie
      @Superwoodputtie 2 года назад +9

      @@rayay248 Thanks for the thoughtful reply!

    • @FeministCatLadySpinster
      @FeministCatLadySpinster 2 года назад +30

      @@Superwoodputtie I think she just dislikes her sister, lol. Though that does beg the question - if it is because of ADHD, why wouldn't they cut that out and have the camera focus on Kristen whilst she's the one speaking? 🤔
      Of course, these are also the "modesty!" "premarital sex is bad!" folks who often film on a bed, so.

  • @UryuIshida86
    @UryuIshida86 2 года назад +688

    Kristen: "Yes, my husband sucks at sex, and this is somehow my fault."

    • @2degucitas
      @2degucitas 2 года назад +1

      She can't even allow herself to masturbate during sex? That's sad. Vag penetration very rarely stims the clit. Girl needs a vibrator, but that's probably "sinful".

    • @Sophia-vk5bq
      @Sophia-vk5bq 2 года назад +1

      "Jesus is the only one allowed to give head in this marriage."

    • @rawfermews4186
      @rawfermews4186 2 года назад +15

      I can’t believe she believed what she said… and I really don’t get it either.. how the hell are you supposed to TRAIN your body to orgasm from somebody?

    • @Sophia-vk5bq
      @Sophia-vk5bq 2 года назад

      @@Andykyoshi One minute? He probably does 30 seconds of Doggystyle before proclaiming himself a sex god.

    • @2degucitas
      @2degucitas 2 года назад

      @@rawfermews4186 Freud said (erroneously) that clit orgasms were immature and vag ones were mature. The idea is still around I see.

  • @grilled_cheez
    @grilled_cheez 2 года назад +814

    Everything about Bethy and Kristen’s personas screams “beige” and Jen’s holiday glam look is the antidote.

    • @wareforcoin5780
      @wareforcoin5780 2 года назад +58

      Beige is too exciting. They're a nice, sensible eggshell white. No paintings on their walls.

    • @bonbon5189
      @bonbon5189 2 года назад +33

      Yesss and what’s with the overexposed filters? Are they supposed to look like they died and are speaking from the after life ?

    • @TaurusWitch29
      @TaurusWitch29 Год назад +4

      Brittany Dawn is a beige for sure.

    • @nina.robbs565
      @nina.robbs565 Год назад +8

      ​@@bonbon5189the whiter the better, apparently

    • @bloochoob
      @bloochoob Год назад

      They should get Beige Lyfe tattoos on knuckles 🎉

  • @TaylorBeem
    @TaylorBeem 2 года назад +942

    Walking into Altered State and slowly realizing it’s a weird religious store was like a scene from a horror movie

    • @drew2510
      @drew2510 2 года назад +78

      I remembering seeing some book along the lines of "girlhood and god" or something like that and immediately turning on my heel and walking out the door

    • @wareforcoin5780
      @wareforcoin5780 2 года назад +65

      I've never even heard of the store before. They're not in my state. Thank god. I'd hate to wander in and find a Girl Defined book and suddenly realize that I'm surrounded by people that literally hate me for existing.

    • @ultraboombean
      @ultraboombean 2 года назад +14

      The clothes are super cute. Eh it doesn't bother me but if I saw a Girl Defined book I would have walked out haha.

    • @Tchxr
      @Tchxr 2 года назад +5

      Is it spelled Altared state? Like an altar

    • @Tchxr
      @Tchxr 2 года назад +13

      Omg I think it’s Altar’d State lol

  • @hello-l4n
    @hello-l4n 2 года назад +492

    maybe being a woman wouldn’t be so hard if people weren’t constantly policing what we do with our lives but what do i know

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад +25

      Yeah, they're definitely partaking in the constant judging of women's every move and action.

  • @colleentoporek3512
    @colleentoporek3512 2 года назад +911

    From that opening video: “Women are feeling more insecure, depressed, discontent, and unloved than ever before…” I mean, speak for your self, honey.

    • @queenash96
      @queenash96 2 года назад +73

      i mean she's right...because of people like them

    • @Sputterbug
      @Sputterbug 2 года назад +56

      nothings really changed tbh people in general always been that way. its just that with social media, you can actually see it

    • @annabeinglazy5580
      @annabeinglazy5580 2 года назад +33

      That one Made me laugh considering the statistics from the 50s are insane. When Most women were housewives. I could easily make an Argument that housewiving was what Made them depressed, but that would be in Bad faith and ignore the context of what was going on in the 50s.
      Funny how that works, bethy, huh?

    • @Yaspis
      @Yaspis 2 года назад +27

      @@Sputterbug That's a load of nonsense. Seriously. Movements for self-esteem, self-acceptance, body positivity, and POC and queer representation flat out DID NOT exist until very recently. The good outweighs the bad here by several tonnes. There has always been people like Beggy and Krusty, but it has not been very long at all since representation started levelling the playing field a bit -- and that is why conservatives are getting louder and louder and more violent, too: their cushy status quo is changing, and they hate it.

    • @Pushnotificationsalwaysoffbye
      @Pushnotificationsalwaysoffbye 2 года назад +14

      Right!! Lol I’m over here doing death drops, spin moves, pole dancing in stilettos, loving being a Mom, navigating divorce gracefully and singing in the streets without the watchful eye of a zealous and judgey church - but still very plugged in with the universe. These girls are trippin maybe they need to try crimping their hair sometime, it’ll change your life 💃🏼

  • @kelligillum3230
    @kelligillum3230 2 года назад +1492

    “Drag queens are preying on your children! I’d hate to have to hear about what happened to them in 15 years…” how about we ask all the people who have been assaulted by clergy now?

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад +4

      I mean, are you actually acknowledging that there are some similarities?

    • @kelligillum3230
      @kelligillum3230 2 года назад +122

      @@naryainc none. I’m pointing out the actual prime candidates for abusing kids, other than a parent’s significant other.

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад

      @@kelligillum3230 I don't think adult s*x culture mixes well with children.

    • @archer1949
      @archer1949 2 года назад

      @@naryainc
      The Reich Wing obsession with pedophilia and human trafficking conspiracies is IMAX level projection on their side. They pull nonsense out of their asses to avoid looking too closely at their local Pastor Billy Bob Bad Touch.

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад

      @@archer1949 Okay. Well I'm not going to participate in breaking down boundaries between children and adult s** culture, but you do you.

  • @emnew480
    @emnew480 2 года назад +153

    “I once saw a drag performer dress up as Sheldon from the Big Bang Theory” SENT ME

  • @pie1o1morris46
    @pie1o1morris46 Год назад +79

    Seeing a man in a dress is traumatizing for children but beating them is perfectly acceptable

  • @bkk1996
    @bkk1996 2 года назад +336

    As a woman, I've never wondered what my purpose was 'as a woman'. Also, Marilyn would hate GD.

