@@Cstumps I know why you're saying it's not live because she seemed very weak and non-emotional but some people can belt out their voices more subtly like that. Also, if you compare this with the recorded version, it's different. There's a bit more background reverb in her vocals in this one.
They're doing the bare minimum of dancing though, is the bg dancers that are doing most of the scenery, which as you said, since they're great singers, is fine
JYP proposed this idea to KBS, and they found these 4 divas for him. It is a new concept, that's why it's has some kpop flavors in their performance, not just pure singing. JYP did mentioned his goal is to have them do a concert/concerts eventually, or even a small tour.
It was all his idea to recruited the legendary four singers and he directly called them, convinced them to participate in this project. JYP and the four artists have known each other for a long time in Korean entertainment industry
K-pop desperately needs this kind of diversity and talent!! I’m so glad golden girls are able to showcase their abilities so let’s show them our support!!
They are all famous divas from the 1970s to 1990s. Even the way they are pulling off the choreo while singing....experience really does count a lot when it comes to stage presence.
@@mxgirl918 cant just shrug it off as difference in experience though.. Look at seventeen, ateez, mamamoo etc all these debuted with the same experience as any new debuts but they way out-performed the rest
@@ArgieSantos-ut9mr all that I listed are idols. Yes a portion of idols are artists but that’s not an excuse to say that idols don’t have experience and that’s why they aren’t able to perform like this
@@gamlash95 It's more like the group are built on whim. Because they need something like this factor, they disregarded the other factor. That's why, you can only 1-2 artist in every group being an all rounder. Because of the said reason, also people tend to overlook vocal nowadays and love unrealistic choreos.
The iconic "JYP" IS BACK! Well, WE SHOULD TALK ABT THIS GURLS INSTEAD! THEY HAVE INSANE VOCALS and they aren't your usual group since the are already in there 50s and STILL SLAY THE INDUSTRY. This is what you call a UNIQUE group that has talent!
For those who say that Golden Girls don't sing live, I leave you at minute 2:39 Dude, Park Mi Kyung literally sang much earlier in this part by accident, that's enough proof that they are singing live lol
@@bkp3414yh, kpop group members have to have stable enough vocals (like when you have a karaoke session with a friend who has a mediocre singing voice) with stupidly intense choreo, while actual singers put SOUL and SKILL in their vocals. I honestly wanna see more professional singers in kpop groups.
We need more of this in kpop. We've had enough kpop girl groups with young teens and young adults. More women groups would be a groundbreaking moment in the kpop Industry!!
Yes, YES. It's so healthy to have diversity of reference of people to admire. Now that I'm getting older it feels so calming to see older women have protagonism and validation and talent as well. It gives me hope
@@user-jc9vb7ki1vbut there are 2 women with short hair , except for one has a buzz cut and one just has a normal cut which i don't know the name but isn't too short .
It's quite strange that we only have a single group that can perform like this, 100% live (Mamamoo), and few singers like Ailee, Hyolyn, CL, AKMU, just to name a few, still do it without the playback of current groups such as IVE, Le Sserafim and New Jeans. The new generations of K-pop should be prepared to sing completely live on music programs.
I am so excited for this new era of Kpop I hope they continue revolutionising the Kpop industry and this way no toxic fans can complain about dating since these ladies are probably married with grandkids
Yes this is the moment! Love hearing great raw vocals again in kpop. This is the revival we needed and they got contemporary ending fairies. Thank you JYP for bringing this group together!
the fact JYP himself watched backstage for these divas are literally so wholesome he's like a dad who watches over his daughters during their performance
박진영이 이 그룹을 결성하기 위해서 그 오랜기간 시행착오를 겪으며 엔터 제작자로 활동한 건가 싶을 정도로 완성도 높은 그룹이었음. 박진영이 진짜 하고 싶은 걸 한 느낌. 그 그림이 눈 앞에 펼쳐져서 감동적이었음. 박진영이 생각하는 최적의 이상향 그룹이 아닐까 싶은 무대였다.
They're impressive! It really shows age doesn't matter when it comes to your passion and dreams. Their vocals are so powerful. We, at the ages of 20-25 act like old people 😂, while they, at the ages of 66, 58, and 57 prove that age is just a number. I wish to listen to more songs from them.❤
I am here seated for Queen InSooni. Before Yoon Mirae and Lee Michelle, there was InSooni. 😭❤️ Each three of them are legends in their own right. With similar stories when it comes to discrimination for being half-black. All three are tremendously talented.