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад +30

      I think one of my earliest memories of considering whether or not I wanted to be a man or a woman as I grew up was when I was 6 years old. (And yes, I did think I could choose at that age) And I had, for some reason, come to the thought that if I wanted to be a man, I would have to go to the military (it is compulsory in my country for all males), and if I wanted to be a woman, I would have to have children (carry them and birth them). I think my mother told me that I didn't necessarily have to do either and since then I never really gave it much more thought until adulthood.

  • @darcy_robin
    @darcy_robin 2 года назад +1438

    i'm the whitest girl on the planet but i feel like these girls are on a whole different level of whiteness

    • @juno3281
      @juno3281 2 года назад +158

      @@suspiciouspooh5988 to be fair their religion is probably the worst thing that happened to them. i don’t think they’re aware that it’s not normal to be drowning in guilt and shame over normal emotions, but if they ever do then… they’re gonna need some intense therapy.

    • @sporer_
      @sporer_ 2 года назад

      I think you’re equating “white” with being sheltered and a religious zealot here (not saying you’re those things, but rather Bethany and… I honestly can’t remember the other name are).

    • @juno3281
      @juno3281 2 года назад +1

      @@suspiciouspooh5988 it’s tragic either way tbh a close friend of mine would throw a fit if we did or said something that wasn’t “traditionally feminine”. we thought she was just a little unhinged, but turns out it was religious trauma. she is naturally a psycho, but adding all that on top definitely didn’t help. she’s still insane just not sexist anymore lmao

    • @moonlighthowling666
      @moonlighthowling666 2 года назад

      White is a state of mind

    • @larissabrglum3856
      @larissabrglum3856 2 года назад +3

      Same

  • @amberrhea5293
    @amberrhea5293 2 года назад +194

    These two look like they just discovered 2017 pinterest and styled their entire wardrobe from it.

    • @pickledragonrebel
      @pickledragonrebel 2 года назад +6

      I was thinking the exact same thing !

    • @dominicfucinari1942
      @dominicfucinari1942 2 года назад +5

      I don't even know enough about the history of social media to recognize how Pinterest was different back in 017 compared to today. I keep thinking of 017 as the year when Breath Of The Wild came out and The Shape Of Water was one of the best films.

    • @HanniPinkHeels
      @HanniPinkHeels Год назад +1

      😂😂

  • @zuzukris4952
    @zuzukris4952 2 года назад +530

    I don’t know if you’ve ever touched on this subject Jen, but I have a friend in San Antonio that used to go to the same church as them. This was years ago. Apparently, someone in the church was getting divorced because of martial rape, and Bethy said that there was no such thing. She chastised this poor woman, saying that he probably left her, because she wasn’t performing her duties as a wife! It was disgusting! I almost choked on my coffee when she told me. Also, I will repeat this meme to Bethy’s face, my child is 100% safer with a drag queen than with any clergy!

    • @BitchboyOzzie
      @BitchboyOzzie 2 года назад +14

      well shit......

    • @jeanakatherine9369
      @jeanakatherine9369 2 года назад

      So Drag queens are all safe for kids? I’ve seen some highly specialized Draq queen shoes that aren’t appropriate for children…& so ur saying all Clergy members are all predators? I see….I’m not vouching for either group of people…How about we just keep our kids with adults that we’ve vetted ourselves & deemed appropriate

    • @BitchboyOzzie
      @BitchboyOzzie 2 года назад

      @@jeanakatherine9369 what the hell are you talking about?

    • @theclasslessreader9279
      @theclasslessreader9279 2 года назад +1

      Omg this needs to be boosted

    • @soveryeri1
      @soveryeri1 2 года назад

      Drag queen vs people literally brainwashed in a cult....yeah I wouldn't even hesitate when given the choice. My kid would have a blast with the drag queens and learn something potentially, they would be so weirded out by extremism which is what girl defined preaches.

  • @denisewreford121
    @denisewreford121 2 года назад +222

    My kids have attended a Drag Queen story time at our local library several times, and I’ve gotta say that I can’t think of a single sexualized element from any of those performances no matter how hard I try.

    • @dominicfucinari1942
      @dominicfucinari1942 2 года назад

      I don't think Christopher Rufo's cultists need any hard evidence to make themselves feel justified. Rufo gave DeSantis and Abbott the idea to make their governorships all about cis-het supremacy throughout the last year, coming fresh off Rufo's campaign to smear critical race theory as a danger to children.

    • @user-mv5zt8qd9l
      @user-mv5zt8qd9l Год назад +43

      It's almost like the narrative is built entirely on out-of-context clips and scenes from adult shows being attached to family-friendly shows where they never actually happened.

  • @scarlettbildhauer
    @scarlettbildhauer 2 года назад +372

    “You could not waterboard that information out of me” - probably the funniest thing I’ve ever heard

  • @clairebearlife
    @clairebearlife 2 года назад +763

    I act like I "hate" my sisters, but in a very loving way. We might bicker and fight, but even when we were at our worst, you could still tell we were siblings. I actually genuinely forgot Kristen and Bethany were sisters because they act like two frenemies that secretly hate each other but act coldly nice to each others face.

    • @QueenOfTheNorth65
      @QueenOfTheNorth65 2 года назад +19

      Agreed.

    • @KattJett
      @KattJett 2 года назад +103

      I feel like in fundie culture there can be this thing where the kids are never allowed to discuss their inner lives openly, so by the time they reach adulthood, they are basically just acquaintances. It’s like painful politeness that never resolves over a glass of wine or something.

    • @clairebearlife
      @clairebearlife 2 года назад +51

      @@KattJett that's a really good point I didn't consider, but I completely agree. They're so repressed and can't be themselves, so how do you connect with someone when you can't even connect with yourself? You're constantly made to question or made to think your true feelings and thoughts are wrong, so you can't even open up to the person you should be closest to. That's some really good insight and something to think about, thank you.
      It's honestly just so sad that they're constantly told to be something they're not and what they are isn't good enough. They're at least relatively intelligent and seem like they would have enjoyed higher education if they chose to do it like they clearly had originally planned to. But like you said, they have to repress who they really are and they've never had a true open talk about their real wants and needs. It's constantly, "oh yes, I absolutely do want this thing I'm told god wants me to do." "Omg me toom" *both nervously bites nails*

    • @joanncaribbeanfan4505
      @joanncaribbeanfan4505 2 года назад +12

      @@clairebearlife Agreed. They need sympathy. Like those poor Duggar girls. My gosh! What a horrible way to grow up. How does someone bounce back from that?

    • @berke2336
      @berke2336 2 года назад +3

      to be fair, their whole family treats Bethany like that.

  • @austinvanwinkle1120
    @austinvanwinkle1120 2 года назад +1608

    I dont know if you guys get this alot, but you've hella helped me deconstruct fron toxic christian fundamentalism!
    Love you and James!
    From Mennonite to Jennonite. Proudly!

    • @probablycrocheting
      @probablycrocheting 2 года назад +50

      congrats!! welcome to the dark side

    • @finevindicatedmess
      @finevindicatedmess 2 года назад +67

      I was raised non-denominational Christian. It wasn't hardcore, but I definitely learned a LOT of toxic beliefs along the way. Fundie Fridays really is doing the Lord's work -- pun intended -- by speaking out against these Fundie and Evangelical figures. But she also leaves room for nuance and "ethical snarking" as she puts it, and that's what made me fall in love with this channel. Back in the day, I used to follow an influencer much like Girl Defined. I was trying so hard to be a perfect little Christian, and it made me burn out. I started the long process of deconstructing and I still am deconstructing to this day. Ironically enough, even though I'm a hardcore agnostic, I still love Jesus and I have found so many other Christians (and non Christians!) who also love Jesus but are also feminist in nature.
      (If you listen to Montero by Lil Nas X and really study the lyrics and themes, you'll find the most accidentally Christian album out there -- and one of the best albums ever, in my not-so-humble queer opinion. I actually wrote a blog post about it!)

    • @nectarina3891
      @nectarina3891 2 года назад +10

      @@finevindicatedmess Link for the blog post? I also was raised non-denom christian and now love jen and lil nas ex and still love jesus but not religion lol. we have a lot in common. ahahha

    • @austinvanwinkle1120
      @austinvanwinkle1120 2 года назад +19

      I completely love this community.
      I started watching these videos, in a very judgemental way, when I was still deep into Plain/Mennonite living, and the irony is i honestly feel whatever "higher being"(not claiming which one) brought me to this channel to free me of the chains of Ultra conservative religion

    • @beckykeyes2910
      @beckykeyes2910 2 года назад +9

      Proud of you! I am an exfundie and it’s super tough and brave to deconstruct. Keep on keepin on :)

  • @jacquelinekemp4897
    @jacquelinekemp4897 2 года назад +244

    Bethy: wants desperately to be tan. Also Bethy: every photo and video is extremely over exposed.

    • @mynz4464
      @mynz4464 2 года назад +46

      "And then I realized dark skin was bad, and embraced my whiteness in the most toxic way possible." But for real, can she do anything moderately? Tanning till she blistered?

    • @dominicfucinari1942
      @dominicfucinari1942 2 года назад +5

      @@mynz4464 AND she's willing to roll the dice on melanoma! That was the condition that ruined the tanning oil industry back in the 00-Agents' Decade! Perhaps Beal has forgotten?

    • @Dutch3DMaster
      @Dutch3DMaster 2 года назад +8

      I feel the overexposed part is meant to give their video's a clean, heavenly pure look....and some camera's can be set so that the higher tone areas are using less contrast between darker elements, so that (especially in video) wrinkles in skin can become less apparent...

    • @Dutch3DMaster
      @Dutch3DMaster 2 года назад +5

      @@mynz4464 Well, if there's one thing that I can sort of relate to with Bethany it's also that I can't tan: I burn, whatever I do.
      When I was younger people said "You need to built up your exposure!" and whenever I had to be out in the sun for 15-20 minutes straight I burned, with sunscreen, people were immediately going "You don't need to do 2-3 hours straight!!" and I had to explain that it was just 15-20 minutes...
      (My mom has sometimes jokingly said that I should've had red hair :P )

    • @lydiathornton1999
      @lydiathornton1999 Год назад +1

      @@Dutch3DMaster haha, I DO have red hair and I was the same! And I'm the same age as these women so I definitely remember the huge emphasis on being tan when we were growing up and despairing of my inability to do so. I think I always knew that no "build up of exposure" (I remember that one too...) was going to change it though, so I just had to learn to love my ginger complexion. And now these two are, like, FULL Targaryen to a creepy degree so good for them, I guess...

  • @hushlander
    @hushlander 2 года назад +139

    It strikes me that how she explains the consequences of kids going to drag shows is exactly how I feel about mommy influencers who put their kids all over social media. “They can’t consent”, “in a 15, 20 years I wonder what stories we will see coming out”

    • @dominicfucinari1942
      @dominicfucinari1942 2 года назад +3

      As for gender reveal parties, which weren't a thing until a blog post from the year Two Double-O-Eight conceptualized them, barely any strangers will care whether a random social media obsessed couple's baby will be a boy or girl. And when a stranger *does* care, it's for the worst reasons imaginable.

    • @Dutch3DMaster
      @Dutch3DMaster 2 года назад

      @@dominicfucinari1942 That's....not exactly what hushlander was talking about, it's a very specific thing yes, that I also don't get about why to put that on social media, but not the overall thing...

    • @dwell7315
      @dwell7315 Год назад

      The irony knowing these girls' connections with the Duggars now, after SHP has come out, and this comment rang more true than I'm sure you were expecting.

  • @ilikecomicstoareallyproble8617
    @ilikecomicstoareallyproble8617 2 года назад +219

    These women nod more in their videos than I think I have in my 33 years of living.

    • @MISNM0
      @MISNM0 2 года назад +1

      🍻

    • @AVspectre
      @AVspectre 2 года назад +8

      * nods in agreement *

    • @MISNM0
      @MISNM0 2 года назад +2

      @@AVspectre
      💀🤣

  • @aravisthetarkheena
    @aravisthetarkheena 2 года назад +418

    Eesh, it's so insidious how they say that Marylin Monroe's life ended tragically even though she had "everything" ... like, it was her own personal decision rather than the fact that she was so horribly treated and never treated like a person by the society we live in 😑 it's very telling tbh

    • @madis4913
      @madis4913 2 года назад +30

      Especially makes me angry considering their own ignorant approach to mental health and sexuality. We’re talking about a woman whose relationship to sex was virtually always about men projecting onto her, even when she tried to assert herself like a grown woman. Nothing more biblical than that.

    • @Sputterbug
      @Sputterbug 2 года назад +15

      and she was treated by men how they want all women to be treated by men. which isnt good. theyre just projecting

    • @boots1622fan
      @boots1622fan 2 года назад

      purity culture has killed women but girl defined wants to blame the women instead smh

    • @2degucitas
      @2degucitas 2 года назад +3

      And they ignore all the evidence she was murdered

    • @laurend9829
      @laurend9829 2 года назад +2

      It’s also questionable if she killed herself or overdosed. Either way everyone projects their agenda onto her.

  • @juno3281
    @juno3281 2 года назад +227

    i don’t know how marilyn monroe would describe her life but i can guarantee it wouldn’t be “anything a woman could want”.

    • @2eachaccording
      @2eachaccording 2 года назад +1

      Agree: this DOES seem like a safe bet...

  • @skyboxAngel
    @skyboxAngel Год назад +18

    kristen looks like she's constantly prepared to say "bless your heart" in the most condescending possible way

  • @pigpjs
    @pigpjs 2 года назад +49

    While I don't think Bethy was scouted, my husband is a football coach for a public high school and has had homeschooled kids play on the team. Basically, they are allowed to try out for the after school sports/clubs at the public school they are districted in.
    He had one super religious homeschooler who did turn down a D1 scholarship because the kid didn't want to be that far from his church. It haunts my husband to this day that boy was handed an amazing chance at an education and turned it down with full support of his parents because of his religion.