와 진짜 은미언니 센터상 뭔가 알수없게 눈을 못때게 매력적 인순언니 에너지 리더쉽 에너지가 마디마디 느껴져서 음악에 지루할 틈이 없고 0_0 미경 언니 목소리는 귀구멍에 독보적으로 꽃히네요 꽃혀 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 노래랑 잘어울려요! 먼가 진짜 아이돌 가창력 같은 느낌 2000% 효범언니는 비주얼 담당이확실하네요! ㅋㅋㅋㅋ노래도 좋지만 너무 예쁘신거같아요ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 얼굴에 시선이 확! 멋있어요!🎉
This is why there’s NO excuses for their juniors to lack so much in their vocal skills & range. They’re not being trained well and only so few of them actually put in work to improve vocally. Let these women and their healthy voices be a testament to how easy it is to use breath support and diction.
I clicked wondering who on earth would name a girl group "Golden Girls" and got a shock to see who were the members (maybe their group name should have just been Golden Legends lol). Made me think whether some time in the future we could have a 1st or 2nd gen supergroup like this when they themselves reach their "golden years". 😂
Nowadays we see so many younger idols on stage that paradoxically, seeing a group of older women is refreshing, reaaally refreshing ! I hope this will bring more diversity, less conformist and restrictions to the Kpop industry !
Their average age is 60 years old....and singing that song absolutely live?😮 Absolutely incredible ❤
They are not singing love. Check out 3:02. They are all talented, but this is not live singing
@@Cstumps I know why you're saying it's not live because she seemed very weak and non-emotional but some people can belt out their voices more subtly like that. Also, if you compare this with the recorded version, it's different. There's a bit more background reverb in her vocals in this one.
Their veteran in the industry, I don’t get why people are surprised…They’re better than current groups now
@@Cstumps라이브다 알고말해
experience…decades of entertaining. Love it.
These ladies are known for their singing I don't think it's necessary for them to dance, their voices can be captivating enough, you go golden girls!
They're doing the bare minimum of dancing though, is the bg dancers that are doing most of the scenery, which as you said, since they're great singers, is fine
and they're also aging, you can't trust aging people with dance.
저도 춤을 출 필요는 없다고 느낍니다만 대중들이 관심을 가지려면 이미 잘 하는 노래보다는 언니들의 더 큰 도전이 있어야하기에 춤을 같이 하는것 입니다
Girls ?
@@KangNdraAdventure Do you even know the name of the group?
JYP proposed this idea to KBS, and they found these 4 divas for him. It is a new concept, that's why it's has some kpop flavors in their performance, not just pure singing. JYP did mentioned his goal is to have them do a concert/concerts eventually, or even a small tour.
It was all his idea to recruited the legendary four singers and he directly called them, convinced them to participate in this project. JYP and the four artists have known each other for a long time in Korean entertainment industry
were they famous singers before being in the group? I don't know them sorry
They are all legendary singers/performers - Insooni, Park Mi-kyung, Shin Hyo-bum and Lee Eun-m.
@@osubin is there like a show on this?
@@domTT like trot singers?
K-pop desperately needs this kind of diversity and talent!! I’m so glad golden girls are able to showcase their abilities so let’s show them our support!!
こんなにパワーある歌声を表情崩さず出せるのすごすぎ
若さって武器になるはずなのに、それを用いてすら彼女らには何もかも勝てないような圧倒される雰囲気が出ているのがすごい
将来こういう歳の重ね方をしたいと感じさせられるグループや
Wow, they put idols to shame with their vocals....I wish everyone sang live like this!
They are all famous divas from the 1970s to 1990s. Even the way they are pulling off the choreo while singing....experience really does count a lot when it comes to stage presence.
@@mxgirl918 cant just shrug it off as difference in experience though.. Look at seventeen, ateez, mamamoo etc all these debuted with the same experience as any new debuts but they way out-performed the rest
@@gamlash95Some people just ain't cut from the same clothes.
There's a difference between an artist and an idol. That's why.
@@ArgieSantos-ut9mr all that I listed are idols. Yes a portion of idols are artists but that’s not an excuse to say that idols don’t have experience and that’s why they aren’t able to perform like this
@@gamlash95 It's more like the group are built on whim. Because they need something like this factor, they disregarded the other factor.
That's why, you can only 1-2 artist in every group being an all rounder. Because of the said reason, also people tend to overlook vocal nowadays and love unrealistic choreos.