  • @laurenconrad1799
    @laurenconrad1799 2 года назад +354

    With the sheer number of adult actresses discussing abuse from people like Harvey Weinstein and former child stars detailing abuse, don’t you think Jennette McCurdy or Rose McGowan could relate to Marylin Monroe more than Bethy can?

    • @2degucitas
      @2degucitas 2 года назад +1

      Yes.

    • @2degucitas
      @2degucitas 2 года назад +2

      @Melissa McGregor And they will be for life. Permanently undeveloped.

    • @Katie-mw7pd
      @Katie-mw7pd 2 года назад +4

      @Melissa McGregor I’ve noticed that too and it’s very sad in a way. These women are missing out on the opportunity to have true friendship and sisterhood with other women, because they assume women outside of their small circle wouldn’t understand their struggles or be able to relate to them. I think of how many of my female friends seem wildly different from me on the surface and wonder what I would be like if I had decided to never interact with them on the basis on them not being like me, and the image is really depressing; I wouldn’t have changed or grown at all.

    • @laurenconrad1799
      @laurenconrad1799 2 года назад +5

      @Melissa McGregor I was just thinking, they feel like teens rather than adults. But I don’t know if that’s because they’re targeting content for teens. Or maybe they’re targeting content to teens BECAUSE they can’t relate to other adults, especially outside fundamentalism. Watching these people is a never ending game of hating them and feeling sorry for them. Sometimes it feels like almost every person in a cult is both a perpetrator and a victim.

    • @laurenconrad1799
      @laurenconrad1799 2 года назад

      @beebeebee thanks. ❤❤❤

  • @kaorufan8
    @kaorufan8 2 года назад +426

    She really said "my husband sucks in the sac" and somehow blamed herself for him not being able to get her off, huh?

    • @emanzeism
      @emanzeism 2 года назад +49

      Yes, yes she did.

    • @Force-hiddenmasquerade
      @Force-hiddenmasquerade 2 года назад +104

      Like… is it sinful to teach a man what and where the clitoris is lmao

    • @kaorufan8
      @kaorufan8 2 года назад +17

      @@Force-hiddenmasquerade Sure seems like it! Ditto for the best adult use of the ABCs apparently

    • @missmelodies52
      @missmelodies52 2 года назад +54

      But if you can’t properly communicate (which I doubt she would), how can he be expected to be good? Like if it’s not what you want… just tell him what you want as opposed to trying to “retrain you body”

    • @DieAlteistwiederda
      @DieAlteistwiederda 2 года назад +19

      Talking like this just makes me sad as fuck. I've been with my partner for 13 years now and we aren't married which of course would give people like them a fucking heart attack but we also communicated our wants and needs from day one. Even though we met when we were 16/17.

  • @carelsby
    @carelsby 2 года назад +93

    I was deep in purity culture as a young person, and theres this whiplash that happens because the people leading purity culture movement preach “modesty” and yet talk extremely explicitly about their sex lives, their sin struggles, etc has always confused me. Like you said “you could not waterboard that information out of me”
    Dont get me wrong, i think talking about that highly personal stuff with a trusted friend or mentor is fine and healthy, but these women get up in front of thousands of people and talk about how their husbands cant make them c*m. I call it “parasocial group therapy” and it is rife in the evangelical christian world. I remember vividly being at christian college and hearing a woman literally sobbing her eyes out on stage talking about her past. For people that shove physical modesty down people’s throats, theres no nuance in how they speak, no boundaries in what they talk about, no sense of decorum or appropriate topics.

  • @bethanysellers
    @bethanysellers 2 года назад +361

    As a fellow Bethany, I'm SO glad you started calling her "Bethy" because whenever you use her full name I always get this split-second "uh-oh, Jen's mad at me 😰".

  • @MandaMalice
    @MandaMalice 2 года назад +162

    “You could not waterboard that information out of me”
    I howled!!!

  • @whatever3145
    @whatever3145 2 года назад +430

    They better get Marilyn's name out of their mouth. So disrespectful and exploitative, even after death people continue to use and disrespect her, I hate it.

    • @whatever3145
      @whatever3145 2 года назад +36

      and! Marilyn never had everything she could ever want, like wtf? They don't know anything about her they're so annoying and tacky.

    • @harrietamidala1691
      @harrietamidala1691 2 года назад +25

      @@whatever3145 and they also disrespect Marilyn’s Jewish conversion.

    • @everjustcuriousdesigns5190
      @everjustcuriousdesigns5190 2 года назад +3

      I was about to type the same thing. 😅
      As an aside...Bethany gives the rest of us "Beths" a bad name and helps fuel the "cringey" stereotype. 😒

  • @hellkitty98
    @hellkitty98 2 года назад +479

    31:24 Kristen really told on herself by admitting that she thinks “it’s scary” to look within herself and have all these options and possibilities of who and what she could be.. it’s honestly so sad they think that’s a bad thing and they don’t want that for other people or their own children.. what a sad life. also how brain broken do you have to believe that that’s a bad thing??

    • @simsamsammie
      @simsamsammie 2 года назад +5

      +

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад +6

      I mean, I think people can definitely focus way too much on themselves, e.g. navel-gazing.

    • @wareforcoin5780
      @wareforcoin5780 2 года назад +1

      They're only Christians because they're too intellectually lazy to make their own identity. Honestly, I feel kind of bad for them. They live in a cage of self-inflicted stupidity. But whatever, they can live their lives however they want, I'm going to be great over here despite their opinions on it.
      On birth control: ✓
      Bisexual: ✓
      Atheist: ✓
      Sleeping with people while not being married to them: ✓
      Not buying their books (or even going to their RUclips channel): ✓✓✓
      Sorry girls, but you can't define me. I'm living in sin and loving it. Oh, and speaking out on both control only makes the pill tastier, and should it ever fail me, I'm going to abort. 💅

    • @TheKatarinaGiselle
      @TheKatarinaGiselle 2 года назад +1

      @@naryainc I agree, and pushing thibjig about it onto teens who are already overthinking themselves in every way can do more harm than good.

    • @hellkitty98
      @hellkitty98 2 года назад +14

      @@TheKatarinaGiselle no one is pushing anything onto teens, it’s about opening doors. if anything these types of people are shoving ideas down teens throats. i don’t see how it’s “so bad” to want to explore even more of your identity as a teen? so many people claim its “bad” or confusing but how is it helpful to withhold this information when i’ve always been a bit curious and confused about my identity (sexuality and gender identity) since i was in 4th grade?? i would’ve loved to have the words and concepts i’ve been learning when i was a teenager. i knew i liked girls and boys in 4th grade. i know i mostly present as female/a woman but sometimes i don’t feel like i have a gender, i’m just a person. i’ve had this feeling since 8th-9th grade. what is so bad about having these open conversations about these things?! the worst that can happen is that you realize that some things don’t apply to you and what you’re feeling and that’s fine. ridiculous though to believe it’s harmful.

  • @lane6216
    @lane6216 2 года назад +124

    These women are insufferable. I was raised in a cult, and had to work very hard to undo being raised to be an abuse victim.
    I’m finally full free. Cheering for all those still fighting through. 💕

    • @pickledragonrebel
      @pickledragonrebel 2 года назад +7

      So happy you're free ! Congrats

    • @lane6216
      @lane6216 2 года назад +5

      @@pickledragonrebel, thank you so much. :)

  • @erinhammo9291
    @erinhammo9291 2 года назад +184

    It's so crazy that Kirsten can somehow just get so close to crossing into non-fundie territory and then she swings back in the hardest ways, i.e. being transphobic. You know that she definitely has random thoughts sometimes about her own identity and purpose and then she blinks and she's back to being ofZack. Also you can tell she never goes downtown or she would be eaten uuuup by San Antonio's Queens.

    • @alexandraseabrook9242
      @alexandraseabrook9242 2 года назад +31

      Yes! Sometimes when I watch Kristen I can see these flickers of recognition in her eyes...of like "Maybe I'm getting something wrong here", but it fades as quickly as it comes lol

    • @JasmineTea127
      @JasmineTea127 2 года назад +13

      'ofZack' XD

    • @erinhammo9291
      @erinhammo9291 2 года назад +20

      @@alexandraseabrook9242 And her personal issues veer so closely to left-leaning policies, but she just can't cross the finish line!

  • @sydneyp7867
    @sydneyp7867 2 года назад +166

    Kristen’s anti masturbation plan is such a fascinating thing to me. What she described is a really valuable skill in Dialectical Behaviour Therapy (ABC). It’s just applied in an insane really harmful way in Kristen’s case.

  • @hesboo
    @hesboo 2 года назад +495

    I don’t know what we did to be graced with this incredible makeup look AND more Girl Defined snark, but I’m feeling truly blessed.

    • @brittlebricks10
      @brittlebricks10 2 года назад +6

      I love the choice of lip color with the bright green.

  • @laurena9563
    @laurena9563 2 года назад +229

    Fun fact: I'm not American, was visiting my friend in Texas, we walked into an Altar'd State because it looked like it had cute clothes, only to be jump-scared by an employee when we got far enough into the store to realize everything in the home goods section had bible quotes on it 😂

    • @laurenconrad1799
      @laurenconrad1799 2 года назад

      That’s like walking into what you think is Hot Topic and ending up in Spencer’s. 😂 (For those who don’t know, Hot Topic is a store that sold black clothes and goth accessories to emo teens in malls in the 2000s while Spencer’s was a sex toy store that looked similar to Hot Topic, often confusing teens who just wanted a My Chemical Romance t-shirt and weren’t quite ready to buy a dildo just yet. Lol)

    • @queenvictoriathethird
      @queenvictoriathethird 2 года назад +12

      I loved the clothing at altered state and the clothes are so cute if you aren't on the hefty side. My favorite part of going to the store, was taking my very atheist boyfriend and making bible jokes at the store. Despite the fact that we were being fucking rude and are a mixed race couple in a town that isn't that representative of us, everyone was really nice. Still wish I could fit those clothes, and ironically carry around bible quoting totes. It was a christian hippy wonderland and I lived for it.

    • @joyceneville9214
      @joyceneville9214 2 года назад +6

      I went to Alter’d States website and burned my fingers on the prices! Worse, way too many crop top styles and other things that would have a Texas 16y.o dress coded at school! C’mon now! I’m not paying $60 bucks for a shirt!

    • @ultraboombean
      @ultraboombean 2 года назад

      @@joyceneville9214 i gotta be honest tho put on their clothes and it is sooo soft. Lol . I mean some of their stuff not worth the price but the jackets, cardigans , sweaters are amazing lol.

    • @sheelfjohnson
      @sheelfjohnson 2 года назад +8

      Haha! I just heard "altered state" and thought "drug paraphernalia".

  • @becausehiddles
    @becausehiddles 2 года назад +970

    Girl Defined is really out here saying drag queens are harming children by being "oversexualized" and "predatory" when child beauty pageants are literally right there

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад

      I honestly think you can make a compelling case for both being oversexualized and predatory.

    • @_o6629
      @_o6629 2 года назад +22

      They can't see it 🤌

    • @FanyLI
      @FanyLI 2 года назад +16

      Two things can be true at once, they just are blinded to one just like you it seems

    • @jeanakatherine9369
      @jeanakatherine9369 2 года назад +17

      @@FanyLI Exactly! Drag queen events are strictly 4 adults (imo) & that’s ok! & child beauty pageants are horrible also!!

    • @reidleblanc3140
      @reidleblanc3140 2 года назад +20

      some drag is definitely that way, but the art has gotten so much broader recently. like drag these days basically means "putting on absurd amounts of makeup while being a gay male"

  • @emschule
    @emschule 2 года назад +39

    they really said "thinking is so hard i just want someone to tell me what to do! looking within is terrifying"

  • @lanaunicorn
    @lanaunicorn 2 года назад +175

    Take a shot every time Jen includes “thank you Michelle” clip in her videos
    God I love that video

    • @8polyglot
      @8polyglot 2 года назад +5

      Thank you, Michelle!

  • @Akursedtime
    @Akursedtime 2 года назад +342

    I have never seen two sisters who look more uncomfortable with each other. The awkward laughter, the nods and the uptight facial features.
    They nearly look like one of them is going to scratch each others eyes out. 🤣

    • @shinyfruitbat8024
      @shinyfruitbat8024 2 года назад +30

      I definitely get the impression they can't stand each other, too, esp with the constant shade they throw at one another lol. It wouldn't be surprising if it came out that they only "tolerate" each other on camera, and are worse off camera.

    • @soveryeri1
      @soveryeri1 2 года назад +18

      God I hope it's caught on video when bethy finally snaps

    • @macymiller7858
      @macymiller7858 2 года назад +3

      They are sisters??? Yikes yeah they don’t give sister vibes wow

    • @Ukraineaissance2014
      @Ukraineaissance2014 Год назад

      They sort of look the same but different at the same time? I think they just look like generic bigoted american blonde woman to my foreign eyes.

    • @mandeanraje2300
      @mandeanraje2300 Год назад +2

      Sister relationships are rough sometimes. But when you put money into it… a nightmare if y’all are not tight like that. I’m repairing my relationship to my sister but you couldn’t paaayyyy me to get in such a public business with her when I can’t just walk away. Lmao I’ll drive myself to where we go just so I can walk out when I need to. So I can empathize, but babes it was a choice.

  • @AidenFeltkamp
    @AidenFeltkamp 2 года назад +155

    These two are the mean girls I had to deal with my whole childhood in the stupid mega church I was forced to attend. It’s so clear exactly who they are. Thanks for this breakdown!!

  • @jbshiva865
    @jbshiva865 2 года назад +75

    We really need the Fundie Fridays/Trixie Mattel collab video. Even if it's just putting on makeup or making toast.