聞いてきたけど結構なハイレベルで鳥肌。この年齢だからこそのパフォーマンスなのかもしれないが、若い頃でも見たかったな。日本には純烈というシニアアイドルグループがいるけど、年を重ねると色々言われやすいのが女性アイドルなのでそれを打ち破るような先駆け的な存在になってくれたら良いな…
The iconic "JYP" IS BACK! Well, WE SHOULD TALK ABT THIS GURLS INSTEAD! THEY HAVE INSANE VOCALS and they aren't your usual group since the are already in there 50s and STILL SLAY THE INDUSTRY. This is what you call a UNIQUE group that has talent!
Yesss! I miss hearing tags like “jyp” and “brave sound” 😢
@@Nina-xo555brave sound carried fr
I want a special stage of them with mamamoo it will be amazing!
So true!
And Spica.
mamadol too!!
YESSS
minus moonbyul
For those who say that Golden Girls don't sing live, I leave you at minute 2:39 Dude, Park Mi Kyung literally sang much earlier in this part by accident, that's enough proof that they are singing live lol
Even with the timing being a second off, they're still impressive AF!
They are singing live observe their lips ang belting technique.
I can see a huge gap between 'Professional Singer' and 'Idol Singer'. Golden Girls fighting!✊️🔥
Very true
@@bkp3414yh, kpop group members have to have stable enough vocals (like when you have a karaoke session with a friend who has a mediocre singing voice) with stupidly intense choreo, while actual singers put SOUL and SKILL in their vocals. I honestly wanna see more professional singers in kpop groups.
It’s giving second generation vibes and I’m obsessed. Their stability is on a whole another level!!!
can we go back to first gen 😭, i felt too old as i was introduced in the 2nd gen and im just half of their age 🤧
this is refreshing! it's not every day you see older people debut into kpop
And are the biggest sunbaes in the building at the same time, lol.
They did it once before with The Refund Sisters.
@@ragedvenom1487these woman are on. A whole other playing field. They are older and stronger as a vocal unit. It’s amazing really.
We need more of this in kpop. We've had enough kpop girl groups with young teens and young adults. More women groups would be a groundbreaking moment in the kpop Industry!!
Yes, YES. It's so healthy to have diversity of reference of people to admire. Now that I'm getting older it feels so calming to see older women have protagonism and validation and talent as well. It gives me hope
professionals!!!! they sing like that effortlessly??? amazing
They're solo artists so they have the skills😫❤
The one with the short hair!!!! Truly amazing, her voice is incredibly cool and really captivating.
그녀의 이름은 이은미 입니다 lee eun mi 많은 좋은 노래들이 있으니 꼭 들어보세요 😊
@@user-jc9vb7ki1vbut there are 2 women with short hair , except for one has a buzz cut and one just has a normal cut which i don't know the name but isn't too short .
@@Bunnyyy56 silver hair : lee eun mi
brown hair : shin hyo bum
@@user-jc9vb7ki1v ok thank you :)
they're the best 4th gen vocalist🤣
It's quite strange that we only have a single group that can perform like this, 100% live (Mamamoo), and few singers like Ailee, Hyolyn, CL, AKMU, just to name a few, still do it without the playback of current groups such as IVE, Le Sserafim and New Jeans. The new generations of K-pop should be prepared to sing completely live on music programs.
みなさんめちゃくちゃかっこいい！歌が上手すぎて迫力があってびっくりしました
これが生歌…！？
やばすぎるww
4人ともそれぞれ異なる美声で4回泣いた……
何度聴いても良いですね😍💕💕💕💕
You know, when I said I wanted kpop companies to debut actual adults, this isn't exactly what I meant I wanted, but maybe it's what I needed
Absolutely
THEIR MICS ARE ON, THEY ARE ON FIRE !! THEY CAN SING !!
I am so excited for this new era of Kpop I hope they continue revolutionising the Kpop industry and this way no toxic fans can complain about dating since these ladies are probably married with grandkids
Only 2 of them, Insooni and Eun Mee, are married while Mi Kyung and Hye Bom are still single. ❤
this is gen 5 rookie girl group with a total of more than 150 years of experience 😂
They are not even 150 years tho,, haha but I get your joke, They are very talented , I agree with you saying they are talented!!
@@rupakekevys9671150 years of experience
やっぱり歌がうまい！歌手って感じ。若い人には負けてない🌱
Yes this is the moment! Love hearing great raw vocals again in kpop. This is the revival we needed and they got contemporary ending fairies. Thank you JYP for bringing this group together!
想像を遥かに超える歌唱力！今のアイドルたちは、こんなすごい歌手を見ながら育ってきたのか、そりゃレベル高くなるわな
The sound better live than 80% of the kpop industry😭😭
The way they support every single note is such a flex. Love to hear it
the fact JYP himself watched backstage for these divas are literally so wholesome he's like a dad who watches over his daughters during their performance
そういうメンバーを集めただけあってさすがうまいしかっこいい
ウンミさん？めっちゃかっこよくて好き
才能を手繰り寄せる天才だなJYP🙏パフォーマンスやエンターテイメントの形は無限大だと教えてくれる…いい時代だ☺️💗
歌唱力が凄すぎて最高でした🎉
Hello, a ONCE came to support Golden Girls. These women are really legendary singers, I'm looking forward to their next song :)
上手い！カッコいい！！👏👍
I'm NSWERs and ONCEs come here to support our new family! Congratulation and fighting golden girls!! I love their voice!
さすが、としか言いようがないよね。本当に歌唱力、表現力、声量、どれもさすが！！！
５０代ですが、活躍して頂けるとこちらも元気になります😊
Eunmi's voice makes my heart riottsss!
Phew that rasp ❤
Admitting here that JYP is really awesome, he knows how to break boundaries!
rightt❤
박진영이 이 그룹을 결성하기 위해서 그 오랜기간 시행착오를 겪으며 엔터 제작자로 활동한 건가 싶을 정도로 완성도 높은 그룹이었음. 박진영이 진짜 하고 싶은 걸 한 느낌. 그 그림이 눈 앞에 펼쳐져서 감동적이었음. 박진영이 생각하는 최적의 이상향 그룹이 아닐까 싶은 무대였다.
NO MR , VERY GOOD TRUE SINGER I HOPE ALL NEW ROKIE LIKE THAT VOCLA NUMBER 1
They're impressive! It really shows age doesn't matter when it comes to your passion and dreams. Their vocals are so powerful. We, at the ages of 20-25 act like old people 😂, while they, at the ages of 66, 58, and 57 prove that age is just a number.
I wish to listen to more songs from them.❤
2:00 that part of the choreo is so satisfying!!
2:28 SUCH AMAZING HARMONIZATION! 🤩
GOLDEN GIRLS 화이팅!! ✨
0:49-0:51 is really harder than it looks, and they nailed it
若い子には無い声の迫力、めっちゃかっこいい💕
어떤 걸그룹이 라이브로 저런 가창력을 보여줄 수 있을까요 골든걸스가 유일하다고 봅니다
Mamamoo
@@Felix_grey 마마무 잘하죠 근데 보컬에서 저정도의 레벨이 되기엔 살짝 차이가 있지 않을까 싶어요
Nmixx y mamamoo
@@zi-hoonbak5766 그런 것 같아요. 마마무도 잘 부르지만, 아이돌 레벨에서죠. 저분들이 마마무 나이 때는 가수 중에서도 최강에 속한 분들이었죠. 굳이 그룹 중에서 보컬만 본다면 마마무보다 빅마마가 근접할 것 같네요.
Busca a Spica, fue muy bueno y me dolió su separación 😢
I am here seated for Queen InSooni. Before Yoon Mirae and Lee Michelle, there was InSooni. 😭❤️ Each three of them are legends in their own right. With similar stories when it comes to discrimination for being half-black. All three are tremendously talented.
확실히 박미경님이 왕년에 솔로댄스가수로 전성기를 경험해서그런지, 제일 뭔가 잘어울리네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 근데 다른것보다도 "AR없는 생 라이브"공연 정말 오랜만에보는듯
This is what talent looks like. The standard it should be. Group concepts nowadays are just on looks and catchy repetitive choruses
It takes decades of training and professional experience to get this good.
If you guys didnt know about them...they are legend...i do admire all the divas 🎉
몇십년 동안 솔로로 활동했던 분들이 어떻게 이리 조화로울 수 있죠?? 지금 이 순간~ 화음 넣을 때 소름ㄷㄷ 너무 멋있어요!!❤
Omg the bridge
This isnt old. This is gold ❤
amazing voices
디바들의 합동 무대를 보게 될줄이야..