    • @radbuffman3487
      @radbuffman3487 2 года назад +2

      Or putting makeup on toast 🤔

    • @jbshiva865
      @jbshiva865 2 года назад +1

      @@radbuffman3487 There was a trend of putting makeup on eggs so why not toast?

  • @thxwanderer
    @thxwanderer Год назад +29

    I find it very odd that a LOT of drag queens have spoken out about drag not being a space for children in general and yet... parents still bring their children and then are shocked when even "child friendly" is used very loosely. Don't take your children to drag events if you think that specific event is going to be too much. Obviously an event where a queen is just reading a book to children is unproblematic compared to a set that may include NSFW elements. Like, come on now.

    • @giannaleng1897
      @giannaleng1897 Год назад +7

      This. They’re are a lot of drag shows that will tell you that it is 18+. So don’t bring your child that is not an adult. It’s not complicated yall

  • @SharhanSLS
    @SharhanSLS 2 года назад +124

    I went to a conference once where these two girls spoke. They were still teenagers and it was supposed to be a mother/ daughter convention. It had to be well over 10 years ago. I remember thinking they were great and how they turned out exactly how my parents wished I would have been as a teen. Or probably even now. It’s is fascinating how one can be immersed into an environment and essentially trained to think a certain way while being unable to see how obviously dangerous the rhetoric actually is.
    Also… your makeup looks fabulous especially the sparkly eye shadow.

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад

      What rhetoric of theirs do you consider to be dangerous?

  • @nataliepaad1869
    @nataliepaad1869 2 года назад +107

    Why do these kinds of women spend so much time telling other women that they should just stay home and not pursue careers.... while they pursue their own sick, twisted "career"? Also, your eyeshadow is absolutely amazing. Great dance too lol

    • @Dutch3DMaster
      @Dutch3DMaster 2 года назад +1

      Sometimes it feels that it's OK if you do it from the home...

  • @danielleseibert7728
    @danielleseibert7728 2 года назад +153

    FINALLY SOMEONE TALKS ABOUT ALTARD STATE! As someone from their town when I found out the store was selling their books I was not shocked but super disappointed… I will never shop there ever

    • @katefarr2036
      @katefarr2036 2 года назад +19

      I didn’t know they existed. And now I know where not to shop.

    • @rachel_sj
      @rachel_sj 2 года назад +11

      As someone who thrifts, shops at local stores, sometimes goes to Anthropologie/Free People (when they got sales going on), walking into an Altar'd State is like walking into a Boho Bizzaro World. It's unsettling 😱

    • @manderly33
      @manderly33 2 года назад +2

      @@rachel_sj Yeah, I saw that storefront in the video and immediately said, “oh, they’re biting off Anthropologie.”

    • @rachel_sj
      @rachel_sj 2 года назад

      @@manderly33 I think the only reason Altar'd State confuses me is because, compared to past Christian Goods Stores and Bookstores, they're a carbon copy (albeit a bit boring and uninspiring) compared to Anthro/Free People
      Growing up,I remember the only Christian Clothing options being oversized, tacky T-shirts and baseball caps, with Bible covers as the ultimate accessory.
      I still kick myself thinking about when my sister and I walked into one at a mall a couple of years ago, but, I'll admit, I sometimes go onto their site to see what kind of clothing and items they sell, just outta morbid curiousity.
      Oh, they also have a Bridal store called Vow'd too and the same sentiments apply to that branch too...

  • @beththielman9106
    @beththielman9106 2 года назад +65

    Those blurry shots of their waists, legs, and feet are so inspiring.

  • @Samantha-dv4je
    @Samantha-dv4je 2 года назад +77

    I once saw a drag queen dress up as Dobby the elf😂…..although I guess that would be extra horrifying to them

  • @cipherpac
    @cipherpac 2 года назад +122

    I don't know why, but these two saying "what does that mean for everyday average girls like us?" While being very conspicuously well-off, blonde Christian youtubers/published authors in full makeup and Sunday clothes shooting a video on several thousand dollars' worth of video equipment made me laugh out loud.

  • @laurenconrad1799
    @laurenconrad1799 2 года назад +146

    Did someone forget to tell these two that adult siblings who hate each other are allowed to avoid each other at all times of the year except the holidays? Did their fundie community neglect to give them that memo?

    • @harveyhaslostit
      @harveyhaslostit 2 года назад +24

      They're kinda financially dependent on their brand ie each other, are they not?
      A big part of them seeming like they've had enough of each other might be that they are basically co-workers who have to spend a lot of time on their job together, so that could really add up over the years.

    • @laurenconrad1799
      @laurenconrad1799 2 года назад +9

      @@harveyhaslostit I personally understand the feeling of having a tense relationship with your sister. But that’s why I don’t actively see her and only end up seeing her when visiting my parents. And I wouldn’t in a million years become coworkers or even go on vacation with her, because I know my limits and I’m not stupid.

    • @ZazooEel57
      @ZazooEel57 2 года назад +4

      That's why Bethany started to do her own thing but it's really not taking off because all she does is speak about how much she hates her husbands and how everyone should have a side hustle but only if they buy her course...

    • @ultraboombean
      @ultraboombean 2 года назад +1

      @@laurenconrad1799 yeah my sisters and I get along but we don't hang out and if we had to spend that many days in a row together we would end up in a brawl.

    • @luciel7751
      @luciel7751 2 года назад +1

      @@laurenconrad1799 Hmm, personally I don't hate anyone in my family

  • @LifeStyleResearch
    @LifeStyleResearch 2 года назад +58

    Just going to say this is your best casetify ad this year. No joke, that was well done. Bring back local government and community ads.

  • @Leahi2024
    @Leahi2024 Год назад +16

    I’m going to say this the nicest way I can. I feel like most of the animosity is Bethy towards Kristen, bc they’re from a very vain and appearance obsessed culture, and Kristen is very conventionally attractive. Bethy strikes me as resentful of Kristen. I get the impression Kristen is favored by their parents and community higher than Bethy mainly bc of appearance. Bethy seems to take so much joy in cutting down Kristen for her fertility issues, I think it’s bc Bethy finally has a fundie social advantage over her

  • @goblin3359
    @goblin3359 2 года назад +60

    I can't imagine a more miserable, repressive, incurious and counter-creative family environment than the Girl Defined household. What nasty pieces of work.
    You and James, however are delightful, colourful and empathetic beings and I adore you both. Thanks for another great video.

  • @kelleyt9869
    @kelleyt9869 2 года назад +124

    I love how they're getting so flustered at the number of options for women in the world. I bet they really hold up the line at chik fil a.

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад +1

      What do you mean?

    • @michellexbeauty9832
      @michellexbeauty9832 2 года назад +17

      @@naryaincit’s a joke, like they probably can never decide what to eat at the chick fil a drive thru because they can’t comprehend women having free will

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад +3

      @@michellexbeauty9832 Ah, I see.

    • @reidleblanc3140
      @reidleblanc3140 2 года назад +8

      chik fil a is a fitting choice of store for this joke lmao.

  • @latesummer
    @latesummer 2 года назад +313

    if a 6'5" princess came to read to my kindergarten class at story time id like the world a little bit more

    • @Dutch3DMaster
      @Dutch3DMaster 2 года назад +20

      Girl Defined also typically likes to reinforce the idea of a very limited, very stereotypical appearance of men: in their discussions about trans people or drag queens they always use the examples of supertall men, with superbroad shoulders and obviously male body characteristics....
      And while some of the people I know are not religious (and if they are, not to the level of Girl Defined), those ideas about masculinity and femininity when it comes to appearance are stubborn: as soon as they meet me (I'm a transfemale) they get completely confused, "Why are you so relatively short for someone born, like...ehm, well you know?" or "You have such small shoulders for a man..."
      It's really weird that people only realise that almost no one looks like their stereotypical idea of men and women, including themselves.

    • @GrumpyKay
      @GrumpyKay Год назад

      Christians like these women are hallow, superficial, empty, awkward, DRY and uncomfortable to be around. They lack tenderness, love, and acceptance. Them reading books to kids would be the most boring and dead show.
      Now a Drag Queen on the other hand, is fun, supportive, positive, accepting. You genuinely feel loved and you feel the warmth from drag queens. And they are FUNNY!! Like hands down, kids will have a better time with drag queens instead of 2 dried up shallow witches who lack depth and especially warmth.

    • @hailyjohnson407
      @hailyjohnson407 Год назад +6

      @@Dutch3DMaster definitely! Like my boyfriend is 6'3" and very hairy, but otherwise, he doesn't have other traditionally masculine physical traits. If you shaved him and removed the very prominent Adam's apple, he'd just look like a tall, thin woman. He doesn't have broad shoulders or a sharp jawline. He has soft facial features and a relatively undefined frame, not a masculine or feminine build/body shape. He also has super, super long eyelashes naturally, so if you shaved his facial hair off and looked at only his face, you'd probably think he was a woman with his soft face shape and soft eyes. Most people have a mixture of "masculine" and "feminine" body traits.

    • @evelien135
      @evelien135 Год назад +5

      @@hailyjohnson407 haha same for my man. He is tall. But very slender with piano hands & if you’d shave his beard.. also extremely long thick lashes of which I’m very envious.
      Also.. I’m quite tall. The kid I used to babysit is now a grown trans woman. She was talking about ffs and I said: girl the things you are naming as masculine about your face.. I am a cis woman and my face has all those things trans women describe as manly 😩
      You look at least as much as a cis woman as I do.

  • @IndigoAlpha
    @IndigoAlpha 2 года назад +128

    Good to know that the Cold War between them to be the Alpha Sister ™ is still going strong after all these years ❤

  • @Sophie-iq2tw
    @Sophie-iq2tw Год назад +15

    32:00 confusion isn't always a negative thing. continuing to develop your identity throughout your life is a beautiful thing. that confusion becomes harmful (stressful, depressing, self-guilt) when certain possibilities are seen as wrong and even disgusting

  • @gracelament
    @gracelament 2 года назад +58

    So let's add Girl Defined to the long list of people who use Marylin Monroe's death as a host for the shit they should probably be unpacking in therapy...

  • @JasmineTea127
    @JasmineTea127 2 года назад +73

    Oh my gosh the pain on Kristen’s face when they talked about wanting to fight against their roles as women!

  • @callielee
    @callielee 2 года назад +66

    all I know is that MY purpose as a woman is to destroy everything these two stand for lol

  • @trashnyc
    @trashnyc 2 года назад +371

    As a cis woman drag queen whose sexiest number is a Danny DeVito mix, thank you for advocating for drag as an art form and (selfishly) for reminding everyone that drag performers aren’t all cis men. You’re the best, as usual 💖

    • @tarajh
      @tarajh 2 года назад +22

      A Danny Devito mix?! Do you have any vids online of your performances? ♡

    • @blaszaczka
      @blaszaczka 2 года назад

      Girl, that must be sexy

    • @coffee8599
      @coffee8599 2 года назад +2

      I actually didn't know that! Sounds fun. Enjoy yourself!

    • @ollie72
      @ollie72 2 года назад +1

      SLAY THATS SO FUN

    • @trashnyc
      @trashnyc 2 года назад +2

      @@blaszaczka if you saw my little gremlin look after the reveal, I think you’d stand by that assessment 😂

  • @salem7700
    @salem7700 2 года назад +97

    Would you potentially do a new Sister Wives video? I saw a tweet referencing Cody being down to 1 wife and would love to hear what is happening and I love your videos and how you go over everything and would rather wait than seek out other people lol

    • @Rhaifha
      @Rhaifha 2 года назад +13

      Sooo, afaik Kody basically abandoned Meri, Christine said "fuck this shit" and divorced (not that they were legally married) and then Janelle joined the party as well and left. Good on them. I hope they find happiness in their independence.

    • @emilybarclay8831
      @emilybarclay8831 2 года назад +5

      @@Rhaifha so he finally got what he wanted, Robin being his only wife?

    • @salem7700
      @salem7700 2 года назад +1

      @@Rhaifha Dang yea I knew about Christine leaving but not anyone else. Honestly good for them

    • @bonesonstones1
      @bonesonstones1 2 года назад

      From what I've read, Cody was the one to break up with Meri during the filming of a special (?), on camera. Apparently, he was having doubts about polygamy. Would love a video on this as well!

  • @stillmagic714
    @stillmagic714 2 года назад +64

    I love how they're like "parents should be teaching kids these things" and then talk about how terrible it is that parents are teaching kids these things.

  • @Oskan247
    @Oskan247 2 года назад +23

    I cackled at the line "damn, you could not waterboard that out of me". Same girl. Same.

  • @glossypots
    @glossypots 2 года назад +217

    When GD were talking about buying wedding dress before finding the man, I grew up with girls who considered the last and least important wedding accessory was the GROOM. They paid heavily for that one in the years that followed.

    • @andreakoroknai1071
      @andreakoroknai1071 2 года назад +21

      I was going to say, she needed to find a husband to match that dress:O

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад +13

      That is pretty sad. I do get that someone who likes to plan out their life in advance and who knows their taste might be tempted to buy a dress in their early 20s without even being in a relationship, but I think you might set yourself up for failure if you do. Your body might change drastically, you might feel pressure to find someone and feel like a failure if haven't and your taste might simply change by the time you'd actually wear the dress.

    • @lacey892
      @lacey892 2 года назад +7

      @@naryainc when you grow up in a culture that only values married women or women with children, it becomes like the pinnacle of womanhood for them. I always thought Bethany was violently jealous of her sister for getting married first, which is why I think the purchase of the dress was also probably like a way to take a passive aggressive jab at her.