이은미 가수의 댄스와 랩을 보게 될 줄이야.. 그야말로 전설의 레전드다
인순이님의 노련함이 느껴지는 무대 장악력, 박미경님 때문에 올드함이 전혀 느껴지지 않고 트렌디해 보이고, 신효범님의 특급 가창력, 이은미님의 걸크러쉬한 매력! 누구 하나 빠지면 안 되는 빈틈 없는 공연이네요! 퍼갑니다^^
와 진짜 은미언니 센터상 뭔가 알수없게 눈을 못때게 매력적
인순언니 에너지 리더쉽 에너지가 마디마디 느껴져서 음악에 지루할 틈이 없고 0_0 미경 언니 목소리는 귀구멍에 독보적으로 꽃히네요 꽃혀 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 노래랑 잘어울려요! 먼가 진짜 아이돌 가창력 같은 느낌 2000% 효범언니는 비주얼 담당이확실하네요! ㅋㅋㅋㅋ노래도 좋지만 너무 예쁘신거같아요ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 얼굴에 시선이 확! 멋있어요!🎉
아이돌 노래는 가사가 안들리는데 시원한가창력에 가사가 귀에 들어오니 너무좋아요
そうなんだ？滑舌悪いとかでもないもんね?
Their voices are just incredible 😍
迫力凄い！
そして皆おきれいだわ
こう言うコンセプトはもっと増えたらいいな。
Ohhhh I love them❤ finally a girl group so cool
Amazing voices❤❤❤ love their charisma ❤❤
신기하네.. 듣다보니 노래가 좋아지네;;
This is why there’s NO excuses for their juniors to lack so much in their vocal skills & range. They’re not being trained well and only so few of them actually put in work to improve vocally. Let these women and their healthy voices be a testament to how easy it is to use breath support and diction.
実力めっちゃすごい
Con solo su presencia y voz brillan...
Perfect vocals OMG❤😮
歌が上手いってやっぱりいい
聴いてて気分が上がる
골든 걸즈들이 연말 연기대상에서 축하공연 하면, 아마 거기 배우들 웬만해서는 다 기립해서 공연을 보겠네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 이루어져랏 ㅋㅋㅋ
I clicked wondering who on earth would name a girl group "Golden Girls" and got a shock to see who were the members (maybe their group name should have just been Golden Legends lol).
Made me think whether some time in the future we could have a 1st or 2nd gen supergroup like this when they themselves reach their "golden years". 😂
Okay now we need a collab with Mamamoo!!
BEST DEBUT EVERRRR🎉🎉🎉
THEY GENUINELY HAVE THE PRETTIEST VOICES I’VE EVER HEARD
they left all these kpop girls in shambles imagine being outdone by someone who could be your grandma
My bias is Insooni! ❤
カッコいい！めちゃ上手い！🥰
네분 모두 멋집니다
새로운도전 응원합니다
凄すぎる！この域に達するまでの努力たるやいかにですね。圧巻としか言いようがない。若いＫＰＯＰアイドルは是非聞くべきです。
Added to Spotify!
They are 50 and their vocals, energy is amazing
Their vocal are far better then young idols..
Just found out about this group today. They each have unique voices. ❤👏👏👏
THEY ATE
the vocal are fireeeeeeeeee
I'm sure they would open a door to a new trend.
さっきベルーナドームで見てファンになりました
クソかっこよかったです
THEY ATE SO HARD
2:28
I love this part❤
아이돌은 이 무대를 본보기 삼아 자기를 더 발전해 나아갈 것. 예쁜척 멋있는 척 하면서 춤만 잘 춘다고 아이돌이 아니다. 가수는 기본적으로 라이브가 되어야 한다. 내가 본 최고의 아이돌.
They came back to remind the younger gens that a popstar sings pop and adds little dances to it to capture the hearts of audiences ❤
NEW FAN HERE
Nowadays we see so many younger idols on stage that paradoxically, seeing a group of older women is refreshing, reaaally refreshing ! I hope this will bring more diversity, less conformist and restrictions to the Kpop industry !
2:28 tickles my brain
Same
This was so great! Kpop can sometimes be repetitive and this busted that mold wide open! Well done and I hope they keep going!
That harmony is insane.
골든걸스 분위기 메이커 신효범언니ㅡㅡㅡㅡ골든걸스 띠어주네요ㅡㅡ이뽀용ㅡ난 신효엎 언니팬👍🩷❤️
Oh they sang sang. I love them. Age doesn't have a number when you love what you do. I would love to see them in concert
Insooni is stunning in ways I can't even begin to describe - her aura is so powerful
Many artists perform fierceness. She just is fierce in her being.
우와 진짜 멋있다 감동 힐링 그 자체임😂
네 분 다 멋찜 뿜뿜 그러나 왕 불청팬으로서 가창력 짱짱으로 다시 귀환한 신효범님 최고로 멋지네요😊❤🎉