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад +3

      @@lacey892 I think Bethy was envious, not jealous. But I also think who wouldn't be at a young age. I at least used to wish I was married in my early 20s because life was hard on your own, but then again I'm really glad now that I didn't find anyone then because life would probably have been just as hard with a 20 year old husband. Although, I also have to admit that I admire how much fundie culture values mothers and married women, because the mainstream western culture sure as hell does not value motherhood. However, it's not okay that fundie mothers then parentify their own daughters instead of actually mothering their own kids.

    • @dominicfucinari1942
      @dominicfucinari1942 2 года назад +2

      @@naryainc It may seem like only non-western culture values motherhood, but if you want to encourage more women in the US to marry and have children, it has to be affordable, and you'd have to take that up with whoever made medical and child care costs so steep, just to start.

  • @ananicholson6152
    @ananicholson6152 2 года назад +41

    “She was looking up new hats!” Why did I cried laughing at this

  • @vsmith1688
    @vsmith1688 2 года назад +129

    Between you and Annamarie, my Friday has been blessed with a double dose of Girl Defined dunking.

  • @Spookyspooky16
    @Spookyspooky16 2 года назад +28

    32:55 “DAMN, You could not water board that information outta me” 💀💀💀💀I spit my coffee out

  • @whimsical_me5135
    @whimsical_me5135 2 года назад +67

    Guys! I'm celebrating Christmas for the first time in my life this year! I just wanted to say thank you to Jen and James for the part they've played in my deconstruction❤ it feels good to make my own choices.

  • @joy2pointoh
    @joy2pointoh 2 года назад +45

    jfc Marilyn can't get a break in any subculture. let the woman rest

  • @sarahenchanted
    @sarahenchanted 2 года назад +60

    they clearly hate each other and have 0 chemistry which makes it hard to take them seriously compared to other influencers. Also people who demonize drag queens like this live in their own world. At pride this year this little girl (with her parents holding her) was handing out dollar bills to the queens doing lip syncs and it was just the cutest thing and the world didn't end!!
    Also you or James def should do an episode about Allie Beth Stuckey... she's something

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад

      I just hope you don't make excuses for people who are trying to break down the boundaries between adults expressing their sexuality and children, because that would be disgusting.

    • @user-mv5zt8qd9l
      @user-mv5zt8qd9l Год назад

      @@naryainc I just hope you don't go round throwing that accusation out without evidence like the rest of the "LGBT = groomer" crowd

  • @epgarokco
    @epgarokco 2 года назад +53

    I want to compliment your hair, and your makeup, and your jewelry, and your cardigan.... Then I just realized it would be best defined to compliment your EXISTANCE!!! You are such an inspiration to humans!

  • @radiostatic
    @radiostatic 2 года назад +35

    Ah yes, Bethany’s “e-books.” A PDF containing a cover and two pages of info. *Priceless* literature at our fingertips.

  • @lopsidedbear6301
    @lopsidedbear6301 2 года назад +36

    Imagine being bothered by a pretty person in a pretty dress reading picture books to little kids.

  • @killeravocado
    @killeravocado 2 года назад +37

    "And I'm a Reverend! Fuck you." was the best part of the video.

  • @mikkilarese4930
    @mikkilarese4930 2 года назад +105

    I use to work at altard state... I would love to see a deep dive on this store.... I have STORIES

    • @aquariusshade
      @aquariusshade 2 года назад +8

      Ooh, please tell.

    • @starzzzy22
      @starzzzy22 2 года назад +7

      I've been in the store at my local mall and always thought "who is this for?" and now I know! I'd love to see a deep dive on the store and hear some stories.

    • @funnycatzz123
      @funnycatzz123 2 года назад +1

      I am so intrigued now!!

  • @mikekuppen6256
    @mikekuppen6256 2 года назад +30

    Always assumed mom Heidi was pronounced the German way (something like Haidi). Learning it´s pronounced Hatey in Texas made my day.

  • @izzyb404
    @izzyb404 2 года назад +71

    i find it so interesting that girl defined loses their absolute shit over the lgbtq+ community “grooming” kids by existing but then they go on their channel, something they know is very heavily watched by vulnerable and sheltered children, and talk about sexual interactions in VERY graphic detail that absolutely nobody needs to hear, especially young girls being groomed by the church

  • @stan_dinghere
    @stan_dinghere 2 года назад +25

    the part about how its too hard to figure out who you are if youre given freedom is actually so sad

  • @youllaskforme
    @youllaskforme 2 года назад +57

    There is something so funny about watching ‘Marilyn’ file her freshly painted nails during their mission statement video

  • @PerksJ
    @PerksJ 2 года назад +37

    I think this is the only channel I actually watch the ads on and don’t jump thru. Great work guys!

  • @laurenconrad1799
    @laurenconrad1799 2 года назад +112

    “If you’re gonna say I know better than god…” Well, I know better than Bethy and Kristen.

    • @Saibellus
      @Saibellus 2 года назад +13

      i like that they immediately leapt to "better than god" um last i checked krithany god made trans people so who are YOU to say you know better than them~

    • @laurenconrad1799
      @laurenconrad1799 2 года назад +1

      @@Saibellus YES!

  • @poppysdaddi
    @poppysdaddi 2 года назад +32

    also love them admitting that their husbands can’t satisfy them sexually 😭

  • @elisewhatley
    @elisewhatley 2 года назад +36

    "In short: Girl defined bad. Fundie Fridays good." - Rev. Jen

  • @Kb-gh2rk
    @Kb-gh2rk 2 года назад +42

    I honestly just fucking love that they changed their last name to honor their Nazi roots. I don’t know why that makes me laugh cry every time I think about it. 😂🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️
    Who tf does that.

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад +3

      I know, that is actually bonkers. I really hope they talk more about that and expose themselves further.

    • @Lilacrosepetalleaf
      @Lilacrosepetalleaf 2 года назад

      Seriously?

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад +1

      @@Lilacrosepetalleaf Yes, they didn't use those exact words but you can look him up and make your own conclusion.

  • @amandawilliams5352
    @amandawilliams5352 2 года назад +88

    My favorite thing about Reddit snarkers talking about girl defined is that they abbreviate it to GD so it always sounds like they're talking about "that GOT DAYUM CHANNEL!"
    I love it.

    • @Letthatonemarinate-h2r
      @Letthatonemarinate-h2r 2 года назад +2

      I always read it as “gestational diabetes”

    • @naryainc
      @naryainc 2 года назад +1

      @@Letthatonemarinate-h2r I read it as Gender Discourse...

    • @skrtskrt22
      @skrtskrt22 2 года назад +1

      I think it's gdragon.

  • @RachelETyler
    @RachelETyler 2 года назад +8

    I, a queer, casually gender-queer, Reverend and Deacon in the Episcopal Church fully agree with your canonical view of the woman in Proverbs 31. Love it, love the things you do. You provide such community to those who grew up this way and I for one am grateful.

  • @gamerwednesdayaddams
    @gamerwednesdayaddams 2 года назад +18

    As someone who lives in San Antonio, I was shocked to remember these women live in my city. I almost expect them to be from Utah or California